7 ms·
Beijing's US Treasury holdings dip
- SubiculumCode 7y agoMaybe I am just ignorant, but I do not see the appeal of gold. "Gold. How archaic." is what I immediately think. So many other commodities will hold value, even in the worst of times, being either useful or desired, and have long shelf lives.
- bluntfang 7y agoReal question...what is useful about gold today that makes it valuable, other than it's scarcity?
- ChuckMcM 7y agoIt is actually an industrial metal.
- Marcus316 7y agoAll sorts of electronics have gold in them. Minute traces, to be sure ... but it is a use ...
- TotempaaltJ 7y agoIts scarcity is the primary reason it holds value, from what I understand. But: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold#Other_applications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold#Other_applications Electronics mostly, it seems.
- throwayEngineer 7y agoIt's scare. Yes. It's a rock trading card that people have been trading for thousands of years. The industrial uses exist, but it's a vehicle of Economic exchange. This is why I find Bitcoin useful. It's nuclear chemistry proof.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoLet us say that there was a nuclear war, and everyone left is near starvation, lacks resources and security. What holds value? Gold? I'd say useful or desired commodities: Food, fuel, guns, working machines, liquor, tobacco. Perhaps gold will be settled on as the most fungible (and transportable) material for trade, but if I were preparing for such times, I would be betting on the commodity, not an inert bit of metal.
- Nasrudith 7y agoOf course those commodities are pretty terrible currencies in non-destabilized to a dark age times.
- EpicEng 7y ago>This is why I find Bitcoin useful. It's nuclear chemistry proof. But not people proof, as it's wild fluctuations will attest to.
- mrob 7y agoIf we have energy cheap enough to make nuclear transmutation a practical source of gold then the economy is already unrecognizable.
- germs12 7y agoCompletely agree.
- sunseb 7y agoGold is a symbol. Gold is the color of the sun. Gold is a pure metal (which doesn't rust). It's like the metal of the gods.
- ericd 7y agoIt’s the incredibly long and consistent history of being considered valuable. It cannot easily be devalued by any government, unlike any fiat currency. It’s extremely portable, even for relatively large values of it. And faith in all those things is what gives it value.
- Agathos 7y agohttps://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/02/07/131363098/the-tuesday-podcast-why-gold https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2011/02/07/131363098/the-...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIts scarcity. The US Federal Reserve can create dollars at their discretion, but they can't change the chemical composition of the earth's crust. You can think of gold as insurance against fiat currencies being debased by their issuing governments. You can also be pretty sure that it will be valuable anywhere you go.
- crazynick4 7y agoGold has been the longest most stable 'currency' historically. Governments with some of the largest economies hold large supplies of gold (and they're not trading it for BTC). It's value has been on par with inflation since we've started keeping track of its value. This creates confidence among buyers. People agree it has value because the most powerful players in the global economy agree that it has value. There is also a limited amount of it.
- londons_explore 7y ago> There is also a limited amount of it. Do people trade gold 'still in the mountain'? I could start a market for gold still underground, effectively saying "you have purchased 1kg of gold, but to redeem, you have to pay $500 of mining costs". Since there is a near unlimited supply of gold in the entire earth's crust, that could work to make a price ceiling on actual gold, which in turn would severely reduce its use as a reserve currency.
- crazynick4 7y agoI see your point but it's not like we ever just mine a ton of gold and flood the market. New gold gets mined but it's not done at a rate that influences that market price. Theoretically yes, there is an unlimited amount, but in practice most of that gold will never be found.
- Reedx 7y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. It's a valid thought. And Warren Buffet agrees gold is not a good choice because it's not a productive asset. A bar of gold in your safe won't produce anything. After 50 years it's still just a bar of gold. Compare that to what the market does over 50 years. It's better to buy farmland or part of a company or a property that you rent out. Productive assets.
- sangnoir 7y agoWhich market, and which 50 years? Looking at a global inflation map, one would have fared better with gold in a surprisingly large number of countries. I will concede that the US has had a great past 50 years - but I do not believe in infinite growth from finite resources, on the other hand I'm not going to hazard a guess as to when the growth will slow down. > After 50 years it's still just a bar of gold. Not rusting or otherwise degrading is a great thing. Gold is not just pretty to look at, it has great electrical properties that make it useful to industry
- smaili 7y ago> Some of this capital is going into gold. China's gold reserves have grown for six straight months since December, the first time the country increased its holdings of the precious metal in more than two years. Russia has made similar moves, slashing its dollar-denominated assets while purchasing gold as essentially a borderless currency. I know it's crazy but I have to ask - with countries seeking more neutral currencies, could it be fathomable that adoption of digital currencies would grow as well?
- thinkingkong 7y agoDigital currencies seem to have separate barriers. There also arent any countries providing bonds in crypto so the mechanisms employed by countries to manipulate currencies wont take effect.
- Topgamer7 7y agoGovernments wouldn't do it themselves. The average person still sees crypto as risky and volatile (if they are familiar with crypto at all)
- stcredzero 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Currency_Act_of_2018 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Currency_Act_of_2018
- allemagne 7y agoThe intention is for China to reliably store capital, but digital currencies have not only been extremely volatile but also have hackable private keys.
