25 ms·
Oxide Computer Company: Initial boot sequence
- ipoopatwork 7y agoThat office space [1] looks awful. Why is everything an open space theses days? [1] https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- couchand 7y agoLooks like it's still being built out in that picture. For their sake, hopefully they remember to put up some walls.
- lfowles 7y agoRight now all three accounts of this are adjacent news items on HN. Heh.
- steveklabnik 7y agoJessie's: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21682405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21682405 Brian's: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21682358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21682358
- malvosenior 7y agoI'm really curious why. This seems like an ok enough idea but hardly anything innovative. Is it just because the founders are bloggers and have a large following that it's getting traction? There's barely a description of what the product will be.
- chx 7y agoCalling these founders bloggers is perhaps true in the strictest sense of the word, as in they surely have blogs but that's not why some people perk up at this news. Jessie Frazelle did some serious Docker work, went on to work on Kubernetes, Hyper-V, a brief stint at Github saw her working on their Actions product. Bryan Cantrill was working on the Solaris kernel for a decade, his dtrace is particularly famous. And then he was CTO at Joyent. You maybe have heard one of the projects they helped with called node.js?
- thedaemon 7y agoI'm on the comment page here because all of the articles have less information than the comments! Thank you HackerNews users for giving us the skinny on Oxide.
- weego 7y agoAre these people of note? The title could be a lot more contextually relevant
- kick 7y agoCantrill is one of the people responsible for dtrace, and more or less the only Sun-alumni who's not retired or disappeared (a lot of them stopped blogging when Oracle killed the Sun blogging culture and site/killed Sun). He also was the CTO of Joyent. Frazelle was one of the people responsible for Docker. I think Tuck is a finance guy who used to be a sysadmin? And he was COO of Joyent for a while, apparently.
- streb-lo 7y agoCare to shed some light on internet history? How did Oracle kill the Sun blogging culture? What/Who was the Sun blogging culture?
- ilikejam 7y agoEngineers blogging about Solaris etc. Internals, gotchas, upcoming things, heads-ups on problems. The patching guys' blog was particularly useful in the face of Solaris' atrocious packaging utils, for example. There was a _huge_ amount of official-unofficial documentation in the blogs that disappeared from the Sun site when Oracle ran its bulldozer through it.
- kick 7y agoSun very strongly encouraged their employees to have blogs, and was either one of or the first to do so (especially at their level). Basically no restrictions on subject matter. Even their CEO regularly blogged! A better question would be "What didn't Oracle do to kill the Sun blogging culture?"
- pjmlp 7y agoOracle still has plenty of ex-Sun on their Java team, which blog seldom, but still blog.
- 7y ago
- kick 7y agoAlmost more interesting than two giants who, for better or worse, have drastically influenced modern computing practices starting a company, is that they started a podcast. The former happens every day, and sure, it's exciting, but how many times have you seen one of these people start a podcast?
- xwdv 7y agoNot sure who any of these people are, or what exactly their “computer company” sells. Do they custom build computers like Falcon Northwest or System76 or something? People need to improve their skills at conveying information; fast and efficiently.
- pimterry 7y agoThe site homepage (rather than the launch announcement) is a bit clearer about their plan: https://oxide.computer/ https://oxide.computer/ > Hyperscaler infrastructure for the rest of us > Oxide is building a new kind of server. > True rack-scale design, bringing cloud hyperscale innovations around density, efficiency, cost, reliability, manageability, and security to everyone running on-premises compute infrastructure. They're building servers, for people who run their own compute infrastructure.
- xwdv 7y agoA better title then would be “Oxide Computer to build servers for compute infrastructures.”
- kick 7y agoThat's far less explanatory.
- xwdv 7y agoWhy? It names the company and what they do and what they sell for. The current title conveys 0 useful information. Don’t know who those people are and a “computer company” could be anything.
- tonyarkles 7y agoThe discussions about the title are interesting to me. I have followed both Jessie and Bryan for years, and seeing their names together and "computer company" got me exceptionally excited!
- adamnemecek 7y ago"While we don’t specify experience levels with particular languages or tools, you’ve almost certainly done work in C and assembly – and you have probably started to play with Rust if you haven’t already outright fallen in love with it." Pumped about Rust.
- sdan 7y agoAfter using GCP and AWS for years and paying exorbitant amounts as a student, I was thinking of just switching to some old Dell rack server. Glad that Oxide will hopefully allow people and companies to utilize their infrastructure on components that may not be so old/may be easier to use.
- blondin 7y agowell what i am getting from cantrill's article is that they wanna build the hardware and the software together. i think maybe on-prem contracts with ibm or dell might not be the target here. in fact open firmware got mentioned a few times. i wish them luck, it's a very interesting approach they are taking here.
- sdan 7y agoI feel like they could incorporate a lot from https://www.openstack.org/ https://www.openstack.org/ for the software side.
- davidrupp 7y ago“exuberant”? I think “exorbitant” makes more sense in this context. Edit: Unless you were really really happy about what you paid, I guess.
- sdan 7y agoYeah, exorbitant. Didn't like paying $300 a year just to run some simple websites/databases
- ekvilibrist 7y agoEC2 instances?
- ak217 7y ago$300 a year is nothing compared to colocating your own server, or even getting a business-grade network connection. If you can get away with hosting on your own computer on a residential connection, that's great for you, but it's a totally different product from what AWS/GCP/colocation offer. By the way, reserved instance pricing on AWS and GCP starts around $20/year. But if you know how to use S3/GS and Dynamo/Datastore, you don't even have to use an instance.
- xwowsersx 7y agoCan someone explain in simple terms what this company will be building? I cannot tell from this post or the other on Oxide.
- Operyl 7y agoTo the best of my comprehension, Hardware and Software designed hand in hand for a good on-premises “cloud.”
- xwowsersx 7y agoWho uses on-prem cloud?
