21 ms·
Why play a music CD? No ads, no privacy terrors, no algorithms
- munmaek 8y agoI buy CDs occasionally and rip them, but it's 2019, there's no real need to amass a CD collection (unless you want to). For most of my needs, spotify works out. I don't mind paying $10/mo since I use the offline listening so much. I only buy and rip CDs for my own collection if I -really- like that album or a song on it, and a web download isn't available. Occasionally spotify doesn't have a very specific version of a song–Legend of a Mind by the Moody Blues from the 1967? BBC recording sessions comes to mind. Or artists like King Crimson. I don't buy through itunes because of drm and the lack flac/alac options–why would I buy an mp3/m4a/aac file that I'm stuck with and can't transcode if needed? Bandcamp is a great alternative if the band you want happens to be on there. The app isn't too bad either if you forgot to download and sync an album. Other benefits of ripping a CD or downloading a flac/alac file include having a perfect lossless copy. I can then transcode to any format that I want, whenever I want, however I want, from now until forever (or at least until the storage goes bad/breaks), without losing any quality. With spotify pro + ublock origin, I never see ads on spotify or youtube anyway.
- NotPaidToPost 8y agoI think CDs are still a very good option when you think about how you intend to maintain your digital collection in the next 30 years. CDs I bought in the early 90s are there, in a box. I'd like to see people's iTunes collections in 30 years... Yes, I know that CDs have a shelf-life and that real long term storage would involve backing them up. But CDs still seem a better option than the current alternatives. Edit: The issue even with a DRM-free local iTunes library is: how are people going to keep that over 30 years? If you have a CD you only need to have a CD/DVD/Bluray player, which are still ubiquitous, and to push a button. But for a local iTunes library you need IT admin skills to manage it, to back it up, to transfer it from one machine to the next, perhaps to understand that you can access the music without iTunes, etc. The vast majority of the public don't know how to do that.
- teekert 8y ago"I'd like to see people's iTunes collection in 30 years" Might look different and be called different, but I bet there is some service offering most music in existence in 2050.
- NotPaidToPost 8y agoAre you saying that they will be lost and people will keep buying it again and again?
- teekert 8y agoPeople will subscribe to another service. But you mean the local iTunes library? Isn't that DRM free? I mean having DRM on it still makes it their music that you "rent", so basically a subscription service. My father was so ethical and bought a lot of music from some service of his ISP (Planet music or something), it is all lost. I'd never pay for DRMed music. At least with Spotify you know you don't own anything and just pay for access to a lot of stuff as long as you pay.
- AlexandrB 8y agoI have at least a dozen albums that are not on any music service today! In 30 years they’ll be impossible to find in any form. If you get deep into any small/independent music scene you’ll find CDs are still king.
- grosun 8y ago... or bandcamp (increasingly so in my experience)
- Crinus 8y ago> I'd like to see people's iTunes collections in 30 years... I bought my first album from iTunes 10 years ago and it is right there in my external HDD since iTunes does not have any sort of DRM anymore (it was removed years ago). Unless computers in 20 years do not allow people to have local data and force them to use The Cloud (at which point i'd probably stop using computers altogether outside of necessity), i do not see them disappear. If fact i rebought several albums i had in CD format because i lost some of the CDs after moving and a bunch of M4A files in a folder are more convenient than a bunch of CDs in a box (although TBH i do get the nice feeling of having something to look at that is physical... but only for things i really like and for me that is usually games not music).
- Crinus 8y ago> I don't buy through itunes because of drm iTunes does not have DRM and is the only reason i buy albums through them: after i download the album, i have a bunch of m4a files i can play with any player i want, in any device i want and store on my own external drive.
- otikik 8y agoI have purchased some albums in the past on itunes and discovered with disgust that they had DRM. They were only playable on itunes. I returned them (a not very user-friendly process). I have googled it a bit and it seems that DRM is not used any more on iTunes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay#iTunes_Store_DRM_changes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay#iTunes_Store_DRM_chan...
- lancewiggs 8y ago2009. That’s when the DRM was removed. 10 years ago.
- epanchin 8y agoA good lesson for anyone considering user unfriendly features.
- coldtea 8y agoNobody "considered" them, it was what the music industry demanded at the time. In fact, as far as major services (e.g. major distributor and not some niche music market with "indie" artists only) iTunes was the one that spearheaded the un-DRM of music (with Steve Jobs' call to end music DRM: https://betanews.com/2007/02/06/apple-s-steve-jobs-calls-for-end-of-drm/ https://betanews.com/2007/02/06/apple-s-steve-jobs-calls-for... ).
- ubercow13 8y agoThe music industry considered them, then
- Nextgrid 8y agoJust wondering how you manage Spotify + your own music collection. Is there an app that can play both Spotify and imported files and present them in a single UI? At the moment I can’t enjoy anything that’s not on Spotify simply because I wouldn’t be able to listen to them really. I have hours of music on Spotify playlists and I would only need maybe a dozen of songs that aren’t on there, so manually switching apps for those few times would be annoying.
