28 ms·
A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10 seconds (2018)
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoI think a lot of people, then and now, miss the important takeaway here. It's not about Ratner or his products; it's about all the other products that we continue to use and trust every day, because their creators are smart enough to maintain the lie.
- whenchamenia 7y agoMost people on HN just treat it as a cautionary tale, as the implicit lies that underlie most SV companies are piled high and deep. Everyone knows they are standing on a rug, and are anxiously looking around for any pulling.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoYeah, exactly. Whether someone takes this as a lesson for business owners instead of for consumers tells you something about them.
- yummypaint 7y agoAll the guy did was be honest, and its not like he revealed anything people didnt know already. Seems like an emperors new clothes kind of situation.
- cat199 7y agocalling it 'crap' is quite a different thing from saying it is 'affordable' and 'a good value', even if both imply the same thing w/r/t cost:quality vs absolute quality in that product family - one will get you bad press and social stigma, the other will win you fans. it's all about presentation.
- the8472 7y agoseems like a bug in humans, since the material reality underlying those statements is the same.
- ghaff 7y agoThe connotation is a lot different even if the reality can converge. A mass market pen I pickup in an office supply store can probably be reasonably described as affordable and good value. It's not as nice as one of the good pens I keep at home but I don't think it's fair to describe as "crap" in most contexts.
- the8472 7y agoSure, but the statement doesn't change the material aspects of the goods. If it was true then they were crap before, if it was not then they remain in the affordable category afterwards. Then again, jewelry is to a large extent about perception and not their material properties.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoYou can't offend anybody more than by telling them a truth they don't want to hear. If you insult someone with something that is clearly not true, they will brush it off. But tell the truth they don't like and you will be hated more than anyone. This is coming from someone who was frequently hated for saying the truth, because I come from a different culture and hadn't figured out how to navigate human interactions in the west. Especially when it comes to points that are related to people's identity formation (jewelry being a part of that) Or as a favorite song says: When the truth walks away Everybody stays Cause the truth about the world is that crime does pay
- kamaal 7y agoI guess the working class buyers knew they were buying cheap stuff. They just don't want to be humiliated or joked for doing so. Often people buying these women's jewelry are men. A lot of women care more for their men who take time out and care to buy anything for mush more than the price itself. Why humiliate them this way?
- shmerl 7y agoSomeone speaks the truth for once, and they call it "the effect". Reminds an episode it the Water World, where everyone says to Deacon how good his artificial eye looks (they are too scared of him), and only one kid says "it looks like sh*t".
- insickness 7y ago> so why did he do it? This is the most interesting question, which the article doesn't answer.
- mjw1007 7y agoHe'd made the same jokes in speeches several times before, and it had gone down well with the audience. Presumably he just didn't consider the possibility that the press would think it worth making a story out of.
- archgoon 7y agoInteresting; what was difference about this audience? Or was it just a slow news day this time?
- paulpauper 7y agoMy guess is way more ppl were in attendance and he doubled down on the joke
- mixmastamyk 7y agoA large gathering of business leaders with press attending + random chance.
- scandox 7y agoI read an article (in the 90s) that stated it was a slow news day. It was his sixth time making more or less the same speech.
- cmauniada 7y agoI don't get it. So he made these jokes infront of shareholders just for kicks? Why would someone even say this infront of anyone, I don't understand. I am starting to think he might have been under the influence.
- whatshisface 7y ago
- draw_down 7y agoGod forbid a business leader should tell the truth!
- magoon 7y agoThis reminds me of Adam Osborne, who tanked sales of his new Osbourne 1 by prematurely bragging about the future Osbourne 2. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect
- happycube 7y agoInteresting that much of what sunk Osborune was actually a sunk cost fallacy from the $150K of assembled Osbourne 1 boards... if they had been sold off to a liquidator or hobbiests, they might've still turned a profit on em in the end. At the very least they could've scrapped the boards and taken the tax writeoff.
- CodeWriter23 7y agoCompanies like Osborne and many others in the early-80’s microcomputer game were built by engineers who had taken a second mortgage. So when the cash ran out, there weren’t second chances via creative finance. Many ended up going back to their old high-paying jobs to pay down their debt and keep the house.
- the-dude 7y agoSection: The Osborne myth
- dmix 7y agoSounds like more of a Sega-CD vs Playstation type failure than just his words. He probably felt he needed to talk about the next gen Osbourne 2 to really compete since he was trumped by competition.
- krustyburger 7y agoWhat kind of jewelry did people think they were getting for a few quid?
