23 ms·
I was an astrologer
- TheRealDunkirk 7y agoPlease don't try to lecture me about the death of "news." Following that link shows all the reasons that news deserves everything that's happening to it. How much reputation does it take on this site to downvote submissions? I've been waiting a long time for that.
- dmurray 7y agoIt's not news. It's still journalism.
- russfink 7y agoRelevant here because it mentions an app. I liked it.
- skrebbel 7y agoThis isn't news. It's a background story. It doesn't pretend to be news. Newspapers have been running background stories for a long while. I think the editors who put the "protect good news, subscribe now" copy into that yellow box assumed readers would know that not everything in a newspaper is news. Clearly they're mistaken.
- ChrisSD 7y agoa) It's "Life and style" not "news". b) What specifically is wrong with it?
- TheRealDunkirk 7y agoSpecifically, literally half of the page was covered up by the subscription and cookie warning banners, and half of the other half was the site header. On Safari, on a MBP. I could only read the headline and, like, 2 lines of text. I might as well have been on a terrible mobile site. But what do I know? Clearly very little. Maybe everyone here is already a subscriber and has already dismissed the cookie crap. All of this on top of the fact that it was a click-baity "article" that should have been a blog post, but, hey, I clicked!
- saagarjha 7y agoYou can’t downvote submissions.
- Angostura 7y agoI thought it was an interesting and well written piece of reportage. It wasn’t news and it didn’t pretend to be. It’s in the Life and Style section, where you will also find gardening and makeup tips.
- empath75 7y agoYou must be fun at parties.
- TheRealDunkirk 7y ago"Parties?" What are those? /s
- dang 7y agoPlease don't do this here.
- russfink 7y agoWhat happened to the man who yelled fraud? Don't leave us hanging! :-)
- xwdv 7y agoPassed away.
- sunseb 7y agoI don't understand how HN algorithm works. Sometimes, submissions like this link seem to magically pop from nowhere?
- AndrewDucker 7y agoIt's got 39 points in under an hour. That's clearly enough to push it up the rankings. What are you confused by?
- buboard 7y agothat's how the supernatural works
- me_me_me 7y agoYou might need to seek a psychics help to figure this one out. xD
- naringas 7y agoright now at 12p UTC there's a different set of top stories. I call these Euro top stories. Within the next 2-4 hours USA will wake up and the top stories will change.
- Sharlin 7y agoThis would be really interesting to study. Same with Reddit.
- 7y ago
- buboard 7y ago> My friend’s imagination had done all the work. Sounds a lot like how professional economics or entrepreneurship works
- k__ 7y agoThe Management Myth, haha.
- ipnon 7y agoAn activity based on intuition or heuristics is going to get fuzzy on the edges. The saving grace of entrepreneurship is that truly good ideas will succeed in a market and the ones based on faulty logic will not. There isn't a similar market function for peoples' internal psychology.
- jacobsenscott 7y agoIf by "truly good" you mean makes money, that's a tautology. If by "truly good" you mean materially improves lives entrepreneurship hasn't panned out.
- wccrawford 7y agoAfter all the help she gave all those people, she quit because someone called her a fraud and refused her help? I think this woman needs to stop and revisit what she was doing. She wasn't a fraud. She was exactly what those people were paying for. For many, it was someone to talk to. For some, it was someone who could look past their biases and clear their minds. For some, it was a magic trick. Her mistake wasn't the advice, but in not giving it in the accepted way: As mysticism. Tell him to go to the doctor, but have an in-character way of doing it instead of using logic. If they were willing to listen to logic, they wouldn't be there. I'm sure it's stressful to "lie" to people all the time in this way, but all jobs are stressful in their own ways. And I see nothing in this article to indicate the author has any other options open to them at the moment. Edited: Replaced "he" with "she". I was mislead by the image at the top and actually had to search for the author's name.
- k__ 7y agoFelicity who wanted a "hot boyfriend" and studied theater is probably a woman, I think.
- tshanmu 7y agoyour unconcious bias is at work my friend, we are in the woke aqaurian age: Felicity could be a man looking for a hot boyfriend! gender identity is fluid - please dont box people into your preconceptions!
- Scarblac 7y agoStraight women still outnumber gay men by a lot, so it's still the safe bet.
- tuesdayrain 7y agoThat's why I just refer to everyone as a chinese male unless they ask me to stop.
- thanatropism 7y agoWhen I was a teenager (boy), girls were into astrology and one way to be around them was to indulge them on this. But I told them I had investigated the existing sign and didn't really identify with any of them; and that I was looking into maybe creating my own sign once I got to a chart of the constellations etc. (This was pre-internet.)
