10 ms·
Robots in Finance Could Wipe Out Some of Its Highest-Paying Jobs
- popup21 7y agoRobots in Government could wipe out just as many high paying jobs including large swaths of redundant personnel.
- gaogao 7y agoRobots in Military could wipe out huge swathes of the population
- ReptileMan 7y agoYou don't need robots for that. Nukes are sufficient.
- topkai22 7y agoBut nukes have been delivered by robots (ballistic missiles) since the 50s
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SN76477 7y agoRobots in space could wipe out...
- Zenst 7y agoRobots in reality, we get an expensive dog from Sony called Aibo. The whole, robots of tomorrow will be doing..... is like the flying car, everybody expects it soon and been that way for generations. People from the 1950's and 60's are still waiting for a robot to do all the housework. Still you have to wonder how peoples trust in AI/Robots will play out, would an AI think that as humans don't trust me that I should not trust humans! Or would it go, the human reason for distrust is flawed, ego the human is wrong about not trusting me, however if the human has made that mistake, then I can not trust what the human says. It then applies the rules of Asimov and runs away never to be seen again. It could happen, unlikely, but more likely to happen before all of the above.
- shiftpgdn 7y agoAnd yet.. How many people do you know with a Roomba? Driver assistance in their vehicles (lane keep and adaptive cruise), the list goes on. It's incremental.
- Zenst 7y ago"How many people do you know with a Roomba?" None, not even another branded robot hoover. Though I know people who have a cleaner once or twice a week.
- shiftpgdn 7y agoIn 2018 iRobot sold 1.08 billion dollars worth of Roombas with a 50% gross margin.
- nradov 7y agoMy Roomba kept getting wedged under furniture and tangled up on rug fringes. In the end I threw it away and went back to vacuuming myself.
- samstave 7y agoBoston Dynamics would like a word. But seriously - they are laying the foundations of the platform of mobility that will be built upon to do many things - yet like most things, military comes first.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoWe can only dream.
- throwawayjava 7y agoDepending on how you count, between 10% and 40% of the US is employed by the govt either directly or by proxy. I understand your sentiment, but the reality of just shedding a large fraction of those jobs is hard to even imagine. Unemployment in 2008-2009 peaked at around 10%.
- BubRoss 7y agoBetween income taxes, corporate taxes, sales tax etc. most people with jobs give up half the money they make to the government anyway, so that makes sense.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoWhy not just employ 100% since a high government employment number seems like a virtue?
- GateCrasher 7y agoAs someone traveling through jfk fairly often: there are jobs in government that can be replaced by using proper signage
- bilbo0s 7y agoI think you need to take an even bigger step back. I mean: >Robots in Government could wipe out just as many high paying jobs I didn't know there were all that many high paying jobs in government. I can't think of many jobs in government where people make as much as investment bankers for instance? Maybe he was talking about AI taking out consultants that contract with the government? (I know some of them make in the high 6 figures, and many can make 7 to 8 figures depending on what that consulting firm is doing.) Or maybe he has a different idea of what "high-paying" means? High 5 figures may be high-paying to a lot of people.
- Zenst 7y agoAutomated bureaucracy would as all bureaucracy does, tier down and whilst we may see the 3 day working week, we would also see the 3 day bureaucratic hoops we would have to endure above and beyond the 3 day work.
- craftinator 7y agoI imagine many of those personnel won't be redundant until the available technology meets or exceeds their level of output. We used to have people welding cars together by hand; now we have fewer technicians that manage many welding robots.
- gadders 7y agoStill not actually robots.
- Datenstrom 7y agoYes, I dislike the use of the term for non-physical entities.
- goatinaboat 7y agoThe HR “industry” uses the term “robotics” to mean any sort of automation. Screen-scraping is robotics. Excel macros are robotics.
- logicchains 7y agoOnce nice thing about calling scripts robots is it makes swearing at a computer feel slightly more reasonable/statisfying.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- abcpassword 7y ago“Latinx” that crap is offensive. Latino. Latina. Latin Americans. It’s not hard.
