16 ms·
Study of “moral grandstanding” helps explain why social media is so toxic
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dwoozle 7y agoThe psychological root of “call out culture” is the same as sports brawls, wartime civilian massacres, and bullying. Vanquishing people is... can we admit it... fun. That’s why the Olympic gold medalists smile so much. Now, vanquishing someone with no risk to oneself, with no work required, and in the safety of a huge mob? It’s like getting to be a war hero with the risk and effort of playing Call of Duty.
- mcguire 7y agoNot just the root of "call out culture"...
- dilaudibble 7y agoWhat I find odd about this is that I am effectively (I hope) anonymous online, even on twitter, but I still get totally mad when people trash my ideas. It's like my ideas are a part of my extended self. This I think is why moral grandstanding is a more valuable concept than Virtue Signalling - VS wouldn't make sense in an anonymous context, and apparently signalling means something different anyway according to this: https://www.adamsmith.org/blog/stop-saying-virtue-signalling https://www.adamsmith.org/blog/stop-saying-virtue-signalling
- blix 7y agoFor many, ideas are a part of identity. I am a good person because I support good policies and vote for good party. I am smart because I have intelligent thoughts and ideas. When the quality of these ideas is challenged, it therefore can be a challenge to the quality of the person holding them, if they base their identity on their thoughts. I find this is quite common. Another effect of this mindset is that changing your mind becomes more difficult. It's a hard thing to get out of.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoAre there people who have a [strong] sense of identity that's somehow not centred around their ideas? I'm trying to imagine what that looks like? Maybe "it doesn't matter what I think, I'm $Nationality and that's who I am"? [But does anyone think like that? And isn't that just an idea that informs identity?]
- duhgafdt 7y agoIt is not the great taste of the peanut butter and jelly sandwiches which you enjoy, it is the idea that 'pb&j tastes great' which informs your enjoyment of it.
- blix 7y agoIn earlier times, identity was mostly a function of social relationships. This seemed to be a lot more concrete than abstract concept of identity that is popular in industrial societies. Here are some other things that might inform/create identity besides political opinions shared on twitter: race, religion, ethnicity, nationality, gender, occupation, consumption preferences, skills, activities, appearance. All of these are ideas to some degree, but some are more concrete than others. But ultimately, identity itself is an idea and I don't think it can be fully separated from other constructs of the mind.
- im3w1l 7y agoIf you ask me about my identity the first thing that comes to my mind is the life I've lived. The things I got to experience, my failures, my accomplishments, the choices I made.
- kmm 7y agoI get sad and frustrated when I get downvoted, even though I'm (pseudo-)anonymous. It's completely irrational, and I'm a bit ashamed for it, yet it's gotten to a point where I basically just don't bother anymore with politics online. It's strange because I don't have such issues in real life. And my friends confirm that I'm intellectually honest and nuanced, or at least not nuts. I just can't imagine people talking to me face to face in the way I'm so used to on the internet, all smug and doing their best to find the worst possible interpretation of a comment.
- rolph 7y agothe article speaks about individuals attempting to gain recognition through grandstanding. I think the more contemporary issue would be with individuals attempting to manipulate the 'psychological set" of a large group through a moderated grandstanding eg your with us, or your with the [insert villain here] ! note this is simultaneously an assertion of brinksmanship.
- Izkata 7y ago> This is “moral grandstanding” — publicly opining on morality and politics to impress others, and so to seek social status. This is much better known under the name "virtue signaling"...
- dilaudibble 7y agoThe authors address this in the paper. They claim that MG is different to VS as VS is a colloquial term used to criticise people on social media, whereas MG “has been extensively explored and defined in philosophical literature”.
- mcguire 7y ago"Our basic contention is that one grandstands when one makes a contribution to public moral discourse that aims to convince others that one is “morally respectable.” By this we mean that grandstanding is a use of moral talk that attempts to get others to make certain desired judgments about oneself, namely, that one is worthy of respect or admiration because one has some particular moral quality—for example, an impressive commitment to justice, a highly tuned moral sensibility, or unparalleled powers of empathy. To grandstand is to turn one's contribution to public discourse into a vanity project." https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/papa.12075?campaign=woletoc https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/papa.12075?... I personally strongly disagree that anything from 2016 can be "extensively explored and defined in philosophical literature".
- brailsafe 7y agoOnly on the internet I think, if you happen to spend a lot of time in particular areas iver the last 5 years.
