21 ms·
Electric Vehicles Are Overwhelmingly More Energy Efficient
- ArtDev 8y ago"Only about one in four or five of those gallons of gasoline you pump and pay for provide energy you actually use, and perhaps 60-70% of what statisticians call the world’s primary energy use is really just waste" Interesting.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoTotally interesting! It's not waste for no reason. Energy transfers have thermodynamic efficiencies and at practical temperatures the transformation of chemical energy into shaft horsepower is like 30% efficient in a small engine. Making electricity from fossil or nuclear fuel in large plants is between that and 60% efficient.
- Gys 8y agoI was wondering how much then is lost in transport. Turns out to be only 2-4%. The same article also confirms that efficiency in large plants is about 60%: http://insideenergy.org/2015/11/06/lost-in-transmission-how-much-electricity-disappears-between-a-power-plant-and-your-plug/ http://insideenergy.org/2015/11/06/lost-in-transmission-how-...
- Sami_Lehtinen 8y agoNo all plants are combined cycle plants, even if improves efficiency a lot. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_cycle_power_plant Or even something better Cogeneration plants. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cogeneration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cogeneration
- userbinator 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake-specific_fuel_consumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake-specific_fuel_consumptio... Yes, it's in the 30s for typical petrol engines, and over 50% for large 2-stroke diesels.
- jacquesm 8y ago> at practical temperatures the transformation of chemical energy into shaft horsepower is like 30% efficient in a small engine Does that also hold for hybrid electric vehicles?
- snovv_crash 8y agoYes. That is the percentage of fuel energy that gets to your wheels. The rest is made into heat, and is why fuel engines need such big radiators - for every HP going to your wheels, a minimum of 2 go to the radiator. Hybrids just recapture the heat from the brakes, another major loss point, but unrelated to the engine. If you want to actually get better energy efficiency you need plug-in hybrid or fully electric.
- Gibbon1 8y agoMostly. The efficiency of a gasoline engine varies widely depending on rpm and power output. Hybrids keep the engine in it's most efficient operating range. It's also why hybrids produce about a fifth the pollution as straight gasoline engines. I think hybrids can also make some trade offs losing power density and torque for higher efficiency.
- SigmundA 7y agoMany gas hybrid run the atkinson cycle vs the otto cycle, this improves efficiency some at the expense of torque, which the electric motors make up for. Hybrids are much better in the city due to the stop and go nature allowing lots of braking regeneration and idle savings. On the highway much of their advantage is lost especially if comparing to say a diesel.
- asaph 8y agoTesla (not mentioned in the article) deserves a lot of credit in accelerating the shift towards battery powered cars.
- benj111 8y agoI'm sure Tesla will receive more than enough credit in all the 1000s of articles yet to be written about it, and has already received lots of credit. Not every article about EVs needs to mention Tesla.
- goodcanadian 8y agoYou are not wrong, but on HN, at least, I feel Tesla gets more credit than it deserves and Nissan doesn't get enough. I was an early fan; the roadster made me believe it was possible, but in the meantime, Nissan produced a mass market car and sold it worldwide in the hundreds of thousands. Only now, with the model 3, is Tesla arguably entering the same market . . . at the same time as everyone else, really. I will grant that they are producing on a larger scale than anyone else, but I'm not convinced they can keep that advantage long.
- agumonkey 8y agoOther brands did try and make great EV but it's only with a bold 'EV only and no more fossil fuel ever' pitch that the polarization effect was there.
- vinay427 7y agoI agree that Nissan was definitely more significant in the (early) mass-market electric segment. However, for the people I know who purchased Teslas, a lot of their decision had to do with a Tesla not seeming like a quirky or weird electric car with compromises. The range of most Tesla models far exceeds that of the Leaf, and while they obviously cost more partly as a result, a lot of people would prefer a vehicle that makes EVs seem usable, normal, futuristic, and "cool" though expensive rather than one that makes EVs accessible to people already interested in them who are willing to change their habits and preferences somewhat. It seems like a distinction in branding that Tesla seemed to hit the mark on, in my view.
