16 ms·
Apocalyptic claims about climate change from both sides are wrong. As the article says, climate change won't destroy human civilization. Halting climate chang
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
Apocalyptic claims about climate change from both sides are wrong.
As the article says, climate change won't destroy human civilization.
Halting climate change won't destroy the economy, nor would it significantly affect it. It'd cost on the order of a trillion dollars. That's a crazy amount of money, but the US can and will spend that kind of money regularly. For instance, it's comparable to the Iraq War or the Apollo project. It's less than WWII.
And it's not like the trillion would disappear; it's being spent in the economy. And via the broken windows measurement fallacy of economics, it would likely increase our GDP rather than decrease it.
- devonkim 7y agoI usually argue against conservative colleagues that are primarily business minded that climate change is demonstrable risks to our private sector economy and national security. Is there a private sector solution towards a global problem that's possible when it's an international policy problem? No, there isn't, especially when so many interests are disincentivized to do anything about the problem. I hate to use increasing GDP arguments either - GDP is a measure of activity and _what_ it's used for is completely out of the picture. If every American was on payday loans and would be dying immediately after having spent their last dollar on basic needs and capital efficient goods & services our GDP would soar - this is clearly not something that should be optimized for except it's the path we're heading toward right now.
- shkkmo 7y ago> If every American was on payday loans and would be dying immediately after having spent their last dollar on basic needs and capital efficient goods & services our GDP would soar While the GDP per capita might soar, the GDP itself would plummet. When you kill off productive workers (all else being equal) you lower your GDP.
- wavepruner 7y agoAssuming the trillion dollar claim is true, there would still be a huge amount of disagreement on how it is best to spend it.
- KON_Air 7y agoOf course it will be spent on financial markets and derivatives. Why else do you think Al Gore is pumping out teenage enviromental activists?
- coldpie 7y agoYeah, this is the most frustrating part of all this. Halting climate change isn't even that hard and would clearly benefit billions of people. It just affects the pocketbooks of a couple of rich people, so we can't do it, and instead spin our tires with dumb nit-picking articles like this one.
- robomartin 7y agoNo, halting climate change is actually impossible. All you need in order to understand this is elementary physics (conservation of energy, etc) and critical thinking. This isn’t my opinion, we have known this —by this I mean, science, not voodoo— for many years, probably a decade or more.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoYou're making a claim but you're not substantiating it, could you elaborate what you're referring to exactly?
- meiraleal 7y agoThere is no need to substantiate it, it is plain pure logic. The climate will always change. We can influence it a bit, but definitely a lot less than we having giving ourselves credit for. More than that, we don't have enough data to understand how the climate would change by itself, without human influence. The same way there is night and day, winter and summer, planet Earth might be subject to other climate variations that we don't have a clue. One thing I know for sure: if the population is growing, the Earth is becoming better for human-life, not worse. I'll be concerned about climate change when the population starts to shrink but we are way far from that.
- glial 7y agoObligatory (for you) xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/
- take_a_breath 7y ago
- paulddraper 7y agoOr twice the amount to prop up failed lending businesses in 2008. That is terrific news; any sources? It's incredible you could change enough with "only" that many resources, even limiting the scope of discussion to the U.S.'s 15% contribution [1] to the global total. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_greenhouse_gas_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_greenhous...
- bryanlarsen 7y agohttps://time.com/5709100/halt-climate-change-300-billion/ https://time.com/5709100/halt-climate-change-300-billion/
- paulddraper 7y ago> $300 billion. That’s the money needed to stop the rise in greenhouse gases and buy up to 20 years of time to fix global warming, according to United Nations climate scientists. Wow, I'm surprised the claim isn't more widely circulated.
- breakyerself 7y agoIt's going to cost us trillions more if we keep doing nothing so it's actually a savings.
- n0rbwah 7y agoIt's going to cost the next generations trillions more. Most people making those decisions are hoping that they'll have checked out by the time shit really hit the fan.
- dirtyid 7y ago>Halting climate Halting or mitigating? I don't see climate change halting when 3/4 of the world are still clawing out of developing status. Whatever projections we have now we should triple it. Though I agree it's worth investing in engineering solutions now if only because we need proven solutions later as conditions gets worse.
