11 ms·
I agree with the premise. Workplaces are much more enjoyable when everyone is respectful, professional, and courteous to their peers. Most of these guidelines
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
I agree with the premise. Workplaces are much more enjoyable when everyone is respectful, professional, and courteous to their peers.
Most of these guidelines are reasonable enough. I think it's important to keep the DOs and DON'Ts list to the minimum, though. These interaction guidelines become counter-productive when they try to be all-encompassing definitions of good and bad interpersonal behavior.
I worked with one team who had an ever-expanding code of conduct. Each time they had a conflict, they tried to add rules to the CoC that they thought would prevent the conflict. Good intentions, but counter-productive execution. Three things happened:
1) New hires had to learn to navigate a minefield of obscure code of conduct rules. They tended to shutdown and socially isolate themselves for fear of accidentally triggering another obscure CoC issue, like including emojis in code reviews. The safest thing to do is only interact with close allies within the company, and minimize unnecessary interaction with anyone else. Silos.
2) The CoC became a tool for power plays. For a few bad apples, the CoC became a list of gotchas that they could use as a power play against others. At one point we had someone reading every Slack conversation and code review just to call out possible CoC violations (remember, this includes things like using emojis in code review) so they could call other people out on their violations. Substantiative conversations moved to private messages or in-person conversations. Not healthy. Partially solved by adding a CoC rule about minding your own business and explaining healthy ways to share the CoC with others.
3) Human interactions started to feel robotic, almost scripted. This one is harder to describe, but each interaction with someone in public or outside your close friend group started to feel like everyone was following a mental script for how our conversations could proceed. Conversations felt like a mental checklist of what was an acceptable way to discuss a differing opinion or answer a question without the possibility of stepping on anyone's toes. It became draining in ways that I haven't experienced since. It was a huge relief when I moved to another company where people were allowed to talk freely to each other, like professional adults.
- chrisco255 7y agoConflict isn't necessarily bad and it's often very, very healthy as long as it doesn't descend into name calling or something toxic.
- BeetleB 7y agoAgreed, but I consider this kind of a non-statement. Conflict isn't bad. It's misunderstandings that are bad and lead to name calling or worse. In my experience, the majority of bad behavior at work is due to a misinterpretation of good/neutral intentions. Conflict avoidance is pretty bad, in my opinion. However, it is a mistake to look at codes of conduct purely from an avoidance angle. This blog post is likely not about avoiding conflicts.
- bluntfang 7y agoHmmm number 3 doesn't seem like a negative or counter-intuitive. I feel like software devs (in bay area startup world, or FAANG) are usually a certain demographic and they usually come from a place of privilege where they've never had to do the mental work that's involved in communicating effectively across diverse demographics.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> Hmmm number 3 doesn't seem like a negative or counter-intuitive. This is the core of the problem: Some people like the idea of robotic, semi-scripted conversations according to a well-defined set of rules. They think that if there's a rulebook, they can predict how people will respond to them. Or worse, they think they can control how people react and respond. Yes, we should put some constraints around egregious communication issues as well as provide general guidelines, but the important thing is to let people interact naturally within those loose constraints. > I feel like software devs (in bay area startup world, or FAANG) are usually a certain demographic and they usually come from a place of privilege where they've never had to do the mental work that's involved in communicating effectively across diverse demographics. It's a fallacy, though. You can't create perfect rules for human conversation. Everyone needs to build those interpersonal and conversational skills, even if it's somewhat painful along the way. The basic skills can be guided with simple rules and guidelines, but the problem comes when you try to control too much of the conversation or set the constraints so tightly that it's a minefield to navigate.
- bluntfang 7y ago>Some people like the idea of robotic, semi-scripted conversations according to a well-defined set of rules. Thinking about the words you use in daily conversation with diverse peers doesn't have to be "robotic". You're just being exposed to how other people in less privileged positions have to think and act, and that's uncomfortable. >You can't create perfect rules for human conversation. Is anyone here claiming that their goal is perfection? >Everyone needs to build those interpersonal and conversational skills And there's nothing wrong with receiving help and guidance while you're on that journey.
