18 ms·
* watch lists * red flag laws * no fly lists All well intentioned. All ripe for abuse. All unconstitutional. All rights require due process before they can b
by exabrial 7y ago
* watch lists
* red flag laws
* no fly lists
All well intentioned. All ripe for abuse. All unconstitutional. All rights require due process before they can be be removed.
- olliej 7y agoRight? especially given their tendency to also be implemented in the most braindead ways imaginable :-/
- devoply 7y agoI see nothing wrong with denying anyone guns for a limited period of time because their state of mind is in question. I don't see who is losing out when this happens.
- voldacar 7y agoTheir state of mind as determined how and by whom though? This just makes it easier for whoever happens to be in power to deny rights to [disliked or marginalized group] Also the connection between gun violence and mental health is extremely tenuous, and I would add that firearm homicides in the states are at a multi-decade low right now, though the media would have people believe otherwise
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- h0h0h0h0111 7y ago> I would add that firearm homicides in the states are at a multi-decade low right now Have you a good source for that? I seem to find lots of unclear sources. I found a source that they are down from their peak in 1993 (this source was 2013: https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2013/05/07/gun-homicide-rate-down-49-since-1993-peak-public-unaware/ https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2013/05/07/gun-homicide-rate...), but that the last 10 years has been a climb back up (https://edition.cnn.com/2018/12/13/health/gun-deaths-highest-40-years-cdc/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2018/12/13/health/gun-deaths-highest... which I sourced from wikipedia, and granted is overall deaths rather than just homicides)
- voldacar 7y agoYeah my source was the same dataset from Pew.
- pnw_hazor 7y agoA high percentage of ex parte temporary protection/restraining orders are later found to be unwarranted when the restrained party has their chance to argue against the order. Also, lazy family law attorneys often include requests for protection orders as a matter of course in divorce filings. These often have similar firearm restrictions as so-called red flag laws.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMy country has a history of institutionalizing dissidents with a reference to their mental health. I am not based in the US but I would be heavily against restricting any rights on that basis.
- vorticalbox 7y agoBecause you have the right to due process, wh9ch you dont get when being but on the list. And sure in some cases it works but if you have no way to fight the claims, there is nothing stopping it being abused.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI always wonder what due process means in a country where most people can't afford a $400 emergency.
- WalterBright 7y agoAll too often, officially labeling people one doesn't like as "crazy", "unbalanced", etc. has been used to marginalize/destroy them. I don't want crazy people to have guns, either, but I worry about the path we go down here because it's very, very difficult to objectively find the line between crazy and sane. (Historical examples of such abuse include people having the wrong religion, the wrong sexual orientation, and the wrong political beliefs.)
- droithomme 7y ago> I don't want crazy people to have guns I realize that's a common position, but it strikes me as strange. It seems to assume that crazy people are the ones committing violent crimes. If that was actually the case though we would have huge numbers of mass murders and killings resolved with the defendant being declared not guilty by reason of insanity. That's not the case though, a finding of not guilty by reason of insanity is an extremely rare situation, almost unheard of in the court system. The reality is that overwhelmingly it is not the crazy but the sane who commit the violence and the mass murders. It makes more sense, based on not guilty by insanity statistics, to allow crazy people to have guns, and disallow the sane from having them.
- krapp 7y agoIt's a mistake to assume that the legal definition of insanity used to determine whether a defendant can stand trial is the only one relevant to conversation. Someone who commits mass murder can be legally sane if they are cognizant of the concept of right and wrong, are not severely mentally handicapped, are capable of understanding and responding to questions, etc. Yet I doubt anyone would consider a person capable of shooting up a synagogue to be sane. I don't think it would be "strange" to consider that someone with suicidal thoughts or someone in the heat of passion should be trusted with a firearm simply because they can also sign their own name.