- zizee 8y ago> Bloomberg NEF forecasts sales of electric passenger vehicles ... to overtake sales of those running solely on internal combustion engines in 2038. Perhaps I am naive, but I would be surprised if it takes that long. There are so many obvious benefits* to electric cars that the only thing holding them back from Mass adoption (IMHO) is the price of batteries. With such significant investments being made, and such steady progress being made, it is hard for me to imagine it will take almost 20 years to get to this point. * Yes, range anxiety, cold weather's affect on performance and lack of charging infrastructure are all problems, but they start going away when cheaper batteries make electric cars cheaper to own/run, and more cars are on the road to justify businesses to start installing charge stations in carparks.
- aaronblohowiak 8y agoCheaper and lighter. The dry electrolyte from maxwell that T acquired can do both.
- flexie 8y agoYou are absolutely right. The only way EVs are not going to overtake by 2030 would be if battery technology somehow stopped improving despite both investments in battery research and investments in battery manufacturing capacity are increasing exponentially. Already today, the expensive versions of Model S drives 370 miles / 600 km on one charge. If you live in a country with superchargers on main roads, this will be enough for all driving scenarios, whether it's the daily commute to and from work or it's the long vacation drive in mountainous regions or cold weather. In 3-4 years, similar range will be achieved by mid prized cars, and in 6-8 years, the higher end of the low prized cars will have that range. And at the same time charging networks expand rapidly, with Tesla's just being one of several. So around 2030, if you buy a cheap EV, range will simply not be an issue.
- burlesona 8y agoI think you’re right. This year Nissan said their plan is for their Infinity brand to go all-electric by 2022. Most forecasters today are looking at the straight line trend and underestimating the upward curve. However cars do tend to last a while so I imagine the lag between “most new cars sold are electric” and “most cars on the road are electric” will take a while, and “all cars are electric” may take a lot longer, or not happen at all if you consider niche vehicles.
- donquichotte 8y agoIt's sad that this "article" is not going more in-depth. What bugged me most was: > [...] it matters where the electrons going into an EV come from; coal-fired power is [...] less than 40% efficient on average. [If ...] we lost 6% in transmission, it would still add up to only 10 million barrels a day in oil terms. The efficiency gain is overwhelming. No! What about losses in the electric grid? What about losses in the battery? As far as efficiency is concerned, electric cars are just as bad as ICE cars, given their electricity comes from thermal power plants. Plus, a lot of rare earths are required to manufacture them, mainly for the permanent magnets in the synchronous motors and the batteries.
- mlindner 8y agoSorry that's a myth. Internal combustion engines are MUCH less efficient than any combustion based power plant. Ever notice how your engine is hot? That's all lost energy. Cars are only 25% efficient or so and the rest is lost as heat. Natural gas plants are 43% efficient and Coal is 32% efficient. Battery losses are extremely minimal and the rare earth thing is a red herring. There aren't any rare earths in batteries btw.
- serf 8y ago>There aren't any rare earths in batteries btw. they're common in motor design, especially motor-in-hub designs. To play devils' advocate : batteries are filled with so-called 'conflict materials', and the places that export things like lithium and cobalt have famously bad worker conditions.[0] The popularity of such materials is only going to make their conditions worse unless they're accommodated somehow. [0]: https://blog.ucsusa.org/josh-goldman/electric-vehicles-batteries-cobalt-and-rare-earth-metals https://blog.ucsusa.org/josh-goldman/electric-vehicles-batte...
- clouddrover 8y agoSome car manufacturers are working to reduce the use of rare earths in their motors. BMW's fifth generation motor doesn't use any rare earths: https://www.bmwblog.com/2018/12/28/upcoming-electric-motors-from-bmw-will-be-free-of-rare-earths/ https://www.bmwblog.com/2018/12/28/upcoming-electric-motors-... Car manufacturers are also making an effort to reduce the amount of cobalt used in batteries and are trying to increase the transparency of the supply chain to avoid sourcing cobalt from conflict regions. Volkswagen and others are using IBM's Blockchain Platform to document the cobalt supply chain: https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/volkswagen-joins-blockchain-initiative-for-purchasing-cobalt/ https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/volkswagen-joins-blockc... The problems are real but car manufacturers are working on them.
