12 ms·
Microsoft Is Killing ePub Support in Edge Classic
- logfromblammo 7y agoThis makes no sense to me. EPUB is basically HTML in a ZIP container with mandatory included files. If you already have a full-blown web browser, and a ZIP library at hand, naively rendering EPUB pages by unzipping to temp files and tweaking the URI resolver is an easy addition. If you already have a full-blown web browser that already renders EPUB pages better than a lot of EPUB-specific reader programs, removing that support is doing work to reduce functionality.
- sedatk 7y agoIf it isn't used a lot, I'd prefer the budget to go somewhere more useful instead.
- snazz 7y agoThey don’t have to maintain it, they just don’t need to completely get rid of it. That part is baffling.
- WalterGR 7y agoDidn’t Microsoft kind of do that with IE 6? a. How well did that work out? and b. How does the ‘tech community’ view Microsoft for that choice?
- snazz 7y agoAn ePub reader is a little different than an entire browser. They’re already getting rid of Edge Classic at some point anyway; why remove a useful feature before then?
- themacguffinman 7y ago> They don’t have to maintain it Yes they do. Rarely used, unmaintained code is a great way to accrue security vulnerabilities and other bugs.
- icebraining 7y agoSecurity vulnerabilities can only occur when the software bridges two different levels of privilege ("crossing the airtight hatchway", as Raymond Chen puts it). An EPUB reader has no business doing that, it can run completely inside the same restricted environment as any other potentially-malicious website. Other bugs, sure, but since when did presence of bugs prevent anyone - much less Microsoft - from shipping anything? Especially since the whole browser is going away anyway, so there's no long term burden.
- logfromblammo 7y agoThey would still have to maintain it, but they wouldn't need to add features. If they coded it well enough in the first place, that could be one person putting in 8 hours a month on the highest-priority issues in the backlog. EPUB is a container format. It's basically an encapsulated multi-page website with some metadata. The marginal effort for a web browser is unpacking the files with a ZIP library and deciding how going from chapter001.html to chapter002.html works inside the existing UI. If you don't want to think much about the latter, render each page exactly as if it were downloaded from an online website, and use the forward and back buttons to step along the built in reading order. I actually wonder why all web browsers don't support it natively.
- saagarjha 7y ago> “Download an .epub app to keep reading,” a notification in Edge classic reads when you load an EPUB document. “Microsoft Edge will no longer be supporting [sic] e-books that use the .epub file extension. Visit the Microsoft Store to see our recommended .epub apps.” What’s wrong with this? It looks grammatically correct to me…
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 7y ago> What’s wrong with this? This is answered in the next sentence of the article: it’s “support” not “be supporting,” Microsoft. The is using the future continuous when the simple future is more appropriate to the message.
- saagarjha 7y ago“Microsoft Edge will no longer be support e-books that use the .epub file extension” sounds very wrong.
- farresito 7y agoWill no longer support
- pwinnski 7y agoYou misread the suggestion.
- dragonwriter 7y ago“support”, as the author of the article suggests, should replace “be supporting”, not just “supporting”. The simple future is called for, not the future continuous.
- ilikehurdles 7y ago"will no longer be supporting" is completely fine, though.
- superkuh 7y agoI wasn't aware of any browsers having epub support. Additionally, the practice of using browsers as your OS is bad. Native applications are the way to go. Pdf support should also be removed from all browsers.
- rchaud 7y agoEPUB is based on XML if I recall, so needing a third party app to view them seems burdensome.
- klez 7y agoMore like zipped html and some metadata, but yeah, basically it's that simple.
- penagwin 7y ago> Pdf support should also be removed from all browsers. Why? Instead of opening a PDF like any other webpage, or image, or video, etc. Which is instant and doesn't require any mental focus shifting, I should instead download the PDF, and use a PDF viewer instead? For something so ubiquitous it seems kind of silly. Browsers are for browsing and consuming content, if a specific type of content has widespread usage, I see no reason not to include it.
- delfinom 7y agoOne problem is browsers have incomplete PDF implementations. PDFs with 3d models is big in the engineering industry as dumb as it is and Chrome completely fails there and results in numerous less engineering user complaints :/
- jjohansson 7y agoPDFium and PDF.js have only implemented a small subset of the spec. Other features they don’t support include certain image compression formats or colour management. It’s really only suitable for the simplest of PDFs...
- Causality1 7y ago>Aside from the contorted grammar and word usage in the notification—it’s “support” not “be supporting,” Microsoft There's nothing wrong with that grammar; Paul Thurrott's just a douchebag.