- droithomme 7y agoWell the discussion was about "crazy" people, people who are not just colloquially crazy (ie Bob is crazy if he thinks we can get this fix done by the weekend) but clinically insane. > someone with suicidal thoughts I don't think someone with suicidal thoughts is crazy. In fact I've never heard of anyone that doesn't have suicidal thoughts at some point in their life. That's a normal part of human existence. Different from an attempted suicide though. And someone attempting suicide is also not insane simply because of that. > or someone in the heat of passion That doesn't sound like insanity to me either. I don't even know how something like that could be evaluated. How would a gun seller know someone is in the "heat of passion"? The phrasing suggests a temporary emotional state of some kind. Perhaps the idea is if they are ranting and screaming at the gun seller and claiming they are going to use the gun to commit a mass shooting. And in that case gun sellers don't sell guns. Someone who in this heat of passion who intends to commit violence presumably is going to act normal while buying the gun. Not insanity, not something that can be determined at point of sale. > I doubt anyone would consider a person capable of shooting up a synagogue to be sane Antisemitism is pretty common among those known to be sane. No physician would diagnose madness simply based on antisemitic beliefs. There have been groups in history that mass murdered Jews, and other groups, who were the predominant people and majority of their society. They were not insane in the general case so it's not correct that someone capable of committing atrocities, including genocide, is not sane. Is a previous diagnoses of madness by a qualified medical professional using accepted standards of practice a common or even not-infrequent attribute of mass shooters and murders? Not that I can see. So we're back to someone not known to be insane - a sane person - doing this crime and the label only being applied after the fact. Again, I propose that the insane are more responsible gun owners than the sane because so few murder convictions involve those actually determined at any point to be insane by anyone qualified to make such a determination. It's easy to say killers are crazy. How does that help prevent crime? It is counterproductive in fact because it suggests that restricting civil and constitutional rights of people with diagnosed mental illnesses (about 1/5 the US population is on psychiatric drugs which require a diagnosis to be prescribed) is a solution when this group is not in fact the group that is committing these crimes and therefore there is no reasonable premise for restricting said rights.
- mikekchar 7y agoPersonally I don't see anything wrong with denying people guns. <- that's a full stop ;-) However in the US it is your constitutional right to bear arms. This has been widely (virtually universally in the US) regarded to mean that it is your right to not be denied a gun (without due process). Questioning someone's state of mind is not due process. It really doesn't matter if we are talking about guns or we are talking about hamsters: if you have a right enshrined by your constitution it's pretty darn important that you don't have that right stripped away simply because someone levels an accusation at you. It would be pretty weird to have a right to bear hamsters...
- DoctorOetker 7y agofair enough, I still think it is good to deny a person a gun, especially when theres red flags going off, but I agree that there should be an appeals process. I guess the reason there isn't (if there isn't, what do I know) is because authorities do not want suspicious people to find out why they are suspicious... but that should mean either nobody gets the right to own a gun, or everyone, ... unless authorities do disclose why some person should be denied a gun...
- maxwell 7y agoWho decides who should take away the guns, and how do you prevent them abusing that power?
- wool_gather 7y agoWe already have a fairly robust* process for deciding that someone's fundamental day-to-day freedom should be taken away -- i.e., for deciding to put them in prison. Is there any inherent reason we couldn't have a similar process for gun ownership? *Not flawless, of course, but what is?
- maxwell 7y agoIf you're talking about the U.S. prison-industrial system, you answered your own question. More people are imprisoned in the United States than were in the Soviet gulags or Nazi Germany. More black people are in the prison/parole system than were enslaved before the passage of the 13th Amendment.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoAny sufficient reason to render them helpless is an equally good reason to lock them up. Both are dehumanizing.
- stevenicr 7y agoI occasionally consider how this could be used with the other things in the bill of rights. A couple people swear that person C has questionable state of mind and their free speech is taken - social accounts frozen, ability to address city council, publish things, use the mail.. do this 6 weeks before an election or council votes for example. Before an IPO? I believe that almost half of those on fbk would get almost half of people kicked, and vice versa.. If search and seizure rights could be suspended groups could go door to door finding something to remove entire populations from the voting block. just a couple of people saying they are concerned, what things could happen with the other rights? How groups in power could use these things is an interesting consideration.
- Lazare 7y agoDo you see a problem with denying someone the ability to vote in an election, or to petition the government, or to have an abortion, or to be free of unreasonable searches, for a limited period of time because their state of mind is in question? All of those examples are clearly terrible, right? If merely "questioning" someone's state of mind is enough to strip a fundamental right, then a bad actor could trivially strip that right from people when they need it most. I suspect what you're getting at is that you disagree with gun ownership being treated as an important right like "not being thrown in prison for no reason" or "being able to criticise the government" or "voting", but given that it is a protected right in the US, it's nonsense to suggest that a right should not be protected, or that merely having a right temporarily removed is not a significant infringement.
