23 ms·
Employer health plans are getting pricier and skimpier
- non-entity 7y agoI was just thinking the other day. Every job I've had has offered health insurance through the state BCBS. Those plans are ways a little over $100/m (for a single worker) Meanwhile, I've had people brag to me about paying $10/ for damn to near full coverage. I'm starting to wonder if BCBS employer plans are just garbage
- maxerickson 7y agoBCBS often just administers the plan that the employer offers. The statistical value of single insurance (Basic ACA) for 1 year is north of $10,000, so $1200 has the employer picking up most of the tab still.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe average health insurance monthly premium for individuals is a couple hundred dollars ($321 in 2017 per https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/23/heres-how-much-the-average-american-spends-on-health-care.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/23/heres-how-much-the-average-a... ; it'll be higher now). $10 or $100/month both mean the employer is chipping in a bunch, they're subsidized via the exchange due to low income, or they've got absolutely garbage coverage that won't actually pay for anything significant. This is why the linkage to employers for coverage is so insidious - it hides the true cost of the system in lowered salaries. People look at an unsubsidized exchange plan like mine, with its $2,144/month premiums, and go "holy shit, I only pay $10/month for mine at work, that's horrible!"
- lojack 7y agoI was just looking up individual insurance rates the other day. You can probably find health insurance for $321/mo, and really don't cover all that much outside of catastrophic problems. If you want decent coverage you're looking at $600-$1000+/mo.
- vkou 7y agoMy wife just took a job at a place that has a 'good' health insurance plan. If she opted into it, her contribution would be ~$300/month, her employer's contribution would be $900/month. If she wanted to cover me with it, her contribution would be $1,500/month, and her employer's would be $900/month. Unsurprisingly, we did not take advantage of this, and she remains on my insurance (Since my employer handles 90% of the premium for both of us.) When we were still dating, I had a good look at what the $300/month health plans provided. Absolutely flippin nothing. Deductibles of $8,000/year, and co-pays of 25%. If all you can afford is a $300/month plan, there's no way in hell you can afford an $8,000/year + 25% medical bill. Meanwhile, Canada provides universal healthcare for $5,200 USD/year/person, with similar health outcomes. Edit: fixed a typo in the employer's contribution.
- jnwatson 7y agoI think you made a typo. $9000 a month is a small company’s entire cost.
- dannypgh 7y agoCoinsurance is paid only until the out of pocket maximum is met, no? I have a plan on the state exchange for around $300/month and an out of pocket max around $8k (I'm 34 years old). I just budget $12k/year for healthcare and move on. This seems reasonable for people who can afford to take the risk of potentially having to pay anywhere from $4-12k/year.
- creaghpatr 7y agoIn a lot of instances, the employers subsidize some or all of the premiums. BCBS has a lot of different plan structures too, depending on the size of the organization or association involved in purchasing the policies.
- british_india 7y agoMy BCBS plan has a $4,000 deductible per insured person per year.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoDoes anyone know the extent to which this is happening faster or slower than the background increase of medical care costs? I know that historically medical care costs have been outpacing inflation. So it's not altogether surprising that, in an unsubsidized environment, the costs to the end-user of that care would also increase, by roughly the same amount.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- badrequest 7y agoThe sooner we can completely divorce healthcare from employment, the better.
- throwaway_law 7y agoI hear this statement all the time...but what does it mean? If employers didn't provide health insurance to employees wouldn't we just wind up with 40% of the insured uninsured? Its not like Corporate America is going to make up the difference and start paying cash to compensate for the lost benefit, at least thats what happened as pensions got stripped away from the workplace. Even if the employer's did make up the cash difference, its not like that will bring pricing down, individuals can't negotiate individual insurance rates, pools of employees can negotiate group rates, so if anything costs would probably go up. How will this help: 1) insured more people; or 2) bring costs down?
- ceejayoz 7y ago> individuals can't negotiate individual insurance rates, pools of employees can negotiate group rates, so if anything costs would probably go up This is why the exchanges exist. They're huge pools of people on a group rate. New York state negotiates with insurers on my behalf, and is additionally able to regulate their premium increases each year.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAnd the nice, healthy white collar lived are locked away in employer group health plans, resulting in fewer insurance companies being able to offer insurance on healthcare.gov, resulting in higher premiums for lives on healthcare.gov. Another advantage for big businesses over small businesses.
- throwaway_law 7y agoWho is in charge of negotiating for this pool? Just as an example between 2017-2018 the average silver plan went up 32% and the average gold plan 20%, who the hell negotiated that? At least with the employer provided insurance the employer is negotiating, and you know who that is and you know they have a self-interest in keeping costs down.
- tempsy 7y agoYep, and what people don't always realize is that because employer health plans get more expensive every year for employers, it negatively impacts wage growth. You are paying for it even if you don't necessarily feel it.
- throwaway_law 7y agoBut the individual policies on the exchange have increased year over year as well, and a lot of those insurers on the exchange went out of business/disappeared after 2-3 years anyway. (from 2017-2018 for example insurance on the exchange increased 32% for silver plans and 20% for Gold plans)
- tempsy 7y agoI don't understand what that has to do my comment. I never mentioned anything about the exchanges. Health insurance policies generally get more expensive year over year for everyone, whether an employer is paying for it or you as an individual.
- throwaway_law 7y agoYou seem to be highlighting employer provided insurance costs increase (which they do), but historically they increase at a lower rate than individual plans (i.e. the alternative).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhat does that have to do with what tempsy wrote?
- throwaway_law 7y agoThe articles is about employer health plans getting more expensive, the comment was about employer health plans getting more expensive...whats the alternative to an employer provided health plan? An individual private plan, I thought it seemed relevant those are increasing in cost too (at a much higher rate).
- KoftaBob 7y agoThis is why I feel the "most Americans like their health insurance" cliche is complete garbage.
