16 ms·
How AMD Gave China the ‘Keys to the Kingdom’
- mappu 7y ago> The partnership with the Santa Clara, Calif.-based chip maker was a game changer for China, which has long been unable to match the U.S.’s supercomputing power because of its inferior chips, one product the country has so far struggled to master. Author forgot about Sunway TaihuLight, the top supercomputer in the TOP500 at the time the transfer happened, using a completely domestic CPU architecture. > The AMD deal gave China access to state-of-the-art x86chips, which are made by only two companies in the world: AMD and Intel Corp. Author forgot about Zhaoxin. The new LuJiaZui in particular is really interesting.
- est 7y ago> Sunway TaihuLight, the top supercomputer in the TOP500 It can be traced back to DEC's ALPHA chips.
- jl2718 7y agoInteresting. Almost all leading-edge US chip designs have a piece of their pedigree I can trace from the engineers that worked on the Alpha in that Littleton, MA facility. Did Sunway hire their people or just copy their designs?
- fps_doug 7y agoI wouldn't say that invalidates their achievements though. It's not like they took a 20+ year old architecture, built it on 14nm to bump up clock speed and were done. Improving something existing still requires you to thoroughly understand the technology. There wouldn't really have been a point in starting completely from scratch (why not even reinvent electricity while you're at it), other than some additional street cred.
- chithanh 7y agoI think only the older Sunway (SW1600) chips use Alpha ISA, and not the design. The ones in the TaihuLight (SW26010) are not Alpha. Similar to Loongson, which used the MIPS ISA, but a homegrown design.
- runciblespoon 7y agoWas this written by the advertising department of Intel?
- craftinator 7y agoThat was my first thought, along with Nvidia.
- notacoward 7y agoI'm sure it's just a coincidence that this is being published in multiple outlets now, when AMD is kicking Intel's butt, instead of when it was originally known. Why would anyone suspect otherwise?
- ulzeraj 7y agoWhy do I think this is FUD?
- fwip 7y agoOne clue might be the scaremongering about "this might help China develop nuclear weapons," as if A) they didn't already have nukes B) making your own x86 processors were a prerequisite to nuclear technology
- monocasa 7y agoSeriously, we peaked with control logic for nukes in the 70s. China has been able to put their hands on PDP-11s for quite a while now, lol.
- azinman2 7y agoIt’s not about control logic as supercomputers are used to simulate explosions so you don’t have to do it in the world releasing a lot of radioactivity.
- monocasa 7y agoSure but using that to optimize for yield (ie. scariness) peaked in the 70s too. Like anything past and including tsar bomba ceases to make sense.
- sinuhe69 7y agoBut you can not put a tzar bomb on a rocket, that can be fired from a silo or even from a submarine. And to threat America and Europe your rocket need to flight 10000 miles or more and reach Mach 5 or even faster. All possible only with high yield, compact warheads, which the Chinese do not have yet.
- monocasa 7y ago
- intheknow12 7y agoI have worked for certain major semiconductor companies. At least two of them. The question is not “Why did AMD hand over all its IP to China,” the question is “Why did our incompetent government allow this to happen and why did they turn a blind eye to the strong arming that was going on?” A further question is: “Why did only some (always smaller) tech companies fork over the IP while very large ones did not?” Let me tell you a story about a fab in a distant country that begins with a C. The rumor was that it was a very expensive server fab. One day, the wafer (the thing that the server chip is produced with and is extremely valuable, multi billions in the case of a server chip) went missing. They locked down the factory for 48 hours and brought in a search team, scoured the building from bottom to top and then found nothing. Then, as if by magic, the wafer appeared three feet away from where it went missing. Industrial espionage. And that is what you get when you are big. What happens when you are small? They put a gun to your head (metaphorically) and say “Split off a company and hand it over to entities controlled by the Chinese government. All your IP will be shared with them. They will own the market in China and send you a royalty check and have the ability to modify your IP to build custom products. If you don’t like it, fuck off, no China for you.” What lazy, incompetent and useless western journalists have been shockingly non curious about is why certain companies like Microsoft and Apple magically don’t seem to get this treatment. It is almost as though....some other arrangement was getting made. No lazy western journalists to my knowledge have yet bothered to investigate why it is that Intel, Microsoft etc have not been forced to do these IP sharing agreements while AMD and others have. One day, Lazy western journalists might be curious and get off their asses from Covering trump but somehow I doubt it. Blaming AMD for “handing over the keys” is fucking stupid. It is the United States government’s lack of a spinal cord that is the problem. These companies had no choice. Either play the game or get shut out of the market. Bad journalism, everywhere along with a lack of curiosity.
