15 ms·
There are now more people over sixty-four than children younger than five
- grandinj 7y agoThe obvious question is - has the data been adjusted for the fact that people now live longer, otherwise the conclusion is not very useful.
- point78 7y agoGood? We need less population, not more...
- cheez 7y agoWhy do you think so?
- Conjoiner 7y agoThat's africa, not the west.
- draugadrotten 7y agoThere will be several hundred million migrating from Africa to the west. https://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2016/jan/11/population-growth-in-africa-grasping-the-scale-of-the-challenge https://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals...
- toomuchtodo 7y agoOnly if western policy supports it.
- pessimizer 7y agoA westerner is 10x worse for the environment than an African.
- hsnewman 7y agoBut the chart is forecasting 11+ billion!
- Gwypaas 7y agoBecause the shape of the population pyramid is changing. From a wider base when the fertility used to be high to about everyone surviving to their 80s. It's this momentum that will keep the total population increasing a couple of decades. Read Factfulness by Hans Roslin if you want to learn more about this phenomenon and similar questions about poverty in the world.
- nolok 7y agoMaybe but we also need an increase in quality of life, not a decrease. While a plateau (and even reduction) in number of people would not necessarily be a bad thing, it needs to be in a kind of controller fashion to avoid a broken age pyramid, ending up with too many elders incapabke of substaining their means by themselves, and too few working age people to support them, ending with both group living below the means we should strive for them to reach. The age pyramid in some european countries, in china, in japan, ... Is scary, and not because of the decline of population it represents, but because unless we also change and adapt society accordingly there simply won't be enough people to pay for those who can't work anymore, and the few that can pay end up paying more than their fair share. It's a huge issue, and nobody wants to change it much, making it feels like we will wait until the situation explodes before adapting.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 7y agoRight, it's a balance. A small decrease may not impact quality of life but a larger one would. Imagine Steve Jobs living in a world of population 1000. He'd be living like a homeless person foraging for berries in bushes in the forest, no matter how good his entrepreneurial skills may be. We need people to innovate, build, grow, trade with each other to achieve high quality of life.
- candiodari 7y agoBut that ship has sailed. Population changes are notorious in how extremely predictable they are. If we wanted a slow decline we needed to act 20 years ago. Right now the numbers look suspiciously quiet, hiding the fact that there are a number of countries growing ridiculously fast (sub-Saharan Africa), and a lot of countries (all of "the West", except the US) in accelerating decline. So there will be increasing immigration despite low (global) population growth. And this is over and done with. It's a fact at this point. Policy today can only determine if in 20 years we want to cause +0.2% in kids or -0.2% in kids. I mean anything short of a meteor strike or new spanish flu won't really influence anything sooner.
- Nasrudith 7y agoIf they are predictable then many people have done an extraordinarily bad job at projections. Because there are a lot of real howlers out there then if you look at proven wrong population projections of the past both from Malthusian demagogues and official sources trying to do extrapolations. Although it is true we can only "add" at 0 for new humans if you want workforce ready new humans immigration from elsewhere is required.
- afpx 7y agoHasn't a lot of GDP growth over the last century been caused by population growth? What happens when the GDP pyramid scheme pops?
- brobdingnagians 7y agoA lot of technology comes from population increase too. Necessity is the mother of invention, and more brains and resources means you can do more interesting things and things which increase the quality of life and production of everyone else. If you want technological advancement, innovation, and better life for everyone-- we need more people. And if you want space exploration and expansion, we need more people with more ideas and resources.
- RichardHeart 7y agoDo you think less people make progress faster? What's your target level of depriving life of existence? How do you plan to keep mankind robust from extinction events on a single planet? You might just need more people. What do you think our technology would look like if we had 10x less people for the last 100 years? More people make more progress faster. Aren’t you glad your parents didn't decide the world would be prettier or work better without you in it? If great minds like Einstein, Bell, Tesla, Da Vinci etc., were still alive and productive today, the world would be a better place. You're literally asking for others to die out of your fear. The burden should be higher. Have courage.
- icebraining 7y agoWe know it makes more sense to use materials from outside than having to drag them out of Earth's gravity well; I don't see why wouldn't that apply to humans as well. Let's have kids there when we get colonies going, it'll be a new and wonderful experience; there's no need to rush. > You're literally asking for others to die out of your fear. On the contrary, you're the one playing up fears like extinction events. People are not having kids because they don't want to, not because point78 asked them to.
