11 ms·
Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance
- dragontamer 7y agoI'm no financial expert, but based on discussions with them years back, it seems like Black-Scholes has all sorts of issues and isn't actually used in practice anyway. Black-Scholes is basically the textbook model taught in schools. But modern finance has more complex models to address its flaws. In particular, Black-Scholes assumes that Call-options and Put-options are symmetrical, but in reality, people value put-options more than call-options. (In laymans terms: protecting against market drops is more valuable than protecting against market upswings).
- ryeights 7y agoAdditionally, Black-Scholes does not account for the possibility of early exercise in American options (versus European options, which it was designed for)
- dragontamer 7y agoMore like Black-Scholes fails to account for dividends, which is the only reason why you'd want to exercise early. Under normal circumstances, a call option is always more valuable than the stock itself. The exception is of course, the dividend. True owners of the stock will receive the dividend, but call option holders will NOT. However, for any stock without a dividend (ex: AMD, Tesla, etc. etc.) American vs European style doesn't seem to matter. Its always better to hold onto the option of buying a stock, rather than being "forced" to buy the stock.
- rabidrat 7y ago> Its always better to hold onto the option of buying a stock Tax laws change that equation significantly.
- omeze 7y agoPeople ~5 years ago were certainly using Black Scholes where I worked, just with a lot of caveats. The volatility smile you describe only really applies to out-of-the-money puts - people trading with black scholes as a signal will look at the at-the-money strikes.
- beezle 7y agoAt the end of the day, excepting edge cases, the spread on most listed equity options absorbs any difference between model pricing.
- bra-ket 7y agoit is used everywhere as the foundation, all the more recent models (stochastic vol/Heston, Local volatility, SABR, SLV, SVI etc) are just incremental extensions and generalization of Black-Scholes
- dragontamer 7y agoAt its core, Black Scholes is a set of "obvious" differential equations. You assume a normal curve. You define "volatility" (the market's uncertainty to the price of something) as Geometric Brownian motion with some standard-deviation / variance, and then perform differential equations on that to determine the "proper price" of an option. After all: Options grow more valuable in times of uncertainty, and grow less valuable when everyone can accurately predict future prices. The part that "brakes" because of negative rates is the "risk free rate", predicting the future value of money. To me, it seems like there are a variety of obvious extensions you can do to fix this problem. You could redefine Black-Scholes to operate on "Real" terms, and then convert everything back into "normal" terms later. ---------- Black Scholes doesn't "fundamentally" require postivie interest rates for the risk-free rate. It was just an assumption that they had in the original model. But as a differential equation, its pretty easy to tweak your assumptions around and fix these issues. But any such tweak means you're no longer working with classic Textbook Black Scholes. Sure, it served as the basis of the theory, but you gotta account for more real-world variables than the original textbook model.
- Xcelerate 7y ago> At its core, Black Scholes is a set of "obvious" differential equations. Interestingly, the Schrodinger equation works about the same way. Just assume a handful of reasonable and "obvious" things about physics, and out pops the equation.
- mcguire 7y agoIsn't Black-Scholes based on a normal distribution? Is that an appropriate probability distribution?
- cm2187 7y agoIt is used for quoting between market participants. People may use more complex models for the underlying pricing and risking, but they will quote option prices in black/black-scholes format as an implied vol.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ptah 7y agoaccording to nicholas Taleb, Black-Scholes was always broken. I tend to believe him based on results achieved by Scholes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management
- grenoire 7y agoThis fact is luckily slowly leaking into higher education of finance, and is preventing hundreds of poor finance students from attempting to reinvent the wheel.
- pfortuny 7y agoAlso, options were priced (and this price agreed upon both parties) long before the formula. So, the formula is just a technical so to say after-the-fact explanation of the pricing. Interesting as a technical tool, but not mind-shattering per se.
- conistonwater 7y agoBut LTCM wasn't based on options trading, its main strategy (the one that failed) was arbitrage of bonds with different maturity dates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management#Fixed_Income_Arbitrage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management#F... That hasn't got much to do with Black-Scholes
- viburnum 7y agoLTCM cracks me up because it should have been obvious that linking a massively liquid market with a not very liquid market was going to be trouble. IIRC when the crisis came it turned out there were only three or four buyers on the tight side, and when they sat on the sidelines it was game over for LCTM.
- mikeyouse 7y agoTaleb's funds aren't any more impressive.. LTCM blew up very publicly but Empirica shut down after many years of losses and Universa isn't exactly a high performer. He's still out there banging the drum about hyperinflation!
- joker3 7y agoBlack Scholes isn't a bad approximation for pricing short term call options that are either in-the-money or not too badly out of it. For anything else, the assumptions that go into it mean that it's wildly inappropriate. It needs to go away, and if this is the final nail in the coffin, then that's a good thing.
