17 ms·
What Happens After Amazon’s Domination Is Complete? Its Bookstore Offers Clues
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 7y ago> An Amazon spokeswoman denied that counterfeiting of books was a problem, saying, “This report cites a handful of complaints, but even a handful is too many and we will keep working until it’s zero.” The company said it strictly prohibited counterfeit products and last year denied accounts to more than one million suspected “bad actors.” If it were just a handful of cases, you wouldn't have a million "bad actors" getting caught. You'd have a handful. A million people a year aren't trying this because it's unprofitable.
- foota 7y agoI believe they're saying there were a handful of cases where they didn't catch it.
- ceejayoz 7y agoSure, and I'm saying that doesn't pass the smell test. A million accounts a year being banned means folks are seeing all that trouble (it's not anywhere near as easy a process as just signing up for a consumer Amazon account) as worthwhile.
- mcv 7y agoIt smells like the common kind of contradictory denial: It never happened, and when it did, I didn't do it, besides, I already fixed it.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoI really don't see how Amazon is any different to Pirate Bay here. I take it there aren't too many pirate movies being sold so that Hollywood won't get involved.
- gwern 7y agoAn irony here is that it looks like you are increasingly more likely to get the real book if you go to Libgen rather than Amazon.
- wbl 7y agoThe old Yo Ho has rarely gotten me anything not as described. The same cannot be said for amazon.
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoIt’s actually far worse than the pirate bay IMHO as they appear legit and pocket a part of transactions—ie profiting over screwing over otherwise moral agents who attempt an honest transaction.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoThat's a great analogy / comparison. Lots of interesting thought experiments and research could go into separating the differences between, and collating the similarities of, the two. The original Pirate Bay founders were pursued internationally to be held accountable for their intellectual property facilitation. Will Jeff Bezos join Kim Dotcom in New Zealand to hide from US prosecution for facilitating the sale of counterfeit books? Will there be any follow-up or holding to account? Hahahaha, NO! How does this sit within the context of the US-China trade war? (Physical) Counterfeit products versus (electronic) intellectual property breaches, with seemingly more importance placed upon the less tangible, electronic, law-breaking. You've found the entry to a labyrinthine rabbit hole.
- krick 7y agoWell, Pirate Bay sure is cheaper...
- 7y ago
- gubbrora 7y agoWe've been told that the antidote to deep fakes is supply chain security. It's troubling to hear that supply chain security is already broken and by fairly unsophisticated attackers from the sounds of it.
- valleyer 7y agoIs the term "deep fakes" commonly used to refer to counterfeit merchandise? I hadn't heard it used that way before.
- chii 7y agoI would not use deep fakes to refer to counterfeit goods. Deep fakes refers only to artificially generated videos of a real person (usually face, but it could include voice).
- gubbrora 7y agoNo. Per wiki. Deepfake (a portmanteau of "deep learning" and "fake"[1]) is a technique for human image synthesis based on artificial intelligence. It is used to combine and superimpose existing images and videos onto source images or videos using a machine learning technique known as generative adversarial network.[2] The phrase "deepfake" was coined in 2017. Because of these capabilities, deepfakes have been used to create fake celebrity pornographic videos or revenge porn.[3] Deepfakes can also be used to create fake news and malicious hoaxes.[4][5]
- lithos 7y agoLook at the post history, it's a bot. Always posts something tangential and maybe sourced from forums of a topic that seems close.
- colejohnson66 7y agoThat doesn’t mean it’s a bot.
- mockery 7y agoI didn't read the parent post as using it that way - I believe they're saying that any claim that "supply chain security" (of videos) will combat deep fakes* isn't necessarily a credible model of security considering that the "real" supply chain (of physical goods) isn't apparently particularly secure. I don't think I actually agree, however. Things like hashing and cryptography make me inclined to believe a digital 'chain of custody' is easier to prove and validate than a physical one. ( *I'd never heard this before, but it's an interesting claim )
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- naringas 7y agothe digital nature of information removes the need of exclusive ownership. we must find a way to make a marketplace function without exclusive ownership.
- chii 7y agoPrepayment instead of post-payment could work. An author asks for money upfront. This amount is going to fund the creation of the work. Then a copy goes to the preparers to do as they wish (including making copies to distribute). I foresee crowd funded prepayments to be the norm in the future, and also sponsorships (like patreon) style payments would be the alternative model.