- dumbfoundded 7y agoOf course, everyone who bought it already knew it was crap. It's the same thing for buying $15K engagement rings. Everyone knows it's a stupid use of money and that the rings have no value. Same goes for clothing, cars, and many other things. These types of products succeed because of a shared delusion. Take fashion for instance. Everyone believes some clothes are more fashionable than others. The way you dress says a lot about you but why? It's simply because other people think it does. If the delusion runs into reality from the person hawking it, it can collapse quite quickly.
- sysbin 7y agoThat's a far leap from engagement ring cost being the result of society sharing a delusion and believing there is a delusion with some clothes being more fashionable than others. Psychology has a definition named the halo effect and it's very real. A person definitely gains advantages in society when they appear more attractive than less attractive. Naturally people associate good health with attractiveness and it's hard wired in us for finding a healthy mate compared to an unhealthy mate. Good choice of clothing for the frame of a person can enhance personal features and make a person look better than if wearing something less fitting. So there is some benefit & gain that can be made with understanding fashion of clothes as a real benefit. Is the advantage based on a delusion of a person being more healthy than another? Sure, but it isn't because people intentionally have a delusion about one shirt looking better than another.
- whatshisface 7y agoIf that were the whole story then fashion would never change. The idea that your clothes should be the right size doesn't have much to do with the weird color cycling that clothing companies try to foist on people.
- 7y ago
- sudhirj 7y agoThis is really applicable to any products that are valued based on their marketing efforts instead of intrinsic value or utility. Costume jewellery, designer clothes, some kinds of art, all derive their value from the story the creators tell. The most expensive art seems to be that which has the most thoroughly verified, or at least the most believable story. I like to think I’d prefer Apple products over the competition and pay a premium for them even if I didn’t know Jobs or Ive, or watched the marketing videos - but I’m not entirely sure these days. I Tim Cook said Apple products were super cheap to produce, or Ive said he didn’t design any of them and had some intern do it, would sales tank?
- jolux 7y agoApple stuff is just so clearly beyond anything the competition provides with regards to software, though. I don’t really buy them for the hardware, I buy them because I don’t like Windows or Android, and I don’t want to futz with Linux. Android is still too inconsistent design-wise.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI buy Apple products in spite of Cook and Ive. I am mostly ambivalent about Cook, though I don't think he's nearly as strong a leader as Jobs was. And I really dislike Ive. If he disavowed his designs as coming from an intern, I'd feel relieved.
- seem_2211 7y agoPrice, value and practical utility are not really correlated. A Rolex and a Timex will both tell you the time. An iPhone and a $129 Android will do mostly similar things. A Toyota Camry and a Porsche will both get you to work. But practical utility and value aren't necessarily the most important thing. Apple intuitively understood this, at a time when other computer companies didn't. Lots of people look at a Macbook and see an overpriced computer that costs a few hundred dollars more than a similarly equipped PC, albeit in a pretty case. But that's the point - lots of people want their computer to look good! Apple products are relatively cheap to produce - and they make an enormous margin on their hardware. But it doesn't feel cheap. The boxes are substantial. The finishings are high quality. The user experience is taken care of. Other PC makers might have been much cheaper, but you notice that to do so, they've cut corners in places. I don't think the lesson here is in what he said, but rather that he made his customers feel like idiots. Only a fool would believe that a ring for £1 has the level of quality and craftsmanship that you'd get with a £100 ring, but you don't want to feel like a dumbass for buying it. You don't go to McDonalds with expectations of buying a Michelin Star meal. You go there for something warm & tasty, that comes out quickly.
- overcast 7y agoWhat I don't understand, is how it wasn't immediately apparent this stuff was junk? You couldn't possibly think that it was equal in quality to much more expensive competitors. I guess it's just the case of not being real, until someone says it.
- tyingq 7y agoDiamonds, especially the recent craze around discolored ones might be a good comparison. They are valuable mostly because of years of shrewd marketing. If DeBeers started telling the truth, they could drop in value pretty quickly.
- Loughla 7y agoI was absolutely floored when I started seeing advertisements for 'chocolate' diamonds a few years back, and even more floored that people I knew just HAD to have them. I had dealt with 'chocolate' diamonds for years, I currently have hundreds in my wood shop! My father works as a machinist, and brown, low-quality diamonds are their abrasive of choice for many jobs. They're (or rather, they were) super cheap because they were such low quality. I always swiped a handful when I visited him at work as a kid, because they made great pellets (they were exceptionally tiny and really hard) for my slingshot. I had a whole jug of them and just forgot about the things. And now here we are.
- WalterBright 7y agoJust look at the mania for wearing torn jeans.