- shkkmo 7y ago> I don't see climate change halting when 3/4 of the world are still clawing out of developing status. The article suggests that is a good thing and we should help this 3/4 of the world to acheive afluence >> “If you want to minimize carbon dioxide in the atmosphere in 2070 you might want to accelerate the burning of coal in India today,” MIT climate scientist Kerry Emanuel said. >> “It doesn’t sound like it makes sense. Coal is terrible for carbon. But it’s by burning a lot of coal that they make themselves wealthier, and by making themselves wealthier they have fewer children, and you don’t have as many people burning carbon, you might be better off in 2070.” >>“You’ve got to come up with some kind of middle ground where you do reasonable things to mitigate the risk and try at the same time to lift people out of poverty and make them more resilient,” said Emanuel. “We shouldn’t be forced to choose between lifting people out of poverty and doing something for the climate.”
- radicalbyte 7y agoThe benefits from stopping burning of coal and oil on just the air quality are immense.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThe US can spend any number of trillions, without affecting India and China emissions.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoThat's kind of a childish argument to make - "why should we do it when x doesn't anyway? Hmph!" The US has always presented itself - through media, propaganda, etc - as exemplary, greatest country in the world, home of the free / brave, leaders of innovation, technology, economics and warfare. So why not be better than the others at reducing emissions? It's a huge financial opportunity too, as exemplified by e.g. Tesla that sells cars, batteries, battery technology and solar all over the world, bringing a lot of money back to the US (in theory, assuming it's not whisked off to a tax haven like e.g. Apple and Google do). What I'm saying here is that someone has to take the moral high ground. The US already pretends to do this, but they have the means to put it into practice.
- DATACOMMANDER 7y ago>That's kind of a childish argument to make - "why should we do it when x doesn't anyway? Hmph!" Whoa there, settle down. That’s not the sentiment behind the argument.
- xienze 7y ago> That's kind of a childish argument to make - "why should we do it when x doesn't anyway? Hmph!" Well it’s a _global_ problem. The US isn’t the only party here. Emissions in the US have been going down and in India and China they’ve been going up[1] like crazy. And yet the US is constantly harangued about reducing emissions and concerns about India and China are hand waved away. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_fossil_carbon_dioxide_emissions_six_top_countries_and_confederations.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_fossil_carbon_dio...
- lexs 7y agoSo to be fair, it makes much more sense to talk about per capita in this context as there is also just more consumers in China than the US [0] And then it is also important to look at Consumption-based vs. production-based emissions. Ultimately less emissions are less emissions even if others don't follow. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions#/media/File%3ATotal_CO2_emissions_by_country_in_2017_vs_per_capita_emissions_(top_40_countries).svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_...
- tabtab 7y agoRe: "Apocalyptic claims about climate change from both sides are wrong." Indeed! Don't listen to pundits and politicians. They are generally blowhards, not experts. Even some experts make outlier predictions, and those who want to make a case that there is too much exaggeration glom onto such. If you go looking for exaggeration or nuts, they are easy to find. In any subject, listen to multiple opinions and find the original source of claims or studies, not paraphrased or re-construed summaries. The most accurate voices are rarely the loudest.
- fortran77 7y agoIt may be better for Elizabeth Warren to commit to spending an additional 1.5 Trillion to address global warming than to forgive student debt. I think many more people would be amenable to addressing the problem if it can be demonstrated that it could be solved for a fixed, one-time cost.
- Jamwinner 7y agoOne promises free money to voters of a certain age. The other just (silently) benefits everyone. I wonder which is more useful for getting into office? Its all posturing.
- lkbm 7y agoI'm assuming you mean Elizabeth Warren. Here's her stated plan for addressing climate change: https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/climate-change https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/climate-change Relevant snippet: > Her green manufacturing plan would invest $2 trillion over the next ten years in green research, manufacturing, and exporting It then breaks that down with slightly more detail ($400 billion for clean energy research, $1.5 trillion to "purchase American-made clean, renewable, and emission-free energy products", $100 billion to increase clear energy tech exports.) It also links to https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/green-manufacturing https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/green-manufacturing for (a little) more details on that section. She's not necessarily my first choice, but the claim that she's not talking about "paying a similar sum to fix climate change" is wrong.
- Supermancho 7y ago> how they are to be paid back There is one crux where forgiveness makes sense. You cant pay back a loan with a job you cant get because the school was sued into oblivion for fraud. > bright college students College for all ensures that the majority of students trying to pay for college are below average, while graduates may align more with your assessment. Im not sure how you can characterize a bright student as someone who took out loans in lieu of scholarships.
- fortran77 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- usaar333 7y agoCan you cite the $1 trillion cost? Sources I've read seem more in the tens of trillions (https://www.thejournal.ie/paris-climate-agreement-costs-health-benefits-3879180-Mar2018/ https://www.thejournal.ie/paris-climate-agreement-costs-heal...)