- nine_k 7y agoKickstarter works like this, with a number of spectacular successes, abs spectacular failures.
- robocat 7y agoPrepayment can't work for the first creation produced. By induction prepayment can't work for new authors.
- chii 7y ago> Prepayment can't work for the first creation produced. why would this be necessarily true? And prepayment could work if the payment is discounted enough for unknown creators.
- trevyn 7y agoOr a way to make a society function without a marketplace.
- tzs 7y ago> the digital nature of information removes the need of exclusive ownership There are a variety of justifications for copyright in various legal systems around the world, and I can't think of any of them where information being digital as opposed to analog would make a difference. All digital really changes, as far as I can see, is that it makes it possible to make perfect copies and it makes the cost of copying essentially zero. None of the copyright justifications I'm aware of are based on copying being hard or expensive.
- aeturnum 7y agoIt's interesting to note that the screenshot of the review of Murder On the Orient express is complaining about CreateSpace [1] an Amazon subsidiary that does print-on-demand stuff. [1] https://www.createspace.com/ https://www.createspace.com/
- egypturnash 7y agoShit, Amazon’s already doing this with other stuff. They have a giant counterfeiting problem across the board, and internal systems that only make it worse by fulfilling an order from one vendor with stock from a different one if that happens to be closer to the customer. I first started hearing about it around the 2017 eclipse, when people ordering glasses designed to let you safely stare into the sun got fakes that wouldn’t do the job properly, but it seemed to already be pretty widespread by now. https://www.forbes.com/sites/wadeshepard/2017/12/13/how-to-protect-your-family-from-dangerous-fakes-on-amazon-this-holiday-season/#31bab2217cf1 https://www.forbes.com/sites/wadeshepard/2017/12/13/how-to-p...
- fma 7y agoYep, I remember that - and I made the conscious decision to purchase my glasses from B&H Photo because of this exact reason.
- vanadium 7y agoThe integrity of B&H over my years of ordering from them is literally unparalleled in my experience. Only if I can’t find an item from them will I check elsewhere at this point. If Amazon wants inspiration as to how to do things right...
- codyb 7y agoI also have never had issues with REI for sporting goods/outdoor gear, or Barnes and Nobles for books. If I can avoid Amazon I will, if I can’t I try to order directly from the manufacturer and no other seller.
- on_and_off 7y agoI just wish there were more options :/ Often when I try to find something just a little bit out of the ordinary, Amazon tends to be the only option. And when there is another option, even something like best buy, their experience can be pretty bad (my best buy account is in some sort of limbo where I have been able to create it but can't access it .. so I have to do all my purchases in guest mode).
- SubiculumCode 7y agoAnecdotally, I just cancelled Amazon Prime. Domination won't be --complete-- until they get me back.
- TheRealPomax 7y agotl;dr: because they've already won, Amazon has zero reason (financial or moral) to fight counterfeit products. Nothing the consumer says or does can meaningfully impact Amazon's bottom line, and no regulation exists (nor is likely to exist in the future) to force them to "fix their shit". Unlike banks, Amazon is now simply too big to fail. (Because unlike banks, Amazon has a million and one services that all more than compensate for each other. Amazon, the website, is barely a fraction of Amazon, the corporation)
- jhloa2 7y agoThat might be the case but individuals are still free to refuse to buy items from amazon. I know that they won’t fail anytime soon because of AWS but I absolutely refuse to buy any items from their store because 7/10 times it’s garbage. They might not fail but luckily there’s still good online alternatives
- leetcrew 7y ago> I absolutely refuse to buy any items from their store because 7/10 times it’s garbage. genuinely curious, what kinds of things do you order? I place 1-2 orders every month and I've never received anything that I suspected was counterfeit.
