14 ms·
AMD Rome Second Generation EPYC Review: 2x 64-core Benchmarked
- DuskStar 7y ago> For those with little time: at the high end with socketed x86 CPUs, AMD offers you up to 50 to 100% higher performance while offering at a 40% lower price. Unless you go for the low end server CPUs, there is no contest: AMD offers much better performance for a much lower price than Intel, with more memory channels and over 2x the number of PCIe lanes. These are also PCIe 4.0 lanes. What if you want to more than 2 TB of RAM in your dual socket server? The discount in favor of AMD just became 50%. Well isn't that a kick in the pants.
- snazz 7y agoI'll be interested to see how long it will be before this devastates Intel's business. At the moment, there's literally no reason to buy an Intel desktop or server processor, so how many of the Intel purchases coming from OEMs and big cloud companies are just because of contracts that might let up in a few years?
- steve19 7y agoI think the one reason is that if you need the best gaming desktop performance Intel still dominates, but that little extra performance is coming at a very steep price. My next desktop of will be AMD+Nvidia. Now if only I could avoid the Nvidia tax for deep learning...
- indemnity 7y agoI’ve looked at a lot of the benchmarks and the difference was in the ballpark of 1-5%, which isn’t dominating from my perspective... did I miss a few?
- Funnnny 7y agoDigitalFoundry had an interesting take on frame rate/frame time performance on Intel/AMD. If you look at the graph you can see Ryzen dip down more for a few times when there's more computation or memory throughput needed.
- manbatman 7y agoThat's not true, with more core Ryzen can run game with other apps without any problems it's not the same with Intel though.
- leetcrew 7y agounless you are compiling chrome in the background or streaming, you're not going to saturate even eight cores while gaming. in most benchmarks I've seen, the 9900k still performs better while streaming.
- manbatman 7y agoNow you are talking about Intel's best desktop CPU. of course it performs better while streaming otherwise it would be ..
- 7y ago
- chx 7y agoThere's a very slight advantage of Intel CPUs in non-GPU constrained games (which means more or less 1080p only...). Very slight. Price/performance falls on Ryzen 3 so hard it's foolish to get an Intel for sure. There's no business reason on desktop or server for Intel for sure but there's so much inertia here which AMD needs to counter, it'll take years. Intel is down on the floor until 2021-2022 when their 7nm (which is a smaller node than TSMC's 7nm) begins to ship because a) there's no reason to believe 10nm actually will ship in quantity b) there's every reason to believe even if it does, it's not going to be great, the first iteration of a process is never so and 14nm is so fine tuned by now, it is better in watt/performance which makes Ice Lake look stupid. 7nm is said to be a totally different, independent development and not a fine tune of the (dead) 10nm. Intel has 12B cash at hand though so don't expect them to just go out with a whimper. If their profits go down a little for 2-3 years, they will live. The stock price didn't crash, with good reason. AMD had a net loss for seven consecutive quarters before turning a profit in Q2 2016. Intel won't even turn unprofitable for a similar period of time, just it'll have a littles less profit. And, again, they have a decent sized war chest to draw on if necessary. The chip business is a slow business. In 2012, Intel said they will ship 10m chips in 2015. https://www.crn.com/news/components-peripherals/240007274/intel-charts-course-to-10nm-chips-by-2015.htm https://www.crn.com/news/components-peripherals/240007274/in... This is about the same time when AMD re-hired Jim Keller. AMD saw their window in 2015 when Intel 10nm didn't ship, thrown away K12 in a hurry and brought Zen to market in 2016 -- surely they didn't expect they will have a five year run when Intel can't put up a competition. The fun will start in 2021 when TSMC is expected to have a refined 5nm (they call it 5nm Plus) process which you bet AMD will use vs Intel 7nm.
- ken47 7y agoDisagree. Why would it take years to counter this "inertia?" It's not like you're asking someone to give up a religion they've had from birth. They are being asked to make economic purchasing decisions, and the economics are crystal clear.