- omegaham 7y agoAt least jeans manufacturers weren't marketing based on the unblemished workmanship of their jeans. Their typical message is "Jeans are worn by rugged, individualist people. You want to be a rugged independent person, right?" And I think that torn jeans can fit into that. Like, a farmer might rip his jeans and keep wearing them or something, so ripped jeans might make you look even more rugged and individualist. Chocolate diamonds are a direct contradiction of regular diamond marketing. If you go to great lengths to talk about how important clarity is when justifying your diamonds' prices, it's particularly silly when you start selling the least clear diamonds possible.
- anonu 7y agoI couldn't help but think of Trump and his superlatives. Lots of people joke when he says something is "the best" or "the greatest it's ever been". Trump does this quite a bit with respect to the economy and the markets. The engineer in me takes things at face value: measured, empirical and framed in the right context. But I can understand the salesman approach to selling: you need to promote your product as the best. This is especially true for the markets where valuations are pretty much "maxed out" and at all time highs. So the market runs on optimism and future expectations. The market will go up because I say it will go up! Nothing wrong with that perspective IMHO - insofar as talking about the markets.
- SomeOtherThrow 7y agoWhat were the effects it had on the company? They just mention the stock tanking which, by itself, is pretty meaningless. I'm assuming people stopped buying the stuff? Secondly, why did it have any effect? Who would change their practices because of this? It really rams home how deeply brands are integrated into our understanding of value. How depressing.
- spzb 7y agoIt became a national joke in the UK. Nobody would be seen dead going into one of their stores or giving their jewellery as a gift. It basically put them out of business : https://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/aug/22/gerald-ratner-jewellery-total-crap-1992-archive https://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/aug/22/gerald-ratn...
- Axsuul 7y agoBut did it really put them out of business? They did a re-org as Signet Jewelers and is now the world's largest retailer of diamonds.
- spzb 7y agoAs a brand it put Ratners out of business. Your average man in the street isn't aware of the corporate structures behind the high street brands.
- SomeOtherThrow 7y agoThat's way less of an exciting headline, though. The company is the only way to realize the value of a brand, and if the company is still doing fine today, it considerably weakens the lessons here: it's apparently not even that bad in the worst case scenario.
- TheCoelacanth 7y agoThey did manage to salvage the company, but they lost hundreds of millions of dollars in the process. It was an absolute disaster for them.
- smallgovt 7y agoI think the more interesting lesson to learn from this was how Ratner was able to deal and cope with the public embarrassment following the mishap. It reminds me of this TED talk where Jon Ronson talks about how public shaming has gone out of control with the advent of social media: https://www.ted.com/talks/jon_ronson_what_happens_when_online_shaming_spirals_out_of_control?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/jon_ronson_what_happens_when_onlin...
- dragontamer 7y agoActually, the best "public shaming" talk I've seen are the ones given by Monica Lewinsky. When you consider that Monica Lewinsky was 22 years old during the time of the scandal, a lot of the stuff going on was simply outside of her control. Seeing things from her perspective is pretty interesting, to say the least: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yq7Eh6JTKIg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yq7Eh6JTKIg John Oliver starts the discussion, but there is a Lewinsky interview which is very eye-opening for me.
- minikites 7y agoMonica Lewinsky is an infinitely stronger person than most of us and I'm glad she's able to approach her past with grace. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/02/monica-lewinsky-in-the-age-of-metoo https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/02/monica-lewinsky-in-t...
- favorited 7y agoShe's definitely worth following on Twitter as well.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI never understood why Lewinsky got ridiculed that much. If anything she was a victim in the whole thing. Or am I missing something?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- crawfordcomeaux 7y agoIt's funny how people will paint being honest as a gaffe. The original gaffe was selling people crap and not telling them it's crap.
- dagw 7y agoEverybody knew what they where buying. What they didn't appreciate was learning that the CEO of the company laughing at them behind their back for not being able to afford anything 'better'.
- davidgh 7y agoImagine the difference in how you’d feel as a middle-class working guy buying from them. The CEO could say: “We work hard to keep our prices low by carefully selecting affordable materials while still providing stylish, attractive and fashionable products our customers love.” ...or: “Our products are crap, the materials in them are crap, and by virtue of buying them, our customers assert that all they want is crap.” Producing low cost items is not the issue, and naturally the quality is less with low cost items. People understood they weren’t buying high-grade platinum. It’s the expressed sentiment of the company leader was the gaffe.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThe implied sentiment was "You're poor and I've been treating you as a joke." The previously implied sentiment was "I'm selling you upmarket glamour at an affordable price." Branding isn't about the product, it's about buying a relationship with an entity that has more power and charisma than you do. If you change the implied terms of the relationship, you damage the brand's value. It's why people get so furious when Apple stiffs them with products that fail and then fobs them off with poor after-care. Apple's implied sentiment used to be "You're an important and unusually gifted person with excellent taste." After Cook it's more like "We've taken your money. Why are you still here?"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chucksmash 7y agoInteresting anecdote, but holy minimal-effort-article-writing, Batman: > Have you ever heard of the “Ratner effect”? > Well by the end of this post you will know what it means.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoWhile long-form writing is an enjoyable endeavor, I appreciate the direct approach most of the time.