- jdsully 7y ago> One day, the wafer (the thing that the server chip is produced with and is extremely valuable, multi billions in the case of a server chip) went missing. I assume you mean the mask set...
- 7y ago
- Nerada 7y agoSeems strange to me that China was able to manufacture processors but they couldn't manufacture ballpoint pens domestically until 2017.
- etherael 7y agoProcessors are more important than ballpoint pens.
- benj111 7y agoFun thought experiment. You have to extend it to all writing implements, but what would happen if no contracts could get signed, laws get signed etc. The housing industry would grind to a halt pretty quickly. You'd get actual paperless offices though!
- gchamonlive 7y agoTechniques involved in producing pens are unrelated to producing silicon chips. You can easily have one without the other, one is not a condition to have the other. I guess you mean China didn't have the technological framework to produce hightech products. I am not sure I agree, but I don't have numbers to support any claim.
- ethbro 7y agoIf you show up with bags of money, ASML will sell to you. So yes, it's a major achievement and there's a lot of knowledge layered on top of that equipment, but it's not like they need to reinvent everything from scratch.
- nickpsecurity 7y agoThey're worried about foreign influence and subversion. They know chip making is a critical activity underpinning all sorts of other activities. They want to build the tech it depends on themselves so it's in their control. Maybe backdoor-free, too.
- 7y ago
- wincaltop 7y agoWhen we are fortunate enough later to be enrolled in China's "reducation" camp, where muslims are "enticed" to eat pork and drink beer, indians are "enticed" to eat beef, and christians are "enticed" to study xi jing pingism, and all of us are "encouraged" to donate a liver or kidney, and work to produce products for alibaba, we'll know who to thank for all of that.
- chao- 7y agoThe strategy summarized as "introduce a foreign technology to the market, absorb it, and then innovate to make China a leader" is doubtlessly true, and I am for re-leveling the economic playing field (so-called) between the US and China as much as the next person, but this article over-sells and under-informs in a few ways. For starters, there is a throwaway graph (in that it is not directly addressed in the article) of the Top500 over time. As Patrick Kennedy at STH has rightly complained on over recent years [0], there is a rising issue with taking the lower-to-mid ranks of Top500 to mean anything at all. A lot of the systems are actually web hosting platforms, being temporarily leveraged to run an HPC benchmark for marketing purposes. Most recently he called out two Chinese companies (Lenovo and Sugon) as among the largest offenders. My other nitpick is more core to the article: it is not as if no one in China knew anything about x86 chip design before talking to AMD. Though I will admit I am underinformed on the NatSec legalities, to my knowledge there has a similar x86 license-and-joint-venture structure between Zhaoxin and VIA for many years. The article goes on to say: >Chinese versions of AMD chips already have been rolling off production lines. Which brings up some ominous analogues to displacement of other American products by Chinese manufacturing. That may be inaccurate imagery, though, as it isn't clear which manufacturer's fabs are being used for the Dhyana chips. I am no industry insider but from what I can tell Hygon is fabless (as is Huawei's HiSilicon, for that matter) and I could not find any clear information as to who is actually manufacturing the chips [1]. Does anyone here know? I'll keep my uninformed speculation to myself, but knowing whose fabs and whose process technology actually led to working Hygon designs being realized in silicon is an important detail to fully tell this tale. Now I have no doubt China is working to catch up in this area as well, but it seems that the entire fabrication ecosystem (including companies like ASML, not just Taiwanese and American fabs) represent technology gaps equal to x86 chip design. It takes many actors to put on this play, and laying it all at AMD's feet, or using phrasing like "gave away the keys to the kingdom" feels like a solid overstatement. [0] https://www.servethehome.com/top500-june-2019-our-new-systems-analysis/ https://www.servethehome.com/top500-june-2019-our-new-system... [1] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/hygon https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/hygon
- DevKoala 7y agoPeople with Intel stock are not happy.