- pnako 7y agoPlenty of companies, including medium-sized companies and companies in non-tech industries (finance, healthcare, defense, etc.) Generally for regulatory/security reasons, and also because it can make financial sense. I can see that Dell, Lenovo, etc. are already offering "Kubernetes" optimized servers; it's not clear how much of it is just marketing, though. Perhaps this new company wants to offer something similar, but be more competitive by taking advantage of superior software design skills (if I understand it correctly). Then it would just be a middleware company disguising itself as a "computer company".
- xwowsersx 7y agoGot it, thanks
- mumblemumble 7y agoI've been involved in two investigations into migrating from an incumbent on-prem cloud to The Cloud. Once directly, once tangentially. Both times, the conclusion was that The Cloud would almost certainly increase our IT costs, and also submit us to vendor lock-in. I see The Cloud as being a great play for new companies, and companies with server needs that are both variable and out of phase with everyone else's. Small startups because time is their most precious resource, and picking a major PaaS provider minimizes the time spent making decisions about things that are tangential to the core business. e.g., if you use AWS then you don't have to hesitate for a moment on your object store; it's going to be S3. If you use on-prem cloud, then you'll likely have to burn a few weeks shopping around for vendors and getting it rolled out before you can be up and running. Multiply that cost by every single decision, and you've got a whole lot of distraction hitting you at the most inconvenient possible time.
- draw_down 7y agoDo we need 3 posts about this?
- LeonM 7y agoHey Jessie, congrats on getting your company up and running! > setting up infrastructure themselves is in a great deal of pain and they have been largely neglected by any existing vendor Can you elaborate on what these pains are, and how OEMs aren't helping their customers with this? I guess what I'm trying to ask is: what will Oxide do different compared to existing OEMs?
- nodesocket 7y ago> largely neglected by any existing vendor I am not sure about this. It seems all their experience is geared towards software with little to nobody from a traditional hardware engineering background. Wouldn't they be better off using open compute[1] designs and focusing on the software inside? Building hardware just seems like a stretch trying to compete against Dell, HP, and Supermicro all of which have "Kubernetes" / high density offerings. [1] https://www.opencompute.org/ https://www.opencompute.org/
- wmf 7y agoWouldn't they be better off using open compute designs and focusing on the software inside? How do you know that's not what they're doing? If they sell servers it doesn't mean they designed them. I wouldn't be surprised if they have some hardware changes for secure boot or something though.
- kick 7y agoThis post title is a reference to The Soul of a New Machine, which both Cantrill and Frazelle have written posts on: https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/new-golden-age-of-building-with-soul/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/new-golden-age-of-building-wi... http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/02/10/reflecting-on-the-soul-of-a-new-machine/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/02/10/reflecting-on-the-sou...
- acomjean 7y agoFor those that don't know "Soul of a New Machine" is a book by Tracey Kidder. Its about the team at Data General building a new computer. I was skeptical about this book, but its really quite a good read. (My mom worked at Data General, which is how I ended up with the book) The book won a Pulitzer prize for non-fiction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Soul_of_a_New_Machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Soul_of_a_New_Machine
- qntmfred 7y agoBoth my parents also worked at Data General, and my dad was there all the way through the EMC acquisition. Love that book.
- sowbug 7y agoIf you like this book, then you'll also like Reminiscences of a Stock Operator, which is a fictionalized account of an occasionally successful stock trader named Jesse Lauriston Livermore who was born in 1877. It doesn't sound captivating, but it is. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reminiscences_of_a_Stock_Operator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reminiscences_of_a_Stock_Opera...
- milankragujevic 7y agoAll 3 titles should [probably, IMO] be corrected to name "Server Company". A "computer" is a superset of servers, desktops, laptops, embedded devices and mobile devices. That way it is more accurate. Currently it is ambiguous what the "computer company" is actually going to "do"/produce/sell.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoThis is like arguing whether Amazon is a tech company or a retail services company. The S&P say it's a retail services company, but we all agree it is powered almost thoroughly by technology in general.
- sdan 7y agoAlthough I understand your point, it's like saying this: "Eduardo Saverin, Sean Parker, and Chris Hughes on track to make social company"
- rchaud 7y agoWhen Amazon formed, Bezos described it as a website you could buy books from. I'm sure the authors could have picked a plain-English description as well.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoI was hoping they were going to go full Gateway 2000 and bring back desktop PCs.
- dmitryminkovsky 7y agoThis is what I was hoping/imagining.
- rchaud 7y agoYeah, I was interested when they said "computer company", which the average reader would associate with Apple or Dell but the homepage described something entirely different, and much less interesting to anybody who isn't a sysadmin.
- mmoez 7y agoWas the garage actually used? Or was it just a folkloric step that is now required by any computer company to emulate other successes in Silicon Valley?
- quaquaqua1 7y agoDefinitely the second one. The sad thing is that there are investors/consumers out there who give bonus points to companies who go through this arbitrary stuff
- openstep 7y agohow do you know?
- quaquaqua1 7y agoConsider how much time certain founders spend at networking conferences telling stories about things that are extremely tangential to the actual technical advantages that help businesses compete. Then study how successful they are compared to those who don't. My point here is that a lot of businesses secure funding and clients through "qualitative" means (WeWork) rather than through technical means (AMD)
- dang 7y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- moreentropy 7y agoThat's your most pressing question?
- mmoez 7y agoI've read the whole blog announcement and couldn't find anything but PR stuff for investor consumption. The garage thing was too much for my taste! It's like trying to forcibly resurrect Apple or HP's first years in the 2020s. Do people still need physical presence in a garage to get things done? Working remotely is now an established practice...
- dcminter 7y agoThe contrasting pictures of the garage and the 'bigger space' are delightful!
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y agoYeah, but what's the product?
- tiborsaas 7y ago"Oxide is building a new kind of server."
