25 ms·
Sunsetting Mercurial Support in Bitbucket
- ryebit 7y agoSigh. I really hate seeing hg languish like this. Command line is nicer, and I have yet to find any git gui frontend that matches what TortoiseHG can do (both in terms of invocating dialogs from the cmdline; and in terms of presenting and manipulating the graph). I really hope something happens to help hg start accumulating more market share. Not just for my opinion on the tooling; but because IMO the "git = github = the only place for opensource" monoculture is kinda problematic.
- McP 7y agoThe best TortoiseHg equivalent I've found (after a lot of searching) is SmartGit [1]. It's not as good as TortoiseHg and its not free but it's nice enough for most of my use cases. [1] https://www.syntevo.com/smartgit/ https://www.syntevo.com/smartgit/
- ntobjx 7y agoThanks for the pointer. I'll see if my company will "sponsor" me a copy. Looks nice indeed.
- jzwinck 7y agoDoesn't this mean BitBucket will die? Slowly, sure, but Mercurial support seemed like a key differentiator relative to GitHub.
- the_duke 7y agoThey wouldn't have done it if a they had a significant user base using Mercurial, or if Mercurial usage was showing promising growth.
- cmiles74 7y agoThe article claims that virtually no new accounts are using Mercurial support at all. I suspect that they are working on improving their build pipeline and CI tooling and it's proving to expensive (perhaps in both time and money) to get that working reliably for both Git and Mercurial.
- DanHulton 7y agoIf it's going to die (and it might, I know I couldn't get off it fast enough), this can likely only help, not hinder. Not every feature helps you. There's a support burden with every line of code, and the support burden for another entire version control system is probably pretty high. Every new feature you add has to either be written for that second version control system as well, or come with a disappointing article explaining why not. If anything, this has the potential to free up resources they can spend on creating a differentiator that engages more than 1% of their customers.
- philpem 7y agoThe key differentiator on Github's side is community involvement. The UI allows you to quickly search for projects across repositories. Bitbucket seems more geared to teams working internally; finding projects on Bitbucket is hard. To be brutally honest, I used Bitbucket because I had a grandfathered academic account (most features free). Github offers nearly all that I had on that account now. Github is great for "social" coding, but Bitbucket is very clearly moving towards targeting insular, corporate development tasks. But then, with the price ticket on Atlassian's products, that's hardly a surprise. B2B is their bread and butter.
- antupis 7y agoyeah, I think that open source and other social products will gear towards Github. While Bitbucket will thrive in B2B space. currently, JIRA has a huge moat around it and I am not seeing that disappearing in the near future.
- philpem 7y agoThere's already a self-hosted version of Bitbucket which is fairly decent aside from being as slow as molasses (which, let's face it, is an 'Atlassian thing' at this point). I used to use Jira extensively for my own internal projects (and, hilariously, my personal TODO list), but I'm moving away from that. I'm moving from my own personal server to a couple of Droplets, and I realised in moving JIRA across just how bloated it is. Most of the SCM integration tools I use are pay-for now, so for $10/yr, I'm getting less than I'd get with a Mantis or Bugzilla install. I need to have a look for a new bugtracker. Custom Workflow support would be nice, that's really the only feature which kept me on JIRA for so long!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pard68 7y agoWe use Bitbucket at work because they offer selfhosting. Until Github can offer this I don't think Atlassian has anything to worry about.
- knute 7y agohttps://github.com/enterprise https://github.com/enterprise GitHub has offered an onprem server for some time now.
- pard68 7y agoWould you look at that! This was not an option about a year or two ago when we signed our contract for bitbucket...
- GordonS 7y agoFairly sure GitHub Enterprise has been a thing for several years now?
- nixgeek 7y agoIt was preceded by GitHub:FI, but Enterprise has existed since I worked there in 2013. Definitely not a new capability for them and it’s actually really nice to administer, e.g. very easy high-availability setup and excellent documentation. https://help.github.com/en/enterprise/2.16/admin/installation/configuring-github-enterprise-server-for-high-availability https://help.github.com/en/enterprise/2.16/admin/installatio...