- aaronblohowiak 8y agoQuite a bit of the total energy consumed by/through any vehicle is in its manufacture. Due to their relative simplicity, I believe electric vehicles offer a clearer path to a more consistent high-mileage lifecycle, with the battery pack as the primary wear item. I’d love to see million miles become the norm.
- sjwright 8y agoIt will be interesting to see where the long term "wear items" are in an electric vehicle. Right now, I predict the most serious "wear item" is going to be cabin electronics (touch screen etc) and actuators (door handles, locks, gull wings, steering column etc). Battery packs—Tesla have shown that with sufficient battery management (stable thermals, avoiding charge state extremes) their packs can last extremely long distances. And they wear very gradually; an electric car with 70% of its original range is still a very useful item. Motors—I recall these were a high-fault item in earlier models, but as far as I'm aware these problems have been mostly solved and the reliable units have long lifespans. (And if they don't, they're comparatively trivial to swap out compared to an ICE drivetrain anyway.) Seats/Interior materials—I have no idea how durable Tesla's materials are compared to the competition. Does anyone have any insights on this? The models with all-aluminium chassis (because it's more valuable than steel and has an inherently long lifespan) makes them worth refurbishing. It would be cool if Telsa could license a third party to perform refurbishing on existing models—replacing older parts with newer equivalents. The benefit to Tesla is that improving a car's residuals increases its value and therefore "lowers the price" compared to competitor cars.
- dd36 7y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rhbD44jXffY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rhbD44jXffY Review of wear on Model S with 450k miles.
- 7952 8y agoMaybe this is a bit extreme. But I would love to see car makers be required to offer long term (5 years +, 100k+ miles) warranties for free. Force them to use higher quality components and be up front about long term costs. But allow them to exclude battery packs from the warranty.
- o10449366 8y agoWhat are the environmental and energy costs of producing and replacing batteries? How abundant are the resources required?
- chii 8y agoI would imagine that batteries' total cost of production over its lifetime is lower than the total cost of production of the equivalent energy in petroleum
- zizee 8y ago> How abundant are the resources required? Lithium is very abundant, and I have read that it is easily recycled. Not sure about the other inputs to the mix.
- sjwright 8y agoWorn lithium batteries are still highly valuable for grid storage because at even half their original capacity, they still have much better specifications than cheaper batteries like lead acid. Expect to see old EV cells redeployed into large scale grid storage rather than recycled for their raw materials.
- yholio 8y agoLet's assume used car batteries can extend their lives 2x as grid storage - dubious, since the probability of cascading failure increases exponentially after some point. Even then, it doesn't mean they won't get recycled close to 100%, just that you will have a rolling lithium stock twice as big. At some future point, they will still be removed from grid storage and recycled for raw materials.
- sjwright 8y agoI suspect within 20 years, the technology for automated recycling of standard lithium cells (e.g. 18650) will be quite advanced. The question is whether it will be more cost effective (or more carbon effective) than to continue using virgin materials. Lithium is abundant, after all.
- rapsey 8y agoNo one talks about the used car market for EVs. The battery is by far the most expensive part and the most volnurable to fail. So much so that buying a used EV is a much riskier bet.
- murukesh_s 8y agoHow about replacing the battery? And paying minus the battery?, I see it's much less riskier as there are lesser mechanical parts that are difficult to replace. Also there could be a used EVs marketplace where the battery can be serviced or even rented out (making it less riskier)
- salty_biscuits 8y agoIt isn't that hard to test if it is toast though. The rest of the drive train should be much more robust than an ICE. Much fewer parts and less to go wrong. I can't see a battery being any more expensive to replace than say a diesel engine.
- rapsey 8y agoA diesel engine will do an order of magnitude more miles.
- salty_biscuits 8y ago1000 cycles at 400km per charge. Hmmm... I don't think that is an order of magnitude
- jillesvangurp 8y agoNot without a lot of very expensive maintenance. The cost of that easily adds up to battery replacements/servicing. Batteries are expensive now but will drop in price over time as economies of scale kick in and current technology gets replaced by any of the better things currently stuck in the R&D stages of the many startups working on this. Diesel engines are not getting cheaper/better by a similar rate. Worse, investments in that are at this point being shelved in favor of EV investments. Diesels right now are about as good as they will ever be.
