14 ms·
After correcting for demographics, US schools fare better than EU/Asian schools
- powera 16y agoThe Daily Howler ( http://dailyhowler.com/ http://dailyhowler.com/ ) has been blogging about the "our schools aren't bad, everyone just likes saying they are" for months and months and months. He's talking about this study today as well, and notes the real cause of this isn't really immigration, but the legacy of slavery (blacks score 75 points lower than whites): "Among those 34 OECD nations, only the United States spent centuries aggressively trying to stamp out literacy among a major part of its population. The legacy of that benighted history lives with us today, although our “reformers” work very hard to avoid such painful discussions."
- lucasjung 16y agoI'm with you until you point the finger at slavery. Blaming it on the "legacy of slavery" seems to me to be intellectually lazy: first, it is vague to the point of uselessness. Second, it ignores all of the things which have happened since the end of slavery, some of which happened as the part of the aftermath of slavery, but some of which happened for completely independent reasons. It also ignores the fact that slavery ended at very different times, under very different circumstances, in different parts of the country, but those differences largely aren't reflected in test scores or other measures of social or economic success. If we're going to solve the problem, we need to identify the real, proximate causes so that they can be addressed. I don't have any stats handy, but I've read several times that after the civil war, blacks saw steady improvement in their economic status, on similar (albeit slower) trend to various immigrant ethnicities who faced initial integration troubles, but that this progress stopped and then reversed in the '70s. This reversal correlated very strongly to the rise of out of wedlock births among blacks. I've read that, if you correct for single-parent/dual-parent families, the difference in school performance between all ethnic groups almost completely disappears, even if you don't correct for things like income level or the education level of parents (although those two things also correlate with single/dual-parent status, so correcting for it tends to correct for them to some degree). Did slavery cause marriage and stable families to decline among blacks over a century after the 13th amendment? It seems to me that, just as our society was finally putting "the legacy of slavery" to rest, something else happened to hurt the black community even worse. If we can figure out what it was, we'll be well on our way to closing the gap. Unfortunately, so much damage has been done at this point that I don't think that simply removing the original cause will fix the problem--extra measures will be needed to repair the damage.
- drndown2007 16y agoWish I could up vote this a hundred times. I also wonder what happened in the 70s. A big cultural change in 'white' America that was copied/amplified in 'Black' America? I can't put my finger on it either, but there really is something concrete about 'family values' that expresses itself for generations.
- lucasjung 16y ago"I can't put my finger on it either, but there really is something concrete about 'family values' that expresses itself for generations." I wasn't around at the time, but I think that the social movements of the '60s and '70s threw the baby out with the bathwater. There were definite wrongs that needed to be fixed (segregation being the prime example), but in the process of fixing them we inadvertently damaged key aspects of our societal structure. I think that this happened because of the way our culture lumps together completely unrelated positions into strongly correlated groupings that we label "conservative" and "liberal." As a modern example, consider the fact that people's positions on gun control, abortion, and taxes all tend to correlate very strongly in our country, even though all three are orthogonal (libertarians being an example of people who buck this trend to some degree). In the '60s and '70s, bad things like racism got lumped in with many of the good things we collectively label as "family values," to the point where many of the people fighting against the bad stuff saw the good parts as being part and parcel. This carries over today: my most liberal friends consider "family values" to be an ugly euphemism for "racism," "homophobia," and "misogyny." They don't make any distinction for the good parts like "get married before you have kids," and "marriage is a serious and important commitment which requires a lifetime of compromise and sacrifice." They think that the bad parts are inherent aspects of the culture, which implies that the only way to get rid of them is to radically change the entire culture. I've even read positions more extreme than those of my friends: people who think the parts I label good, like the institution of marriage, to be part of the problem.