- fnord123 7y agoIt's been around since 2011: https://github.blog/2011-11-01-introducing-github-enterprise/ https://github.blog/2011-11-01-introducing-github-enterprise...
- emilycook 7y agoGitLab employee, just wanna pop in here to say we have free self-hosting too in case anyone stumbles across this comment: https://about.gitlab.com/pricing/index.html#self-managed https://about.gitlab.com/pricing/index.html#self-managed
- Sean1708 7y agoAs a data point, our company that only uses git moved from GitLab to BitBucket literally about two months ago. No idea why (waaaay to low on the food chain) but I'm guessing it must have some advantages at least.
- vidanay 7y agoMost likely you will also see a Jira roll-out soon (unless that preceded the move to BitBucket)
- heavenlyblue 7y agoWe have moved from BitBucket after they had several days worth of unavailability over a year and the fact that they would regularly decline our company credit card, which would subsequently immediately block all commits to our repos. It was a mess which was simply fixable by re-submitting the card details again. They only had one job.
- krzyk 7y agoIt is quite funny because BitBucket started as a GitHub for Mercurial users (it had only Hg support). Then they (after it was sold) added git support and now they are removing hg.
- x3n0ph3n3 7y agoUnlikely. The deep integration between JIRA, BitBucket, and Bamboo is a huge selling point.
- probably_wrong 7y agoMercurial support was the one reason for me to still use Bitbucket: there is no other Bitbucket feature I can think of that Github doesn't already have, while Github's community is miles ahead since everyone and their dog is already there. More importantly, Bitbucket leaves the migration to you (if I read the article correctly). Once I download my repo and convert it to git, why would I stay with the company that just made me go through an annoying (and often painful) process, when I can migrate to Github with the exact same command? And why isn't there a "migrate this repo to git" button right there? I want to believe that Bitbucket has smart people and that this choice is a good one. But I'm with you there - to me, this definitely looks like Bitbucket will die.
- irishsultan 7y agoWhen clicking on the link to "A Community thread to discuss conversion tools, migration, tips, and offer troubleshooting help", I see: Article not found The article you are trying to access is not available. It may have been deleted or marked as spam.
- Bellyache5 7y agoIt seems that Bitbucket and GitHub are trying to emulate GitLab’s strategy of being a one-stop tool rather than just version control.
- nathancahill 7y agoThe opposite is true actually, Bitbucket was bought by Atlassian in 2010 to make Atlassian the one-stop shop, a strategy GitHub and GitLab are emulating (GitLab launched in 2011).
- dochtman 7y agoSeems to me that one-stop shop is very different from one-stop tool. GitLab is aiming for the latter, whereas Atlassian (at least when I was using those tools) seems much less integrated. Jira may be the most comprehensive issue tracker (which isn't necessarily attractive -- but then they have Trello now, too), but on the version control and CI front I don't think Atlassian will have an easy time competing against Azure/GitHub/GitLab.
- oaiey 7y agoI think the ALM market was defined and alive before any of these companies even existed. It is natural evolvement of these companies. The common user just realized he or she needed more and demanded them for free. The Enterprise market had DevOps features long before DevOps as term existed.
- twic 7y agoI and the dozens of other remaining Mercurial users will be severely inconvenienced by this. Still, at least SourceForge still has Mercurial support!
- mort96 7y agoI wouldn't trust SourceForge at all after all the horrible stuff they've done. I know they have allegedly improved after new owners and a come-to-jesus moment, but damn, that was some shady shit.
- jlebar 7y agoI suspect the whole post was a bit tongue-in-cheek, not just the line about "There's dozens of us. Dozens!"
- srean 7y agoI think you are thinking about the old and nasty sourceforge. They have since been bought and the new owners have changed what nasty old sourceforge used to be
- mort96 7y ago> I know they have allegedly improved after new owners and a come-to-jesus moment, but damn, that was some shady shit. If Facebook tomorrow started saying they're totally going to stop being creepy and got a new CEO, I wouldn't suddenly start trusting them either.