- dragonwriter 7y agoThe use of the future continuous when there is no reason not to use the simple future is both awkward and needlessly wordy, though it's more in the class of things (in a programming analogy) you'd catch with a linter than the kind that throws compiler errors.
- Causality1 7y agoIt adheres to convention. "We will no longer be providing complimentary dessert" etc.
- jakear 7y agoI honestly don’t believe anyone would look at the phrase “we will no longer be supporting X” as awkward. The meaning is immediately obvious, and the construct is used frequently. Calling out a trivial style problem like this in a technical review is amateur.
- runxel 7y agoThis was literally the only thing Edge was actually good at... Dammit Microsoft!
- durpleDrank 7y agoNo kidding. I was just thinking about that last night!
- marcosdumay 7y agoIt's a reasonably good PDF reader too. Because of it Windows got nearly as good as Linux on that front.
- nolok 7y agoStill worth it to replace it with Sumatra right after install though in my opinion.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThe biggest thing that was exciting to me was EPUB having native OS support, effectively, via Edge. You could assume an EPUB was readable in Windows without downloading something, just like you can assume for JPGs and TXT files. This feels like a huge step back for the format to lose this.
- sitkack 7y agoI just realized that EPUB is the CHM of the modern world.
- jacobolus 7y agoDoes CHM mean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Compiled_HTML_Help https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Compiled_HTML_Help ?
- sitkack 7y agoExactly. The original html based document format.
- interfixus 7y agoWhich was not a bad format. Even as thorough Linux user with no Windows in sight, I have often used .chm files for handy, offline documentation. PHP docs come to mind, back when PHP was something I occasionally did.
- nolok 7y agoText, markup, arborescence, embedded medias, all in a single file, supported natively by the os and comparable between apps. Before the internet everywhere there is an entire generation of windows software, especially developer tools, where chm was the norm for high quality documentation.
- 7y ago
- duncanawoods 7y agoOh what? That is really bad. Epub support in edge was the one thing I used and was impressed by. The text looked great and it supported very good read-aloud that tracked the words in the text. I was impressed how well it read tricky things like numbers and sub-clauses. If you switched to one of the British accents, crank the speed to 2x and it was a great way to power through some books that might have become a slog. When you begin to tire, switch the gender of the voice and it suddenly becomes more digestible again. I just don't know why MS spends so much time shooting itself in it's feet. So much talent and promising product gets burned for indecipherable reasons.
- mips_avatar 7y agoKilling decent products is the Google way. Now that Microsoft is using chromium maybe the Google way is seeping in.
- nitrogen 7y agoIt used to be that Microsoft was famous for vaporware--product announcements that never materialized, to take the wind out of competitors' sails. Not sure which I like better.
- sebazzz 7y agoMicrosoft is also good in building features that don't work or are unusable in any normal use case. Like Knockout support in Visual Studio: I have never seen it working. I believe SQL Server also has a few features that were until the current versions not really usable.
- jeffk_teh_haxor 7y agoUh huh. You should visit the Building 17 courtyard sometime, it's basically a graveyard for defunct MS products.
- userbinator 7y agoInvasive telemetry and profiting from ads instead of selling software is definitely the "Google way" and it's been taking over MS since at least the beginnings of Windows 10 (remember the forced "free upgrade"?)
- underwater 7y agoMicrosoft have a weird habit of releasing niche or experimental products in a fully fledged form and then not knowing how to make them useful or popular (3D Paint, anyone?) Did they really expect a solid ePub reader to be a significant selling point for the browser?
- dgellow 7y agoIt is for me. Also, the PDF reader, and the “Add notes” feature that allow you to annotate any web page. The support for the Surface Pen is just excellent in Edge.
- worble 7y ago>Did they really expect a solid ePub reader to be a significant selling point for the browser? Well it was the only reason I ever opened Edge, so it kind of worked?
- Endy 7y agoOh, it could do that? I still use Calibre and Sigil. Then again, how can any browser not in some way support ePUB? It's just a bunch of hyperlinked XML files in a container. Rename it to a .ZIP and you're good to go.
- fencepost 7y agoWhile I'm sure that there are some adequate ePub readers for Windows desktops, I find myself doubting that there are many actual good ePub readers. At the very least when I looked from a Windows phone a year or two back there was nothing very good in the Windows App Store. Maybe Microsoft's push towards the Surface family particularly the Surface Go as a tablet means that there will be something worthwhile. At least, that's the dream.
- Shorel 7y agoI use this and I like it: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/freda-epub-ebook-reader/9wzdncrfj43b?activetab=pivot%3Aoverviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/freda-epub-ebook-reader/9w...