- openstep 7y agoIt's really upsetting to me to see how many folks here are asking who these people are. I think young engineers are losing sight of not only how computers and the internet started, but how underlying technologies work. Oh well peanut butter.
- cbanek 7y agoWell, to be fair, I feel like I know a little about how computers work and the internet started, but I didn't know all these names off the top of my head either. (To be fair, one rang a bell) I think it's a very different thing to know how something works than who put it together. These days there are so many important software projects, and a lot of people working on each. It's nearly impossible to keep track of. Personally, I think how it works is much more useful than who wrote it originally, especially since these days, most software projects of note have a fair number of contributors.
- Zekio 7y agoI would have no idea who they were if not for stumbling across one of bryan cantrills early talks by clicking random videos on youtube, watched all his talks that I can find since then. His blog post http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2018/02/03/talks/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2018/02/03/talks/ with all his talks let me see a few of the ones I had originally missed
- dx87 7y agoKnowing the name of someone who invented something has nothing to do with knowing how the thing they invented works.
- monocasa 7y agoKnowing what other things they invented normally puts inventions in a much better context.
- kop316 7y agoWhy is it upsetting? It isn't an instinct and isn't a basic law of nature (so it can't be derived), so at some point in time one has to learn it. So at some point they have to ask who they are. I am happy to see this community answer it, but so people don't feel afraid to ask questions, and so people can learn! Put another way: https://www.xkcd.com/1053/ https://www.xkcd.com/1053/
- tamizhar 7y agoI apologize if this is a silly question, but what exactly does "computer company" mean? I read the link. I see "oxide computer" which makes me think, oh is this one of those newfangled oxide transistor but I clicked a few links like oxide computer principles of operation hoping to get an idea of what this is but instead I see some stuff about candor, empathy which is not what I thought principles meant in this context. I looked through the comments hoping to see someone explain it but no win there. Oh well. I'm sure someone will explain it.
- sdan 7y agoThis is a bad landing page. 1. Bad HN title (doesn't say anything about what they did about the computer they made) 2. Landing page image has some generic background and as far as I saw, no tangible product, other than some shelves of their latest workspace. 3. If they could just include some diagram here or there and put some bold text/say they're building AWS for people/startups, that'd be great and to the point Not bashing them, but just some thoughts I had about their presentation. Regardless, I'm extremely excited for what they're building. Been waiting for something like this to pop up.
- LeonM 7y ago> Landing page image has some generic background and as far as I saw, no tangible product, other than some shelves of their latest workspace. From Jessie's blog post [0] it looks like this is the actual garage where she supposedly started the company. But I agree, there is absolute zero information on the product they are planning to build. Probably because they are still working on fundraising. [0] https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/
- dmix 7y agoIt's amazing it has >400 upvotes at all.
- wyldfire 7y agoI suspect upvoters have some context that's implied by knowing the domain of these founders or their previous work.
- malvosenior 7y agoI've read all of the founders' blog posts now and I'm convinced they've packed every anti-pattern they could find into this startup. It's focus is entirely on the personalities involved and not at all on the product. They talk about their cool new office, funding, they have a 50 point list on values, they have a podcast, a newsletter... Yet there's essentially nothing about what the product is (that being the only thing most people care about). This reminds me of first time founders who can't wait to get "CEO" business cards. Worry about the product first, last and in-between. The rest is just there to signal to us that your priorities aren't in the right place.
- jacquesm 7y agoRemember 'Color'?
- CPLX 7y agoYes. Priceless: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_Labs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_Labs
- thomasjudge 7y agoWow, that was eight years ago...
- ErikAugust 7y ago"Color Labs, Inc. was a start-up based in Palo Alto, California. Its main product was the eponymous mobile app for sharing photos through social networking. It allowed people to take photos in addition to viewing other photos also taken in the vicinity." I wouldn't compare the venture in question at all to 'Color'...
- jacquesm 7y agoYou're missing the point. The only reason Color is even known is because its principal had name recognition before the venture was started.
- wila 7y ago
- signal11 7y agoThis is just my first impressions so it may be wrong. Looking at their blog - their proposition appears to me to be, AWS, Google and Azure can build and manage their systems better than Random Corp. trying to build and manage their own servers by ordering from Dell. Oxide Computer will try and bridge that gap and let anyone buy efficient, manageable servers. This is of some interest to me as there are lots of use cases for which cloud isn't practical or has regulatory challenges, and this should give organizations for whom this is an issue some good options. If nothing else, it'll be interesting as a target for Google's Anthos or Azure's On-Premises service. Edit: This is a good summary[1], I think: > Hyperscalers like Facebook, Google, and Microsoft have what I like to call “infrastructure privilege” since they long ago decided they could build their own hardware and software to fulfill their needs better than commodity vendors. We are working to bring that same infrastructure privilege to everyone else! [1] https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/
- tw04 7y agoCall me skeptical. Part of what allowed Google/Amazon/Facebook to "build their own servers" is that they're ordering 10,000+ at a time from an ODM like Foxconn who doesn't want to deal with people that want 100 at a time. But with that comes rigid standardization... which typically hasn't worked well in the enterprise. Everybody wants to be cloud-like until they figure out being cloud-like means you lose all of your hardware-level flexibility. Oh you wanted one with 512GB of memory instead of 768? Too bad.
- hinkley 7y agoI'm guardedly optimistic. Some people are being nervous about how vague they're being but I'm gonna wait an see if they're just playing very close to the vest. The problem with talking excitedly about the things that are safe to talk about is that it makes it very obviously awkward what isn't being talked about. I'm sure a lot of us got a refresher in how that feels last week. Backblaze has their own custom server racks and we seem to like them just fine.
- 7y ago
- spamizbad 7y agoI’m very excited about this. There’s definitely a hole in the market for “turnkey private cloud done right” that isn’t just a massively marked-up bundle of servers that requires consultants to effectively setup and operate. Also, If CCIX takes off, along with workload-specific accelerators, they’re in a much better position to quickly serve those niches rather than waiting 6mo to rent some cloud instance that might be making all the wrong trade-offs.