- dmix 7y agoThere's a hundred variations of this story on those bottom of the article news feeds type "surprising" story blogs. Good luck finding one with effort! Wikipedia is probably the best bet.
- eghad 7y agoYeah the writing and formatting were really poor, they've since changed it to theHustle's article on it, which is at least a marginal improvement.
- kozak 7y agoRemind me of the recent case where a person (Google tells me that her name is Maria Butina) got busted as a Russian spy after she had a habit of bragging that she was a Russian spy when drunk.
- metamet 7y agoAnd George Papadopoulos bragging, kicking off the investigation: > During a night of heavy drinking at an upscale London bar in May 2016, George Papadopoulos, a young foreign policy adviser to the Trump campaign, made a startling revelation to Australia’s top diplomat in Britain: Russia had political dirt on Hillary Clinton. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/30/us/politics/how-fbi-russia-investigation-began-george-papadopoulos.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/30/us/politics/how-fbi-russi... People love to brag.
- cookiesboxcar 7y agoArticle mentions that they had to change their name to "The Signet Group" ... the now parent company of Zales/Kay/Jared. I'd be interested to learn more about that transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signet_Jewelers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signet_Jewelers
- blowski 7y agoIndeed, in the UK they own H Samuel and Ernest Jones - with exactly the same business model and value as Ratner’s. So you could argue it didn’t have much long term impact.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWell they closed hundreds of shops in the years immediately following, and already owned H Samuel back then. Not sure about E Jones, which is a little more upmarket anyway.
- mrosett 7y agoThis article is basically the same story, but more detailed and better-written: https://thehustle.co/gerald-ratners-billion-dollar-speech https://thehustle.co/gerald-ratners-billion-dollar-speech
- dang 7y agoOK, we'll change to that from https://www.businessblogshub.com/2012/09/the-man-who-destroyed-his-multi-million-dollar-company-in-10-seconds/ https://www.businessblogshub.com/2012/09/the-man-who-destroy.... Thanks!
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoI would say this is not the Ratner effect but the Othello effect (as in Reversi not Shakespeare) Ratner merely put down the last piece that flipped almost the whole board. Marketing is usually the uphill struggle to persuade anyone looking at the board that "white is winning" when it is really anyone's game. But eventually one piece is played, often a public failure, and everyone realises the board was destined to be black anyway. It's much harder to play this marketing game when you are selling costume jewellery or other fashion lead items. And the odds of someone flipping the board are high without you realising it. But people play it that way anyway.
- vinceguidry 7y agoThat board didn't have to flip. Ratner could have just kept selling the brand instead of stating his true opinions to a media circus. And the brand would have retained its value, perhaps all the way to today if he could have kept the unit economics alive. What made the brand successful wasn't what Ratner thought it was. The word at hand here is 'hubris'. Successful people slowly lose touch with the rest of the world and eventually make a colossal screw-up.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoNo eventually it would flip - it happens all the time. It's just this time the boss of the company laid down the final piece so it sticks in the mind
- vinceguidry 7y ago"It happens all the time" doesn't have predictive power.
- mrkstu 7y agoThe re-branded company he was forced out of is now the largest diamond retailer in the world- so I'd say that the problem was him and his mouth, not an inevitable flip in fortune.
- mjb 7y agoHaving contempt for your customers is not a good long-term business strategy. Some people get away with it for a while, but eventually they get found out.
- Phenomenit 7y agoMaybe he was fed up and wanted a real exit. There are other stories of people giving away huge fortunes prehumously because they might think the money is better used elsewhere.
- dmix 7y agoMoney isn't a finite resource that "goes elsewhere" if you don't generate it through business activity. This is probably one of the biggest popular misconceptions of how business works, that there is only a limited amount of value to go around, instead of it just being a near unlimited balloon that can expand or contract.
- Phenomenit 7y agoI'm well aware that money moves all the time but giving it away removes the burden of making "good" and rational decision, especially if you have a lot of it. Or Maybe you don't like hanging out with rich people, when you're very rich you can't hang out with poor people. You can but you have to probably lie about your wealth.