- daenz 7y agoUnfortunately that has become a loaded term because it was only used by "one side" against "the other side." Often that term is rejected and ignored outright because of this. But yes, I agree.
- 7y ago
- grawprog 7y agoWatching people argue about politics, or even watching people get into politics, reminds me of people arguing about their favourite sports teams. It always comes down to the other team is bad and immoral or whatever, our team is the best, go chosen sports team, you can do no wrong. Honestly, the way people have been dehumanizing each other over politics kind of scares me. It reminds me of the way propaganda dehumanizes 'the enemy' in war time. It's not a good way to look at other people, especially not over which political party they voted for.
- braythwayt 7y ago> Watching people argue about politics, or even watching people get into politics, reminds me of people arguing about their favourite sports teams. So let me get this right: Arguing about whether children should be locked in cages is like arguing about sports teams? Arguing about whether people of colour are humans or vermin is like arguing about sports teams? Arguing about whether women are entitled to a vote, or to own property, or to equal pay for work of equal value, is like argguing about sports teams? --- I'd say that you are articulating a very distinct political slant, and that slant is that nothing really matters, there is no absolute truth or morality, everything is about tribalism. If you look around more carefully, you'll notice that a great many people argue about politics in a way entirely different than they argue about sports teams. While I agree that there are a lot of people who share this point of view, and really all they care about is their tribe and not the thing they're arguing for or against.. I am not one of those people. And let me tell you, when I disagree with that viewpoint, I am absolutely NOT arguing about it the same way I'd argue whether Eddy Merckx or Marianne Vos is the greatest cyclist of all time.
- boring_twenties 7y agoNo, but misrepresenting your opponent's position to make it seem indefensible is very much like arguing about sports teams.
- tnel77 7y agoThis is the kind of response I think OP was referring to.
- Data_Junkie 7y agoNone of this is true. People do not seek better social status by arguing with unseen, unknown people, they seek social change. The status quo lies to limit the damage, because when unseen, unknown voices speak truth they cannot stop the change, which all the unheard voices want.
- merpnderp 7y agoIf only that were true. But I’ve never seen a single mind changed from these online “debates”, because no one ever enters them willing to admit they might be wrong.
- ben509 7y agoSuppose we divide up the audience of a typical debate. (Caveats: people are on a spectrum, it's not likely symmetric, and this is somewhat framed in terms of political parties but shouldn't be and I can't be arsed to fix it.) Your base agrees with you, and is invested in that position. They're not going to change their mind, but they may abandon you if you don't demonstrate that you're committed. Your aim is to motivate them to support you, through money or activity. The other side's base is the opposite, of course. And your aim there is to get them to stay home, or to abandon their side. This is why hypocrisy is such a common charge and there's so much focus on various scandals. Persuasive arguments are aimed at people who haven't formed an opinion. That's why plainly ideological outlets will present themselves as objective and authoritative; people who feel they are neutral can sign on with them without feeling like they're actually taking a side. So the reason you don't hear people changing their mind is the people who are likely to are those who haven't formed an opinion, and thus aren't sounding off in the first place. Moreover, the evidence you present is rarely as compelling as you think. Ask a lawyer how often they've had to talk down clients who were convinced they had an ironclad argument. The big ideologies have axiomatic differences they are not necessarily fully aware of, and those tend to be why neither is convinced by the other. But it is possible to raise a point they have a genuine problem with. If you have done so, the thing to look for is not an immediate response. It's that the other side's talking points shift in response; especially if they shift to "let's change the subject."
- 7y ago
- semiotagonal 7y agoOn Reddit, several weeks ago, I strongly objected to an author singling out a presidential candidate with a nickname, while not doing the same for the others. It's fair to say I was outraged since I threw an "F" word in there. Although I didn't do it to seek status, it got something like 2000 upvotes. Anecdotally, I can see that grandstanding works, if "karma" is what you care about.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- daenz 7y agoPeople like to pretend that karma/upvotes/likes aren't "real" but they absolutely are real, if everyone even slightly considers them a symbol of status online.
- Jamwinner 7y agoNot to mention making your account more valuable to sell to marketers. Its a booming, and old-as-reddit business.