- FDSGSG 7y agoI don't think I'd want to buy anything from someone so willing to pull the DYKWIA card in response to polite messages that weren't even directed at them in the first place https://twitter.com/jessfraz/status/891200262068736000 https://twitter.com/jessfraz/status/891200262068736000 Jessie Frazelle is not a reasonable, stable person. E: I get that this might seem a bit harsh, but I think it's perfectly fair to call out founders for their previous (public!) shitty behaviour. Remember Mahbod Moghadam?
- morning_gelato 7y agoThey've also started a podcast focusing on the hardware/software interface called On the Metal. https://oxide.computer/blog/on-the-metal-1-jeff-rothschild/ https://oxide.computer/blog/on-the-metal-1-jeff-rothschild/
- cfors 7y agoHere is a relevant quote from Jess' blog: > Hyperscalers like Facebook, Google, and Microsoft have what I like to call “infrastructure privilege” since they long ago decided they could build their own hardware and software to fulfill their needs better than commodity vendors. We are working to bring that same infrastructure privilege to everyone else. [0] Is this same infrastructure privilege an effective, internal cloud? From my experience with large internal cloud platforms, the problems are almost always organizational ones. Regardless, I am definitely hoping that Oxide can provide a better experience. Maybe with centralizing all hardware into a single group, rather than have network folks do switches, another team do servers, and a totally separate group to do ACL's, etc. you could improve the experience of managing an entire datacenter. Edit: Forgot the link: [0] https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/
- jboynyc 7y agoSource: https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ In the same post, the author writes: "If you want to read more about some of the deep technical problems we will be solving check out my ACM Queue articles" followed by some links. The first, on open-source firmware, even appears to be freely available: https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3349301 https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3349301 So that may help get the necessary context for this company launch.
- cfors 7y agoAh sorry, forgot to link the post! Thank you.
- markbnine 7y agoDo you ever get that creepy feeling that HN is being used for guerrilla advertising?
- steveklabnik 7y agoI submitted this post because I know both Jessie and Bryan, and am really excited about what they're doing here. They didn't ask me to post at all.
- pvg 7y agoWhat are they doing here? It's difficult to tell from the thing you've linked.
- steveklabnik 7y agoFrankly, for me, "Jessie and Bryan are going to start selling computers" is enough for me to get excited about it. I'm not sure I could give you an in-depth rundown, because well, I'm not privy to any information, and obviously this announcement is a bit light on details. Some quotes from both of their posts that I think are important: > hardware and software should each be built with the other in mind. > even as the world is moving (or has moved) to elastic, API-driven computing, there remain good reasons to run on one’s own equipment! > Over the last year, I had the opportunity to spend a lot of time talking with folks who are currently running workloads on premises. The consensus from all my conversations has been that everyone setting up infrastructure themselves is in a great deal of pain and they have been largely neglected by any existing vendor. All these folks have very good reasons for running on premises that include security, strategic reasons like latency, specialized workloads, or the reality that the unit economics of running at their scale in the cloud are unsustainable. > the world needed a company to develop and deliver integrated, hyperscaler-class infrastructure to the broader market — that we needed to start a computer company. > Hyperscalers like Facebook, Google, and Microsoft have what I like to call “infrastructure privilege” since they long ago decided they could build their own hardware and software to fulfill their needs better than commodity vendors. We are working to bring that same infrastructure privilege to everyone else! > could we find an investor who saw what we saw in Oxide? Fortunately, the answer to this question had been emphatic and unequivocal: [yes]
- preston4tw 7y agoI follow Jessie and Bryan both on Twitter and at least with what Jessie has been exploring since she left her last job, this seems like a natural progression. It trips me out to see other people in the comments that don't know who Jessie and Bryan are. They're legends to me, and I consider myself basically a SRE. I highly recommend following them on Twitter as well as virtually any talk they've given. Just go type their names into YouTube. Steve Tuck doesn't ring a bell for me, but considering the company he's in I want to learn more about Steve. I'm super interested to see what comes out of this. I think Jessie has a passion for security (also many other things, but it's what comes to mind), and Bryan for debugging (similarly, many other things as well). I think those are really good backgrounds to have when approaching hardware these days, considering the recent security vulnerabilities around speculative attacks on hardware (specter etc.). Some of the conversations Jessie started on twitter in the past few months raised some interesting questions around open hardware and open firmware, and the problems with proprietary and closed source hardware and firmware. It sounds like this Oxide project might be in a similar space as https://www.opencompute.org/ https://www.opencompute.org/. I'll be interested to see if they partner at all. I'm also very interested to see what the actual products are, how open any hardware or firmware ends up being, and if this venture is successful, if they end up at the same place as any other major hardware company or if they tread new ground.
- driverdan 7y ago> It trips me out to see other people in the comments that don't know who Jessie and Bryan are. I always find this funny. Why would everyone know who they are? There are thousands of interesting people in tech. It's impossible to know of everyone.
- laputan_machine 7y agoInteresting idea, and I wish them the best of luck. However this line: > _Further, as cloud-borne SaaS companies mature from being strictly growth focused to being more margin focused, it seems likely that more will consider buying machines instead of always renting them_ Is not something I think to be true from my experience of being in a large company that has moved away from on-prem hosting to cloud providers. Cloud is cheaper. A lot cheaper, especially if using managed services (with the proper arch! With the exception of logging which is surprisingly expensive). The hardware costs of rolling your own hosting is not the expensive part.
- jonny_eh 7y agoNetflix famously moved their infrastructure from their own data centres to AWS.
- twoodfin 7y agoThough isn’t that the “commodity” part of their infrastructure? They’re presumably still spending like gangbusters on their “on premises” ISP-local hardware & software. I imagine that’s the extreme end of the market Oxide is targeting: Provide a HW/SW platform to build your differentiation on, because the capabilities and value (& moat) aren’t there in the commodity cloud.
