16 ms·
Portugal’s radical drugs policy is working (2017)
- 1024core 7y ago> Why hasn’t the world copied it? Because there's too much money* to be made in keeping the status quo. * I use the terms "money" and "power" to mean the same here.
- anm89 7y agoIt's unfortunate that this sounds so tin foil hat because it is absolutely true. There is no grand conspiracy to keep drugs illegal. There is a vast, semi well intentioned system built over a century that people adapted to over time to profit off of and now that they are profiting they are not going to give it up easily. Because of the governmental nature of the people who profit they are also very well positioned to lobby for themselves. The sheer number of small actors who benefit from this system has made it unbelievably entrenched.
- testaccount13 7y agoNothing tinfoil hat about it. Drug dealers & cartels are well-known for using force to maintain monopolies.
- Nextgrid 7y agoI’m assuming the parent comment referred to “legal” actors lobbying to keep drugs illegal, as opposed to the cartels themselves. Do you think cartels have an interest in drugs being illegal, and if so could you explain why? I’d expect cartels to welcome the change as they can do away with fighting the law (where they no doubt pour a lot of their resources into) and start operating as legitimate businesses.
- Youcandothis 7y agoIf drugs were legal I imagine that other than the cartels would produce and sell the drugs. Maybe big pharma and the tobacco industry.
- sigstoat 7y agothey won't function as legitimate businesses. there's not significant money to be made growing legal crops or synthesizing simple, 100 year old compounds. their business is operating a supply chain that most nation states are busy trying to disrupt.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> I’d expect cartels to welcome the change as they can do away with fighting the law (where they no doubt pour a lot of their resources into) and start operating as legitimate businesses. Prohibition reduces competition which raises margins. It's the same reason why large corporations like regulation that destroys small competitors. The cartels don't want to have to compete with Joe Farmer in Iowa growing drug crops and selling them at the same margins as corn producers do.
- testaccount13 7y agoYour definitions of cartels & force are different to mine :) Legitimate opiate producers compete in the same market with illegitimate ones. The force they use is police, dea, etc., instead of guns directly, but the techniques are the same. After all, a state is what happens when organized crime expands its time horizons.
- mattmanser 7y agoWhat a pompous lie. The state happened when people get fed up of being trodden on by tyrants, warlords and robber barons and decide to implement concepts like law, order and justice. That it's not perfect doesn't mean it should be reduced to a trite, intellectually bankrupt, soundbite.
- kingkawn 7y agoNever well intentioned. Always exploiting hollow morality to permit the state to commit acts of violence at will against select segments of the population
- icebraining 7y agoDrugs in Portugal are still illegal, so that doesn't answer the question.
- jaredklewis 7y agoBut now we’re just playing semantics. For most intents and purposes, the difference between legal and fully decriminalized is not significant. The parent’s point is that there are many parties with an interest in drugs being criminalized, which explains why the world has not copied Portugal’s decriminalization model.
- rolltiide 7y agoIts very significant to me “Decriminalized” is the same level as when literal snake oil salesmen were going around fairs in the 1880s selling unknown substances that killed you “Legal” is when the quality is regulated and analyzed for a specific purpose and consumers know what they are buying and sellers face consequences for violating that
- icebraining 7y ago> For most intents and purposes, the difference between legal and fully decriminalized is not significant. Parent talked about profit, but in Portugal the production, distribution and sale are still a crime, and therefore the people profiting from those activities are still the same.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe profit is in enforcing the law. Defense contractors and prison guard unions don't make any money when something is nominally illegal but nobody is actually spending any money trying to stop it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- crdoconnor 7y agoIt's not just that though. It's also seen as a way of criminalising undesirables.
- 50656E6973 7y ago>There is no grand conspiracy to keep drugs illegal Many people working together to keep something illegal in order to profit is not a "conspiracy", it's lobbying. >semi well intentioned system How is valuing money and power over millions of lives "semi well intenioned"?
- anm89 7y agoVery few of the millions of people are conspiring together in a single group. They conspire in small groups to achieve their individual goals which may directly contradict the goals of others within the system on a case by case basis. It's not like some secret cabal where they sit around in black robes and vote on how to maximize false arrests for profit. Do you think out of every one of the millions of people in that system that literally every person has absolutely no intention other than profit? Yes, some people within the legal and even prison system have good intentions. To think otherwise a pretty cartoonish world view.