- Crinus 8y agoWhy not use two apps?
- nitrogen 8y agoShuffle play
- austhrow743 8y agoYou can import music in to spotify.
- Garvey 8y agoSpotify allows you to import tracks from your computer and add them to playlists as if it was on Spotify. Obviously you can only access them on the computer you added them from though. Not sure about the mobile app, I assume it will skip the missing tracks in a playlist as normal but it might be possible that it picks them up if they're present on the device somewhere.
- camochameleon 8y agoYou can share them to an Android or iOS device [1], but it's a little fiddly. I'd love for them to offer a cloud music system like Apple Music or Google Play does, as Spotify checks all the other boxes that those services don't. [1] https://support.spotify.com/us/using_spotify/features/listen-to-local-files/ https://support.spotify.com/us/using_spotify/features/listen...
- yetihehe 8y ago
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoFor most casual music listening I use Spotify; one thing that annoys me there though is that there are some songs which have clear compression issues, the kinda wavy, watery sound from early low bitrate MP3s. I can only notice it in one or two songs with a lot of guitar distortion / wall of sound though. Its recommendations, daily mix and automatic playlist generated after listening to a full album are getting VERY predictable though. That is, same bands and often the same song. I'm not saying Spotify needs to improve their algorithm per se, it just needs to add a bit more variety - switch up algorithms from time to time, shuffle, start way down on the list of matched songs, something like that. It's getting annoying to the point where I'm considering switching to Apple Music for a while. Anyway, for physical music I buy vinyl nowadays. I don't even have a vinyl player (yet), just a box of collectables / memorable albums. I don't like CDs, the boxes feel far too flimsy; I've never owned any.
- nvarsj 8y agoIt’s not really Spotify’s fault. They are at the mercy of the master provided to them. For the most part Spotify sound quality is very good. Tidal has issues with poor masters as well - some songs sound worse on Tidal than Spotify, and vice versa.
- jim-jim-jim 8y agoWhile we're on the topic of prog, Spotify also has nothing by Henry Cow or Fred Frith in general, which combined with the lack of King Crimson is a dealbreaker for me.
- cageface 8y agoApple Music has a whole bunch of Henry Cow. No King Crimson though.
- cnasc 8y agoI just looked and there are 13 King Crimson albums on Apple Music
- coldtea 8y agoPerhaps such artists are not recommended (pun intended).
- jmngomes 8y agoTotally understand your pain :| They've recently added some very hard to find prog albums there, like Planet X, Andy West, Liquid Tension Experiment, Mahavishnu Orchestra, etc, but that obviously depends on what you like. I dislike renting in general, especially something so important like access to music, but the only reason I do it in this case is indeed the availability of some hard to find rarities.
- comboy 8y agoFor all flac lovers: http://abx.digitalfeed.net/ http://abx.digitalfeed.net/ I do understand the sentiment though.
- kozak 8y agoSuccessful ABX test only proves that no differences can be heard for some particular pieces of music, but not for all possible music material. There are edge cases (especially where noise is involved) that can never compress perfectly without overfitting the compression algorithm.
- ac130kz 8y agoTheir music is compressed down to 6db maybe, no wonder it sounds the same, the industry is to blame.
- voltagex_ 8y agoSure, but without FLAC I wouldn't be able to have my music in Opus without re-encoding from a lossy format.
- munmaek 8y agoAs I noted, my reason for flac/alac is for transcoding purposes. I mainly just transcode them to mp3 currently and play them in itunes anyways, but I have the freedom to transcode to any format in the future without a degradation in quality. You can't do that with lossy formats like mp3. Double blind tests show that 320kbp/s mp3s are indistinguishable from flacs, barring very poor masters or some extreme edge cases. For a lot of music you could get away with 256kbp/s probably, but it doesn't cost you anything to just go with 320kbp/s.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoNo privacy terrors? What short memories we have. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...
- rawTruthHurts 8y agoIn all fairness, I'm not sure how much of that applies 14 years later.
- garmaine 8y agoWe’re now invulnerable to rootkits?
- ckastner 8y agoSpeaking as someone who actively boycotted Sony products for a decade because of this fiasco, I also think it's time to put this to rest.
- dingaling 8y agoI'm still boycotting Sony, for the rootkit and the PlayStation Linux switcheroo. They never actually apologised for either.
- Kye 8y agoTrust is hard to earn and easy to lose.
- quickthrower2 8y ago> It then released, for one of the programs, an "uninstaller" that only un-hid the program, installed additional software which could not be easily removed, collected an email address from the user, and introduced further security vulnerabilities.
- dirkt 8y agoTo nitpick: Pure musics CD (CD-DA) can't contain any DRM or rootkits, because the format doesn't allow for data - it's all sound. Only combined CD-ROM/CD-R + CD-DA formats together with the unfortunate eagerness of Windows to auto-execute everything allows such rootkits. So if you feed a music CD to a real old CD player, or to (say) a properly configured Linux computer: No privacy terrors.