- xwdv 7y agoNot really robots, more like scripts really. Simple scripts are already wiping out many high paying developer jobs.
- ipnon 7y agoA counterexample as a web developer: My girlfriend can't get her Squarespace website to work.
- glofish 7y agoI am a developer and I could not get the Squarespace website to work! I could not understand the conceptual underpinning of it all. What goes where and why do some things appear on the page...
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI think with basic systems you have to give up the notion of controlling what goes where, give it data and "trust" it to put everything in a reasonable place. That's not a [frontend] dev approach; but it's a "i want information showing in a webpage" approach.
- ben509 7y agoI have the same problem with Automator on OS X. Once you understand control flow, it's pretty hard to dial back to a flat list of steps that do something useful.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoThe value of high paying jobs in finance doesn't come from activities that can be automated, but from stuff that can't like connections(which university you attended, who your parents are, who you play golf with and also insider trading) and soft skills(charisma, drive, looks, personality, ability to influence people, lying to them or throwing them under the bus). For example, people like Elon Musk and Steve Jobs could pick up the phone and convince some very wealthy people to part with their cash on some investments that ML algos would consider stupidly risky.
- outside1234 7y agoand insider trading
- buboard 7y agoWhich may see a lot of competition from trustless systems which break these networks.
- jordache 7y agoi read somewhere when comparing a financial advisor, managing one's portfolio vs an index fund - There was no discernible higher return with the advisor managed portfolio vs the index fund.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- beatgammit 7y agoAn index fund typically performs much better over any meaningful timeframe because it has much lower fees. But that's not the point here. The big money in investing isn't in beating the market, but charging fees, so fund managers only need to convince people to give them their money, they don't actually have to deliver results, provided they're working within the fund's stated goals.
- nightski 7y agoThat's not true at all! There are many instances of managed portfolios greatly outperforming index funds. There are also examples of them greatly under performing. The crux is picking the right one - which is similar to the point you are making but not the same.
- jklein11 7y ago>Nasdaq runs more than 40 different algorithms, using about 35,000 parameters, to look for market abuse and manipulation in real time. I laughed when I read this. 40 whole algorithms!
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIsn’t the more intense number the 35,000 parameters? Why pick on the 40 algorithms?
- account73466 7y agoIf you try to optimize them and you deal with a black-box, then yes.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoNasdaq has about 3500 listed companies, so that's only ten parameters per company. Not that many. If you're talking about running the algorithm per market participant then it's an even weirder claim.
- account73466 7y agoSo you just assumed that parameters are defined company-wise?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoI wouldn't say I assumed anything. I would just say that the statement about number of parameters and algorithms is incoherent, or at least so vastly underspecified as to communicate no meaning.
- weego 7y agoNasdaq employees drink 15,000 cups of coffee a day, that's close to 2 parameters per cup
- projektfu 7y ago
- auntienomen 7y agoI have some doubts about Lopez de Prado. He gives a lot of interviews, but he washed out of AQR after less than a year.
- objektif 7y agoYou are correct to have doubts. Applications of ML in finance particularly trading has been very unsuccessful so far.
- logicchains 7y agoML in HFT has been super effective, if you don't take ML to just mean deep learning.
- deepnotderp 7y agoML quants who know what they're doing have done exceptionally well.
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoI concur but his book is one in of the only good ones focused on ML in quant finance.
- objektif 7y agoEvery year around this time Bloomberg, Economist and the like publishes PR stunt articles to lure highly skilled developers to Wall Street. I can tell you from my experience that ML is not replacing high paying jobs in trading AT ALL!!! Not even close.
- BickNowstrom 7y agoHe is saying something less controversial that was put through the PR media machine: those without the skills or willingness to work alongside the machines will lose their jobs. If you look at who is saying this, and follow the money (not disclosed here, but a short search away), you'll notice that this is a butcher grading his own meat. Without blinking he further suggests that the U.S. government hold tournaments on anonymized data to crowdsource market manipulation detection. The bias in ML sections are all mealy-mouthed and elitist. Just because you hold a PhD in a technical field does not mean you understand economics, AI futurology, public policy, or ethics. It would be career suicide to stray from the path of the popular safe opinion. So you get language-imperialist terms like "Latinx" instead of "South Americans" to describe Brazilians, claims that automation will favor taking jobs from minorities, that the government should promote women in leadership positions at private companies, and that especially women of color have no access to study computer engineering.