- xamuel 7y agoPossible plot twist: the girls were into astrology because it gave boys an easy way to approach and initiate conversation with them ;)
- hashberry 7y agoIt's called "cold reading"[0] and the "Barnum effect."[1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_reading [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect
- mettamage 7y agoThis is just a story for entertainment purposes. It's all true though. I seriously practiced astrology between the ages of 12 to 16. Specifically from this book [1]. How did I start believing in it? My dad believed in it and went to an Indian astrologer and the guy gave me a reading and got my character spot on. Because of that, I became really enthusiastic. However, since I knew that my family let me down before when it came to matters of knowledge, I decided to do my best to quickly debunk it as fast as possible. I got into palmistry and numerology. It took me 4 years to debunk. The reason it took 4 years: well with palmistry, it's tough to know where to start. Furthermore, life events play out on a life scale, so the instant feedback is zero. At the time, I eventually ruled it out by association, a very weak argument indeed. Nowadays, I rule it out by logic, but I still can't empirically rule it out (not that I care). Numerology was actually doable and that took me 4 years. It took so long because there's an insidiuous effect going on. With most numbers (check the source [1]), the descriptions are relatively positive and when you're capable of always giving quite a positive reading, then people tend to agree with you! In fact, a psychologist tested this on a 100 college students. He wrote the same positive personality description for all of them and got 4 out of 5 stars! While I couldn't find the source of that, I could find the source on something very similar [2]. Eventually I noticed that numerology had an accuracy of 50%, I reasoned that's basically a coin flip's worth of chance (remember, I was 16, I didn't understand what base rate meant) and if numerology would be true, I'd expect a 95% accuracy. Also, in hindsight there were some very strong indicators of it being bullshit. I used the system to pick my friends this way for a while and that didn't go too well (not too bad either). I've wasted a lot of time on it and I'm sad that this is the stuff I spent my time on, and that this is the stuff my dad found important. When I'll be a dad, I'll teach my kids about math, music and the world. I'll teach them about numerology and palmistry as a cautionary tail and how to distinguish true knowledge (math) from nonsense such as astrology (in a scientific sense, I agree that it's useful for simply talking, etc.). The irony is, whenever I give readings to people (once per year on average), they tend to become almost immediate converts despite me saying it's bullshit. That's something to think about. Even more ironic is that ever since that period in my life, I behave as my birth date would stipulate. Since whatever you believe in -- between the ages of 12 and 16 -- stays forever with you. (Obviously, there's a good explanation for that and it doesn't involve planets. It definitely involves the effects of a self-fulfilling prophecy) [1] https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.70770 https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.70770 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect
- cptaj 7y agoGuilty click. Immediately ran away after the site blocked 90% of the screen with curtains
- hyperpallium 7y ago> I heard these stories so often I could often guess what the problem was the moment someone walked in. > "You sounded happier when you said ‘photography’,” I said. My psychic teacher was right – the signals we pick up before conscious awareness kicks in can be accurate and valuable. These are valuable skills.
- m-i-l 7y ago"You sounded happier when you said ‘photography’” See also "Clever Hans"[0], the horse answering questions correctly because it picked up the subconscious reactions of the observer. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans
- xamuel 7y agoOr neural nets trained to detect cancers from patient photographs, that end up learning "if the patient has a ruler next to them, then they have cancer"
- jwist 7y agoReminds me of Orson Welles story about cold reading. https://youtu.be/IjPsnfysrp8 https://youtu.be/IjPsnfysrp8
- gvb 7y ago> A student there mentioned she wasn’t sure what to specialize in – photography, graphic design or maybe industrial design? It was also the first element in the list. Humans tend to sort by preference, often subconsciously.
- lm28469 7y agoThat's how they make you believe, by using basic human patterns/behaviours, they don't read stars/cards/palms, they read you and make you believe they know more about you than yourself, which can be helpful in some ways if you never self reflect.
- 7y ago
- TuringTest 7y ago> It dawned on me that my readings were a co-creation I think this is a key point that rational people and skeptics don't get. Pseudosciences and pseudotherapies don't work because they produce accurate results, they work because of the tremendous effort that believers put in them to make them work. IMHO, skeptics could help believers much more if they instilled in them some common sense and safeguards to avoid the worst crooks and dangerous therapies ("buy as many Bach flowers as you wish, it's your money - just don't abandon your chemotherapy") rather than try to appeal to their rational sense ("don't you realize how ridiculous it is? It could never work!"). At least in personal interactions, it is more likely that the former will gradually succeed in educating them than the latter.
- Dumblydorr 7y agoIts not a revelation to say insulting people's intelligence with skeptical incredulity is a bad strategy to win them over. Same with climate for instance, shaming people isn't likely to convince them of climate science.
- scott_s 7y agoThose from the skeptical community who I read and listen to (mostly from The Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast, https://www.theskepticsguide.org/ https://www.theskepticsguide.org/) are quite aware of this idea.