- positr0n 7y agoThere are many small and large companies with relatively small compute needs (small meaning the own a small datacenter or two). Lots of the code they are running is _extremely_ legacy, and it may or may not be in their risk tolerance to switch vendors to save a hundred grand a year on CPU costs. Especially if they think like OP and believe Intel will match them again in just a few more years. Why rock the boat?
- devonkim 7y agoCome on, "literally no reason"? Maybe because AMD can't keep up with demand for their new CPUs. I can't buy a Ryzen 3900X without paying substantially inflated ebay prices, the BIOS issues out of the gate are super annoying, and all of these factors are not necessarily technical or performance factors but the fact is that I can get a 9900K right now with mature UEFI firmware on them from reputable motherboard manufacturers, and then I can actually do something with the hardware. I've been holding out on building a desktop because I could go for a while without it but my patience is wearing very thin after waiting months and now having to wait even longer just to get CPUs in stock in the first place. Intel's advantage is OEMs and sheer output volume, but the hyperscale infrastructure folks are going to be shoring up AMD financially while Intel has problems and maybe in two years or so of this nonsense AMD might be much more of a serious decision, but as of this moment it isn't a slam dunk for AMD at all.
- chubbyrabbit 7y ago> I can't buy a Ryzen 3900X without paying substantially inflated ebay prices. I'm experiencing the opposite. There has been so many deals on 3900X that I have to constantly tell myself I don't need an upgrade.
- snazz 7y agoSame here. Find nearest Micro Center, see wonderful deal, spend more than you came in looking to spend, repeat. Unless you don’t have any kind of physical computer store near you, I don’t see why buying it on eBay would be useful.
- gwicks56 7y agoDamn, I have been desperately trying to get one since launch. Think the USA is getting them all, and the rest of the world is getting screwed. I paid on launch day, my store is getting 2 3900x's this month, they have 78 people who have paid in full and are waiting.
- 7y ago
- bobdole12345 7y agoWell, other than the unbroken history of AMD managing to fail when ahead. Intel is a juggernaut because even if it's not shipping the best, it's always shipping something on time, every time.
- clhodapp 7y agoWhat? Intel have been slipping the ship date on their 10 nm process node for years. It's slipped so much that it's likely to not to even be fully released before it is discarded for its successor.
- theevilsharpie 7y ago> Intel is a juggernaut because even if it's not shipping the best, it's always shipping something on time, every time. Intel is in their current situation because their 10 nm process is years late, and is still not able to manufacture high-performance parts like server CPUs in any meaningful quantity for a price that the market would bear. They've also had severe shortages over the past year, which has resulted in orders being delayed for weeks or months. And of course, there's the matter of their products basically being warmed-over refreshes of a nearly 5-year-old architecture (because their new architectures are dependent on 10 nm), which has resulted in comically lopsided performance in AMD's favor, in basically every objective metric that matters.
- crazydoggers 7y agoThere’s still a slight performance advantage with gaming. On top of the fact that it’s still hit or miss getting any Ryzen 9s and getting an i9 is easy, anyone who is shelling out for the RTX 2080 GPUs will probably go Intel. On top of which, given the history, those building gaming machines will assume Intel’s next 10nm cpus will still outshine AMDs in gaming for the foreseeable future.
- leetcrew 7y agoexactly, if you're going to spend $1200 on a GPU, why would you care about saving $30 on a processor?
- gigatexal 7y agoIt’s a good set of first steps. AMD needs to keep executing as they have spent decades as second fiddle to Intel. Intel meanwhile has mindshare, enterprise agreements, and other partnerships that make its position as the market leader very sticky.
- ivalm 7y agoFor desktops gaming still drives a huge market segment where 9700k/9900k still have higher performance (esp if you overclock).
- kilburn 7y agoEven for gaming, the advantage is marginal though, and it comes with a price increase that is often better put into a better GPU. Even formerly die-hard intel gaming shops (Linus Tech Tips and similar) are recommending AMD for most gaming rigs nowadays.
