10 ms·
Malaysia will return contaminated plastic waste to the countries that shipped it
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whenchamenia 7y agoIf by dumped, you mean sold, sure. They will also have to sell it on if they don't want it.
- kevin_b_er 7y agoThey are illegal imports. The country, standing for the people, does not want buyers/sellers to have trash be imported through cargo containers. Drugs "imported" don't have be sold on if Malaysia doesn't want them, either.
- bilbo0s 7y agoThe people who agreed to buy it did so illegally. It's just that now, Malaysia is implementing a more robust and wholistic police action to enforce their mandates in that regard. Sucks for us, but entirely within the rights of the government of Malaysia. If we have a problem with the scammers who took our money, then we're free to take that up in court with the scammers. But that has nothing to do with the government of Malaysia.
- dev_dull 7y agoI actually don’t think it sucks for us. We’re better equipped to recycle or properly dispose of the waste. It will definitely cost more but I think it’s something that most people are willing to accept. Even now I’m hesitant to put things like plastic bags and straws into the recycling rather than trash. Only by placing it in the trash can I be more sure it doesn’t end up floating near some reef.
- la_barba 7y agoThey were sold a mislabeled item. They're just returning it to the store.
- diveanon 7y agoActually the law recently changed and trash importation is now illegal in Malaysia. Some politicians are even going as far as calling the owners of these companies who are ignoring the law traitors.
- la_barba 7y agoI don't know if this law applies retroactively. But anyway, its a good step.
- apacheCamel 7y agoI have a lot of mixed feelings about this. I am happy that Malaysia is taking a stand and is refusing to be a dumping ground for trash. I am sad that all of this plastic is coming back to the US where I am honestly unsure on what they will do with it. I am mad that it has gotten this far and there doesn't seem to be an end in sight.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThey’ll just incinerate it, which is probably what they should have done in the first place. Companies in third world countries bidding unrealistically low for recycling contracts has made recycling seem more viable than it actually is.
- dev_dull 7y agoAnd it’s cheaper to dump it in the ocean than to dispose of it safely.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoCheaper to ship it to Malaysia and have them dump it in the ocean than convince a bunch of 1st world NIMBYs that a modern incinerator plant won't give their children a .000001% increased chance of cancer.
- dalore 7y agoLandfill is better then incinerating. Burning it releases toxic chemicals and is effectively dumping it in the air (vs dumping it in the ocean). Landfill (dumping in the ground) is the least worst of all the options. From what you may believe there is plenty of land available.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIncineration works well when modern technology is brought to bear. It also doesn't create later water/land pollution problems. In any cases, one solution might work better than the other depending on the context.
- wyxuan 7y agoThis was just following duterte's moves in sending trash back to their origin. More for show than anything
- Causality1 7y agoGood. Dumping American trash in Malaysia isn't any better than emptying your kitchen trash can on your bedroom floor.
- dev_dull 7y agoThey don’t dump it there. People from Malaysia are buying it.
- NullPrefix 7y agoThey weren't buying used diapers, they were buying recyclable plastic. You wanted a new TV in your living room? Let me throw some puke and used diapers instead.
- dev_dull 7y agoYou seem to be implying there's some kind of cheating happening in what is ultimately a business deal. I wouldn't buy a new TV with puke and diapers unless it was my business reselling the TV and disposing of the rest.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoIt sounds like there was cheating here- there's an acceptable failure rate- such as a chunk of wood, maybe a brick, etc., but to me it sounds a lot more like this somehow-unnamed Canadian company sent them something like 10% recyclable stuff and 90% trash instead of the 90% recyclables and 10% trash they (some entity in Malaysia) was expecting. It also seems like this either happened more than once, or happened once with an entire Panamax-class ship's haul.
- whatshisface 7y ago>You seem to be implying there's some kind of cheating happening in what is ultimately a business deal. In the article, it was revealed that the contracts were for recyclable materials not worthless toxic garbage, and Malaysia was actually being scammed. (That's why their president made such a big deal about it).