- colejohnson66 7y agoI place 5-20 orders a month and have never received counterfeit
- joering2 7y agoSlightly OT but I just won a bet with a buddy of mine who works at Wholefoods. Somewhat knowing Amazon for huge variety of products, he assumed Amazon will even add more products to Wholefoods palette. I told him to the contrary - Amazon is a hard core analytics company with simple website [todays standards] and incredibly rich physical delivery network. We bet $100. Yesterday I visited him at work. Year later Amazon hs cut off its 365 brand of awesome organic stuff unique to Wholefoods and is on plan to cut 20% more products according to internal email he received. Whatever didn’t hit “moving average” high enough is getting sliced - no more 25 types of meat, just one vacuum packed not even prepared at Wholefoods. Amazon is on its path to destroy the brand. Soon there won’t be anything there that you canmt buy at Wallmart at 10% discount. / rant
- siphon22 7y agoThat sounds depressing. Seriously. Similar kind of thing happened at a bakery I work at. We used to make so many varieties of baked goods, but they've been cut down to the items that sold well. I mean, that means less food goes to waste in the end, but it is still disheartening and I think is a shame as the glass displays looked so much more pleasing with the plentiful variety it had before.
- p1necone 7y agoYou can please 80% of customers with 20% of products, but that 20% is different for every customer.
- SeanBoocock 7y agoSure but there is always a tension between being able to address as much of the potential customer base as possible and profitability. On one end of the spectrum you have grocers like Aldi or Lidl that have slashed prices and margins by reducing SKUs (among other cost saving measures). Whole Foods probably has some room to shed unprofitable inventory so long as it preserves its upscale, ecologically conscious brand.
- xmprt 7y ago80% of customers go to Walmart for the cheapest thing they can find to get the job done. I don't think anyone thinks it's a good idea for Amazon to become Walmart (except for investors maybe).
- robertAngst 7y agoDarn I clicked the link, I gave NYT money due to my fear. Although this doesnt change anything. Given how easy it would be for a competitor Fortune 500 to dump resources and marketing into a competing store, they could never 'get away with murder'. FAANG has more to worry about the tech bubble, than the world with FAANG.
- kgwxd 7y agoMaybe a good indicator for other IP/copyright centric business models. Where "product", a.k.a. data, is artificially made hard to access. That is going to die as a business model at some point, including for Amazon, and that day can't come soon enough. If you're heart is still in that business, you had better enjoy lobbying, because that's your purpose, and you better not care about improving society, because you're not making the world a better place when you succeed. I don't think books are a good indicator of what will befall real products. There's no doubt Amazon is causing major pains in that area, but I don't think they'll ever "complete" that domination.
- SquishyPanda23 7y ago> Where "product", a.k.a. data, is artificially made hard to access. That is going to die as a business model at some point I actually see a different future. Artificial scarcity becomes easier with improvements to cryptography. I think the future is full of artificially scarce goods, such as music, video, crypto kitties, etc.
- ses1984 7y agoMusic, video, etc are easy to break. Any crypto designed to protect content from people consuming that content is doomed to be broken. Crypto kitties or hats as part of a central service like a game, that stuff can actually be kept artificially scarce.
- jbay808 7y agoCory Doctorow argues that you can't encrypt people's media and also hand them the decryption keys they need in order to consume it, and not expect those decryption keys to leak. https://corydoctorow.miraheze.org/wiki/DRM_and_MSFT:_A_Product_No_Customer_Wants#DRM_systems_don.27t_work https://corydoctorow.miraheze.org/wiki/DRM_and_MSFT:_A_Produ...
- the_pwner224 7y agoThis is only possible if the user can examine what their computers are doing. These days we have restricted boot ("secure boot") and "trusted platform modules" (which can be used for good though) that allow computers to do decryption without the user being able to see it. For example my Galaxy S9 phone has a locked bootloader. It only boots software signed by Samsung's private key. Google makes DRM software, Netflix and co. sign on, Samsung puts the DRM in their phones because they're useless without Netflix. The only way to find out how to decrypt the video is to crack the hardware. And some companies might make shitty hardware, but Apple has shown that it's very possible to make a locked down device that takes millions+ of dollars to hack. Intel iirc had special paths in their processors for video DRM. Google's Widewine DRM is available in all the major browsers. MS has been pushing restricted boot for a while. All that's left is for them to make it mandatory. Of course none of this matters because you can just record the screen or the speakers... If you're serving content into Bob's eyes or ears then he can use fake eyes or ears to record it.
- lone_haxx0r 7y ago"Counterfeit" is a good thing in my book, as long as there's a way to know the quality of the product before you buy it. Saying that there's zero counterfeit implies that quality is always the same (good quality, most of the time). By not acknowledging the existance of counterfeit, Amazon doesn't allow us to publicize and hence compare the quality of different sellers.