- darkpuma 7y agoI think the hangup people have is when they see apparent orchestration, groups of people making moves that seem coordinated, they assume that conspiracy must be the explanation. But we know from nature that this needn't be the case. Look at a school of fish. There is no hierarchical command structure, nor any democratic council of the fishes, or anything like that. Their schooling behavior is emergent behavior from each individual fish following more or less the same rules as the other, coded in their DNA. They take cues from each other, go with the flow, but they're not actually conspiring with the other fish. There is no Fish Illuminati, just a bunch of fish doing normal fish things. The failure to recognize the possibility of emergent (or convergent) behavior in humans is I think the root cause of many conspiracy theories. This is related to the concept of pareidolia, e.g. seeing patterns when there are none. In this case there are genuine patterns (fish clump up in schools) but the explanation offered up for this behavior is erroneous (fish Illuminati.)
- 50656E6973 7y agoEquating corporate lobbyists and special interest groups with "secret cabals in black robes"? That is caroonish indeed. Unless of course you consider black suits and ties to be "black robes" ;)
- gumby 7y agoIndeed, for opiates the DEA makes it essentially impossible for addicts to get working treatment like Suboxone, basically guaranteeing they’ll continue to be arrested and/or OD.
- rdl 7y agoIs there a high abuse potential for suboxone? Would it be dangerous to just completely de-schedule it (either OTC, or at least make it 18+ at a pharmacy on request)?
- 3p0ch 7y agoSuboxone can be abused and is highly addictive. It's an opiate paired with an opiate antagonist called Naloxone to reduce cravings. It's a maintenance medication to treat opiate dependency.
- achenatx 7y agoI disagree, the problem is that status quo problems are "acceptable". If a politician legalizes drugs they become personally responsible for every death from those legal drugs.
- jdavis703 7y agoTaken another way, would this mean if I pay taxes for a war I think is unjust I'm personally responsible for every death?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- conanbatt 7y agoYou become an objecting collaborator. This is one of the key reasons libertarians hate wars, because taxes make you a war-criminal.
- anovikov 7y agoI absolutely disagree with it. OK it maybe that oil companies are slowing down progress of renewables/preventing acceptance of climate change, because thing has enough money for that. But that opioid crap is simply too cheap to matter on a national level. It's just a bunch of doctors getting some new BMWs writing made up prescriptions and some corporate execs getting a few million extra bonuses for boosting opioid sales. To matter that much to impact politics in the plain view of millions people suffering, it must be a trillion dollar pie. Like oil, or military-industrial complex, or like Microsoft at the very least. It absolutely isn't.
- pier25 7y agoExactly. Cui bono?
- conanbatt 7y agoI got the exact opposite vibe: marihuana legalization in the us is all about increasing tax revenue.
- alkonaut 7y agoHow do illegal drugs convert to “money” and “power”? (Apart from the US where opiate manufacturers are big lobbyists and some weed could both strip you of your right to vote and put you in a for-profit prison. The US is an outlier here)
- maxheadroom 7y ago>...and some weed could both strip you of your right to vote and put you in a for-profit prison. The repercussions are far more egregious than that: The right to vote can be stripped for life[0]. After you've "paid your dues" to society, you will find it hard, if not impossible, to find employment again (also known as having a felony on your record [e.g.: felony possession]); which some states are now recognising is a form of cruel and unusual punishment[1]. To be fair, American society is trending better towards being less militant about justice but it still has quite a long way to go. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_of_rights_due_to_conviction_for_criminal_offense#Disenfranchisement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_of_rights_due_to_convicti... [1] - https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Pennsylvania-automatically-sealing-some-criminal-14064907.php https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Pennsylvania-automatical...
- a3n 7y agoBecause "all is well" is not an effective way to get elected.
- zarathustraa 7y agoIn some US cities, San Francisco for example, possession and consumption of drugs is also basically decriminalized, just like in Portugal. You can openly shot it up your veins in front of cops and nothing will happen to you. I look forward to more cities adopting this policy of tacit decriminalization. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/jimdalrympleii/public-drug-use-san-francisco https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/jimdalrympleii/public-d... https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/philmatier/article/San-Francisco-where-street-addicts-outnumber-13571702.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/philmatier/article/San-F...