- drndown2007 16y agoVery insightful. Thanks
- feral 16y ago"Among those 34 OECD nations, only the United States spent centuries aggressively trying to stamp out literacy among a major part of its population." I'm Irish, and I'd question the accuracy of that statement - whether the US was unique in that regard. You could argue over the specifics of what it means 'to try stamp out literacy', but for 100s of years here (Ireland), the native language (Irish/Gaelige), and education through it, got a very tough time from the occupying British government. More generally, the country had a tough time. The majority of the population (Catholics) had little to no opportunity, and little education ('the penal laws' etc). Many of those who could left as emigrants (going to places such as USA). Now, Republic of Ireland - the OECD nation - has been around less than 100 years, and we've made big strides in this time. Many peoples parents are now college educated; but this is probably the first generation where that's true. So, what does it mean to compare the population of Ireland 'corrected for the demography', as is done on the last chart in that page? And then make statements about the legacy of slavery in the USA, using that comparision? I really think the analysis lies in tatters at that point. While this post is - clearly - raising interest in the measurement of education (a good thing) the method used is just much too crude to possibly draw the kind of conclusions the author, and others, are making. There's just too much historical differences between what it means to be an immigrant in different countries, and too much different history, for such crude analysis to support the conclusions drawn.
- pmorici 16y ago"Libertarians in the United States have often claimed that the public school system (which has more than 90% of the students) is a disaster." The Libertarian argument isn't that public schools are a disaster. Their argument is that the federal government shouldn't be involved in education and it should instead remain a local or state issue where people have more direct control over the system.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoAnd then Texas would refer to slavery as the "triangular trade system" see here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/may/16/texas-schools-rewrites-us-history http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/may/16/texas-schools-re...
- pmorici 16y agoSo you are assuming then that your preference over their preference would win a majority vote in congress? Local control protects liberal leaning policies as much as nutty ones.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoI'm not defending liberal leaning policies at all. I'm pointing out are that there are education standards for a reason. Sorry you don't like facts but that's the reality of the situation.
- cema 16y agoHaving schools conforming to educational standards may be important, but there is a difference between even a country-wide system that proposes (and tests, etc) educational standards, on the one hand; and, on the other hand, government's involvement in education. These two may be completely independent. Indeed, the former (standards) may exist without the latter (government-controlled education). And, please, avoid ad hominem attacks.
- klbarry 16y agoThis is fairly mind-blowing to me, and if this argument is true, then we need to look at education reform a different way.
- Alex3917 16y agoThe best way to describe this argument is "not even wrong." Judging the quality of our schools solely by using standardized tests to compare our students with students in other countries is moronic, and excluding minorities is even more so. Yes, of course parenting and culture have an enormous effect on student outcomes, but this data doesn't actually illuminate anything of use. Don't get me wrong, it makes an interesting talking point, but there's nothing here that you can actually use to make schools better.
- Charuru 16y agoI think that's the point. There IS nothing that needs to be done to make schools better. Reforms need to happen culturally and at home.
- Alex3917 16y ago"There IS nothing that needs to be done to make schools better. Reforms need to happen culturally and at home." Except for that the reason kids aren't learning at home is largely because of the design and culture of school.
- kenjackson 16y agoI don't understand how that follows from the data? Even comparing apples to apples, so to speak, the US is at the 25th %ile. With most countries above (and below) being likely countries, once you exclude the poorest 35% from our country. To put it another way -- stacking the cards in our favor should really put us a lot higher up the stack, considering he didn't control from spending or income.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoNo, "not even wrong" is a pretty crappy way to describe this argument. "Not even wrong" implies a non-falsifiable claim. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong The claims made by this article are easily falsifiable: do a more accurate ethnicity-based slicing of the data and show that US schools fare poorly as measured by standardized tests. You may not find the results useful for your chosen aims ("make schools better"), but that's irrelevant. Is evolution also "not even wrong" because it can't be used to "make schools better"?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- matwood 16y agoThis is a common problem when looking at the US as a whole compared to many other countries. The US is a huge, very diverse place. When I travel to the NE, then to the south, and finally to the west coast it feels like I've been in 3 different countries. The language while still english is slightly different, the attitudes are different, and the people are different. In this environment it really does make sense to have less federal involvement and more local involvement since each locale likely has completely different issues. On the whole it makes much more sense to start breaking the US into regions when doing comparisons with other countries. From there we might be able to find the real problems and look for focused, local solutions.
- simonsarris 16y agoI try to explain North America to others like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nine_Nations_of_North_America http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nine_Nations_of_North_America
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Volscio 16y agoNice, thanks for this. :)
- huherto 16y agonice! From now on, I will be a Mexamerican.