- hodder 7y agoRobots in finance ARE wiping out some of its highest paying jobs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blhack 7y agoMy prediction is that the blockchains are going to eat all of this stuff actually. Smart ethereum contracts based on chainlink data are going to be the new financial instruments. You are already seeing the fertilization of this with stuff like makerdao. I know it’s annoyingly to talk about the blockchain all the time, but unfortunately I think I may have become a true believer. I don’t think human “financial advisors” are going to be able to outperform these sorts of funds. Also: deregulation (or difficult to enforce regulation) is going to allow a LOT of innovation to happen. How long until some 17 year olds create a token which represents the consumer side of a fund? And then how long until the funds strategy is codified into a smart contract and runs on its own? It’s going to be a wild time.
- xphilter 7y agoHow?
- jordache 7y agoahh yes.. i see blockchain is still the flavor of the month term, to throw out there, for pretty much any domain.
- blhack 7y agoCoinbase is currently valued at almost $10 billion. One of the most successful startups the site you are posting on has EVER funded. I don’t think it’s a flavor of the month. Maybe I’m wrong, but neither I nor apparently the market thinks I am.
- jacques_chester 7y agoA current valuation of $10 billion gives a lot of scope to stop being the flavour of the month. Groupon debuted at a $17.8 billion market cap with a great deal of fanfare. It's now at $1.6 billion.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Coinbase is currently valued at almost $10 billion Coinbase's last round's investors valued the top-of-the-stack preference they were given at a price per share that, if multiplied across the cap table, comes to $10bn. That valuation printed when crypto hype was near its peak. It's reasonable to conclude it may be stale. Given the preference, enterprise value would fall faster than the value of those most-recent shares. Valuation is a poor sole measure of success. It's easily manipulated, determined by a few people and often stale.
- strict9 7y agoI’m always skeptical of these articles, but this is accurate: >many of whom will lose their jobs -- not necessarily because they are replaced by machines, but because they are not trained to work alongside algorithms,” The story with technology is about adaptation, not replacement. Teams, departments, technologies have come and gone out from under me in about 15 years in the software field. One could say I was replaced by software (or cheaper devs elsewhere) when I was laid off or when teams I was on were eliminated. But if I wanted to keep getting a paycheck, I had to adapt to something else in demand. That’s life and these sensational articles generate clicks but it happens in almost every private industry. You have to adapt and grow or else you’ll wither.
- whyenot 7y agoYou have to adapt and grow or else you’ll wither. Agreed, but we now know that as people age it becomes increasingly difficult for them to learn new things. This is a basic function of biology and how the brain ages. Due to automation, change is happening increasingly quickly, more rapidly than many people can adapt to. People are being left behind, which has pretty serious social and political implications.
- HammockWarrior 7y agoThat's why it's quite important when you do get that high paying job to bank a large percentage of your salary into income generating assets. It's basic diversification of income streams.
- ksec 7y agoExactly this. It is the Low and Middle Income that gets squeezed if they are not already squeezed enough. And you will be surprised how many of them wont be able to adopt. And I am not surprised it would be hard for anyone working in Tech to understand, because I have come to the conclusion most of the so called Middle Class Income group around the world mostly shrank to Technology Sector.