- taurath 7y agoNobody does. The real translation is old people don’t want to change doctors.
- qntty 7y agohealth insurance != heath care
- hfern 7y agoIt's worth pointing out that for the vast majority of people doctors != insurance. The payer is not the provider. The refrain of "people like their health insurance" deliberately conflates the two. People like their doctors, not their insurance. Doctors accept multiple insurance companies.
- mieseratte 7y ago> Doctors accept multiple insurance companies. Some do, but not all. One of my providers takes exactly one insurer, which I do not have, so pay out-of-pocket. Luckily most insurance companies allow you to submit receipts to receive credit towards your deductible.
- alistairSH 7y agoAnd to top it off, old people (actual old people) are already using socialized medicine. They aren't using private insurance (or, if they are, it's used to cover coinsurance/deductibles).
- Consultant32452 7y agoI loved my health insurance before Obamacare. I had a nice catastrophic coverage plan that was perfect for me. Now those are illegal.
- vkou 7y agoOf course they are, healthcare costs are growing in an unbounded manner, way ahead of inflation.
- blahyawnblah 7y agoWhy is this? Are there more sick people or just more people?
- Wohlf 7y agoIt's a lot of things, but inefficiencies and needless end of life care are big parts.
- mywittyname 7y agoThe healthcare system has become a symbiotic relationship where providers and insurance companies work together to funnel money from just about every business in the US into their pockets. Hospitals increase staff to justify billing more, then insurance companies use increased costs to justify raising rates. Internally, hospitals and insurance companies are also in a tug of war over their slice of the pie. These conflicts introduce even more people-hours into the treatment of patients, in the form of revenue cycle managers, lawyers, medical coders, etc. Each new layer added to the cost onion of healthcare results in the pie growing, since most insurance providers can only take in some percentage of what is spent. So they need to spend more to make more.
- Nuzzerino 7y agoIncentives. There is no incentive for a doctor that sees a patient to provide a favorable outcome for the patient. Whether the patient stays sick or not, the doctor still gets paid. But here's the kicker: The doctor gets paid even more if the patient has to come back. The payments come from the insurance company. Take this concept to the level of a very large health care network (but non-HMO). Patient has early signs of serious but uncommon condition, goes to doctor. Doctor checks for common, obvious things. Finds non-specific symptoms, refers patient to a specialist or three, and the patient is diagnosed with "Not-My-Problemitis". Disease progresses and the patient is now able to tell the majority of the symptoms are vascular in nature, not muscle or bone as previously thought. More referrals are given. The specialist orders a battery of tests, but they yield false negatives as the symptoms are not occurring at the time of the test, and the patient was not advised that the symptoms needed to be occurring during the test for it to be valid. Patient is again diagnosed with "Not-My-Problemitis" and possibly referred to a research institute, where they'll have quite a long wait time. By this point, the patient may have lost their employment due to the frequent sick time and time off for appointments, and generally being frustrated in general. They can qualify for Medicaid but will have to start the process over again, but much slower as providers have to tread carefully with care received under Medicaid supervision, as if they were treading on thin ice. But oops, the patient has now gone into critical condition and is sent to the ICU, which is statistically likely to be owned by the same health organization that had their hands involved in the patient's earlier care. Due to the patient's hospital visit, regardless of whether the patient survives, a payout of Six or even Seven figures is rewarded. Ka-Ching! Insurance companies are hesitant to deny those kinds of claims now, if they involve life or death. Too much bad PR. Thanks, Michael Moore! Of course, it doesn't work out as well for the hospital if the patient had lost their job and is back on Medicare, as there isn't much profit to be made there, if any. That's just the collateral cost of doing business.
- tastygreenapple 7y agoMaybe things would be better if people paid for their own health care? Having workers pay for their own healthcare along with the healthcare of those who are unwilling/unable to work just means that things are going to be expensive for workers.
- throwawaysea 7y agoThe entire health insurance industry makes ~$25B in profits a year, correct? That doesn't seem overly large considering it is the entire insurance industry.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoIt’s not only profit. They also cause a lot of administrative overhead. For example if doctors had to deal only with one insurer or at least one coding system they wouldn’t need four billing assistants as I have seen. In essence insurance companies do a lot of unnecessary stuff. Their profit is only a small part of that cost.
- pg_bot 7y agoThere are two coding systems (ICD - for diseases, and CPT for procedures) that are mandated to use by medicare/medicaid and all the insurance companies use them as well. Most of them even accept the same forms. They need those billing assistants for other reasons.
- Ididntdothis 7y ago”They need those billing assistants for other reasons.” Whatever it is they do exactly it deals with insurance companies. Germany also has private doctors but they have much smaller staff and dealings with insurance are very straightforward. American insurance companies cause a lot of friction. I don’t know exactly why but they do.
- pg_bot 7y agoInsurance companies are mainly trying to combat fraud. They kick back claims if they are formatted wrong (why did you code an operation on the left knee when the right knee was the problem), or they deem that the work done was improper, unnecessary or does not fit the standard of care. Billing staff also handle accounts receivable and collections. The biggest problem IMO is how we structure payment for health services in the USA. The fee for service model is highly inefficient and disincentivizes preventative care. All of the current proposals for universal healthcare do not address this fundamental problem, and so long as this remains in place we will continue to have the highest costs in the world. (disclosure, I am working to try and solve this problem) If you were to pick countries to emulate, I would pick Singapore, Japan, the Netherlands, and Switzerland instead of Canada and the U.K.
- coldcode 7y agoIn no other country is your healthcare tied to your employment but the US. Germany has had a national healthcare system since around 1880 (after the country was unified, based on what Krupp did for their employees). Why is the US the outlier (also in cost per capita)?
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe US system arose during WWII. Wages were frozen, so health coverage became a perk to attract workers. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-the-us-has-employer-sponsored-health-insurance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-th...