- davinic 7y agoNot to mention that since the placebo effect is so real, it can be unethical to explain that to someone. When my mother was going through chemo and radiation and started buying healing crystals as well, I supported her beliefs in that (she was also doing all the doc recommended stuff).
- TuringTest 7y agoIt has occurred to me that pseudo-scientific beliefs "work" for believers, just not in the way that scientists think of a system that works ("I can make repeatable predictions") but in a social and emotional way ("it makes me feel good"). That's a reason why it's so hard to get people away from them.
- Merrill 7y ago>because if you sprinkle magic on top, you can sell people anything. WeWork?
- xamuel 7y agoWhat we need is for someone to apply deep neural networks to astrology. Sure, star-signs never worked in the past, but do you realize how powerful GPUs are these days? Now please give me a $500mil seed round
- qwerty456127 7y agoSome stock market traders actually use astrology and attract investors. Some even manage to make money this way. Perhaps you'd like to read about W. D. Gann.
- annoyingnoob 7y agoThe person that wrote the article should be in Sales.
- Inu 7y agoOne shouldn't forget that some practices that appear pseudo-scientific from today's point of view made sense historically: "It made perfect sense for ancient man to believe in astrology. The influence of sun and moon on earthly affairs is obvious. Likewise the stars can be seen as influential by their association with the seasons. Heavenly bodies are the prototype of self-motion, which is a property also possessed by beings with a soul as opposed to inanimate objects. This leads to the idea of the soul being a "piece of the heavens" and thereby to personal horoscope astrology. The heavenly bodies are associated with personality traits in a manner that have a straightforward justification in terms of objective astronomical properties of these bodies." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCFvtiAig7I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCFvtiAig7I
- whatshisface 7y agoI disagree. You're not an ocean, so looking at the tides and assuming that the moon has a similar influence on you is an unjustified jump of logic. Then, when you start inventing specific effects for the moon to have, you're clearly in the realm of fiction because you know full well you didn't get the ideas you're writing down from observation. I have heard before the argument that "being rational wasn't invented until the 1930s, so you can't call anyone before then irrational," but everybody knows intuitively that the truth is something they see or something they infer from what they see, and a lie is something they make up in their own heads.
- tralarpa 7y agoJump of logic for us. Not for people in the past. This is called a "vertical" (or magic) world view where things with similar properties are believed to be connected. Examples: 1. The moon is influencing the ocean? -> It will also influence humans 2. Those berries are red? Blood is red, too -> Those berries are good for your blood. 3. This planet is moving fast (Mercure)? -> Mercure is connected to things moving/changing fast (mercury, travellers,...) (Example 2 is still practiced in traditional Chinese medicine today)
- whatshisface 7y ago
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoFormer fortune teller here. I used to sit on the sidewalk and read the I Ching to anyone who asked me to, pay-what-you-want. No one ever called me a fraud, but I still quit. A couple folks were just trying to have fun tossing pennies at a smelly book, but the vast supermajority of them were feeling highly anxious because they needed reassurance that their future plans would work out. What if my kids come to America to live with me? What if I divorce my husband? What if I quit my job? I feel sad and guilty about answering those questions by tossing coins around because I think I could have helped them more if we had cut the magic and just talked honestly about what was going on with them.
- rytor718 7y agoBut they almost surely wouldn't have liked you to do that (to cut the magic and talk honestly). That's why people go to clairvoyants. We're all embarrassingly expert at self-delusion.
- kjaftaedi 7y agoIt's easier to believe something as the truth when you think you're hearing it from 'the universe' rather than a random stranger.
- kingkawn 7y agoYou were functioning as a random number generator to help them make an accurate analysis unburdened by the rigidity of the morose perspective that had led them to you in the first place.
- jermaustin1 7y agoThis is an discussion I've had plenty of times with my wife (who is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist). It's hard to articulate in words, but I will try. What gets me about astrologists and psychics, is they are preying on peoples innocent stupidity. At best they are reading their clients semi-accurately, at worst they are swindling them. But in both cases they are not actually helping the client understand what is making them feel this way, and helping down on a path that leads to a healthier self-awareness. We have a friend who doesn't not believe in psychology, but believes in psychics. She refuses to go back to a psychologist because the psychologist wanted her to actually think on and feel her past traumas, to discover why she has some self destructive tendencies. The psychic she eventually went with and still uses today (costing just as much as the psychologist -- more if you have mental health coverage on your insurance) just told her she sees why she is doing certain things, and to call her if she felt these tendencies coming back (charging her of course). My wife thinks that so long as it is helping, it isn't necessarily bad. She feels that people shouldn't see psychics or read too much into the movement of planets and stars, but that whats the harm if it makes you feel better. I feel that the amount of good they could do is way less than the harm they could do. And that the dangers of allowing another person to give you untrained/regulated advise is a terrible path to go down instead of understanding yourself.