- inamberclad 7y agoThe comment above you has other things to say - notably, you're not even guaranteed to get the item from the vendor you ordered from and might get something of lower quality from another seller.
- tasty_freeze 7y agoThat is a short-sighted stance. What incentive do I have to write and publish a book (at least a man-year of effort) when someone expending 1% of the effort gets to reap most of the financial reward for it? Even if the quality of the counterfeit (not sure why you used scare quotes) is fine and you save a few dollars, in the following years you'll find fewer and fewer new books you care to by because few people are writing them.
- asveikau 7y agoThe article talks about a medical handbook whose dosage recommendations might be affected by OCR errors. You want that to come straight from the source and not a scanned copy.
- greggeter 7y agoSpecialized, trusted shops are the future.
- nazgulnarsil 7y agoI'm confused how there isn't a huge opportunity for an online dept store with 100% vetted goods here. Does such a thing exist? If not why not? If so how can one find it? What keywords point to it? They win if they can get that keyword into the minds of the general public.
- bm98 7y agoWalmart. I've been Amazon Prime for years, but whenever I need to buy something with a high risk of being counterfeit (printer ink is the most common one for me), I use Walmart - and it's free shipping from them anyway. Really the only difference is that Amazon usually gets it to my door faster.
- didibus 7y agoI don't know the details, but Walmart is also moving towards more of being an online marketplace: https://marketplace.walmart.com/ https://marketplace.walmart.com/ Is the inventory commingled, are the sellers better vetted, is it obvious that you are buying from a 3rd party and not Walmart, all that I don't know. Just pointing this out.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoTarget.com is okay for now, but supposedly they are going to start going that way also. These days, I look to purchase on the official brand’s website first, or whichever seller they link to on the brand’s website.
- appleiigs 7y agoAre you serious. How about any store that isn't Amazon or doesn't sell second-hand goods. Only Amazon does this. If you go to Nike.com, are you going to be worried about your shoes being counterfeit?
- bluGill 7y agoActually yes. Running a secure storefront is hard, as is supply chain logistics. The easy way out is to have amazon host your storefront - you design the theme and put the products there, but the security, payment and shipping are all Amazon. I regularly buy from a small website that isn't run by Amazon - some months after every order I get a different credit card in the mail because someone hacked the small website. They really need to give up on running their own secure payment processor and hire someone bigger. (I order from them because for the obscure parts my car needs they have the right one in stock and know which are right)
- anon21286 7y ago> But Amazon takes a hands-off approach to what goes on in its bookstore, never checking the authenticity, much less the quality, of what it sells. It does not oversee the sellers who have flocked to its site in any organized way Uh... this seems like an unsubstantiated claim. It's my understanding Amazon has multiple team actively working on manual and automated anti-fraud including for counterfeit. I think there's more inherent problems to this: 1. Making it easier for sellers to sell, mean it's also easier for fraudsters to do so. 2. Being so popular and central means all fraudsters focus their energy on it.
- vxNsr 7y agoI think it's very simple, amazon and all such stores should be held liable for the fraud and lost business as if they themselves created the counterfeit goods. macys wouldn't be given a free pass if it sold counterfeit nikes in their B&M store. so why does amazon get one, they take a 15% cut just like macys does.
- save_ferris 7y agoAmazon is a lot more powerful and influential than Macy's is. I think this is at least partially caused by the increasingly important political relationship between major employers like Amazon and governments. Amazon likely tells governments that being held accountable for things like this would dramatically hurt their business, and therefore cost jobs. No politician wants to be blamed for lost jobs.
- petre 7y agoThere are different kinds of politicians and there's public opinion. https://www.theverge.com/interface/2019/2/15/18225646/amazon-nyc-hq2-collapse-secrecy-incentives-automation https://www.theverge.com/interface/2019/2/15/18225646/amazon...
- save_ferris 7y agoIirc, this was orchestrated by the progressive wing of the NY Democratic Party and was a fairly controversial decision. The progressives still represent a fairly small contingent of the left, and don’t really have the influence to materially alter policy decisions, especially at the federal level. Much of the US still isn’t very interested in progressive politics, especially given the migration of moderate conservatives to the Democratic Party. 2020 is going to be a make-or-break election for progressives IMO.