- munchbunny 7y ago> 2) The CoC became a tool for power plays. For a few bad apples, the CoC became a list of gotchas that they could use as a power play against others. At one point we had someone reading every Slack conversation and code review just to call out possible CoC violations (remember, this includes things like using emojis in code review) so they could call other people out on their violations. Substantiative conversations moved to private messages or in-person conversations. Not healthy. Partially solved by adding a CoC rule about minding your own business and explaining healthy ways to share the CoC with others. I've seen this happen too. Not for code reviews, but for process rules in general. IMO the key issue is that rules can't be used as a substitute for good judgement, and bad judgement needs to be an explicitly fire-able performance metric. Unfortunately, it's really hard to make sure "good judgement" is educated and constantly re-evaluated, and not just whatever baggage the person carries (misconceptions at best, outright ageism/sexism/racism at worst). From the perspective of leadership, this is a tough but solvable problem: read about people management and sociology diversely and avidly, establish actually anonymous lines of feedback for ground level employees to upper management, and set a precedent for firing jerks promptly. From the perspective of an employee facing bad management, good luck fixing that. It's probably easier to just find a new job.
- SkyBelow 7y agoBut that sounds like an inconsistently enforced rule which means selectively applied, eventually done so on factors that would be considered unacceptable if written down. If a rule is written down, I'm prefer it be fully enforced other than being used as a club to selectively bludgeon certain individuals. Yes, at first it will be used against those who 'deserve' it based on some social metric. But how long before it is used against unattractive people more than attractive people (see Halo effect) or used against people with less social skills more than those with greater charisma? I've seen it happen one too many times to think the new rule won't end up with the same abuses.
- munchbunny 7y ago> But that sounds like an inconsistently enforced rule which means selectively applied, eventually done so on factors that would be considered unacceptable if written down. You're going to have to pick a position on the spectrum between always-enforced rules and purely honor codes (and social pressure). We know the former fails because hard and fast rules can be and are gamed. We know honor codes and social pressure only keep honest people honest. So in practice, where on this spectrum do you stand? If it's your company, or team, or club, or whatever other gathering of humans, you have to make a choice on this question.
- threwawasy1228 7y agoThis is really interesting, I think this is how the general population views social justice and other activist issues actually. It seems to be a similarly structured setup where we implement a byzantine list of things that people of privilege are supposed to keep track up, starting out as a list of good intentions that then spirals out of control. Afterwards nobody is real with anyone anymore and we are simply left with a system where most social interaction feels like a robotic scripted attempt to follow the rules of privilege.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoThe problem is they come up with all these rules for others to follow. They don't seem to realize the rules also apply to them. It's perfectly fine to call for the exclusion of a man because of a controversial tweet but when protected groups do the same thing and people try to hold them accountable they get laughed at as if it was absurd and wrong to even try.
- hogFeast 7y agoThis should only apply for large companies. Only in large companies do you end up employing large numbers of idiots. And only then do you need the rules that a minority go crazy with. In my experience, the cure is usually worse than the disease. Give someone a rulebook that they can use to justify the awful inclinations of their personality, and they will spend 99% of their energy doing this. Small companies manage this better in my experience - outside of the guy who came from LARGE TECH COMPANY and spends all day writing lists and telling people how they do things at LARGE TECH COMPANY - because they will get rid of someone who is being disruptive rather than try to move them somewhere else. HR in large companies tends to be far softer. Btw, my point is that all this applies to social activism too. We need rules because eventually someone will do something dumb. The rules will get taken too far. And that small minority ends up making almost everyone else unhappy. Incidentally: there is a probably a parallel with this forum. Of any internet forum, this place is probably the most humourless and exacting when it comes to people quoting rules (often by number) to each other. The monkeys will take over the zoo 100% of the time in these cases. I have actually even had interviews like this. I remember one particularly funny one was for a front-end role where I was witness to a lecture from a "senior dev" on the topic of: why X technology/pattern is "wrong"?