- Couto 7y agoThat's not the same than being decriminalized. In Portugal, if you do that the police will ask you for your ID if it's a light drug like cannabis, or take you to the police center if it's an heavier drug. If you keep being caught by the police a judge can order you to take psychiatric help. Being decriminalized means that you won't be arrested when you ask for help, and you have access to clean syringes to avoid diseases and infections. Help being provided, it's not the same than being legal.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhile what you're saying is true, I think that's why the world is afraid to adopt Portugal's policy. If getting halfway there is worse than doing nothing at all, it's a very dangerous thing to try.
- Couto 7y agoJust my opinion: In my experience, when people say drugs they think of cannabis, but cannabis was never the major problem in Portugal. Our problem was heroin. I think no country will legalize heroin, at least not in the short/medium term. This is clearly working, one of the major entrypoints of heavy drugs in Europe (Casal Ventoso in Lisbon) is almost clean of problems, there are still heavy drug users of course, but most of the associated violence disappeared. Even portuguese people's mindset shifted from "junkies" to "people that need help". So even if you consider a "halfway there" because you're thinking about legalization, this is still working and it's a good middle term to help society shift their mentality. Disclaimer: I'm talking from my experience as a Portuguese person, not hard numbers. I remember walking in my hometown parks (which is a very small city) and see syringes and drug users everywhere when I was a kid. This doesn't happen anymore.
- minikites 7y agoDrug use is seen as a moral failing that must be punished, not as an illness that should be treated.
- collyw 7y agoIllegal drug use. People use alcohol, caffeine, nicotine all the time but most people don't even view those as "drugs".
- nemonemo 7y agoThe boundary between drugs and non-drugs is murky. Even refined salt, sugar, and flour could be classified as "drugs" -- your brain gets affected by them, potentially permanently, and they are hardly natural -- and even less people consider them as drugs.
- balfirevic 7y agoRefined salt?
- nyolfen 7y agosalt, sugar, and flour aren't natural?
- skosch 7y agoThey aren't typically found in nature in the form in which we consume them. They require human processing (even if it's much less processing than what goes into making a frozen pizza).
- ahelwer 7y agoBut thanks to Reaganomics, prison turned to profits 'Cause free labor's the cornerstone of US economics 'Cause slavery was abolished, unless you are in prison You think I am bullshittin', then read the 13th Amendment Involuntary servitude and slavery it prohibits That's why they givin' drug offenders time in double digits Killer Mike, "Reagan" https://youtube.com/watch?v=6lIqNjC1RKU https://youtube.com/watch?v=6lIqNjC1RKU
- luckylion 7y agoThat may be a big part of the reason in the US, but Germany for example isn't big on decriminalization either, and we don't have anything similar to the US prison complex. I think a large part over here is that people think it's wrong and they don't believe in the individual's right to make a choice they consider wrong. Worldwide it's probably a mix of the two: powerful interests profiteering from the status quo and politicians and parts of the voting population not valuing individual freedom that much.
- ben-schaaf 7y agoFrom some quick googling it looks to me like Germany isn't big on decriminalisation because they're already most of the way there: > In 1994, the Federal Constitutional Court ruled that drug addiction and the possession of small amounts of drugs for personal use were not crimes.
- luckylion 7y agoThat only applied to Cannabis though, not to drugs in general, and it did not find that possession wasn't a crime, but that the state should not pursue indictments for personal use.
- dalore 7y agoThis is what the article touched on. The culture has to shift to viewing drug addicts not as "druggies" but as someone with a problem who needs help. They changed the language they used to call them. Once this shift happened it's led the path to actually helping them instead of vilifying them.
- lostmymind66 7y agoBecause Portugal doesn't have countries like Mexico bordering it that will use the legal drug trade to further fund cartel violence and control over the country. Corruption is already so rampant, they need to fix their problems before we should ever think about legalizing all drugs. We already have an Opioid crises in the US..and this is with legal drugs. Lawmakers are already starting to blame the legal drug dealers and creators for getting people addicted. If drugs are legalized, a person shouldn't be able to sue the dealer or creator. In the US, it seems like the attitude is "my body, my choice". Until that choice has negative consequences and then the person with the biggest wallet is sued for damages. I don't really see happening in Portugal.