- crazydoggers 7y agoi9 9900K: $484 on Newegg https://www.newegg.com/core-i9-9th-gen-intel-core-i9-9900k/p/N82E16819117957 https://www.newegg.com/core-i9-9th-gen-intel-core-i9-9900k/p... Ryzen 9 3900x: $499 and sold out https://www.newegg.com/amd-ryzen-9-3900x/p/N82E16819113103 https://www.newegg.com/amd-ryzen-9-3900x/p/N82E16819113103 And here’s gaming performance. Far Cry 5 has a 25fps advantage. And yes, I have an RTX 2080 Ti https://www.pcworld.com/article/3405567/ryzen-3000-review-amds-12-core-ryzen-9-3900x.html?page=4 https://www.pcworld.com/article/3405567/ryzen-3000-review-am... So for a large group of people, Intel still makes sense. And my reply was in response to “literally no reason to buy an Intel“ which is clearly just not true.
- archagon 7y agoThunderbolt?
- ipsum2 7y agoFWIW Intel still has an edge over AMD for speciality use cases, I would like to see some benchmarks that use Intel's MKL library to AMD (OpenBLAS).
- wickedsickeune 7y agoYou are correct at that, and that's because for over 10 years, especially in academia / HPC / Sci Comp, AMD was non existent. If they get the edge long enough for the HPC community to care, maybe an alternative will be present. Otherwise, if AMD just overpowers intel in hardware / clocks so much, then it might not be an issue. In addition, some specific software (eg Android emulator on Windows) doesn't exist for AMD CPUs.
- makomk 7y agoThe Android emulator can run on AMD CPUs under Windows 10 as of a year or so ago, actually. It now only requires Intel's HAXM on older versions of Windows and I don't think Zen 2 or recent Intel chips officially support those versions of Windows anymore.
- tsoernes 7y agoYou can still use MKL on AMD and it does yield a perf increase over OpenBLAS
- ummonk 7y agoDoes price matter though? I would imagine power consumption is a much bigger deal.
- ken47 7y agoEPYC Rome wins on perf/watt as well.
- Nokinside 7y agoXeon has been making 50–70% profit margin depending on the Xeon type. Intel's profit margins will take a hit when they are forced to cut prices. It's unlikely that AMD has enough manufacturing capacity to fill all demand, so Intel will still make profit. History: AMD had similar upper hand against Intel with their Athlon processor 20 years ago. Intel's transition to the 180 nm process was delayed and AMD's K7 Athlon was superior microarchitecture. Intel's response was to lower profit margins until AMD was in the ropes again. This time AMD has better change, but don't count out Intel. AMD's success depends on their profit margins when competing against Intel. If Intel force AMD's profits close to zero, it can spoil AMD's technical win. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/INTC/intel/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/INTC/intel/profit-... https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMD/amd/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AMD/amd/profit-mar...
- onli 7y agoCorrect me if I'm mixing up the timeline, but that's the moment in history when Intel used illegal market manipulation to keep AMD out of the OEM market, right? So Intel did more than lower their profit margin, they basically bribed their way through that period. An option they are unlikely to have again, and which as a strategy shouldn't even work anymore for the type of data centers existing today.
- Nokinside 7y agoThey did everything they could, but Intel did not win with just bribery and dirty tricks.
- ncmncm 7y agoI am curious why you think it will not work as well as last time. It is not as if law enforcement is more active now. Generally law enforcement at the moment is forbidden to touch the big fish, since the biggest fish sets policy.
- onli 7y agoWhile I'm similarly critical of US corruption and too big to fail thinking in general, there was a bit of (EU) progress in terms of monopoly control. Like the huge fines Microsoft and Google had to pay. But that would be retroactive and not help AMD. But what helps AMD in advance is the data center landscape. How would Intel force Google, Microsoft and Amazon to use their server processors in their custom servers for their cloud data centers? They can compete on price (though price dumping could alert regulators again), but Intel has zero influence on those three. Thus we see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20643604 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20643604. And smaller OEMs should be hard to pressure given the history and hard to mislead given the big companies validating AMDs processors. Regular vendors for desktops and laptops are already offering AMD, so there seems to be limited danger there.
- StreamBright 7y agoWhat about the motherboard chipsets? In the past AMD had decent CPUs but their other chips were not that great.