- elblanco 16y agoIt's actually very interesting. Anecdotally, as somebody who grew up in a "Foundry" area...when I think of moving to another city, other Foundry cities come up first in my mind as places I want to live. I never really attributed it to regionalism but I suppose it makes a kind of sense. Even regions geographically close to mine don't have the same kind of draw as those close to mine.
- duck 16y ago
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- DanI-S 16y ago"Guys, don't panic - our schools are great, as long as you're white!" If they're failing to educate a large number of students, they're not working as intended.
- pmorici 16y agoThats not what he concludes. It's "as long as your parents are educated".
- Alex3917 16y agoAnd he's wrong again. The reason high-SES kids score better on standardized tests isn't because they learn more in school, it's because they learn more at home. In fact low-SES kids actually learn almost as much at school than high-SES kids[1], it's just that they start out 2-3 years behind in Kindergarten[2], and instead of learning over the summer they actually regress[1]. What the data actually shows is that students DON'T learn if they're white, but in a feat of epic illogic this guy has somehow managed to convince himself that the opposite is true. [1] http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED037322.pdf http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED037322.pdf (C.f. figure 2 and 3) [1] http://www.amazon.com/Meaningful-Differences-Everyday-Experience-American/dp/1557661979/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1293561394&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/Meaningful-Differences-Everyday-Experi...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- towelrod 16y agoHe didn't control for parental education, he controlled for recent immigration status.
- kenjackson 16y agoWhich is unfortunate because parental education and income are in the dataset. I wish I had the time to sift through it.
- pmorici 16y ago
- cletus 16y agoThere's something a little creepy about saying there's nothing wrong with the American education system by only looking at those in the US of European descent and excluding all others. Basically it doesn't matter how well or badly the rest of the population does, it doesn't change the OP's hypothesis. The point about immigrants scoring lower is well-taken but this is largely a language barrier. How exactly does this apply to, say, the African American segment of the population, many of whom have been in the US for hundreds of years and most of whom know no other language than English? Socioeconomic factors, the education level of your parents and so on obviously come into play here but I read this post and read it like this: "if we exclude all the problems in the US education system, the US education system is fine!" Perhaps that's not entirely fair but one must be very careful before discounting selection bias when drawing conclusions such as these. Now I'm not claiming the US education system is bad. Frankly I have no personal experience with it (coming from the "negative gap" of Australia). I will say one thing: the US has something we don't in Australia and that's a tenured teacher system that makes it (near-)impossible to fire teachers [1]. It's still not easy in Australia but it is easier. That strikes me as a problem. [1]: http://reason.com/assets/db/12639308918768.pdf http://reason.com/assets/db/12639308918768.pdf
- jerf 16y agoStep one in solving problems is identify the problem. Especially in the political sphere people love to skip over this step for a variety of reasons I hardly have to spell out. If in fact our schooling policies are basically OK and the problem lies almost solely in the homes, then solutions involving throwing more money at school won't work. This is a worthy investigation. My personal biases lead me to believe that if anything there's problems in both places, so my main point isn't that this person is necessarily right or wrong, my main point is Step One: Identify The Problem. It's often harder than you might think and often requires biases to be discarded.
- Alex3917 16y ago"[If] the problem lies almost solely in the homes, then solutions involving throwing more money at school won't work. This is a worthy investigation." Except that we already know how much of the problem stems from the home from the decades worth of research that has already been done. The PISA numbers don't contribute anything to our understanding of the problem, they're just a red herring designed to get people asking the wrong questions.
- sdfdfgsdfgh 16y agoAfter correcting for me being short,fat and middle aged I'm an olympic athlete
- mdda 16y agoIf you like, you can follow the author's suggestion to jump to the graphs to avoid the methodology. But then you'd miss the following important adjustments being made to the figures : """ So ... let us compare Americans with European ancestry (about 65% of the U.S population, and not some sort of elite) with Europeans in Europe. We remove Asians, Mexicans, African-Americans and other countries that are best compared to their home nations. In Europe, we remove immigrants. """ The author has a clear agenda : Some American citizens are more equal than others.
