18 ms·
YouTube's problem is their allergy towards using humans. AI technology isn't advanced enough to replace empathy yet. They simply need to add more humans into
by jedberg 7y ago
YouTube's problem is their allergy towards using humans. AI technology isn't advanced enough to replace empathy yet. They simply need to add more humans into their processes.
Copyright claims is a perfect example. That system is abused by large companies who know how to exploit their algorithms and they know it is worth it because there will be no humans in the loop to stop them.
If YouTube wants to remain viable, they just need to bite the bullet and hire a whole bunch of people.
- CSMastermind 7y agoI've seen videos analyzing the YouTube trending tab and suggesting that human moderation suppresses videos from 'controversial' creators like Joe Rogan and PewDiePie. It's dangerous to become the arbiter of taste, I can understand Google's aversion to more human involvement beyond just the problems with scale.
- cowpig 7y agoThe algorithms are a proxy for some youtube engineers' tastes
- majewsky 7y agoThat's a popular conspiracy theory, but it doesn't hold up to Occam's Razor. The simpler explanation is that content from all sides gets buried to some extent, but it appears biased to people because they only notice when their own content is buried.
- Scoundreller 7y agoWhy is it hard to believe that an engineer would engineer something that agrees with their own beliefs?
- true_religion 7y agoIt’s because of the way the conjecture is structured. It proposes that we believe a multi billion dollar corporation would risk their profit margins on the tastes of one engineer in the shadows.
- SkyBelow 7y agoOccam's razor would say that such a large corporation does not have the direct controls to monitor every single actor. Is it so hard to find actors acting against the interest of their employer? I've even personally experience cases where the actors are rewarded for such actions due to flaws in the incentive structure.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dcole2929 7y agoBecause most people don't work in silos that allow them to operate with impunity. I'd assume at a company the size of google any feature is going to have minimum of 3-4 different sets of eyes on it between Engineering, QA, UX, and Product.
- scj 7y agoSaying AI does funky things from time-to-time is hardly an extraordinary claim. Meanwhile, an individual injecting bias without the hack's true purpose being obvious to co-workers would be difficult. The more subtle and circumstantial the hack, the more likely it will be broken/ignored by someone else's changes. A hack is still possible, but I'd want evidence of intentional bias before entertaining the claim.
- 50656E6973 7y agoAlgorithmic bias does not have to be an intentional "hack" to have drastic effects.
- mistermann 7y ago> That's a popular conspiracy theory, but it doesn't hold up to Occam's Razor. Occam's Razor isn't some sort of physical law that governs human behavior. https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor > Occam's razor (or Ockham's razor) is a principle from philosophy. Suppose there exist two explanations for an occurrence. In this case the one that requires the least speculation is usually correct. Another way of saying it is that the more assumptions you have to make, the more unlikely an explanation. Occam's razor applies especially in the philosophy of science, but also more generally.
- majewsky 7y agoThat doesn't refute my point. A razor is a tool for working with limited evidence, which is exactly what I'm doing.
- mistermann 7y agoStatement #1: > That's a popular conspiracy theory, but it doesn't hold up to Occam's Razor. This comment is open to interpretation. A reasonable interpretation is that something must hold up to Occam's Razor, or else it is not true, especially with the inclusion of "That's a popular conspiracy theory". In fact, the "conspiracy theory" charge is also flawed. The speculative claim "The algorithms are a proxy for some youtube engineers' tastes" may actually be true. We do not know. Statement #2: > The simpler explanation is that content from all sides gets buried to some extent, but it appears biased to people because they only notice when their own content is buried. This persuades the reader, perhaps based on a presumed knowledge of the phenomenon of confirmation bias, that any such beliefs are likely an example of such confirmation bias. Again, the truth is not known. If you don't like your comments being interpreted, you could tighten them up to minimize the need or possibility for interpretation.
- Covzire 7y agoI think he's saying that positing Occam's Razor isn't proof of anything. If he's not, then I'm saying it, and that it gets over applied to the extreme.