- loganabbott 7y agoWe're a small independently owned private company, and not a single person responsible for those decisions made years ago is still involved with the company. It's been over 3 years since we bought SourceForge and we reversed all the bad decisions on day 1 and never looked back. We still support Mercurial https://sourceforge.net/p/forge/documentation/Mercurial/#publishing-an-existing-repository https://sourceforge.net/p/forge/documentation/Mercurial/#pub...
- garganzol 7y agoIt's funny to see how the whole world concentrates on this Git thing, while there is a treasure trove called Mercurial. Mercurial was made for humans. It is seriously convenient and productive. Something I cannot say about Git, which more reminds me of an adhoc job. I use both Git and Mercurial on daily basis. But my preference goes to Mercurial: it is just more sane in a big way. It is clearly a piece of art and love.
- ChrisSD 7y agoAnd yet people overwhelmingly chose Git. Why is that?
- tehlike 7y agoNetwork effect and first mover advantage.
- ChrisSD 7y agoBut they were both released at around the same time. Or at least near enough that they were both serious contenders for awhile.
- gnud 7y agoMercurial was a bit slow in the first years. It's still probably slower for huge repos (I havn't checked), but I doubt it will bother you much nowadays. I used Hg before Git professionally, because when they were both new, Hg had _much_ better Windows support.
- dtech 7y agoAt this point, network effect
- hiccuphippo 7y agoLinus Torvalds made it. That at least got me to look into it. Then saw it was better than svn and never looked back. Or sideways, so I missed mercurial.
- pgt 7y agoIt would be interesting to read a breakdown of why Mercurial failed against Git. It is superior to Git in every way except performance and adoption. Git won because GitHub won, and I bet GitHub chose Git over Hg's Python implementation because it was too slow. I wonder if Mercurial would have won if it was implemented in C or Rust (had it existed then).
- nerdponx 7y agoIn my understanding it's the opposite, that Mercurial is effectively a subset of Git. But I was never a Hg user.
- andrewshadura 7y agoWell, you can express any Git repository in Mercurial terms, but not otherwise.
- gpderetta 7y ago> It is superior to Git in every way except performance and adoption. For me, and I suspect for a lot of developers, the single biggest advantage of git is that it is fast.
- simias 7y agoI'm not so sure really, in my experience the performance difference only becomes noticeable if you have a very large repository. For the Linux kernel I'm sure it matters, for "my library with 100 commits and 10k lines of code" it won't make a significant difference.
- hiccuphippo 7y agoIs there any feature in mercurial that git doesn't have? Is there some plugin to allow mercurial users keep using the client with a git remote repository (like the one for using git with svn)?
- andrewshadura 7y agoChangeset evolution for starters.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sterileopinions 7y agoYou mean the thing that was only suitable for real world use by in-the-wild development teams last year? Something no repo provider really fully supports even to this day? From HG's own documentation (https://www.mercurial-scm.org/wiki/ChangesetEvolution https://www.mercurial-scm.org/wiki/ChangesetEvolution): >While well on the way, the full implementation of the changeset evolution concept is still in progress. HG's entire system requires far more investment in the tool than git will ever ask of you. And you probably don't need the feature in the first place. I consider changeset evolution a nifty feature, but it's also a devop smell in my book.
- andrewshadura 7y agoNo. Evolution was usable since 2015 at least. Supported by Bitbucket and others. Evolution requires no effort whatsoever to maintain.
- krupan 7y agoChangeset evolution has had the "beta" label for way too long. I started using it years ago and it was fine. As far as smells go, its whole purpose is to make editing history less "smelly" than git's rebase -i followed by force push.