- agumonkey 7y ago"jobs" .. when amazon warehouses will be all robots, they won't have this leverage. What a good news.
- zxcvbn4038 7y agoI for one really enjoy Amazon’s dominion. If your old enough to remember the Bell System before it was broken up, the airlines before they were deregulated, Amtrak before they lost government funding, or the postal service before they had to sell out to all the direct mailers to turn a profit — I’d say every once in a while the economists and political scientists can step back and take a break. Seriously. Fly Emirates, ride Eurorail, switch to T-Mobile, burn your mailbox - I think that is about as close as you can get these days. Since the US stopped subsidizing the dairy industry, the snap crackle pop of my cocoa crispies cost as much as a real breakfast. Two industries I’d love to see Amazon disrupt next are healthcare and car rentals. They are both overrun with vested interests and old fogies that have forgotten what a customer is. Amazon could be the first company to have an significant and quantifiable interest in their customers not dying AND do something about it. What customer would be more loyal then the one whose life you literally saved? I’m also pretty sure the entire IRS could be an Alexa skill and I wouldn’t shed a tear if it were. How is democracy working out for us these days? I kinda think it’s been swirling since about 1963, give or take, maybe Jeff Bezos should be King? Sure some people won’t be happy but no matter what you do some people never will be.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- proxygeek 7y agoHonest question: With so many alternatives to Amazon (direct brand retail, Walmart, Target, regional competitors) probably offering lesser fake products and still failing, doesn't it mean that the overall consumer base is not as concerned about the fake product issue? It could be because: 1) Fake product issue is not as widespread (per user, seller or per transaction) 2) Fake product cases are usually resolved in a satisfactory enough way to dissuade the consumer/seller from seeking alternatives 3) The annoyance of getting a fake product is outweighed by other conveniences offered If any of the above is true, well, there is not a real problem for Amazon to address. Of course, the assumption is that there are theoretical alternatives to Amazon for getting stuff you need, minus the convenience perhaps, but with higher degree of trust in product quality.
- bitexploder 7y agoI suspect a lot of people just have no idea they received a fake item.
- ptah 7y agothis! 100 times this! In a totally unregulated market consumers have very little access to information to make a proper decision. some markets should not be free EDIT: alternative is to limit size of companies so there is proper competition
- davidgrenier 7y agoIf the consumer has no idea it received a fake product how is the proper decision not getting the cheaper conterfeit?
- yoz-y 7y agoYou just assume that the product is shit and never buy it again. But the user base is large. With the swath of fake reviews on the site you can’t judge by ratings either. To me, the real victims are the original product sellers.
- kerkeslager 7y agoYet another problem that hasn't been solved by letting companies run unregulated to do whatever is most profitable. What a surprise!
- roenxi 7y agoYour point stands regardless, but Amazon famously doesn't do what is most profitable. Their profits as a business (ignoring AWS) are woeful.
- kerkeslager 7y agoThat seems like a fairly short-sighted view. Much of Amazon's strategy seems to be giving up short term profit to establish a monopoly for much larger long-term profit. They aren't perfect, and have certainly made some unprofitable decisions over the years, but I think that their overall strategy is VERY profitable, even if it hasn't yet yielded all the profits it is going to.
- roenxi 7y agoBezos founded Amazon.com, Inc. in 1994. They have yet to produce an impressive profit margin (outside web services which isn't really relevant to this specific thread). How long sighted are we talking here? The raw numbers are impressive, but they clearly aren't in the game of profit maximisation as we knew it back in the 80s. That is why nobody is really managing to compete with them. I don't really see how they could maintain a monopoly and a margin at the same time. If they had actual profit margins then other companies would compete with them. The reason they look like a monopoly at the moment is because they have no margins. If they change that, competition will spring up like mushrooms. Amazon is basically a web services provider by profit. All the other stuff they do is a mysterious distraction. If you want a company making for-profit decisions, look at how Apple runs itself.