- calibas 7y agoWhat I find most fascinating is that a multimillion dollar company was destroyed simply because the owner told the truth. Imagine if fast food CEOs were honest about the quality of their food instead of just parroting marketing bullshit.
- dheera 7y agoYeah, this is what I find is the most sad part. I actually value people who are willing to be transparent and honest about themselves, and in my mind that kind of honesty should increase the valuation of a company, at least in the sense that there is indirect value delivered to society when more honest people are in control of money.
- ghaff 7y agoI rarely eat at the big fast food chains--and it's usually because I have no other options. But what's the "truth" about the quality of the food? The CEO could quite honestly say that their goals are consistency, speed, food safety, and affordability. Quality? I expect the honest response would be something along the lines of 1.) Millions of customers apparently like our product and 2.) We try to deliver the best quality product we can subject to our customers' other priorities. The CEO probably believes this to some degree or other. They're not trying to deliver a high-end steakhouse experience. McDonald's isn't even trying to deliver a Shake Shack experience--which maybe costs 2x (at least)?
- mywittyname 7y agoI eat McDonalds rather frequently for lunch because there's one nearby, a double cheeseburger is $1.89, and has 26g of protein and under 500 calories. I think they taste fine; I wouldn't pay more for a better tasting one. I'm pretty sure nearly every McDonalds customer thinks the same way. They want quick, cheap, safely prepared food that tastes good enough to eat.
- ghaff 7y agoI pretty much can't stand them personally--except for the fries and maybe a couple of breakfast items. But I readily admit I'm a bit of a foodie. I'm certainly not going to begrudge others who find them a good value or even, gasp, like them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mv4 7y agoPerception is reality.
- bobharris 7y agoSobering, softening article. Perspective.
- losvedir 7y agoAnyone have data on the Ratner Group's shares prior to Feb '91? I'm sort of skeptical because the chart begins there. It could have been on a downward trend anyway.
- xyzal 7y agoRatner apparently bragged too much, which cost his company a fortune, which apparently was not his intent. I wonder, if there is a documented case of someone causing similar loss just for the reason of "having enough" with the pure intent of causing as much damage as possible or just for causing as much evil/pain as possible. In the sense of listening to his/hers dark triad temptation.
- fortran77 7y agoThe modern examples cited weren't nearly as bad: - Lulumon didn't seem to be hurt by Chip Wilson. In fact, the "notoriety" made me aware they they sold men's clothes, too, and I went there and bought some great athletic wear. - Many customers appreciated Barclays' warning not to "pile up debts." That would give me a favorable opinion of a company that offers lines of credit, not a bad one.
- ve7cxz 7y agoSame with John Pluthero at C&W. I was working there at the time and John was well-known for being brutally honest (his management style was one of the reasons he took over when C&W bought Energis, despite him running the much smaller Energis). It's a while ago now, but he was right at the time and I don't remember anyone disagreeing.
- tempguy9999 7y agoI prefer straight honesty in social dealings, but it is vital in business, even when that is my bossing telling me I did crap, or me telling the boss I think he's wrong. Arsing around gently in business contexts, not giving info that would help even if unwelcome, is plain damaging.
- sharadov 7y agoLululemon is genius, their quality is great, but the branding is even better! They revolutionized the exercise wear industry, were single-handedly responsible for "athleisure" and killing denim sales!
- fortran77 7y agoand maybe it's true that some styles of clothing are "not for everyone"
- sushisource 7y agoNot maybe, definitely. Just one of those things that for some reason isn't acceptable to say despite being obviously accurate.
- throwaway6845 7y ago> Elon Musk (right) has drawn comparisons to Gerald Ratner in recent years The 1980s British businessman who Musk most reminds me of is not Gerald Ratner but Robert Maxwell.
- walshemj 7y agoReally I don't recall Elon doing any of the really shady shit that Maxwell did.
- seem_2211 7y agoYou should take a closer look at Elon Musk (starting with some of the sketchy shenanigans at Solar City).
- walshemj 7y agoYour probably to young to recall Maxwells shady dealings in the political/spook world (some people think that is what killed him) And also stealing hundreds of millions from pensions funds that lead to wholesale reform of the pensions industry in the UK
- seem_2211 7y agoYeah, both are shady AF.
- dlivingston 7y agoSources?
- ascorbic 7y agoMost of Maxwell's really shady shit didn't come out til after he had died.
- klagermkii 7y agoThis should be a lesson for adolescents who wonder why people tend to get less and less "edgy" as they grow up. Just takes one moment of too much edge to lose the gamble and end up throwing everything away.
