34 ms·
>Popper's tolerance criteria, by contrast, seems clearcut What is that criteria? Because I can easily see people disagreeing on what is and is not intolerant.
by irrational 7y ago
>Popper's tolerance criteria, by contrast, seems clearcut
What is that criteria? Because I can easily see people disagreeing on what is and is not intolerant. Would you agree that saying that a baker in Colorado must make a cake for a gay wedding is intolerant of the baker's belief? Because I'm certain a sizeable proportion of the US population would agree that it is intolerant.
- newhaus1994 7y agoThe criteria is pretty straightforward: you apply the "intolerance of intolerance" to the first intolerant action in the chain, i.e. the one that infringes unprompted on someone else.
- irrational 7y agoSo, the gay couple coming to the baker that doesn't want to make a cake for a gay wedding are the intolerant ones because they are the first intolerant action in the chain? Because you know that will be how it will be spun.
- DonHopkins 7y agoCongratulations on the apt handle. Your argument is irrational because it ignores the fact that the baker committed the first intolerant act in the chain, not the gay couple.
- educationdata 7y agoSo refusing to provide service is "intolerant"? Does this only works on "protected groups", or does it work in general? How about the baker is willing to provide service to the gay couple, but just not the gay wedding? Now, please elaborate how you define "intolerant".
- DonHopkins 7y agoAbsolutely: refusing to provide service to gays, when you provide the same services to other people just because they are not gay, is indeed literally intolerant, without your scare-quotes or any other qualification. What's so hard for you to understand about that? If you're trying to argue for some slippery weaselly nuanced non-standard definition of "intolerant" which excludes bigoted bakers that you just pulled out of your butt, remember that it's a double edged sword that cuts both ways, and also excuses gay couples for not tolerating homophobic bakers. It's not my responsibility to provide you with the standard definitions of common English words, when you're obviously capable of googling them yourself, and obviously misunderstanding them on purpose, and obviously not arguing in good faith. Look it up on Wikipedia yourself.
- antepodius 7y agoThe baker's argument was that it wasn't the same service. They would have baked them a cake; but they didn't cakes with "jim and john's wedding" written on them, in the same way you wouldn't bake a cake with the 14 words on it, even if you'd bake a cake for Richard Spencer.
- DonHopkins 7y agoI don't bake cakes for Nazis, no matter how many words they want on it. Simple as that. Not even cupcakes. No nuances. It's pretty obvious when the baker and their supporters start bending over backwards to make nuanced hypothetical situations and ridiculous unbelievable qualifications, that they aren't making good faith arguments. If their best and most honest argument is that their bible told them to be intolerant bigots, then that's their problem for choosing to take their marching orders from that particular bible, while choosing to do business in that particular state which bans discrimination. The fact that your bible tells you to do something illegal is certainly no excuse for stoning your wife to death or killing gays, either. https://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-sn-manny-pacquiao-bible-instagram-20160218-story.html https://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-sn-manny-pacquiao-bible... So we should have the conversation in which everyone has to make the best arguments they can, instead of trying to go recursively meta with the Paradox of Tolerance, accusing the gays of being intolerant of the baker's intolerance. Simply judge them all on the merits of their best arguments and intellectual honesty and willingness to address valid counter-arguments.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- krick 7y agoHow so? Nobody invited them into his bakery.
- imtringued 7y agoIt isn't irrational because every human being involved experiences a different intolerant act as their first intolerant act. The baker experiences the customer as committing the first intolerance to him. The customer experiences the baker as committing the first intolerance to him. There is no global ordering of intolerant events. This is basically the CAP problem. Every node (or human) sees their own version of the database (or the world) unless all humans coordinate with all other humans (aka impossible).
- afiori 7y agowhat if the "unprompted on someone else" is wrong?
- DonHopkins 7y agoThen you have a discussion about whether that is right or wrong, instead of having a discussion about how recursively meta you can go with "intolerance of intolerance of intolerance of intolerance of intolerance of ...". Call it the "no recursion" rule. Case in point: The baker who refuses to bake a wedding cake for a gay couple is intolerant of gays. That is unjustified and wrong. The gay couple who sues the baker who refuses to bake a wedding cake for a gay couple is intolerant of intolerance. That is justified and right. The baker is unjustified and wrong to complain about the gay couple's intolerance of his intolerance, because he was unjustifiably intolerant himself, first.
- afiori 7y agoOk, let me be facetious. Take the baker situation and push it to full overdrive. Let's say the baker was a victim of sexual abuse and the client was asking to bake a cake rape-themed. (Not in support, you can suppose it was a replica for a documentary let's say). The baker refuses, the client sues, who is the first intolerant? Another case, a client enter the shop of a muslim baker and asks for a depiction of Allah on a cake. Who is the first intolerant? Maybe you have answer for all such situations, but how confident are you that a majority agrees in all cases?
- sinsterizme 7y agoI think both these cases are fundamentally different -- the baker can refuse to bake a certain type of cake, on the grounds of religious expression clashing with the cake he is making. However, it's different if he refuses service on the grounds of the type of people he is making the cake for.
