36 ms·
I have mixed feelings about this: Julian Simon did a pretty good job of supporting the anti-malthusian thesis, and that more people implies more opportunities f
by gumby 7y ago
I have mixed feelings about this: Julian Simon did a pretty good job of supporting the anti-malthusian thesis, and that more people implies more opportunities for creativity.
On the other hand he didn't disprove such a theory either -- we might have been just moving up a curve towards a critical point, where hysteresis then screws us.
But in general I'm pretty neutral: if people want more kids, great; if they don't, that's great too. So this sentence right at the front of the article really disturbs me:
> Population growth is vital for the world economy.
Most people seem to agree with this statement, which is the very definition of a pyramid scheme (see my point about hysteresis above). We've defined the goalposts such that this statement is in some sense tautologically true, but it leaves me with a profound sense of "so what?"
If fewer people are born, ultimately fewer houses will be needed, but why should that presume that less house construction will happen (perhaps there will be lots of renovations, or removal and new construction, or house builders will simply move to new fields as horsecart makers did).
We already know our growth metrics are crude and wrong, though we don't know really how much and in what ways. But there are plenty of potential scenarios where economic growth and human wellbeing does not require massive, or perhaps any population increase.
- api 7y agoAs with many things the optimum is not at the edges. Too much or too little fertility are bad, though they lead to different problem sets. In the short term I think slightly below replacement level is ideal. Once we get past fossil fuel dependence at or slightly above replacement might be best. As long as we run on fossil fuel we are basically putting our children on a credit card with an unknown interest rate.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWe already know how to get off of fossil fuels. We know how to make solar panels, nuclear reactors, electric cars, electric heat pumps, etc. The technology exists. It will likely continue to improve, but we could do it entirely with what already exists. If we deploy it by the time today's unborn children become a significant fraction of the global carbon footprint, it isn't going to matter how many of them there are. And if we don't deploy it by the time today's unborn children become a significant fraction of the global carbon footprint, it isn't going to matter how many of them there are.
- wahern 7y ago>> Population growth is vital for the world economy. > which is the very definition of a pyramid scheme AFAIU, population growth being beneficial is predicated on the notion that not only does every additional human contribute a pro rata factor of N=(contribution/cost) wealth to society, where N is greater than 1, but more importantly that for every additional human N increases. Maybe some professional economists can cite to the particular theories and research (I'm too distant from my academic days), or alternatively disabuse me of this notion. But that's my understanding, and in that light population growth is definitely not a pyramid scheme. It doesn't mean that population growth is the only way to increase N. There may be ways to increase N fast enough to compensate for the loss of the population growth dynamic, but those ways seem to be fairly elusive.[1] It also doesn't mean that there aren't pyramid scheme-like dynamics elsewhere (e.g. land use, housing prices, etc); they're just not intrinsic to the overarching dynamic. [1] And that's because rate of innovation is partly a function of population size. The more people there are, the more risk takers exist, the more opportunities available, the more possible social arrangements, etc. An analogy: To a first approximation, the more neurons you have (population), and the more interconnected they are ("free market"), the more capable and potentially intelligent the network.
- gumby 7y agoThat is a good statement of Simon's thesis, but as I discussed in my brief note there is nuance he did not address in writing (he was super smart and told me once that he understood the issue but didn't know how to characterize it). > An analogy: To a first approximation, the more neurons you have (population), and the more interconnected they are ("free market"), the more capable and potentially intelligent the network. A good analogy but every system has a "sweet spot" regime; outside that zone various advantages stop being (evolutionary, in this case) advantageous, else our brains would be eve larger.