- hinkley 7y agoI really think this shouldn't be an either-or thing, most especially for established companies, but to some extent for growing ones as well. If you run a data center in the same city/cities as your engineering strengths are located, that doesn't necessarily give you the geographical diversity you need for many companies. But if you don't run any data centers, you're blind to some of the cost structures, and architectural limitations of the system, and you can become soft. I was going to make a simile to Google and Facebook having their own hardware divisions, but I don't really need to, because they are planning to make cloud-friendly custom hardware for data centers. This seems like an area that the incumbents should be all over but I can't recall the last time I read of innovations from them. Which means there is space for someone new to establish a toe-hold. If I were based in Chicago I'd want a data center in Chicago, and Cloud Servers on the West Coast, (and Europe, etc as applicable). But the lock-in situation is untenable to me right now. It's pretty easy to end up deploying multiple solutions for the same situation. That just complicates reasoning about the system. It bears a resemblance to the Lavaflow antipattern and I can tell you that either can be no fun at all.
- briandear 7y agoShould I know who these people are?
- smlacy 7y agoSo this is just Box 2.0 Signature Edition, right?
- holoway 7y agoEvery thread here about how it’s vanity is bananas. They’re going to build computers! With software to go with them! So that you can have the same experience that the hyperscale companies do. It’s a great bet. This isn’t a blitz to help with fundraising: they already have the money. They are also hiring - which is why they have a long list of principles and values, and talk about each other. They’re looking for kindred spirits. This is a good idea, from people with a history of good ideas.
- Accujack 7y ago>They’re going to build computers! You know they're mostly software people, right? That's actually irrelevant, though. Even if all three of them were Woz-level hardware hackers, that's no guarantee that they're bankable success. Being an impactful software or hardware company takes a team, and in the US at the moment that team is mostly about financial and legal work, not technical. We've all seen that "best technical idea" does not usually equal "best business success" I wish these folks well, and I'm sure their fans will enjoy following them, but people acting like this is a major thing for the whole tech industry are gonna be disappointed.
- jakebasile 7y agoFeeding their index through [Bullshit.js][1] is amusing. [1]: https://mourner.github.io/bullshit.js/ https://mourner.github.io/bullshit.js/
- gtirloni 7y agoI'd remind everyone of the Openstack-based Nebula company that went bankrupt overnight and sold the same dream. You don't bet your on-prem projects on newly born startups.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TheRealPomax 7y agoAm I supposed to know these people?
- mychael 7y agoWhen the blue checkmark crowd on Twitter thinks everyone knows who they are.
- rchaud 7y agoIf I'd just read the post and not clicked the homepage, I'd have no idea what they mean by "computer company". Turns out it's some boring B2B server thing. Does it annoy anyone else to see blog posts where the first paragraph is a bunch of links to other posts? The first paragraph should give the reader at least some idea of what the main idea is. If the material has been covered in detail elsewhere, then post those links at the bottom of the post.
- briandear 7y agoI am not sure why this is news. Anyone can say they started a company. It’s news when someone actually ships a product. Until then, it’s literally nothing but talk. Apple Computer delivered an actual product April 1, 1976 and didn’t even incorporate until 1977. They certainly didn’t spend a year talking about being a computer company before shipping a product. These “we are starting a computer company!!” posts are useless beyond just creating vapid hype. Wasn’t there a companion post on how they started this in a garage? Let’s get real, until you ship a product, you don’t have a company, you have a blog and forcing the “started in a garage ! [omg, omg!]” just seems like a contrived attempt at capturing old-school, Silicon Valley magic. Facebook, Google, Apple, Amazon, Netflix etc. didn’t spend time talking about their new company — the companies just sort of happened as a result of having a product to sell. Get back to us when there is actually something people can buy that solves a real problem.
- rchaud 7y agoThey may be looking for funding. Can't really think of why else they'd need to announce something that's currently vaporware.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIt sounds like they have the funding. The vaporware hype is to attract employees, AFAICT.
- rchaud 7y agoAh, I didn't think of it as a hiring pitch. Yes, that makes sense.
- rakefire 7y agoPeople on Twitter seem to just joke around about it...
- thr0w__4w4y 7y agoJessie = CPO = ???
- Serow225 7y agoI'd guess Chief Product Officer?
- thr0w__4w4y 7y agoJessie Frazelle is listed as the company's "CPO" - huh? Isn't that a Star Wars character? :-P (Obligatory clarification: of course I'm joking; but is that "Chief People Officer"?)
- wombat-man 7y agoMight be Chief Product Officer
- raesene9 7y agoMy guess would be "Chief Product Officer"
- znpy 7y agoBryan Cantrill is basically my role model. I'll be following this.
- mongol 7y agoI am not so fond of the word "privilege" in this context. A sign of the times, I guess.
- briandear 7y agoWriting a biography of a company that doesn’t have a product is a bit trite. When you ship a product, then years later you talk about the history. Right now it like a near live stream of just how old-school “computery” their new company is. I actually hope they are successful. I would love it if they execute on all the bullshit they are hyping — but I am doubtful because I have seen this pattern over and over: people talk about changing the world before they actually do — never do.
- I_am_tiberius 7y agoWhy is that nr 1 on hackernews?
- at-fates-hands 7y agoI love the marketing mumbo jumbo: True rack-scale design, bringing cloud hyperscale innovations around density, efficiency, cost, reliability, manageability, and security to everyone running on-premises compute infrastructure. How are they going to do this? Buy equipment from other vendors and resell them? Build their own servers from scratch? Nothing in the above paragraph tells me how they plan to be better than any other company right now and why, as a business owner I would want to buy my servers from them.
