11 ms·
It's ironic that as we move into a world where anyone can be a "journalist" and anyone can have a voice, we need professional journalists more than ever. Now a
by jedberg 7y ago
It's ironic that as we move into a world where anyone can be a "journalist" and anyone can have a voice, we need professional journalists more than ever.
Now a journalist will not only need training in writing well, conveying a story with facts, and investigating, but they will also need to become experts in identifying fake source material.
In a world where anyone can make a video or photo of anyone doing anything, we'll need to rely on reputable journalists to vet that material for us.
Saw a video on YouTube of the President saying something bad? No idea if it's real anymore.
Sure, a lot of this technology has existed for a while, but it was usually in the fringes (see The National Enquirer). Now it's going mainstream.
And the worst part is, there are a whole group of people who will not trust a professional journalist (sometimes with good reason) but will trust anyone online who happens to provide evidence that boosters their existing opinions.
- dv_dt 7y agoIn part, imho, the distrust comes from the the standards of the highest tiers of professional journalists being on a low right now too.
- nsomaru 7y agoJournalists are following clicks instead of the other way around
- phkahler 7y agoEvery day the NYT sends me a summary email. Every day there is a status on impeachment. They dont even call him president, its Mr Trump. The bias is obvious. They would like me to pay for more!
- mtnGoat 7y agoI agree, I will happily pay for news, but most of these "news" outlets are just a bunch of opinions and usually they are all one way or the other depending on the editor.
- jimmyjohndoe 7y agoThe NYT has referred to presidents as Mr. X for hundreds of years
- bobthepanda 7y agoTo bolster the claim, "Mr. Obama, Your Move" (2014): https://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/10/opinion/sunday/mr-obama-your-move.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/10/opinion/sunday/mr-obama-y... And more historical, "Another Interview with Mr. Lincoln; His Opinion of Compromises" (1861) https://www.nytimes.com/1861/01/14/archives/anotherinterview-with-mr-lincoln-his-opinion-of-compromises.html https://www.nytimes.com/1861/01/14/archives/anotherinterview...
- rhizome 7y ago"President" isn't a title, it's a position or role. You don't say "Director Spielberg will be in attendance."
- nemild 7y agoI'm doubtful that most journalists actually want it to be that way. Those are just the economic and reader incentives in journalism today. There are some great stats about just how much the number of professional journalists has shrunk in the social media era.
- catalogia 7y agoThe very premise of for-profit journalism seems questionable at best.
- rhizome 7y ago>in the social media era. In this context I think it should be termed "now that there are no classified ads."
- bostik 7y agoI know it's easy (and tempting) to put the blame on social media alone, but there's more than that. The rise of social media certainly accelerated the evisceration, gutting, and - as some might say, annihilation - of journalism but the tailspin trajectory has been in the making for quite a bit longer. Here's a thread from January this year, where a journalism professor lays bare the facts about the decline of his domain: https://twitter.com/jeremylittau/status/1088503510184927233?lang=en https://twitter.com/jeremylittau/status/1088503510184927233?... If my memory serves me right, that thread was on the HN front page at the time. Essentially the expense of quality journalism was seen as frivolous in the 80's, got nixed, and by the mid-90's newspapers relied on their established captive audience to churn out reliable profits with little appetite for innovation. Who was going to compete with them, anyway? Internet changed the landscape, and social media has been instrumental in hammering nails in the coffin. But the decline of journalism and destruction of quality newsrooms has been going on since before there was public internet.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoPeople don’t want to pay for good journalism, nevermind spending time to read and evaluate if it is or isn’t good journalism. Maybe it’s not even realistic for everyone to do that.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoPeople also don't want to pay for good government. As a rule, people don't want to pay for anything that benefits them in a second-order way with non-immediate consequences - even if objectively the benefits are real. It's a classic economic monkey trap. Holding onto something now is "better" than letting go and getting a bigger benefit later. Which suggests that perhaps we should be doing more to eliminate monkey traps from our economic and political systems.
- rhizome 7y agoMy stance is that it's anti-your_country not to want to pay for good government. All of it, tax breaks for high earners, shelters, financial engineering to reduce taxes paid...all of it is treasonous to your fellow citizens.
- wruza 7y ago>People also don't want to pay for good government. Maybe because it’s already a paid service and its quality still has to be observed. But if you take their government from them, returning that substantial income cut, they instantly want it back. This doesn’t have to invalidate your point, but this particular comparison seems pretty shaky. (Or it’s not and I’m missing something.)
- jacquesm 7y agoIt's not the journalists but their bosses that are the problem.
- gowld 7y agoIt's not the bosses but their customers that are the problem.
- dv_dt 7y agoGiven the bundled nature of mass news media, it's impossible for customers to send a signal for example that CNN news specifically isn't up to their standard. They can cut the cord on a whole set of products or keep their cable bundle neither of which sends signal to CNN about the quality of their journalism. More niche publications don't have that problem, but I think a big question is how we systemically increase the quality of mass journalism.
