18 ms·
Online installment loans have taken the subprime market by storm
- notus 7y agoI feel like the government should be offering some type of non predatory debt relief comparable to this. This service is only a detriment to the borrower due to the crazy high interest rates, but I think the government could break even with much more reasonable interest rates, consumers would be better off financially, and the predatory industries would disappear since they can't compete.
- TylerE 7y agoI am leery of government-backed loans. Look what FHA did to the housing market and what student loans have done to the cost of college.
- notus 7y agoI'm not entirely sure what FHA did to the housing market, but as for student loans, yes it wasn't a great outcome, but it is a substantially better outcome than everyone being in debt with high interest rates with predatory lenders.
- entropicdrifter 7y agoExcept that student loans can't be abandoned even if you declare bankruptcy. That one little factor makes them some of the worst loans imaginable in terms of long-term prospects.
- notus 7y agoStill not worse than triple digit interest rates
- godzillabrennus 7y agoThose unpaid predatory loans fall off your credit report after about a decade. Student loans are forever.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chasd00 7y agothe tradeoff is insanely low interest rates. Without the federal backstop student loans would have the interest rates of credit cards because as soon as new graduates get into the workforce, can't find a job, they'll file for bankruptcy to get out of the loan. Managing that risk without a backstop means incredibly high interest rate to cover for the losses of loans lost in bankruptcy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoStudent loans didn't have those kinds of interest rates back when they could be discharged in bankruptcy 20+yr ago. Why would they now?
- mrguyorama 7y agoThe downside/risk to the lender is about 10x higher per loan than it was 20+ years ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- woeirua 7y agoNo, it's not a better outcome than if the market was private because frankly no one would graduate with $150k in debt for a degree in basket weaving if private lenders were backing the loans. A well regulated private market would prevent the extreme situations that we are seeing today. You can make a (somewhat legitimate) argument that we shouldn't require young kids to major in subjects that result in good paying jobs, but on the other hand you wind up with the mess that we are in if you don't. The status quo cannot go on. I'm in favor of either fully privatizing the system again, OR fully socializing it. In either case, the government would absolutely not be backing loans anymore.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoWhat does it mean to “fully socialise it” in the context of being from the US? Do you mean buying out all of the universities? PS: I come from Europe, studied in the UK when the tuition was capped at £3K/year.
- woeirua 7y agoNo, it would mirror the European experience. Essentially just capping the cost of tuition, fees and room/board and subsidizing the schools to an extent to make up the difference.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> No, it's not a better outcome than if the market was private because frankly no one would graduate with $150k in debt for a degree in basket weaving if private lenders were backing the loans People get private loans for bullshit degrees all of the time. Lenders don't care, because private student loans are non-dischargeable.
- woeirua 7y agoIn a privatized system student loans would be dischargeable under the existing bankruptcy laws, as they were before Congress changed the law.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI think that would be a terrible idea. The gov't would want to make the debt non-dischargeable like they do with student loans. It would be devastating. Maybe we could try to actually tackle things like medical costs so people aren't getting so deeply into debt to begin with.
- notus 7y ago> I think that would be a terrible idea. The gov't would want to make the debt non-dischargeable like they do with student loans. It would be devastating. I fail to see how this is worse than current predatory loan scenarios.
- kaikai 7y agoBecause current predatory loans can be discharged through bankruptcy.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> The gov't would want to make the debt non-dischargeable like they do with student loans That's a strange assertion, considering there are dischargeable government loans, and private student loans cannot be discharged.
- papln 7y agoYou must be too young to remember when loans were dischargeable before the banks got the laws changed.
- papln 7y agoThe solution to bad credit can't be more credit -- people will (and do) just take the credit, waste it, and then seek more credit. A better solution is to allow discharge of private debt so that lenders put more effort into validating debtors. If a creditor want to get money back from a debtor, they need to put the effort in to validate that the debtor has sufficient assets to pay it back and isn't paycheck-to-paycheck buying highly depreciating products. If you need to buy a house or a car on credit, you can. For almost anything else, you don't need credit unless you have an (usually illiquid) asset to back it -- a slowly-depreciating asset like a house or car, or a steady job. If you want a loan for a business, the creditor is on the hook for your default. Perhaps they'll insist on keeping your funds under trustee in escrow so you don't waste your loan on a luxury car and WeWork. And while we're at it, term-limits on secured loans that cannot extend much beyond the depreciation of the loan-enabled purchased. There's no reason that non-dischargable debt has to be arbitrarily easy to obtain.
- snagglegaggle 7y agoNo debt besides student loans is truly undischargeable. Historically it seems like it was pretty easy to avoid paying, for better or wose; unfortunately, now judges are more likely to set up unreasonable payment plans and to hold people in contempt for being unable to meet those plans. That this has not received more attention is troubling -- debtors prisons are illegal, and this is de facto creating a debtors prison. And that is often the only legal test required. That no one who can change the situation cares is indicative of societal rot.
- streblo 7y agoWhy can't the government just regulate the parameters of lending? Isn't that sufficient? Why does the government have to actually get into the business to help solve the problem?