- brobdingnagians 7y agoA lot of technology comes from population increase. Necessity is the mother of invention, and more brains and resources means you can do more interesting things and things which increase the quality of life and production of everyone else. If you want technological advancement, innovation, and better life for everyone-- we need more people. And if you want space exploration and expansion, we need more people with more ideas and resources.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoReminds me of this speculative post on SlateStarCodex: https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/04/22/1960-the-year-the-singularity-was-cancelled/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/04/22/1960-the-year-the-sing... Ultra-brief summary: it may be that technological progress is actually tied to population growth, not economic growth - and population growth is slowing down. So unless we can figure out a way to switch the driver of scientific and technological breakthroughs from population (more researchers) to economy (e.g. machines that would think for us), we're gonna stall the progress of science and technology too.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOr. Use the existing population more effectively? Educate everybody instead of just the rich few. Subsidize technology again. Understand that basic research is the foundation of later development. But we have to hope for a rational society for all that! I will be far easier I agree, to just grow population instead.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoUsing the existing population more effectively through structural changes would IMO very quickly hit diminishing returns. But it could be viable with various kinds of technologies designed to improve individual and organizational cognitive performance; hell, I think this is the very way from here to the "machines that think for us", so it's a part of the solution.
- 7y ago
- crispyporkbites 7y agoI don't know many people having or even considering children under the age of 30. The window to actually have them gets pretty tight, a mother aged 35 or older is considered a geriatric mother on the NHS (basically higher risk). I'm sure that a lot of my friends are going to find it difficult to have children as they get older, in contrast to parents in the 80s and 90s who were mostly having their first child in their 20s. From my anecdotal perspective it feels like we are going to see population growth flatlining and global population starting to decline over the next 100 years. It feels like the data is moving in that way to back that up. This could be a really tough problem to solve. How do we keep economic growth going if our main driver (human capital) is disappearing?
- ajeet_dhaliwal 7y agoI don't think it's just anecdotal, some data suggests this is happening. The book 'Empty Planet: The Shock of Global Population Decline' talks about this. The only place in the world with high total fertility rate is now subsaharan Africa, even countries you might think have a lot of children don't really anymore. China is well known to have a low TFR now, but even India appears to have reached replacement level, although something called population momentum will mean population continues to increase for a couple more decades, and then decline.
- yters 7y agoWe in the West are doing our best to make their populations decline too, through contraception, abortion and disrupting their traditional structures. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Study_Memorandum_200 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Study_Memora...
- aitchnyu 7y agoThe states with better human rights, medicine have gone below replacement while the others have not progressed. South India with ever-lower voter share is becoming irrelevant to national politics, in effect a punishment. https://scroll.in/article/865569/indian-population-is-growing-much-faster-in-the-north-and-the-south-is-paying-the-price https://scroll.in/article/865569/indian-population-is-growin...
- johnchristopher 7y agoSo, to put it simply, more and more people have to work to support more people than before, right ?
- RobertoG 7y agoOnly if productivity have not increased.
- johnchristopher 7y agoHas productivity increased enough to compensate for it ?
- liveoneggs 7y agotaxes to fund those not working would be required to absorb the productivity gains
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agoOnly if productivity have not increased. It has not, alas. Take cars as an example: if we were building Fort T models, then yes, they would cost peanuts (especially Chinese copies). But for every dollar of productivity increase we add two dollars of safety devices, emission controls and new shiny gadgets.
- gjm11 7y agoMaking safer and less-polluting cars is a productivity improvement: it means people are getting better cars -- and everyone else is getting less likelihood of getting killed in a car accident, less health damage from other people's exhaust fumes, etc.
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agoRight, but in the context of this discussion the cost primary function of the car (moving my butt from one place to another) has increased, or, in the best case, stayed the same.