- batty_alex 7y agoIt's no conspiracy, we all encode our beliefs into what we do. I don't think the poster is suggesting it's on purpose. Occam's Razor would suggest it's more work to take bias out, I would think.
- teddyh 7y ago“You know, you can remove men like Alan and me from the system, but we helped create it. And our spirit remains in every program we designed for this computer.” — Dr. Walter Gibbs, Tron, 1982
- 50656E6973 7y agoHave you never heard of algorithmic bias? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algorithmic_bias https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algorithmic_bias It's quite real, and it is not illegal (in the US), so asserting this is a "conspiracy theory" is silly. Software engineers are human beings, so of course they have inherent bias.
- liability 7y agoThe very term "conspiracy theory" is frustratingly flawed in the first case, in practice being nothing more than a perjorative for anything that runs contrary to the official narrative, where 'official' is highly context sensitive. In practice it means 'a theory about a conspiracy' with the implication that conspiracies aren't real and therefore the a theory involving a conspiracy is wacky bunk. But sometimes the official narrative is that there was in fact a conspiracy, and in those cases the term 'conspiracy theory' is not typically used. A prime example is the 9/11 Commission Report which describes in great detail a conspiracy to commit mass murder. When it comes to 9/11, everybody agrees there was a conspiracy. I've yet to even hear rumor of anybody who believes that day was a series of unlikely coincidences. Whether you think it was bin Laden or Dick Cheney, it's obvious somebody was doing some conspiring. I think the difference between the logical and practical meanings of the term is rooted in a specific case in which popular theories were theories about conspiracies, but for which the official narrative is that the guilty party didn't conspire with anybody. Obviously I'm talking about the assassination of John F. Kennedy.
- moate 7y agoSure it does. I'm hypothetically designing a filter that checks for objectionable content on my site. You find any use of skeletons objectionable. I don't, if they're cartoon skeletons. My filter will not prevent cartoon skeletons from being posted, but will post real skeletons. Bias has been introduced. The fact that "both sides" are affected doesn't mean there's no bias, it means there's > no bias. It's literally impossible to censor something without SOME bias, because somewhere, someone doesn't find the thing you censor objectionable.
- asdfman123 7y agoMy right wing friend argues that Google straight up manipulated search results to harm Trump and I don't have any evidence to argue against him. https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Epstein%20Testimony.pdf https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Epstein%20Tes... I wouldn't be surprised if there's an anti-alt right bias (which frankly I don't feel so bad about because many of those folks are toxic). Also, to be pedantic that's a misapplication of Occam's razor. The simplest explanation to explain nature is likely true. Nature likes simple laws. People and organizations, however, can be endlessly complex.
- nfrbc 7y agoThat's funny, because the only political video recommendations I get are right wing videos, despite actively avoiding them for years. I guess when it comes to politics the Youtube algorithm just shows whatever the user doesn't want to see.
- p1necone 7y agoYoutubes PS4 UI "breaking news" section is exclusively videos about brexit/boris johnson (this was even before he became PM) for me despite me not living in the UK and having zero interest in the topic. It's weird.