- dwd 7y agoAt the end of the day, they are all individuals with their own biases, ambitions or plain irrationality. You just have to take that into account in all you read and hear.
- nemild 7y agoOne of the scariest quotes for me was Facebook's Little Red Book in 2012 (a book handed out to every employee) that had this quote: > "When everyone has a printing press [i.e., Facebook], the ones with the best ideas are the ones people listen to." In retrospect, it gives a ton of insight into the flawed beliefs within the company. https://twitter.com/nemild/status/1006533287378968576 https://twitter.com/nemild/status/1006533287378968576 https://www.businessinsider.com/inside-facebooks-little-red-book-2015-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/inside-facebooks-little-red-...
- btown 7y agoI can see this being a naïve but realistic take given what we knew in ~2008. In 2012 it should have been clear that this model could be gamed. And it's on Facebook that their culture wouldn't allow them to see that.
- pushpop 7y agoYou’re assuming they didn’t see that. Given it’s now nearly 2020 and we’ve had years of reports of election meddling yet Facebook are only calming down on suggestive emoji - stating that they have no interest in policing “free speech” when it comes to political ads - I’m inclined to believe they’re not unaware their network is being games but rather don’t care because it’s still money in their pocket.
- davidajackson 7y agoI don't think you're right @nemild, it's not a scary quote and it's also true. Sure, people can be duped temporarily but the best quality ideas last. Information is best distributed when it can be distributed freely. What alternative would you propose, censorship, regulation? Facebook solved a problem (connecting) but it also created one (fake content, bot farms). Either Facebook will fix it, or if they don't, new products will pop up to solve the problem to try to provide more reliable content. Recently, might have seen it on here (I forget where) someone trained an AI to try to detect fake news. Sure the first attempts will be crappy prototypes, but the point is that people are trying to figure the problem out.
- prvc 7y agoProfessional journalists have abdicated that role, and can no longer said to be "reputable". Plausible deniability that they were working in good faith was irrevocably lost when they failed to adapt in response to the valid criticisms they were receiving on social media, not because "fake news" trolls took over. Twitter did indeed kill the newspaper star, just not in the way they think.
- sgt101 7y agoSome professional journalists. And there were some valid criticisms. This is a very common stance now - because one person said one thing, or a person said something once, or did something once then all people associated with that person (in the mind of the commentator) are a "thing". The reasoning is "a rightwing person once said a racist thing, therefore anyone who is rightwing is definitely racist" it is clearly nonsense, and is extremely corrosive to debate.
- nradov 7y agoThat's nothing new. Journalists have always needed to identify fake source material. Dan Rather wrecked his career by reporting a story about George W. Bush based on fake documents.
- soheil 7y agoIt's interesting in the current world, prior in our "move into the world.. where anyone can make a video or photo of anyone doing anything" we're already struggling pretty badly with identifying fake news and what is considered fact vs fiction. I don't see this as a move into a new world, but rather the increase level of hopelessness we're dealing with when it comes to good journalism. It may be time to pause and rethink our current approach to journalism since the current model is not working very well now and certainly won't be in the future.
- reilly3000 7y agoThis only happened because a team of professional journalists worked on the story for months, despite Facebook denials and stonewalling: https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/10/11/pro-trump-outlet-linked-epoch-times/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/10/11/pro-trump-outlet-link... https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/11/12/bl-fake-profiles/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/11/12/bl-fake-profiles/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/12/13/facebook-bl-cib/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/12/13/facebook-bl-cib/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/12/20/facebook-removes-the-bl-pages/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/12/20/facebook-removes-the-...
- dchichkov 7y agoArguably, in a long term, it might be better that the appearance of the person would not matter as much. It actually might be harder to establish a cult of personality and really bad dictatorships, if there are humorous fakes and parodies flying around. But it also might make it more difficult to keep track of real events.
- throwawaybbb 7y agoIronic that all journalists got the Iraq war wrong without the need for fake news. We don't need real journalists, we need a way to pay for news that makes accurate reporting profitable.
- jedberg 7y agoGood journalism is still no match for a functioning US intelligence apparatus intent on disinformation.
- mattr47 7y agoAny competent government intelligence agency. Every government puts their own spin on information.
- Cookingboy 7y agoThe cynical side of me: accurate reporting isn’t profitable because there is very little demand for accurate reporting from the general public. People want to read/watch news they want to believe or agree with, and instinctively they shun away from facts that causes cognitive dissonance with them. What they want is to believe their preferred news sources are objective, but they will do everything they can to avoid doing actual due diligence to verify that objectivity. That’s why if we leave it to purely market economy, completely objective, facts based journalism will never be as profitable as sensationalism based stuff you see these days.