- akvadrako 7y agoI'm not sure what the top poster's "plan" is, but if we wanted to switch to significant amounts of solar+wind, that would require batteries costing thousands of trillions. Practically impossible. However if he meant planting trees and switching the world to nuclear, that might be doable for a few trillion. Every government project goes over budget, so it's probably much higher than that.
- bryanlarsen 7y ago> That would require batteries costing thousands of trillions. Overprovisioning is a much cheaper solution.
- hwillis 7y ago> that would require batteries costing thousands of trillions. Hilariously disconnected from reality. That would be tens of petawatt-hours. The world uses tens of petawatt-hours of electricity annually.
- ben_w 7y agoLi-ion batteries cost ~$145/kWh (new), can last >4,000 cycles. That’s <$0.03625/kWh when adjusting for product lifetime. World electricity production is ~5 TW, assume that you need to store half of it to cover nighttime (seasonal adjustments exist, but I think that’s more a problem for production than storage when the storage itself is effectively a stockpileable consumable), 2.5 TW-years of battery production per year @ $0.03625/kWh = $729.4 billion/year worldwide. And that’s even ignoring things like a worldwide power grid as an alternative to batteries, as I agree that government projects are often over budget: batteries can be done at a household scale and every kWh helps. I really should write up a long form blog post about this, these conversations keep circling around the same points.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hzhou321 7y ago> As the article says, climate change won't destroy human civilization. It will devastate part of the population. Climate change is just an inevitable change. To cope with the change, certain portion of people will be sacrificed and certain people's position will be leveraged. So the view depends on the perspective. If you looking at humanity as every one together and equally, then it is apocalyptic. There is little hope that we can sustain. If you are looking at human civilization as something carried on by elites (as we always have), then such changes may even be welcomed -- all the reason that one need be prepared.
- Vysero 7y agoThis isn't true and is exactly the kind of fear mongering the author is trying to discredit.
- kortex 7y agoIt's not not true though. Climate change is absolutely an existential risk. Maybe it would not be on it's own, but we have nukes. Even a "small" nuclear skirmish could dramatically destabilize all of human economics. Perhaps the framing needs tweaking. It is inaccurate to say "if we don't fix climate change, it will end humanity". But "unmitigated climate change could spell the end of the world as we know it. Do you like the world as it currently is, or do you wanna roll the dice and risk apocalypse/Mad Max/ etc?" is completely plausible. Is there a semantic and ontological difference between "er'rybody gonna die!" and "[almost] er'rybody might die!"? Of course. Is there a difference in terms of expectation value of human quality of life in the future? Not a very big one if you ask me.
- asjw 7y ago> Climate change is absolutely an existential risk. So are sleeping volcanoes and space asteroids The point is that the "end of the world as we know it" has already happened in history, more than a few times already. I'm sure either we stop it or not that things are going to be vastly different after . But it doesn't mean is gonna be worse
- Brakenshire 7y agoYou don’t need broken windows for economic growth from action against climate change. We’re going to see numerous core technologies of civilization becoming significantly cheaper than the incumbent technologies. We’ve already seen that with LEDs and lighting. Likewise opportunistic electricity use (which doesn’t depend on time and location) derived from wind or solar is already perhaps half to a third of the cost of the cheapest fossil fuel source. Electric vehicles will also end up significantly cheaper per mile, and in fact are already cheaper at the right levels of utilization. Fossil fueled electricity and road transport are going to be progressively undercut by the zero carbon alternatives, and that’s going to make the global economy vastly more productive. That’s to say nothing of the economic benefits of reducing air pollution and the massive costs associated with its impacts on human health.
- mikojan 7y agoYou are wrong and the author of that article, too, is wrong. Some scientists the author claims do not exist even made this handy chart for y'all: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_Clock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_Clock
- blunte 7y agoThe US currently has a 1 trillion dollar annual budget deficit. So clearly, such a borrowed cost is not unreasonable.
- ogre_codes 7y ago> As the article says, climate change won't destroy human civilization. It's likely climate change itself won't destroy human civilization. Food shortages, massive wildfires (which climate change contribute to), rising sea levels, and changing weather patterns will have huge and unpredictable effects on global politics. What the downstream effects of those changes will be is extremely hard to predict, but the chances of a nightmare outcome are far greater than the chances civilization will remain largely unchanged over the next 20-30 years. The good news is the most likely scenario is things will just keep getting shittier slowly and we'll avoid any sort of apocalypse. We'll just leave our grandkids a super-shitty world. Yay Us!
