20 ms·
Brain Simulation Promised a Decade Ago Hasn't Succeeded
- auvi 7y agois the proposal for the billion euro funding for HBP public? it would be interesting to see.
- Anon84 7y agoI couldn't find the original proposal text, but you can read the final partnership agreement text on their website: https://www.humanbrainproject.eu/en/about/governance/framework-partnership-agreement/ https://www.humanbrainproject.eu/en/about/governance/framewo...
- brink 7y agoHumans have a terrible tendency to underestimate the complexity of reality, and the same stroke - diminish its beauty. The fact that we can look at a tree, or look into the sky with boredom is a great testament to this. With this same mentality, we've looked at a human brain and oversimplified it, and underestimated it. We're continually finding that reality is more complex than we thought.
- hhs 7y agoGunther Stent made an interesting comment about this: "I believe that science is, by nature, reductionist, but I also believe that reductionism will not carry us all the way. One of the reasons why I think science will eventually peter out is because you must always explain some higher level in terms of some lower level - that's what scientists have to do. But I think that when finally we get to sufficiently complex things, this will not be possible." That's one perspective. I do wonder how deep we'll get with understanding and simulating the brain.
- nefitty 7y agoWhat would replace science? Some sort of enterprise of systemic analysis? "We see all the dots science has shone a light on. Let's now figure out how they're connected and how they affect each other." That would be cool.
- GuiA 7y agoStatistical models fed by massive data that no single human can fully understand are still “science”, but it’s definitely a very different paradigm for science than what we’ve had for the past few centuries, and it seems to be what we’re heading towards. Eg a few decades from now, 24/7 biometrics monitoring at massive scale + machine learning might let us predict complex conditions like Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, various types of cancer, etc very accurately and very early, yet we might not be any closer to understanding what causes them at a fundamental level in the first place.
- realbarack 7y agoIf by "sufficiently complex things" Stent means "things like consciousness," I found Max Tegmark's hypothesis in "Life 3.0" compelling: that just as information can arise from an arrangement of matter (data on a magnetic disk), consciousness might arise from an arrangement of information.
- Hoasi 7y ago> Humans have a terrible tendency to underestimate the complexity of reality, and the same stroke - diminish its beauty. True, but this is like optimism. With the motivation to go through life and do things, an optimist can afford unrealistic goals. Sometimes, that is what pays off.
- xt00 7y agoTrue.. old folks like to mention that kids take things for granted.. if they didn’t they would just be staring at cars go by all day going “wooooowwwww.... you guys seein this shit??”
- buboard 7y agoI think a lot of it has to do with tribal politics from a the outset of the project that were never reconciled. The goal of the project was ambitious and inspiring, but such project requires contribution from everyone in the neuro community. Sadly it has not delivered usable output as a project. It has not produced landmark datasets and i have not found any important software to use from it. I still believe the vision is valid but it needs an Apollo-level focus in execution
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Jweb_Guru 7y agoThe neuro community correctly viewed this project as a massive scam. Blaming them for not going along with it seems shortsighted to me.
- buboard 7y agoI think criticism was overblown as well. The many thousands of small electrophysiology projects testing a single hypothesis also cost a ton of money and mice lives, and do not have ambitious goals. A concerted, centralized effort often breeds spectacular results.
- marmaduke 7y agoAfter the community push back in 2015, this is no longer true. Most of the software is being open sourced, and the data from the BigBrain project is already open and will complement similar sized data from Allen Institute and the HCP. I work for a work package leader for the next round of funding, and the European Commission seems to be demanding a Apollo level focus nowadays.
- dmix 7y agoHow can they get Apollo level focus if they can’t get early NASAs complete buy in from academic and private industry (across multiple nato countries). It seems it’s having trouble even getting credibility with in neuroscience. Which is absolutely necessary if you want the level of talent that Apollo required.
- situational87 7y agoI think I've been reading the same article about how AI and the singularity is just around the "five year corner" for like at least 20 years now. I worked very briefly with some folks who do ML engineering and they were disillusioned to the point of nihilism. They claimed that most of their day was just spent fiddling with weights until they got the magic number their bosses wanted to see, and they were all looking to get out of the field.
- tempodox 7y agoIn the meantime, business and PR geniuses went the other way and were successful in lowering the standards far enough that a machine that adds 2+2 and sometimes arrives at 4 is an AI.
- marmaduke 7y agoHBP has not much to do with AI/ML though the latter are used for model building within HBP
- perl4ever 7y agoAre you sure you don't mean "a quantum computer"?
