8 ms·
The ‘circle of trust’ behind the world’s first gene-edited babies
- vector_rotcev 7y agoIs there any news on whether or not it worked? I read the article (albeit quickly as I'm on lunch break), but I can't find anything reporting on whether or not the experiment resulted in healthy children, or if they are immune to HIV (if that can be tested without infecting them, of course - I don't know anything about immunity detection either).
- sohkamyung 7y agoThere is, for now, little to no news as to what has happened to the babies. For reporting on the experiment itself, see one of the linked articles [1] which does not end on a hopeful note: > [T]he editing of CCR5 in Lulu and Nana could have no detectable consequences at all. With no one providing updates on the health of the children, that outcome, perhaps the most likely one, may never be headline news. [1] https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/08/did-crispr-help-or-harm-first-ever-gene-edited-babies https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/08/did-crispr-help-or-h...
- imtringued 7y agoMaybe it is possible to take skin cells and infect them in a laboratory.
- vibrio 7y agoHIV infects White blood cells. it won't infect skin cells. Its trivial to draw blood and infect them in the laboratory, but that isn't an interesting experiment. His poorly executed (and unethical) experiment was attempted to be based on the established knowledge that there is a subset of people that have a CCR5 mutation that confers some resistance to HIV infections. That is established and wasn't an experiment that needed to be done on humans.
- AstralStorm 7y agoAnd why is modifying a human unethical, or more so than modifying any other animal which we do all the time? Technically, there should've been phase 1 trials. How do you propose to do that otherwise with genetic modification of germline cells otherwise? Someone will have to be risked, like with any unproven treatments. Either you can ban human modification on shaky grounds (not really ethics), or you will have to take that risk to just see if modification can take. There is no third way, no amount of animal studies proves the technique works in humans. You could test it on embryos, but then you have to either kill them or are back in the same place. And it does not provide complete information - only about relatively early development.
- vibrio 7y agoIt "worked" is binary and that doesn't exist in medicine. The people who have the naturally occurring deletion 32 CCR5 mutation aren't immune. they have decreased risk of infection. There are safe and approved medicines that can greatly reduce the risk of transmission whether given before or shortly after exposure. Unconsented Germ line genetic modification of humans cannot justified, at very least for this use case.
- whatshisface 7y ago>Unconsented Germ line genetic modification of humans cannot justified How are you going to get consent from a human that isn't even conceived yet?
- teh_infallible 7y agoExactly! I don’t see how anyone can justify permanently altering a human life like this, in the absence of a clear pathology. Wouldn’t it be better to simply not have a child?
- AstralStorm 7y agoEasily. If it is an improvement with low chances of failure and even lower of catastrophic failure, why leave all the failures to nature? Not having, say, HIV resistance could be considered a failure of nature, a deficit. We're not talking about frivolous modifications for no reason here.
- eximius 7y agoThat is sort of his point, whether you agree or not.
- SkyBelow 7y agoIf one views the genetic material as belonging to the parent until conception, one simply needs to get the consent of the parent. If one views the fetus as part of the mother until some stage of conception, it is even simpler to justify. You might as well be asking when did any two parents get consent to produce their child with the specific DNA that child has (say in a situation where both parents are at risk to genetic defects).
- dontreact 7y agoI'm not sure that the mutation conferred actually proves to be beneficial, even if it took place without any offsite modifications. It is associated with a fairly large increase in mortality. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/06/190603124709.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/06/190603124709.h...
- neom 7y ago"That circle included leading scientists—among them a Nobel laureate—in China and the United States, business executives, an entrepreneur connected to venture capitalists, authors of the NASEM report, a controversial U.S. IVF specialist who discussed opening a gene-editing clinic with He, and at least one Chinese politician. "He had an awful lot of company to be called a ‘rogue,’" says geneticist George Church, a CRISPR pioneer at Harvard University who was not in the circle of trust and is one of the few scientists to defend at least some aspects of He's experiment." "an entrepreneur connected to venture capitalists" made me chuckle.
- casefields 7y agoHoly cow. Jeffrey Epstein funded George Church, which is also on the front page right now: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/peteraldhous/jeffrey-epstein-science-donations-apologies-statements https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/peteraldhous/jeffrey-ep... These tentacles are all over the place.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoEpstein himself also was interested in eugenics for this purpose. It's incredibly chilling.
- vibrio 7y ago"He had an awful lot of company to be called a ‘rogue,’" says geneticist George Church Was Church referring to He or Epstein as a rogue? /s
- Hitton 7y agoIt's only matter of time before gene-editing becomes commonplace. March of progress can't be stopped. He Jiankui will eventually be vindicated and possibly lauded as visionary and pioneer.
- de_watcher 7y agoI look at it as a huge pile of obfuscated code. So yes, it's all there...
- wickedsickeune 7y agoGene editing humans was not per se the problem. The huge issue was that it's not obvious that this gene would in fact not cause other issues to these people, and the fact that it was done at a later stage in fetal development, causing possibly some of the cells not having the same genetic code as the rest. This is reckless and stupid, apart from the whole experimenting on humans thing. Someone who jumped off a cliff while trying to build an airplane, was not lauded as a visionary, but as a splat on the ground.
- AstralStorm 7y agoWhy is it stupid or reckless? In fact, this is a good way to mitigate risk. Most genes in mosaicism, even if parts of the mosaic is faulty, continue to function or partially function. Would you rather risk complete failure? (Potentially killing the fetus or embryo.) Also, someone has to take those (potentially reduced) risks if germ line modifications are needed.
- imtringued 7y agoWhat prevents us from using traditional selective breeding on humans? Why can't women just go to a sperm bank and buy premium DNA?
- SEJeff 7y agoI believe the term you're looking for is Eugenics. If you google it for some background, it has been tried before and uh, didn't end out so well.
- teh_infallible 7y agoThe article doesn’t seem to mention any of the risks of this type of procedure, only the potential benefit (possible immunity to AIDS) Is this benefit worth what I assume is a massive risk of developing cancer?
- Symmetry 7y agoProbably not cancer? Cancer is usually caused by a large enough number of mutations occurring in some cell over its lifetime that it starts reproducing uncontrollably. It's very bad in that a single bad cell can kill you but it takes a bunch of mutations to occur. A typical child has 0-3 or so new mutations depending on chance, how old their parents are, etc. We might very well expect that if this treatment was badly targeted it would produce many more. Generally a random mutation won't hit anything that has an effect at all on a cell's operation. Fairly often a mutation occurs in an area that's critical to a cell's function and the fertalized egg never turns into a pregnancy. Rarely the embryo turns into a child which survives to birth but has some problem with missing some protein or other that you need. If this was, e.g., AMY1 which is used to digest starch and which you probably have a bunch of copies of if your ancestors were farmers no big deal. But if it hit Factor VIII then you've got hemophilia and that really sucks. Only a small fraction of the genes in your body are involved in cancer and it's very unlikely that if you get a germline mutation that it will be one of these that it affects. Again, it's different as an adult because mutagens affect different genes in different cells and you only need the mutations to line up the right way once across essentially all the cells in your body to give you cancer. If one cell in your body gets Factor VIII knocked out then it doesn't matter, other cells can keep making the clotting factor you need and you'll be fine.