- mbell 7y agoThis should be interesting to watch. The new Ryzen CPUs are good, but the desktop market is a rather small portion of the overall CPU market which is dominated by server and laptop. AMD making inroads in the server space is where they _may_ actually be able to eat up some meaningful market share. That said, I wouldn't count the chickens before they've hatched here. AMD did this once before with opteron in ~2006. For them to have holding power they need to keep it up for several cycles, only then will the big fish jump ship. I expect Intel to respond with price cuts, they've been monopolizing the server market for a decade or so now without real competition so they can charge whatever they want. At least in theory since Intel owns fabs they should win a price war.
- liquid153 7y agoAny idea when Zen2 laptops
- ken47 7y agoThis is different than the Opteron days. Today, AMD's offering is substantially cheaper than Intel, both on an absolute and performance-adjusted basis. AMD is now ascending at a time when Intel is plagued by a never-ending stream of embarrassing security flaws, and the market has grown sick of its monopolistic exploitation of its customers. Furthermore, AMD has already designed the next generation chip! AMD could have clearly charged more for these EPYC Rome chips, but they priced low for a reason -- to grab as much market share as humanly possible as quickly as possible, and I believe they will do so.
- AgentOrange1234 7y agoI don’t understand the spec2006 results. In the first table, what are the units? In the second table, are positive or negative percentages good?
- opencl 7y agoSPEC has a reference machine that they ran the benchmark on, the numbers given are (reference machine runtime)/(tested machine runtime). So bigger numbers mean it ran faster, positive percentages are good.
- magicalhippo 7y agoI assume they're throughput numbers[1], going as ~1/(time taken). So higher is better. The percentages for "A vs B" seems to me to be (score_A / score_B - 1) * 100. [1]: https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/spec/cpu2006 https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/spec/cpu2006
- twotwotwo 7y agoPage 4 (https://www.anandtech.com/show/14694/amd-rome-epyc-2nd-gen/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/14694/amd-rome-epyc-2nd-gen/4) lines up AMD's prices, core counts, and frequencies with Intel's. AT says all these have 128 PCIe 4 lanes and support up to 4TB RAM aper socket. Intel's own competitive analysis figured competition in servers "is likely to be the most intense in about a decade" (https://www.techpowerup.com/256842/intel-internal-memo-reveals-that-even-intel-is-impressed-by-amds-progress https://www.techpowerup.com/256842/intel-internal-memo-revea...). Sounds about right. The AMD presentation had announcements from Azure and GCP but not Amazon. How soon Intel gets Ice Lake ready for servers seems pretty relevant here.
- lettergram 7y agoFrom the article, mid-2020 for the Ice Lake equivalent: > Ice lake promises 18% higher IPC, eight instead of six memory channels and should be able to offer 56 or more cores in reasonable power envelope as it will use Intel's most advanced 10 nm process. The big question will be around the implementation of the design, if it uses chiplets, how the memory works, and the frequencies they can reach.
- twotwotwo 7y agoRight, depends on the things AT mentioned, but also on execution: whether the the issues with 10nm are over (now that they've shipped some chips) or if they'll also slow the scale-up to server-sized dies. Intel moving to chiplets could certainly mitigate that risk some, with tradeoffs similar to the ones in EPYC.
- lettergram 7y agoSupposedly, they will only be shipping to select customers initially (and at 28 cores) in 2020.
- frankchn 7y agoAmazon already has 1st generation EPYC servers available: https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/amd/ https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/amd/ so I assume they will follow up as well.
- chx 7y agoQuestion: does anyone know whether the current generation of Google TPU uses PCIe 4.0 already? The POWER9 systems support PCIe 4.0 and last year Google confirmed they use them. If that TPU is 4.0 already then expect Google to buy an ungodly amount of these EPYC servers to match them as Intel have absolutely nothing to match here, not until 2021, next year Ice Lake is only rumored to ship with 26 cores tops.