- rdm70 7y agoMaybe I agree if by go away you mean don't really use it for pricing derivatives for real. However it's still a very useful intellectual tool to understand how to generate a price for a very simple derivative. As an analogy in high school physics they give you a problem like someone 2 meters tall shoots a gun and the bullet is moving so many meters per second, how far does the bullet go before it hits the ground. You use your formula for gravitational acceleration and figure it out, and Yeah! you get the right answer. But you can't use this formula if you really want to calculate how far the bullet goes. You have to take into account air resistance and then you need differential equations and you probably need to approximate an answer with a PDE solver. That's just the difference between a tool to explore foundational concepts and something that attempts to be actually be useful in the real world...
- loganfrederick 7y agoBefore Black-Scholes gets bashed too hard, people should keep in mind that it's nearly 50 years old. Of course it's going to be outdated and inaccurate (as all models are). It's worth reflecting on what options markets were like before Black-Scholes: a lot smaller and valued through qualitative, "over-the-counter" measures. More like handshake one-off business deals than liquid markets. Regardless of how you feel about options trading or the role of liquidity in financial markets, Black-Scholes was an intellectual achievement and should be remembered as such, even as newer better techniques replace it. To his credit, Ed Thorp also realized this at the same time as Black-Scholes but chose the money-management route and didn't feel the need to publish his strategies as papers for the academic community (and probably giving up the Nobel Prize in Economics). My two favorite books on these people are Perry Mehrling's biography of Black and Ed Thorp's autobiography. Fischer Black: https://www.amazon.com/Fischer-Black-Revolutionary-Idea-Finance/dp/0471457329/ https://www.amazon.com/Fischer-Black-Revolutionary-Idea-Fina... Ed Thorp: https://www.amazon.com/Man-All-Markets-Street-Dealer/dp/0812979907/ https://www.amazon.com/Man-All-Markets-Street-Dealer/dp/0812...
- viburnum 7y agoThere’s an excellent book called “An Engine, Not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets” that lives up to its title.
- camjohnson26 7y agoMyron Scholes was heavily involved in LTCM, a hedge fund whose strategy was to apply statistical models to trading. It was one of the most spectacular business failures of the last few decades, losing $4.5 billion in value. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management
- cheez 7y agoIn their defense, they were fine until they stopped paying attention to risk and correlated positions. So this isn't a knock on the BS model necessarily, but human greed.
- avvt4avaw 7y agoI worked in an investment bank (Barclays Capital) in 2008, and at the time we were already developing models which could handle negative interest rates. The idea that this is somehow a new problem that has "broken the pillars of modern finance" is bizarre.
- rolltiide 7y agoAs the article states, this is more about getting two people to agree on the price of illiquid derivatives So you have your counterparty on the phone or in group chat and you arent using the same formulas in the same way then its difficult to get same pricing
- frausto 7y agoThat's a good way to put it. As my economics professors liked to point out, Black-Scholes was a self-fulfilling prophecy in that the success of the model was determined by the fact that everyone was using it (or some variation of it) to price derivatives. If it had never been published would it still have been as accurate? Who knows. When you dive deep it's easy to think of economics in terms of math and forget the fact that, unlike physics, it is a social field and there is no right and wrong aside from what people agree on.
- alfiedotwtf 7y ago> If it had never been published would it still have been as accurate? Who knows. I think if prices didn’t follow the model, there will be arbitrage opportunities either in the options or the underlying.
- lucozade 7y agoThe vanilla European swaptions market has always quoted wrt the Black model. If you strip out the hyperbole, I think this article is suggesting that they're looking for a cheap and cheerful model that accepts negative forwards. It's somewhat orthogonal to how financial organisations actually fair value their rates volatility. All the market makers had to move away from log normal vols years ago as negative forwards have been around for a long time in other currencies.
- munificent 7y ago> Negative interest rates have quite literally broken one of the pillars of modern finance. ... > Granted, the current state of affairs is more a nuisance than a serious problem. What a poorly written article. Must be a slow financial news day.
- choiway 7y agoMost of the criticisms regarding Black-Scholes that I've seen has to do with the assumption that the probability distribution of future prices is a normal distribution. I didn't think using the risk free to account for the time value of money was that controversial. Have there been suggestions on alternative ways to factor in the time value of money?
- dragontamer 7y ago> I didn't think using the risk free to account for the time value of money was that controversial. Its not "controversial". Its just that with negative rates, you can't take the log(interest rate) anymore, so the math literally breaks. I don't think its a particularly difficult problem to solve, there are probably going to be a bunch of easy extensions to account for negative rates of the modern era.
- choiway 7y agoGotcha, the "short cut" doesn't work any more. edit: Actually took at look at the model. Looks like the issue is with a negative strike or current price, not the risk free rate.