- robotron 7y agoYeah I can't decouple articles like this from the market.
- dmix 7y ago> That technology is helping China in its race with the U.S. to build the first next-generation supercomputer—an essential tool for advanced civilian and military applications. Are we entering a space-race with China for supercomputers or something? Did I miss the memo?
- cc439 7y agoOh, hey! I know how this story ends: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Have_No_Mouth,_and_I_Must_Scream https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Have_No_Mouth,_and_I_Must_Sc...
- chao- 7y agoYes you did miss the memo, but most of America did. My first awareness came about five years ago through friends who are in (or adjacent to) the HPC space. What has surprised me most is the difference in awareness and framing between the Chinese and Americans I have spoken with (though obviously "data" is not the plural of "anecdotes"). When I speak with Chinese friends, and contemporaries in tech sectors, many view the current state of US-Chinese economic conflicts in two parts: a trade war and a related-but-separate "tech war". Speaking with Americans, among those who work in the technology sector, less than half see there being a separate "tech war", outside/beyond the context of the tariffs and related trade negotiations. Outside of tech, no Americans I have spoken to see there being a separate tech war, and it is entirely contextualized in President Trump's current trade war framing. As for Chinese nationals outside of tech, I have far fewer conversations. I did recently speak with a gentleman from a maritime BRI project in Africa (i.e. very removed from tech). He nonetheless seemed to hold a pride for recent Chinese technological advances as a part of his identity (or personality?) and viewed it as outside/beyond the specific incidentals of the current trade war. He was happy to be working on the BRI, but he thought that it was less important than the technology contest. My guess is that a lot of it comes down to intentional framing and emphasis in popular news media?
- addicted 7y agoMaybe because people realize that despite this "tech war" that China is apparently winning, Apple still makes the vast majority of profits in the smartphone world, and the vast majority of those profits find their way to the US. Google still.makes the vast majority of OSes installed in the world, followed by Microsoft and Apple, and the money there also largely goes to the US. Intel still makes the vast majority of money in the semi conductor world, and the vast majority of that flows to the US. Their biggest threat is ARM, a British company owned by the Japanese, also an ally and open societies. American software companies dominate tech and internet in both mindshare and profits throughout the world, excluding China. Despite them "stealing" all this IP. Sure, the US may not be able to compete in China, but the openness of the US meant that the rest of Asia, Europe, Africa America's were willing to buy their products. When the US engages in nationalistic trade wars, it loses China's market which was never really available to it. But it also gives Europeans and Asians and Africans an excuse to exclude the US from their markets. Any country wanting to do that, which I suspect a lot of them will now that Trump has decided he just wants to fight trade wars despite the US being the biggest winner of the current economic system, simply needs to point to the well known American spying to ignore American suppliers and software companies and developers. The US may come out net better in the relationship with China but it's gonna lose a lot more. (it won't even here...China had been giving America TVs and computers and what not for pieces of paper. If you told an alien this deal they wouldnt believe the US is complaining. The US's problem is entirely that it hasn't been able to distribute this massive wealth surplus it has enjoyed throughout it's society, because it has prioritized the ability of the richest to hoard that wealth to the point they don't even have islands left to buy, instead of providing healthcare to the poorest).