- pkaye 7y agoDuring World War II wages were frozen to focus on the war efforts so employers used ancillary benefits to attract workers. Then things carried on from there. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-the-us-has-employer-sponsored-health-insurance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-th...
- tempsy 7y agoI think another thing about employer-based healthcare that few think about is that if you work for a large company then it is almost certainly self-insured, meaning that you or your employer is paying premiums into a fund that it is managing itself. How crazy is it to think that not only does Apple or Ford or Trader Joe's need to manage it's own business but that it is also hiring actuaries/insurance specialists/consultants etc to manage a complex insurance program for all of its workers? I'm not sure many people that work at large companies realize that their employer knows every diagnosis, procedure, and prescription you've ever picked up, and actively trying to incentivize you to use as little healthcare as possible.
- mieseratte 7y ago> I'm not sure many people that work at large companies realize that their employer knows every diagnosis, procedure, and prescription you've ever picked up, and actively trying to incentivize you to use as little healthcare as possible. I work for such a company, and it's great. I pay about $30 per month for a plan with a tiny deductible ($2,500), and they offer great wellness perks like weekly classes (yoga, kick-boxing) in-office, partner with a local CSA that does a bi-weekly produce truck out in the parking lot. They do encourage folks to get yearly wellness screenings, and basic dental cleanings by increasing your plan by about $2 per week if you don't. This is a single, no dependents rate. I believe the comprehensive plan, with families runs about $70 per month. As it were, the plan is employer funded but we have some type of partnership with a major provider for administration so the employer itself isn't hiring actuaries / specialists / consultants. Perhaps your personal experiences differ here?
- tempsy 7y agoI don’t understand your comment. If the company is large it is likely self-funded, so it is taking on the risk, whether they are doing it in house or hiring a benefits consultant to do it for them. I didn’t say anything about the quality of a self-funded plan, simply just pointing out that a self-funded plans means your relationship with your company is not merely just a worker but you morph into this insurance risk that they now have to actively manage. I am pointing out how strange it is to ask a company to have to do that, which is unlike any other country in the world.
- abstractbarista 7y agoIs it possible that it is due to more people becoming insured that are burdensome on the system? I thought it was pretty expected that as you get more of the unhealthy parts of the population into healthcare, costs will rise for everyone else.
- ceejayoz 7y agoPart of the goal of the individual mandate in Obamacare was to force healthy people to obtain meaningful levels of health insurance to offset that.
- war1025 7y agoMy understanding is that the issue is payment is so divorced at this point from services rendered that there is no pressure to lower costs anywhere. Hospitals pass their costs along to the insurance companies and insurance companies pass those costs along to individuals, and everything that happens in the middle is so convoluted that the average person can't make heads or tails of it to push back.
- notadoc 7y agoThe American health insurance and payment system is a huge mess and is only getting worse.
- _bxg1 7y agoOur healthcare system is so wildly (and increasingly) inefficient, I don't doubt there will be a breaking point when politicians will finally be forced to nationalize it. Let it keep getting worse. Let them see the bed they're making.
- onemoresoop 7y agoThey are covered %100, they won't feel the bad they're making.
- _bxg1 7y agoFortunately, pressure on politicians doesn't come solely from how their policy affects their own lives.
- opportune 7y agoEven at famously generous employers they will try very hard to push you towards high deductible plans by giving you 1-2 thousand extra dollars per year in your HSA. Of course the high deductible plans discourage you from seeking care so it saves your employer peanuts it can add to its war chest in Ireland Some of this probably has its roots in the ACA adding extra taxes onto “Cadillac insurance plans” though which I didn’t even learn about until recently. Yes, apparently you may need to pay extra taxes for extra good insurance
- ng12 7y agoThere are a ton of hidden taxes tacked onto ACA but everyone I know with a marketplace plan hates theirs. I'm really not sure where that money is going.
- cullenking 7y agoI manage a health plan for our smallish business of 19 employees. We offer "pretty good" health insurance, meaning, we pay around $600 per employee per month for health and dental. It gets worse every year. I am considering moving toward a HSA based plan, because upon analysis, it's actually probably better for everyone involved. The max out of pocket per year is the same, but instead of a $1000 deductible you have a $5k deductible. This works for our business (and I am assuming a bunch of other tech businesses) because our employees are generally young and in good health. It's a cheaper plan, the worst case scenario for an employee is the same, and I can give raises for the difference in price, and once every few years someone will need more than a $1k deductible, but the raise from the last couple years greatly exceeds the one time cost. Anyway, just trying to frame my logic here, because I don't consider myself an evil employer trying to skimp on health insurance for my employees (which many I consider friends), but an employer that has to approve health plan changes annually which each increase cost by a considerable amount. If this trend continues, each employee will cost $900 a month within 5 years, and the coverage will be half as good. That's $5k a year per employee that I could put into their salaries, while not screwing anyone over on the worst case scenario.
- opportune 7y ago
- black6 7y agoThe American health insurance system is not insurance--it's a long-term payment plan. Why does insurance need to get billed when I go for a yearly checkup with my doc, or when I pick up some prescription-strength ibuprofen? My auto insurance company doesn't get billed when I get the oil changed in my truck. My homeowners insurance company doesn't get billed when I have to recharge the refrigerant in my heat pump. The insurance companies have taken all the monetary interactions between clinics and patients away, except for the (oftentimes criminal) balance billing that occurs when your claim was denied for some ass-hat reason like "You didn't tell your insurance company whether or not you had other insurance."