- wahern 7y agoWhen I was working on onion routing and mesh networking 10+ years ago, I remember reading a paper that showed that in a mesh network every additional node added total throughput capacity, but the rate of increase asymptotically approached 0. I don't have the citation handy, and I'm sure the proof was tied to a particular topology, but the take home for me was that it was possible for mesh network advocates and skeptics to both be correct; that mesh networks can be a way to continually increase network capacity cooperatively without centralized authority, but that doesn't mean such capacity increases would be meaningful. The same might apply here: yes, the rate of increase in N may approach 0 such that at some point it becomes an irrelevant factor to economic growth. OTOH, in the absence of alternative drivers even a tiny rate of increase is something, and removing it could lead to accelerating reductions in global wealth. But we just don't know. The relevant questions and answers are more empirical than theoretical. My point was just that the growth narrative isn't predicated on a pyramid scheme, it's just the safest and possibly only known reliable strategy we understand. But an end to population growth seems inevitable in the next couple of generations (barring space colonization), so I suppose we'll find some answers rather soon.
- abrookewood 7y agoHave to agree - it was the first thing that struck me as worrying as well. We need to be able manage our economies without subscribing to the fallicy of unlimited and unrestrained growth. The planet can not support an infinite number of people.
- XorNot 7y agoNo, but if tomorrow is better then today, then in some capacity more resources were successfully allocated to it. You can have growth with zero additional material use.
- dev_dull 7y ago> Most people seem to agree with this statement, which is the very definition of a pyramid scheme (see my point about hysteresis above). We've defined the goalposts such that this statement is in some sense tautologically true, but it leaves me with a profound sense of "so what?" For countries with any kind of social / welfare programs, there is no option available but to grow population. Even here in the USA programs like social security are only solvent to 2037[1]. Many state programs (such as public pensions) are in way worse positions... 1. https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v70n3/v70n3p111.html https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v70n3/v70n3p111.html
- triceratops 7y agoWhy? Productivity continues to increase, regardless of population increasing. It's like saying we can do more with less everywhere, except when it comes to taking care of people and the elderly.
- paulajohnson 7y agoTaking care of the elderly is a labour intensive business. Automation doesn't clean an old person's glasses (real life example), make their bed or cook their meals.
- tyscorp 7y agoNot yet.
- triceratops 7y agoAutomation doesn't need to do any of those things (even though it eventually could). It could simply make other industries so cheap and efficient that more labor flows into elder care.
- buboard 7y agoincreased demand will drive more automation in that sector self driving cars may be limited but they will be a great solution for the elderly
- nategri 7y agoExcellent points. For many reasons, economists are going to have to give up their fixation on 2nd-derivative metrics sometime this century.
- jammygit 7y agoThis neglects the massive rise of infertility in the last few decades (eg, sperm counts are halved). It doesn’t seem to be a choice for a growing number of people (I guess if you’re well off there are some procedures that can help)
- mdorazio 7y agoWhat's interesting about that is the fact that it seems to be only men affected by rising infertility [1]. [1] https://www.livescience.com/38877-infertility-rates-drop-united-states.html https://www.livescience.com/38877-infertility-rates-drop-uni...
- AstralStorm 7y agoCan we actually get numbers for men, or is that just too hard?
- lordnacho 7y ago> Population growth is vital for the world economy. The thing is we know world population boomed for the last few centuries. We don't know what will happen if that stops, there's simply no observations yet. Hysteresis is indeed the major question mark. We can certainly imagine some terrible problems. Probably the biggest problem that comes out of this imagining is a reverse specialization effect. Think of the economy as a tapestry of different specializations, some of which support a very few people on a global scale. For instance, any particular thing that people get phds in like particular materials research. Or industries that are highly concentrated, which you'll find quite a lot of if you look closely. They might stop being viable on their own, requiring consolidation into wider industries or they'll get dropped entirely. The hysteresis comes in where we go back to a previous population but we unfortunately cannot support the same economy. You see things like that article about the Japanese trainline that stopped once that girl finished school. I mean that town might well have had a train when it was a similarly sized town getting bigger, I don't know. But that kind of thing might happen in many places.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoSo if the population grows from 1 (in units of 8 billion, say) to (1 + A), and the productivity per person goes from 1 to (1 + B), then the world economy goes from 1 to (1 + A) * (1 + B). If the population doesn't grow, then the economy only grows to (1 + B). As you say, so what? Is the world economy some kind of deity, that we are here to serve its needs rather than our own? If each of us are the same (1 + B) better off, why do we care whether the global economy grew more or less? As Edward Abbey said, "Growth for the sake of growth is the ideology of the cancer cell." If the growth actually leaves people better off, that's a positive. But if it just makes bigger numbers on a page, what's the point?
