10 ms·
This is all driven by globalisation, and don't get me wrong I'm a globalist, but this is just a fact. First manual labour in manufacturing was outsourced abroad
by simonh 7y ago
This is all driven by globalisation, and don't get me wrong I'm a globalist, but this is just a fact. First manual labour in manufacturing was outsourced abroad, then higher tier tech jobs in software and product engineering. Now big firms from former third world countries are muscling in on markets at every level of the economy, creating competition at every level of business.
You can't add hundreds of millions of Chinese people to the global work force, now at every level of the global economy, without affecting the market for that labour.
I said I'm a globalist, yes I am. My wife is Chinese, I've been going there regularly since 2001. When I first went private car ownership was near unheard of. It's a different country now, near-empty streets with a few donkey drawn carts are now choked with commuter traffic.
The result has been a pause in income growth in the western world. We've benefited from cheap imported goods, but lost out in domestic growth. The upside is that hundreds of millions of people, not just in China but in plenty of other places too, have been elevated out of poverty. I've seen that for myself and it's done an incalculable amount of good, it's just that all the benefits haven't been evenly distributed.
Could we in the west have benefited more if we'd had less globalisation? I really don't know. We have benefited I think, and we've had opportunities to invest and sell into those markets we wouldn't have otherwise had. I don't know, it's hard to evaluate what could have been as it's such a radically different shape for the world economy. Maybe we'd have ended up even worse off, who knows? But we might have been better off, I can't deny it.
For the future, we can already see incomes in China have shot up. Low level manufacturing jobs are moving out of China, because Chinese labourers have more skills now and can command high enough wages in more upmarket jobs that they don't need the low end work any more. I suspect that's why the employment rate in the US and elsewhere, at the bottom end of the economy, is picking up. I hope that continues, and in future growth will be more balanced across the economic and wage spectrum.
- danaris 7y ago> The result has been a pause in income growth in the western world. We've benefited from cheap imported goods, but lost out in domestic growth. Except that's not true. There's been growth; it's just all gone to the very wealthy in the West.
- atomi 7y agoI've read our production has more than doubled since the 90's; wages have not.
- johnminter 7y agoHow much of that is due to automation? Profit margins are also important, especially in a global economy.
- uoaei 7y agoProfit margins take a backseat to citizen welfare in questions of ethics.
- johnminter 7y agoHave you started or worked in a small business? Margin makes the difference between making payrolll and continued operation or failure/closing. Large corporations also prosper or fail based on margin.
- mrfredward 7y agoWell, the executives making the outsourcing decisions still have their paychecks and people who own stock are reaping the profits from cheap labor. It matches the gp comment's description of events just fine.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoSure, but "growth" isn't some physical thing that the very wealthy might have stolen. "All the income growth has gone to the very wealthy" means the same thing as "Income growth has paused, with an exception among the very wealthy".
- danaris 7y agoExcept that they have stolen it. Through lobbying and other means, they've gotten the laws changed so that it's much easier for them to hoard vast amounts of money and not be taxed on it (low capital gains taxes, offshore tax shelters, etc). Simultaneously, they've gutted the power of unions, reduced social safety nets, and convinced a huge chunk of America that the ones that are really to blame are other poor people (who just happen to look slightly different than them). There isn't just some random "exception" among the wealthy. They've very specifically engineered the economy so that they get vastly disproportionate amounts out of it.
- nsporillo 7y agoAverage voter doesn't care about the merits of competitive advantage. Maybe if the Chinese actually opened their markets up to competition would we see true benefits in the west. The problem of course is preventing the majority of the wealth going straight to the top.
- Pigo 7y agoMaybe if China played by the rules, and did something about ip theft...