- btilly 16y agoIf you jump to the graph and read what it says on the legend, you would not miss that. It says that right there in the legend on the graphs. If you read the article, you'll find reasoning for that methodology. Furthermore I suspect that every major ethnic group does better in the USA than in their respective home countries. From the data in the article, it holds true for those of European and Asian descent. Given what I know about the appalling state of education in Mexico, I am sure it applies for Hispanics as well. I know less about Africa, but wouldn't be surprised if the same holds for African-Americans. I fully agree that we can and should do better about erasing differences, but on the whole I'm happy counting that as a success.
- DanielBMarkham 16y ago"After correcting for demographics..." I didn't read the article, but isn't that just a fancy way of saying "certain people are smart and certain people aren't. We just have a lot of stupid people." I exaggerate, of course, but that's how it looks from a cursory glance. Correcting for demographics is the one thing we cannot do in measuring education's effectiveness, as the purpose of an education is for folks to gain habits and be able to do things in the real world -- a world that does not care which demographic you belong to.
- btilly 16y agoYou should read the article. Because that is really not what it says. One of the major demographic things corrected for is the fraction of the country that is made up of immigrants. First and second generation immigrants perform significantly worse in school, and this relation holds across most countries. (The significant exceptions are Australia and Canada, which have a skill-based immigration system that selects immigrants who are likely to perform better in school.) It is worth noting that the author was an immigrant from Iran to Sweden. (I don't know whether the author has since moved elsewhere.) Furthermore the author in the comments very strongly comes out against the notion that any race is naturally less intelligent than any other.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI think you've got race on the brain and are missing the point. You can't externally label and measure groups of people -- by race, by income, by percentage of immigrants -- as part of an effort to improve education outcomes. This is management by statistical measurement, and it's fraught with problems, the basic one is that it confuses measurement with meaning, correlation with causation. Externally-defined statistical measurements are attractive, as they claim to give understanding. But in reality they provide very murky value at best.
- btilly 16y agoTake a look at http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_-EMpadQx4hM/TRKZ5kB-49I/AAAAAAAAAY8/c_2n4vdbkPk/s1600/immigrant.jpg http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_-EMpadQx4hM/TRKZ5kB-49I/AAAAAAAAAY... and tell me again that it is appropriate to ignore immigration levels in judging how effectively the education system is doing its job of educating students. (Note that the exceptions of Australia and Canada are discussed in the article.) When factors that big are out of the control of the education system, a proper analysis of the performance of the education system itself should not ignore them. The resulting outcomes may not be what is wanted, but that is not necessarily the fault of the schools.
- zephyrfalcon 16y agotl;dr: We manipulate data until the US looks good.
- jmtame 16y ago"In almost all European countries, immigrants from third world countries score lower than native born kids. Why? No one don’t know exactly why." might want to adjust this, has a double negative and feels awkward to read
- warmfuzzykitten 16y agoCorrecting for demographics, US schools are great. Correcting for demographics, the US doesn't have a disproportionate number of incarcerated citizens. Correcting for demographics, the US doesn't have much of a jobless problem. I couldn't decide which was more charming, the claim that Americans of European descent (65% of the population) are not some sort of elite, or the call to compare African Americans to those in their "home nations". The US is their home nation! This article is racist rot.
- cema 16y agoActually, only the former may be correct, and in any case, it is the only claim that is discussed in the paper. If you close your eyes you will not be able to see if a problem exists, identify it, find a solution and follow it through. And calling people names would not help either.
- davidedicillo 16y agoBeside what said by Cletus, I think that the main problem behind that post is that nobody is saying that American are dumb. The problem is that many Americans are ignorant (please don't take offense here), especially regarding things outside the US. For example the italian school system (the only one I really know) sucks big time, and it doesn't prepare students to the real world in any way, but on the other hand it provides a pretty good general knowledge, that helps to have a more open and flexible mind.