- cannonedhamster 7y agoI've found SumatraPDF to be the lowest overhead document browser for Windows. Surface book is actually a really nice piece of kit. I'm surprised the surface laptop came from MS.
- fencepost 7y agoThis is quite late, but maybe useful for later thread viewers. https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/E-book_software#Windows https://wiki.mobileread.com/wiki/E-book_software#Windows
- hackerbrother 7y agoVery annoying, but I guess makes sense as chromium doesn't support epub and they'd want to keep the different edges consistent. And the old edge will be gone soon anyways.. A natural question is: is edge still going to be the default PDF reader in Windows? And will edge's pdf viewer look just like chrome's
- WorldMaker 7y agoProbably and it does in Dev and Beta builds (which is a disappointment because "Edge Classic" PDF Viewer was better and Chrome's a distinct regression in some disappointing ways).
- hackerbrother 7y agoyeah, you'd think it wouldn't kill them to have whatever you call the opposite of continuous scrolling?
- phjesusthatguy3 7y ago"X browser is killing support for Y format" Well, good. Now we can go back to when browsers handed files off to helper apps that supported the formats in question. I'm all for it.
- srikz 7y agoThey should spin off the old Edge as a reincarnation of Reader from Windows 8. It was a great app and I hoped it would become as versatile as Preview on Mac. It was annoying when I double clicked a EPUB (or PDF) it would open the browser and sometimes all my tabs from last session would open and in most cases just the EPUB would open and I lose the previous browsing session. This needs to be a dedicated app separate from the browser. I hope they have something in the works.
- liability 7y agoDoes windows have anything analogous to quicklook? That's one feature I think Apple did well with.. though it's obnoxious it can no longer be extended to support non-MPEG-LA video formats... I've experimented with using mpv controlled over json IPC as a FOSS substitute to quicklook, which works well for media but not documents...
- filmgirlcw 7y agoBoth QuickLook and Seer do this and both have plugins making it much more akin to the Quick Look circa Leopard and Snow Leopard. QuickLook is more actively maintained but both are very good. [1]: https://pooi.moe/QuickLook/ https://pooi.moe/QuickLook/ [2]: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/seer-pro/9pgvfjbvbzwx?activetab=pivot:overviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/seer-pro/9pgvfjbvbzwx?acti...
- dgellow 7y agoYep, I recently moved to windows 10 for my personal machine and as looking for equivalent to macOS features. QuickLook just work, and has even more options than the version from macOS
- Shorel 7y agoNot from MS but I think this one is great: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/freda-epub-ebook-reader/9wzdncrfj43b?activetab=pivot%3Aoverviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/freda-epub-ebook-reader/9w...
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoI'm very surprised how bad most ePub readers are. You would think that by now picking an ePub reader for the PC would be a no brainer but it seems there are very few good ones. Too bad, the ePub reader is very good. It's the only reason I use Edge.
- Kaiyou 7y agoSame with physical ebook readers, really.
- hollander 7y agoHow is it bad? What is the problem? The only thing that doesn't work properly is displaying PDF because many PDFs are setup bad. And sometimes - in epub - images are too small to display properly. That is something that really can be improved - image display and handling.
- Kaiyou 7y agoNot responsive enough when changing pages. Too much tech crammed in to ramp up the price of something essentially worth $15. Navigation is unintuitive, it's hard to get stuff on the device. Not all formats are supported by all readers and PDF support isn't what it should be. I can't turn pages with either my left or my right hand, no easy switching beween books and if you've got more books on there than the average person, like maybe 70, you're already screwed to find what you want to switch to reading at the moment quickly.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoPDF display is another pain point. We are over 10 years into the Kindel era but it's still a problem to read PDFs on all ebook readers. Why? Why are there no display guidelines so you can read them with ease or at least a way to reformat them so they can be read in an eReader?
- IloveHN84 7y agoThey are starting wrapping up and deprecating Edge classic, as the Chromium one is now in beta
- lenkite 7y agoI really wished they hadn't killed Edge. And I love EPUB in Edge for technical books - you can open several in different tabs and also search within them. The browser is the most natural vehicle for EPUB! Using a third party reader on Windows is going to be a pain.
- anoncake 7y agoIt boggles the mind. Literally everything happens in the browser except reading hypertext documents.
- ZuLuuuuuu 7y agoI think it was a mistake integrating the browser with an Epub reader. Having said that, it was still a very nice and elegantly designed part of Edge. So I would like having it as a stand alone app, but I don't expect MS doing the right thing. They will either kill it completely or rewrite it from scratch with Electron.
- contravariant 7y agoUsing a browser to read an Epub which is effectively just some bundled HTML seems like a very logical thing to do to me.