- 7y ago
- dragonsh 7y agoIt's very sad to see bitbucket dropping mercurial support. Now only Facebook and volunteers are keeping mercurial alive. Sometimes technically better architecture and user interface lose to a non user friendly hard solutions due to inertia of mass adoption. So a lesson in Software development is similar to betamax and VHS, so marketing is still a winner over technically superior architecture and ease of use. GitHub successfully marketed git, so git and GitHub are synonymous for most developers. Now majority of open source projects are reliant on a single proprietary solution Github by Microsoft, for managing code and project. Can understand the difficulty of bitbucket, when Python language itself moved out of mercurial due to the same inertia. Hopefully gitlab can come out with mercurial support to migrate projects using it from bitbucket. For people who believe in self hosted solution can install Kallithea (https://kallithea-scm.org https://kallithea-scm.org) or Rhodecode open source edition. Kallithea is used by Unity engine to manage their source code internally with mercurial.
- kyrra 7y agoGoogle contributes to Mercurial as well.
- dragonsh 7y agoI didn't know that, I thought Google is using customised perforce and later moved to Piper for their mono repository. I do not know if Piper still use some parts of mercurial or is based on mercurial. But it's good to know Google is supporting mercurial.
- durin42 7y agoPiper still exists, but Mercurial is a viable client tool to interact with Piper's version history.
- zhengyi13 7y agoAs do Facebook, if I recall correctly: https://engineering.fb.com/core-data/scaling-mercurial-at-facebook/ https://engineering.fb.com/core-data/scaling-mercurial-at-fa... That's from 2014, but I don't believe they've moved away from it since. In 2018, there's this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16565299 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16565299
- tecleandor 7y agoI'm not a Mercurial user, but some might be interested on this team that's working on adding Mercurial support to Gitlab, currently in the from of a fork or distribution called Heptapod: https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/31600#note_198825557 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/31600#note_19...
- vladsanchez 7y agoThanks for sharing, ppl may be headed to Gitlab then.
- vnorilo 7y agoI will be affected. I think I will take a serious look at sourcehut[1] now. I get a good vibe, but the bus factor scared me away before. [1] https://hg.sr.ht/ https://hg.sr.ht/
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoDon't worry, in the event of my untimely demise there are trusted people with access to the servers to pick up the mantle.
- vnorilo 7y agoSir, I wish you long life and godspeed, but my threat model includes acquihire and lost interest ;) However, I keep talking how we need to avoid monocultures, so I guess it is about time I assume some minor risk.
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agohttps://man.sr.ht/billing-faq.md https://man.sr.ht/billing-faq.md Sourcehut has accepted no external funding and once the alpha period ends, all accounts must be paid. Even with optional payment, it already turns a profit. I'm pretty confident in the sustainability of the service. As for me losing interest, the good news is that I need software hosting no matter what I'm working on, so I'll always be working on it. And, since it's open source and patches are welcome, so could you add anything you need.
- bjoli 7y agoYou just got another paid user. I am very much in the amateur hacker camp, so I might not add much revenue. Anyway, thanks for sourcehut. Mercurial is my preferred way. I have managed to shoot myself in the foot so many times with git that I just gave up on it and since it is my hobby I don't want to spend much time with git.
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoWelcome to sourcehut!
- j0ba 7y agoThis is disappointing. Bitbucket is the premier place to host free private mercurial repos. Just look at the hosting page on the mercurial website. There is literally not a single other place for free private hosting. There may be some smaller ones out there I'm not aware of. Hacker news, question: Have you ever tried mercurial? Don't you like to save keystrokes? Isn't `hg com` easier than `git commit`? Isn't `hg pul` easier than `git pull`? Is there any way to shorten the amount of keystrokes to use git?
- chronial 7y ago> Is there any way to shorten the amount of keystrokes to use git? Sure, you can just set up aliases in your shell and in git. Set an alias in your shell for git → g and in git for commit → c and you can commit with `g c`.
- j0ba 7y agoAwesome, wasn't aware of git aliases. Thank you.
- Arnavion 7y agoJust be careful that if you define an alias that shadows a built-in command, your alias will be (silently?) ignored. Mostly a problem if a future version of git adds a command and clobbers an alias that used to work.
- ad-hominem 7y agoThese are just aliases, they work with any shell commands, they're not git specific. Just fyi.