- jacoblyles 16y agoIn the conversations I've had with Europeans on the internet many have an ignorant, almost comical view of American culture. Perhaps everyone is a bit provincial. Europeans and American leftists have a tradition of claiming Europe is better than America that goes back centuries. If hard facts aren't at hand, they'll make up soft ones. American schools might be better than Italian ones in every way, so you just claim that Italians have "a more open and flexible mind" - a conveniently unmeasurable quantity. It sounds like you are simply asserting stereotypes as fact.
- afhof 16y agoA few thoughts that occurred to me: What is PISA? Why do they only target 15-16 year-olds? Are they a representative sample? Can the entire test be lumped into 3 categories: Math, Science, and Reading? All of these subjects are interrelated. Anyone can play with these numbers until a preferable conclusion is made. For example, the first graph that the article presents makes Greece look half as competent as Finland.
- ugh 16y agoPISA is a set of standardized triennial tests organized by the OECD.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoIt's important to know what sort of problems US schools face. It seems likely based on a lot of evidence (anecdotal and otherwise) that US schools are no worse than EU and Asian schools. However, American schools do have a different problem because we can't simply accept the inability to educate a huge subset of American students merely due to their culture or ethnicity. Less diverse countries may seemingly have an easier problem in education, but that doesn't get rid of our need to cultivate a literate and educated citizenry. But there are even bigger unexamined issues at play here. Firstly, are we able to accurately measure quality of education through these studies? Given the increasing reliance on college degrees as necessary credentials for basic competency in core skills such as literacy and math it seems likely the answer is no. Secondly, what confidence do we have that modern public schooling provides any educational value? Given the similarity of educational achievement on standardized tests across much of the developed world when adjusted for socio-economic status one has to wonder. How much of a students basic educational competency would they acquire regardless of public schooling merely due to the educational status and expectations of their parents and peers?
- InclinedPlane 16y agoFollowup: consider a "control" experiment (which, due to ethics cannot be conducted) whereby schools are replaced with "classrooms" of hundreds of students and a single custodian. There is no curriculum, there is no teaching, students sit for several hours a day at desks. They are allowed only to read or write, sit doing nothing, or do anything that looks vaguely like doing homework (though it could be doodling), as long as it's done quietly. Every month their parents are asked to fill out a survey of how they think their children are doing education wise, but there are no consequences attached to any of this. Now, the big question is how would students fair in terms of education in this experiment relative to existing schooling, especially when correlated by socio-economic and cultural background? I highly suspect that we'd get similar results to today's educational system. Kids with educated and/or affluent parents would tend to acquire some modicum of education, other students would do less well. The work the OP has done tends to lead to this conclusion which is not anything like an endorsement of the current public educational system.
- Symmetry 16y agoI seem to recall a similar study I heard about a while ago, showing that although the average life expectancy of Norway was a lot higher than that of the US, people of Norwegian descent in the US tended to live longer than those in Norway.
- spoiledtechie 16y agoWhats the crime ratio. How many people get murdered in the US compared to Norway. Those numbers you speak of are scued not to a persons health, but to how long they actually live. Maybe taking a survey of everyone above 50 of each country since they have grown past many stupid accidents and are less prone to being killed and see what the ratio is then...
- anamax 16y ago> Whats the crime ratio. How many people get murdered in the US compared to Norway. The US has a higher murder rate. That tends to push down the lifespan. Are you suggesting that Norwegians in Norway are more likely to be murdered than Norwegian-Americans?
- jessriedel 16y agoThe murder rate in industrialized countries is much too low to have a significant effect on life expectancy. The vast majority of people die of disease or accident. 15k people were murdered of 300m in the US in 2009. That's 0.005% of people per year, meaning roughly 0.3% of people die from murder.
- spoiledtechie 16y agoThe main reason I "think" liberals want to poor money into the public school system, is because most teachers/educators are liberals. If there was a study of politcal parties in the American Education system, it would vastly weigh towards most educators are Liberals/Democrats.
- paradoja 16y agoThat would mean, by itself, pretty little. They could be liberals due to the liberal stand on education, not the other way around.
- partition 16y agoI'm taken aback by this whole discussion. For all the bashing that goes on in HN about schools being glorified test prep centers and not living up to their potential for educating students, we sure are quick to accept "studies" like this that use test scores as an indicator of intrinsic worth of the educational system in a country.