- xphilter 7y agoIf you want to blame anyone, blame the RAND institute with poor studies that pump up the hype around high-deductible plans: https://www.rand.org/pubs/technical_reports/TR562z4/analysis-of-high-deductible-health-plans.html https://www.rand.org/pubs/technical_reports/TR562z4/analysis... My last reading of their work was years ago, but at the time the study found that folks will use fewer health resources when on a high deductible plan. However--the study allowed folks to revert to their old insurance (i.e., lower cost insurance) if they got sick. Meaning the study would show those in high-deductible plan would use fewer resources only because the people in that plan who used more resources quit the study.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nickgrosvenor 7y agoThis is absolutely the biggest story in America, and most people aren't talking about it. An entire generation is draining their savings to keep up with premium costs. Not to mention the millions of people locked into careers they would otherwise get out of, if not for the health coverage. This situation is probably going to lead to unbelievable outcomes.
- fennecfoxen 7y ago> ... and most people aren't talking about it. Have you looked at a newspaper since, say, 2007 or so? You will find that many have politics sections which have spent an awful lot of time covering the matter. Other news sources frequently cover it as well.
- cafebabbe 7y agoIt's rather painful to watch from this side of the Atlantic. I guess that I need to acknowledge this is really what most people want in America.
- cschep 7y agoIt isn't what "most" people want. It's what the rich people in power want.
- Someone1234 7y agoI just want to tack on: People being forced to skip simple preventative medicine, potentially building up a ticking time bomb when those conditions become more expensive to treat.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> An entire generation is draining their savings to keep up with premium costs. Knock on wood but, myself and pretty much everybody I know has insurance covered ~75% through our full time employers. I think my portion of my insurance is about... $100/mo? I've never had to use it way/shape/form in the past... 5-10 years. Isn't the truth that the most unhealthy people are what drives health care costs? It'd be interesting to see a visual of who uses their insurance and how much of it they use. Let's not forget that lack of exercise, obesity, and heart disease are rampant in America.
- wpdev_63 7y agoThey really should offer the employee the option to take the benefit in cash instead of getting the health insurance then you could barter with the healthcare centers. The health insurance and healthcare centers(hospitals/clinics) are a cartel and the only way to bring down prices is through competition and that doesn't happen when you give an arbitrary amount of your paycheck to a clandestine insurance agency that has dubious relationships with the hospitals.
- knob 7y agoSharing this idea in order to gather critique. The cost of healthcare in the USA is insane. Could we look for insight into the US Military? Example: This morning, a coworker told me she's going to have an operation on her back. The "cost of the tray" (I have no idea what this is) is $14,000. She has to pay $8,000 up-front two days before the operation, and the remainder will be financed over two years. To me, it's insane to think the US Military pays $14,000 for this same operation in US Veterans' hospitals. Why don't we look into the military to see how they're doing it? Or am I completely off-base here? Thoughts?
- notTyler 7y agoThe insurance companies are for profit corporations who pay politicians so they can keep taking your money when you're healthy and cutting you when you're not. The army is not, as far as I know, a for profit enterprise.
- geggam 7y agoInsurance is socialism for profit
- chooseaname 7y agoThis is the one and true answer with regards to insurance companies.
- kemiller2002 7y agoOh I'm sure the military doesn't pay that much. They get to leverage staff doctors, and negotiated rates. You know like other countries with single payer systems, etc. get. People in the U.S. get screwed, because hospitals are businesses, and they know how much they can charge to make a profit. When a hospital has an entire legal arm just for suing people in court, because they aren't making their payments, you know something is wrong.
- baq 7y agoisn't the problem actually that there is no limit on what they can charge? if i have an accident they won't ask me if i agree on the price, they just charge me while i'm unconscious. i don't get to negotiate prices and the ambulance will take me to the closest hospital, not the cheapest for me.
- afarrell 7y agoIf any of y'all have questions about the process for getting a Tier-2 visa in the UK, I know waaaay more about that than I wish I did. (I'm an American living and paying income taxes in the UK as a software engineer. It is an option.)
- tempguy9999 7y agoGenuine question, what is the link between a tier-2 visa in the UK, and the subject of the story. Thanks.
- idoh 7y agoI was curious too and Googled it. Something about how healthcare in the UK is free, and if you are on that visa then you can get that health care.
- tempguy9999 7y agoReplying to both (am the original questioner, and thanks for the answers) I'm a brit and to be precise, the NHS is free at point of use, not free. Just to be clear. It's also now underfunded, but it's still a system I'll literally fight for.
- flyingfences 7y agoGP is implying that us Americans all want to flee our country for his just for their "perfect" healthcare system.
- afarrell 7y agoWhy would a Brit know anything about the visa system in the UK (unless they were a solicitor)? NHS isn’t perfect. But its cost structure is miles more navigable and we’ve found wait times better.
- patrickmay 7y agoHealthcare is expensive and getting more so because of over reliance on insurance and government imposed restrictions on supply. See "Overcharged" for a detailed summary of the issues: https://www.amazon.com/Overcharged-Americans-Much-Health-Care/dp/1944424768 https://www.amazon.com/Overcharged-Americans-Much-Health-Car...
- 29_29 7y agoIs it possible for an American to move to Switzerland?
- arcticbull 7y agoYou can get permanent residency in Canada within 6 months via Express Entry, unless there's something you're particularly looking for in Switzerland you won't find in Vancouver ;) [1] You can then apply for citizenship after having lived there for 3 years out of the most recent 5. [1] https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/express-entry/works.html https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/se...
- atemerev 7y agoYes, it is possible. Our health insurance is only slightly less expensive, though (and can only be paid with post-tax money). We hold the proud second place in healthcare costs. You’ll also have some issues with opening a bank account here — Swiss banks are not particularly fond of US customers, because of reasons.
- tempguy9999 7y agoNo, Americans have a long and deeply embedded tap root so they die if they are pulled up. Nope, sorry, I'm thinking of turnips. Easy mistake. Yes you can move I guess. Alternatively perhaps you can give some aggro to your representative and make a public noise so this horrible system you appear to have gets fixed. Bonus: you get to stay in your own country and make things better for everyone else there as well.
- baggy_trough 7y agoIf you think health care is expensive now, wait until it's free.