- zimpenfish 7y agoAlthough bear in mind here that Epstein has a long-standing beef with Google that may be introducing a bias here. > In 2012, Epstein publicly disputed with Google Search over a security warning placed on links to his website. [...] Several weeks later, Epstein admitted his website had been hacked, but criticized Google for tarnishing his name and not helping him find the infection. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Epstein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Epstein
- caconym_ 7y agoHere is a thought experiment: there are two political parties vying for control over the government of a country. Ahead of an election, leaked documents are published on the internet describing a plan by one of these parties to tear down the institutions of democracy in that country and install themselves permanently as a dictatorial elite. This party's political enemies will be rounded up and killed on an ongoing basis by a militarized police force, women will be stripped of their rights and property and reduced to chattel, possession of subversive materials will be punishable by torture and death, and so on. This is all outlined in the document, which was written and reviewed by the leaders of that party. They've been caught red-handed! The other party has its skeletons-in-closets, but no analog to the above-described document exists. So, people using popular search engines to research their options ahead of election day find this horrifying information about party A and nothing comparable for party B, and they end up voting for party B mostly on this basis. So, those search engines, despite providing results that faithfully reflect reality without a priori bias toward either party, will (hopefully) greatly influence the outcome of the election. Is that bad? Should they have censored this document in results so that nobody comes away from a web search with different opinions than they had going in? Is finding the truth an unacceptable thing for "big tech" to facilitate? It's like when politicians like Steve King complain that search results for their names make them look bad. To me, if you conduct yourself as a racist, bigoted lunatic on the public political stage, that's what a web search result about you should say. I recognize that statements like "racism is bad" are subjective value judgments, but that's rolled up in all of this too: if as a society we don't think racism and other bigotries are bad, then this sort of search result won't be seen as negative. So there's some admission here that Steve King and his ilk know their words and actions are viewed negatively by a large segment of the population and so they would like them to be suppressed. By not suppressing them, are major search engines exhibiting a bias? No, not really. I don't think so. P.S. The burden of proof falls on the purveyors of conspiracy theories, not the other way round.
- RickS 7y agoI've always found this argument strange. Your comment isn't specific enough, so I don't want to put words in your mouth, but in general – Do people really believe youtube engineers are encoding their values into the algorithm, intentionally or unintentionally? Intentionally, I just can't imagine. What might this look like? How does it get through code review? Is it broad enough to apply to the entire ranking algo, or does it only act on tiny pockets that the offending engineers specifically care about? In the unintentional case, certainly they're twisting specific knobs like engagement time, ad revenue, vids watched per session, etc... but is that encoding a specific person's taste, or a broader company's thirst for revenue? Do they even care about taste, or just metrics? In other words, I find it suspect that youtube's policy is "More Jordan Peterson conflict vids", and more likely that it's "float high activity posts to the top", creating an echo chamber. To be clear, I think there's some blame that rests on youtube eng (and let's be realistic, the broader product teams bossing eng around). But it's not for encoding their tastes, it's for indiscriminately allowing the tastes of their markets to echo in a feedback loop that becomes a screech of extreme content. Not always anti-social, or even politically directional, just extreme flavors of whatever it is.
- rowanG077 7y agoUnintentionally. Of course they are doing it. Youtube's content policy is so laughably bad that they probably have no choice but to take their own interpretation and use that.
- bluedino 7y agoThey have so many goofy things going on over there. One example is certain bands will never make 'trending'
- mattr47 7y agoIt is definitely possible. Imagine an engineer gets approached by some other corporation that wants to boost a few videos, ads, etc. It would not take much to nudge the system in that direction. The resulting payoffs could be in the billions.
- jedberg 7y agoThey do apply humans but not where it matters to creators. A lot of creators hate their automated compliance schemes. Curation is terrible too, when it comes to kids content. I won't let my kids use YouTube kids anymore, it's awful. It used to have mostly appropriate kids content, but now people have gamed it.
- RickS 7y agoI've seen others that allege that the YT related-to algo is being systematically gamed to raise the prominence of such videos, so the removal is a return to norm, rather than a suppression. What's frustrating is that we don't have many ways to find out what's true. Youtube's algo is an arbiter of taste whether they're happy about it or not. I'm not sure it's possible to be apolitical here.
- ralusek 7y agoYes it is. Just recommend videos similar to ones you've watched, and attempt to cater neutrally to your sensibilities. Use views and engagement to determine when something is trending. That's apolitical. Arbitrarily excluding Joe Rogan or PewDiePie is political.
- MrMember 7y agoI think it's pretty clear that "trending" videos are manipulated. I've seen a video with 10k views and five times more dislikes than likes show up in trending.