- SEJeff 7y agoGiven the players here (Brian and Steve are both from Joyent) and what little I can deduce from the marketing fluff on their website, this seems like they're just trying to build a hardware stack to go with something like Joyent's (most awesome) Triton: https://github.com/joyent/triton https://github.com/joyent/triton Triton is/was the betamax of on-prem cloud orchestration. It is better tech in the beginning than Kubernetes, but then lost due to the stigma associated with Joyent/Solaris. Kind of a shame as it is really good tech. A bit more non-technical overview: https://www.joyent.com/triton/compute https://www.joyent.com/triton/compute
- travbrack 7y agoIt's pretty good but if you want to do Docker, Kubernetes, etc, you're stuck using LX branded zones which (my layperson understanding) is a Linux user space on top of a SmartOS kernel with Linux system calls implemented. It works OK for most things, but compatibility is a real issue.
- outside1234 7y agoThis is great proof that what many startups are are collections of talent - not products - that are aqui hires
- cryptozeus 7y agoFor those confused about the company, this from their homepage : “Oxide is building a new kind of server. True rack-scale design, bringing cloud hyperscale innovations around density, efficiency, cost, reliability, manageability, and security to everyone running on-premises compute infrastructure.”
- excerionsforte 7y agoNice to see Bryan Cantrill going all in on his assertion that containers must run on hardware. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXWaECk9XqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXWaECk9XqM
- jxramos 7y ago> ...the sharpening desire among customers for a true cloud-like on-prem experience (and the neglect those customers felt in the market) made it more in demand than ever. Great to have options.
- Animats 7y agoWe have started a computer company! (... name dropping ...) ... hyperscaler-class infrastructure to everyone. ... (whatever that is) ... If you are interested in following our progress sign up for our mailing list. If you are interested in potentially joining us, check out our careers page. And if nothing else, give a listen to our podcast, ... (Giant sucking sound from onboarding funnel) This reads like something from a fake startup site generator. Is this for real?
- Timothycquinn 7y agoThis is great news for the Rust community as Bryan has been a strong proponent of using Rust at lower levels of computer systems such as drivers and it sounds like Oxide will be focusing much of their development on this level of development in order to deliver best in class enterprise grade servers. This is a fantastic development for the Rust community that will likely have a positive impact on the linux ecosystem, in the long run if they do this driver development in an open manner. I look forward to following their developments.
- throe12345 7y agoThis whole thread is quite revealing in respect to the fanboyism that is prevalent in computer circles. There's really nothing but buzzwords and two and a half semi-popular tech people behind this startup and people are going crazy about it. When was the last time you heard about people following celebrities in mechanical engineering on Twitter and applauding them founding a new company based on no substance?
- thrillgore 7y agoI literally know nothing about their product, and it seems like both this site and the various blogs being floated (if not outright promoted, especially here) are about the founders, and not the product. I don't care about the team behind it. Give me a tangible product. Or at least a sense of what the product will look like.
- lr 7y ago> Don’t cheat: We believe in playing by the rules of the game, abiding by both their letter and their spirit. If we don’t like the rules, we work openly and collaboratively to improve them. I can't help but think this is a huge swipe at companies like Airbnb, Uber, Lyft, and any of the others that knowingly break laws (or aid others to do so) and hope they can get away with it, or change the law(s) later.
- asdfq1234 7y agoJust what the world needs. Another computer company.
- m00dy 7y agoNothing but a great product will save you guys.
- VectorLock 7y agoGreat Hacker News blasting but whats the product?
- jonny_eh 7y agoComputers?
- zzzcpan 7y agoNo, cloud stuff in a box kind of product, i.e. software, hardware is obviously secondary to it. People are confused because of the comedic level of bullshit (reminds me of "the box" from a Silicon Valley tv show episode).
- VectorLock 7y agoYeah I think they should have saved the HN bombing for when they actually had The Box to sell.
- thedaemon 7y agoIt's likely they are looking for further investors via hackernews.
- anon1m0us 7y agoMy initial impression is a return to on-premise data centers but with cheaper, commodity hardware and a software stack on top. They are doing for on-prem with hotswappable computers in a cloud what hot swappable hard drives did for on-prem storage. My prediction is that their technology will be used by existing data centers more than it will be used by enterprises wanting to return to on-prem from their current cloud operations. They might help serve internal customers in the enterprise, like developers, and intranets, but the cost of pipes will be prohibitive for companies needing lots of bandwidth to serve external customers.
- devdas 7y ago
- doublerebel 7y agoWhen investors bet on an early stage startup, they are betting on the team. This is startup fundraising 101, the track record of the team is what shows they will stick it out and find a solution. These are three people who know product! But they could be totally wrong about how the market will take the product, and have to be willing to work together and possibly pivot until they find product-market fit. Finding teams like this pre-product is what makes early stage investment so valuable. There should be no confusion about the focus on team and vision. I am stoked to see cloud scale tooling become even closer to the hardware, and become more accessible. The completeness and openness of the stack is what attracted me to -- and kept me on -- Joyent's products. Best wishes on your new venture!!
- peterwwillis 7y agoAh, finally we have the business plan: > desire among customers for a true cloud-like on-prem experience > it seems likely that more will consider buying machines instead of always renting them They know companies are insistent on making the mistake of trying to build and run their own platforms, so they're becoming the company that you can throw your money at if you're not willing to pay for IBM/Oracle/etc private cloud. Old folks remember the revolution in distributed computing came from commodities. The idea was to get a lot of the cheapest resources you could and loosely tie them together. This was fast, cheap and effective, because everything was disposable, flexible, open. Even if you hired a dozen engineers, you saved 3 mil a year on enterprise hardware and software licenses. What these folks are betting on is that businesses want to "buy a cloud" cheaper than they'd get it from a traditional cloud vendor. But to get cheap hardware and software, you need to strip it down to bare essentials, use the cheapest, crappiest parts, literally throwing away parts rather than fix them. Purpose-built hardware and software is the opposite, and of course ignores the management costs (unless that's going to be part of the payment strategy?).