- 99chrisbard 8y agoWhy not transition to EV motorcycles?
- dymk 8y agoBecause I don’t want to die in what would be a mild collision in a four wheel vehicle
- agumonkey 8y agoif we all drive ebikes the issue is less so
- tirant 8y agoOr E-bikes, even more efficient and safe than motorcycles.
- vinay427 7y agoHow exactly are they inherently safer? With the implementation of bike lanes and the inability of the operator to do something insane, they can in practice be safer but that's not really a property of an e-bike.
- interfixus 8y agoFive years from now, it will be clear to anyone buying a new car that if it's legacy tech, its resale value is going to be essentially zero. Past that point, the trend towards electric will go exponential.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoYes that's already happening right now. The premise of buying an expensive car is that you can sell it a few years later for a predictable price. Once that price collapses, things get ugly very quickly. Once new buyers suspect there is an issue there, they will be very reluctant. So, the luxury car market will shift to full EV a lot sooner than 2038. IMHO that's happening right now and will largely have happened by 2025 already. It's the rest of the market that will take a bit longer. Not because of a lack of demand but a lack of supply: it will that long to build enough production capacity. And while capacity is limited, the high end of the market is more lucrative to use the capacity for. A Tesla model 3 with 20% margins selling for 40-60K is more interesting than say the equivalent of a Ford Pinto for 15K with 5% margins. The economics of that are different if you have enough capacity to do both of course but that is not the case yet. As long as battery production is a bottleneck, people will be looking to put them in high margin products rather than low margin products.
- leoedin 8y agoLooking around urban streets in the UK, the biggest blocker to widespread electric car adoption is almost certainly charging infrastructure. Most people in cities here live in flats, terraced houses or other houses without driveways. Charging therefore needs to be on-street or in centralised locations. We have a handful of electric car charging points, but these are often full even now, when electric cars make up a tiny proportion of the fleet. The amount of investment needed in street charging and supercharger like stations before electric cars can be the majority is absolutely vast here. It's going to need a lot of political will to happen. I think the situation is similar across much of Europe and the rest of the world. The US model - a driveway for every house across most of the country - is quite unique globally.
- londons_explore 8y agoThe issue is current charging stations are big dedicated things that cost thousands of dollars. They have screens and card readers, and loads of relays and switches inside. Some models (like Tesla superchargers) have a lot of very expensive power electronics in. They'll only be successful when someone can come up with a sub-$100 model which is integrated into a kerbstone.
- homero 8y agoThere are cheap plugin ones but they take all night
- goodcanadian 7y agoI could easily do a sub-$100 AC charger; installation cost is the real problem.
- shawabawa3 8y agoNobody in the UK has a petrol pump in the front of their house, it didn't stop petrol cars taking off I imagine people will charge at work, or supercharge for 20mins once a week
- homero 8y ago
- thesaint 7y agoElectric vehicles are a joke. How are they more energy efficient? Where does the electricity come from - magic? No in all likelyhood it comes from burning fossil fuels. How long does it take to tank a fossil fuel vehicle? Two minutes? Five all in? How busy are petrol stations? How long to charge batteries? Are the proponents of electric vehicles mad? Electric vehicles equal less freedom, more taxation and more costs. More energy effecient? - bullshit...
- Proven 7y agoThen why the hell are we forced to subsidize them
- woodandsteel 7y agoHere is a link that criticizes the BNEF report and argues EV adoption will be far faster https://cleantechnica.com/2019/05/19/bnefs-latest-embarrassingly-lowball-ev-outlook/ https://cleantechnica.com/2019/05/19/bnefs-latest-embarrassi...
- foxyv 7y agoI wish I could afford an electric car, but the real cost of ownership for one is so far beyond my gassed Honda Fit that I can never justify it. Instead I just try to use my bicycle and e-bike as much as possible. Maybe when the Honda finally dies I can justify an electric car, but I doubt it unless they get a LOT cheaper.