- melan13 7y agoSwiss Franc is the primary alternative. I don't see digital currencies going farther away than being used in the dark market/crypto-trading.
- dageshi 7y ago
- yeldarb 7y agoThis doesn't seem particularly newsworthy. It's such a tiny blip that it's immaterial. The RMB & USD have traded in a very tight range throughout 2019.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoReally it is about the trend. China couldn't just dump their treasuries (as explained in the article) as they would lose a lot of value that way. So dribbling them out and exchanging them for gold maximizes the value returned. At $20B/month that is a pretty steady pace of a quarter trillion a year. EDIT: A quarter trillion not billion dollars, thanks.
- nvusuvu 7y agoI think you might have meant a quarter trillion.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoSo true, just 3 decimal orders of magnitude :-). And it would eliminate their holdings in 5 years if they were to stick to it.
- duderific 7y agoI think you meant a quarter trillion? A trillion here, a trillion there, pretty soon you're talking about real money!
- dageshi 7y agoSo far as I know, the rmb/usd rate is still pegged within a range by the chinese government?
- w23j 7y agoSelling large amounts of dollars to buy gold should devalue the dollar against other currencies, right? Isn't that what Trump wants to happen anyway? (Looking at his attacks against the fed [1], for not dropping rates or attacking the ecb for planning to do so and thus devaluing the euro: Mario Draghi just announced more stimulus could come, which immediately dropped the Euro against the Dollar, making it unfairly easier for them to compete against the USA. They have been getting away with this for years, along with China and others. [2] [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-06-18/white-house-explored-legality-of-demoting-fed-chairman-powell?srnd=premium https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-06-18/white-hou... [2] https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1140935620291964928 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/11409356202919649...) Why is this a good move in the trade war then? What am I missing?
- NTDF9 7y ago> Why is this a good move in the trade war then? What am I missing? Because then America is poorer in the world and is not the biggest customer any more. Thus it cannot bully the rest of the world. Something having cake, something eating it too will not work.
- w23j 7y ago> is not the biggest customer any more. Thus it cannot bully the rest of the world. That is exactly what Trump wants. Reduce trade deficits, more manufacturing in the USA instead of importing from China. Since that seems to follow I am trying to understand the move.
- astazangasta 7y agoThis was my first thought, but I'm not sure this is true. Buying debt from the US government increases the numbers of dollars in circulation (since bonds are redeemed in dollars) and shores up its price. Selling this debt to someone else (i.e., not back to the US government) doesn't destroy those dollars, it just changes its owner. It's not clear this would result in devaluation.
- 7y ago
- hsnewman 7y agoChina owns a considerable amount of American debt. If they sell it off, the result could be a major drop in the US dollar. Combining this with tariffs we could see Russia in the 1980s style shortages (ie: nothing on the shelves). Countries which have been blockaded (ie: Cuba, Iran, Venezuela, etc) always have their economy drop. Doing it to ourselves is, in my opinion, self injurious.
- nradov 7y agoWho exactly would China sell that debt to, and for what? How would that impact the US dollar? They certainly aren't going to cut off exports to the US.
- jfengel 7y agoThey can "sell" a lot of it back to the US government. The debt is held in bonds that mature. Big bondholders regularly roll their bonds over, so it acts as if they're just holding the same debt indefinitely. But some fraction of their bonds mature every month, and if they don't buy new ones, the government has to give them their money. It doesn't directly impact the dollar, per se, but it does mean that the government has to find the money elsewhere to continue operations. If it has to look harder, it will have to spend more, and that ultimately has to be backed by the taxpayer.
- nradov 7y agoThat's really not how US bond sales work in practice. The Chinese government is a relatively small player. And you didn't account for FOMC operations.
- neckeri 7y agoThey could sell it back onto the open market and convert it to USD. Alternatively they could wait for it to mature and get USD. The key thing here isn't about the reserves, its how they they acquired them by creating a swap on USDCNY from Chinese exports from their reserves - effectively holding the Yuan from appreciation. The other thing is for the trade deficit to decrease the reserves need to decrease too. The reserves, especially the way they were created using swaps give a proxy of USD held savings held but not yet poured back into the US (and hence creating a trade deficit). This is all of course useless if the holder of those bonds is still China, but through another country such as Belgium with an overseas account - which they've done before.
- conjecTech 7y agoThis is a misrepresentation which is trying to paint a relatively weak position as a stronger one. A small fraction of that money is being spent on gold. According the financial times[1], China only bought 15.6 tonnes - about $675 million worth[2], compared to the dollar deficit of ~$7.5 billion. China has a trade surplus with the US, but is net losing dollars because it has to use dollars to buy oil and other imported goods as very little international trade is transacted in yuan. They aren't choosing to shift away from the US dollar. They need them and are going through their stockpile. [1]https://www.ft.com/content/ca50aa10-8b18-11e9-a1c1-51bf8f989972 https://www.ft.com/content/ca50aa10-8b18-11e9-a1c1-51bf8f989... [2]https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=value+of+15.6+tonnes+of+gold https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=value+of+15.6+tonnes+o...