- cr0sh 7y agoWe are having mass shootings at a minimum of one a month. Ordinary person-on-person gun violence happens daily. Ideally, neither of these would be regular occurrences, but they are. Are we to just throw our hands up in the air and say "oh well"? Would you still think that if you were among those shot, as you lay there bleeding to death? Let me tell you this - I'm politically liberal, and I support 2nd Amendment rights. Reading the various arguments presented in this article's thread, I agree with many of the 2nd Amendment viewpoints addressed about the nuances and such of the right. Even so, I feel that something needs to be done to get our current out-of-control situation under control. The problem is, I'm not sure that circle can be squared, so to speak. The consensus seems to be that if you want an intact 2nd Amendment, then you have to be willing to be among the dead victims in a shooting. I'm not sure that is what the Framers intended the 2nd Amendment to be about. In fact - just thinking about the wording of the 2nd Amendment right now - isn't it more focused on the right of the people to keep and bear arms, for the protection of country (or State?), being part of the militia - against internal or external threats to it? That is, again thinking about it, it doesn't seem to indicate that such people are free to carry or use their weapons at just any time they wanted to, but for when there was a perceived threat against the collective, not the individual? Of course, they would need to always have access to their weapon, so they should be able to carry it, in case that threat arrives when they are away from home or something... This is more a exercise in reading the wording of that particular amendment - the nuances of the words, comma placement, etc. Maybe my above "re-interpretation" is not compatible; I know it certainly isn't the interpretation of the courts today. It feels like I want to have my cake and eat it, too. I don't want to be the victim, or my loved ones to be victims, of potential future random gun violence. At the same time, I want to keep the 2nd Amendment intact. For me that would mean the ability to hunt, the ability to shoot predators or varmints on my land, the ability to protect myself and my fellow citizens if needed, the ability to practice (ideally in a controlled range), and the ability to own the guns I want and keep them in a safe manner, with proper training. Is it possible for both to be accomodated? I certainly hope it can - but maybe I'm just nursing along a fantasy...
- pmiller2 7y agoOne of these things is very much not like the others. Red flag laws have been associated with huge reductions in gun-related suicides. The confiscation orders are also only temporary. You are being disingenuous lumping them in with terror watch lists and no fly lists that provide no due process or way to get off them, all in exchange for little to no benefit.
- deogeo 7y ago> Red flag laws have been associated with huge reductions in gun-related suicides. I upvoted your comment, because you implicitly raise a very popular, and I believe very dangerous point: That results justify taking away rights. Dangerous, because the 2nd amendment is not the only one that can be sacrificed for safety.
- mantap 7y agoThe 2nd amendment has become an absurd right because due to technological advancement it must necessarily be severely limited for the good of society - you can't carry an RPG or a machine gun or most kinds of arms that have been invented subsequently to it's introduction. Retaining a right but in a defunct state is itself dangerous as it makes it possible to contemplate broad limitations to other rights.
- tkifnn 7y agoThe significant limitations on the second amendment are not the ones banning new technology. Laws preventing open carry or conceal carry, requiring permits, red flag laws... They all erode the ability of citizens to defend themselves.
- deogeo 7y agoPerhaps. But restricting it must be done carefully, or you will end up with a disarmed populace, against well armed corporate security.
- wlll 7y ago
- paggle 7y agoIn the US, due process is only required for deprivation of life, liberty, or property.
- solotronics 7y agoWhy would a gun not count as property and/or liberty?
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> due process is only required for deprivation of life, liberty, or property This is incorrect. The Fifth Amendment expands that coverage[1] to which the Fourteenth adds the equal protection clause [2]. As a result, the “Supreme Court of the United States interprets the clauses as providing four protections: procedural due process (in civil and criminal proceedings), substantive due process, a prohibition against vague laws, and as the vehicle for the incorporation of the Bill of Rights“ [3]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Text https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Amendment_to_the_Unite... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Text https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteenth_Amendment_to_the_... [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_process https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_process
- solotronics 7y agoEverything seems reasonable to some people when it is applied to someone they don't agree with. Instead think about how a government can and will abuse a law. Taxes in the US were supposed to be temporary to pay for a war. Imagine using red flag laws and no fly lists to totally decimate the opposing political party, doesn't sound so good to give the government these powers. More people are killed with hammers and clubs each year in the US than with guns it just doesn't make the news like high profile gun violence.
- Griffinsauce 7y agoI like how you moved the goalposts. Shifting to the gun debate like that will surely induce a healthy discussion...
- jhayward 7y ago> More people are killed with hammers and clubs each year in the US than with guns This is blatantly false. You appear to be repeating a sound bite from far-right web sites that claims that "more people are killed each year by hammers and fists than by AR-15s". The above statement excludes about 97% of the people killed by guns. Guns kill vastly more people than fists or clubs in the US - the numbers are on the order of > 10,000 killed by guns, < 800 killed by fists and clubs.
- mieseratte 7y agoRather interesting that so much focus is placed upon the AR-15 which kills less than bare hands, year on year. Even better is that some two-thirds of deaths are suicide, yet we consider this categorically the same as homicide for some reason.
- CPLX 7y ago> the AR-15 which kills less than bare hands Right but the AR-15 kills more people each year than the bare hands of people named Robert.