- totony 7y agoagreed epub is basically a zipped html, so it's sensical to implement it in a browser
- ZuLuuuuuu 7y agoThat is like saying a Zip file manager should also include Epub reader since Epub is basically a zip file. Reading a book and browsing web are fundamentally different activities and need different UX and business logic. Putting book reading capabilities to a browser makes the code base bloated in my opinion.
- ryantriangles 7y agoI have to say I disagree there. "Our program for handling HTML+CSS content should handle HTML+CSS content stored in containers" is a much more reasonable idea than "Our program for opening containers should also handle whatever content is inside those containers." It's a common thing for programs to do. VLC plays videos in zip files and RetroArch plays games in zip files, for example. And I don't think reading a book and browsing the web are fundamentally different activities. They're near-identical. The web was created as a way to access documents consisting of text, images, and links to other points within the current document or to other documents. A book is a document consisting of text, images, and links to other points within the current document (endnotes, footnotes, "see page X") or to other documents (references/citations). The UX and features you'd want for a book reader are the same you'd want for a browser's Reader Mode, as implemented by Edge, Firefox, and Safari. I don't see any difference between reading an ePub file and reading a long article on a website.
- lcnmrn 7y agoCan't they develop an EPUB extension for Chrome (new Edge)?
- WorldMaker 7y agoPossibly, but they likely don't have any incentive to do that and are just going to leave it to third-party devs. Their eBooks store for mobile was the reason they added it to Edge Classic in the first place, and that store has already shut down because no one was using it.
- agluszak 7y agoWhy won't they just open source the reader instead of abandoning it? I would love to have at least one 100% working epub reader on Windows...
- piotrkubisa 7y ago> I would love to have at least one 100% working epub reader on Windows... SumatraPDF is fine to read EPUBs on Windows (also supports PDF, MOBI, FB2, CHM, XPS, DjVu) - it's free, open-source software [0][1]. [0]: https://github.com/sumatrapdfreader/sumatrapdf https://github.com/sumatrapdfreader/sumatrapdf [1]: https://www.sumatrapdfreader.org/free-pdf-reader.html https://www.sumatrapdfreader.org/free-pdf-reader.html
- niceworkbuddy 7y agoThis is really unfortunate. Killing one of the best applications? I mean it's fast, reliable, simple, easy to use, integrated...
- sireat 7y agoBizarre decision. I've done my share of epub wrangling by hand (that is with Sigil). Epubs are basically zipped HTML. How hard would it have been to leave basic support? So now one has to "freeze" Edge to keep epub support. I doubt it is as easy as moving Edge to a different folder. Probably need to mess with regedit as well.
- darekkay 7y agoAfter getting a Windows Tablet, I was looking hard for a good epub/pdf reader with annotations. To my surprise, Edge was by far the best reader out there. However, a few weeks later an update killed the annotations feature - I just couldn't save them anymore. None of the support-provided solutions has worked. I then started using Calibre to convert my epub files into azn3 and open them in the Windows Kindle app, which is also quite nice.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 7y agoanti-competitive purge of features the browser industry is colluding
- dajohnson89 7y agoCan someone explain why one would use ePub, vs pdf? PDF seems way more popular.
- piotrkubisa 7y agoI'd say PDF is all about presentation, while ePub/Mobi is closer to real books that focus on content and legibility. EPubs are perfect for long-lengthy documents, where you can bookmark position to given line of text (not page, so I'd say it's more precise to get back in which paragraph you've finished reading), everything is searchable/copyable/highlightable, formatted into single-column, usually justified, wrapped using hyphenation, easy to change font size, colors (i.e. day/night mode) and there isn't strict paper (canvas) size. Basically, it increases accessibility and focus. While the PDF is just like a ZIP (I think those formats share the same popularity), that consist collection of numbered crisp, anti-aliased PNGs and SVGs, sometimes with an attached metadata. I often hear, there isn't any chance to PDF document look different on other device. However, PDF is just a subset of PostScript (hence the name) and has many versions (standardized as a public document, by ISO, by other parties or just paywalled)[1]. Fortunately, quite old PDF1.5 version has majority of features used by typical document creator, also fact that there aren't many competing implementations and they seem to be up-to-date with PDF2.0 convinced users and developers to use it. That's worth noting, PDF supports reflow [0], but it is far from perfect and I guess many bookworms will refrain from using it at all. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Portable_Document_Format_(PDF) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Portable_Docume... [1]: https://helpx.adobe.com/acrobat/using/reading-pdfs-reflow-accessibility-features.html#reflow_a_pdf https://helpx.adobe.com/acrobat/using/reading-pdfs-reflow-ac...