- arcticbull 7y agoThat's weird because in every other OECD country that offers "free" healthcare (as in, single-payer or two-tier with national option) it's dramatically cheaper and has much better outcomes [1]. Reality doesn't line up with your pre-conceived notions. [1] https://www.oecd.org/unitedstates/Health-at-a-Glance-2017-Key-Findings-UNITED-STATES.pdf https://www.oecd.org/unitedstates/Health-at-a-Glance-2017-Ke...
- geddy 7y agoWhat do the obesity rates look like in those countries? You cannot compare a country like Sweden or Finland to the United States when they have completely dissimilar obesity rates, the main driving force behind healthcare costs. A close example to a region with high obesity rates would be the UK and the obesity epidemic has been straining the NHS for years: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/apr/04/obesity-putting-strain-on-nhs-as-weight-related-admissions-rise https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/apr/04/obesity-putt...
- arcticbull 7y agoIf you’re solely using obesity as a comparison point Canada is just slightly behind in obesity but health costs are one half. The NHS while strained costs one third of what the US system costs. You could add the per capita spending of the NHS and Canada together and just barely be in the same league as the US incredibly inefficiency system. Y’all better be hella fat if that’s the justification you’re using.
- solarwind 7y agoThis. Spreading the cost of something that's getting increasingly more expensive across the populace doesn't solve the fundamental factors that are causing that thing to become more expensive in the first place. It also removes the incentives to fix the underlying issues.
- greenonions 7y agoWhat makes health insurance cheaper is a larger pool of people. There is no other mechanism by which costs can be reduced. This is why a single payer system is dramatically cheaper. It ensures complete coverage, reducing the cost of insurance to it's minimum. Furthermore, it leverages the collective bargaining power of all subscribers. There is no substitute for a national health insurance, and the United States slowly bleeds money, time, and health outcomes every day we continue with our current state.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoWhat makes health insurance cheaper is not paying for as many expensive operations per capita. While there are a host of factors making US health insurance expensive, the critical factor since 2008 is laws: laws which require that the insurance cover patients who will have very expensive operations, and do so at the same rates as other patients. The primary advantage of a national health insurance scheme is that it can ration its care for expensive operations, and people won't be able to yell "Greed, greed!" at insurance companies as a scapegoat (ignoring that the profit margins sit at about 4%, which is not exactly the sort of health insurance savings that would fix anything).
- shkkmo 7y agoThere is little evidence to support the "US consumes too much healthcare" narrative and some good evidence that our total healthcare spending is inline with our level of wealth [0]. There is quite a bit of evidence to support the "Prices for equivalent healthcare are significantly higher in the US". [0] https://randomcriticalanalysis.com/2018/11/19/why-everything-you-know-about-healthcare-is-wrong-in-one-million-charts-a-response-to-noah-smith/ https://randomcriticalanalysis.com/2018/11/19/why-everything...
- ksdale 7y agoThat doesn't necessarily follow. Whether or not it gets cheaper or more expensive depends on how likely the new people are to get sick compared to the other people in the pool. Adding a bunch of sick people raises the costs for everyone, adding a bunch of healthy, young people (and making them pay) lowers the costs for everyone else. I agree that at this point, we'd be far better off with a single payer system, but it's certainly not cheaper for everyone.
- weeksie 7y agoInsurance companies need to be expropriated. The entire thing needs a restructure from the ground up, there are too many critical path issues that will keep things expensive if we try to have two systems at once (medicare for all + private) the US should get real medicare, then move to a public/private system where you get base coverage through medicare and pay extra for fancy coverage.
- geggam 7y agoSimply removing insurance and letting the free market adjust would fix the issue. When I was a kid no one worried about hospital bankrupting the family. Now anything larger than a paper cut has the chance to bankrupt most families. Combine that with the accident rate in cars you have an almost certain chance for a large percentage of the US to be bankrupt
- weeksie 7y agoFree markets don't work with the information asymmetries involved in healthcare.
- geggam 7y agoOdd how it worked before insurance took over the healthcare system. Care to share what you see would be different ?
- zanny 7y ago50 years of medical innovation leading to the propagation of procedures, medicines, and equipment costing upwards of tens of millions of dollars to procure and maintain. Nobody is equipped to try to make an informed purchasing decision on if they want the $50k or $100k option to try to save their life while bleeding out of a gurney after getting hit by a car.
- pembrook 7y agoOh yea, we're forgetting about the no insurance glory days of pre-WW1 medicine! If your definition of "worked" is letting everybody die because most of modern medicine hadn't been invented yet, than sure, going back to those days would certainly drive down costs. No need for those expensive CT scan machines anymore, just rub some dirt on it.