- Couto 7y agoYou are right, but just to give a better picture of Portugal: We still have a lot of illegal drugs coming from Morocco, it's not a solved problem yet. When this law was approved (2001) Portugal (Casal Ventoso) was the major Europe's entrypoint for heroin and everybody knew someone who was addicted, and it was impossible to walk in any city's park and not see an used syringe on the ground. I think what's happening in the US with the opioid crisis is a bit different that requires a different solution. Regulation vs Decriminalization.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sbov 7y agoLegalizing drugs is the best thing the US could do with respect to the cartels. Not only would it reduce profits, it would give producers an arbiter to go to when there are disputes rather than forcing them to rely on their own version of justice.
- masonic 7y agoCalifornia's legalization has shown this to be untrue. Cartel grows in public lands have exploded as the legal market provides general cover for grow and transport activities. There is an estimated 16 times as much cannabis grown in CA than traverses the legal markets... and that excludes imports.
- adamcharnock 7y agoFrom what I hear (as someone now living in rural Portugal), a turning point came when most of the electorate knew someone suffering from a drug addiction. Be it a family member, partner, or friend - there came a point when the majority of people could not only see the problems caused by the epidemic, but could also empathise with those with addictions. As a result of this understanding/empathy, it was possible to pass this legislation. I see parallels with the legalisation of same-sex marriage. I saw somewhere that there is a correlation between support of same-sex marriage and actually knowing that a family member or friend is LQBTQ. It seems to me that once people can empathise on a personal level, new approaches become acceptable (/ enter the Overton Window). How this relates to the opioid crisis in the USA I do not know. I’ll leave someone else with more familiarity with the situation to pontificate on that.
- mtgx 7y agoThe majority of people wanting a certain law doesn't work in the US anyway as Congress is dependent on corporations much more than it is on the people: https://youtu.be/5tu32CCA_Ig https://youtu.be/5tu32CCA_Ig Until corporate bribes are removed from electoral campaigns this won't change.
- ianai 7y agoCorporations actually have a reason to be pro legalization. They’re just not always the same corporations against them. There’s lots of industry to be made around medicinal and recreational uses of drugs. It might even make jobs in rural America in the form of additional cash crops. Further, imagine the societal impact of removing the money for cartels. I think Mexico and central and South America would become dramatically less violent over night. Farmers wouldn’t need to work with cartels to sell now legalized crops. The US would see fewer refugees.
- Qasaur 7y agoConversely I think there are a lot of vested interests in favour of keeping the status quo - I imagine there is a lot of money that is being poured into defense contracts for the War on Drugs, not to mention the private prison industrial complex.
- atemerev 7y ago“The world” is not just US and UK. Here in Switzerland, you can register as e.g. a heroin user, and be provided with cheap Swiss pharmaceutical quality heroin, for the nominal price, in specialized centers for drug users (you obviously can’t take it away, consumption is only allowed on premises — where medical and psychological help is available, and counseling programs for quitting drugs are advertised). The program is immense success, there are no drug dealers on our streets anymore (can’t compete with cheap drugs from the government), drug-related crime has plummeted, and drug users numbers are falling down too (due to these counseling programs). And yes, marijuana is now fully legalized (up to some percentages of THC) and you can buy it with grocery stores just like cigarettes. Nobody seems to be particularly interested, there were no significant changes in consumption culture, etc.
- grenoire 7y agoCouldn't see much about marijuana legalisation in Switzerland, most articles refer to recent trials and such. Any sources?
- atemerev 7y agohttps://theculturetrip.com/europe/switzerland/articles/switzerlands-legal-cannabis-comes-without-a-high/ https://theculturetrip.com/europe/switzerland/articles/switz...
- rolltiide 7y agoUp to 1% of THC which is useless, according to the total absense of peer reviewed clinical trials on CBD and also no fun. Europe would be perfect if literally anywhere got this sorted out Sure, the general lack of life ruining prison sentences is ok and a stark contrast from the US, Middle East and South East Asia. And further decriminalization is ok. But where are the gummies! The edibles! Recreational highs from a convenience store are totally absent. Hanging out with “edgy” people in Europe feels like high school 20 years ago. I really like the West Coast US culture of working professionals having weed and edibles casually.