- gowld 7y ago#3 used to be called "professionalism" A comic take on professionalism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRzxJZrm3iU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRzxJZrm3iU https://arresteddevelopment.fandom.com/wiki/Wayne_Jarvis https://arresteddevelopment.fandom.com/wiki/Wayne_Jarvis
- benologist 7y agoI think what makes HN so high-quality overall is the constant policing for personal attacks and toxicity. Some sites have 'rules' that are barely or not enforced at all that you must be respectful but this is the only site that consistently and objectively enforces good conduct.
- blub 7y agoOne weakness is that users can gang on politically incorrect comments or threads and flag them. Last I've seen this was a thread about the professor which was claiming that women aren't disadvantaged in physics. It was a totally harmless thing, about how a journal decided to publish his views.
- wwright 7y agoime, what is called “political correctness” is often interpreted as “respecting others” by different people. You can disagree with what expectations they have for interpersonal respect, but I think that’s how the other side sees it.
- Jamwinner 7y agoDownvoting without offering counterargument is disrespectful and counter productive.
- raxxorrax 7y agoBut this is enforced by the users themselves to 99%. This is a very fundamental difference.
- esotericn 7y agoI find this really interesting. I'm wondering if this is a cultural thing. I didn't interpret the list as being a set of instructions at all. More of an expression of an opinion on what people should do. You read it, learn, incorporate it into your working life. It happens to be that I pretty much agree with it all, but if I didn't, I wouldn't find myself consulting the list to decide whether I should or shouldn't say something. If someone 'called me out' on a 'violation' of this document, I'm not sure how I'd respond. Probably with laughter? I honestly don't know, perhaps I'm just in a bubble. We can discuss as adults, if there's a problem with my communication I want to know. I don't want to be pointed at the rule book, this isn't primary school.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> I'm not sure how I'd respond That might depend on whether or not you were worried about losing your job over it.
- esotericn 7y agoRight, hence my comment. I wouldn't be worried at all. It feels like a different working culture (or country). It seems like one of those cultural things, like how Europeans and Americans have inverse views on the severity of sex and violence. I think you may have even misinterpreted my comment as me thinking I'm somehow "above the rules" or whatever, even. It's not that. It's that it would have literally never crossed my mind that my continued employment would be related to how I behave in relation to this document. In my personal life I left behind that sort of 'rules lawyering' when I left school. No job I've ever held has actually functioned like that. The closest I've been is working at a large accounting firm, but even there most people had a mutual understanding that the 'book' (a lot more official than this post) was just a CYA fluff document invented to keep certain people busy and certain other people happy.
- bonoboTP 7y agoI also wonder this when looking at the "Workplace" Stack Exchange site or at Reddit's /r/legaladvice. So much CYA stuff, "you must collect a paper trail", "email yourself your recollection of the situation, so it's time stamped", how quickly you can become a liability for HR and how much companies are scared of getting sued for, to me, frivolous reasons. Sure this also exists in corporate Europe, but it seems America is more "robotic" in this respect. Well, they'd just call it being professional I guess.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- michaelbuckbee 7y agoCoC are a tool like any other - helpful if applied to the right situations and harmful if misused. I think you've made a really insightful point about keeping it small and maybe less a rule book and more a guideline for interaction.
- Aeolun 7y agoNo emoji’s in code reviews? I have a hard time seeing how that helps instead of hurts things. What was the reasoning behind it?
- SoftwareMaven 7y agoOne of the most important things I've learned over the years I've managed people is that processes and policies of any sort are two-edged swords. It's easy to add a policy, and to convince oneself of the advantage the policy will confer. What is very often ignored is the cost of a policy. Every policy comes with an associated cost, and those costs can add up quickly. People always ask "what will this policy make better", but, just as important, is to ask, "what will this policy make worse".
