6 ms·
I increasingly feel that this is what it must have been like with the rise of Nazi Germany - I have frequently asked myself "how come people still supported Ger
by gambiting 7y ago
I increasingly feel that this is what it must have been like with the rise of Nazi Germany - I have frequently asked myself "how come people still supported Germany as it was heading in that direction? Why didn't other countries oppose it harder?". Well, I think I know how now - because it's invisible from the outside. I'm not saying that China wants to attack its neighbours and take over the world - but fuck, there's estimated to be over a million people in "reeducation" camps in China. The survailance apparatus judges you if you are being a "good" citizen with harsh consequences for doing anything that the party doesn't approve of. Censorship is widespread. And yet, people don't seem to have hugely negative feelings towards China. Most people I know wouldn't even object to going there on holiday. I honestly feel that in 20-30 years we're going to look back and say "how did we not see this? Or how did we ignore this?".
- frozenport 7y agoI think everybody knows what's going on.
- sametmax 7y agoIt's not invisible. We know. But we don't feel a sufficient motivation to do something about it.
- EGreg 7y agoCan you share videos that prove all this stuff? The more people shown in the re education camps, the better. Seriously, please post 10-20 links to videos so we can share them! Reports are going to have people claiming one thing and others denying that thing. This is a really serious human rights concern involving MILLIONS of people. It has been going on starting with Falun Gong since 2000 or earlier, then Uyghurs, Tibetans etc. It’s the word of the Chinese government vs all those groups. So it’s pretty clear this stuff is happening, but only because so many disparate groups are claiming this. But there is nothing like VIDEO to make clear what exactly is happening. We need to have these videos in order to share them. Same as Tienemen Square videos.
- Moru 7y agoI guess it's not very safe to show up at a camp with a camera, looking like a journalist from outside China.
- hutzlibu 7y agoIn the age of cheap smartphones and the allways existence of desperate people who have nothing left to loose, I think its highly unlikely that videos of such camps could not get out. Not if it is on that scale. (just refering to the argument, I did not check whether the camps exists or videos) On the other hand, such camps would not look much different from prisons, so I doubt you can expect KZ style pictures. Edit: just wondering, is my argument really that bad, or am I dealing with patriotic bite reflexes?
- EGreg 7y agoI don’t care who does it. There are cellphones everywhere today. Millions of detainees, I am sure there are videos somewhere! I think that the following devices would be REALLY useful not just for human rights but proving what happened in an altercation: A tiny device that can record video or video, perhaps embedded in the clothing or body of a person. The stream is ENCRYPTED AND THEN transmitted to local towers or wifi or whatever, and finds its way to some servers. Maybe via a DHT routing. Anyway, these servers store the encrypted data and the keys are generated by Shamir Secret Sharing so 3 or more parties can come together and decrypt the video. In countries with rule of law, this could be used to figure out rapes on campus, by having such cameras in every dorm and bedroom. The keys would be obtained during a court case only. In human rights cases, the keys would be generated by human rights organizations. So this will eliminate “peeing toms” and “spying” by having warrants for decrypton of a video strean, and curation by trusted agencies what gets shown to the public.
- Hasknewbie 7y agoWhat a bizarre comment, these camps have been widely reported and nobody serious disputes their existence. But hey, here you go: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=chinese+internment+camps http://lmgtfy.com/?q=chinese+internment+camps
- fredsir 7y agoIndeed. We can’t openly talk shit about our trading partners, lest act against their will. It’s just not good business, ethics be damned.
- simonh 7y agoThat’s a really strange thing to say in the middle of a rapidly escalating, open trade war.
- the_duke 7y agoWe are quite far from a real trade war. Right now it's still more of a civilized sparring.
- natch 7y ago“rapidly escalating”
- lovedva 7y agoA real trade war would be devastating for China both economically and politically. Imagine this 300m workers having nothing to do all day but also no income to buy the rice to feed their families. The rest of the world could easily get by by moving production lines and factories to Vietnam and Indonesia and South America, etc, while paying a flat “tax” in increased prices across the board for cheap products.