- est 7y ago> How AMD Gave China the ‘Keys to the Kingdom’ Or: how China invested in AMD when its stock price was at historical low, so in return AMD gave China its x86 secrets and Zen architecture.
- AareyBaba 7y agoAMD was about to go bankcrupt in 2012-13. CEO Rory Read laid off a large number of non-engineering staff and sold off real estate to stabilize the financial situation and managed to stave off imminent bankruptcy. When Dr Lisa Su took over in 2014, AMD was desperate for a cash infusion to plow into R&D for the Zen architecture. There was no U.S. investor willing to make a $300 million investment in a company that held key CPU and GPU technology and world-class engineering expertise. Apple, Google, Microsoft could have benefited from AMD's CPU/GPU tech but they would rather make multi-billion dollar offers for companies like Groupon and Snapchat or Dr Dre's Beats. An American company was saved by this joint venture with China while Wall Street was gleefully shorting AMD.
- adventured 7y agoAbu Dhabi did more to keep AMD alive than China. They ploughed $600 million into AMD in 2007. Mubadala had built up a 13% stake in the company.
- AareyBaba 7y agoYes that is correct. Abu Dhabi investment kept AMD alive for a while but by 2012-13 AMD was at rock bottom and needed more cash to implement a turn-around. There was a lot more financial jugglery going on but to go into detail would be off context to the discussion.
- throwaway2048 7y agogoes to show how out of wack shit has gotten with investment in the real economy has gotten, as opposed to chasing online ad money.
- jpmattia 7y agoIt's probably worth remembering that WSJ is a Murdoch property. > Three weeks after getting the top job, Ms. Su, a Taiwan-born New Yorker, jetted to Beijing to meet officials at China’s Ministry of Industry and Information Technology. A Chinese vice minister urged her to partner with China “to achieve mutual benefits based on AMD’s technological strength,” according to a ministry press release at the time. I assume the message is: ZOMG, foreigners are giving away US technology!
- azinman2 7y agoWhich is true. These dual venture deals are very stupid to make long term. China is being very smart here, while the groupthink towards outsourcing and the stock market demanding Chinese access has created their own doom.
- rchaud 7y agoA good subset of HN commenters defend union-busting ("right-to-work" laws), outright regulation breaking (Uber's "greyball", Airbnb) and poor domestic working conditions (Amazon fulfillment centers), if it results in "value for the shareholders" and "frees companies to innovate". Of course, since this involves selling chips to a CCP-adjacent entity, it's no longer a story about how AMD saw a 10x boost in its stock and brought competitive new products to the market.
- tracker1 7y agoI'm in favor of right to work, only because I don't want to be required to join a union. Of course, I'm also in favor of much greater restrictions on Corporation "Freedom" and bringing IP legislation back to something reasonable.
- xvilka 7y agoThis whole story of later years, maybe it will bring more attention to the lack of progress in commercial hardware design tools, their ridiculous price, and existing efforts to create modern open source alternatives, like SymbiFlow [1], Chisel3 [2]/FIRRTL[3], The Open ROAD[4] project, etc. [1] https://symbiflow.githib.io https://symbiflow.githib.io [2] https://github.com/freechipsproject/chisel3 https://github.com/freechipsproject/chisel3 [3] https://github.com/freechipsproject/firrtl https://github.com/freechipsproject/firrtl [4] https://theopenroadproject.org/ https://theopenroadproject.org/
- Topgamer7 7y agoYou spelled github wrong in your first link.
- lambdasquirrel 7y agoChina made investments in AMD when they weren’t doing well. If they wanted to, they could have hired away AMD’s team instead. Maybe people miss the notion that this particular strategy had likely kept jobs in the US in the longer term. It is a similar strategy to Geely’s ownership of Volvo. But of course you can expect the WSJ to spin it this way.
- azinman2 7y agoPerhaps some might have gone, but the majority in Silicon Valley would have just stayed there, going to Intel, IBM, Apple, and other ARM makers. People don’t change countries randomly (and so drastically) because they lost their jobs.