- tempodox 7y agoI'm not sure that would be an accurate portrait of quantum computers, at least when applied to a deterministic problem. I was referring to the inflationary use of the “AI” moniker.
- marmaduke 7y agoI work on parts of this project. No one outside of Markrams small close circle thought HBP would do what he promised, but it was rather seen as a way to fund ambitious computational neuroscience projects otherwise unimaginable. For example, Neuromorphic chips have been ever present within HBP. We are building new multiscale simulation tools to tackle neuro degenerative diseases. The list goes on. Simulating a human brain itself was just the tag line, technically already accomplished by eg Izhikevich, TheVirtualBrain project, Eliasmith's SPAUN among others. edit despite working within the project I definitely think a critical view of such large funding is essential, so articles like this are welcome
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- p1esk 7y agoSimulating a human brain itself was just the tag line, technically already accomplished by eg Izhikevich, TheVirtualBrain project, Eliasmith's SPAUN among others. No. No one has simulated a human brain. All those projects have simulated something that might vaguely resemble some of the brain's structures or operations, but we know so little about the whole thing that it was pretty much a pointless exercise. HBP has been different from all of them because they attempted to do the true bottom up approach, not feasible without massive resources. As the article states, it turned out that even given the massive resources the task is just too difficult currently.
- derefr 7y agoI think you're ignoring the difference between a simulation (or model) and an emulation. A bottom-up approach produces an emulation. AFAIK, nobody has ever claimed to be trying to produce a human whole-brain emulation in the style of https://neurokernel.github.io/ https://neurokernel.github.io/. It's a problem that is obviously intractible right now.
- wuliwong 7y agoI don't think what you are saying is correct. Isn't an emulator something that takes the same inputs and produces the same outputs? I don't think "bottom-up" has anything to do with it.
- boyadjian 7y agoYes, it hasn't succeeded, but progress in this field of science are incredibly fast. Neuromorphic computers are evolving fast. Of course, a human brain is very complex and performing, but I think that I will be alive to see singularity.
- ggm 7y agoWas this a sub-form of the "emergent behaviour" school of intelligence? Connectionists?
- yters 7y agoPerhaps the brain is an antenna. No matter how much you simulate an antenna your simulation will never give you a nice TV signal.
- gilbetron 7y agoWhile unsubstantiated, I love the analogy, I hadn't thought of that possibility.
- jacquesm 7y agoNot until you simulate a second antenna and electromagnetism.
- taneq 7y agoI've wondered about this but the fact that brain damage can alter personality so drastically makes it seem implausible.
- yters 7y agoRunning into a tree can dramatically change how my car drives, but that doesn't mean the car is driving itself.
- adamnemecek 7y agoPeople have been promising artificial intelligence since 1956 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dartmouth_workshop https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dartmouth_workshop
- neilv 7y agoAmbitious projects and optimistic predictions have seemed not-unusual among big-name AI people, since the start. Marvin Minsky predicted emergent behavior and recursive effects much sooner. (I think this was in all honesty: not realizing how complex the human brain, and not knowing how hardware would develop.) Douglas Lenat apparently thought commonsense knowledge and reasoning would be easier. Ray Kurzweil was often making predictions about hard-AI accomplishments just around the corner, which we're starting to see much later.
- ghostbrainalpha 7y agoInteresting note about Ray Kurzweil, his predictions on when humanity accomplishes human brain simulation don't predict we will achieve this until the next decade. (2020-2030)
- echelon 7y agoWhich is still way too early. Everything we thought was just around the corner is not: flying cars, self-driving cars, AGI, cold fusion, the singularity... Hype cycles are a thing. I for one don't think we'll see any of these in our lifetime.
- tim333 7y agoGood self driving cars maybe but if you don't mind an iffy one here you go: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaOB-ErYq6Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaOB-ErYq6Y
- tim333 7y agoWhile Kurzweil is cranky in many areas like his 100 pills a day, his extrapolations of Moore's law type growth patterns seem quite sensible - here's the log graph, let's get a ruler and extrapolate the pattern continuing. Not really rocket science and you don't need Kurzweil to do it but he's perhaps the leading populizer of the approach.
- Chathamization 7y agoKurzweil is an interesting case. His predictions have been impressively wrong for the most part, yet he seems to refuse to admit it.