- kindatrue 7y ago>We'll just leave our grandkids a super-shitty world. But just think of GDP as people continually try to patch the super-shitty world!
- undersuit 7y agoIs this a Broken Windows Theory thing?
- lordnacho 7y agoThat would make sense. You'd measure GDP, which is a gross figure. But making your life livable again doesn't help your net. Just like if you feel you need bodyguards, are you as well off as someone who spends the same on something he doesn't feel compelled to buy?
- asjw 7y ago> We'll just leave our grandkids a super-shitty world. Yay Us! What if it's exactly what they deserve? Who knows, maybe if we leave an healthy planet with an healthy economy and a bright future, they will colonize and destroy some other civilization...
- bdamm 7y ago
- loopz 7y agoWhat is a bit alarming, is how human-centric the discussion is, while ignoring what rapid temperature change may mean to life and nature as we know it.
- pksdjfikkkkdsff 7y agoHere in Germany we have an airport that has so far cost 5 Billion to build, and it doesn't even work yet. So you are saying, for just the cost of 200 of those airports, climate change could be halted? I find that extremely unlikely. I mean for the price, you could basically only build 200 things that are the size of that airport (granted, you can build them cheaper, but apparently it is not a given that it works out). I think you need to change far more things than just 200 airports to halt climate change. New power plants or solar energy thingies or whatever. New cities so that people don't have to commute with energy sucking cars. New cars, so that people don't need to burn fossil fuels for driving (and we are talking millions of cars). New factories, new farming methods, and so on and so on. And not just in one country, but world wide.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIt's not the absolute cost, it's the incremental cost. For example, the world has about a billion vehicles; just replacing those with electric vehicles would cost tens of trillions. But you don't count the whole cost of the car, you count the price differential between an ICE vehicle and equivalent electric one. And that differential is dropping rapidly -- the most shocking thing about the Tesla Cybertruck announcement wasn't it's ugliness, it's that it is at price parity with a comparable ICE truck even without a subsidy. Similarly wind power is now cheaper than gas.
- pksdjfikkkkdsff 7y agoBut that would not halting climate change now, but in a few decades when all the current vehicles have been replaced? Also afaik the CO2 difference between electric vehicles and fuel based vehicles is not even that great? The scary part is that I think many things climate activists propose actually produce a lot more CO2 in the short term. Factories to build those new cars. Building housing to shorten the commutes. Many other things. Wouldn't it be better to use the existing infrastructure for as long as possible, rather than build new things to replace it? I wonder how much of a proxy for CO2 output the cost of things is, anyway (since oil price affects so many things). If "cleaner" new products cost more, it makes me suspect they actually consume more CO2 in production. Of course you have to factor in CO2 production in use (fossil fuels vs battery powered cars for example). But often the advantage is not so clear cut. If the new things were better, there would be no need for political intervention to make people use them.
- fredgrott 7y agoacidification of the Ocean was involved in the last animal and plants extinction where over 50% stuff GONE! Simple science CO2 is the root cause of such things.. Its very freakling real folks despite money people not willing to protect our futures! Does anyone every pay attention to the chemistry and biology we had in hs anyo0mre?
- StacyRoberts 7y agoThis is the sixth time the carbon cycle has extincted life on earth. Why will this one be different? It's as inevitable as the water cycle or the citric cycle. > one estimate published in 2004 expected that some 90% of the currently spoken languages will have become extinct by 2050. What is that, but the destruction of human civilization? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extinct_language https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extinct_language There is no stopping it. We must accept that fact and choose to adapt if humans are to survive as a species on this planet. Otherwise, I don't think there will be humans 100,000 years from now. I don't know what timeline you're thinking, but we are doomed on some scale assuredly if we don't get over our hubris. This planet is not under our control.
- ratboy666 7y ago"Halting climate change"? Please -- the climate changes. It has ALWAYS changed. To think that we can "halt climate change" is hubristic.
- codeulike 7y agoHalting the change that we've caused that is outside the scope of normal changes is obviously what they mean. Why are you pretending to not understand
- schwartzworld 7y agoAre you being deliberately obtuse?
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoIt's certainly easier than actually thinking about the issue.
- hinkley 7y agoWars are literally about destroying things until the other side gives up. The new money goes into the economy yes, but wherever you replace things instead of adding things, any 'value' of the defunct equipment is pretty negligible, isn't it? Let's say we decommission a coal plant. On the one side you have the human support materials (furniture, office supplies, etc). On the other side you have the equipment for power grid tie-in. All of these could be redistributed into non-coal related businesses. Isn't there a lot of stuff in the middle that's scrap? It had more value than that. Both objectively and subjectively (sunk cost fallacy), there's going to be some loss associated with the process.