- 0x0aff374668 7y agoKinda reminds me of Transmeta. Except they had a product, a shitty one, but a product. Or Ampere, but they only have one product they inherited and no flashy names. Silicon startup challenges are rough. RISC-V is probably the best hope for a new architecture (hint: its not a new architecture).
- floatboth 7y agoWell, this new company seems to be about building servers (probably with custom mainboards?) with existing chips and open firmware. Would be fun if they used Ampere :) but my guess would be that the first products at least are gonna be Corebooted Intel platforms.
- generatorguy 7y agoTransmeta was going to be the next big thing, code morphing! Linus was on board. News on slashdot every day! And then ... some product released but no needle moved. I wonder if they built something that got outpaced by intel, needed network effects to take off that never materialized, were ahead of their time, or just no market for their product? These guys seem like they’ve identified a market and who their first customers are going to be.
- happycube 7y agoSort of... Transmeta was basically a VLIW chip optimized to recompile x86 code. The problem was by that point all x86 chips (even plucky little VIA/Centaur!) were recompiling x86 instructions into RISC-ish ones, and without sucking up RAM and more importantly memory bandwidth to do it. So even if the VLIW chip was on paper more powerful/efficient (and I'm not sure it was), it just couldn't keep up with doing it in hardware.
- amznthrowaway4 7y agoThe pile-on exists largely because one of the founders is a woman and HN is bigoted af.
- tus88 7y agoHow narcissistic is this?
- dang 7y agoPersonal attacks and name-calling aren't allowed here. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. The idea is: if you have a substantive point to make, make it thoughtfully; if you don't, please don't comment until you do.
- hx2a 7y agoBryan Cantrill recently interviewed Arthur Whitney, as discussed in another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21671918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21671918
- nickpeterson 7y agoThat was a repost, the interview happened a decade ago.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zer0faith 7y agoNo where on their website can I find what they are about, how their product adds business value, what makes them different from everyone else selling snake oil... basically nothing.. just some flashy graphics, 10$ words and a company name that makes me think of oxidation (literally rust).. this reeks of marketing.
- Iwan-Zotow 7y agoMessrs. Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs are proud to present the Marauder's Map
- mikl 7y ago> Jessie Frazelle, Bryan Cantrill, and Steve Tuck Are we supposed to know who those people are? I’m sure they are great guys, but trying to trade on your name kinda requires you to be well known first. I’ll be interested to read it once they can say something concrete about what they’re building.
- brandly 7y agoJessie is not a guy.
- AzzieElbab 7y agoI can't figure where all the negativity is coming from. Envy, sloth, pride? Good luck Oxide founders !!!
- ssully 7y agoSame! I saw someone post this originally to twitter and thought it sounded neat. Coming here, the reaction has been really weird/negative.
- wmf 7y agoHN doesn't know anything about hardware + Oxide hasn't explained themselves in detail + cool cynicism. HN also thought that Dropbox was basically rsync.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nickik 7y agoEvery time any company 'starts' and doesn't in detail lay out their 10 year plan to profitability, Hacker News will start shitting on the idea calling it a cheap ripoff of X and it should go away. Same pattern always.
- pnako 7y agoTo me, and I suspect to many other people outside of Silicon Valley, this just sounds like "those 3 people you should know about just started a company". Fine. But in this case there is absolutely nothing: no product picture or description, etc. So we're left with guess work (which is also fine I suppose). It's a bit like telling us that Susie and Jim from Facebook just got engaged. It's good news if you know them, but a bit disappointing otherwise.
- nickpeterson 7y agoDefinitely have a good bit of work done on that whiteboard I hear naming is one of the hardest problems in CS.
- DrScientist 7y agoMy summary: 1. They believe there will be a shift back to on-prem, due to cost, improved security & latency. 2. They can take commodity hardware designs ( Open Compute Project ) and add their own software for manageability. 3. They are big on values, because in the past Bryan got a bit of a rep for being a bit hard to work with. ( eg https://blog.valerieaurora.org/2016/10/22/why-i-wont-be-attending-systems-we-love/ https://blog.valerieaurora.org/2016/10/22/why-i-wont-be-atte... ) 1. I'm seeing this in big companies - cloud can be an expensive option if you are generating your own data on-prem. While the economics might change, security and latency issues won't so easily. Also cloud is a big risk in that realistically what is your migration cost to another provider? If that's high, that's how much your cloud vendor can gouge you before you move ( I like to call that the Oracle business model ). 2. Don't know about the hardware, but those guys have a track record on systems software and Bryan was involved in building similar stuff before in the storage space ( http://www.oracle.com/us/products/servers-storage/zfs-storage-family-ds-173093.pdf http://www.oracle.com/us/products/servers-storage/zfs-storag... ) 3. He is definitely older, perhaps he is wiser.
- buryat 7y agothat's pretty bold idea that there'll be a significant shift back to on-prem given that companies are still migrating into the cloud and the overall cloud market is predicted to continue growing, but we'll see https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2019-04-02-gartner-forecasts-worldwide-public-cloud-revenue-to-g https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2019-04-0...
- mpweiher 7y agoSkate to where the puck will be.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI remember Gartner being real big on SOAP and Web Services, I was an early REST convert, about 5 years after my conversion Gartner came to the government agency were I was working and made one of the guys in charge of lots of SOAP based initiatives cry by flatly announcing that SOAP had lost and REST had won. It was 5 years of Yes SOAP until suddenly it wasn't anymore. So as the other commenter said skate to where the puck is going to be - and don't rely on Gartner for puck location trends.