- hpaavola 8y agoAny recommendations for music stores which sell mp3's? I ordered Nokia 8110 4G and ditch my smartphone once it arrives. I think it only supports mp3's so I need to start buying albums and not rely on Spotify.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoGood question. When I recently wanted to buy an album as plain MP3 download, I was surprised there was only Google Music and Amazon (and iTunes, though it's a hassle with the terrible iTunes app) left.
- butteroverflow 8y agohttps://bandcamp.com/ https://bandcamp.com/ ?
- vbuwivbiu 8y agoBandcamp is truely the best music platform and one of the best websites there is today. It's fair to artists and its UX is in the rarest of states: done. I hope to god they never change a thing.
- garmaine 8y agoYou’re local library and a CD drive.
- tadzik_ 8y agoI think that's where CDs come in: for a lot of artists this is the only way to buy an album and end up with non-DRMed, not watermarked plain MP3 you can listen to on whatever you want. You end up with unnecessary plastic waste on your shelf, sure, but at least you have you own, independent music files – and at least you got more value than someone who straight up pirated it.
- thallian 8y ago- CDBaby (https://store.cdbaby.com https://store.cdbaby.com) has lots of stuff (they stopped offering flac downloads but if all you're after are high quality mp3 files that's not an issue). - Magnatune (http://magnatune.com http://magnatune.com) has interesting stuff too (they changed their pricing since my last visit a while ago, now you pay once for the whole library it seems). - Smithsonian Folkways Recordings (https://folkways.si.edu/shop https://folkways.si.edu/shop) is an absolutely fantastic resource in my opinion.
- atoav 8y agoI mostly buy my music via bandcamp nowadays and from time to time I buy a vinyl. I don’t believe in the idea of the superiour vinyl sound, but I like that it makes listening a concious ritual. Because I DJ from time to time I like to have the stuff I like on my drive and so it ends up beeing either a download or vinyl. CD has totally fallen out of favour with me..
- foobar1962 8y ago> it ends up beeing either a download or vinyl. CD has totally fallen out of favour with me My best friend in school was quite eccentric, and used to have a wind-up gramophone and collect acetate 78s. He'd make his own player needles from cactus spikes. He completely skipped LPs and went to CDs.
- TimTheTinker 8y agoI once was chatting with a producer who worked for Disney for around 15 years. He said the so-called “warm” tone of vinyl vs the “harsh” sound of CDs is really that the vinyl format acts as a partial low-pass filter. So it’s really just that you’re hearing less high-freq sound on vinyl than on a CD.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoKind of. Vinyl can't carry much bass, so it's cut with a special EQ curve - called the RIAA curve - that eliminates most of the bass and some of the mids. Phono preamps have the opposite curve. In theory when the music comes of the preamp you get a flat response overall. In reality any added distortion warms up the bass a lot, the mids some, and the treble barely at all. Because what's left of the bass is still cut close to the dynamic range limits of vinyl, it's always distorted. But because of the extreme EQ this rounds out the low end and gives the mids a boost. The overall effect is a warm sound. Vinyl isn't a true hifi medium. It's more like an Instagram filter for music. It can sound very nice, but it's a heavily processed sound, not a realistic one. Digital has other issues. But for ultimate fidelity, personally I would always - no exceptions - prefer to listen to a lossless 24-bit digital recording of a master tape captured with studio-grade converters and streamed from hard disk than from vinyl, CD, or any compressed file format.
- sschueller 8y agoWhat bugs me is that quite a lot of things are not available. I ripped my entire CD collection and uploaded into Google Music (not sure if that feature still exists). I have all this music available but I can not find it on other peoples google music. So if I share a song, they get an error. Most of this music is nothing special and quite mainstream but if I search on other peoples devices I can not find the songs only alternate versions from other people who made a cover version of the song. I am also worried now that songs will just disappear. I no longer remember specific names but instead hit thumbs up to add them to a list. If the song gets removed from google due to license expiring or what ever that song just disappears from my list and in have no idea that I every had it on my list.
- chewz 8y ago> I can not find the songs only alternate versions from other people who made a cover version of the song. Try some jazz like Coltrane or Miles Davis. It seems they never stoped issuing albums - remastered, Coltrane for lovers, Miles for cooking. It is next to impossible to find original album or remastered original. Yesterday on Youtube Music oldest Coltrane album was from 2015.
- imglorp 8y agoI think all these algorithms reward novelty to keep you engaged, which means snipers making phony compilations beat the original.
- orloffm 8y ago"or" here really simplifies things. Nowadays almost every 70s-90s album on streaming services is a remaster with overloaded levels and clippings. One has to resort to torrent sites to find rips from original CDs or vinyls.