- makomk 7y agoYou mean the trade war that you must oppose if you wish to be seen as a decent, intelligent person? The trade war that the entire mainstream media portrays as a delusional, racist folly? That trade war?
- soulofmischief 7y agoI'd go stand in front of a tank right now. Like what are we actually supposed to do? I have tons of motivation to do something about the largest totalitarian regime. Just tell me where to go and what to do. I woulnd't assume that quite a few people don't feel this way. The issue isn't lack of motivation. It's the lack of any sort of leverage over a giant totalitarian foreign government.
- Leary 7y agoNo need to stand in front of a tank. Go convince some Chinese people you know that what is happening in XinJiang is a bad idea.
- dtech 7y agoHow? Chinese folk don't hang around western internet sites, if they can even access them and read English. Going there and spreading that message seems like a bad idea.
- theseadroid 7y agoI can tell you there are plenty on HN, myself included. I mean if you wanna make a bigger impact you can learn Mandarin and maybe go to China to meet some more people. Actually there are plenty of Chinese in SFBA or Seattle already. Have you talked to some of them???
- soulofmischief 7y agoHave you learned Mandarin?? That seems like a large amount of time to devote to something, only to go to China and immediately get disappeared after contacting a plainclothes cop.
- theseadroid 7y agoFrom your previous comment, you dare to stand in front of a tank, yet you wont put in the effort to learn Mandarin. I dont know about others but that's pretty irony to me. What's more, you replied without read my comment (or misread?). I said I'm a Chinese in the first sentence. I would like to have conversations with people who are serious about the matter but even on HN where people are rational and logical in most other topics are not showing their best when it comes to topics about China. Anyway here's one guy who learned chinese: https://www.youtube.com/user/jaredfaa https://www.youtube.com/user/jaredfaa (he's a bigger influencer on bilibili coz youtube is unfortunately blocked in China) here's a guy went around the world and passed China without knowing Mandarin: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HjI1O11S8KY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HjI1O11S8KY (one of his several vidoes) Anyway, ignorance promotes fear. Understand the problem first before propose solutions.
- akvadrako 7y agoWell assuming you aren't Chinese, it's not our place to get involved in their internal issues. But that doesn't mean we have to deal with people we don't like. The USA at least is doing something which respects their sovereignty and reduces their power.
- IshKebab 7y agoTo be fair a million people is 0.07% of China's population. 0.7% of the US is in prison, so that would be about 1/10th of the prison population. I'm not saying US prisons are the same - you get a vaguely proper legal process, and conditions are probably better. You're not likely to have your organs havested. But "a million people" isn't the problem.
- humanrebar 7y agoA million people is enough to be concerned about. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- ppod 7y agoIt's not "whataboutism" to point out that this level of incarceration is not unusual. It is being portrayed as unusual in the article, when, in global-historical terms it is statistically perfectly normal. The small number of western democracies that do not practice violent state suppression of dissent and exploitation of the poor are the anomalies. The comparisons to Nazi Germany are also misleading. Nazi Germany was unusual in the degree to which it industrialized and systematized its racial slaughter, but the propaganda, state suppression, and state police brutality doesn't seem to me like an outlier among 20th century governments.
- humanrebar 7y agoIt's exactly whataboutism to say "What about U.S. incarceration?" when defending China. It's 100% analogous to what would come up in discussions of the USSR. "The USSR is bad for its people." "What about Jim Crow?" It's also worth noting that there is a bipartisan criminal justice reform movement in the U.S. that is critical of the U.S. government at various levels, so, no, it's not apples to apples.
- wizzairflyer 7y agoI think the parent meant that looking at raw numbers isn't enough to get a good idea of if a situation is bad or not. Since China is so big anything they'll do will affect a huge number of people, even if it's not excessive.
- shrikant 7y agoNazi Germany didn't have the good sense to satisfy consumerist lifestyles with cheap tat.
- Torwald 7y agoThis is a self contradictionary statement. People who are shallow enough to sell their ideals for "cheap tat" will not care about the origin of said tat and how they vote withe their dollars.