- RobLach 7y agoSeems like they’re building some custom rack servers for container workloads, leaning on Rust for system software. Sounds cool. Should be a good team to pull it off.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kev009 7y agoThis is the funniest thing I've seen all day. What a hoot. Look at the job req for "hardware engineer": they have no idea how to solicit EEs or what they are even looking for on the _most_ important roles for even doing something in this space (and none of the personalities have skills or credibility in). That they duped a VC into funding this is side-splitting hilarious and a sign of impending correction in tech.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't be a jerk on HN. Even if you don't feel you owe the people you're attacking any better, you do owe this community better if you're posting here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tzs 7y agoRandom observations on the garage photo. Nice collection of floppies (3.5" and 5.25"). I wonder how long floppies stored in a garage actually remain usable? The cans that say "RePop" and BSW on them are microphone pop filters from Broadcast Supply World. For podcasting? On the shelf below the floppy shelf looks like some kind of tape drive, and maybe those are tape cartridges to the left of it? Is that a couple of motherboards in anti-static bags on top of the tape drive? What is the box to the right of that? It kind of looks like an adjustable DC power supply, common in electronics labs, except I don't see any terminals on front...unless those two round things on the lower right are jacks? But the jacks are usually black and red, and I can't see any color there in the photo. Based on the box colors, the top box of Coke is twisted mango diet Coke, which was introduced in early 2018, putting an upper limit on the age of the photo. There is some kind of tablet with pen on the desk. Anyone recognize what kind it is? That's a lot of pens. They should have bought 3 or 4 fewer pens (which would hardly even be noticed) and used the money for a taller jar. Interesting file cabinet. What applications is that style of file cabinet designed for? I don't think I've seen one with so many horizontal draws that are that short before. I can't recognize anything on the keychain sitting on the desk (well...anything other than keys I mean).
- hokumguru 7y agoTablet: https://remarkable.com/?gclid=Cj0KCQiAiZPvBRDZARIsAORkq7dzKgo0KOYlBnuq50BZqvUOpfRNplrLGBxrbAesEju8v2jNwuqe-XUaAvnBEALw_wcB https://remarkable.com/?gclid=Cj0KCQiAiZPvBRDZARIsAORkq7dzKg...
- andrewprock 7y agoThe issue of the ACM is from August of this year: https://cacm.acm.org/magazines/2019/8 https://cacm.acm.org/magazines/2019/8
- dylanz 7y agoI 80% understand what this company is doing, but I 100% know that this team is awesome. I'm very much looking forward to more news and progress as it happens.
- markmm 7y agoStill unclear on what their product is. Hardware? Software ?
- jasoneckert 7y agoTrying to figure out what this company does from their website is fundamentally the same as trying to nail Jell-O to a tree.
- cagenut 7y agoThis sounds fairly similar to where Hyve [1] and Penguin Computing [2] fit in, so what does Oxide plan to do differently? [1]https://hyvesolutions.com/ https://hyvesolutions.com/ [2]https://www.penguincomputing.com/ https://www.penguincomputing.com/
- wmf 7y agoHyve and Penguin probably have the same shit AMI UEFI and shit AMI BMC firmware as every other vendor. It sounds like Oxide is going to write higher-quality firmware.
- par 7y agowho are these guys?
- SwellJoe 7y agoCantrill is probably the most well-known. Long-time Solaris advocate, worked on Joyent for a long time, etc. You'll find his fingerprints on a lot of stuff. It'd be hard to find someone more capable of building on-prem cloud infrastructure at a systems level, I think. Frazell is pretty well known for Docker and container-oriented stuff. I think she was at Google for a while, but maybe Microsoft? Somewhere big doing cloud things, for sure, though. I don't know the other person. But, I would guess they have to be reasonably impressive to be on this team.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y agoA quick Google shows he was the COO of Joyent, so likely Cantrill's sidekick.
- ryancnelson 7y agoSteve Tuck was the long-time cornerstone of the sales team at Joyent. He was at Dell before that. He rose to Sales VP, then GM, then COO there. He's not a kernel coder; he's a tech-business-person, and a cool, noble, and legit one at that.
- W-Stool 7y agoHonest question: what is this company trying to do that buying a couple of blade chassis full of blades, a bunch of VMware licenses, and a SAN won't do? I truly don't get it.
- AndrewBissell 7y agoA few months back I randomly ran across Cantrill, Frazelle, and Tuck while they were at a FedEx Center printing and signing some docs for Oxide. As a recent convert to Cantrill YouTube fandom, I recognized him and said hello. They were all tremendously welcoming and friendly, and Cantrill took a great deal of time to shoot the breeze with me about Rust, the plans for their new business, and the pain points of working with Xoogler architects (not in reference to Frazelle, I should note). I've been watching off and on for their launch announcement ever since. Some of the reservations about their business plan expressed in this thread ring true with me, and yet I hope they will succeed in spite of it all. The last thing the world needs is an internet which runs entirely on computers owned by Amazon, Microsoft, and Google.
- dang 7y agoThere were three large threads. We merged them. The other URLs: https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ https://blog.jessfraz.com/post/born-in-a-garage/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/12/02/the-soul-of-a-new-computer-company/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/12/02/the-soul-of-a-new-com... Comments about the garage were probably in response to the jessfraz.com post. Other than that I didn't see any merged comments that were specific to one URL.
- martyvis 7y agoUnless they really want to have him for the laughs, they need to drop Steve Tuck from the tech podcast. Using "instruction set" in place of "instruction” and not immediately understanding the forward slash / backslash disconnect between Windows and everyone else really puts him in a different mindset
- zxienin 7y agoThe premise here is that there is market for folks who want to _preferentially_ be in private DC, rather hyperscalers. > True rack-scale design, bringing cloud hyperscale innovations around density, efficiency, cost, reliability, manageability, and security to everyone running on-premises compute infrastructure. Surely, this influences manageability (and $$). Does it influence the on-demand provisioning benefit of hyperscalers (achieved at scale) though? _One_ of the reason me and my team chose hyperscaler is that I get my compute today, now. Rather having to wait weeks/months for my in-house IT to get for me.