- 0n34n7 7y agoYour argument assumes China could find more than ~$675M of physical gold on the market in April.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- conjecTech 7y agoThe trend is even weaker for the previous 6 months. The financial times article also mentions those numbers.
- wtvanhest 7y agoWould you mind expanding on your point? I understand that there is limited trade in gold, but why does the fact that they are running up against a limit in buying gold matter to the argument?
- docker_up 7y agoThere's a common belief among conspiracists/Zerohedge believers that the amount of physical gold is basically fraudulent, and that the gold that is being traded doesn't exist. So when the coming financial crisis happens and gold becomes the currency of trade, when people actually open up their coffers, they'll see that it either doesn't exist or it's gold bars filled with tungsten.
- bensonn 7y agoFrom "Currency Wars: The Making of the Next Global Crisis", which I read too many years ago to clearly remember, this was a economic war strategy. During economic war-games the Pentagon set up this strategy was successfully employed. China, Russia- the "anti-west" powers started buying gold, dumping US debt and finally proposed creating their own currency for regional trade instead of using the USD as their reserve currency. This is a summary based on a book I can't really remember and concepts I might not have understood. That said, I do remember it was a good book, worth a read.
- 0815test 7y agoThis is not much of an "economic war" strategy, TBH - it's just a very visible signal of the "hey, we hate the U.S." sort. The "reserve currency" one uses as part of world trade is immaterial, except for convenience; the U.S. are not perceptibly better or worse off as a result of such choices. Tariffs and trade barriers though? Now, there's some "economic war" if I've ever seen it! "When goods won't cross borders... armies will."
- aaronblohowiak 7y ago>the U.S. are not perceptibly better or worse off as a result of such choices. How is that true? We can print more dollars. We don't have the same kind of control over other currencies.
- 0815test 7y ago"You can print more dollars" only as long as market participants trust that you're not going to print too many dollars - as soon as you try to do anything of the sort, your status as "safety deposit box of the world" goes away. That's not much of a privilege!
- jddj 7y agoIn most of the analyses I've read, the petrodollar has been of huge benefit to the US - effectively propping it up in the face of massive QE efforts and (in theory) allowing much more to be printed to service debts than would otherwise be sustainable. I mean, there must be some reason that trading or threatening to trade oil in Euros is practically asking for some kind of forced regime change.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chocolatefor3 7y agoAnother discussion on current state of China (was on the homepage, but got flagged right away) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20215382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20215382
- xmly 7y agoThis is really weird. You buy something and sell something. This is entirely up to customers. Why make it so big deal? It is the customers' freedom to do so. So respect the customers' choice, respect other countries' choice. They want to sell, let them sell.
- BubRoss 7y agoThis is a report of publicly released numbers, it isn't a judgement. No one is trying to stop anyone.
- dnprock 7y agoChina is in a delicate position. They're fighting trade war from weaker position. Their diversification to gold makes sense. They probably know that they don't have the power to "sink" the dollar. If they need the dollar in the future, they can still sell their gold and purchase US treasury again. I think they are testing out strategies. Gold is an alternative. The US and its European allies still control most of the gold reserve. Western countries have an upper hand if currency war moves to gold. Some Asian countries are voicing support for gold backed currency. But they together don't have substantial gold reserve. I think China is waiting for a break of European countries to gold. That would be a real opening for them in this battle. There's also bitcoin. China doesn't like it because the system is decentralized and supply is limited. They can't easily take control of the market. But the US also face similar issues. That would make an unpredictable battle field. For now, it seems China is treading slowly with gold.
- dageshi 7y agoThe only thing that really matters is the relative percentages of what currency is used in international trade. If you need to buy stuff from outside your country and they want to be paid in USD then you need USD to pay them. The RMB isn't really that useful outside of China, I don't honestly see gold being the substitute because there just isn't enough of it, any gold backed currency would end up deflationary and people would hoarde it for the sake of hoarding it.
- dnprock 7y agoGold backed currency doesn't have to be 1-1 with gold. You can use fractional reserve to issue more currencies. Or you issue bond to borrow. Given you keep your promise to pay debt and allow people to redeem currency using gold. People will trust you as long as you keep your promise and have enough gold reserve. I personally think having the ability to hoard gold is good. I can decide that for myself. It's easier to understand than the voodoo economics of money printing. It's the fallback to keep accountability.
- dageshi 7y ago
- mywittyname 7y agoThe US President is looking to the Federal Reserve to interest lower rates. By reducing their T-Bond holdings and curbing future purchases, China is increasing the volume of T-Bonds the Federal Reserve must purchase in order to achieve the US President's wishes of lower interest rates. It seems like a good move, seeing as the President's base has a negative opinion of national debt and government interference.
- HansLandaa 7y agoMassive selling pressure would push bond yields up. Fixed income security prices and yields have an inverse relationship
- mywittyname 7y agoRight, which means that the Fed will have to buy even more to push rates down.