- seph-reed 7y agoI think the adolescents might be on to something with that. I tend to do a good job of keeping my unpopular opinions between me and close friends, but I can't say I'm thrilled with the dependency on nepotism that's creeping into my life. Perhaps being edgy is the best way to force oneself into self reliance, and self reliance being the best way to hold ground against corruption... maybe the edgelessness of "adults" is just a sign of forfeit within a corrupt system.
- perl4ever 7y agoBeing "edgy" is a symptom of still having a mindset that there are railings between you and the abyss, and/or someone whose purpose in life is to tackle you before you go over the "edge". Believing that you can avoid it in the long run, while fearing you're not an adult if you stay where it's safe.
- jdietrich 7y agoMichael O'Leary being incredibly rude is a key part of Ryanair's branding. If you're paying £19 for a two hour flight, you'll always have the sneaking suspicion that the airline is skimping on maintenance. O'Leary makes it absolutely clear that they save money by treating their passengers like cattle. He carefully cultivates the image of a man who utterly despises his own customers, but is far too miserly to allow an aircraft to crash. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_O%27Leary_(businessman)#Controversy_and_reputation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_O%27Leary_(businessman...
- fortran77 7y agoI agree. Fellow "cheapskates" who just want to get from Dublin to Edinburgh on a cheap flight probably admire his thrift.
- isostatic 7y agoSuch cheap flights are possible because the airlines aren’t paying the externalities they cause. Ryanair don’t fly to London btw. Or Brussels.
- andrepd 7y agoThey do, to Stanstead and Luton.
- crispyporkbites 7y agoStanstead and Luton are 30-40 miles from London
- bgibbons 7y agoWow...insert foot in mouth. It is pretty unbelievable that today leaders of immense influence i.e. Elon Musk, others referenced in the article aren't more careful with what they might put out in a Tweet. Truly amazing.
- jcims 7y agoThat's one way to look at it. Another way to look at it is that constantly vomiting BS into twitter will erode its value as a source of material information. Anybody that makes a giant investment decision based on a Musk tweet now is certifiable.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoMusk will say some stupid garbage, but he'd never call his own products crap. He really believes in them.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoAlso, the products are not crap. Can't argue with rockets going to space for cheaper than ever, whatever the CEO says on twitter. Rockets aren't earrings.
- keiferski 7y agoThis situation sounds like more of an indictment of the media and sensationalist journalism more than the entrepreneur himself. People make mistakes and say stupid things sometimes, after all, they’re human. Expecting leaders to be perfect 100% of the time will only result in leaders that are good at appearing perfect.
- giarc 7y agoI think you can expect a CEO of a company not to call their own products "crap".
- keiferski 7y agoMaybe from a marketing perspective, sure. But from a truthfulness perspective, I think you’ll find that most people are annoyed by the fake opinions that come from most businesses. Indeed a number of companies have been successful specifically because they talk like real human beings and readily admit the strengths and weaknesses of their products.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Indeed a number of companies have been successful specifically because they talk like real human beings and readily admit the strengths and weaknesses of their products. I'm curious - can you name a couple?
- macintux 7y agoDominos used the lousy quality of their pizzas to market a revamped recipe.
- giarc 7y agoThat's not quite an apples to apples comparison. CEO of the jewelry store was saying that his current products were crap. I'm assuming Dominos was saying "our old recipe was crap, new receipe is good."
- ElijahLynn 7y agoOr was it that he decided to come clean, because he felt shame for what he had done, and didn't mind the consequences? I think it was unlikely but just posing the question.
- hinkley 7y agoI don't really have a particular desire to be the public face of any organization (although, having joined some pretty small groups lately, the odds of this happening have increased from 0 to >0), but a lot of the other examples in this article reinforce for me the advice about phrasing your criticisms constructively or as a value statement. It's harder for someone to blow them out of proportion or context when they are phrased that way, although people can still play the hypocrisy card.
- Izkata 7y agoThe speech was in April, and there was an impact from it, but on the chart the stock didn't start plummeting until September. What's the real story?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe chart shows a 20% drop within 2 weeks.
- Izkata 7y agoBut only after gaining immediately prior to that, after having already started a slow tumble a month before. That April spike looks like an outlier gain during a slow, 4-month decline (March through June). Over in September and October however, it suddenly dropped about 45% in about 4 weeks, after having nearly stabilized, and then dropped 60% over November. It absolutely didn't start plummeting until months after he made these jokes.
- dlphn___xyz 7y ago“the truth is like poetry and people hate poetry” -steve carell as mark baum
- cryptozeus 7y agoKudos to the guy for bouncing back though !! “After losing everything, he toiled in misery for years — but he eventually made an improbable comeback. In 1997, he took out a £155k (US$203k) loan on his house, built up a health club business, and sold it for £3.9m (US$5.1m). He then used the profits to start an online jewelry company. (The Ratners Group rebranded as Signet in 1993; today, it is the largest diamond retailer in the world.)”