- adrianN 7y agoDuring the rise of Nazi Germany antisemitism was a worldwide phenomenon. Recall that few countries wanted to take in the Jewish refugees. Had Germany not started the war, they might have gotten away with exterminating all the Jews.
- Intermernet 7y agoI have a horrible feeling that, in 50 years people will be saying something similar about today. "During the rise of <insert power here> anti<blank> was a worldwide phenomenon. Recall that few countries wanted to take in the <blank> refugees. Had <power> not started the war, they might have gotten away with exterminating all the <blank>." Substitute for whatever you feel most applicable. A frightening number of variables fit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 7y agoIslamophobia is a worldwide phenomenon. Few countries want to take in refugees from Syria, Libya, or Yemen - and there are a lot of such refugees. There are 3.6 million in Turkey: https://data2.unhcr.org/en/situations/syria/location/113 https://data2.unhcr.org/en/situations/syria/location/113 (for a sense of scale for Americans, that's somewhere between the populations of Ohio and Conneticut)
- luckylion 7y ago> Few countries want to take in refugees from Syria, Libya, or Yemen - and there are a lot of such refugees. And that's about islamophobia? Saudi-Arabia is refusing to help because they hate muslims?
- pjc50 7y agoSaudi Arabia is part of the problem in Yemen, they're a belligerent? The Sunni-Shia conflict is an ancient one that's also a serious problem in the region for muslims, although how much of it is a religious conflict and how much is just a regular Iran-Saudi power struggle is hard to say. Yemen is unfortunate in being both strategically located, having little oil, a huge problem with the drug Qat, and rapidly running out of water.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zzzcpan 7y agoWell, you are probably ok with mass incarceration, other countries don't oppose it. You find a way to justify imprisonment for non-violent crimes, consent to this is manufactured through media that you are exposed to. So you feel like it's acceptable in society. I'm not exposed to that media, I feel as equally awful about mass incarceration as about reeducation camps.
- soulofmischief 7y agoDo you think people shouldn't go to prison for serious financial, non-violent crimes? And it's quite rude to project such a belief on someone. OP made no statement about their feelings toward mass incarceration, and claiming they are OK with it just because of the country they are in is like saying the Chinese are OK with what's happening in their own country.
- zzzcpan 7y agoYes, I think it's not ok to imprison people for financial crimes.
- soulofmischief 7y agoThen I have no incentive not to steal everything you own while you're out to town. Or your car while you're sleeping. Financial crimes always boil down to some kind of theft.
- rihegher 7y agoI think we can find better solution for them, like forbid them to use any bank account themselves by placing them under tutorship, it would probably cost much less to the society
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- soulofmischief 7y ago
- ghostcluster 7y agoIt's also a de facto ethnostate for the Han chinese. Foreigners cannot become citizens even if they marry a Chinese citizen. And the people they keep in their reeducation camps are stubborn ethnic minorities.
- 0815test 7y agoAnd proof that "ethnostates" are a terrible idea - see the amount of Han Chinese elites who are now fleeing that sinking ship and trying their luck in Western countries (that in turn, by and large, started out as "ethnostates" of their own but got rid of that aspect since it was a hell of a limit to their prosperity!) Ethnostate = good old boy network by another name.
- api 7y agoAmazing you are downvoted so much. There are a lot of neo-fascist/alt-right/whatever kool aid drinkers in tech. Ethnostates are just another kind of collectivist totalitarianism and it works about as well as the rest. Those who can flee generally do.
- tomp 7y agoI kind-of agree, but then, on the other hand, it’s nice to have a definite home that you’re always welcome to (and I think many Jews would agree). There’s not a lot of countries besides US and maybe some southamerican countries that have (almost) achieved that ideal...
- Hendrikto 7y ago> The survailance apparatus judges you if you are being a "good" citizen with harsh consequences for doing anything that the party doesn't approve of. Sounds just like the USA. Just look at Snowden or Assange.
- bojohohoho1966 7y agoThe difference is that I can call Donald Trump a fascist Nazi (or Obama an illegal immigrant and a communist) with absolutely no fear of repercussions from the govt, credit agencies, etc. Hell, I could even plaster it on billboards, make YouTube videos, and tv commercials. Big difference there.