- WhompingWindows 7y agoChina IS doing something about industrial espionage: they're supporting and encouraging it. This isn't dissimilar from what all the Western economies did with industrial espionage during the 1800's. In Rhode Island, we have the first mill in the US, known as Slater Mill, which was created by an industrial spy who stole secrets from England. The English were ahead in industry for textiles, coal mining, steam engines, steel, railroads, and all the other Europeans and Americans sent spies there to "tour" the factories or "apprentice" only to disappear just in time. So, we shouldn't forget history and be shocked that the US is having its economic secrets stolen, as that's happened numerous times in the past.
- nyolfen 7y agono one is acting surprised, they’re acting upset, and rightly
- AlexandrB 7y agoI really hope they don't. Western IP laws have become suffocating to innovation (life of author +70 years copyright, software patents), and need to be weakened. Perhaps if China is successful with weaker IP laws it will get some politicians off their ass on the issue.
- nyolfen 7y ago
- jonbon2 7y agoThe author talks about this in another of his articles called "The tree fusions"[1] [1]-https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2018/08/the-three-fusions/ https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2018/08/the-three-fusions...
- mc32 7y agoOne big problem is GHW, Clinton, GW and Obama said we’d be able to sell into their market and we’d come up on top. That the middle class would see more and better jobs as a consequence (we’d graduate from arduous manual labor into more value add). That’s been nonsense. Perot was prescient and he was right. But we laughed him off the stage. Instead, big biz, some bankers some dealmakers, politicians and other value add service professionals made money. Joe and Jill Bluecollar and Cindy and Ted Middleclass saw an erosion in job prospects, income, job security and future prospects for their children. These people cannot afford the Chinese au pair to teach their kids Chinese. These people vote for Bernie and they vote for Trump. The pols made that bed, so don’t cry when people vote for the above. It was a long time coming.
- take_a_breath 7y agoDon’t forget how Reagan told us that tax cuts would “trickle down” and busting unions would make us all more prosperous.
- mc32 7y agoNo doubt but that’s amateurish compared to how we got screwed by people who said they were fighting FOR US. On the other hand he deregulated airlines and telephony which jump started the tech revolution.
- take_a_breath 7y agoI don’t see how it’s any different, let alone “amateurish”. Clinton cleared the way for the internet to create as much wealth as it has (Telecommunications Act of 1996). Every President has had positive policies and negative policies, so we could play that game all day. Acting like deregulating airlines and busting unions are on the same level is curious. One has created some new companies (and many corporate bankruptcies) while union busting and trickle-down economics helped lay the foundation for the income stagnation the article is largely about.
- 7y ago
- intended 7y agoThat’s incorrect - the global pie has grown bigger. Inches and markers exist which never existed before. All those new workers are consumers for goods and services from America. America soy beans are famously bought in China, as are American bonds. Economically- if you get cheaper goods, you do more with the same income, meaning your quality of life goes up. The issue is not the growth of China- the issue is the distribution of wealth. As the pie has grown, the share of the pie has changed.
- Despegar 7y agoThe pie may have grown, but aside from labor in the Global South, the people who have captured the gains from that growth have been the capital class in the developed nations (i.e not blue collar workers or the professional class). And no, getting some of your compensation in stock options doesn't make you apart of the capital class, unless you can stop working.
- dcolkitt 7y ago> the people who have captured the gains from that growth have been the capital class in the developed nations (i.e not blue collar workers or the professional class) Wrong. Middle-class Americans have captured gains through cheaper, higher-quality products than would have otherwise existed without trade and development. Are you using a phone made in China, or wearing clothes made in Bangladesh, or eat fresh fruit in the winter? Then by definition, you've captured gains from trade.
- _iyig 7y agoMaybe so, but nobody's happy about cheap lawn furniture, for example, when they can't afford homes, healthcare, or education.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI think that's a consequence of pulling wealth from the future into the present to counteract the loss of wealth due to decreases in the price of labor due to increase in supply of labor from other countries and decrease in demand of labor due to automation. Question is how far into the future are we going to keep pulling.
- sct202 7y agoGlobalism has definitely supported the US tech industry significantly and wealth in cities that have tech giants. The internet was left basically open across borders, and I don't think that American tech's dominance would have been possible if everyone acted like China did by throwing up firewalls to protect local companies.