- i_am_proteus 8y agoThis[0] is a good resource if you're interested in the dynamic range of remasters. If you listen to anything that falls into the "progressive" genre, this[1] channel may interest you. Only high-dynamic-range versions of albums, often ripped from vinyl. Steven Wilson has been mixing everything he can get his hands on and most of it is both brilliant and faithful. [0]http://dr.loudness-war.info/ http://dr.loudness-war.info/ [1]https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCXL-7ZVrR7wf7Nf5-FcUVRw/about https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCXL-7ZVrR7wf7Nf5-FcUVRw/about
- rienbdj 8y agoYou can achieve most of the convenience with a downloaded collection of mp3 / flac / alac why use CDS?
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoAnother reason CDs are still worth considering: classical music and, to a lesser extent, jazz CDs often feature extensive and informative liner notes that have never been posted online anywhere. I myself typically rip all my purchases to FLAC immediately and then I listen through my media centre, so I often forget that I have the original physical release there on the shelf, but when I do go back and look at that CD I am often amazed how good the liner notes are.
- layoutIfNeeded 8y agoIndeed. I not only rip my CDs immediately to FLAC, but also scan all the artwork in 600dpi on my CanoScan 9000f photographic scanner. These are then stored in a PDF file next to the music.
- beat 8y agoI think that's one reason for the vinyl resurgence - artwork is so much better.
- leemailll 8y agoI agree. I mostly listen to classical music, although I also rip them but most of the time I still use cds. It seems current music players on computers never thought about creating classical music pieces playlist. I had to manually add pieces to create them with correct order or just add albums which is the same as just playing a cd. In the end, I listen to music with CD players mostly, and still insist on buy a car with CD player
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThis is primarily the fault of later era CDs when the index marks were abandoned and small movements were separated by track breaks. Originally, Redbook audio was supposed to always have a silent pregap between tracks and indexes were for intra-track navigation. You will find this on early classical CDs. Then the problem is finding a player that supports skipping index marks.
- JudgeWapner 8y ago
- Nodzi 8y agoI honestly prefer Spotify. The reality is that I have 1014 songs on my playlist at the time of writing, and it sets me back the equivalent of about $5 PM (Converted from ZAR), and I get to be picky about what I listen to frequently. In an album from someone, odds are that I might like 2 of the songs at most, so buying a CD for only 2 songs is a pointless activity for me. This means that to collect 1000 songs that I like on CD I'll have to buy 500 CDS total. That's a lot of money. I also enjoy being able to mix up my music and not having to swap out discs when I get tired of an artist. I understand privacy is an issue for some, but I don't really care if Spotify collects the data of who I listen to, it only improves their algorithm and makes my music discoveries easier. The reality is that you're always connected to the internet, and even if you listen to CDs on your computer the media player is still collecting your data and behaviour.
- Spearchucker 8y agoYour comment about liking say 2 songs on a album is interesting. I bought the double disk Led Zep Remasters CD in 1992 just for Immigrant Song. And since then have grown to love all of their stuff. Sure, since ~1990 I have amassed lot of complete albums (almost 2,000 of them) which cost me a lot of money. Spotify Premium at €10/month for all those years is €3,480. Suspect Spotify is cheaper but I've developed this crazy distrust for anything I supposedly own but isn't DRM-free on my PC. Yoar approach is easier, no doubt.
- tadzik_ 8y ago> even if you listen to CDs on your computer the media player is still collecting your data and behaviour I'm not sure what OS or media player you use(d), but implying that it's somehow inherent to playing music on your computer in general is an overstatement, to put it mildly. As a counterpoint to your argument: I tried Spotify and went back to offline music. I don't use CDs of course, it's all ripped to MP3 and sitting there on my hard drives, with some of it copied over to my phone. The internet is always there except when it isn't – cross the border to a non-EU country with crazy roaming charges and suddenly you'd wish that you had stuff offline with you. On the other hand with online services the music collection you have “with you” is effectively infinite, as long as the data connection is up. There's ups and downs to everything. The thing that ultimately turns me off from Spotify is the client: I've come to expect the ability to add a few albums to a makeshift playlist, shuffle the tracks, remove some of them because I don't like them, reorder a few songs whenever I feel like it etc. Whenever I try out Spotify it seems like my options are either to listen to whatever The Algorithm[tm] serves me or painstakingly create a custom playlist every time I want to listen to something non-standard. The “Play Queue” management in Spotify is next to nonexistent (or hidden so well in the UI that I couldn't find it), and compared to regular desktop players like Cantata it's just annoying to use.
- asmendes 8y agoHow does the algorithm actually negatively affect your experience? I use mostly Spotify, and in their case, their suggested playlists and discover weekly actually put me on to a lot of great musicians I wouldn't have known otherwise.
- satokema 8y agoBut who picks the pickers? The suits plan ahead and begin with the algorithm. Part of the solo hobby of listening for me is discovering stuff and getting into a favorite artist's discog in depth. Having an algorithm just recommend stuff to you ruins the fun. Plus, my taste is weird enough that my experience with streaming services is they either slowly nudge me towards either the mainstream where the algorithm can actually recommend stuff, or a weird overfitting where they end up playing the same stuff over and over because it can't grok the true form of my preferences. (To be fair, neither can I.)