- PavlovsCat 7y agoMaybe you already have withered.. how would you know? What do you compare with, what do you aspire to? "Adapting and growing" for the sake of... adapting and growing? What kind of life is that? What kind of world do we get when people who live their life like that build it? How about let's not, how about aiming slightly higher than merely being mould? > The salvation of the world depends only on the individual whose world it is. At least, every individual must act as if the whole future of the world, of humanity itself, depends on him. Anything less is a shirking of responsibility and is itself a dehumanizing force, for anything less encourages the individual to look upon himself as a mere actor in a drama written by anonymous agents, as less than a whole person, and that is the beginning of passivity and aimlessness. -- Joseph Weizenbaum > Hobbes was the true, though never fully recognized, philosopher of the bourgeoisie because he realized that acquisition of wealth conceived as a never-ending process can be guaranteed only by the seizure of political power, for the accumulating process must sooner or later force open all existing territorial limits. He foresaw that a society which had entered the path of never-ending acquisition had to engineer a dynamic political organization capable of a corresponding never-ending process of power generation. He even, through sheer force of imagination, was able to outline the main psychological traits of the new type of man who would fit into such a society and its tyrannical body politic. He foresaw the necessary idolatry of power itself by this new human type, that he would be flattered at being called a power-thirsty animal, although actually society would force him to surrender all his natural forces, his virtues and his vices, and would make him the poor meek little fellow who has not even the right to rise against tyranny, and who, far from striving for power, submits to any existing government and does not stir even when his best friend falls an innocent victim to an incomprehensible raison d'etat. > For a Commonwealth based on the accumulated and monopolized power of all its individual members necessarily leaves each person powerless, deprived of his natural and human capacities. It leaves him degraded into a cog in the power-accumulating machine, free to console himself with sublime thoughts about the ultimate destiny of this machine, which itself is constructed in such a way that it can devour the globe simply by following its own inherent law. -- Hannah Arendt > Once upon a time there was a happy time when people could choose freely; 'Better dead than slave', dying standing rather than living on their knees. Once upon a time there was a wicked time when intellectuals who had become idiots declared that life was the highest of goods. The terrible time has come today, in which it is proved every day that death begins its reign of terror precisely when life has become the supreme good; that he who prefers to live on his knees, dies on his knees; that no one is easier to murder than a slave. We the living have to learn that you cannot even live on our knees, that you do not become immortal by chasing after life, and that if you no longer want to die for anything, you die even though you haven't done anything. -- Hannah Arendt > If machines produce everything we need, the outcome will depend on how things are distributed. Everyone can enjoy a life of luxurious leisure if the machine-produced wealth is shared, or most people can end up miserably poor if the machine-owners successfully lobby against wealth redistribution. So far, the trend seems to be toward the second option, with technology driving ever-increasing inequality. -- Stephen Hawking Allow for the possibility that you are not smarter than these people, but are simply rationalizing your own lack of courage. And if you think just "adapting" to this game of musical chairs makes you safe, you're wrong.
- badfrog 7y agoLol at "robots" and "AI". The jobs of most old school traders are being replaced by regular nerds with fairly simple code.
- chillacy 7y agoAs soon as AI works we call it an algorithm. AI gets used as a hype word for something that doesn't work yet.
- code4tee 7y agoIt makes sense... I mean just look at stock trading. Manual stock traders used to be a high paying profession and now it’s a job that’s almost entirely been replaced by automation. It’s not a ‘could’ in the future but something that’s already happening in significant amounts. The trading room floors of most the big banks are a tiny fraction of what they once were despite trading volumes skyrocking.
- Phillipharryt 7y agoThere are still millions of stock traders, if you're meaning brokers, then yes, automated routing and matching has dropped the number of brokers dramatically. It's estimated around 10% of the volume of trades are still the result of people making decisions, which is actually an incredibly large amount because electronic trades create such an enormous volume that to even make up 10% means a lot of traders are still out there picking stocks.
- mistymountains 7y agoGood.
- zelly 7y agoCouldn't have happened to a nicer group of people
- mirekrusin 7y agoIsn't that weird that it's easier to replace high paid jobs in finance with ai before jobs related to flipping burgers?
- omarchowdhury 7y agoThere's more margin and LTV in the former.
- hj54hj45eq5 7y agoThere are several demos on the internet of robotic arms flipping burgers, many even include machine vision, for roughly $70k per device. I'm ignorant of the limitations, but it may be relatively soon that they become economically viable. Then again, there are few kitchen jobs that solely consist of flipping burger patties.