- philpem 7y agoThere's a really good starter set in the Git manual: https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2/Git-Basics-Git-Aliases https://git-scm.com/book/en/v2/Git-Basics-Git-Aliases I'm so used to "git co" and "git br" at this point (which are effectively analogues of the same commands on Hg) that I have to think for a minute when I SSH into a machine which doesn't have these set up.
- caiocaiocaio 7y agoI feel old. I can literally remember dozens of silver bullet technologies I was told were necessary to know ("you're not a real professional if you don't..."), and then forgotten by nearly everyone. All of these were supposed to save the world and most of these were cutting edge less than ten years ago.
- antonyme 7y agoWhat a damn shame. I use git when I have to, hg when I get to choose. The usability and ergonomics are just so much better. I've never had any performance complaints. I chose Bitbucket over Github specifically because of Mercurial support. Unfortunately it's a business decision and they had to make a tough call.
- throw0101a 7y agoThey link to an SO survey: * https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2018#work-_-version-control https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2018#work-_-versio... where "zip backups" and network copy (each 7.9%) and "no version control" (4.8%) are higher than Mercurial (3.6%). If you're in that boat, I can understand not using git (87%) because its UI sucks (IMHO), and not using SVN (16%) because it needs infrastructure, but Mercurial has neither of those hindrances. Heck, even RCS would be better than nothing at that point, and Hg is better than that.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoWell git is the go-to default at many companies, so junior developers, if they learn anything, will learn git. People using network copy, no version control, or zip backups didn't choose those answers because they preferred them to mercurial; rather, they ended up with those because they either don't yet know about or understand how to use git (or any vcs).
- doubleunplussed 7y agoIMHO mercurial's usage is so low because github/gitlab don't support it. I understand bitbucket not wanting to, but it says nothing about what mercurial's usage would be like if people didn't have to choose between it and being able to use github or gitlab.
- emilycook 7y agoHi GitLab employee. While we don't officially support it, there is a friendly fork project of GitLab CE that does, and we do provide official support to them :) https://heptapod.net/ https://heptapod.net/
- _pmf_ 7y agoStrange. I would have thought that serving more niche customers would be a more sustainable business model than competing against GitHub and GitLab on their home turf. Is Bitbucket profitable?
- nixgeek 7y agoIt’s owned by Atlassian but who knows if revenue generated exceeds costs incurred for that specific product. Somehow doubt they’re going to disclose that. Would be nice if companies were transparent about which products and services made the most money, rather than (best case, public companies) stating earnings for the whole company and breaking it out fairly opaquely through categorizations. On the flipside I could see this being useful information to competitors, and instructive on which parts of your business to attack.
- dylanz 7y agoI remember playing pool with Chris Wanstrath back in the day and he was telling me how he just started a product based on Git. I told him to bail on it and use Mercurial instead! I listed a bunch of reasons why I thought it was the best distributed VCS. I remember shaking my head a bit thinking: "Whelp... good luck with that". I probably lost that game of pool too.
- ddevault 7y agoSourcehut has Mercurial support. It's open source and community maintained, and will remain supported for as long as the Hg community wants it to be. We recently took our Hg team out to Paris to meet the Mercurial community at the first Hg conference, and discussed how we can get involved in the future of Mercurial and committed to continuing to improve our offering into the foreseeable future. I've whipped together a script to help you migrate your repos to hg.sr.ht, for those interested: https://hg.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/invertbucket https://hg.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/invertbucket Let me know how it works out for you - I'd like to hear some test results before I post it to sr.ht-announce. Cheers :)
- vnorilo 7y agoEvaluating hg.sr.ht right now. On quick scan I saw that man.sr.ht has no API reference for hg - I was wondering what the status for that bit is. Thanks!
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoman.sr.ht has an API which is equivalent to git.sr.ht's API except for the portions which deal with querying git data: https://man.sr.ht/git.sr.ht/api.md https://man.sr.ht/git.sr.ht/api.md So you can create and manage repos over the API today. We're still figuring out a good API design for fetching hg data over REST.