- harry8 7y agoand they don't need to if they don't want to but switch employers, branch offices are a thing.
- lambdasquirrel 7y agoThe counterpoint is, you have to remember the timeframe when a lot of these hardware companies were not doing too well. I had many friends who got laid off around the same time. Many had mortgages. As a rule, hardware companies of this sort do not just start up.
- izacus 7y agoThe fact that this submarine hatemongering keeps surfacing to the top of this site is rather concering. If only this article had substantial content... but, as other commenters pointed out, it doesn't even pass the basic smell test.
- rwmj 7y agoI'm also confused why it's even a problem if China has top class fabs. There'll be more competition, so it's better for us. Are we worried about Intel's profit margins?
- iagovar 7y agoIf I were American I'd be worried about jobs and maintaining certain level of independence in case of conflict.
- oblio 7y agoA decent chunk of US's success in the past 70 years has been reliant on the US having no real competition. By real competition I mean someone with both the same skill level and the same heft/weight. If you look at how the US reacted when Japan was rising, it wasn't a pretty view. It only died down because Japan stagnated 2 decades ago. China's kind of the same story, but if it stagnates at about the same level at Japan, the Chinese economy will be 2-3x the US economy. That's super scary if you haven't competed on equal footing for more than half a century. Obviously, China being an autocratic regime doesn't help either, or that China's national interests in the region directly conflict with the US interests there (Taiwan, South Korea, etc.). I'd bet dollars to cents that even if China had the most pristine Swiss democracy, the US reaction would be 99% the same.
- throw0101a 7y ago> I'm also confused why it's even a problem if China has top class fabs. Some people don't like the idea of a totalitarian state being a world power with top-notch technology.
- lm28469 7y ago> I'm also confused why it's even a problem if China has top class fabs Don't you listen to the news ? Everything China is bad. /s
- pcr910303 7y agoMaybe this is because I’m not a US citizen, but why do Americans dislike China so much?̊̈ I just cannot understand why China building it’s own jets is a problem. US already builds it’s own jets and nobody hates that to the point ‘Let’s not partnership with US to not leak any info’. Why is this particular dislike to China?̊̈ Is it just the ‘Communism is bad...’ thing?̊̈ Or is it something much more?̊̈
- themacguffinman 7y agoThe Chinese government is authoritarian and anti-freedom of speech. As a Western person who agrees with Western values, I do not view the ascendancy of such a government to be a positive thing.
- greatpatton 7y agoSo can you explain us why Saudi Arabia an absolute monarchy that oppress at least half of its population (women), kill everyone speaking against the king is one of the best US ally? Having such double standard undermine greatly US credibility.
- themacguffinman 7y agoI don't support the US' alliance with Saudi Arabia. What's your point? What does this have to do with my dislike of China's government?
- ptah 7y agoit is not about you personally, i think OP refers to american foreign policy
- themacguffinman 7y agoI should rephrase: what does the US govt's alliance with Saudi Arabia's govt have to do with American/Western people's dislike of the Chinese govt?
- greatpatton 7y agoGiven the number of bad articles regarding China lately (NYT,Bloomberg,WSJ), It seems that the journalists of the land of freedom have the same level of integrity than the Chinese journalist. Simple question: Chinese money saved AMD in 2013 when the stock was less than 2.5$ and the company almost dead. Why did the USA not pay for their own technology, rather than complaining 6 years later when this investment is now becoming fruitful?
- RomanBob 7y agoIt seems that in the mind of the general US public, the idea that the US global hegemon status is being challenged is unacceptable.
- sct202 7y agoI remember wondering if AMD was about to die back then from Intel strangling it to death. They totally did this out of desperation, and I'd imagine they were not the only Western company that were faced with choosing between impending doom or fire sale to China.
- dbancajas 7y agoqualcomm also did this recently (search for qualcomm HXT). A lot of companies prolly do this to get access to china.