- Verdex 7y agoReal life is hard to deal with. However, if you look at what other people do, then you can learn from their mistakes. But there's still too many scenarios that occur and too few people to watch. So you can listen to the stories that your peer group tells. You're second hand watching the people your extended peer group is watching. And bonus points, you can get tribal knowledge where people remember what others have said long after they're gone. This makes being a person who people listen to an important aspect of being part of a society. If you're listened to, then you and your "social lineage" get to survive to the next generation of how to live. This also means that you don't have to relearn the lessons of a competing "social lineage" in order to stay compatible with your peers. Getting likes is an easy feedback mechanism to know if people are listening to your ideas. Additionally, some people will listen to people who others listen to. So getting likes can directly feed into your own social fitness. Likes are much more real that most other things that people deal with in their day to day lives.
- daenz 7y ago>“Collectively, these findings provide support for an account of moral grandstanding that conceptualises it as a status-seeking behaviour that is driven by status-seeking motives,” and that could explain some of the problems with social discourse, especially on social media, the team writes. It gives me hope to see researchers starting to tackle this social phenomenon. Now that there is a foothold on some scientific results, maybe we can finally start to take it seriously and influence behavior. IG's experimenting with removing likes seems to be a step in that direction. Hopefully there will be more initiatives like this.
- romaaeterna 7y ago> Higher scores on prestige-seeking were associated with narcissistic extraversion and extraversion more generally, while the dominance aspects were strongly associated with narcissistic antagonism (a willingness to exploit others for personal gains), and related to lower conscientiousness, agreeableness and openness. This is terribly interesting, especially if you've read Haidt. It means that every political argument on the internet will naturally split up into left-associated "virtue signalers" and right-associated "trolls."
- 12xo 7y agoOr end up in the basin of Godwin's law...
- mcguire 7y agoAre the trolls not virtue signalling in their own community? The interesting part is that there is no place for honest beliefs or serious discussion on any side of any argument on the Internet.
- romaaeterna 7y agoI think rather that it's not possible in any large group. Reasonable people are drowned out by the highly motivated people.
- StuffedParrot 7y agoThese are only two traits measured leaving many who correlate to neither. I am hardly well versed in the jargon discussed here to speak authoritatively, but more than half the variance is unaccounted for. An outsized effect for sure, but not the whole effect, and not even the largest single factor.
- mindgam3 7y agoAny explanation of why social media is toxic without mentioning the Like button is incomplete. All of the status-seeking behaviors the researchers describe existed before Likes, but by gamifying social status Facebook threw gasoline on the narcissism fire. And yes, Facebook didn’t invent the like button (that was Friendfeed) but they made it a standard. Also worth noting that a key component of Facebook’s initial positioning was that it did NOT have any gamified counters, unlike MySpace and Bebo which were fueled by profile views and friend counts. Source: was Bebo engineer/exec 2007.
- buboard 7y agoindeed , there were forums well before SNs were a thing, and while they were contentious at times, they weren't constantly at the brink of explosion/tribal wars. Makes one wonder if we even need likes/upvotes to reward opinions. It's possible that they were useful to get the social conversation going, but as the networks grew to huge scale, they ve lost most of their usefulness. I wonder how twitter would be without likes for a day
- mindgam3 7y agoI too remember forums back in the day. Usenet via AOL was my first online social experience. I think Twitter etc would be more like that old school experience - much more of a niche product, still with the usual trolls etc but in general higher quality to noise ratio.
- Gene_Parmesan 7y agoLikes are 100% never going anywhere. They provide a means for Google/FB/whoever to categorize you. The instant you click 'like' on a post about the latest pro-Dems thing, or on a post organizing a pro-life rally, or on something a band posted, they instantly know a lot about you. (Or more specifically, the algorithms begin acting as if they know a lot about you.) Every time you click 'like,' you are fine-tuning the company's profile of you. Maybe at one point they were about rewarding opinions or something, but in today's big-data-driven social networks, they are entirely about categorization for ads.
- zozbot234 7y agoSignificantly, from the article: > Political ideology had no relationship with moral grandstanding scores. i.e. narcissism is a bipartisan problem. (I mean, we knew that already, didn't we? "Crooked X", "X belongs in jail" and the like, relating to a well-known presidential candidate, is not something that the "left" came up with!) OTOH, it's nice to finally have an actual research paper that clearly links this sort of hypocritical grandstanding with narcissistic tendencies.
- 12xo 7y agoAt some point in the last 20 years, politics became a sport. IMHO its due to the rise of cable news silos and talk radio charlatans taking on the role once reserved for journalists and experts. By oversimplifying very complex issues into Us vs Them, they created an environment ripe for exploitation. And since the currency of media is Attention, the more sensationalist you become, the more attention and money you receive. This translates perfectly to social media, where the currency is also attention and the rewards, a bit more convoluted than just money. Its what this article describes, the need for attention outweighs the actual results...