- d883kd8 7y agoIt's a problem for rich people and governments, who get to take a fraction of everyone's productivity through surplus labor value (i.e. capital gains) and taxes.
- Descartes1 7y agoRich people are the only ones who will get to reproduce.
- perl4ever 7y agoIt seems to me obvious that if I have a computer, I am more productive than with a stone axe, and it is a more productive asset if I am using it. There is obviously a surplus from combining labor with capital, and an inevitable struggle over allocating it, but I don't understand at all why people ostensibly think it's obviously all rightfully belonging to one or the other. If I earn a dollar, and then I collect interest on it, then the interest is really a part of my wages that was withheld. It's not extra. Whether anyone is being cheated of the amount of the interest depends on whether I got the dollar honestly, or cheated or stole to get it, but that has nothing to do with the essential nature of labor or capital.
- greeneggs 7y agoIt isn't just a problem for rich people, it is a problem for everyone who can save money. A growing population means that everything can grow accordingly (businesses, infrastructure, …) so there are good investment opportunities. If you can afford to save money, this means that there are productive things to do with that money, and you'll naturally get higher interest rates (and increasing stock prices, etc.). Higher interest rates aren't all good, but extremely low interest rates (like in Japan for the last ~25 years) aren't good either, especially if you want to save for retirement. Social Security isn't the only useful "pyramid scheme."
- nwah1 7y agoThere are various types of network effects that happen as a result of larger populations. Greater use of specialization and comparative advantage. Economies of scale. Agglomeration. All of these tendencies allow for niche fields like quantum physics to be viable. A very tiny fraction of the population is capable of understanding it, and to keep it a thriving discipline, we need people actively studying it. Statistically speaking, if only one in a million people is capable of understanding it, then you're in trouble if you don't have that many millions, and if the people with the capabilities are required in other equally important fields. Transmitting this information purely through written works is extremely difficult if there are no living mentors. And the resources necessary for something like CERN are vast, and only possible to fund in an enormous economy. Same story with semiconductors, rockets, MRI machines, and most other important technologies.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> All of these tendencies allow for niche fields like quantum physics to be viable. Well, Quantum Physics was created by a population that was approximately 1/6 of ours.
- nitwit005 7y agoBecoming hyper specialized appears to eventually create productivity issues. Scientists have sometimes made progress just by applying ideas from one specialized part of physics to another, where they were unaware of the progress in related ideas. And there are more mundane costs. The more specialized you are, the higher the odds your tiny niche will go away due to market or technological changes. That means losing income retraining and finding new work.
- jes5199 7y agowell what if we managed to keep a stable population of a few billion? we've already demonstrated that it's a sufficient number for all the processes you named
- yters 7y agoSupposedly that's wrong. An economist I think named Solow showed the US economic growth in the early to mid 1900s was almost entirely due to innovation, not labor. The population growth equals wealth is more due to the Marxist concept that labor is wealth.
- jonplackett 7y agoIt makes sense for the current dominant population (adults with power) to perpetuate this because a) their interests are tied to economic growth. And b) when they get old they want a good economy and many people to look after them, fund their pension, and (literally) wipe their arse in a nursing home. Beliefs get perpetuated because they serve a purpose not because they’re actually true.
- throwaway35784 7y agoRead "prosperity without growth" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosperity_Without_Growth https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosperity_Without_Growth