- lettergram 7y ago> AMD offers you up to 50 to 100% higher performance while offering at a 40% lower price I expect to see many more AMD based EC2 tiers on AWS
- dman 7y agoI wish I had not built an Epyc based workstation last year. This looks like a spectacular release.
- sphix0r 7y agoYeah, I'm interested in those performance penalties as well.
- sangnoir 7y agoIf you had waited until now, then next year you'd be saying exactly the same thing when AMD announces the next iteration.
- sounds 7y agoSell last year's Epyc workstation on the used market and buy a new one. (Seriously - I'm about ready to buy a used Zen1 workstation.)
- bob1029 7y agoAbsolutely brutal TCO improvements... I feel like this could start a new race to the bottom with the hyper-scalers. The implications could be profound considering how concentrated a huge portion of our global compute capacity is these days. Is there a hypothetical point at which it becomes cheaper to spend additional capital in order to remove a perfectly-good Intel server in favor of a new AMD server (considering potential savings on cooling+power+space)?
- ken47 7y agoThe best time to buy an EPYC Rome server was 10 years ago. The next best time is today. Edit: Okay, since some people are downvoting my joke, a more serious answer -- if your server farm is running out of space, and you're currently looking at renting additional space to accommodate your growth, EPYC Rome will take up substantially less space for a given level of performance. This is one case where it may make sense to instantly replace. Another is to test EPYC Rome on a limited basis, to evaluate potential for a larger scale replacement in the future -- I think many companies in the space are going to fall into this camp. Hence in the near future, there will be a modest increase EPYC Rome uptake, followed by a massive increase in the medium-term future.
- Accujack 7y agoPhysical space is almost never a constraint in data centers. It's power and cooling that are almost always the limit. If AMD's chips offer better performance/watt, that would make them attractive. The capital cost of purchasing a server tends to be a smaller number than the cost of the power to run and cool it over its lifetime. However, what also matters is vendor support. Lots of companies have contracts for pricing and support on servers, and they won't necessarily change to save even a large amount of money on one generation of hardware. So for adoption of Zen2 CPUs in the data center, it will be critical for AMD to get the big names on board.
- ken47 7y agoBig names like Cray, Google, AWS, and Microsoft are already on board. The next generation of the Zen chipset has already been designed. EPYC Rome is likely being priced s.t. Xeon's would have to be sold at a loss to match $/perf.
- mroche 7y agoFurther benchmarks on Phoronix of the 7502/7742: https://www.phoronix.com/vr.php?view=28142 https://www.phoronix.com/vr.php?view=28142
- zwaps 7y agowow, I don't think I have ever seen such a dominant benchmark victory across the board... for 40% less dollars.
- lettergram 7y agoAt the end of the Phoronix review, you'll find that performance per dollar is 4x - 8x better with AMD. Assuming Intel slashes prices, I still dont' know if they can match it.
- tyfon 7y agoIt also beats Intel on performance / watts according to the last page. Seems like a slam dunk from AMD.
- aeleos 7y ago> "We designed this part to compete with Ice Lake, expecting to make some headway on single threaded performance. We did not expect to be facing re-warmed Skylake instead. This is going to be one of the highlights of our careers" Looks like AMD expected Intel would actually start to fight back a few years ago when AMD started the Zen and Rome cores, and AMD has been running full steam ahead since then. Meanwhile, in reality, Intel dropped the ball and was too slow to react, and now AMD has basically leapfrogged them. What a time to be alive.
- mktmkr 7y agoIn the “what a time to be alive” category, this is essentially a repeat of Opteron.
- caspper69 7y agoAnd it was a hell of a time to be alive. AMD was first to 1GHz, and the Athlon/Operton opening up the x64 (amd64) architecture was awesome. I didn't go back to Intel until the Core2 duo, which was also an amazing cpu.
- tyingq 7y agoOpteron also (eventually) killed off all the 64 bit RISC players. Quite a juggernaut.
- bri3d 7y agoZen was originally led by the same person as Opteron/K8/Hammer, Jim Keller... who now works for Intel. I think the situation is a bit different this time around though as AMD’s bet on TSMC is paying off in a major way while Intel continue to flounder in the fab space.