- Litmus2336 7y agoBecause, theoretically, these companies would not be profitable if their interest rates were regulated, and therefore nobody would offer loans. But I don't have statistics on default rate or anything of that sort.
- streblo 7y agoThese companies wouldn't be profitable, but other companies that are founded post-regulation could be. Companies have a remarkable ability to mold their business models around regulation.
- rohit2412 7y agoIt will be ugly, just like the venezuelan government setting prices of food items led to farmers abandoning agriculture.
- sem000 7y agoThere is regulation in many states. The problem is the default rate. Example: An investor issues loans for $100k at $1k each. He charges the legal 30% interest to make $30k profit / return on his money. However, 30-40% of the borrowers default and these are unsecured loans. He makes 0% return. He stops offering these loans and now these people don’t have the access to these credit facilities.
- Kalium 7y ago> I think the government could break even with much more reasonable interest rates This is a big claim to make. Do you have some data to back it up?
- streblo 7y ago> I feel like the government should be offering some type of non predatory debt relief comparable to this. Just want to point out the fact that US government-backed student loans are non-dischargeable through bankruptcy. You will have that albatross around your neck until you pay it off or die. This is the ultimate predatory loan and it's provided by the government.
- driverdan 7y agoThis is the market at work. The reason the rates are so high is that the market put them there. These are high risk borrowers and many will default. Lower interest rates would result in a negative ROI. Tax dollars should not be subsidizing defaulted loans.
- geggam 7y agoWhy should society be bailing out the banks who loan money to folks who cannot afford it then turn around and bail out people who borrow money and cannot afford it ? If you are broke file bankruptcy and reset your life. Quit trying to steal tax dollars
- notus 7y agoIf filing for bankruptcy had no negative consequences I would agree, but that isn't the case. I agree that we shouldn't be bailing out banks, but we should have a safety net to bail out individuals. People go broke for various reasons, but the hallmark of an accomplished society is being able to ensure a decent quality of life for most people. Telling people to accept personal responsibility for everything that happens to them is a huge cop-out. You're basically saying you refuse to consider what scenarios might warrant this because it doesn't fit into your world view.
- geggam 7y agoDisagree, You make the choices for life. Accept personal responsibility.
- mikestew 7y agoI’m going to assume that you’re young with limited life experience, which allows you to think that life is that clear-cut. I’d argue, but experience tells me I’ll have to wait until life decides its your turn to stand in front of the steam roller. A much less charitable interpretation has you making convenient answers so that you can conveniently wash your hands of social responsibility. But, man, I hate think that about anyone, even anonymous internet commenters.
- geggam 7y agoWrong. 5 decades in, started in the trailer park and worked my way up. Had enough life challenges to understand how this stuff works.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoWhat's HN's opinion on 0% balance transfers? Yes, there's usually a 3% fee but... I've been able to borrow about $5k-$12k for a one time 3% fee over 18 months multiple times in a row now. I make sure to always pay the balance back before it is due. Why don't more people who need a cash infusion do this?
- S_A_P 7y agothere is usually an asterisk next to those offers* *well qualified applicants only...
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoI had a feeling this was the case. I didn't realize it because I've been getting them in one degree to another since I was very young (~19-20 years old)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 7y agoThey simply don't qualify. Would you even consider a $3,000 loan at 25%? That's what's going on with these companies.
- ac29 7y ago25% would be a relative bargain - that's better than some people's credit card rates. The screenshot in the article shows a range of 60-225% APR.
- chasd00 7y agoWell keep in mind, to a cash strapped individual that "minimum required payment" line is very attractive. a $3k loan can turn into a decade of "minimum required payments" that sum to well over $3k without even touching the principle owed.
- mindslight 7y agoI'm shocked that an economy based on the median person being in debt is finding new ways to get debt into everybody's hands. This topic is ultimately just a symptom. Focus on the larger economic design (eg rent treadmill) that precludes most everyone from saving a positive amount of wealth, rather than their needing to take on debt for emergencies.
- kovacs 7y agoExactly. Sure, some of the customers of these products are simply mismanaging their finances, a great deal of them are simply not getting enough value for their labor. How do we get to a form of capitalism that works for all people? Not an easy answer for sure.
- papln 7y agoClickbait headline is referring to "online installment loan, a form of debt with much longer maturities but often the same sort of crippling, triple-digit interest rates"
- blhack 7y agoOkay these loans certainly sound like a bad deal, but what are people supposed to do? Say your car breaks and you can’t get to work. For all of us here billing out >$100hr or whatever your local consulting rate is, the answer is some calculus around the cost of losing your job vs the cost of fixing it. But for MOST people, the cost of fixing it is functionally infinite. They literally do not have even a few hundred dollars to, for instance, replace a tire. Yeah, the interest on these is predatory, but then what are these lenders supposed to do? Many of the people getting these loans WILL default on them. Yes it would be great to offer these loans at a reasonable interest rate, but they are unsecured loans. The only collateral is the clients credit score. It’s easy for all of us with our comfy tech jobs to hate on these, but to me that feels like kicking the poor while they are already down. Yeah, they know the loan is bad. They probably don’t have any other options. Instead we should be looking at ways to make it so that giant unpredicted expenses don’t happen at all. That means cheaper transportation options, cheaper access to healthcare or preventitive care, predictive diagnostics, etc. It helps nobody to point out how foolish the poor are.