- FabHK 7y agoYes. One can absolutely see things in a nuanced way, and acknowledge that there is much wrong in the USA, and quite a few things going right in China, but obviously political freedoms are in much better shape in the USA (and, say, Europe) than in China.
- low_poly_shiba 7y agoThe mistake here is obviously to compare China and the USA as apples and apples. The US is an empire comprising the mainland, as well as vassal and occupied states. China has a smaller periphery (Taiwan, Tibet, Xinjiang, HK, etc.) If you actually wanted to make this comparison, you would need to compare the treatment of people in the USA's occupied territories, such as Iraq or Palestine, to the worst in China, not the worst in China to the worst in the USA, that by default grants a huge arbitrary importance to national borders. (Although the worst within the USA is very bad). China's appalling assimilation of muslims should be criticized, but Americans rarely draw a baseline comparison to how they deal with large muslim populations (invading their countries, murdering their people, drone-bombing weddings, etc.) Reminds me of a friend who said "Churchill may have been a belligerent racist, but I'd rather have lived under Churchill than under Stalin!". The assumption is that "soviets" lived "under Stalin", but "englishmen" lived "under Churchill". However, it turns out the victims of Irish and Indian human-made famines also lived "under Churchill". He automatically imagines himself as an english citizen, not an indian subject... and it's not clear why? Or, to put it more simply, if the middle east or historical comparisons don't work for you, you can just look at the Monroe Doctrine that has been openly re-centered thanks to the efforts to realign Venezuela into American consensus. If you compare all of China to all of the Americas, you get a much better comparable population + land mass, and you can really contrast how the USA treats peripheral regions: blockades, banana republics, coups, black sites, paramilitaries, etc. Americans will tell themselves "we may be bad but we are better than the enemy" over and over again, and that is what we will eventually study as the core repeated mantra of American propaganda during its waning years.
- sehugg 7y ago"How China buys the silence of the world’s human rights critics": https://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/2101795/how-china-buys-silence-worlds-human-rights-critics https://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/21... Even in the 90s, when this was a prominent issue in American minds, when the State Department would offer the occasional "stiff rebuke", politicians told us that trade would inevitably move China toward an open democratic society.
- api 7y agoI think you just nailed the narrative that has been proven wrong: that free trade would move them toward an open society. More generally I think recent history has disproven a core tenet of libertarianism: that personal and societal level freedom are inseparable from economic freedom and capitalism (in the liberal meaning of the term) and the prosperity it generates. China proves that capitalism works just fine and even "benefits" (in a raw GDP sense) from an otherwise totalitarian state and that personal freedom and human dignity are optional. Pushing back on China is one of the very few things I agree with the Trump administration about, and I think it was bound to happen anyway without them. The deal was that we would open generous free trade with China and they would liberalize and open up to us. They broke the deal in multiple ways, taking that economic growth and then closing their markets and re-embracing totalitarianism.
- zzzcpan 7y ago> that personal freedom and human dignity are optional Political freedom that is. Personal freedom and human dignity are optional in "open societies" too with many countries having it worse than in China.