- archi42 8y agoI feel the same, but fondly remember the old last.fm recommendations. Those were pretty good (I hope that's not just nostalgia speaking). Plus browsing scrobbles [=playback history] of people with similar tastes was a good way to find more great music; or explore new genres.
- everdrive 8y agoA lot of people feel this way, and a lot of people feel the other way. I'm not sure how to quantify or measure this, except to say these algorithms have never worked out well for me.
- dastx 8y agoI keep pointing this out, but Spotify's shuffle algorithm is absolute horrible. It plays the same 10 or so songs for hours on hours before it moves on to the next 10 or so songs. Their offline feature has become rubbish. Every morning I have a 10 minute walk to the train station and I usually open spotify right after I lock my door. Throughout this walk, spotify has played for about 1 minute in total, on a good day this number might jump up to 4. Sluggish as hell. When I open any of the items (my songs/home/individual playlist) the first time I load up the app, it doesn't even load for several minutes. So until it loads, even that 1 min or so, I can't even choose a song. I've been wanting to move away from spotify, and for me, the only other viable streaming platform is Google Music (does that still exist?). Having tried it for a few months, and completely cancelled spotify, it's the same shit but combined with an even worse UI. What gives? I have a Galaxy S9. One of the top of the range Android phones. I used to have a Xperia Z3 Compact. Which at the time was pretty powerful. The annoying thing is, from here its hard to move away. The only thing I've found that makes it easy for me to move away is some project called spotitube, which matches songs against YouTube and downloads them from there and converts them. So sure, if I used it, I'd get the songs back, but now it's shit quality and it's illegal.
- coldtea 8y agoUse shuffle and offline frequently and have never experienced any of the above. Perhaps it's some other issue?
- dastx 8y agoPerhaps it is another issue, but the fact that I've had it across multiple devices, I'd be surprised if it isn't Spotify's shoddy "algorithm" (if you even wanna call it that). I posted this a while ago on reddit on /r/Spotify[0] that shows two examples of the same song being chosen close to each other (one of which actually was listed one after the other). This is either terrible algorithm or an algorithm that benefits Spotify, not the consumer. The issues have been raised on Spotify's official platform, but they've just ignored it. There are literally thousands of replies[1]. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/spotify/comments/966nx7/uhh_dear_spotify/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spotify/comments/966nx7/uhh_dear_sp... [1] https://community.spotify.com/t5/Implemented-Ideas/Implement-an-actual-shuffle-function/idi-p/27607 https://community.spotify.com/t5/Implemented-Ideas/Implement...
- wisty 8y agoWe act like we can control the internet, like a drunk thinks they control the booze.
- nickjj 8y agoInstead or privacy terrors you have other terrors like wondering if the CD will even play, especially if you've listened to it a lot over 5+ years, even with good care. I'm surprised the article doesn't cover a more relevant approach like just playing local mp3s from your computer. You get the same no ads, no privacy issues, no algorithms but you have the added benefit of not having to lug around a binder of CDs to play the songs you want. This is how I've been listening to music for around 20 years and it works nicely. Been using foobar2000 since the beginning too (shortly after the Winamp rewrite that made it suck). It's a minimal mp3 player that uses about 5mb of RAM but has every feature I'd want for play back.
- timw4mail 8y agoMy experience is that bit-rot with CDs is excessively rare. Scratches and scuffs are rare "with good care". Even then, deep scratches are the real issue. Minor scratches are often irrelevant with the error correction. So how does one need to wonder if the CD will even play?
- PretzelFisch 8y agoI've had issues playing CDs on older players. I think newer models have better error correction.
- timw4mail 8y agoPlayback lasers can also weaken over time. Not so much a property of the CD as the playback device.
- avra 8y agoI'm curious why a CD would not work anymore after listening to it a lot? Is the laser powerful enough to damage it or is it the heat from the device itself which is degrading the material in the long term?
- ziari 8y ago
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoWorth noting here that ripping a CD is a copyright infringement, yes even for individuals, here in UK. We had about 2 years when it wasn't. Yes, that means Apple iTunes and the like provide tools for copyright infringement -- far worse than the young adult that got extradited to USA for providing links on a website (which is allowed in UK law) -- and in theory could be sued for contributory infringement.
- Freak_NL 8y agoWorth noting that the UK (along with Malta) is an exception in Europe. In the other European countries ripping a CD you own for personal use is completely legal.
- 2Ccltvcm 8y agoWorth noting that the UK never had a proper revolution
- amelius 8y agoAlso for research purposes?