- princeb 7y agomalaysian recyclers, as far as i know, were fairly profitable despite paying a much lower rate compared to chinese recyclers. there are companies out there squeezing a fortune out of rubbish. the visual impact on the landscape is notable, although not much more can be said about the sime-darby fields of palm trees and container housing that dominate the rest of the rural countryside. while i feel bad for them, the reality of business in malaysia is that you are at the mercy of politicians and their policies. these change like the squalls at sea.
- linuxftw 7y agoIMO, this is effectively the same thing as buying conflict diamonds or conflict oil. Too much of our economy relies on serf or outright slave labor by doing business with despotic governments. Note: I'm not making comments about Malaysia specifically, I don't know anything about the place, and parent's comments might not apply to them, IDK.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThe president of the Philippines recently threw a tantrum, threatening to declare war on Canada if they didn't take back their garbage. I dug into it and found that the president is completely justified in being pissed off. A Canadian company shipped "recycling" which turned out to be undisputable trash. Diapers and such. What pisses me off is that I cannot find the name of this company anywhere. So Canada is taking all the blame for some company that shipped them trash and labeled it recycling.
- linuxftw 7y agoIf the agreement was Canada as a country ensures their recyclable exporters will only export things that conform to some standard, then the burden would be on Canada, yes. But, what kind of bizarre world do we live in where we ship our trash to overseas places to be 'recycled' ? It just doesn't make any sense. We are exporting our waste and pollution to developing nations, those people are probably facing much worse environmental conditions than those in the developed world. It's truly despicable.
- Waterluvian 7y agoYeah that's a good point. It's unusual that the articles keep mentioning "a Canadian company" but never names it. Maybe the agreement was at a national level. And yeah, it's absurd. I just moved somewhere in Ontario where every garbage bag I put at the curbside costs $2. It's absolutely amazing to stand out on garbage day and see just how little people have set out. The system works. The recycling is still "free" but I would love to see the same happen.
- 52-6F-62 7y agoIt really is amazing how much you can adapt. I live in a building in Toronto and we don't get charged (directly) for trash. But the building has an organics path on the garbage shoots. My partner and I started making the effort since then to separate our organics and recycling, etc. I think we've maybe put a bag or two of actual "garbage" out in the past year or more. Most things can be recycled—that we use at home anyway. I'm glad we have the compost shoot. That's the thing we put out the most. Some things that seem like major uphill battles are really just a little mindfulness and a modicum of effort—and they become mindless routine after a short while.
- hammock 7y agoMalaysia's real estate is too valuable for them to be storing plastic trash on it. The entire place is being aggressively deforested to make room for more palm plantations and that's way more important than whatever they get for taking in garbage.
- fabianhjr 7y agoChina stopped accepting trash last year.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI thought that was recycling? Maybe we should require them to take the trash back. After all, they are manufacturing it.
- rakoo 7y agoWhat right do we have to require them to do anything ? They're not manufacturing it because they want to, they're doing it because developed nations buy it. They closed the pipes because their internal production has reached their own recycling capacity. It's time we do the same.
- rootusrootus 7y agoThe US doesn't really have much of a recycling problem domestically, though. We handle it fine. Lots of times that just means landfilling it, but that's actually not that terrible a solution. The upside of throwing it back at the manufacturer is that they would be forced to consider the costs of disposal as part of their bidding for new contracts. Turns it into a market problem. But ... the vibe I get from a lot of folks in this thread is that it's more about pinning all the blame on the wealthiest nations and assuming that the poorer nations aren't able to resist being exploited. I don't agree with that.