- tmd83 7y agoThis just smells like a rat like some others said. It's probably true that the deal while might not be essential probably did help Chinese cpu development. But it's unlikely that US govt. at the time didn't understand the implication or couldn't have stopped it if they really wanted it. And it's not like reporters are finding out about this just now. I don't know the financial situation for AMD was at 2014 and they might have ceased to exists for all I know. But the article writes as if the money itself turned the company around. It's the R&D and design of a new chip that heralded a new era for AMD. And if I'm reading correctly the deal actually ended up being done in 2016 by which time most of the work on Zen was already done I presume. As someone else said in another comment it is kind of shameful how investment works. Forget about China/US thing, chip development is important work and no one invested in it properly. For big cloud companies simply the pressure over intel (with a competitive AMD) should have been worth it by itself.
- metildaa 7y agoThe author also omitted that China has no bleeding edge foundries (like TSMC & Samsung's 7nm fabs) and it is unlikely they will be able to build one any time soon. Both Intel and Global Foundries are trapped on older nodes, and China is in a slightly worse position (with their most advanced node being 14nm). All of AMD's new cores are built on TSMC 7nm, and with outdated nodes & 3 revision old designs, China is unlikely to be able to significantly improve on the designs they licensed from AMD. Arguably, China doesn't have the homegrown talent to do chip design. Allwinner yeets barely altered SOC designs from ARM into existence, and Hygon's chip design talent is in large part not China based.
- rwmj 7y agoThe Chinese govt is pouring huge amounts of resources into training homegrown chip designers. They're doing it based on RISC-V.
- microcolonel 7y ago> The Chinese govt is pouring huge amounts of resources into training homegrown chip designers. They're doing it based on RISC-V. Frankly both of those statements are true of all major industrial nations.
- ulfw 7y agoFrance and Germany put huge amounts of money into training chip designers? Huh?
- orbifold 7y agoGermany is investing 3 billion in deep learning accelerators and all the big automotive companies are investing large amounts aswell. They want to own the supply chain, just as they used to. There are even some army guys sitting in the negotiations (unusual for Germany).
- 7y ago
- grwthckrmstr 7y agoFeel like there is excessive scaremongering about "China" from US based media publications off late, with a "and this is how China ffukkd us" twists. Perhaps it would be wise for people to keep that filter in mind (as this is how mass manipulation works folks).
- vectorEQ 7y ago:') oh noes, china also has business men and women with money who want to invest in things. lets find any reason to be negative about it and try to get it back in our western hands
- codedokode 7y agoIf Chinese manufacturers infringe on patented technologies, then it will be easy to ban import of their products. If they don't infringe and make something innovative then there is no problem. Having more competition is better for consumers. Also, as AMD entered the deal voluntarily, it means that it was considered profitable despite the risks. And I don't see the problem with building a supercomputer. Is it a privilege that shouldn't be available to developing countries?
- 0x262d 7y agothere is a flood of anti-china articles because china threatens the US' monopoly on high-tech profitmaking, and the US companies and rich people are laying the basis to protect their profits with war.
- fuzzyset 7y agoThe focus on supercomputing seems odd. x86 is not nearly as dominant in supercomputing as it is in servers. A quick look at the TOP500 shows many other architectures (top 3 aren't x86). Is there something a homegrown x86 chip would give China over top of the line Intel silicon? Does Intel have secret IP on the die that only the US govt can access?
- zelon88 7y agoTl;dr: AMD turned itself from a domestic $5b company with 2,000 employees and no capital into a global leader in semiconductors while simultaneously enduring 30 years of crushing (and illegal) anti-competitive practices by it's primary competitor of 25 times its net worth and 50 times it's workforce strength. Now that AMD has managed to take those 2,000 American workers and push back against 80k American Intel workers + 20k Israeli Intel workers the US has decided it's not fair for "AMD to license it's highly proprietary, highly impressive, highly competitive products to undemocratic nations." cough-Israel-Wintel-lobbyists-cough