- _delirium 7y ago> AMD’s bet on TSMC is paying off in a major way Going back a bit further, AMD spinning off GlobalFoundries and then shopping around for fabs on the open market is definitely looking like a very good decision with hindsight. GF has also, since then, run into problems rolling out a next-gen node, and eventually cancelled their 7nm. Hard to say how much you can credit AMD for foresight there vs getting lucky, but being manufactured by TSMC vs. in-house has worked out well. I don't think this was obvious at the time. Some people thought it was a good move (obviously including the decision makers), but a good number of pundits interpreted AMD giving up on a proprietary in-house fab and relying on commercially available facilities as basically AMD throwing in the towel on being able to compete head to head with Intel as an integrated chip designer/manufacturer, relegating them to more the budget space. To be fair, at the time (2009), TSMC processes were behind Intel's, so you would've had to predict TSMC catching up and surpassing Intel.
- zepearl 7y agoWere Spectre/Meltdown/etc... remediations active while benchmarking?
- Symmetry 7y agoI didn't see it called out in the article but other articles have mentioned applying them and I assume that's standard practice at AnandTech.
- privateSFacct 7y agoThe thing is you can't even get Ryzen inside a Dell or Lenovo machine - so for businesses it's kind of hard to get onboard with they hype. So intel is going to keep up market share until AMD can get into some prebuilt systems.
- PixyMisa 7y agoTyping this on a Dell Ryzen system. They don't have Ryzen 3000 systems out yet, so that much is true.
- adtac 7y agoIn laptops, you can. Lenovo launched the T495 and T495s a couple of months ago. AMD being a part of the venerable T-series is a huge testament to their come back. Not sure about desktops.
- puzzlingcaptcha 7y agoIt's also available at lower price points. Typing from E495 which set me back like 600 EUR.
- CitizenKane 7y agoThe shift for this is likely going to take some time. The design cycle for business machines is glacially slow. Even the first generation Ryzen CPUs are amazing for multitasking and general computing workloads. Zen 2 is quite a bit further beyond that, and is priced highly competitively. That's something that can translate into increased productivity along with savings, but it's going to take some time before OEMs are really ready to take the plunge rather than just dipping their toes in.
- nolok 7y agoWhat ? Lenovo is selling Ryzen based desktop by the truck load. I've bought more than a dozen this year already. Dell is in that game too. What AMD need for consumer computers is to get in the laptop oem build.
- 7y ago
- myrandomcomment 7y agoThe build team has already started to look for a 1RU, 2 server blade, 2 cores each server to buy to test our workload on it. Space and power vs. test and build throughput wins all battles. Great job AMD. Me personally, I just want to know if it can handle Civ6 with huge map and 18 AI players. It’s the little things..
- ndarwincorn 7y agoIDK about EPYC, but my 3700x was blazing through startgame with those settings on Linux Civ 6. Where standard/8 AI was unplayable on my FX8350.
- mastax 7y agoCiv AI is still single-threaded so the 9900k and 9700k are the reigning champions. Zen 2 brought AMD close to parity though.
- myrandomcomment 7y agoIs there any benefit to multicore on Civ6 at all?
- aristophenes 7y agoI prefer the ServeTheHome review, this is more in their wheelhouse: https://www.servethehome.com/amd-epyc-7002-series-rome-delivers-a-knockout/ https://www.servethehome.com/amd-epyc-7002-series-rome-deliv...
- ksec 7y agoYes but when I posted the Anandtech review the ServeTheHome review wasn't up yet. Both are very decent review, I could only hope this get more upvote so other could read on it as well.
- marmaduke 7y ago> OEMs were also reluctant to partner with the company without a proven product. I'm a little puzzled by this; we've been able to buy Ryzen and Epyc stuff from Dell in our university for a while. The biggest problem has been the nvme ssds..
- nolok 7y agoLenovo is all over Ryzen since Zen+ too.
- close04 7y ago> Due to bad luck and timing issues we have not been able to test the latest Intel and AMD servers CPU in our most demanding workloads AT just can't catch a break. Any reviews out there that tested heavy workloads? These are the interesting ones on a CPU like this one.