- eric_b 7y agoThe problem is that there is not a single reason that healthcare is so expensive. Even if you list the top 15 reasons, you still have to apply the "5 whys" to each of them to find root causes and possible solutions. - Doctor's are paid too much... why? - Well they need to be paid a lot because medical school debt is 250k or more... why? - Medical schools/the AMA are artificially limiting the number of students and residents for their own ends (keeping wages and scarcity high) so they need to charge a lot... why? - I honestly don't know. But the current political climate in the US is incapable of dealing with any kind of multifaceted problem. One thing that will not make healthcare less expensive is "Medicare For All". It will just shift the bill to different people. Now, you can argue it's the morally correct course of action, or those people who will be forced to foot the bill (upper middle class taxpayers) are more capable of doing so, but you cannot credibly claim with a straight face that it will make anything cheaper. In fact, the opposite will occur. (I don't want to hear one thing about negotiating power. That is a debunked line of reasoning. Medicare/Medicaid cover more people than many single payer systems in other countries, and their costs are still outrageous)
- otakucode 7y agoNo reason? Hey, let's assume you're running a business. Only it's a special business. The customers really need your service. And they don't pay for your service. Someone else pays the bill for them. And they are extremely interested in acquiring the absolute top quality possible when using the service. So when you charge $50, but the guy across town charges $500, the customer will fight tooth and nail to get in and use your competitor instead. Call it 'reverse capitalism.' That's insurance-supported medical care in the US. No one wants to go to the cut-rate bargain-basement doctor. And the majority of patients aren't paying their own medical bills. The insurance company is footing that bill. So when their kid gets sick, they're price-shopping in reverse. They only want the premium level, and offering a good deal actively stops people from using the service. And that doesn't even get into the price-fixing that insurance companies engage in, entirely legally, because insurance is determined to be "not commerce" and therefore exempt from all antitrust laws. There is definitely a reason why Americas sub-standard care is so expensive - insurance.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago
- bdcravens 7y agoBecause medicine isn't paid for as a government-provided service. Insurance companies exist to profit - they defer risk. It is not a public service. I have a pre-existing condition, and I have a very mild case of Cystic Fibrosis: my healthcare at market costs about $500k a year. There's a lot of nuance to how much insurance companies actually pay out, etc, but looking at it in a simplified manner, it takes 25 families at $20k in premiums a year (with no claims to pay out) for them to break even on one of me. tl;dr Health insurance is a for profit product, not a public service.
- arcticbull 7y agoTime to change that! :)
- bdcravens 7y agoNo doubt. The tough questions are around where will the sacrifices be made?
- arcticbull 7y agoMarketing, claims denial, billing and executive compensation budgets that together amount for 20% of the expenditure of an average US insurer after they were legally capped to that level.
- bdcravens 7y agoEven eliminating those expenses doesn't really help much. It just changes the numbers in the headlines. $16k in premiums is still tough for most US families.
- arcticbull 7y agoIt’s still $0.6 trillion dollars saved per year, and a solid place to start. There’s all sorts of other places that a socialized system saves of course. This would at least make the US no longer far and away the worlds worst. Bringing everyone under a single umbrella should reduce everyone’s cost of coverage to the per capita cost, $10K (now $8K after savings). Then as a progressive tax system yields costs that scale according to your income the least able to afford it pay much less than that and the most able pay much more. Done and done. This is what the rest of the world does, no new ground is being broken here.
- nkurz 7y agoIt seems like a strange omission for this article not to mention that the reason health insurance is so expensive in the US is that health expenditures are so high. The US spends more than $10,000 per year per person on health care[1], more than any other country. Clearly, on average, premiums clearly must be higher than the amount paid out on behalf of the customer. If you want lower premiums, you somehow need to lower the amount spent on health care. The problem is that, perversely, health insurance companies are incentivized to spend more on health care rather than less. By law, they must spend at least 80% of the money collected as premiums on health care costs[2]. The more they pay, the larger the 20% they are allowed to keep. So if you want to reduce the cost of health insurance in the US, you need to reduce the cost of health care. If you want to reduce the cost of health care, you somehow need to change the incentives so that the big players benefit when the cost of health care goes down rather than up. Failing that, you need to change the system so those big players are no longer in control. [1] https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/health-spending-u-s-compare-countries/ https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/health-... [2] https://www.healthcare.gov/health-care-law-protections/rate-review/ https://www.healthcare.gov/health-care-law-protections/rate-...
- claudeganon 7y agoOnly the latter option is a feasible solution. If you look at countries with mixed systems (like South Africa), a great deal of the cost savings disappear. Tim Faust has a great new book that breaks this down. Also, recommend his interview on the Death Panel podcast. https://www.mhpbooks.com/books/health-justice-now/ https://www.mhpbooks.com/books/health-justice-now/ https://deathpanelpodcast.com/2019/02/02/all-care-for-all-people-w-tim-faust/ https://deathpanelpodcast.com/2019/02/02/all-care-for-all-pe...
- simonsarris 7y agoIs there even a single non-political way that plan buyers can, even in aggregate, do something about this?
- ativzzz 7y agoStop getting sick and having to use the healthcare system. So no, not really, unless we change our living habits as a civilization, but then we get old anyway.
- simonsarris 7y agoWell, I think there's some literal truth to that. Even though I seem weirdly unable to get sick, and I've been to a doctor once in 15 years (just to get a note! required by other insurance), I still have to pay unfunny premiums. So being super healthy still doesn't help. AND YET if everyone in aggregate used less healthcare, I bet it would do more to move the needle than anything a politican plans. Americans are deeply, deeply unhealthy and I wish I could convince them all to eat better. To me it is just wild that so many people complain about non-insurance healthcare costs but do not want to invest in better food/behaviors for themselves.
- kaybe 7y agoI'm a lot less salty because the money I pay is being used to treat everyone who gets sick, including poorer and older relatives and neighbours, and nobody looses their house and life due to healthcare costs. Even if you pay a lot (because you can, with high income) there is a clear benefit for the people around you, not just cooperations. Basically, everyone around you is safe, and that's a good feeling. (Germany)
- zeppelin101 7y agoIf this is the price of living in the land of the free (and the home of the brave), then count me in. Freedom isn't free, folks! /s
- sarcasmOrTears 7y agoOpen the market. Liberalize the selling and buying of healing goods and services. Abolish patents. You can even keep some certification of ability and quality, as long as they're on point (no 6 years training for stitches), specific, free and unlimited in number. Put current psychopats behind the medical industry under death penalty as a warning for future generations. Seems harsh but they killed hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, and all for unjust profit. They deserve it. 80% cancers cured in max 20 years. No more threads on hacker news about people going around like dogs begging for a decent diagnosys. Stem cells for every need at costco, top quality. Problem solved.