- kerkeslager 7y ago> How long sighted are we talking here? As long as it takes to get the monopoly. This can't be rushed. Their competition is from i.e. Walmart. These competitors are big and a single major event isn't going to take them down. It requires a series of major events for a company of that size to fall out of serious competition. But it does happen: look at Sears. It took almost three decades, starting with a pricing scandal in 1992 to declaring bankruptcy in 2018, with many mis-steps along the way, but they did eventually fall. > I don't really see how they could maintain a monopoly and a margin at the same time. If they had actual profit margins then other companies would compete with them. By that logic, monopolies can't be profitable, but they clearly are profitable, so your logic must be faulty. Once a company reaches a certain scale, it becomes very difficult to start a competing company for a bunch of reasons: 1. First to market advantage: name recognition. Amazon is a household name. A new company isn't. A new company could overcome this with marketing, but marketing costs money, and then they have to pass that cost on to consumers, and Amazon will win on price. 2. First to market advantage: pre-existing infrastructure. Amazon has warehouses everywhere, so they can deliver to most places quickly. In places like NYC or SF they can deliver something from a few miles away, so they can deliver it on the same day. They have already spent this money, so they can provide this speed at a lower cost. A new company could overcome this by building out their own infrastructure, but this costs money which they have to pass on to consumers, and again Amazon wins on price. 3. Efficiencies of scale: Amazon is already huge. If it costs them $10 to write a line of code or lay a brick, that cost is amortized across millions of purchases that occur each day. A new company has to write the same line of code and lay the same brick to provide the same feature or distribution center, but that cost is amortized across only a few hundred purchases a day when they're new. There are more reasons, but basically, Amazon is well past the point where new companies could pop up and reasonably compete with them based on profit margins alone. They still have competition, but it's from the likes of Walmart--other giant companies that already have some of the same advantages Amazon does. It would be possible for a newcomer to compete, but it would require an extraordinary innovation which is highly unlikely. > The reason they look like a monopoly at the moment is because they have no margins. If they change that, competition will spring up like mushrooms. They don't look like a monopoly because they aren't yet. They have major competition with, for example, Walmart.
- mysterypie 7y agoIt sounds like there are a million deceived customers and cheated small businesses, but no individual customer or small business can take on Amazon. How about a kickstarter or other crowdfunding plan to raise money from everyone who's suffered due to Amazon's apparent tolerance of counterfeits? I.e., if you received a counterfeit product, or if your product or book was counterfeited and sold on Amazon (like the Antimicrobial Therapy handbook)? The kickstarter plan would be to either sue Amazon as class, or sue based on the best individual cases in all available jurisdictions, or failing all of that, to lobby the government to bring Amazon under control. Assuming it got enough funding, is there any chance that the lawsuits or lobbying would work?
- ilikepi 7y agoWell, I think lawyers in class action suits typically work on contingency, so there wouldn't be any up-front cost to suing, and they would just take a big chunk of the settlement or judgement instead as a fee. However, as is the trend nowadays, Amazon's Conditions of Use[1] include an arbitration clause, so that will probably make it rather difficult to bring a suit anyway. EDIT: clarification [1]: https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=201909000 https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=...
- swift532 7y agoIt's such bullshit that they can do that, especially as they're so dominant.
- justinclift 7y ago> This is not really negligence on Amazon’s part. It is the company’s business model. Still sounds like negligence. Obviously non-trivial to fix too. Still, it's Amazons responsibility to do so.
- oblio 7y agoKnowing that someone is breaking the law (with your support, even!) is not negligence. Amazing mental gymnastics over there :-)
- justinclift 7y agoWell, it's either negligence, or active assistance. ;)
- oblio 7y agoIt can also be passive: they're making money from it, the threat of lawsuits to counterbalance the money they're making seems to be low right now, so they just turn a blind eye to it. I refuse to believe that a company with these values: https://www.amazon.jobs/en-gb/principles https://www.amazon.jobs/en-gb/principles, a pretty thorough recruitment process, probably 100k engineers (including many, many data engineers) on their payroll, etc. can't do better about identifying fakes. It's just not in their interest because $$$.
- justinclift 7y ago> It's just not in their interest because $$$. Meh, I'd call that negligence. They're knowingly allowing harm to come to others, through putting in a token effort (CYA style) rather than instituting meaningful change. And it's their marketplace, so they get to set the rules, and they have significant resources if they actually wanted to engage.
- saadalem 7y agoAlso Amazon is increasingly painful to use. It's a good time to start the new product search engine.