- kace91 7y agoApparently dislikes count almost as much as likes for popularity - videos that evoke an emotional response are considered better by YouTube. It's a general trend in social networks, because it leads to more views, and one of the causes of the current environment of polarization and toxicity.
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoUnless you know the algorithm for how "trending video" is selected -- I certainly don't -- you can't say that that's "manipulation." Is it a number of clicks over a certain period of time? What's the period of time? How many clicks? And most importantly, how much of what any given user sees as "trending" is based on contextual information: what they've most recently watched, what they tend to watch on average, what channels they're subscribed to? An awful lot of discussion around YouTube and human curation/moderation elides just how much content they're dealing with; the most recent figures I've seen -- which are over a year old at this point -- show that about 500 hours worth of video is uploaded to YouTube every minute. If we figure an average video is about 15 minutes (a 2017 statistic I found suggested that "the average length of a first page YouTube video is 14 minutes, 50 seconds"), that's 2000 videos a minute -- over 30 a second. Is it impossible that YouTube employees have secret levers to raise and lower the profile of individual videos and channels? Of course not. But it's absurd to think that such manipulation is common, let alone corporate policy.
- munmaek 7y agoNot only is it manipulated, it's flagrantly obvious. PewDiePie for example trends in many countries except the US [e.g. 45 times in Canada, 42 times in Germany vs 1 time in the US], and it's not just him either but many "controversial" channels. Source: an analysis of 40,000 trending videos [7 months of trending tab videos]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqBeXJ8Zx8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqBeXJ8Zx8
- root_axis 7y agoPewDiePie is literally the most popular vlogger on the internet by a wide margin, and Joe Rogan is the biggest podcaster on the platform, I find it hard to believe that any "suppression" they are facing is at all significant.
- shard972 7y agoLiving under a rock, there was a statistical analysis recently which proved CNN gets trending multiples more times than someone like PDP with magnitudes less views.
- aphextim 7y agoThis is a video I recall watching recently that backs up your point. Not sure if anyone has refuted this person's points but they are pretty alarming no matter what side of isle you sit. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqBeXJ8Zx8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqBeXJ8Zx8 (What 40,000 Videos Tell Us About The Trending Tab)
- ape4 7y agoThey could improve the AI to figure out when it doesn't know something. As for a cheap way to have humans in the loop, some kind of voting by trusted creators might work.
- blakesterz 7y agoI don't really disagree with you, but I can't even imagine what "hire a whole bunch of people." looks like in this case, the numbers would be enormous I would think.
- glitchc 7y agoThe cost of the number of humans required to exclusively curate youtube would render the platform unprofitable in very short order.
- PLenz 7y agoThen maybe they go out of business. Capitalism doesn't guarantee that a firm's business plan will work forever.
- glitchc 7y agoAs long as the advertisers don’t complain, their AI-based business model is perfectly viable. On youtube, both the creators and the consumers are the product. The advertisers are the customers.
- root_axis 7y agoWell yeah, the point is that YouTube would not engage in a business plan that they believe would put them out of business.
- howard941 7y agoAnd I don't disagree with you but the parent company is ginormous and the monetary sums almost unfathomable. Its revenues may comfortably support an enormous number of well-paying jobs.
- astrange 7y agoAlphabet's revenues are already supporting those jobs, though. People don't go to Google to do useful work, they go because the owners are hoarders and like collecting engineers to keep them in a zoo and stop them from starting competitors. Thus Google will hire Vint Cerf because they think he's cool, even though he's not going to contribute anything, but what forum moderator is cool enough for a PhD hoarder to keep around?
- hrktb 7y ago> They simply need to add more humans into their processes As usual, how many ? In particular if we are talking copyright claims abuse, could you give a ballpark number of the number of humans you think youtube needs to hire ?
- jedberg 7y agoEnough so that a human can review every claim. I don't know how many claims they process in a day so I can't give a hard number. But I suspect the number of copyright claims would go down significantly once they have a bunch of people reviewing them, because the erroneous claims would become unprofitable, assuming they punish entities that make too many erroneous claims.