- bumbledraven 7y agoThanks for making `invertbucket`! I used it to import my bitbucket repositories and ran into a few issues: 1. `invertbucket` should check that the machine has `hg` installed. (I accidentally ran it on a machine that didn't.) 2. Say my sr.ht username is "thegreengiant" and my bitbucket repository is "abc". At the end of its run, `invertbucket` says: > Imported to: https://hg.sr.ht/srht_owner/abc https://hg.sr.ht/srht_owner/abc That URL 404s. It would be an improvement if `invertbucket` replaced "srht_owner" with "~thegreengiant".
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoThanks for the feedback! Fixed on both counts.
- mamcx 7y agoThis suck big time. HG is by far the best UX of all SCM I have used. Without bitbucket I think usage of hg will drop even faster. The sad thing is that git requiere so much arcane usage that hg have spared me for so much time. I wonder why the worst always win? C, C++, JS, MySql. Don't tell me is for "speed" or "features". Is incredible how much stupid effort and money go in put a lipsick on top of that when nicer ways exists... and are know... and have proved to work... and even faster (look at you, C/C++ build times)... Even MORE bizarre is why not improve the tools coping what is good from others AND cleaning the usage of them? Probably only python of the "good" side have critical mass...
- umvi 7y ago> The sad thing is that git requiere so much arcane usage that hg have spared me for so much time. Like what? I've been using git for 5 years and I hardly ever stray from the set {push, pull, reset, checkout, rebase}. I use VSCode for staging, committing, diffing, etc. though, so that probably spares me some commands, but I rarely (if ever?) have had to do what I would consider an "arcane" command. > Even MORE bizarre is why not improve the tools coping what is good from others AND cleaning the usage of them? Git has improved over time. Why, in the latest release they improved UX for the "checkout" command. Before it could mean "switch branch" or "restore file" but now there are 2 explicit commands: "git switch" (for switching branches) and "git restore" (for restoring files).
- SpartanJ 7y agoI've been using Bitbucket with Mercurial repositories since 2011, both for private and public repos. I can count more than 50 mercurial repos that I'll need to manually move somewhere else. I'm really disappointed right now. I can understand their motives but they need to provide a single click method to at least convert a repo to git (this is a MUST IMHO). I love mercurial but also can see that the community is shrinking, mercurial still relies on Python 2.7, and we are approaching to the EOL of Python 2.7. TortoiseHG also suffers from this, and the release cycle is always out of sync with the hg releases, and this breaks thg. These little things shows the sad state of mercurial, and in the end, this will drive most of the developers away from using it. I guess it was great while it lasted... now, Bitbucket, please provide the developers the right tools to move away from mercurial with celerity.
- altano 7y agoMove your repos to hg.sr.ht: https://hg.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/invertbucket https://hg.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/invertbucket
- SpartanJ 7y agoI'll consider it, thanks for sharing.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoHg already works with Python 3, and tortoisehg's Python 3 development is proceeding at a rapid pace. They're not dead, they just left it to the last minute, relatively speaking. I expect them both to make the cutoff of Python 2 EOL with stable releases. The releases being out of sync is not great, but if you're on Windows you download tortoisehg with a compatible hg, and if you're not your distro's repositories should ensure they don't push a new hg to you before tortoisehg is updated. I went and looked at the history, and the average delay from a mercurial release to the corresponding tortoisehg is only about 3 weeks. Not a big deal. On Arch Linux since tortoisehg isn't in the repos it's a slight pain to hold back mercurial. Hopefully after the Python 3 transition tortoisehg makes it into the repos. ...though if there is not mercurial hosting available by the time bitbucket sunsets support, then maybe I won't care. I really want to keep using mercurial for my public open-source projects.