- malvosenior 7y agoIn addition to the causes you list, I'd add that education has become increasingly politicized (in the extreme). To the point where many new graduates are either activists or reactionary from having been steeped in that environment for at least the time they were in higher ed.
- 12xo 7y agoThat's pure speculation based on your own views and experiences. What you probably noticed, is the visibility into these people's lives that you or others did not have prior to social media and 24/7 connectivity. Universities have always skewed towards the left side of the spectrum, it used to be called liberal arts educated, today the right has successfully renamed it as indoctrination.
- malvosenior 7y agoIt's not speculation. "No platforming", "safe spaces", "trigger warnings"... are all relatively recent inventions. Universities have always been left leaning, but the "moral grandstanding" mentioned in the original post is a more recent development.
- watwut 7y agoMoral majority, letter campaigns to FCC, christian boycott of immoral companies, comic code, Hayes code ... civil rights era boycotts.
- sbhn 7y agoHN is the Moral Grandstanding scoreboard
- 40acres 7y agoThe schadenfreude that occurs when someone tries to 'cancel' another person on social media, only for them to be 'cancelled' for their own previously uncovered misdeeds is pretty pleasing. [O] Unfortunately I think this is reflective of our society. With social media, there is little room for growth, acknowledgement of mistakes, and understand. You're either with the crowd or not. It's a big reason why I've removed myself from social media. Glass houses everywhere. 0:www.buzzfeednews.com/amphtml/juliareinstein/des-moines-register-iowa-reporter-fired-aaron-calvin-carson
- l33tbro 7y agoIsn't 'cancel culture' vastly overstated? We hear so much about it because media personalities (mainstream through to podcasters) are the targets of it, so they're naturally going over-value the threat of it.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI'd argue a phenomenon that affects anyone with an audience of any size is critically important, even if most people don't have an audience.
- 40acres 7y agoIt's definitely overstated but I do think it exists particularly within social media where everything is public but the social bonds are weak.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hombre_fatal 7y agoJon Haidt, one of the authors of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Coddling_of_the_American_Mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Coddling_of_the_American_M..., said that "isn't it overstated?" was such a common assertion that it was one of the reasons he wanted to go quantify it for this book. And it's not overstated. Of course, instead of throwing a book at you, here's his 1-hour podcast interview with Sam Harris about the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaniQUlqzgE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaniQUlqzgE Though the book (nor interview) is just focused on call-out culture. But it does talk about some interesting aspects of it, like how calling out is a way to win prestige.
- jmmcd 7y ago> the individual is seeking to gain status Yes, but the individual may not know they're doing that. (I guess this is too obvious to the researchers to bother saying.)
- xenocyon 7y agoAs is so often true, the headline is not substantiated by the body of the article.
- zebrafish 7y agoPretty fascinating and also sort of "no duh." Thinking about how those with access to information networks have leveraged the technology throughout history, it seems like it is always used for the purpose of "moral grandstanding." Social media is just the fully fleshed out network. I'm just thinking about the progression from letters, the pony express, the railroad, the telegraph, the telephone, radio, movies, television, internet, to now social networks. Haven't those with access to the information network always used it to express why their opinion is right or wrong? The toxicity is maybe just a function of the rapid increase of access. There is now an "infinite" number of those with access to an "infinite" number of listeners. With TV or radio, the listeners are still there, but access to dissemination is highly restricted. With telegraphs or telephones, both access and audience are restricted. I'm not sure if this problem was ever solved before. Maybe it was just stifled....
- campfireveteran 7y agoA billion-dollar idea: a combination pseudo-outrage, crybully, political correctness, troll, flaming and keyboard warrior pre-filter. And for 2.0: a micropayment cost to comment that adjusts based on social reputation and identity verification (people who give very good, high-signal answers should get some payment or bonuses periodically and per engagement).
- pgcj_poster 7y agoThis study seems like it was designed to reach the specific conclusion that it did, based on the way that it defined "moral grandstanding." Here are some questions they asked to measure it: 13. When I share my moral/political beliefs, I do so to show people who disagree with me that I am better than them. 14. I share my moral/political beliefs to make people who disagree with me feel bad 28. Even if expressing my moral/political views does not help anyone, it is important that I share them. …and lo and behold, they found that people who answered "yes" to those questions were also more narcissistic and more concerned with appearance than substance. Ok. Well, that's not really surprising. But it tells us nothing about how prevelent these motivations are compared to genuine concern for the issues at hand. I'm quite sure Hacker News would have ripped into this sort of study if it weren't promoting the "politics is sports" narrative that this community is so fond of, which is sort of ironic given how the study specifically talks about "echo chambers."