- hrktb 7y ago> enough That could be a tenth of the planet’s working population, and we all know it. It’s not like youtube’s scale is some well kept secret. If we are thinking about any serious solution and not some philosophical one, just throwing bodies at the issue is a no go (and would be inhumane in my opinion, I don’t want even millions of people spending their life dealing with copyright claims) Either change the rules about who can emit claim, change how claims are emitted, change the effect of the claims so they’re not so drastic. There’s many realistic directions the issue can be taken.
- Moru 7y agoIf there would be a button for claiming copyright that has a checkbox above saying "I accept liability for falsely claiming copyright." the problem might fix itself after enough lawsuits?
- Despegar 7y agoA bunch of countries are going to force them to do it anyway.
- RickS 7y agoIs it even possible to scale a human operation to this level, even with youtube's checkbook? It's not that AI needs to replace empathy alone, it needs to replace culturally and legally nuanced judgement about copyrighted works, among other things. That's hard to teach fast to a mechturk type workforce, and staffing a team of people competent enough to understand that nuance at youtube's scale has to be prohibitively expensive if it's even possible. Humanizing operations buys quality at the expense of putting a upper bound on scale. Few companies are willing to accept that ceiling for fear of losing market share.
- dawnerd 7y agoNo but they should be putting more humans towards their larger creators. Anyone with over 100k subs shouldn’t have to beg on social media just for YouTube to take action. Some creators have direct contacts but even those contacts are limited in what they can do.
- RickS 7y agoThat makes some sense. I'm not sure where I stand on it. On the one hand, it seems a bit unjust that smaller creators should be snuffed out for things that wash off the back of established players. A two tiered justice system isn't just. On the other hand, it's a reasonable (and more cost effective) way to do more than nothing. A bit gross, but it would probably work in YT's favor to suppress cries of injustice early. Would this even be a scandal if it only hit small creators?
- TulliusCicero 7y ago> A two tiered justice system isn't just. Luckily, this isn't the real legal system. The way I look at it, it's really about the users affected, rather than creators. A creator with 100k fans has more people depending on them than a creator with 100 fans. It makes sense that Youtube would be more careful with the former than the latter, because of the customer impact.
- icelancer 7y ago
- nickjj 7y ago> Copyright claims is a perfect example. Yep. One of my favorite subscribers to watch is some guy (Harald Baldr[0]) who travels around remote areas of the world and vlogs it. But he's said a number of times how even 10 seconds of background music can cause his video to get demonetized and then all ad revenue for the video goes to the record label who owns the copyright and there's absolutely nothing he can do to combat it. This happens even if his video is 30 minutes long and has nothing to do with the music at all -- it just so happens he's walking past a store or hotel lobby that has music on. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKr68ZJ4vv6VloNdnS2hjhA/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKr68ZJ4vv6VloNdnS2hjhA/vid...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mebutnotme 7y agoYouTube are actually adding some tech to help with this. In future when making a claim you have to add the timestamps in the video where the copyright occurs. Then the creator will get that info as well as a few simple quick-fix options to cut out that portion of the video or replace it. It's long overdue but they do seem to be making some strides to help creators at last.
- kevingadd 7y agoYes, but will it detect the claims and allow you to fix them without stealing all your revenue?
- anticensor 7y agoYes, but subject to claimant's approval if you did not remove the offending sections.
- dvtrn 7y agoA part of me feels like claimants will find a way of gaming this and making their approval a series of endlessly nudged goalposts...given the way IP holders are already taking advantage of the tools already at their disposal.
- asdkhadsj 7y agoWhile I agree with you, I think you over emphasize the technology and under emphasize the flawed contracts. Eg, the copyright claim system seems fundamentally designed for abuse. You can't throw humans at it and expect it to work properly, it's working as designed now. You could change it, have humans handle the decision making or w/e - but if you are going to change it you could also "simply" write a better contract. Something not so flawed and easily abusable; of which there have been many ideas, discussions, etc.