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ylesaout 7y agoWhile he made a successful comeback (however far from his first success), saying he toiled in misery for years is a little bit exagerated. Indeed, he was still the owner of a house (and probably of other goods). And this house was big enough to have a value probably equal to a today million dollars. That's not what I call to be toiled in misery.
- colechristensen 7y agoBeing rich doesn't make you automatically happy, you can hear many stories about billionaires who have and have achieved everything they could possibly want being miserable – wanting things and then getting them isn't the source of happiness, being faced with this reality firsthand by running out of things to want and still feeling dissatisfied with life can be (imagined at least) really miserable and hopeless.
- digitaltrees 7y agoThe line is subsistence, not being a billionaire. If you don’t have food, shelter and health care you are often very very in happy. If you have those, each additional dollar contributes a much smaller degree of happiness. The research suggest the line for diminishing returns in the US is $80k in most cities.
- core-questions 7y ago
- cozzyd 7y agoTo anyone else similarly confused, this is NOT the same Gerald Ratner for whom the gym at UChicago is named.
- 0898 7y ago"When Gerald Ratner took the stage before 6k high-powered businesspeople" The phrase "high-powered" has never sat right with me. It sounds so hand-wavey.
- a-raccoon 7y agoI wish more CEOs were as witty, plain and blunt as his remarks were. All his talking points were true, all of his jokes on point, and the only people who probably gave a crap were a very small handful of financial investors that are easily (and completely unreasonably) spooked. I say there should be more Ratners. Standardize his personality-type across all industries and political spheres.
- hirundo 7y agoI did a ratner with a girl once. She said something like "well you have good genes anyway, right?". I listed a few of my imperfections. She said "oh", and went away. It was a good lesson.
- imulligan 7y agoI see Tesla in the Horizon.
- atombender 7y agoIn the 90s there was a popular, now-forgotten CRM/bookkeeping system for MS-DOS called Vega. When they launched version 2.0, the founder/CEO boasted to the press about how 2.0 was old hat, and how they were working on 3.0, which was going to be so much better. Subsequently, almost nobody bought 2.0, because the current product worked well enough and they wanted to hold out for 3.0. I believe the company went under as a result.
- marktangotango 7y agoI lived through that exact thing a few years ago. Company never recovered.
- rajacombinator 7y agoThe key mistake here is not respecting your customers. Unsurprising in an inherited business, and in many corporations, which are essentially inherited by promotion.
- drummyfish 7y agoThis is possible only in capitalism, where the demand doesn't come from people's needs but is simply created by the sellers themselves. I've seen successful online businesses based on selling people animal feces.
- robertheadley 7y agoI really enjoyed this one. Thanks for sharing it.
- chenster 7y agoSmells like clickbait
- JJMcJ 7y agoAnd this is why most corporate communication is so bland and stereotyped.
- jberm123 7y agoReminds me of the recent Patrick Byrne CEO of Overstock resigning after making comments he's involved with the deep state (which also crushed Overstock's stock price): https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/22/overstock-ceo-patrick-byrne-resigns-following-deep-state-comments.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/22/overstock-ceo-patrick-byrne-...
- Phillipharryt 7y agoSo I've actually done a fair amount of research on this speech, and there a few skipped points most times people report on it. Firstly the audience loved the jokes, they laughed at them all. It wasn't like he delivered them to stunned faces and immediate shock. The only thing that brought him down was a newspaper reporter noted it down and newspapers pushed it as an artificial scandal. Everyone buying 5 pound earrings knew they were of very low quality, they just didn't want it being shouted at them in their daily news. Secondly it wasn't even the first time he had publicly made these sorts of jokes, in fact it wasn't even the first time they had been published in the papers. This was entirely a newspaper driven downfall, they wanted to see him fail and wanted to sell papers about a scandal, so they did.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> it wasn't even the first time he had publicly made these sorts of jokes, in fact it wasn't even the first time they had been published in the papers. > This was entirely a newspaper driven downfall That first point is good evidence that the jokes weren't very responsible for what happened. But it seems like it's just as good evidence that newspaper coverage also wasn't very responsible. Why attribute it to the newspapers this time, when they tried and failed before?
- concerned_user 7y agoMaybe different kind of newspaper? Like a tabloid compared to a respected paper, but that is just an educated guess, I don't know the actual story.
- Spare_account 7y agoAt the risk of alienating the same people that Gerald Ratner did (and in full knowledge that all generalisations are false), the people buying the stuff he sold didn't read the broadsheets. It was the tabloid press, targeting their readers, that brought Ratners down. I don't know why they did it though apart from increasing their sales by generating buzz about a subject maybe.