- Iv 7y agoIf you assume only balanced and benevolent people will do astrology and psychic readings, that's fine. The problem is that if you have a little bit of problem yourself, a bit of delusion, it is easy to bring down the gullible that come to you. People die of preventable disease because they listen to their psychics. An astrologist with a bunch of fervent followers can make a transition into a cult the day he or she wants to make serious money.
- jiveturkey 7y ago+1 it's like saying gambling (or alcohol, or other vice) is just fine. most vices are fine in moderation. the problem is that some people can't moderate, and for those people the harm is quite bad. the purveyors of such vices are absolutely knowingly taking advantage of these people will low self control. most prominently (but perhaps least acknowledged) in today's attention economy.
- whatshisface 7y agoI have heard of a bias where people will try to justify paying a lot of money for something by thinking that it's better. The $50 price tag probably made the spooky predictions appear to work better.
- Pete_D 7y agoThe price tag probably also helps to discourage repeating too soon. Few things puncture the illusion of meaningfulness around a tarot reading, I Ching divination, etc. like rerolling until you get the answer you want.
- rafaelvasco 7y agoThe most complete definition for our reality that I've seen is that everything is One. Everything in the Universe is connected, part of a whole; Everything is made of the same basic components, only vibrating, at different frequencies; As we are all made of the same basic components and everything is interconnected, we can affect the Universe , just as the Universe affects us. That for me explains and validates most of these concepts that most people think are fantasy: Clairvoyance, Telekinesis, Mind Reading, Telepathy etc; Once you start seeing the big picture you start to glimpse reality; Science is just starting to grasp these concepts. There will come a time when mysticism and science will be one and the same, and religion won't exist; Because we won't be needing it anymore; We'd have transcended it;
- dkersten 7y ago> Clairvoyance, Telekinesis, Mind Reading, Telepathy etc The problem with these things is that nobody has ever been able to prove they exist when put under scrutiny and anything attributed to them has generally always had alternative explanations that don't require the existence of the paranormal or whatnot. Until you can prove it exists, in a controlled test that eliminates biases, its no better than a fantasy, even if it does exist. I'm a hobbyist (sleight of hand) magician. I can do things that people believe are physically impossible. I know the methods of many more illusions (that I can't perform myself) that many people online claim is real magic/demons/whatever. This is completely laughable when you know the techniques. Its all a mixture of trickery, sleight of hand, misdirection, gimmicks/props, camera tricks and stooges. It often can look truly impossible and therefore magical, until you know how its done. Another concept that is often played on in performance magic is psychology: you can trick people into missremembering a sequence of events in order to make them appear even more impossible, for example, spectators often re-tell the performance saying things like they shuffled the cards, even though they only cut them, or that I didn't touch the cards and it all happened in the spectators hands, even though it actually did happen in mine and I did touch the cards. Just because you don't know the mechanism of something, doesn't mean that anything fantastical, mystical or paranormal actually occurred. I've yet to see any substantial evidence that anything ever has.
- 7y ago
- sunseb 7y agoIf we had to remove all bullshit businesses in the world - not just astrologers - 99% of stuff we buy and sell could be removed of as well. Astrology already has a bad rap, but how many beliefs and legit businesses out there are just scamming people too? I would say many...
- stoolpigeon 7y agoMyers Briggs, Enneagram, Strength Finders, it goes on and on. It's big money and most of it isn't any better than astrology, tarot cards, etc.
- superqd 7y agoyeah, that is pretty much the business model of companies that sell personality assessments for employment screening. Just find some legal bullshit to sell.
- mikorym 7y agoThe town where I went to primary school in somewhat rural South Africa had, for quite a few years, a stand/shack smack in the middle of the town and on the side of the main road (if it can be called that). The shack had a big sign: "ANASTROLOGER HEALER". [1] I am not sure whether the anastrologer healer misjudged the space on the sign or what, but kudos to them for remembering the a/an rule for English. [1] It could also have been "ANASTROGIST HEALER" but I forget now.
- ipnon 7y agoFreud would say that people enjoy having their problems. A dysfunctional replacement for therapy or a reasonable world-view would let you have the twin enjoyments of pouring endless effort into a perceived solution (astrological charts, tarot readings) while doing effectively nothing to resolve the actual cause.
- jmkd 7y agoThere is an approach of modern astrology that is not predictive and mystical, and that appeals to many because it is non-judgemental and makes no scientific claim for itself. It's not a scam or a swindle, it's only claim is being a guide or tool for creativity. It works in the same way the I Ching does, simply by presenting connections and ideas to people and allowing them to draw conclusions, resolve issues and work on their healing. Without the I Ching we would not have the best of Philip K Dick, so dismissing all forms of astrology disempowers those for whom it is genuinely useful and inspirational. This is an unfashionable and unscientific view, but that does not decrease the value for humans who - it turns out - are never 100% rational beings, and that's a wonderful thing.