- 7y ago
- coretx 7y agoBecause half of the security industrial complex and the USA would go bankrupt.
- dmix 7y agoIt’s illegal in Canada (everything besides weed) and most of the western and non western world too. We don’t have private prisons or even a separate agency like the DEA whose job is directly tied to drugs. It’s very much still a cultural reality people haven’t accepted. Although it doesn’t help with the gov agencies constantly fear mongering or straight up lying.
- coretx 7y agoIndigenous Canadians use ( not abuse ) drugs since forever. Traditionally, religion is the gateway to murderous drug policy almost everywhere; uphold by the highly profitable and rent seeking security industrial complex. It's a self reinforcing circle. One that's not likely to end anytime soon. Look at the downvotes i received on my previous post - one that is not only evident but can easily be proven to be true.
- dmix 7y agoSure but a lot of people still believe drugs should be illegal and it’s still a big cultural taboo in many parts of the world. Only recently in the west has that started to shift over 50% for pot. Other ones are much farther behind. That has a big effect on the system as a whole. I still think the agencies and policy directly influences people’s opinion. They constantly hear about drug dealers getting arrested so they associate it immediately as bad people engaged in bad things. So it does have a cyclical effect but not just for financial or rent-seeking reasons. Which exists but I suspect has a smaller role than you think.
- angel_j 7y agoDeciminalisation first. Stop treating everybody like a criminal. It is so mf oppressive, to everybody. "In many ways, the law was merely a reflection of transformations that were already happening in clinics, in pharmacies and around kitchen tables across the country. The official policy of decriminalisation made it far easier for a broad range of services (health, psychiatry, employment, housing etc) that had been struggling to pool their resources and expertise, to work together more effectively to serve their communities."
- imtringued 7y agoBecause the world doesn't want it. The drug addict problem exists by design.
- damnyou 7y agoA lot of this depends on how evenly people suffering are distributed through society. One reason queer rights caught on so quickly is that LGBTQ people are evenly distributed across racial, ethnic and class boundaries. A rich white kid is exactly as likely to be trans, say, as a poor Brown or Black kid. People suffering from drug addictions in the US are more concentrated among certain communities.
- acpetrov 7y agoDo you have a source on racial/class distribution for lgbt? Would be interested to see it
- jacquesm 7y agoAre you trolling? It would seem obvious that such things are distributed exactly the same no matter what ones social status or ethnic background is. It would be very surprising if it wasn't.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- darkpuma 7y agoDo you have data to that effect? What you're saying runs contrary to the data I've seen (e.g. https://news.gallup.com/poll/234863/estimate-lgbt-population-rises.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/234863/estimate-lgbt-population...) and it doesn't matter how elegant a theory is, if the data doesn't fit. There of course may well be additional data that I'm missing, which is why I'm asking.
- casefields 7y agoThat’s such a shockingly small number.
- dondawest 7y agoIt’s not obvious AT ALL. If you’re aware of the “cluster effect” of those with rapid-onset gender dysphoria, you’re aware that being trans is highly influenced by ones social conditions. You’re making an argument that nature is everything when it comes to one’s LGBT status and nurture means nothing, but there’s mountains of evidence to show this is not the case. If you want to tell me that it’s JUST A COINKYDINK that so many female movie stars have male children that JUST SO HAPPEN to be gender dysphoric, your “nature means everything and nurture means nothing” philosophy on LGBT status seems incredibly far-fetched.
- rambo5 7y agoThe CIA aren't going to give up their lucrative drug business that easily
- hugoromano 7y agoThis story always comes back every year. With some ground knowledge on this, as I worked previously for Portugal Ministry of Health (Regional Subdivision). All this is price, and the programme works because drugs go where the money is, i.e. not Portugal, goes to the UK and Germany. On the other hand, Alcoholism is a massive issue in Portugal, and there is no Government action.
- badrabbit 7y agoWhat do you believe could be done at a government level to combat alcoholism?
- ernst_klim 7y ago> because drugs go where the money is, i.e. not Portugal, goes to the UK and Germany. What do you mean? Russia is one of the main drug consumers, and that's not where money is.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hamilyon2 7y agoWhy is only sensible drugs policy called radical is the real question.