- low_poly_shiba 7y agoIt's truly bewildering to read an American write this. America right now is waging war in 8 nations, has caused the actual death of a million Iraqis, has destroyed several functioning nations such as Libya, is funding the death of how many in Yemen? It's choking Venezuela with completely arbitrary sanctions, while supporting the neo-fascist regime in Brazil. It's allied with the apartheid regime of Israel and the monarchy of Saudi Arabia, the latter which dismembers journalists and decapitates feminists and democrats. Their history has them funding all sorts of paramilitary groups in Europe via Operation Gladio, such as the opposition to France conceding Algerian independence: >France >In 1947, Interior Minister Édouard Depreux revealed the existence of a secret stay-behind army in France codenamed "Plan Bleu". The next year, the "Western Union Clandestine Committee" (WUCC) was created to coordinate secret unorthodox warfare. In 1949, the WUCC was integrated into NATO, whose headquarters were established in France, under the name "Clandestine Planning Committee" (CPC). In 1958, NATO founded the Allied Clandestine Committee (ACC) to coordinate secret warfare.[29][30] >The network was supported with elements from SDECE, and had military support from the 11th Choc regiment. The former director of DGSE, admiral Pierre Lacoste, alleged in a 1992 interview with The Nation, that certain elements from the network were involved in terrorist activities against de Gaulle and his Algerian policy. A section of the 11th Choc regiment split over the 1962 Evian peace accords, and became part of the Organisation armée secrète (OAS), but it is unclear if this also involved members of the French stay-behind network.[31][32] and both domestically and in Germany itself employed and propped up actual Nazis, >Germany >US intelligence also assisted in the set up of a German stay-behind network. CIA documents released in June 2006 under the 1998 Nazi War Crimes Disclosure Act, show that the CIA organized "stay-behind" networks of German agents between 1949 and 1953. According to the Washington Post, "One network included at least two former Nazi SS members—Staff Sgt. Heinrich Hoffman and Lt. Col. Hans Rues—and one was run by Lt. Col. Walter Kopp, a former German army officer referred to by the CIA as an "unreconstructed Nazi". "The network was disbanded in 1953 amid political concerns that some members' neo-Nazi sympathies would be exposed in the West German press."[35] and actual assassins: >Spain >Several events prior to Spain's 1982 membership in NATO have also been tied to Gladio. In May 1976, half a year after Franco's death, two Carlist militants were shot down by far-right terrorists, among whom were Gladio operative Stefano Delle Chiaie and members of the Apostolic Anticommunist Alliance (Triple A), demonstrating connections between Gladio and the South American "Dirty War" of the Operation Condor. This incident became known as the Montejurra incident.[55] According to a report by the Italian CESIS (Executive Committee for Intelligence and Security Services), Carlo Cicuttini (who took part in the 1972 Peteano bombing in Italy alongside Vincenzo Vinciguerra), participated in the 1977 Massacre of Atocha in Madrid, killing five people (including several lawyers), members of the Workers' Commissions trade-unions closely linked with the Spanish Communist Party. Cicuttini was a naturalized Spaniard and exiled in Spain since 1972 (date of the Peteano bombing)[56] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Gladio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Gladio Americans also have by far the largest imprisoned population in the world, one that is openly acknowledged by its architects to be the product of disenfranchisement strategies and continuing of slavery to ensure republican rule: >The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I’m saying? We knew we couldn’t make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders, raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did. https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Ehrlichman https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/John_Ehrlichman They have a home-grown Black Lives Matters movement where people march and plead for cops to stop murdering black people with complete impunity. Their police are completely militarized and use surplus military equipment like tanks and riot gear routinely. They also have child concentration camps for immigrant children where the death toll of children is growing at an alarming rate. They also have a massive propaganda industry where everything from their superhero with superpower kids movies to their dragon movie dramas reflects their governmental interests, and a completely pliant press that has never in its history opposed a war that the government asked for. When their torture program was revealed, a whole slew of propaganda items from 24 to Zero Dark Thirty to public intellectuals like Sam Harris immediately deployed several propaganda items to successfully make torture acceptable, and now it's featured as a gag in kids films like Zootopia. They worship their own leaders so much they carved their face into a cliffside and completely downplay their histories of slavery or corruption as it may be fit, and every single morning kids recite the pledge of allegiance, the military comes to every sports game, and military jets often fly overhead blanketing the sky in the national colors. Completely senseless propaganda terms like "they hate us for our freedom" are de rigueur. --- It's funny Americans have the gall to go into China threads wondering "What would I do about Nazi Germany?" You're showing the entire world what you would do in Nazi Germay lol. You'd be either vehemently a supporter of the fuhrer, or a coy supporter that would say "the fuhrer may be bad but better than our enemies".
- low_poly_shiba 7y agoIt's so funny to see Americans talk about their fears about the suppression free speech while my long post, packed with citations, gets sunk and deleted from the conversation without response: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20014965 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20014965 Any complaints about this censorship? Gets sunk too. The daily two-minute hate against China cannot and will not be interrupted!