- malvosenior 7y agoThis assumes that there are no negatives to introducing and supporting anti-science en mass. I think society is at a very real risk when it embraces false reasoning and anti-intellectualism. We need more logic and fact based thinking in our world, not less.
- jmkd 7y agoBy this logic art is anti-science. The value of the I Ching or elements of astrology is the value of art.
- malvosenior 7y agoArt doesn't pretend to have the ability to predict the future through mystical means. It doesn't present an illogical premise that's meant to be taken seriously. You might view astrology as art, which is fine but plenty of people really believe in it.
- jmkd 7y agoTo be clear, only some parts of astrology pretend to predict the future through mystical means. Just as some parts of religion insist their version is the only truth. So I believe the most reasoned response on these topics will depend on whether we are talking about the whole or a part.
- marc_io 7y agoFor a more contemporary – and informed – view of Astrology, please read “The Passion of the Western Mind” and “Cosmos and Psyche” (important: you must read in that order), by Richard Tarnas.
- yosefzeev 7y agoUh, that's not how any of that works. Rather, that's how it worked for the article writer.
- gerbler 7y agoI dressed up as a fortune-teller at a Halloween party in a house I shared with a few people. It was a fairly big party, 40-50 people. As a joke, I set up a little booth under a sheet and started telling fortunes. People went wild for it. Many of them knew it was me (slightly drunk) and they still sort of believed me. People waited in line for 15-20 minutes. I told people mostly jokey things that were positive. I started getting adventurous and told people random things - if they didn't like what I said they were genuinely sad. What surprised me the most was that people would take anything seriously from a tipsy fortune-teller beneath a sheet.
- tedajax 7y agoIt seems like Terry Pratchett was on to something with "headology"
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoPratchett was on to something with the entire Discworld and other stuff besides. Every time I hear of a new, promising cure for Alzheimer's I go a little happy and a little sad, because I think that, if he had held a bit longer, maybe... But then, none of those cures ever work out in the end so I'm just left with the sad. Sad that I never got the chance to see him up close and shake him by the hand.
- advaita 7y agoThanks for introducing me to Terry Pratchett!
- Pete_D 7y agoI saw the same sort of effect a few years ago when I was running some IRC bots. In addition to the usual dice, 8ball, etc. one of them would respond to queries with a random aphorism from a list I put together from Googling "wise quotes" and such. It was a big hit, and kind of spooky to watch when people got responses that sounded relevant to their question. People joked that my perl script was being influenced by the spirits. In the end I concluded that you can read deep meaning into almost anything if you work hard enough.
- murukesh_s 7y agoBeing an Indian citizen and especially from the southern state of Kerala, it's tough to not believe in astrology. It's considered a science in ancient times and a significant energy was spent on perfecting the art/science. For e.g. refer to Kerala school of mathematics, which had done some pretty significant work before Calculus was discovered in Europe and that period most of the mathematicians were also astronomers as well as astrologers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerala_School_of_Astronomy_and_Mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerala_School_of_Astronomy_and.... My own uncle is an Astrologer and sometimes he makes pretty accurate predictions. He is a retired professor and he does it for a hobby and not for monetary reasons. I don't have a scientific explanation for how it works, but would love to apply some statistics/ML learning with reliable public data available on well known persons whose time and date of birth is published and find a scientific correlation, if at all it exists.
- freddex 7y agoWell, speaking strictly logically: If they were both astronomers and astrologers, and their astronomy was sound, it does not mean that their astrology was, too. Many great scientists of the past were religious, and yet that is no proof of god. It's just hard for me to see how astrology could work. Either the movement of the stars affects the fate of individual humans everywhere, in a weird semantic connection ("Mars, the bringer of war" and so on), or people seek out astrologers to confirm whatever they need confirmed (Confirmation bias). This just seems massively more likely and doesn't clash with anything in the scientific framework. Astrology simply plays into all the biases everyone is affected by, so I don't mean to belittle anyone who believes or practices it, but it can't be called a science in any sense of the word.
- derangedHorse 7y agoSpeaking logically you also can’t discredit any logic behind it as well, just like one wouldn’t be able to discredit a religion. To know that human behavior is not affected by the stars requires an understanding of the human mind not yet attained
- jmcqk6 7y ago
- kingkawn 7y agoAstrology is a means of emotional regulation and the reestablishment of a sense of control over an otherwise chaotic world. All worldviews, whether they celebrate themselves for their rigor or not, serves this function in addition to whatever other outputs they do or do not produce. In my personal experience women are more often the ones utilizing astrology, which means not that they are being duped as many of the comments here patronizingly say, but rather that astrology is solving a particular problem that women have adapted it to solve. That there are scams that make use of the symbols of astrology hardly separates it from the company of any other worldview.