- hamilyon2 7y agoOk, why downvotes?
- cjblomqvist 7y agoA lot of comments about why decriminalization of drug use is a no brainer. I'd like to point out that it's not that simple. From what I understand from different "experiments" like Portugal, it's a lot depending on context (eg culture) and how it's done. For example, easier access (lower taxes) on alcohol caused a rise in alcoholics and alcohol related deaths in Finland). Not everyone living in Colorado is happy about the outcome there either (sorry for no references, but please look it up if you'd like). I'm not saying it shouldn't be done but like a startup venture, an idea is worth very little and the environment/market + how it's realized makes all the difference!
- ganzuul 7y agoAlcohol and nicotine are extremely addictive and damaging, and you know what happens during prohibition. Same as cultures differ, so do the drugs. The effects of labeling sick people (I believe the rare fully healthy people don't get addicted easily.) as criminals are however the same everywhere.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- computer_czar 7y ago[citation needed]
- arcturus17 7y ago> easier access (lower taxes) on alcohol I think you are conflating decriminalization with taxation, and decriminalization with legalization, because alcohol is a legal drug. Most people I know who are in favor of legalizing other drugs also support their taxation; at the very least to a point where (a) consumption is heavily disincentivized, (b) external negativities are paid for, and (c) black markets nearly disappear.
- crunchyfrog 7y agoI think drug addiction is really misunderstood and this leads to bad policy. The two popular narratives that drug addiction is a moral failing or a disease are both wrong. In some ways it is more simple than that: drug addiction is a coping mechanism. Most people who get addicted to drugs are using them to escape pain. This is occasionally physical but usually mental. It is memories of traumatic experiences or abuse, loss, stress, etc. That is why incarceration is so counterproductive, you are just giving the addict more pain they need to escape. Also treating drug addiction itself without understanding and addressing the underlying reason for it will just lead to constant relapsing. I recommend the book Chasing the Scream for people who want a better understanding of drug addiction.
- daenz 7y ago>drug addiction is a coping mechanism. That's reductionist. The bigger picture is: why do some people end up with drug addiction as their coping mechanism, but others don't. Why aren't all abuse victims drug addicts? What separates the ones who fall down that hole and the ones who don't? Opportunity? If not opportunity, then what is that X factor? That's why you get to the larger questions of disease, responsibility, and moral failing.
- crunchyfrog 7y agoI'd say opportunity, physiology and personality. Telling someone who is already in more pain than they can handle that they are sick, weak or immoral is not a good idea. After all, they might decide it is true.
- Phenomenit 7y agoThere's always a coping mechanism, it's just a matter of where in society you and what norms and taboos you subscribe to. If drug use has been a part of your life or people around you it's easier to reach for. This is why demonizing drugs and drug users kind of work. But other coping mechanisms are just as bad and sometimes do way more harm to the individual before being surfaced. Workaholism is very detrimental and can have a long lasting effect on ones life(speaking from personal experience).
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoI recently read some something that had the following premise: Immigrants leave their family and friends behind. People who are more empathetic have a harder time doing this. Therefore, countries with net emigration will grow more empathetic. Countries with net immigration will grow less. While just anecdotal, this is something that I've confirmed with my experiences. I'll add in that countries which were founded on a genocide that happened not too long ago, probably will have echos of this continuing for a long time. Backwaters also tend to be less aggressively restrictive of freedom, as greedy, aggressive people naturally navigate out of them.
- AdrianB1 7y agoIt does not seem right to me. My country is also a small Latin country like Portugal and we have significant emigration - people are not more empathetic, the hard life that makes people leave does not make the others empathetic.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoYou need a baseline of comfort to be empathetic. You can't be very empathetic when your kids are hungry.
- zcid 7y agoSame-sex marriage never achieved enough support to be legalized [0][1]. It was voted against throughout the country including liberal states such as California. Same-sex marriage was legislated by a small number of judges. I'm not making an argument for or against so please don't debate me on the merits of this issue. I am merely pointing out that the people did not decide this issue. A very small number of elites did. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-sex_marriage_legislation_in_the_United_States#Efforts_to_ban_same-sex_unions_by_constitutional_amendment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-sex_marriage_legislation_... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._state_constitutional_amendments_banning_same-sex_unions_by_type https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._state_constitutio...