- afiori 7y agoand in the actual case the baker refused to write a message on the cake. he was fine with the clients and with the cake. He only objected to a custom message defying his belief. There are good arguments on both sides. (my stance is sort of about scale as in if he had enough employees to delegate or he was the only cake-maker there)
- incongruity 7y agoIs this confounded or bound up with things like fake news or bad science -- would I, if I owned a platform – call it π-Chan –be prohibited from banning users who espoused anti-vax ideas because I firmly believed they put society at risk (or whatever the justification may be)? I would, on the one hand, be strongly supported by science, but on the other intolerant of others' who have differing points of view. Would I be allowed to run my platform the way I wanted? Whose rights would prevail in that case?
- moate 7y agoThe question is "who do you want to be your consumers" here. Both choices are PR choices. Legally, you're allowed to do either ("neutral platform" and "moderated discourse forum" are both things that are legally allowed to exist in the US at least). If you want to appease the free speech crowd, you let the anti-vaxers stay (Gratz, you're running a Chan!) If you want to appease the intelligent discourse crowd, you ban/moderate people who violate your TOS (Gratz, you're running something closer to Hacker News!)
- wesammikhail 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-refuting_idea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-refuting_idea And if you can´t see why the above applies, maybe you ought not to use the word "straightforward" anymore because you are clearly not qualified to do so.
- DonHopkins 7y agoIs that the ideological opposite of a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licking_ice_cream_cone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licking_ice_cream_cone ?
- wesammikhail 7y agokind of yea!
- mensetmanusman 7y agoIsn’t every choice the exclusion of the alternative?
- ajross 7y ago> I can easily see people disagreeing on what is and is not intolerant Not in the subject at hand. I think pretty much everyone reasonable agrees that "kill the {jews,muslims,hispanics}" (once more, folks, this was the THIRD ethnic massacre advertised on 8chan!) is intolerant, no? Can't we start there?
- balls187 7y agoWhat about "kill the {terrorists|Vietnamese (circa 1960)|germans (circa 1940)|japanese(circa 1940)|rebs (circa 1860}" My response is clearly whatboutism, and I understand that jewish, muslims, and hispanics are greatly different than naming the belligerents of armed conflicts, but this very slippery slope is why historically the US Supreme Court has resoundingly only made the most narrow rulings regarding limiting speech.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoThis is a terribly laid out argument. It's not kill the Germans/Japanese/Vietnamese. Hell in Vietnam we had Vietnamese allies. In Okinawa we routinely tried to stop civilians from committing suicide. There's a massive, massive difference between calling for erasing an entire people simply for existing and fighting a declared military force. No one in the US is going over to wipe out all Arabs, they are going to protect civilians and our own people under a strict set of rules of engagement meant to minimize civilian and not combatant casualties. These people are advocating violence against a people who don't even know they exist or have no defined I'll will against them. You're also conflating government protections for free speech and requirements to support said speech by civilians. No one has to provide your microphone to tell through. The mail will still deliver their racist pamphlets, they can still shout their horrors in public spaces. They don't have a right to have their hate hosted online.
- balls187 7y agoYour reply is a straw man. The original statement was building consensus that "reasonable people" agree killing {some group} is intolerant.
- ddebernardy 7y agoFrankly, I don't know what a specific legal criteria might even look like. In fact, I'm not even sure I'd like someone smarter than me with legal street credentials to come up with one. What I do know is that SCOTUS famously refused to define what porn is [0], and went instead with something to the effect of: I know it when I see it, and this is not it. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it Methinks we as a society can arrive to similar types of rulings for intolerance.
- ColanR 7y ago> Methinks we as a society can arrive to similar types of rulings for intolerance. Freedom of speech is too important to be of secondary value to something that can't even be defined clearly.
- ddebernardy 7y agoOn the contrary. It is so important that it cannot be secondary to something that can be defined clearly. Hence my comment. Edit for clarity: What you think is fine or not today may or may not be considered fine in the future. So there's an incentive to not set what is intolerance in stone on the basis that today's standards may not match those in the future.
- ColanR 7y agoFreedom of speech ensures we can always debate the value of the rest of our rights. Without it, that amorphous 'tolerance' could remove the ability to speak against bad things. Who defines hate speech? Mobs? Who gets to enforce the official definition of intolerant behavior? Trump? Hillary? (hyperbole to make a point) If we don't maintain freedom of speech above tolerance, then we cannot speak out when our words violate the accepted (and as you pointed out, transitory and unpredictable) definition of 'what is fine'. Do you really want to just stop talking, without recourse, when a future mob decides your words are unacceptable?
- 7y ago
- jmull 7y agoIsn't that the key exception of not tolerating intolerance? That is, the baker's belief is not being tolerated because it is intolerant.
- your-nanny 7y agoIf the baker were only baking a cake then it would be. But these were artistic cakes with a great deal of self expression, so issues of compelled speech are forefront. Also, I wonder if, as software devs, we'd feel comfortable being compelled to take on contracts we might object to on moral grounds, e.g. I refuse to engage in projects building weapons and surveillance systems. I'd be quite upset if I were to be taken to court for refusing the contract on those grounds.