- devchix 7y agoFor people asking why is there even such a thing as negative interest rate (lend $100, get back $99), NPR Planet Money has a good explainer. TL;DR: There's a lot of cash in search of investment. While waiting for opportunity, you could stash it under the mattress. But that's not safe, you'd probably have to buy a safe, hire some guards. Also it's not very liquid. So you pay a bank to hold it for you, put it in their safe, use their transfer system, etc. Tah-dah: negative interest rate. https://www.npr.org/2019/09/20/762748958/episode-940-interest-rates-why-so-negative https://www.npr.org/2019/09/20/762748958/episode-940-interes...
- selimnairb 7y agoIn another sense, doesn’t the existence of long-term negative interest rates suggest that some people/institutions have more money than they can productively use? If so, this would seem to be a pretty clear argument for wealth re-distribution in the name of poverty alleviation and reducing economic inefficiency.
- ISL 7y agoIn a sense, that is precisely what low/negative rates do. If cash-holders' future purchasing power is diminished, it effectively redistributes future purchasing power to those earning money and making things now and in the future.
- imtringued 7y agoIn theory. In reality low income people do not have access to loans and therefore no access to low interest rates.
- Mikeb85 7y ago> In another sense, doesn’t the existence of long-term negative interest rates suggest that some people/institutions have more money than they can productively use? Yes. This is why venture capital is a thing, why it's so easy to get funding for a variety of businesses, and why hedge funds that have very modest returns are popular. > If so, this would seem to be a pretty clear argument for wealth re-distribution in the name of poverty alleviation and reducing economic inefficiency. Inflation is wealth redistribution. By reducing the real value of money, it benefits those who are engaged in economic activity and makes sitting on money a losing proposition. Actual wealth redistribution is a bad idea because it reduces incentives to invest or engage in economic activity and encourages capital flight.
- bwanab 7y agoWhen I first got into finance, it was working for a professor who'd come up with one of, if not the first, reasonably good fixed income option model. Our original implementation allowed for negative interest rates since as he put it, they're not unheard of (this was in the 1980s, so long term interest rates in the US were well over 10% at the time). Everywhere we demo'd the model, practitioners complained that you can't have negative interest rates, so our next iteration got rid of them. Interesting times.
- lordnacho 7y agoI used to trade all the instruments mentioned in the article. It seems a little overblown to me. If you were setting up a new spreadsheet(!) you'd tend to call some counterparties and hear what they thought of how to value things. It's not something they'd keep secret from you, maybe you'd even get a free meal out of it. If course you still have to think for yourself whether what they said makes sense. As for BS model, I think of it as a demo tool. Everyone knows the underlying assumptions are not met, but it still illustrates the so called stylised facts that people in social sciences tend to be fond of.
- twic 7y ago> you'd tend to call some counterparties and hear what they thought of how to value things They might well tell you how they think you should value things ...
- lordnacho 7y agoYes of course. But you have more than one counterparty. And not everything is a thing you're currently considering to trade. You might well use them to calibrate.
- listenallyall 7y agoTraders want deal flow. They also need to trust counter-parties. It really isn't in anyone's interest to have a market participant who mis-prices everything, because they won't be able to both buy and sell (and they will likely soon be out of work). Even pretty dumb traders will quickly realize when it's me, it's not everybody else, whose model is wrong. Now, it's a whole different story if you are not a trader, for example you run a massive pension fund, a university endowment, a government treasury, etc. In that case, the investment bank's attractive salespeople will invite you to golf at a famous country club, a helicopter tour of the city, dinner at the best steakhouse in town, all while lying through their teeth about the value and safety of the financial product you're about to purchase.
- d--b 7y agoThis is an ill-informed vulgarisation article. 1. Black-Scholes was originally designed to describe the price of assets like equity (which tend to move proportionally to their price). So applying to rates was already using it for something it was not meant to. And everybody knew it. A lot of people had developed normal models instead of lognormal models. 2. Black Scholes has been broken for years. Pricing with a volatility smile has been around since the 90s. It's a way bigger hack than what's needed to make black scholes work for rates. 3. If the problem is that R can go below 0, you can just model R+2%, and voila, you get a process that's never negative 4. The negative rates problem dates back to crisis, so of course people have already found ways to make it work. Was it painful? Well it required tweaking the models for sure. But this is neither high-flying math nor out of "business-as-usual" activity.
- JackFr 7y agoJapanese rates have been negative or near zero a number of times over the past 20+ years. This is not a new problem. I know in 2002 Nomura Securities was using some extension of the SABR vol model to address it.