- perl4ever 7y agoBut does it make sense to frame this as a statement about human beings, rather than a statement about what is logically required by the evolutionary-style process of information multiplying? Regardless of where society's starting point was, when it's really easy to transmit information, the information that gets transmitted the most is the kind that doesn't demand analysis first.
- qznc 7y agoEven more meta, but one of the really big questions is: How to give people what they need instead of what they want? I think it was pg who said "make something people want". If the plan is to get rich that is the way to go. If you want to improve the world, you should build something people need. Unfortunately, they often don't want it or don't want it enough to pay for it which makes the endeavor unsustainable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mkolodny 7y agoVerifying sources has always been important. I recently learned about Stanislov Petrov - he helped prevent a nuclear war in 1983 by ignoring a false alarm reported by Russia's early warning system [0]. The system reported that the USA launched up to six missiles. Fortunately, Russia's stance was that nuclear retaliation requires multiple sources to confirm an attack. Stanislov went against his orders, and declared the attack a false alarm. As was true before the internet, we need to make sure we have reliable sources to trust the news. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov
- intricatedetail 7y agoIn most countries journalists double as officers of propaganda ministry. You only have to look how certain topics are being reported to get an idea.
- burtonator 7y ago> In a world where anyone can make a video or photo of anyone doing anything, we'll need to rely on reputable journalists to vet that material for us. signed media is going to become FAR more important in the future. We're going to have cameras shipping with crypto so that news agencies can sign their video.
- narrator 7y agoSounds like the spam wars from the 2000s again.
- pixl97 7y agoTyrannical governments would love the idea of all camera images being signed.
- leppr 7y agoThe signing could very well be completely optional/pseudonymous. Don't fall into the trap of false dilemmas BigTech loves to impose on its users: the wonderful thing about technology is how malleable, and thus user-empowering it can be.
- gjs278 7y agono it’s not. nobody will care. spotting fakes is trivial.
- KibbutzDalia 7y agoAnd yet nobody wants to pay for journalism. Everyone here just complains about NY Times and WSJ having a paywall.
- rsnor 7y agoI had the thought a day or so ago that a system could be created to tie images to their respective cameras with a private key stored inside of a chip that self-destructs when you attempt to read the key from outside of it, along with a trust hierarchy of certs from various camera manufacturers. A little like hardware auth tokens mixed with PKI. Does that sound like something that would be feasible to produce/practical in the real world?
- eitland 7y agosomething similar was done a number of years ago but cracked later. I think it was Nikon who had it and the proof of the crack was someone signed the Beatles crossing the road with a Nikon camera key. Meanwhile secure enclaves are now possibly a lot safer, but as Kalium mentioned it might not be very attractive for everyone. For forensics experts however it could become very useful I believe.
- Kalium 7y agoFeasible? Sure, to the limits of what we can do with secure enclaves today. Desirable? Well, you've created a system that authenticates a camera as being at a place at a time. It's a good way to authenticate photos, but a bad way to stay anonymous. How do you feel about photographers and journalists becoming even larger targets for anyone who wants to keep a secret?
- sgt101 7y agoIn the past the actual image authenticated that the camera was at a place at a time, and anonymity was preserved. The issue is : does it authenticate that a particular camera that belongs to a particular person is/was at a place at a time and produced an image - because if so then if the device is found in a search the owner/user/keeper is in hot water. So the camera must be anonymous - but it must be impossible for a lie about the place and time to be encoded into the image.
- Kalium 7y agoIf you assume that "Anyone could have been using that camera!" is a defense, you're absolutely correct. It's perhaps worth considering that an authoritarian government might not trouble itself with such legal niceties. All they have to do is mandate that journalists with cameras register their keys, make possession of a camera with an unregistered key criminal, and track sales / border entries. China springs to mind as a country that might do such a thing. Again, you're absolutely correct in asserting that anonymity of camera-user is important! It's just perhaps worth considering how linking hardware to images might undermine that in dangerous ways.
- smadurange 7y agoWell, it's not like the professional journalists don't lie at all for profit and self-preservation. Lol. Facebook does a lot of disageeable things but making everyone a journalist isn't one of them. This just decentralised journalism and actually empowered freespeech. There are issues with it, but that's a better problem we can work on to mitigate than giving a few channels a monopoly over truth.
- cerved 7y agoFacebook provides a medium where most people can disseminate their message, with little restriction or cost, to a potentially large audience. It doesn't make everybody a journalist.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Saw a video on YouTube of the President saying something bad? No idea if it's real anymore. I've lived through enough presidencies to assure you that it never mattered if it was real or not. Supporters ignored or excused it, opposition treated it like the end of the world. Sane people stopped paying attention long ago to keep their sanity.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y agoThey need to be paid appropriately and must be absolutely unbiased, also.