- Zigurd 7y agoThat's not a particularly good example. When you enter into commerce you step out of the personal space freedom of thought. And you do so in ways that may seem arbitrary. That arbitrariness is accepted as the price of entry. At least by most people with realistic expectations.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 7y agoThe baker case is very very specific, because it came down to the question: Is the cake art? If it is, and your business is to make are, can you be compelled to make art against your beliefs? If I recall, the bake got rid of all custom cakes and got in further trouble for refusing to tell cupcakes to homosexual couples. But going back to the above post: at one time homosexuality was considered this abhorred plague, just has bad as modern day Neo-Nazism and white supremacy. So who decides what is and isn't acceptable speech? When you start closing down those roads, you easily squeeze out any descent or ability to form new moral ideas. In the case of 8chan, you're spreading these people to even more constrained services that amplify their view. You don't get less hate; you just bury it underground and give them they feeling like they're being persecuted. It will make the situation worse, not better.
- merpnderp 7y agoYour last point seems spot on. The only way to get rid of nazis is to change their minds so they are no longer nazis. It should have been easy to show him that skin color doesn't determine culture or politics and that his actions were going to do nothing but drastically weaken his cause.
- krustyburger 7y agoI can think of at least one other way to get rid of Nazis, as depicted in the Quentin Tarantino film Inglorious Basterds.
- Renevith 7y ago"You don't get less hate; you just bury it underground and give them they feeling like they're being persecuted. It will make the situation worse, not better." I think the recent rise in white supremacist violence fueled by viral media on mainstream platforms like Youtube and Twitter is a pretty strong argument against this belief. Any content on such large and familiar platforms gets to borrow some sense of legitimacy, and people who consume the content have some plausible deniability. Furthermore, algorithms that favor "engagement" create the exact constrained hate-filled extremist communities you are picturing... but then actively draw users into them from the rest of the platform! http://facebook.com/l.php?u=https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-youtube-drives-viewers-to-the-internets-darkest-corners-1518020478 http://facebook.com/l.php?u=https://www.wsj.com/articles/how... Having this content "above ground" is truly leading to more hate, not just making the existing hate more visible.
- greglindahl 7y agoA majority of the US population was tolerant of refusing service to N——--—— when it became illegal. Put another way, it’s rare that the rights of minorities are established by majority vote, even if these rights are owed by the Constitution.
- sterkekoffie 7y agoI'm sorry. Refusing service to whom?
- scarejunba 7y agoTo black people who they referred to via a racial slur.
- greglindahl 7y agoIt seems amazing that you might not know, but in your case, may I recommend the film Blazing Saddles? These days, it’s usually called the “N-word”.
- mkl 7y agoThe strange pattern of dashes you used suggested something else. Why not just say something clear like "African Americans" or similar?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sterkekoffie 7y agoI did know. That was an "um, come again?" not a "can you repeat that?" Your comment literally reads as "they used to tolerate refusing service to (slur)s." Not only was it totally inexplicable to use the slur in the first place, you didn't qualify it in any way. No quotes, no "people they called," nothing. You just used it. Absolutely insane.
- mushufasa 7y agoI think it can be simple. Intolerance is a set of beliefs or behaviors that exclude. Cake baker would be in the wrong, because he excludes. It doesn't matter how many people hold an intolerant belief for that belief to be intolerant.
- irrational 7y agoSo nobody can exclude anyone else from anything? That would mean any organization is not free to stipulate who can and cannot be a member of that organization. Is the American Medical Society intolerant for excluding someone who does not believe in vaccines?
- Y14NZZRhRT5 7y ago> beliefs or behaviors that exclude Exclude, as in a company that excludes a website from their platform? Simple huh.
- jquery 7y agoI get the feeling that most people in this thread citing Popper haven't thought about it very hard.
- dwild 7y agoAre you intolerant if you won't let me enter your house? You let your friend enter, thus you exclude me. Something even what seems simple, isn't so simple.
- gdulli 7y ago> Would you agree that saying that a baker in Colorado must make a cake for a gay wedding is intolerant of the baker's belief? The whole point of that position is to prevent exactly that society. Where the hate, fear, discomfort, prejudice based intolerance grows to cause a society to degenerate into a sizeable proportion of a population deciding another proportion is morally wrong for preferring their own gender. The goal of preventing that dysfunction supersedes word games about one type of intolerance being speciously equated to another.
- Chazprime 7y agoBecause I'm certain a sizeable proportion of the US population would agree that it is intolerant. It doesn't matter. Religious freedom doesn't come before the civil rights of gay people. Gay marriage is the law of the land in the US; if your business can't service the needs of its citizens because of your religious beliefs, perhaps you shouldn't be in a position to be serving the public. It's really that simple.
- bumby 7y ago> Religious freedom doesn't come before... It's literally the first right in the Bill of Rights. I'm not saying anything about gay rights, just that freedom of expression lays the foundation for all other rights
- zaroth 7y agoThe Supreme Court disagrees with you, but the other response lays out why that is so.