- contravariant 7y agoIt's a bit weird to just throw up your hands just because you need to take a logarithm of a negative number. Plugging ina negative number might cause the solution to become complex but as far as I can tell it should remain a solution of the corresponding differential equation. So either the partial differential equation has no real solutions or the complex part cancels out or can be removed. Some information seems to be missing to truly determine Black Scholes to be broken.
- cm2187 7y agoI wonder how you transfer a complex amount of cash through the banking system...
- williamscales 7y agoPresumably the cash amplitude can be taken as positive.
- contravariant 7y agoWell, to illustrate my point the differential equation f'(x) = 1/x has the solution log(x) for positive x. If you let x become negative then that particular solution ends up becoming complex, however there is still a real solution namely log(-x) (which only differs by a constant). The Black Scholes equation is a tad too complicated to say whether something like that will happen but it's too simple to just conclude everything breaks because of one complex logarithm.
- codesushi42 7y agoWhich financial model actually works in the real world? A lot of what is studied seems to be nonsense from more than 60 years ago, because computers and algorithmic thinking started to come into vogue in economics research. The same can be stated about Markowitz portfolio optimization, a product of hype in the operations research space at the time. It obviously doesn't work because portfolio optimization isn't a simple convex optimization problem in the real world. Yet anyone who studies finance is forced to learn it and other empirically failed bullshit.
- pixelpoet 7y ago> Yet anyone who studies finance is forced to learn it and other empirically failed bullshit. By that measure we'd better stop learning and teaching Newtonian gravity, too.
- codesushi42 7y agoHuh? That's a terrible example, gravity is easily observable here on Earth, hence why the theory was formulated using empirical experiments. Way to find an example that supports my point.
- pixelpoet 7y agoNewtonian gravity is empirically wrong. sigh
- codesushi42 7y agoThat's not the same. It has held up quite well, wouldn't you agree? A lot of financial models have never, ever worked in any sense when put to use in real markets. It is completely different. These are mathematical models predicting the outcome of complex systems, not physical laws that are observable in every day life (even if the intuition can be wrong, only work above the subatomic level etc). There's no "unifying theory" to uncover. A lot of the research is just plain garbage. Otherwise it would be easy to become wealthy through pure academic pursuit, wouldn't you agree? But markets don't work that way, and these theories can be easily tested and fail every time.
- zarro 7y agoI think the argument is funny: We will continue to arbitrarily create money, and create incentives which force us into subpar investments in order to motivate people to take out loans they otherwise wouldn't have, in order to work to create products there wasn't otherwise enough demand for, and in the meantime the middleman will collect the fees for their "work" in managing these "investments". Really kind of reminds me of Rick and Mortys microverse episode.
- apta 7y agoIt's no wonder interest (usury) is banned in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. It's absolutely at the root of the financial problems we're seeing today.
- adeelk93 7y agoUsury is not interest in general, but rather, unreasonably high interest
- PopePompus 7y agoNot in the context of Abrahamic religions.
- dpark 7y agoStrange then that so many millions of Christians and Jews worldwide engage in money lending and borrowing.
- kungtotte 7y agoPeople also use profanity, work on their rest days, drink alcohol, eat pork and shellfish, covet other people's things, and do lots of other things they're not supposed to according to their religion.
- 7y ago
- fancyfredbot 7y agoEven when today's rates are positive the black-76 model doesn't price in the possibility that rates will become be negative in the future. For this reason the model breaks down well before the rate actually becomes negative, and practitioners have had to worry about this for quite some time! Using a shifted lognormal model is a quick fix, as the article mention. Then you just need to pick a shift size...
- samsonradu 7y agoAren't negative interest rates deflationary by design? When an entity already in debt borrows money at negative interest rates the debt will keep shrinking, thus destroying monetary supply.
- Litmus2336 7y agoThe negative interest rates discourages holding money and encourages spending (and investment), which drives inflation. I do not believe negative interest rates destroy money, but I am not an expert. I cannot find any literature to prove or dispute that.
- samsonradu 7y agoYou're right, it does encourage spending and investment. However a part of the money does eventually go into negative interest rate assets (due to regulations etc.) and I believe that shrinks the money supply. Not an expert either.
- imtringued 7y agoYou get $1000. You pay back $950. The monetary supply increased by $50.
- samsonradu 7y agoUhm... no. I borrow $1000 and promise to pay back $1050. Lender now has a $1050 IOU which he will likely put into circulation (borrow against it, trade it etc.). Monetary supply just increased by $50.
- rq1 7y agoI don’t understand why the Black Scholes model is broken for negative interest rates. There is no such assumption about positivity of the interest rate in BS. The CIR model is broken yes because of the square root, and people started to use the old Vasicek model instead. Nothing in the HJM framework forbids negative interest rates neither. Edit: ah they meant model the IR directly with BS like SDE?
- neonate 7y agohttps://outline.com/ZNWx2n https://outline.com/ZNWx2n