- alkonaut 7y agoThat AMD prices this aggressively to me indicates that they expect intel to slash prices hard too. If the graphics card releases is anything to go by, AMD might even cut further after intel shows its hand. I know intel have good margins for server parts but it’s also their bread & butter - what would it mean to intel’s bottom line if they had to cut prices (not just to select whales but msrp) by enough to compete here, say 40%?
- tempguy9999 7y agoCan anyone explain this? > ...first generation of EPYC, ... attaching each one to two memory channels, resulting in a non-uniform memory architecutre (NUMA). OK > 2nd Gen EPYC, ... solved this. The CPU design implements a central I/O hub through which all communications off-chip occur. Well it's solved in that all mem accesses now uniformly are a bit slower as all have to go through the new memory access hub. Is this a correct reading? also > The CCDs consist of two four-core Core CompleXes (1 CCD = 2 CCX). ... those CCX can only communicate with each other over the central I/O die. There is no inter-chiplet CCD communication. What is the communication for, presumably the MESI (or whatever AMD uses) cache coherence stuff, and poss. the sync instructions (CAS, atomic increment) too? Anything else I'm missing? Thanks (edit: bloody love that you can click the 'Print This Article' button and it becomes a single long web page. Webbyness as god intended).
- dragontamer 7y ago> Well it's solved in that all mem accesses now uniformly are a bit slower as all have to go through the new memory access hub. Is this a correct reading? Yes. But the new EPYC chips have doubled their L3 cache, and that new memory-access hub has stupidly high bandwidth. The larger L3 cache mitigates the latency problems, while the memory-access hub has more than enough memory-bandwidth to feed all the cores.
- tutanchamun 7y agoservethehome had an interesting paragraph in their review: > We are also not allowed to name because Intel put pressure on the OEM who built it to have AMD not disclose this information, despite said OEM having their logo emblazoned all over the system. Yes, Intel is going to that level of competitive pressure on its industry partners ahead of AMD’s launch. https://www.servethehome.com/amd-epyc-7002-series-rome-delivers-a-knockout/9/ https://www.servethehome.com/amd-epyc-7002-series-rome-deliv...
- tomp 7y agoCan you expand on this a bit? Who is disallowing whom to not name what? From my first reading of your comment, it seems like Intel is pushing partners to not disclose their relationship with AMD? Is that not, like, almost cartel-like behavior?
- tutanchamun 7y agoIt's probably best to ask servethehome since I've also understood it that way when first reading it but on a second read I'm not sure. The wording also reads to me as if they forgot a word or two (but maybe that's because I'm not a native speaker). Here is the entire section: > We are going to present a few data points in a min/ max. The minimum is system idle. Maximum is maximum observed through testing for the system. AMD specifically asked us not to use power consumption from the 2P test server with pre-production fan control firmware we used for our testing. We are also not allowed to name because Intel put pressure on the OEM who built it to have AMD not disclose this information, despite said OEM having their logo emblazoned all over the system. Yes, Intel is going to that level of competitive pressure on its industry partners ahead of AMD’s launch.
- ksec 7y agoAs with all the comment, this really is EPYC. And we have a roadmap of Zen 3 and Zen 4 in the next two years. Zen 3 will likely be some enhancement of Zen 2 with 7nm EUV, Zen 4 will be DDR 5, PCIe 5.0 and 5 nm ,likely some more IPC improvement and I/O Die improvement. The way I see it is that CPU performance for most of my needs has reached the tipping point. Unless something unexpected happen the performance per dollar in the next few years are only going to increase. I would not be surprised to see 128 Core / 256 Threads in Single Socket by 2021 / 2022. The question I have in my head now, when will DRAM price drop to the point, where I have 64 Core EPYC Server with 4TB of Memory and call it a day. While there are some insanely large dataset, for possibly 90% of the Web DB I doubt we have a Database that is 4TB large. And it could all be in Memory. But even at $10 /GB, which is very low already for a 256GB DIMM Stick, 4TB is like $40K