- agumonkey 7y agostop the web, stop ~modern stuff, localize for important matter, let ecommerce implode
- Tepix 7y agoI agree. There are some really great product search engines available in Germany (geizhals.de and idealo.de) that allow you to search many many articles by custom criteria (depending on their category) and then do a price comparison. Amazon lacks basic search filters. And it has a lot of other annoyances. For example when I search for shoes in my size, Amazon won't display the price of the shoes in my size until I click on the shoes. Instead of shows the price range for all sizes in the list of shoes. Makes it a huge hassle to browse through a lot of shoes.
- aaron_oxenrider 7y agoExactly. Anything with options on Amazon is a terrible user experience now. One hack I found is the mobile app will give you the price along with the option. Why the desktop site is now worse than mobile I don't know.
- bfdm 7y agoHonestly I don't understand why this is so hard to solve, unless amazon is willfully ignoring it. If the item is shipped by a third party directly, tracing the counterfeit origin is easy. It's the comingling at the Amazon fulfillment centers that muddies the water. However, why not just tag each individual item with the supplying vendor as it arrives? You must of course credit them with stock, so just assign a code for that unit or box or pallet connected to that seller. They can still cross-fulfill (though I don't think they should) and record the origin code with each order as it's packed. Don't tell me this is too complicated for Amazon. It's an extra code like a second SKU per item, not conceptually challenging. Of course there are process issues to solve, but this should be a huge internal priority for Amazon. I see it as a weak spot that leaves room for a competitor to do better. Of course identifying fakes is still a challenge, manufacturers have long had systems for verifying authentic units. If a $20 webcam has a unique serial number I don't see why we couldn't have one for an $80 board game.
- adinobro 7y agoThey should copy China to solve the problem. The standard policy in China is x3 refund if the product is fake. The all online sellers have this policy but it makes it a lot easier to tell if something is likely to be fake. Also if you get a fake then you get a triple refund...
- secabeen 7y agoThey do already offer this, but it's not free, and you have to re-label each item with your barcode, and cover up any UPC codes, if possible. The base problem is that UPC. Amazon wants to use it to identify everything, as it's already there, and easy to use. However, it's also easy to counterfeit along with the item. It would also be a significant technical challenge, as it would increase the size of Amazon's item database by at least an order of magnitude, and would increase the amount of unique bins they need to maintain in the warehouse by a lot too. They clearly need to do something, but understand why they don't want to go down the road of tagging per-vendor if they can avoid it. On more expensive items, they seem to be trying the alternative of allowing vendors that control their supply chains to also exercise control of the amazon supply chain. It's starting to hit for more prominent vendors. I can no longer sell used Canon lenses on Amazon anymore. To do so, I need approval, which consists of "At least 1 purchase invoice for products from a manufacturer or distributor, 1 letter from Canon authorizing you to sell their products". (Note, this is for selling used gear, not new, or like-new. Just normal, used camera lenses that I bought and no longer need.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Uptrenda 7y agoUnfortunately, I only see a way to solve this for fungible goods where you would still need to get every actor involved in the supply chain to upgrade to the same secure tracking solution. It could be done in theory with crypto and tamper-proof packaging, but overcoming the network effect of today's archaic supply chains would be a huge undertaking. The article points out how sellers are creating unique, non-fungible goods. So how does a customer even initially know that they're discovering 'the original' and not something that has been re-branded? With a Lamborghini, re-naming the car to another brand isn't a problem since the customer won't find it (and a supply chain integrity solution might work.) But how would you solve the Amazon problem? I suppose you could have a time-locked escrow account where sale funds had to be locked there for N days. That way there would be time to challenge counterfeit sales and re-distribute the funds to the original authors (and / or make customers whole) when fraud was detected. But I am pretty sure people would hate that. Everyone would have to agree to use it for it to work and it wouldn't stop the potential for brand damage from low-quality counterfeits. If it were a short enough time-lock though, it might work? High enough that it removes the incentive for fraud, low enough that it doesn't frustrate vendors.
- airnomad 7y agoIdk how closely you guys are watching but industry around Amazon affiliates is huge and getting bigger. Amazon is basically outsourcing discovery to third party which means their AI can't keep up. I believe Amazon could be disrupted by niche player who do discovery and quality right.
- _pmf_ 7y agoFrom a product quality point of view, they have long peaked. From a customer service point of view, I've yet to see something better in the consumer space.