- cushychicken 7y ago>The range of problems faced by people who can afford $50 for fortune telling turned out to be limited: troubles with romance, troubles at work, trouble mustering the courage for a much-needed change. I'm not ready to say fortune telling is good, but I'm not ready to say it's bad if it's helping people make changes they need to make. Source: me, who's working on making some big changes in my life. (No fortune tellers involved.)
- smdz 7y agoI do not disagree with astrology but its application. In fact, stuff like cellular automata got me curious about astrology (obviously I did not find any relation). My point of view: astrology is a way of "evaluating the environment/universe and its effect on us" and determining a probabilistic outcome, not a perfect outcome. It is more like an ancient equation passed on to astrologers, that gives us the probability of success for a person trying to cross a river with a strong current. The intuition about these equations is either long lost and not yet discovered in science. I have been told by some astrologers (quite a few) that I could not do certain things. But I stood determined, and did those successfully. If I had not tried, I had already failed. But both of us were right. I could not do those things in a traditional manner, I had to achieve those differently. Retrospectively, after learning a bit of astrology myself, I can see why they said so.
- a11yguy 7y agoI feel 100% sure that the movement/patterns of the planets, the sun, moon and other celestial objects have a significant effect on who we are and how we feel. BUT, I am also pretty sure that most people claiming to understand what is going on are lying. "Astrology" is real, "astrologists" are charlatans.
- lostcolony 7y ago"Third variable problem" That is, the movement of the stars is predictable...as are a number of other things in life. That's not to say the stars are in control. This is classic correlation != causation. For instance, we know that the amount of natural light a person has has a pronounced effect on how they feel. So it's fair to say that when (insert astrological statement here, somethingorother is ascendant, referencing winter, when there is less daylight), you will be prone to being more depressed. This, obviously, has an effect, but to just shrug and say "it's the heavens!" is both unscientific, and unhelpful (since you can treat it by getting increased light of a given wavelength. You can't treat "state of the universe")
- a11yguy 7y agoI think your point about 'Third variable problem' is a steelman interpretation of my statements, and a better path to explore.
- manthedudeguy 7y ago> I feel 100% sure that the movement/patterns of the planets, the sun, moon and other celestial objects have a significant effect on who we are and how we feel. 100%? Why?
- driverdan 7y agoWhat you feel is irrelevant to how the universe works. Just because you "feel" something doesn't mean it's true. The gravitational effect of remote celestial objects is insignificant on something the scale of a human.
- 7y ago
- kept3k 7y agoI believe what was going on was some Spiritual Warfare. It's interesting that she was working with the two different sides. And they were actively pulling against one another. This isn't uncommon. God was showing her what true love and compassion looks like at the Catholic hospital. The devil didn't like that. He wanted to deceive her into thinking she could be a psychic, and that she can control the universe with her own free will. She was also actively deceiving her clients, who were turning to her instead of God.
- toss1 7y agoWhile listening to an NPR radio interview on astrology, I got increasingly impatient with the nonsense, and it just occurred to me that astrology is nothing but quasi-random assertions acted upon by confirmation bias. Nicely confirmed by this key passage in the article: "Some repeat customers claimed I’d made very specific predictions, of a kind I never made. It dawned on me that my readings were a co-creation – I would weave a story and, later, the customer’s memory would add new elements. " This whole practice has endured for millenia, is built on the foundation of one of the most common of human mental error conditions. Makes me wonder about the likelihood of other massive fundamental erroneous practices we haven't yet learned to question.
- banuguler 7y agoCo-creation isn’t a bug. It’s a feature. Astrology has stuck around for 2,500 years is because it is a robust language developed over millennia to capture the complexity of being human. Your ego, your communication style, your love language, your instinct for action – each have their own, often contradictory, flavor. You can use this language to walk into a room and say, ’I’m going through my Saturn return. I’m reckoning with restrictions and limits and boundaries right now.” It’s humanizing, and tender. You can start a conversation, “Why did we get into that insane fight and why did you shut down? Is it because you’re a Capricorn Mars?” People don’t use astrology to predict the future. People use it to explain and create the present. BTW ---> We’re probably who she’s subtweeting. And we’re hiring. https://www.costarastrology.com/jobs https://www.costarastrology.com/jobs
- warp 7y agoIf you "really need engineers", why hire only locally?
- banuguler 7y agoIn general, we think the point of tech is to get off tech and be together IRL. Same thing when we're thinking about features to build. Want to walk the walk, etc.
- malvosenior 7y ago> You can use this language to walk into a room and say, ’I’m going through my Saturn return. I’m reckoning with restrictions and limits and boundaries right now.” I wouldn't recommend doing that as anyone who is logic and science based will immediately cease to take you seriously. We have so much more information on how the universe works now than we did 2,500 years ago and there's nothing to suggest that astrology is anything other completely false. People used to believe that leeches could bleed out toxins, thankfully we've evolved our knowledge models since then. Let's not go back.