- ldng 7y agoOver the year I've used CVS, SVN, bazaar, Mercurial and Git. Mercurial has always been the one I struggled the most with. It never clicked with me. Just to respond to some arguments I see floating around. In my last team we switched from Hg to Git and absolutely everyone but the CTO felt more comfortable with it. including the data scientists. To me, Mercurial UI might be friendlier than Git's but it's really a moot point if it does not fit with the way people actually think/work. Also, I sincerely think Git was getting more popular _before_ Github. Granted, it massified the adoption.
- srean 7y agoAnyone knows what happened to Spolky's hginit.com ? It used to be one of the most accessible Hg tutorials out there.
- epalm 7y agoI also miss hginit.com. I've been referring new devs to https://web.archive.org/web/20180924182907/http://hginit.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20180924182907/http://hginit.com... I guess hginit.com disappearing was a signal of things to come.
- daveslash 7y agoI don't know what happened to it, but I was just searching for it as well... I found it on the Wayback Machine. Is good. https://web.archive.org/web/20170320142857/http://hginit.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20170320142857/http://hginit.com...
- mixmastamyk 7y agoAnother casualty of the expanding Github empire.
- fredcy 7y agoDamn, this is disappointing. I've long preferred hg over git but developer preference has clearly moved to favor git. I like using mercurial queues for managing local config changes but I guess I'll have to get better using `git stash`. I hope bitbucket provides some tools to easily convert repos from hg to git. Frankly, though, I'll likely just move from bitbucket now.
- thieving_magpie 7y agoI have 92 mercurial repositories at my company that I'll need to convert.
- dogweather 7y agoOMG, sad. And I'm part of the problem: I've always wanted to use Mercurial; I'd always found its user interface to be an improvement over git; as if it shipped with a great "porcelain" by default. I respect its ability to leak fewer implementation details while still offering plenty of power. But I kept using git for all my projects, and GitHub with it.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoA disaster for me, I've got dozens of hg repos over there. Do they support an automated conversion? If not, probably no reason to use bitbucket any longer.
- jobigoud 7y agoI'm in the same boat. And Mercurial support was the key differentiator for me, I'll probably convert the repos to git (hg is almost sure to die after this) and move to GitHub in the process, including the git repos I have on Bitbucket.
- burner6565 7y agoSince this is likely to attract bitbucket users, I’ll toss out a question in hope someone knows: It appears that in bitbucket enterprise cloud, there is no way for me as an administrator to prevent members of my team from making repositories public to the Internet. Is that true? If so I may need to look to on prem options, or perhaps GitHub enterprise cloud which seems to support better permissions. We deal in sensitive data so can’t risk an analyst publishing them to the net accidentally.
- wooptoo 7y agoWhen I picked up a DVCS years ago I initially went for Mercurial for its ease of use. It had a clean command line interface and it just clicked with me (Git still had some bits written in Perl). It worked very well for my small projects. Its hgweb worked without fuss on top of Apache (which was still popular). Bitbucket was a small time site back then (about 2008) and I mainly hosted the projects locally on a web server. However the industry has voted by putting its weight behind Git and Git has won. It has caught up usability-wise. Its performance is miles ahead of Mercurial. While its underlying model is not straightforward to grok it enables great work flows. Honestly I'm happy with Git and never looked back.
- mcbits 7y ago> June 1, 2020: ... all Mercurial repositories will be removed. It's understandable that they would discontinue Mercurial support, but this part is shocking. No doubt that 1% includes more than a few obscure but historically interesting repos that will disappear because the owner wasn't monitoring their email (or is no longer with us). Is BitBucket really that pressed for disk space? I hope they will reconsider and move those repos to a read-only archive like Google Code and CodePlex did instead of obliterating a piece of history for no good reason.
- flurdy 7y agoFull bullet text: """ * February 1, 2020: users will no longer be able to create new Mercurial repositories * June 1, 2020: users will not be able to use Mercurial features in Bitbucket or via its API and all Mercurial repositories will be removed. """ The February 2020 deadline to prevent creating new Mercurial repos seems too late. Why delay? Ok, not next week by why not 1st November 2019. You will just upset randoms that by accident creates a Hg repo with bitbucket only to be told it will be deleted soon. The June 1st 2020 deadline, is two parts. 1st part of disabling Hg features seems fine. But as you say the second part should be punted way into the future if not never. Sure, cripple it to read-only browsable only. But don't delete. There are plenty of tumbleweed open source projects that won't react before next year and be lost.