- 7y ago
- nulbyte 7y ago> All unconstitutional You seem to base this on lack of due process, however I've only heard of red flag laws that specifically require due process before a judge. Are there others? If so, it would be useful to distinguish them. Otherwise, the statement is generalization.
- rayiner 7y agoIt’s not clear to me that you can take away someone’s second amendment rights even with due process, just as you couldn’t take away someone's first amendment rights with due process. (You couldn’t, for example, create a “red flag” law that imposed prior restraints on the political speech of specific people, even if it required a signed order from a judge.) Due process is the baseline required to deprive someone of “life, liberty, or property.” If you could take guns away with merely due process, then you wouldn’t need the second amendment, because guns are also property. That right merited it’s own amendment, with additional protections.
- Invictus0 7y agoFelons are not allowed to own guns.
- sverige 7y agoThey aren't felons until they've been found guilty of specific laws in a court of law, which is where the due process occurs.
- Invictus0 7y agoThat's exactly my point: the parent was saying that, even with due process, their guns could not be taken away.
- alistairSH 7y agoSure, but the response above was arguing that due process could NOT be used to limit access to guns. That the 2nd was absolute, or nearly so. Which is poppycock. We already limit access to machine guns. We already have age limits on access (typically 18 for long guns and 21 for handguns). And, as you mentioned, felons are prohibited.
- tyingq 7y agoAnd all subject to high rates of false positives. Also see OFAC, where a simple first/last name match makes it impossible to bank in the US: https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/SDN-List/Pages/fuzzy_logic.aspx https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/sanctions/SDN-List/...
- wil421 7y agoI’ve seen checkboxes on air travel and bank documents specifically for this reason. Check here if you have a name similar to someone well known/infamous. If your name’s Osmama Bin Laden or Charles Manson check here to avoid extra screening.
- cf141q5325 7y agoOne would think that an infamous person would check that box too. The idea seems kind of absurd, either your system knows the difference between Bin Laden and for example a 5 year old kid with the same name or it doesnt.
- noknownsender 7y agoI had that thought as well, but I would think that it would just prompt a quick second look by the TSA (or whoever). They Check the box, then the screen agent takes a closer look, "Hmm, this nine year old indian girl named Charles Manson is probably not the 70+ year old dead man that we were worried about"
- wil421 7y agoI’d imagine the system would even show the wanted person next to the person in front of you. But then again the TSA is probably using an abstraction over an Access DB built by the lowest bidder in the early 2000s.
- tinus_hn 7y agoPerhaps if you check the box the system doesn’t allocate the biggest clown in the circus to your check and you get someone who can reason like, it says Osama but the terrorist Osama is dead. So it must be someone else.
- gumby 7y ago> All well intentioned. You are more sympathetic than I. I considered at the time that the watch list and no fly list(s!) Were conceived in anger. Thanks for giving me a chance to reconsider my assumptions.
- mindslight 7y agoRegardless of the attached feelings, the motivation is the standard authoritarian delusion - a belief that more control will straightforwardly translate to better outcomes, or more commonly prevent bad outcomes. We see it across our society - it's not just the politicians, but the whole mass media cum social media narratives of the government needing to "do something" in response to something bad having happened. In reality society is not a monolithic top-down entity, but rather full of individual actors that each have their own motivations and respond to incentives in their own way. The idea that lawmakers can simply declare something to be a certain way and it will effectively happen that way is a naive fallacy. And unfortunately bad ideas do not fail fast in the modern age due to a surplus of resources that allow them to keep going indefinitely.
- gumby 7y agoStandard delusion or standard excuse? Often with authoritarians cruelty is the whole point. I agree with you that on the broader society side, "something must be done; this is something; thus we must do it" is pretty pervasive.
- mindslight 7y agoNobody views themselves as a bad person. If you want to understand actual motives, it is important to remember this. Your assertion is surely applicable to some sadist cops, but not to the average voter that gets riled up by the political/media establishment.
- jeffdavis 7y agoSame with Extreme Risk Protection Orders, a.k.a. red flag laws. EDIT: looks like red flag laws were already listed by the parent comment. Somehow I must have read right past it.
- jrnichols 7y agoand the same list the Obama administration wanted to use to prevent gun purchases too. It looked like that was a possibility too. glad to see cooler heads prevailed. https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security/discriminatory-profiling/until-no-fly-list-fixed-it-shouldnt-be-used-restrict https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security/discriminatory-p...
- cardiffspaceman 7y agoDue process seems to only affect a specific circumstance. For example if you want to drive around but you are stopped at a checkpoint that is supposed to find inebriated drivers, a court will rule on whether that was an undue restraint of your constitutional rights and if the court goes against you it will not waive the rights of free movement or association entirely.