- mike4u2 16y ago"After correcting for demographics..." GOOD students will do fine in almost any school system. I think what makes a difference is how you motivate the kids with problematic backgrounds. Excluding them from studies is certainly NOT the solution.
- alain94040 16y agoI flagged this article: 1) poor style, using his own experience to draw vast generalizations 2) clear editorializing, so the author is pushing an agenda and makes no attempt at objectivity 2) data is possibly cooked. For instance, the author says removing recent immigrants in Europe could raise the score by 50 points, then goes on to look at the white population for the US, and it's now 24 points ahead of Europe. So you corrected one country and not the others and are draw huge conclusions from that fact?
- joelmichael 16y agoHe excluded first and second generation immigrants from the European set in his comparison.
- ig1 16y agoThe author is clueless about the research in this area. I was formerly the co-founder of a social mobility think-tank so I'm pretty familiar with the work that's been done in this area. The author's statement "In almost all European countries, immigrants from third world countries score lower than native born kids." is just false. A quick look at the British data will tell you that students from Chinese or Indian ethnic backgrounds do considerably better than "White British": http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmhansrd/cm081014/text/81014w0030.htm#081014100004585 http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200708/cmhansrd/c... This is broadly true in most European countries. If you look at for example children of Pakistani immigrants, they do much better in some countries such as Canada than they do in the UK. Cross-country studies pretty much all agree the difference is down to parental background. If the parents have middle-class backgrounds than their children are much more likely to perform better than average (regardless of country of origin). Essentially by cutting out non-whites he's just disproportionately cutting out the poor and lower-class children which is pushing the scores. It's nothing to do with race. Note particularly how he's treating the ethnicities which are primarily middle-class as "white" (e.g. jews).
- kenjackson 16y agoThere's a better article here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-jim-taylor/are-public-education-chic_b_798354.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-jim-taylor/are-public-educa... The real point is that this person is controlling probably more for wealth/income than anything else. But the problem persists. If most of our country is being educated as if it was a third world country, what does that say for the future of the US?
- tokenadult 16y agoAny time taxpayers are paying real money for something, one part of the value proposition is price. I have lived outside the United States, and I have a first-generation immigrant to the United States in my immediate family, and I live in an ethnically diverse ("race" or place or birth considered) neighborhood, with supposedly good public schools. What most analyses like this ignore to too great a degree, and what most of the more than 100 comments posted here so far aren't focusing a lot on is how much provision of government-operated schooling costs in the United States compared to what it costs in other countries. By most reasonable standards of comparison, United States schools provide less learning added to learners per dollar of inputs than most schools in quite a few other OECD countries. That's apparent whether one looks at a variety of comparisons of mathematics achievement (a crucial educational goal), or second-language achievement (a goal often neglected in the English-speaking United States), or in science achievement (a safeguard against irrational public policies). Having grown up in the United States, and having lived overseas for two separate three-year spans, the second one with my children, I can't be complacent about the provision of government-operated schools in the United States.
- HilbertSpace 16y agoIt's a very old story: But if compare students in Finland with students in the US with ancestors from Finland, then might have something. Similarly compare students in Nigeria with students in the US with ancestors from Nigeria. But do NOT compare all students in the US with all students in Finland. To heck with Nigeria and Finland. Instead, there is a general result: For some positive integer n of, say, a few dozen, take n relatively homogeneous populations. Give the tests. Take the best, say, 5 populations on that test. Now, for population n + 1, take a 'mixture' of the populations of the n other populations, give the test, and compare with the top 5. Then very likely population n + 1 loses. This is true just by a simple convexity argument that never mentions Finland, Nigeria, or the US but still does explain why the US has a hard time beating the best of the homogeneous countries. The NYT, the McKinsey study, etc. won't tell you any of this.
- joe_the_user 16y ago"So much for the bigoted notions that Americans are dumb and Europeans are smart." Yes, let's move to other bigoted notions...
- DanKurt 16y agoPerhaps I missed it but why not consider mean racial IQ as a factor in the differences found.
- Chi019 16y agoThis reflects human biodiversity. When you compare groups with similar evolutionary backgrounds they have similar levels of intelligence.