- root_axis 7y agoI think Facebook proved pretty clearly that humans are not a solution to this problem. It doesn't matter if it's an algorithm or a human, at the end of the day the creators believe YouTube wants to censor their content so they will ascribe that motive to the execs, the engineers writing the algorithms, or the humans manually curating content.
- white-flame 7y agoEven as a non-youtuber, I think it's been made quite clear that the "motive" is selling ads, and advertisers don't want to be associated with particular topics or tones. It's no longer "Broadcast yourself", but "Deliver us specific content we can monetize, and don't dare touch major IP holders' content", which is a completely different creator audience.
- root_axis 7y ago> Deliver us specific content we can monetize, and don't dare touch major IP holders' content The creators are complicit in this agenda, that's the reason for the backlash, they have an expectation of income from YouTube and when they run afoul of the algorithm it hurts their paychecks.
- VikingCoder 7y agoNo. Adding humans is a terrible idea. "More Than 500 Hours Of Content Are Now Being Uploaded To YouTube Every Minute". Do that math. Filing copyright claims can be completely automated. Humans can't keep up with that. In my opinion, YouTube should enjoy Safe Harbor laws. When someone wants to make a Copyright claim, they should have to post a bounty. If their claim is found to be without merit, they forfeit the bounty to the person who created the video in question. And this should be resolved by a governmental judicial group, who also gets a cut of the bounty.
- jedberg 7y agoBut you just proposed the solution. A penalty for a failed copyright claim. Penalty+human intervention would cut the claims dramatically.
- pjc50 7y agoYouTube is already covered by safe harbor, and in theory making a false copyright claim is perjury! It's just that the law isn't going to be enforced in that direction.
- xanipher 7y agoBut most of this content will get a negligible amount of views, which means that most of the conplaints come from a much lower number of videos.
- la_barba 7y agoYour math is flawed. This is about reviewing videos that face copyright strikes. Every single minute of uploaded content does not need to be reviewed. And on top of that there are several technology aids that can be used to shorten review times - while still having some human involvement. > If their claim is found to be without merit, they forfeit the bounty to the person who created the video in question. That would mean there needs to be an appeals process and humans who do the reviews, right?
- VikingCoder 7y agoMy math is not flawed. I highlighted that filing copyright claims can be completely automated. The punishment for doing so is nothing. I'm proposing a way to limit the false copyright claims. It also shouldn't be Google's responsibility to resolve copyright claims. If it's Google's responsibility, then you're just raising the barrier to entry for any YouTube competitor. The people who benefit from Copyright need to themselves pay for fairly enforcing copyright. I can't imagine another way around it.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoDon't think youtube wants the liability that comes with active decisions. Imagine making a mistake that favors a pirate, lawsuits. Make a mistake that favors a copyright troll, endless hate?
- notatoad 7y agoYouTube does have human moderators though. YouTube just make a point to pretend they don't exist and the PR tries to make you think all moderation is algorithmic, because the alternative is angry YouTubers trying to retaliate against human moderators. They can hire more people, but they will (and should) never let you call them up and tell at them after your video is demonetized.
- unicornfinder 7y agoIndeed. A friend of mine used to work for a company that shared an office with them. There's far more human work involved than YouTube wants people to think.