- syntheticnature 7y agoI don't think it's about disk space at all. Read only browse means nearly all the same code, with whatever vulnerabilities it has, is there and needs to be supported. I'm sure a good chunk of removing the all Mercurial support is not needing to keep an eye on the code to allow repo browsing, etc.
- BlackFingolfin 7y agoThey don't need to allow browsing it; but at least have a minimal page which shows the presence of the repository, and allow cloning it.
- bovermyer 7y agoA friend of mine is a core contributor to Mercurial. He is... well, I suppose "livid" is as close a descriptor as any.
- scblock 7y agoEnjoy your monoculture.
- gumby 7y agoI'm astonished, just because hg defined bitbucket for me. Else its other features were just OK. Also, though I never found a reason to choose hg I had been told that it fit the Windows file system better than git. If so that wasn't enough.
- loganabbott 7y agoSourceForge still supports Mercurial https://sourceforge.net/p/forge/documentation/Mercurial/#publishing-an-existing-repository https://sourceforge.net/p/forge/documentation/Mercurial/#pub...
- kissgyorgy 7y agoMercurial is officially dead.
- barseghyanartur 7y agoThis is terrible news. I prefer Mercurial to Git. I intensively used both for years and I can't say that Git is any better than Mercurial. I do think they should at least come up with a plan to seamlessly migrate existing repositories to Git. Still, shocking.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DenisM 7y agoGuess I'm taking my money and going elsewhere, then. Several things seem really odd to me: - They are ditching one thing that was a safe harbor from github. - No migration path to Git inside bb service. If I am going to migrate outside bb I might as well move away completely. - Armageddon-style wholesale destruction of the old repos. Could have left the read-only repos on a separate server. Or even just a tarball. It just looks so disorderly and thoughtless...
- cosmojg 7y agoFor anyone looking to jump ship, check out invertbucket (https://hg.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/invertbucket https://hg.sr.ht/~sircmpwn/invertbucket), a script which automates the transfer of mercurial repos from Bitbucket to Sourcehut. Support for transferring tickets and pull requests should be coming soon as well.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoAll my software is in Bitbucket for two reasons: Free private repos and Mercurial. Now that Github has free private repos and Atlassian is removing support for Mercurial, I have no remaining reason to keep my repos in Bitbucket. Sayonara, Bitbucket. You just created a Github customer.
- gitbucket 7y agoI am annoyed at this news. v1. Bitbucket == Mercurial v2. Bitbucket == Mercurial|git v3. Bitbucket == git However, GitHub is better at git, so now GitHub > Bitbucket May bitbucket and it's management forever have it sheets and stocks shorted. They deserve it. Since I want my repos' outsourced and I'm being forced to use git, I am moving to GitHub. Define: git - https://www.google.com/search?q=what+is+a+git https://www.google.com/search?q=what+is+a+git
- z3t4 7y agoOnly reason I use Bitbucket is because of Mercurial. I guess that's what you get for using centralized services. The funny thing is that both Git and Mercurial was designed to be decentralized! But we humans are social creatures, and Github is like Facebook for invert's - instead of posting pictures of your acquaintance you post your software projects. Stars are the likes ... So in order to fully decentralize, the human/social bit also need to be decentralized. But there is also the convenience, while setting up Git and Mercurial hosted repositories is straightforward, I can understand why dev's choose to use a service instead, especially when it's free.
- errnoh 7y agoThe Software Heritage [1] was mentioned in another thread today. They seem to archive source code from most of the popular locations, but Bitbucket doesn't seem to be on the list? If Bitbucket is planning on actually removing Mercurial repos it seems like a good idea to crawl and archive those before that happens. [1] https://www.softwareheritage.org/archive/ https://www.softwareheritage.org/archive/