- banuguler 7y ago"Saturn return" is the technical term for when Saturn returns to the same place in the sky that it was when you were born. Very curiously, this happens on a regular basis – just about every 30 years.
- werber 7y agoI've "read" tarot cards for most of my life and have 0 belief in the supernatural. But, the cards are prompts for discussions with people, who need to believe in "magic" to look inside themselves and talk it out with someone. I don't do it for money anymore, but, I think sitting down with someone who has empathy for you, tarot reader with cards or priest with a book, can have some therapeutic value
- philshem 7y agoIt’s my duty to post all relevant and recent NYer articles, so here you go: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/10/28/astrology-in-the-age-of-uncertainty https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/10/28/astrology-in-t...
- polynomial 7y ago> "Astrology is one big word association game.” This is essentially the point Sontag makes in her essay Under the Sign of Saturn, while adding that word games can be fun, and tell even you a lot about someone.
- hosh 7y agoThat's a great article. I read astrology charts for a hobby, though I am skilled enough to do it professionally. I rarely read in person, and tend to read it from just the chart, via the internet (so very little telegraphing from voice tone and body language). One of the things that turn me off to reading for people in general are some of those things that the author brought up: - People have a limited range of issues: relationships, career advice. They need counseling, not an astrology reading. - The kind of readings I do or would like to do have little to do with what the person wants - There are actually multiple ways to read charts. For example, two popular house systems, Placidus, and Whole Sign House can give different apparent results. Some people get really mad when charts are read with a different house systems. - There was at least once when I used the wrong chart for someone's reading, and they seemed to relate to that reading. Having said that, there are enough unusual things that came out of the experience. I don't think it is completely worthless. I don't use the method the person described -- sympathetic magic, or word association. Nor do I base my astrology on the popular notion, that astrology is a science. It most certainly is not a science. I don't see it as a celestial clockwork that mechanistically produces results that are predictable (I have pissed off astrology enthusiasts who think that way). Instead, my view of astrology is a map for Consciousness (the idea that mind did not emerge from the mind, but rather, matter solidified from mind), and it is something I think many (but not not all) psychonauts can relate to. For those who are exploring things that way, it can be valuable map.
- fortran77 7y ago> The clairvoyant had said none of the things my friend claimed. Not a single one. My friend’s imagination had done all the work. This reminds me of people recounting things that they believe happened at a party in high school 30 years ago, to members of Congress.
- _bxg1 7y ago> I watched nuns offer compassionate care to the dying...I became uncomfortably aware that New Agers do not build hospitals or feed alcoholics – they buy self-actualisation at the cash register. > Half the time, though, I couldn’t get a word in. It turned out what most people want is the chance to unload for an hour. > “Get to a doctor,” I told him. “Now.” I grew up in an evangelical, southern-baptist church. I indeed saw many mission trips, community events, charitable efforts. But there was always a catch: it was always a veiled effort to convert people. You didn't have to convert of course, but that's what the whole thing was about. Every greeting, every friendly conversation, every volunteer effort. They were all just spoonfuls of sugar. None of it was without ulterior motives. It was like one of those business "seminars" that really just wants you to buy something. Every interaction with another human was steeped in this mentality. Of course, when asked, they would argue that converting people is the most compassionate thing you can possibly do. I have to disagree. What I never got, even as a convert, was a real chance to unload to someone who would actually, truly listen. As someone with deep anxiety and depression, nobody ever told me to go to a therapist. Not once. They would always nod, and smile sympathetically, and say "have faith and leave it up to God". Every religion - even every religious body - is different. I just felt the need to provide a counterexample to the rosy light that traditional religion was left in by the author. For me, Christianity was astrology: something that made me feel superficially better sometimes, but was really just pushing me further and further away from any actual healing or personal development.
- ErotemeObelus 7y agoYou just learned the hard way that right-wing authoritarians don't believe internal state exists.
