5 ms·
“It’s not cost efficient” isn’t a valid reason to discriminate against people, if you ask me. An analogy to your justification: the most cost efficient thing t
by dangus 7y ago
“It’s not cost efficient” isn’t a valid reason to discriminate against people, if you ask me.
An analogy to your justification: the most cost efficient thing to do with hazardous chemicals is to dump them down the drain.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eloff 7y agoWomen software engineers are a much smaller percentage of women than male software engineers are of men. That's pretty obvious to anyone who's ever worked in software.
- dangus 7y agoThe wording was unclear to me at first because it wasn’t explicit. Anyway, I completely changed my comment to more closely go along with the point I want to be making. Regardless, besides being unfair the idea that the policy is economically justified doesn’t seem to be immediately intuitive to me. It seems like you should advertise on subject matter for that kind of thing, e.g. people who watch EEVBlog would get an advertisement for electrical engineering jobs.
- marcosdumay 7y agoThe wonders of target advertising. It's probably not possible to target the readers of CS and EE content, but targeting young men is easy.
- qtplatypus 7y agoHowever that is in part because employers have been historically hesitant to employ them (and clearly if they are not advising to women then the will not be getting employment) this creates a self supporting feedback loop. Part of employment law is to break this loop.
- collyw 7y agoYou say that as if it is fact. Do you have any evidence to support it? I always assumed that it was mainly down to more males taking an interest in the subject. In my career in IT women have always been seen as equals where I have worked. There just aren't many of them.
- concordDance 7y agoI thought there were more women computer programmers than men in the 60s?
- conanbatt 7y ago> “It’s not cost efficient” isn’t a valid reason to discriminate against people, if you ask me. It's literally the perfect reason to do discrimination. It is just like discriminating for having work experience, education, demonstrably market skills, etc.
- dangus 7y agoYou should read the Equal Employment Opportunity Act. None of the things you listed are examples of discrimination in the context of civil rights. The Equal Employment Opportunity Act. Perhaps I should also remind you that this isn’t 4chan.
- conanbatt 7y agoYou are using the legal definition of discrimination, and I am using the economics definition of discrimination.
- chii 7y agoand the courts only care about the legal definition.
- karlakush 7y agoand this isn't a court.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoAnd Voters should care if their elected legislators permit injustices to remain technically legal
- conanbatt 7y agoThe courts only care about what they know
- dangus 7y ago“Officer, you’re just using the legal definition of speeding!”
- dragonwriter 7y ago> “It’s not cost efficient” isn’t a valid reason to discriminate against people, if you ask me. Moreover, it's not, in general, a legal reason in the US to discriminate where a protected class is involved, including, in employment, age over 40 or gender.
- aianus 7y agoWhy is it legal to charge men more for car insurance? It’s definitely more profitable that way, but maybe so is the targeting in the article.
- dangus 7y agoBecause it’s not covered by the Equal Employment Opportunity Act.
- mirimir 7y agoOr by other laws that prohibit discrimination. But of course, there could be laws that prohibit linking vehicle insurance cost to gender. My solution, when I've been married, has been having my wife get insurance, and add me as a driver. But that doesn't matter so much now that I'm older. Edit: I do agree that discrimination by gender is fundamentally unethical.
- bradbeattie 7y agoWhile the user did ask why it's legal, I think it's clear that the question is "why is it /ethical/ to discriminate in this case and not that?". Saying that Law X exists answers the literal question, but not the implied actual question.
- dragonwriter 7y agoBut no one said it is was ethical in the case where it is legal, so if that was the intended question, not only is it phrased wrong but it starts from an unsupported premise, to wit, that people in the discussion believe that one is ethical and the other not.
- blitmap 7y agoI think the parent comment's logic is sound from a financial point of view, but you do a wonderful job of reframing it to bring it back to an equal rights point of view. Women and older workers have just as much right to the same advertised opportunities as others. Sticking a job ad in the mens restroom or within an age-restricted night club when you're looking for accountants seems misguided, but it's easy to see how that wasn't considered.
- eloff 7y agoYes, that's true. It seems to be illegal, so talking about ROI is really beside the point. And it's a pretty hypothetical situation. I'm just trying to think why the companies might have taken this approach apart from outright discrimination.
- eropple 7y agoWhat, in the stretch of American labor history, compels you to think that individual companies need or have ever needed more than "outright discrimination" to do something that is not in their economic best interests? Companies make stupid decisions all the time.
- kamaal 7y ago>>“It’s not cost efficient” isn’t a valid reason to discriminate against people, if you ask me. That is the literal definition of capitalism. The opposite of it, 'Communism' - Every one gets to win the prize. isn't exactly known to work well.