- namirez 7y ago> As the article says, climate change won't destroy human civilization. I think most reasonable people agree with this statement. I've personally never heard about the collapse of human civilization in the near future due to climate change. Having said that, this article sounds a bit too optimistic. Some people attribute the Syrian civil war to long droughts and climate change [1]. The science is disputed but regardless of the cause, we can all see the backlash against the flood of refuges in Europe. Now imagine the scale of mass migration is one or two orders of magnitude larger; do you really believe you can persuade voters by saying that the solution is less expensive than WWII? I think the real danger of climate change will be political. Who is going to pay for it? The countries which are most affected don't necessarily have the resources to manage it and the countries which have the resources might have a hard time convincing their citizens to bear the cost of it. This requires a coordinated international effort. [1] https://www.wired.com/2015/03/global-warming-helped-cause-syrian-war/ https://www.wired.com/2015/03/global-warming-helped-cause-sy...
- golergka 7y ago> As the article says, climate change won't destroy human civilization. And why are we so sure about that? As far as I can tell by what's happening in the oceans, climate change may very well destroy all surface-dwelling multicellular life.
- thu2111 7y agoThere are no models from standard institutions that I'm aware of in which projected climate change destroys all multi-cellular life, that's exactly the kind of absurdly over the top claim the article is arguing against. Go look at long term temperature graphs over time and then look at current temperature trends as measured by satellites: https://www.drroyspencer.com/latest-global-temperatures/ https://www.drroyspencer.com/latest-global-temperatures/ They show a slight warming trend, but still quite under the projections and nowhere near enough to cause more than economic disruption, let alone destroy humans, let alone all multi-cellular life. The climate has had far greater extremes in the past and multi-cellular life was just fine.
- pvaldes 7y ago> climate change won't destroy human civilization. But this people still have a problem https://www.kgou.org/post/five-years-after-tornado-moore-rethinking-how-it-prepares-disasters https://www.kgou.org/post/five-years-after-tornado-moore-ret... Looks a pretty finished work to me... If is recoverable or not would depend on the interval of time between each reconstruction.
- c2h5oh 7y agoActually you can ignore economy. tl;dr; Futurama was right: nuclear winter cancels global warming 1. At high humidity max temperatures humans can survive for more than 30 minutes are not that high. 2. During a heatwave (peak 46C at ~50% humidity) in India 30% of Ahmedabad all cause mortality was connected to temperatures https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4024996/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4024996/ 3. Temperature increase is not going to be the same across the globe. Many models predict with a 2C global avg temp increase a 4C increase of average temperatures in India and Pakistan with peak temperatures during heat waves going up by as much as 10C. 4. That temperature increase pushes conditions beyond what most people can acclimatize to. In large areas of India, Pakistan and China (among other places) physical labor and maybe even survival without access to cooling will not be possible for as much as 20-60 days per year. 5. A significant chunk of 3.9B people living in India, Pakistan and China will be displaced with nowhere to go. All 3 countries have nuclear weapons to make sure they have somewhere to go :P
- etatoby 7y ago> Futurama was right: nuclear winter cancels global warming I'm not sure it does (I'd love to read an accurate model of it) but I get your point. It's a very compelling point. I wish humans didn't need the threat of nuclear weapons to keep the basic needs of other humans in mind, but since they do... there you go.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> it's not like the trillion would disappear; it's being spent in the economy. And via the broken windows measurement fallacy of economics, it would likely increase our GDP rather than decrease it. Wait, what? You're correctly calling out the broken windows fallacy as a fallacy, but saying that it's _true_? Wealth is tied to value/utility in a way that isn't fully captured by spending, and the broken-windows phenomenon shows up in GDP figures too (it just trades short run for long run, at unfavorable exchange rates).
- thu2111 7y agoHe's saying that GDP is a measure of activity frequently misunderstood as a measure of wealth, and the broken windows fallacy is a conflation of an increase in economic activity with an increase in wealth. Same thing. Put another way, arguments about GDP growth are frequently fallacious, which I agree with.
- zebby 7y agoWhen my government wants to increase my taxes even further to combat climate change (already 50% tax rate for income above €17k/yr and 21% VAT), yes it does indeed destroy the economy of my wallet. Infuriating since the emissions my little country, Belgium, producese, are next to nothing.