- objektif 7y agoI think Warren said it right in the last debate I also have never met anyone who likes their health insurance. Medicare for all is supported by 72% of people according to polls. I think it is time we go for it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- marklyon 7y agoBecause you can’t buy true insurance. You are buying a combination of prepaid healthcare - often including things you don’t need - with some insurance features attached.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- payne92 7y agoI just got my renewal quote: $2,372/month for a family of 4 is going to $2,883/month. That's a ~20% increase, to $34,595 PER YEAR. (And this is while benefits continue to be cut back: $150/month for many prescriptions, etc.) As others have written, there's no single reason. But, I think there's a major unintended structural problem: under US law, insurance companies are required to pay a high percentage (like ~90%) of their premiums out to service providers. The intent is to cut administrative overhead. The effect: it's very hard for an insurance company to invest in technology or administrative improvements. So, the status quo persists. WORSE, the admin overhead is pushed onto the providers, so the overhead cost gets hidden. It's not uncommon for a family medicine general practitioner to have a back office of 3-5 people dealing with billing and insurance paperwork.
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoThat's slightly lower than my family is paying in total taxes in Canada...
- Gibbon1 7y ago> WORSE, the admin overhead is pushed onto the providers, so the overhead cost gets hidden. It's not uncommon for a family medicine general practitioner to have a back office of 3-5 people dealing with billing and insurance paperwork. My old doctor from when I was a baby till he retired had a practice with three to four other doctors. They had a nurse and one of the doctors wives did all the office work, billing, and answering phones. Current doctors practice has two doctors, four nurses, and eight office staff. Old doctors office could would take x-rays and set a simple fracture. Or stitch up a simple cut. New doctor won't do any of that.
- kxrm 7y agoThere aren't many industries where price shopping is as hard as healthcare. When you remove the cost of a good so far from the actual beneficiary costs become incredibly hard to control. Not many here will remember when the insurance markets started in the US, but the original deal was that people pool their resources and get a discount vs street rates. However now that everyone is pooled, what possible metric can you use to determine if you are actually getting a good deal? Sure, we hear stories of outrageous bills that are sent to patients that their health insurance "covers". However, the reality is the insurance company expects a discount which has caused an opposite effect to uninsured patients. Costs go up so that the "deal" the insurance company gets looks good. All the stories about $20 pill of Advil, is all pointing to the leverage hospitals and doctors used to fight cost cutting at insurance providers. I think there are only two ways to resolve this at this point. Build a free market solution where price transparency is required and make it easier to shop for non-emergency care, while the government continues to cover emergency visits or full single payer healthcare with the government footing the bill. Based on the moral logic that many U.S. citizens see healthcare and life savings services as fundamental right, I think we inevitably will need a single payer system in the US. I know the desire is to see something federally mandated but I am quite surprised that not one state has taken up the idea of single payer and made it a system available to all residence who prove they have resided in their state at least X days. I'd like to see the different solutions presented in each state and let the state with the best healthcare solution win and eventually become federal.
- throwawaysea 7y agoHow much of this problem goes away if price transparency is required by regulation?
- dang 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21074455 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21074455 is a related article, whose thread we merged into this one.
- glitcher 7y agoThis is the first year I have had to really utilize my healthcare coverage to its fullest due to a cancer diagnosis in my family. I work at a very small company doing its best to provide a decent healthcare plan, but with our numbers we have very high monthly premiums plus a high out-of-pocket maximum for me to reach (which will now likely happen every year). I can't help but wonder if I am paying WAY more with my current healthcare plan than if I didn't have any insurance at all and negotiated the "uninsured" price per each service myself.
- d1zzy 7y agoI would love if everyone that seems to be in support of a single player system would make a mental note right now that they were in support of it, and then years later after the US moves to such a system (seems pretty likely?) they review how much it helped. I grew up in a single payer system and I'm theoretically in support of it for the many reasons people already listed in the comments (larger negotiation position, spreading the risk to more people, because it's humane, because it removes an incentive to stay in the wrong job, etc). But while I agree with those arguments I also have a strong conviction that if such a system were to be adopted in the US, it will NOT result in better care and more efficient and overall reduce the costs in the system. Not without many other changes in other laws and even cultural changes. Just because something works in Germany for example it doesn't mean it will work in the US, there are different demographics, different mentality, different service expectations, different tax system and a largely different legal and law system. Not to mention we were just discussing a few days back about the increasing national debt and this needs to be done without increasing the deficit.
- cheschire 7y agoAfter a late night out, a man in an English town walks up to a traffic crossing at 2 AM. After waiting a couple minutes for the cross walk light to turn green, he looks both ways and notices no cars are coming. He turns to the man next to him and asks "So, you're German too?" I feel like this simple joke highlights your point about some distinct cultural differences that allow a system to work in Germany that would utterly fail in America.
- GordonS 7y agoI'm in the UK, and have unfortunately had all too much experience of the health care system here. My view is that it's optimised for the majority, and for the "easy" things. For example, all the NHS endocrinologists I've seen have only really known about diabetes, the dieticians I've seen only really know about weight loss, the pain specialists I've seen have a narrow and fixed list of mess they prescribe, and the neurologists I've seen only really knew about... well, not much TBH. I can only guess it's because they're over-stretched and simply don't have time, but it's also been my experience that consultant's knowledge is way behind the times; almost like they haven't read a paper since they left medical school. Oh, and waiting list times are often ridiculous. The NHS fails many, but I know helps far more than it fails, and if you have the money you have the option of private medical insurance or self-funding private medical care. I'd still take our "sort of works for most people" system over that of the USA any day.
- nof1 7y agoCadillac plans getting taxed?