- rakoo 7y ago
- docker_up 7y agoThis is a good thing. I had no idea we weren't recycling our plastic and just shipping it across the world, only to get dumped in a forest or into the ocean. We need to stop producing so much plastic. We need laws to standardize plastics so that only purely recyclable plastics exist and no more single-use plastics, or compostable containers. Anything else should be banned. I don't care if it runs some companies out of business because the costs are too high. I would rather those companies fail than keep piling up with all this sickening useless and ultimately poisonous garbage from single-use plastics. We should also make it illegal to ship our garbage outside of the country. That will force us to deal with our own problems.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoAlso it seems likely at this point that the danger has been wildly underestimated. The rallying cry against plastic used to be that "it takes hundreds of years to break down". But now we know that when it breaks down, it gets worse. Microplastics are suspected to be bioaccumulating, carrying poisons and bacteria, and possibly could get into cells like asbestos. And the only way to dispose of the stuff that won't eventually become microplastic is incineration - putting all that carbon into the atmosphere, along with other unpleasant combustion products.
- docker_up 7y agoYes, as usual those of us that told us the risk was low or non-existent were wrong again. How often do we have to be duped by so-called experts before we realize that the "experts" have actually no idea how to calculate risk, and that we can't rely on their "assurances"? It goes both ways, where scientists told us that salt and high fat diets were causing heart disease and now both of those have been walked back.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoThe experts were working with the facts as they were known at the time. Microplastic wasn't obvious. Most things, when they break down, aren't harmful. This isn't a problem of experts. This is a problem of hubristically creating a never seen before material and assuming it would have no impact.
- stunt 7y agoThis is really bad. Many are just dumping them into the ocean. As long as it is cheaper to export waste, we are not going to build a better recycling system or even better stop producing so much plastic. East Asian countries should stop taking plastic waste.
- taksintikk 7y agoCan the Scandinavia trash>energy plants handle “contaminants”?
- Thlom 7y agoThey claim there’s no pollution from our local plant at least, but we don’t burn plastic.
- objektif 7y agoDo we have a solution for taking care of such waste in a clean way? I saw a company that claims to convert it to fuel.
- Joakal 7y agoNot that I know of. But there's a simple policy solution. Producers must take back waste as a condition to sell. If they're brand new companies, then simply ask for a bond until they've been around a while. All this is risk free but single use waste cost is priced in for consumers. Countries that don't adopt this policy will have higher taxes to deal environment costs which is worse than prevention. Companies affected by this can bypass conditions by only using list of approved materials; recycable, biodegradable, etc.
- toss1 7y agoMy first thought is to wonder how this issue is related to this recent finding: 10 Rivers Contribute Most of the Plastic in the Oceans https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/stemming-the-plastic-tide-10-rivers-contribute-most-of-the-plastic-in-the-oceans/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/stemming-the-plas...
- marcusjt 7y agoAccording to https://youtu.be/SnB6iRDoJ90 https://youtu.be/SnB6iRDoJ90 (7:45 onwards) even before China started refusing recyclable waste only 9% of what went into blue bins in the USA was actually being recycled, the other 91% was being incinerated or landfilled. what the stats are now I don't know but they're almost certainly worse not better.
- Joakal 7y agoNot the country's fault but Chinese companies definitely should take back the waste. They produced it in the first place. If not, they should not be allowed to sell.
- zaroth 7y agoYesterday I was opening up yet another Amazon white bubble wrap envelope when I took a closer look at the recycling logo. “Please remove paper label before recycling.” Mind somewhat blown. How often do you think that actually happens? But also, really shows you how hard this stuff is to process. Of course peeling off the label is nearly impossible. I wish after tearing the perforation off, there was another flap in there waiting to be deployed to cleanly reuse the envelope (versus the tape monster which you end up with if you try to reuse it by folding it over on itself). And then another row of perforation. And another flap. All the way from 8.5x11 or so, down to 8.5x5. Some of the clothes mailers I get are designed like this, with an inner flap and adhesive strip designed for sending back what didn’t fit. Would that be worth it in the end at scale? I for one would definitely save the bubble envelopes if they were cleaner to reuse. But then that label would also have to peel off easier too (different type of adhesive).