- api 7y agoI love the quote at the end: > In 2014, I attended TED’s main Vancouver conference and watched the opening talk, from the MIT Media Lab founder Nicholas Negroponte. In his closing words, he claimed that in 30 years, “we are going to ingest information. You’re going to swallow a pill and know English. You’re going to swallow a pill and know Shakespeare. And the way to do it is through the bloodstream. So once it’s in your bloodstream, it basically goes through it and gets into the brain, and when it knows that it’s in the brain, in the different pieces, it deposits it in the right places.” I'm on the fence about whether people like this are delusional and actually believe that someday we will swallow a pill that can teach us language or whether they're deliberately pumping hype for funding. I lean toward the latter given that this idea is so deeply and thoroughly absurd I can't believe anyone with any knowledge at all of learning, neuroscience, or information theory could possibly believe it. It's much more ridiculous than the "water memory" claim around homeopathy given that the amount of information we'd be talking about here is orders of magnitude beyond what one might imagine a homeopathic cure would need to convey (assuming homeopathy worked).
- f00zz 7y agoI highly recommend Kurzweil's "The Age of Spiritual Machines" for many predictions like these, with a detailed timeline. According to him, being able to simulate human-level intelligence on a computer is simple matter of having enough processing power, which he estimates at 20 petaflops. He also predicts we'd be able to buy 20 petaflops for US$ 1k around 2009, IIRC. (Edit: had to check - he actually wrote 2020. Looking forward to it.) (It's a fun book though, I like it. Except for the creepy bits on cybersex.)
- perl4ever 7y agoThat sounds like a classic example of assuming a sigmoid curve is purely exponential.
- thr2131adf 7y ago> is simple matter of having enough processing power Isn't this provably false though ? I don't think the openworm project has gotten anywhere near simulating C.elegans.
- nradov 7y agoI'm constantly amazed by the ability of TED organizers to convince people to pay to listen to nonsense. How do they do it? Sure there a few gems, but overall the content quality is equal to TV infomercials selling snake-oil nutritional supplements and get-rich-quick schemes. Is everyone afraid to say that the emperor is naked?
- vkou 7y agoIf people paying for TED talks wanted to learn, they'd enroll in an evening class at their community college. The purpose of TED talks is not learning. It's getting all the dopamine hits that come with learning, without actually putting in the work.
- Dylan16807 7y agoThat's a weird criticism. Even when your goal is learning, unless there are no better options it's unusual to take an entire course in something you have only passing interest in. A community college only has so many courses; not very many will match up with the passions of the average person. (This is ignoring people that take a course for social reasons.)
- pault 7y agoAre you lumping TedX into that assessment? Those are independently organized and are mostly terrible.
- 0xffff2 7y agoYou're absolutely right about TEDx, but I'd apply GP's comment to TED proper as well. They're inspirational and sometimes aspirational, even if it costs them rigor. They give you the feel-good talking points without ever delving into any challenges or complications involved with the topic of the talk.
- dmix 7y agoIt’s an excellent place for hucksters to thrive with pseudo-intellectual optimism. Like clickbait it’s always - a mix of some highly accessible topic with something either surprising, controversial, or in some way challenging the norms. They’re not all bad obviously but it’s not a good place for reasoned, moderate, and calculated predictions, which is the plane where most science or businesses live and die on. When your big ideas hit reality. Theranos probably had the best TED pitch around, if they ever did one.
- meremortals 7y agoPeter Thiel discusses this often, and recently on The Portal with Eric Weinstein-- where all these sorts of breakthroughs are perpetually right around the corner. previous hn discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20465053 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20465053 youtube interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nM9f0W2KD5s&t=8941s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nM9f0W2KD5s&t=8941s
- criloz2 7y agowhat if is impossible to simulate a brain without ending creating exactly another one, brain use tiny space and mass, and in that confined space is very efficient doing a lot of calculation that we are not even aware of, using the least amount of energy and dissipating the least amount of heat possible. have you ever feel that your brain is suffering from overheating?
- aznpwnzor 7y agoI was in this field. In 2012, tt was already seen as a crazy accomplishment in showmanship and fundraising. Everybody in the field thought this was irresponsible and foolhardy, but good for the field overall. Long story short, I left for machine learning as everybody else without wet lab experience also did from my lab.
- Nasrudith 7y agoOne thing that hasn't been mentioned in the article is how well the smaller brain models performed compared to the real thing - which is kind of crucial to our understanding of many of the encapsulated questions and assumptions. Even something relatively simple like "We managed to convert the optic nerve to a signal and strobed the poor mouse into a seizure - would the model mouse brain also show similiar brain reactions?" If you have the neurons mapped but not the biochemistry the divergence could be very telling even if countless "emulation bugs" occur from the implicit assumptions that lead to the states.
- buboard 7y agoNot even close. There are so many pieces and parameters missing that large scale simulations are useless for anything more than “we saw some oscillations that vaguely resemble some recorded oscillations “. It was the hope that HBP would fill in those blanks