- 7y ago
- skrebbel 7y agoI've always been amazed at how important it appears to be to lie about selling crap. I find that invariably, businesses who compete on price make it iff they say it's good stuff, even if everybody knows it isn't. Eg Holland has a number of cheap shoe chains. Schoenenreus and Scapino both breathe an air of cheapness, and one went bust and the other is struggling bad. Their direct competitor Van Haren sells exactly equally crappy shoes, and everybody knows it, but they are thriving, simply because the store feels like a proper high quality shoe store. Or take ALDI, which competes on price and nothing else. In every country I visited has the words "the ALDI principle: low prices, high quality" printed on every storefront and on every page of their paper promo flyers. Granted, little of what they sell is "total crap", but little is of truly high quality either. Their bread goes stale faster and their coffee is bitter. This surprises nobody. It appears to me that this weird dichotomy is the only way to successfully compete on price. Make it perfectly obvious that you're cheap and of mediocre quality at best, while loudly shouting that the quality is high. Nobody believes you, but nobody wants to buy from you if you're honest about what you're selling. I find this surprising because blatant lies don't generally work that well in the long term, so why do they here? I generally hate dishonest messaging. Why don't I mind here? I buy ALDI and Van Haren all the time.
- novaRom 7y ago>ALDI, which competes on price and nothing else They offer lots of good quality things, so better to say they have the best price/quality ratio.
- ajsnigrutin 7y agoAnd not just that.. they optimize sales as far as they can. Everything is in a box (no need to arrange things carefuly on shelves), huge barcodes (faster scanning), larger items on pallets (just bring a new pallet in when old one is empty), just a few people work there and do everything, etc. They sometimes also buy everything you have to get a cheaper price (a friend of mine has a rather large vegetable farm, and they offered to buy literally all the produce to get a lower price.. he doesn't have to deal with sales that year, and they get it cheaper). I like aldi, and buy a bunch of stuff there (i'm not sponsored by them), but at the same time, you know what you're buying - need a drill? They sell a perfectly ok one for really cheap... for a casual user, who uses a drill once every few months. What I don't like is some other stores selling the same items (just branded differently) for 2x the price. If you need a good drill for professional use, there are just a few companies that make them good - and you probably know them all. If you need something cheap, you'll get it cheaper at a store like aldi (or lidl, or similar) than at [hardware store] under their brand, or even some reputable brands. Stupid example: https://www.productreview.com.au/listings/aldi-food-dehydrator https://www.productreview.com.au/listings/aldi-food-dehydrat... This was sold here for 30eur at aldi. Gorenje is/was a reputable brand here, and they sell theirs for 50eur: https://www.mimovrste.com/susilniki-sadja/gorenje-susilnik-hrane-fdk-24-dw https://www.mimovrste.com/susilniki-sadja/gorenje-susilnik-h... Just look at the photos and compare.
- abstractbarista 7y agoI guess I'm weird compared to most consumers or investors. I applaud and enjoy when company leaders call out their products or services as crap. Because frankly, they mostly are. Most business is partially a constant lie about how good, reliable, or worthwhile they are. This is constant across the global economy. So why not embrace it? We all know you get what you pay for...
- _-___________-_ 7y agoMaybe the deeper lesson here isn't so much "don't be indiscreet about how shit your products are", but rather, "don't work on something you're not proud of".
- spoovy 7y agoMy dad, a working class man, must have bought my mum jewellery from Ratners in the 80s, because I remember this scandal and how genuinely furious he was. I remember him saying to me words along the lines of "of course we know deep down that it's crap, but it's all we can afford so we kid ourselves that it's not". Ratner saying out loud that it was crap was destroying people's private delusions, which is all some people have. It was idiotic of Ratner to say it and I don't blame the newspapers for printing it at all.
- Arcadian 7y agoInitially, Ratner tried to play it off by featuring special in-store promotions that put a “humorous twist” on his remarks — but within a few weeks, it was clear that what he’d said had taken an irreparable toll on his business.
- BackToSchool 7y agoWithin months, all Ratners locations were plastered with vibrant orange and red posters with all-caps pitches like “LAST CHANCE — MEGA RED STAR SALE!” and “SALE SALE SALE: HALF PRICE!” Everything in the window was clearly marked with a price tag.
- Fnoord 7y agoAh yes, the Ratner effect [1]. See also the Osbourne effect [2] and the Elop effect (which did Nokia no good) [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Ratner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Ratner [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Elop#%22Burning_Platform%22_memo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Elop#%22Burning_Platfo...