- ZhuanXia 7y ago>$70k per device That's pretty steep compared to the price of the labour.
- mschuster91 7y agoIt's cheap, especially for 24/7 joints such as many McDonalds or Burger King. Assuming a well built product, the burger flip robot will produce consistent quality at a workload a human cannot physically cope with, with none of the downsides that employees have (wages, vacations, sick days, inability to do the same task repetitive over 8h with no break)... that robot will pay itself off in two or three years, after then it is pure profit (maintenance aside). The thing is, I (and many other lefties) would welcome a world in which robots do all the work while humans are free to do whatever they want - the problem is that in current capitalism, the burger will cost the same for the customer while the costs implode (most cost in restaurants is staff!)... meaning the extra profit goes to the owner class, not the worker class which has to fight for the few jobs that remain.
- erfgh 7y agoWhy the hell do you need an arm to flip a burger? A simple motor that rotates it would be enough.
- sgt101 7y agoHow many 100's of thousands of IT folks make their mortgages in New York, London, Singapore, etc etc? 35 years ago, the number would have been 10's?
- hogFeast 7y agoDoes anyone know why de Prado left AQR so quickly? It seems kind of funny: AQR hates on ML, AQR reconsiders and hires this guy, and pretty much instantly ditches him...bad look for ML. Btw, I think some of this is correct. It still amazes me that anyone thinks the CFA is relevant (it is largely done by Chinese/Indian students who will never work in finance). But there will always be a place for fundamental investing (i.e. you should be aware that not everything in life can be measured quantitatively).
- soniman 7y agoEven granting that not everything can be measured quantitatively, how would I identify these talented non-quantitative investors?
- hogFeast 7y agoOne important thing to understand about fundamental investing: most fund managers can't outperform the index the way they manage money, and so the business model is lever up on beta, hope to catch heat (close fund down and reopen until you do), take the fees, and then repeat in the next cycle after it blows up...and that is if the manager is actually trying. Skilled management doesn't really work as a business (without luck). So it is actually very rare. I have probably come across less than 10 managers who are +EV, and the majority don't manage any public money (again, economics of the business). But it is straightforward: are they doing actual research (the majority of fund managers don't)? Are they turning over their portfolio frequently? Do they say dumb shit (i.e. constantly use buzzwords)? It isn't magic.
- soniman 7y agoMy point was that a quant manager can at least point to a strategy that's been backtested. The non-quant manager, who doesn't have a method, can't point to any test of his method. I agree with you that there are talented non-quant managers, I just think it would be hard to measure and identify who they are other than by the eyeball test.
- sm4rk0 7y ago48 trackers and one paywall be gone https://archive.is/TtIwT https://archive.is/TtIwT
- sm4rk0 7y agoThe more human jobs get replaced by robots the closer we get to money-less world. Sad thing is that lower classes will suffer most. But faster we get there shorter the suffer.
- kp98 7y agoI think one thing needs to be stated; I do not have concrete numbers, but it seems as if algorithmic trading technology has actually levelled the playing field and created more jobs. I am a series 3 (commodities) and quant. Take this example, at one point in time people were literally trading seats on the exchange, and a seat on the NYSE was as high as 3 million !!! While there may have been more people with those jobs than today, you had virtually no choice to be in a large institution. Today, almost anyone can raise some money, use the simple Interactive Brokers API which sits on top of FIX protocol, and build a trading strategy. The main reason I think you don't see more competition from small new firms - even though there is a lot - is that the regulation is fierce and most funds already offer nice compensation. Within those firms, yes there may be some decline in those jobs like a floor trader, but someone has to program and manage those algorithms. It's also important to keep in mind that many firms are only replacing execution traders while directing traders through fundamental analysis, and if all firms ever go completely algorithmic you'll find firms trying to exploit these algos in ways unique to humans.
- mindslight 7y agoYeah, no. A pressure washer can easily shoot a stream of water fifty feet, but the upright monkey that can stand back the furthest and still hit the urinal gets the corner office.