- pessimizer 7y agoI think this is absolutely wrong. Youtube algos offer plausible deniability, something that was existentially threatening to any future profitability for youtube in the case of copyright claims. I'm fairly sure that most of the content watched on youtube was uploaded by someone other than the copyright holder, at least historically. Having an algo people have to actively thwart, can be unaware that the particular content is copyrighted, and/or generates a significant enough number of false positives that google can claim that they're trying hard enough to damage a portion of their legal business is a tool in and of itself. Not using an algo makes it clear you're doing editorial, and once you're doing editorial, oversight follows. Anyway, even with the algo you can do as much editorial you want through training and dispute resolution. By slow-walking some disputes and fast-tracking others, you can change the shape of your business to hopefully be more independent of legally fragile stolen content. The Trump/Russia conspiracy was a boon to all of these algorithmically filtering DMCA carriers, now they can actually explicitly filter points of view. I decided that point was inevitable anyway after I heard of the first facebook censoring of an anti-wingsuit post. IMO humans + that degree of editorial = worst case scenario, at least laundering it through the AI means that editorial requires some cost and degree of engineering skill. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/adventure/features/why-are-so-many-base-jumpers-dying/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/adventure/features/why-ar... > “The post got deleted by Facebook, and I pissed off the entire community,” says Lewis. “My message was followed up by the most fatal month in BASE. I just painfully sat back and watched my friends die one after the other.”
- la_barba 7y agoYour point seems to be hiring humans is wrong, because YouTube incorporated more AI to pretend like they're doing something, remain in the good books of copyright folks and make themselves more money. Is that correct? So, what if a person does not sympathize with Google or care about them making more money? Ultimately your perspective is shaped by whose side you're on.
- pessimizer 7y agoMy point is that hiring humans is wrong for Google. > So, what if a person does not sympathize with Google or care about them making more money? I have no advice for them. They should do what makes them happy. My point is that Google does not sympathize with them (mostly because it is not a person) and makes decisions based on how the people who control it will benefit.
- Crontab 7y agoThe copyright problem isn't just on Google's end - copyright complaints should be required to be human generated as well. Otherwise anyone can be de-platformed/DDOS someone with bogus automated copyright complaints. > they just need to bite the bullet and hire a whole bunch of people. This issue is not specific to Youtube but to all platforms where users can post. I don't see how Facebook or Twitter or Reddit can hire enough people to review their communities.
- proc0 7y agoHumans are not scaleable.
- Pxtl 7y agoThe Youtube Kids is another good example - algorithms gave us ElsaGate.
- ganzuul 7y agoWasn't that the time when little kids chose to look at super weird content? I think that was utterly fascinating. A long hard look at the dark side of the psyche.
- hitpointdrew 7y ago> That system is abused by large companies who know how to exploit their algorithms Not even this, but the algorithms are designed in way that is bias towards the person making the copyright claim. It isn't like neutral algorithm and the companies just figured out how to leverage it better than creators, it is literally built in their favor.
- Cookingboy 7y ago>If YouTube wants to remain viable, they just need to bite the bullet and hire a whole bunch of people. I completely agree, but that's against everything Google wishes for, which is a world where everyone is 100% online 100% of the time with their data 100% in the cloud and decisions being made by AI 100% of the time. Pushing for human intensive operation inside Google might as well be career suicide, this is why they would much rather keeping spending large amount of resource on "improving the algorithm" instead of just hire more humans and make more progress with a fraction of the cost.
- dijksterhuis 7y agoWRT copyright claims: “Abused” in a similar way to how YouTube existed for (something like) 10 years without paying a single iota of money to anyone for copyrighted material? I’d call that abuse of copyright law myself (neglect can be a form of abuse). Copyright claims is YouTube finally existing within the scope of the law. There are implementation issues - rerouting all money on a first come, first served basis is wrong - but Rome wasn’t built in a day. And, from what I know of large record labels, they don’t know how to exploit the algorithms themselves. Most of them work in Microsoft Excel. Beating the claims system is beyond them. They have software that they’ve bought to do that for them!
- ksec 7y ago>YouTube's problem is their allergy towards using humans. AI technology isn't advanced enough to replace empathy yet. Not really a Youtube problem, but Google Problem. Google and Apple seems to operate at completely opposite end of spectrum. There is nothing Human about Google's Product and Services, even if they did try, it is as if it was designed by Data Mining and Algorithm. But it was fast, efficient, and instantaneous. Apple on the other hand is far too human, literally having a hand on every step of the process, which means it is very slow, and sometimes bureaucratic. But they do seems to care way beyond what a normal persona and other companies would do.