- mattmanser 7y agoIsn't 64 a rather arbitrary number? 65 used to be retirement age (for men at least), it clearly needed raising years ago, but was hard to do politically in many countries. It is finally being raised. When pensions were first introduced they were meant to run 5 years, not 20. In the UK, at least, you could argue we're left paying for a generation of Baby Boomers who are swanning about on cruises, golf days and health spas on pensions they never paid even half towards. Most are perfectly able to work for another 10 years at least (and if you're younger than 50 you'll have to work those extra 10 years), but for some reason we need economic migrants for economic growth. Even though we're not building anywhere near enough homes, schools, hospitals and transport infrastructure for this mass immigration, and we're not training enough nurses, doctors, teachers. We are effectively just shunting all the economic problems of the end of continual growth 20 years down the line. We even scrapped bursaries for student nurses! Utter madness. And then, rather ironically, it's this same generation who overwhelmingly voted for Brexit to even further destroy their children's and their children's children prospects because they're not happy about the changing face of the Britain they're not even going to live in.
- MRD85 7y agoI'm Australian and my parents "retired" at 58. They're not quite on cruises and golf days but they're perfectly capable of work even now at 63 if they really wanted. They just don't want. Is it their fault or the governments?
- hydrox24 7y ago> if they really wanted. They just don't want The premise of working for cash is that no-one really wants to do it, which is why you need to give people money in exchange for the work. So if they don't want to work, and they are entirely self funded, good for them! It's their "fault" and I'm happy for them. But if they have enough cash flow only because of the current Australian franking credit setup (it no longer merely prevents double taxation, it's a subsidy for investors), tax breaks on Superannuation, and so on, then it's the Government's fault for incorrectly calibrating the benefits in such a way that tax payers end up paying people to be unproductive.
- Asooka 7y agoSounds about right. If people don't die young, the population pyramid becomes a rectangle, so there should be approximately the same number of people under 5 as above max age - 5, let's say 80.
- ironSkillet 7y agoThat's only true if birth rates also remain constant across time, which is not the case.
- sysbin 7y agoEntering late 20s and I’m basically hoping for a next life similar to my parents generation. This generation has so many requirements thrown upon us that made living a modern day prison and only unless born into an upper class family that would pay for what have become necessary requirements to succeed past the apartment life. Sure, some people are anomalies and had events making the contrary but it just hinders the truth of the majority who didn’t necessarily get worthless degrees but still struggle to pay of student loans in an crippling economy for people without much money. I’m not sure if this is all the product of student loans, not enough homes being built, the all sexes need to equally work, and or people controlling capitalism getting even more greedy. Something is making it where having a kid would make a financial disaster even worse.
- vortico 7y agoI need a table with booleans "There are now more people over X then children younger than Y."
- fouronnes3 7y agoShould be quite easy to even draw the Y=f(X) curve if you have the population histogram
- snarf21 7y agoHere is the data: https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/datasets/2010-2017/national/asrh/nc-est2017-alldata-r-file01.csv https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/datasets/201...
- jtuente 7y agoCouple of interesting items from this US census data (month 6): 1. There are more people over 74 than under 5; there are more people over 80 than under 3. 2. x = [12, 62], y = 74 - x It's a near linear relationship between those older and those younger for this age range, i.e. those older than 62 outnumber those under 12 and those older than 12 outnumber those under 62. Make note that the y-intercept equals the under 5 comparison age. 3. There's a large difference between the populations of those age 63 and 64, those born around 1946-47. The baby boom
- conmarap 7y agoI'm supposed no one has mentioned the - sort of - deterioration in our relationships. back in the day it used to be a lot easier for two people up meet, fall in love, get married and have kids. I'm not saying that there weren't any forced marriages, but that's not my point. In the age of tinder we are exposed to more and more people and possibilities. So basically it seems like the average Joe and Betty keep holding off for the perfect mate, when chances are they already rejected them. I'm just observing that the typical meets are decreasing rapidly and could be to, at least partially, blame.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- liveoneggs 7y agoget off tinder and get on to eharmony with a profile like "I'm interested in getting married" then see what happens
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoDo people actually do this?