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoFair Dealing is extremely conservative. Could you expand on what you mean, give an example of the research situation and scope? AIUI the CDP would probably allow you to do format conversion for private study if the matter wasn't available to buy in a format you needed for that study; they'd probably want to see some outputs to show it was study and not entertainment (remember in tort the consideration is balance of probabilities, they don't have to show you infringed just that it was most likely - without research outputs [eg study notes] then the likelihood is you copied for entertainment purposes. In short, if you're thinking "I can pretend it was for study" then I think you'd find the court is not that naive. YMMV, this is not legal advice.
- amelius 8y ago
- m1el 8y ago"Why play music from your hard drive? No Ads, No Privacy Terrors, No Algorithms"
- taneq 8y agoYeah, I feel like people have forgotten mp3s somehow. - Storage cost is trivial even with multiple backups - Can be better quality than streaming - Available offline, forever, at no extra cost Sure, in some jurisdictions it's not legal to rip CDs you own but it's easy enough to defend morally if you're doing it for private use.
- loudmax 8y agoPretty sure you're using 'mp3s' in a general sense, but I'm going to nitpick because I love audio format geekery. If you're going to rip your CDs, you should consider ripping to FLAC and Opus. The only reason to rip to mp3 is that basically every legacy device out there understands the mp3 format and knows how to play it. If you're playing back on a phone or PC or a more modern device, you should use a modern format. Both FLAC and Opus are totally open source. FLAC is lossless and will reproduce your source CD bit for bit, but in a compressed format. Listening to music in a FLAC format is the same as listening to the original CD. Opus is a lossy format, so you lose some fidelity by necessity, but if you make that trade it's the best quality you're going to get. A double blind test had it outperform AAC and Vorbis, and significantly outperform mp3. I rip my CDs to FLAC and store those files on my NAS. Then I convert the FLAC files to medium quality Opus files and those go on the SD card in my phone. I don't use old mp3 players, so I can do without mp3s.
- taneq 8y agoTrue. My collection is all in mp3 format but any local DRM-free audio format has all the same advantages and usually fewer disadvantages.
- PretzelFisch 8y agoI guess it depends how much you trust the playback software. For me, at the end of the day I might choose a cd or record because its just simple and works and I am tired of dealing with software.
- tools-4-NYT 8y agoWow, another fucking New York Times article. Sorry. I'm not interested in participating in discussion guided by some authoritative mouthpiece of pre-approved water cooler banter.
- apt-get 8y agoI listen to a lot of japanese doujin music (self-released albums produced by amateur circles at conventions). This is often a couple hundred albums every year, between Comiket, M3, and other smaller conventions. The overwhelming majority of it simply isn't available as a physical release on typical online marketplaces, much less on streaming services. Importing the physical release + ripping or relying on community downloads is often the only way to listen to these. These are arranges or sometimes heavily sampled albums that simply wouldn't pass on typical streaming platforms. Just something like Death Grips' cult Exmilitary album got removed from Spotify because it used a tad too many samples to their taste (although luckily it's available for free on their website).
- swtrs 8y agoIs there an online community for doujin? Sounds similar to the vapor/future/chillwave community on Bandcamp.
- apt-get 8y agoOfficially, not really. The 'scene' is a tad too big for that, although some circles publish on bandcamp sometimes (mainly those who can't attend the physical convention). In the west, there used to be forums (like doujinstyle) dedicated to sharing new releases after every event, which turned into large discord servers in the past year. Otherwise, a lot of the releases can be found on Asia-oriented private trackers as well. These are often the only way to get a chance of actually listening to the album, since there's generally a limited number of physical albums available for sale at the event, and reprints during the next edition of the convention are uncommon.
- skinnymuch 8y agoHow do you go about finding the chillwave community on Bandcamp?
- rebane2001 8y agoMost of the music I listen to is from Bandcamp I like it because I can directly support the artists and I get to show off my collection online, while still keeping my (easily redownloadable) mp3/flac collection offline I do like Spotify (even have a Premium subscription), but it's often missing the artists I like and the program itself is pretty terrible compared to something like Foobar/AIMP/PowerAmp In addition, having local music files opens up a whole world of new possibilities, like being able to add them to videos, having fun mixing/editing them and playing rhythm games like Audiosurf and Riff Racer
- poelzi 8y agoMe too. In fact, I find the prices and especially the flac extra price something from the last millenium, when storage and bandwith where expensive. Also the discography option is so wonderful, it helps with the backlog if you dive into something new. I already got 2 or 3 labels to be there because there was no proper place to get their music :)
- rebane2001 8y agoI feel like Bandcamp is also more geared towards artists. When I discover new music on Bandcamp, I see the custom-designed artist pages and make a connection between the music and the artist while on Spotify and YouTube it feels more like going from song to song, but not focusing on artists separately (which is not necessarily a bad thing, but I personally prefer the former)
- Shivetya 8y agoI ripped my CDs ages ago and have listened to music in my car or on my motorcycle through iPods or my iPhone since then. I would love to be able to get rid of all the CDs that I have accumulated throughout the years. For the last few years all my purchases have been through iTunes with an exception or two done through Amazon. I even downloaded a few albums and tracks made available by the artists themselves. The key to me is that I am pretty much set in my music preferences. I still hear and occasionally buy new music but for the most part its static and I am just fine with that. Now of the streaming or the one satellite service give me enough flexibility to hear only want I want to hear. Worse, why would I want another monthly bill? Radio, I used to use it for commute traffic only and for the most part its the only reason I can see using it. Even now my car can update traffic on the navigation frequent enough to let me know what I may encounter
- matwood 8y ago> The key to me is that I am pretty much set in my music preferences. I used to think that until I got a music subscription. I end up finding old music that is new to me. About the only genre I do not like is country, but even that isn't a hard rule. I also find it fun to just get lost exploring genres of music, but I understand that may not be a common thing to do. > Radio, I used to use it for commute traffic only and for the most part its the only reason I can see using it. For me, podcasts killed the radio. Terrestrial radio feels like it's more commercials than content. If I do turn on the radio and on the rare chance it's not on a commercial, one is coming in the next minute or so.