- 0x445442 7y agoThe problem is the imbalance between the mobility of capital and the mobility of labor. If it were as easy for Joe Iowa to move some place with a lower cost of living to compete for labor as it is for Joe CEO to setup manufacturing there then I'd be all for Globalization.
- Slothrop479 7y agoThe mechanisms by which globalization works to favor the rich is laid out well by economist Dean Baker in his book Rigged. The introduction looks at how trade imbalances with the global south benefit the rich in the west. The third chapter examines the macroeconomics of upwards redistribution itself. The entire book is available free on his website: https://deanbaker.net/images/stories/documents/Rigged.pdf https://deanbaker.net/images/stories/documents/Rigged.pdf In terms of US policy, the state of American inequality, and the domestic movement of corporate interests to create policies to favor the rich - the book Winner Take All Politics is a concise overview of this history since the 70s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winner-Take-All_Politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winner-Take-All_Politics
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 7y agoThing is, Joe Iowa generally can move to cheap third world countries and work in manufacturing there, the work visa rules usually restrict only the opposite movement of labor - it's just that it would be a really bad deal for him because despite the the much lower cost of living, his working conditions and purchasing parity adjusted income will be much worse than in Iowa. A USA blue-collar worker can't possibly expect to compete for labor in the global market and keep their current lifestyle - for an illustrative example, many such workers can afford cars and houses, which is a relative luxury if they would have to compete with workers who live in dormitories next to the factory. Someone who's earning $35000/year is in global top 1% in income; and adjusting for purchasing power doesn't change it that much, they'd still be in top 10% globally, and they can stay so relatively wealthy only because (and until!) they don't have to directly compete with all the much poorer laborers of other countries. Any increase in global labor mobility will only make it much worse for Joe Iowa.
- buboard 7y agoThe idea was that globalization would push the West to ‘creative’ jobs. Instead we got bullshit jobs. (And this is even more prevalent here in europe)
- andreilys 7y ago“ We have benefited I think, and we've had opportunities to invest and sell into those markets we wouldn't have otherwise had.” The we in this case being those who have easy access to capital. Those who have seen their wages stagnate or jobs erased could care less about what happens to the citizens in another country when they themselves struggle to put food on the table.
- istjohn 7y agoWell, I'm one of the losers--my blue collar parents did better than me and most of my siblings. And I am genuinely happy for those who have risen out of abject poverty thanks to globalization. The fact is, there is no reason we couldn't have spread the costs and benefits of globalization across society.
- istjohn 7y agoAren't there billions of people in the world outside of China who can continue to provide cheap manufacturing labor for decades to come? Also automation will begin to pick up any slack left by outsourcing. I don't think the blue collar jobs of the 70's and 80's are ever coming back. The knowledge economy is replacing globalization as the transformative economic force. In a knowledge economy, the winner takes all, and that means more and more education is required to play in the big leagues, even as the big leagues become the only game in town. I believe only aggressive wealth and income redistribution like universal basic income can prevent a dystopian future of stark inequality.
- kmonsen 7y agoThe pause in growth (or rather the growth in inequality we got instead) have almost killed of our democracies stopping any real fight for a better future. Was it worth it? I would say no. We all had a feast of our seedcorn and now we will reap what we didn't sow.
- fspeech 7y ago"because Chinese labourers have more skills now and can command high enough wages in more upmarket jobs that they don't need the low end work any more" I think what is happening is that the low-skilled laborers can now earn higher wages in service (such as online shopping delivery) because the higher skilled labor force can now command a higher income and generate demand for more service. The point is while the overall skill level is up it is not necessary for the low-skill section to also have higher skill in order to have higher income. This has already happened in the developed economies, but people here seem to look down on these service jobs and pine for manufacturing jobs.
- amanaplanacanal 7y agoI was under the impression that automation has had a much larger effect than globalization. Unfortunately they both have happened in the same time period and are hard to disentangle.