- liveoneggs 7y agoof course they do. It's the entire point of that website as far as I can tell. a friend of mine did something similar and was married inside of two years.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- randomdata 7y agoMore to the point, there is a curious social stigma around having children before you enter your 30s that has developed. The idea that you should "play the field" is part of it, but I'm not sure that tells the whole story. There seems to have been a concerted effort to reduce pregnancies among younger women. In fact, programs like "16 and Pregnant" and "Teen Mom", which follow young mothers in their teens and 20s, were, according to their creator, meant as a "cautionary tale" to reduce pregnancy rates. In modern culture, "rural hick" even conjures up images of a young mother. Not the image most want to portray, which is a powerful social tool. Equally curious, once you enter your 30s all of a sudden the social norms flip to "why haven't you had children yet?", "the clock is ticking", etc. However, once you are in your 30s, there are some rather hard limits to how many children you can practically have.
- lbj 7y agoIs it surprising that items in range 64 - 120 is larger than 0 - 5?
- chucksmash 7y agoIt is at least notable if it wasn't previously.
- amalcon 7y agoYes. Total species populations grow exponentially, and all of the growth is at the lowest age bracket. The number of living members in each birth cohort also decreases exponentially as the cohort ages. It follows straightforwardly from this that population numbers by cohort will be on some log scale. We can naively estimate the relative size of these cohorts like this: >>> math.log(6) - math.log(1) 1.791759469228055 >>> math.log(121) - math.log(65) 0.6214032757011045 So we should expect a little under a 3x difference in favor of 0-5, which is in the rough ballpark of the 2.6x difference that the chart shows for 1950. Note that actual scientists work on this, and use much better methods than this (with confidence intervals and all that jazz). However, this method is a decent "try it at home" approximation, and still much better than comparing the number of years in the age cohorts.
- lbj 7y agoFair enough - Thanks for clarifying :)
- Tepix 7y agoInteresting. One piece of information is missing: When are we expected to stop getting older on average?
- iontop 7y agoThere is a great book that lays out the case that the boomer's decisions, policies, votes, actions, and inactions have destroyed our environment, our economy, and our future. The greatest generation handed the boomers a world with a bright future; the boomers have squandered it. Instead of investing in critical infrastructure that would ensure a better future for their grandchildren, they have decided to shackle us with financial ruin. And then they blame millennials. The book is : A Generation of Sociopaths Thanks to the boomers, you will never be freer (as in liberty and privacy), you will never experience the same economic opportunities, and you and your grandkids will pay for their short sidedness long after they are dead.
- eudora 7y agoLove the concept for the site, and love the interactive charts
- whiddershins 7y agoPeople got confused and started thinking there was something virtuous about not having kids. Which, in my opinion, is one of the most anti-human sentiments that you could construct. In a weird way, one could make an abstract argument that choosing not to have kids has an element in common with murder. It’s reducing the amount of lived human life. Regardless, on a practical level we are seeing non-replacement birthrate in advanced countries ... and people are complaining about it ... while making parenting as unpleasant as we can possibly imagine ... This is also part of the same philosophy, but turned sideways. Instead of viewing children as a resource they are viewed as a huge obligation, and we seem to feel a little guilty about bringing them in to the world. It’s fascinating.
- StavrosK 7y ago> In a weird way, one could make an abstract argument that choosing not to have kids has an element in common with murder. It’s reducing the amount of lived human life. So is not spending every waking moment (and every sleeping moment, where possible) having as many kids as you can. I can see the slogans now: "Abstinence is murder", "Contraception is murder", "Save a life: fuck!".
- jobigoud 7y ago> People got confused and started thinking there was something virtuous about not having kids. It's simple resource management really. We have three alternatives: 1. Keep multiplying, keep our lifestyles and fuck the planet until it's unhabitable, 2. Keep multiplying but drastically reduce our impact on the planet by rationing ourselves, 3. decrease the multiplication rate so that at some point we can sustain our lifestyle while not fucking the planet up. I can't see how wanting all humans to live decently is anti-human. Until we have good enough confidence that future humans will live decently, spawning new ones is risky, and spawning so many that our numbers keep increasing is just reckless. Are you familiar with "The Repugnant Conclusion"? https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/repugnant-conclusion/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/repugnant-conclusion/
- qwsxyh 7y ago> People got confused and started thinking there was something virtuous about not having kids. Bringing people into a world that's going to be destroyed fairly within their lifetime because we can't get over the profit motive to save the climate is completely immoral.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ramblerman 7y agoIt would be terrifying for population projections if it were the other way around. This is good. The only argument I see as a downside is the reverse population pyramid. Which will be a problem but still a better problem to have.