- bubblewrap 7y agoSo counterfeits are an invention of Amazon? Amazon's business model is counterfeits, and they have no interest of curbing the practice? What a bullshit article, in the usual fashion: collecting a bunch of anecdotes, to convince readers "emotionally" that Amazon is the devil. The reality is probably that at the scale of Amazon, some issues are bound to happen. "Journalists" looking for "evidence" can always find some anecdotes to relay. Counterfeiting is big business in China and other places. It's presumably a difficult problem. It would exist with or without Amazon. Article does not give any indication that it would be easier for Amazon to fight it.
- tomohawk 7y agoThis is why the FTC should be taking a close, hard look at these guys. The FTC has many tools it can use. They could force Amazon to institute fraud control that actually passes a blush test, or face massive penalties for not complying. Having a monopoly is bad enough. Having an unaccountable, unregulated monopoly is intolerable.
- blunte 7y agoIf you have a brick and mortar store and you repeatedly sell counterfeit goods, you'll be repeatedly raided and probably shut down by some authority. It's strange (ok, not really, and not surprising) that one of the biggest, richest, smartest companies is given a pass on following the same rules that little people have to follow. Amazon has no legitimate excuse, period. And if Bezos is the high performing micromanager that we've read about, then it's a certainty that he knows that they are flagrantly selling (or facilitating the sale of) counterfeit goods. Let's put this a different way: If some of the products on Amazon were known to be hollow shells filled with drugs, you can bet that Amazon would suddenly become capable of identifying and preventing the sale of illegal products.
- wool_gather 7y ago> drugs, you can bet that Amazon would suddenly become capable of identifying and preventing the sale of illegal products. Although they probably still wouldn't face any legal liability, going back to your parenthetical comment "not surprising".
- ptah 7y agosounds like there is a niche for a store with proper quality control
- amelius 7y agoReminds me of this post by Richard Stallman: https://stallman.org/amazon.html https://stallman.org/amazon.html And it looks like the list needs to be extended.
- jumpinalake 7y agoCouldn’t read the article because NYTimes blocks my incognito browser mode. Times are changing.
- gopher2 7y agoYeah, don't buy it on Amazon if you don't literally want to purchase the knock-off version.
- Finnucane 7y agoLaissez-faire attitude toward counterfeiting + prescription drugs = what could possibly go wrong?
- nelzya 7y agoCounterfeiting killed reliable brands. Try to find a good charger or surge protector: on amazon they all are fake and nobody else is selling them - it's impossible to compete with amazon's fakes.
- __MatrixMan__ 7y agoPlot twist: the publisher is selling the counterfeits too. Why sell one good book when you can sell one bad one through Amazon and _then_ one good one directly from your site? Ok, probably not, but if we're talking about the dystopian end state of a system where the middlemen have gotten out of control then maybe we should look out for things like that. In _Anathem_ (a sci-fi novel) Stephenson describes a future where for every authentic version of a document on the net there are millions of fake ones--bogons, they call them. The history of how the bogons (and the defence system that successfully ignores them most of the time) is somewhat left to the imagination, but I imagined it like this: - Content creators set up special channels where they can get paid for access to the content. - Parasites infiltrate the channels and resell access the content, undercutting the Creators. - The Creators ban the Parasites from the channels, so they can't make copies of the content. - The Parasites re-infiltrate without much delay. - The Creators stop banning the Parasites, and instead--after identifying them--serve them slightly degraded content, so rather than having to compete with themselves, the Creators now compete with a slightly shittier version of themselves. They hope the Parasites don't notice the content degradation. - The Parasites notice the degradation and get new identities, and continue reselling the original content. - There arms race between these parties produces better and better fakes, to the point where there's so much fake news (or whatever content) that the only way to verify its authenticity is to re-do the journalism yourself to see what you find. In my version, the Creators win by establishing an economy of trust (part PGP, part cryptocurrency) where being a parasite is less profitable than either making good content or helping distribute good content (in a way that benefits the creator and gives the consumer reason to believe that they're not being lied to). I'm not sure if I think this will actually happen, but if it does then we'll have to go through the pre-web-of-trust darkness (where the light of truth is occluded by bogons) before things are reliably authentic again.
- NikkiA 7y agoThe solution is pretty simple: stop buying stuff from amazon 'because of the convenience'.