- philipov 7y ago> Instead we should be looking at ways to make it so that giant unpredicted expenses don’t happen at all. Or maybe fix it from the other end: reduce inequality so fewer people are living paycheck to paycheck and can actually build savings to use for unpredicted expenses.
- blhack 7y agoI’m sorry but this is a ridiculous, unactionable answer that is functionally equivalent to “well we should make things better”. Yes of course we should, HOW? We need more innovative solutions to these problems. I like seeing electric bicycle shares, I like seeing community-based, high density housing with shared kitchens and bathrooms, I like predictive diagnostics and telemedicine (although the FDA is fighting it).
- philipov 7y agoHow about paying people more? That's pretty actionable. Jeff Bezos doesn't need 100 billion dollars. "Just get rid of unexpected expenses" is the one that sounds ridiculous to me.
- mumblemumble 7y agoThis oldie from SNL is never going to stop being relevant: https://vimeo.com/199334296 https://vimeo.com/199334296
- arkw 7y agoI interviewed recently at Fig Loans - they are working to dismantle the predatory payday loan industry. Only in a few states at the moment, but doing great things IMO
- ac29 7y agoThis is exactly the sort of company the article is about - the APR on their homepage is 190%. Maybe that's better than payday loans, but its still predatory and unscrupulous.
- greenshackle2 7y agoI'm torn on this, I don't know what the break-even rate is on such a loan, but it must be quite high, because the default risk is high. Let's say 150% APR is exactly the break-even rate for this kind of loans to high-risk borrowers, would you say a company writing 150% APR loans is predatory? Obviously it is an atrocious interest rate. But what is the alternative? Unless the government or non-profits step in the make loans at a loss (or hey, direct cash transfers) to the poor, the alternative is no access to credit at all, which is strictly worse. This smells of The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics to me: "The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics says that when you observe or interact with a problem in any way, you can be blamed for it. At the very least, you are to blame for not doing more. Even if you don’t make the problem worse, even if you make it slightly better, the ethical burden of the problem falls on you as soon as you observe it. In particular, if you interact with a problem and benefit from it, you are a complete monster." https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethics/ https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-eth...
- apta 7y ago> they are working to dismantle the predatory payday loan industry. Any interest on a loan is, by definition, predatory. How are they working on addressing this issue?
- thrower123 7y agoThis seemed to be a very vague article. I'm assuming that people that take advantage of these loans must have quite bad credit, or otherwise they'd be going the LendingTree/LendingClub option, where you can usually get medium term personal loans up to about $20k at under 10% interest?
- close04 7y agoFor anyone who can't read the original: https://outline.com/WHPVDu https://outline.com/WHPVDu
- majos 7y agoNot an expert at all in this area, but if people are interested in statistics for people's financial habits, the Federal Reserve's most recent "Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households" [1] is useful. It's a survey of about 10,000 people and, as far as I can tell, is the source for many claims like "40% of American adults cannot meet an unexpected $400 expense". That statistic in particular is consistent for the past few years. There are also many other interesting statistics: * 17% of adults are not able to pay all of their current month's bills in full * 20% of adults had major unexpected medical bills in the last year * Among young adults, hispanic people are twice as likely to attend for-profit colleges than white people, and black people are five times as likely * Half of those who attended for-profit schools would change their choice if they could; a quarter of those who attend other schools would Seems like addressing the costs of medical care and education would go a very long way. [1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/2018-report-economic-well-being-us-households-201905.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/2018-repor...
- alecco 7y agoThat’s valid, but financial education is quite bad in US. It shocks the mentality of most people, in particular low income. Many buy $4 coffee, fancy shoes, big TVs, yet they complain about not being able to pay the credit cards. Sorry, I’m foreign, but that’s what most other visitors I’ve met think.
- tempsy 7y agoIs there no money in financial education...? I feel like there's no controversy in suggesting that the state of personal finance in this country is a disaster, even for people who are highly educated (how many tech workers actually understand how their startup options work?) I just wonder what a viable business model would be for quality personal financial education or resources.
- kart23 7y agoA Khan academy for personal finance would be great. Investopedia is a cool resource, but for the financially illiterate, it's pretty tough to understand the wealth of knowledge there.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoThat already exists: https://www.khanacademy.org/college-careers-more/personal-finance https://www.khanacademy.org/college-careers-more/personal-fi...
- cascom 7y agoPeople don’t think in APR for small dollar loans they think in nominal terms. Also - loan origination/servicing costs have a nominal floor - it costs the same to originate/service a $50 loan as a $500 or $5000 one, necessitating what would appear to be a abnormally large interest rates.
- 0000011111 7y agoIf the business model is to use an internet app to run a payday loan operation targeting low-income poor credit borrowers it is unethical in my option. It is the dark side of the internet. We need to work to build communities where people are not as vulnerable to this type of scarcity. For more information on this topic see the book: Scarcity: The New Science of Having Less and How It Defines Our Lives