- BurningFrog 7y agoI've come to believe that ignoring one side of the cost/benefit calculus is the root cause of an enormous number of mistakes. To spell the two errors out: A: "This has a benefit, so we should do it!" B: "This has a cost, so we should not do it!"
- ljm 7y agoI like to talk about trade-offs a lot, and opportunity cost is also a good way to look at it. But yeah, it’s not often I see that happen. Even better, make that a function of time so your cost/benefit analysis looks further beyond your initial preference. Spending more to save more is a highly effective choice in the right circumstances, and equally so, a perceived rapid gain can cost a fortune a bit later on. It’s never so easy as saying always do D, prefer Y, avoid Z. They’re prescriptive and reactionary.
- bradknowles 7y agoYour description here is what I would characterize as an accurate description of how most laws "just growed" in most communities. That is, at least up until the time that the special interests got involved. Then they made a point of ensuring that the laws got written to only be applied to "others".
- vageli 7y ago> Your description here is what I would characterize as an accurate description of how most laws "just growed" in most communities. > That is, at least up until the time that the special interests got involved. Then they made a point of ensuring that the laws got written to only be applied to "others". When was this time that special interests did not exist? One might argue (only partly in jest) that the entire purpose of government is to protect special interests.
- taurath 7y ago> The CoC became a tool for power plays. For a few bad apples, the CoC became a list of gotchas that they could use as a power play against others They should add that you shouldn’t do that to the code of conduct! ;)
- pacala 7y agoFirst rule of the CoC: You do not talk about the CoC.
- ma2rten 7y agoThis blog post originated at Google, but it is not some kind of Code of Conduct everyone at Google has to follow. This was an episode of Testing on the Toilet, as the name implies it is a newsletter, which is posted in the bathrooms.
- droithomme 7y agoYes. CoCs are toxic and all workplaces with CoCs quickly become gamed toxic work environments. It's a nightmare. I never accept offers to join places with CoCs. In order to be effective and efficient I require the ability to speak plainly, clearly and directly about code quality and design issues. Companies that use these tend to stop making good code and products and start using lobbyists to use regulations to anchor their dismally low quality products and squash any upcoming free-thinking rivals with good design.
- siruncledrew 7y agoThe ever-expanding-CoC made me think a lot about the parallels to how laws are made. I do agree the prolific laundry list of Do/Don’t criteria becomes more mentally hampering over time to circumnavigate. Realistically speaking, If there was feedback/questions to bring up, I would just want to leave a comment putting my thoughts into words as efficiently as possible to then continue reviewing. Not a snarky, underhanded jerk comment like something an opponent would say in a multiplayer videogame - just a regular, normal person’s comment in a plain way. For example, “What is the goal of this section?”, “Why use X method?”, “Please use ABC naming convention for the function here :)“. Some of the “Do” ways are just about repackaging a concise statement into a more lengthy form for the sake of issue indirectness (or trying to avoid anything negative). This to me seems less efficient in a code review because it then takes longer to jump through all the mental gymnastics and mulling over phrasing of how to write a sentence referring to a piece of code. I’m not at all saying be a ruthless hard-ass with the emotion of a robot. It’s just policies like a CoC that grows and grows and grows to retroactively counteract every single offense or misgiving feels like drudging through a bunch of HR bullshit. Coders already have enough mental exertion as it is. The simpler and shorter the list for the CoC, the better (IMO). Will it encompass every possible instance or example? No. Will it please everyone? No. Will it get the job done so everyone can go home? Yes. Look, every coder is going to make a mistake at some point and every reviewer is going to make a mistake, too. It’s ok to respectfully agree/disagree/debate perspectives about the code concisely. There is no need to turn an (unfun) diligence process into a pissing contest or a witch-hunt or a gatekeeping exercise. The people who do are wasting everyone’s time. Accept responsibility. Accept feedback. Reach a resolution and move on.