- greglindahl 7y agoSame-sex marriage rights were obtained in several states via a vote in the legislature. And Americans overwhelmingly support the US Constitution and court system. So "the people" were involved in both of those paths.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoIn some states, sure. But where I live in Indiana, the strongly Republican state hates gay people (government and much of the citizenry). Remember that one of the cases in northern Indiana was the 'Gay Cake lawsuit'. Our state only allowed gay marriage because SCOTUS ajudicated it so. Also, the decision also affected me directly because women could legally change their name in marriage for free. But men doing so (I am one of them) had to pay a bunch and go in front of a judge and ask permission. The Gay Marriage decision removed this form of sexual discrimination as well.
- greglindahl 7y agoThe point that I'm getting at is that even in states where a majority dislikes gay people, there's not much of a move to abolish the 14th Amendment. People complain about "activist judges", and there's been one significant recall (Iowa), but that's it. FWIW California was about the same as Indiana in how marriage equality was achieved: a popular vote against followed by a court ruling for. It's popular now, but it wasn't at the time of the court ruling. It's extremely rare that minorities get 14th Amendment rights in a referendum.
- aschmid 7y agoFrom the headline of the article alone, it seems that part of the reason the world hasn't copied it is that it's labeled as "radical", when it really isn't (or shouldn't be) radical at all.
- JasonFruit 7y agoI don't have a strong opinion on Portugal's drug policy. But I do think there's a flaw in the premise of this article: the success of Portugal's policy here was dependent on Portugal's culture, history, population, and a host of other factors that can't be replicated in another country. It's as though I think the United States Constitution is a great thing — as in fact I do — and say, "The radical US Constitution has worked. Why hasn't the world copied it?" You can't lift one feature of a culture out, apply it in isolation, and expect it to function as it did in context.
- AdrianB1 7y agoNot really: Portugal's history, culture and population has no relationship to drug use. There is no history of drug addictions, no culture about it (not even Woodstock), people are similar to other Latin countries in Europe, nothing there to say Portugal is an exception and their solution will not work for others.
- rstuart4133 7y ago> Portugal's policy here was dependent on Portugal's culture, history, population, and a host of other factors that can't be replicated in another country. What Portugal did was pretty straight forward. A lot of people were dying from drugs. They decided it might be because if you sought treatment you we hauled in front of a judge and from there usually went to jail. They didn't decriminalise it - you are still hauled before a judge. But from there the next step was treatment for the addiction. Not surprisingly, the evidence directed treatments works better than the non-evidence directed treatment (jail) so a lot less people end up being severely harmed by them. As a bonus those treatments were a lot cheaper than incarcerating them. The real difficulty is doing that is having a central government strong enough to get it done. Obviously having such a government is somehow related to "culture, history, or population", but only tangentially as I'm sure every parliament in OECD countries could do it equally well regardless of their history. The only difficulty they would be have is opposition from people who are presumably like you and think it would do more harm than good. The only facet that could be surprising is it didn't change the level of drug usage overly. Roughly the same number of people use drugs in Portugal - the only differences are a lot less harms are caused and their habit costs society as a whole a lot less. I don't know what percentage of people think that that way. It's a bit foreign to me, as I find the idea of trying to prevent people from injecting poisons into their blood stream by threatening to harm them in other ways to be downright odd.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThis only works if there are treatment options available which won’t happen in the US. Otherwise prisons wouldn’t be full of people with mental health problems.
- andrewstuart 7y agoPortugals policy seems deeply flawed to me because it does not legalise the sale of drugs. This keeps a strong criminal element and does not protect drug users from contaminated drugs.
- AdrianB1 7y agoIt is solving some problems, not everything. It is much more than what the rest of the world is NOT doing.
- tyingq 7y agoIt's a reasonable question, and I can't call the current US policy as sane in any way. There is, though, some need to account for culture. I doubt, for example, that replicating gun control laws from the UK to the US would result in similar gun violence stats. That said, at the very least, country wide decriminalized marijuana seems like a good start for the US. It's probably less overall harm than alcohol. The long window of employment THC tests probably holds this back.
- dang 7y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15857833 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15857833