- authoritarian 7y agoYes, I knew a girl who was raped and her mother would only allow her to talk to their priest rather than medical and/or mental health professionals. People in the thread are talking about how astrology, religion, psychics, etc. are all ok because they don't cause harm but I believe they can and do cause harm in many cases. Of the people I know that strongly believe in things like astrologists, psychics, or religion a large percentage also believe other absurd conspiracy theories such as vaccines causing autism, the moon landing being fake, etc. I think we set a dangerous precedent by allowing people to blindly buy into things like astrology, without calling them out. I of course don't believe these kinds of things should be made illegal/regulated as people should be able to make their own decisions, but I also don't think they should be humored and blindly tolerated by the rest of the population.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- air7 7y agoI'm surprised by the many positive/understanding comments on this thread. Personally I find this kind of behavior despicable. Giving people what they ask for doesn't make it morally justifiable. Even if helps then in the short term. Astrologers, psychics, tarot readers and the likes are mis-educating people. Pushing the population back towards the dark ages. The real danger of this is specifically when it seems to work, in that it strengthens people's belief in "something" "beyond understanding" "magic" etc. Adults living in a fairy-tale world is dangerous. There is no moral dilemma. People who want their curse lifted should not have anyone to go to that isn't a doctor. Personally I also add "mentalists" and the likes to the list. I find Darren Brown, Lior Suchard and the such just as despicable as Uri Geller or any other con-man. The small yet crucial difference between a "mentalist" and a magician is the back story, and more importantly the effect of the back story on the viewer's world view: A magician leaves the viewer with the (very important) realization that they too can be fooled and they are not smart enough to understand and explain everything they experience. This is a very uncomfortable feeling for most people but honest magicians leave you with it. "Mentalists" ease your pain by throwing in an pseudo scientific "explanation": NLP, body reading, etc. But with that they rob the viewer of a valuable life lesson about their own shortcomings, and replace it with a wrong understanding of how the world works.
- Noos 7y agoThe problem is the doctors can't lift the curse. At best, they can only treat it, and sometimes you treat it by bargaining other aspects of your life for it (the side effects medicine and treatment may give.) There are no "shortcomings" to learn a life lesson from. Or perhaps they are. Cinderella is told there are no fairy godmothers, so pull your self up by your bootstraps and go get your prince! Until she realizes what this mean is that unless she is incredibly lucky, she will be a scully maid forever. Be careful when you wish for this. The reality is that a secular and scientific culture cannot solve or help as much as you think, and by driving out people's illusions about their chances you might end up driving any sense of hope from them at all.
- GrumpyNl 7y agoI have worked for and with them. One word, charlatans.
- droithomme 7y agoI used to do Tarot card demonstrations for friends, explaining exactly what the psychology was, that it was just arbitrary noise and they were projecting on to random open ended ink blot like designs and assigning meaning to it. Didn't work. All my friends believe now I am psychic. Because how could I know these things that I showed them?
- qwerty456127 7y agoNot taking it too seriously, I still feel like atrology still is a fun thing to learn. Can anybody suggest a good reading which won't take too much time but would still give all the essential knowledge and understanding an astrologer is supposed to have? I mean the model, the formulae to calculate the deterministic part, basic clues on interpreting it etc. Isn't it fun to study magical arts which have deterministic models as important parts of them? I'm also curious about how does the rectification thing work. Astrologers say they can figure out your exact birth time given information about some events in your life.
- RichardCA 7y agoThis is a good one: https://www.amazon.com/Secrets-Stargazers-Notebook-Debbi-Kempton/dp/1892881268 https://www.amazon.com/Secrets-Stargazers-Notebook-Debbi-Kem... Astrodeinst / Astro.com has for a long time been a good resource for doing people's natal charts. https://www.astro.com/ https://www.astro.com/
- RichardCA 7y agoYou might also find this to be of some use: https://www.astrolog.org/astrolog.htm https://www.astrolog.org/astrolog.htm
- qwerty456127 7y agoBy the way, I'd like to introduce another astrology-like thing to those who haven't heard of it so I could find out what smart guys here might say about it: it's "human design". It takes your exact birth date+time (+place unless you can specify the timestamp in UTC) as its only input an produces a very detailed an precise review of your personality (well, what it actually produces is a bizarre looking chart with lots of digits and weird words but it's very deterministic and straightforward to interpret given the knowledge on what do these digits mean which can be obtained from a book or a paid course, no "sympathetic magic" or anything like that has to be used). I have done some research to find out the meaning of the details depicted on the chart and found out the personality profiling it provides mind-bogglingly precise. It fits me exactly, while it doesn't fit me at all if I change the date. I have also tested it against some other people I know well. It's orders of magnitude more precise than Meyers-Briggs or anything like that. It absolutely does not feel like cold reading or random stuff which would more-or-less fit everyone. How can this possibly work? The official explanation says it has something to do with neutrinos and CMBR but this obviously sounds bullshit. Nevertheless it's impossible for me to deny it works. This seems so curious I would even conduct a study involving a reasonable number of subjects to verify the predictions against if I had enough spare time an money.
- qwerty456127 7y ago> modern astrologers still use Earth-centred charts, as if Copernicus had never existed. That's because it's not about causation but about correlation. Obviously the stars can not influence our individual lives, nevertheless I can not be equally sure there is no rhythm driving our personal histories and it can't correlate with that present in the geocentric model. Perhaps, if that's the case, a more relevant model could (or could not) be derived given modern understanding of astronomy but nobody bothers to invent it as long as the traditional model produces predictions sufficient to satisfy the overwhelming majority of the target audience.