- brailsafe 7y ago> But it tells us nothing about how prevelent these motivations are compared to genuine concern for the issues at hand. I found that to be a curious statement, because—and I didn't read the study, just here for the commentary—it seems like we're talking about how certain types of behaviour are differentiated from a whole for some reason. In this case, the effort seems to be toward finding disingenuous grandstanding, but how do we define genuine concern? When does a political belief that someone has become genuine and how do others outside this apparent narcissistic group reflect more noble intention? My impression for some time has been that genuine concern for any given political topic is a function of the cost in having, revealing, or defending it. For example, if you are Brandon Eich, there is a tremendous cost in upholding his homophobic values; to himself and others. The racist who has never met whoever they hate, the gay man with anti-abortion values, nor the 17 year old who screams on reddit about Hong Kong and Blizzard but still buys their games and isn't in the crossfire quite a lot less. -- Tried to use contemporary references. Brandon recently did an AMA and refused to answer any question about that controversy, not building too much confidence in his product called "Brave"
- pgcj_poster 7y ago
- cmdshiftf4 7y agoThe sheer level of damage and instability social media has done to the West in the past decade can only lead one to suppose that it has been intentional and that there has been a powerful hand behind it. What benefits has it brought about? We know we're increasingly anxious, lonely and isolated despite it, so what "social" benefits have these "social" enterprises actually caused? Because the list of damage is endless, and the list of victims never-ending. Watching politicized animosity, done for the purpose of the researched grandstanding, spill over into universities and public life has been horrifying. Careers and lives ruined for not keeping up with the ever-changing morals of the online mob, culminating in events such as those at Evergreen State College, the Christakis furore at Yale, the constant speech policing because non-adherent political speech now makes others feel "unsafe", etc. People who were once the leaders of progressive movement turned into right-wing nazi bigots over publications that were on-narrative, or ahead of it, when published, now resurrected to be held against them by today's constantly changing standards. Even in this thread, a topic on an objective study of the effects of social media, simply pointing to it has caused an uncontrolled, partisan, shitshow. None of this ends well. A society full of increasingly anxious and isolated people, seeking purpose in online identity groups known for electing the most vitriolic doomsday preachers as leaders, who are increasingly viewing the "other side" as an enemy, armed with a treasure trove of historical tweets/fb posts/etc. to dig through for evidence of their crimes, does not end well. Social media may prove to be the biggest mistake we've ever made.
- flashman 7y ago> can only lead one to suppose that it has been intentional and that there has been a powerful hand behind it /\ / \ /,--.\ /< () >\ / `--' \ / \ / \ /______________\
- plntd 7y agoDoesn't this also explain why traditional media, politics, religion, academia, etc are all toxic? Is it that social media is toxic or that the toxic world has now adopted social media? Moral grandstanding has been around for millennia before social media.
- leoc 7y ago> This is “moral grandstanding” — publicly opining on morality and politics to impress others, and so to seek social status. Around these parts we used to describe performative, status-seeking wokeness as 'craw-thumping'.
- flashman 7y agoCraw-thumper used to describe pious Roman Catholics, so it's interesting how it's been repurposed
- RickJWagner 7y agoI'm glad to see this coming from the British Psychological Society. One of the most active feeds in my news reader is the BBC, and they seem way over-the-top PC. (I fear this was beginning to shade my perception of the whole UK.) I feel better about things. God save the Queen!
- ALBERT300 7y agoHIRE A PROFESSIONAL HACKER FOR ANY HACKING RELATED ISSUES: OUR SERVICES INCLUDE: CELLPHONE MONITORING SOCIAL MEDIA HACKING DATABASE ALTERATION SPYING ON ALL SORT OF DEVICES CLONING ( WEBSITES, DEVICES, CELLULAR etc. ) HACKING SPOUSE PHONE UNIVERSITIES GRADE CHANGE RECOVER LOST CRYPTO CURRENCIES GET IN TOUCH WITH THE BEST HACKER VIA: EMAIL:THEREDHACKERGROUP AT GMAIL DOTCOM PHONE/WHATSAPP: 5 7 1 3 1 8 9 4 9 8