- comnetxr 7y agoImagine if grocery stores forced us to choose one of a few dozen grocery "insurance" memberships to buy groceries, and negotiated directly with the insurers. No prices are labeled in store, they just detect whatever you take and send you a bill at the end of the month. (Differing brands of the same food product are not available in store of course.) Individuals are charged 3-100x more per product than negotiated rates, but can't find out until afterwards. Grocery "insurance" would then become a necessity. People would trade away disproportionate amounts of their salary to get good grocery benefits from their employers, i.e. to not get price-gouged by virtue of being an individual on the market. Stores would run discount programs for the very poor, which they could point to when people get outraged (as drug companies do now.) When politicians would threaten the system, grocery stores would fund ads about the "long lines" and limited food availability that would occur. Instead laws would get passed reinforcing the system by making sure everyone gets grocery insurance, as its a necessity (and it would _be_ a necessity). I'm not saying that health care _could_ be exactly like grocery stores, with many alternatives, transparent pricing, and customers making the final decisions, but that it would have to be much _more_ like grocery stores to call it a free market. What we are working with now is just a system of pricing cartels supported by fear and lobbying. It needs to go.
- pmart123 7y agoThis isn't a bad analogy actually.
- plughs 7y agoThen imagine that there are some people who can't afford the food they need in the grocery store and are going to die. Alternatives and transparent pricing isn't going to make brain surgery affordable to the average consumer.
- kbutler 7y agoThere are people who can't afford groceries now - we don't fund that by having the government pay for all groceries for everyone.
- purplezooey 7y agoStop voting up all these people that don't want to fix it. It's that simple. Just stop it.
- bluedino 7y agoWhere I work (in the USA), we have an employer-paid plan. There are no weekly premiums paid by the employees. There's a minimal deductible, around $500-1500 maximum per year. The employer gets the bills, they pay them. They belong to a cooperative and get negotiated rates, they have a provider network and everything. Why isn't this more common?
- CyanLite2 7y agoIt's the supply, stupid. Congress limits the number of medical school students, thus limiting the supply of doctors. You see all kinds of programs to introduce more STEM or coding camps into public schools. But you won't see schools encourage more doctors. Why? Because of special interest groups.
- arbuge 7y agoI see alot of the proposed solutions to the US healthcare system boil down to some form of "Medicare for all". I think a single payer system would be great and I am all for it. That said, I doubt it would solve all the problems in the US healthcare system at this point. It seems to me the biggest one is that providers, i.e. doctors, hospitals and drug companies all bill way too much. I think it is just politically less palatable though to go after doctors than after a big anonymous insurance company. I do remember when I had an appendix operation a few years ago and was billed $50,000 for it, including some gems such as $4,400/night just for the hospital room and $50 for 2 tylenol that the Walgreens down the road would sell you for $5 a 24-pack. I know several doctor acquaintances making >$1m and even $2m a year - I know they get together regularly where they actually discuss techniques to bill their patients the most money. One dermatologist discovered that removing 2 skin lesions on the same day was a bad idea - he got paid about 50% less for the 2nd one that way. Sending the patient home and telling him to come back next week for the 2nd one would however double the bill. So that's what he does! More patient inconvenience and added expense - but who cares?
- grecy 7y agoEverything in American society is done the way it is done because it's making someone very, very rich. Healthcare. Education. Defence. Incarceration. Taxes. Bank Transfers. Telco. Roads. Infrastructure. Patient convenience, Overall society happiness - whatever you want to talk about. It's a money machine. And the money is more important than the people.
- aianus 7y agoThis is the real problem right here. I live in Canada and the government pays for healthcare but (or maybe 'therefore') the providers do all sorts of sleazy things to get more money like schedule separate billable in-person appointments for an STD test and the reading of the negative result of said test.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoThe U.S. is supposed to be immune to this in principal due to the nature of states being test beds of policy. The only reason this is happening in all states is because of federal policy that has destroyed the ability of states to experiment in this area. When you ask for zero risk, you are asking for infinite cost.
- patientplatypus 7y agoSo many healthcare deniers in this thread. This is, what, the second or third presidential election we've had where the central debate is about the skyrocketing cost of healthcare? Government healthcare has been shown to work in multiple other countries with lower costs, but I guess we can't let facts get in the way of HURF DURF SOCIALBISM HURF DURF. If only your local MD could cure criminal stupidity.
- camhenlin 7y agoDefinitely feeling this during my company's health insurance renewal this year. I used to think that I had it pretty alright, but over the past few years, things have gotten worse and worse. This year, for our "gold" plan, which was sold as the equivalent of the previous year's "gold" plan, our insurance provider increased our monthly cost by approx $120/mo, and increased our deductible by $5,000, up to $15,000. I used to be against single payer, but now I'm rooting for any politician that thinks they can pull it off. I'm willing to pay a bit more tax in exchange for no longer having the "best" health insurance plan that I can afford that, quite frankly, I am terrified to use. Health care costs in this country are completely out of control. We need to have the system burned down and rebooted.
- GrayTextIsTruth 7y agoWhere's the regulation? I'm upset that the democratic party has been increasingly more focused on social issues than worker issues in the last decade. Once neither political party cares about the working man then you'll start to see unregulated capitalism like whats happening with healthcare/insurance costs. The republicans are starting to care more (or at least pay lip service) for the working person but neither party is fully committed.
- tylerl 7y agoAnd here I was expecting that an environment that suppresses price information and and eliminates competitive pressure would just get cheaper and better over time. Silly me.
- ckorhonen 7y agoI thought it was fairly common among tech companies to provide 100% paid health, dental, vision for the employee and dependents? (Current company does, and I’ve had this at previous jobs also)
- GoodJokes 7y agoITT: people who can’t accept that Medicare for All is the only answer. I am sorry it isn’t some complicated problem to wonk over. Healthcare is a human right. Give it to everyone and lay for it through taxes.
- jswizzy 7y agoWe have politicians now saying they want to ban private health insurance.
- DocTomoe 7y agoHm, 7100 USD for a single person seems pretty affordable. Sounds to me like the US healthcare system is a lot more affordable than they made us believe. In Germany, with my income level, I pay about 17000 EUR (roughly 18600 USD) per year (of which my employer pays 50%).