- layoutIfNeeded 8y agoOr just skip the middlemen and buy directly from the artist via bandcamp?
- everdrive 8y agoA couple years ago I took all my music back out of google music and restored from physical backups where necessary. Now, my audio player is an old laptop running linux, hooked up to some very nice speakers. (it can play podcasts too!) The laptop just uses Rhythmbox, but you could obviously use whatever player you like. It's the best setup I've ever had. No terrible UI, no syncing, no garbage. I control what music is on there and where it's backed up. And most importantly, it has separated my music from general computer use. Yes it's technically playing on a computer it's the old linux laptop that's hooked up to the speakers. It barely uses any power and the keyboard is in an awkward position to type on. It's not convenient to watch videos or browse the internet on. It's not convenient to type on. It's really only good for listening to music. You can set it on and read, or do chores, or exercise, and never feel the urge to jump on HN, read the news, etc. If it weren't for the podcasts, it'd never even connect to the internet. And therefore it wouldn't matter if it were even updated or password protected.
- rochak 8y agoSo, do you buy each song separately digitally or physically? Also, after buying, how do you move it to your setup? For physical copies (CDs or Vinyls), do you rip and convert them to .flac or .mp3? For digital, do you remove the DRM?
- everdrive 8y agoIt's smorgasboard. Some are MP3s I probably downloaded more than 20 years ago, others are ripped from CDs, others are bought from Amazon or other sources. The caveat with Amazon, Google play, etc is that they must be some DRM-free format. I'm not an audiophile, and medium-to-high quality MP3s are fine by me. I've actually got a record player, so most of the Vinyl stays in vinyl format. As far as getting music to and from my setup, I'm usually pretty old fashioned. I have an external hard drive that I use for backup, and a thumb drive or two. Further, I have Owncloud set up on a Raspberry Pi, which is nice for moving a few files, but wouldn't be suitable for moving files of any real volume. Obviously, anyone could build a more mature and robust network drive if they liked, but this setup is more than suitable for my needs.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nihil75 8y agolol where do I even find a CD player..
- Hendrikto 8y ago> No algorithms Seems like people actually have no idea what that word means.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoSo, is the Loudness War finally over? Or are CDs still clipped to hell?
- Tepix 8y agoCDs in general aren't. Some genres perhaps. But the clipping is going to be the same even when you're streaming the songs.
- pier25 8y agoWe've reached a point where compressors and maximizers cannot really add any more loudness to the music. So the war is over and the result is that many genres of music have no dynamic range.
- ducttape12 8y agoI think people are missing the point - his point is simplicity. This is actually why I've stopped buying albums and switched entirely to streaming internet radio like di.fm. I spent way too much time and effort managing my mp3 library over the years. (ripping, tagging, file naming, album art, etc)
- yoz-y 8y agoDon't all streaming services have a way to add albums to collection and listen to those instead of a randomly generated stream? I use Apple Music and have both albums that I can stream and music I have uploaded there myself. There are no ads, I believe none of my privacy is violated and there are definitely "no algorithms" assuming the author talks about curation.
- floor_ 8y agoI buy most of my stuff from amazon and bandcamp. The convenience of amazon just sending you a zip file is just too good of an option to me.
- joombaga 8y agoDoes Amazon do lossless?
- lunchables 8y ago>amazon just sending you a zip I just googled this and it looks Amazon lets you download your music from them, DRM free?
- kome 8y agoI still use SoulSeek.
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoSoulSeek was awesome for discovering music. Unfortunately, the quality of the music shared was usually at lousy quality (96-128kbps), with the result that I usually ended up deleting the albums later and re-acquiring them at higher quality from somewhere else.
- raehik 8y agoWhere are my Rockbox users at? My tiny plastic Sansa Clip+ MP3 player has been going for years, I'd be nothing without it. >10hrs playback, supports >128 GB microSD, plays OGG/FLAC/MP3/AAC/anything. The Rockbox firmware is still being developed, albeit at a slow pace. By far the best combination of hardware+firmware I own. Unlikely to replace it for another few years. Sadly not produced any more :(
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoI was a happy user of a Sansa Clip+ circa 2009-2011, but I think like most others, once we started getting decent smartphones, carrying a dedicated music player just didn't seem worthwhile anymore, except maybe for a long plane ride where preserving my phone's battery life was critical. I suppose with headphone jack and SD slot becoming an increasing rarity in the Android world, the Clip might become more relevant again. But I hold out for the models that keep both.
- jaifraic 8y agoYeah, I really liked it. My last Sansa Clip+ broke a couple of month ago, though. I couldn't find a decent replacement yet.
- opencl 8y agoThe AGPTEK Rocker is okay, runs Rockbox and is reasonably small and affordable.
- reaperducer 8y agoTry the Goodwill auction site. They show up there occasionally, though often mislabeled as iPods.
- kop316 8y agoI have the same set-up. The Val Down button doesn't work anymore, but aside from that, it is an awesome little device. I use it for my Gym mp3 player. Sadly I outgrew my Clip+, and I am using a FiiO X5 Gen 2 for my main player.
- 8y ago
- wiz21c 8y agoI went the CD road too and use a squeezebox. Very fine. Except that ripping audio cd is tedious. Does anyone know about a music player that, once it sees a new CD, plays it and rips it at the same time (so I just play my CD and, next time, magic !, my CD is ripped)
- wprapido 8y agoI use streaming services like Spotify and even YouTube purely for discovering new music, on my terms. Music I want to listen to is music I own, as in I have it locally, managed by me. Ads, privacy, audio quality and many other issues plague streaming services.
- quake 8y agoA few years ago I bought an 'old' ('00 Integra) that had the stock head unit. It would only play CD ROM. It was a total pain to find actual CDs and not DVDs. I dug up mine and my girlfriend's old zip-up CD books full of ripped/torrented mix-cds from when we were teenagers, and it was an actual blast. It felt so good to rediscover some albums I hadn't thought of in the last 10-15 years. The Integra is getting a little long in the tooth, and I'm going to be sad that my time machine to 2005-2007 is going away.
- asdff 8y agoI have the same year integra! It's leaking every fluid now and I'm going to get rid of it soon, but the original clutch is still gripping strong
- bigred100 8y agoThe only place I’ve heard music in years is YouTube on my phone, car radio, or live. There’s so much on YouTube that I frankly don’t care to look almost anywhere else at this point.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI have been buying CDs lately but only because of market irrationalities - bizzarely at times CD + autoripped MP3s are cheaper than just downloading. I can only assume this bizzare inefficency is related to someone's bonuses related to disc sale metrics or accounting and logistics which encourage reducing unsold stock over the effectively infinite downloads.
- aembleton 8y agoYou can also buy CDs second hand off ebay.
- sproketboy 8y agoDoes Apple still ignore CD Text if you import a CD into iTunes? Probably.
- modbom 8y agoClickbait title... Article is just an interview with a nyt journalist who covers the music industry. Was interested in the discussion of cd vs streaming.
- londons_explore 8y agoUnless it's a Sony CD... In which case, watch out for rootkits!
- snvzz 8y agoCDs are massively inconvenient. When I get a music cd, I just rip it to FLAC. From that point on, I have a file. Much more convenient to work with, and easily backed up with all the other files. Having a good backup strategy, I'm more likely to be hit my lightning than lose a flac file. As for buying DRM'd music online, I haven't so much as considered it. It just won't happen, ever.
- bo1024 8y agoYou can now buy non-DRM music from many downloading sources, including high quality FLAC. Example: Bandcamp
- kstenerud 8y agoI've got all my music ripped to FLAC, sitting on my file server, a little N40L microserver with 8tb mirrored storage (my music takes about 300gb total). On the server, I've got a script that uses ffmpeg to convert from flac to whatever format I want (currently aac and mp3, which my player devices support). The script also applies replaygain to keep the volume consistent. I run the script once and it processes the whole shebang. This means that I control all of my music, stored in lossless format on a backed up server in my house, able to be deployed to any device I want whenever I want, in whatever audio format is popular at the time, in perpetuity.
- durnygbur 8y agoI was wondering if some media server [1] set up in local network and serving audio and media files in popular formats from an external USB drive would do the job for me. Don't have the time to experiment even with such a simplified setup. [1] https://www.turnkeylinux.org/mediaserver https://www.turnkeylinux.org/mediaserver
- _bxg1 8y agoI just have all my music on Dropbox in max-quality MP3s. I use TuneBox on iOS to get a music player experience, and whichever MP3 players on my desktop OSes. Not lossless, but a simpler setup.
- omega3 8y agoSlightly of-topic but how do you discover new music to listen to?
- Someone1234 8y agoI'd like to know too. I also don't consider this off-topic considering we're contrasting streaming music with CDs, and one of the "value adds" of streaming is discoverability.
- kstenerud 8y agoSame way I have for the past 30 years. I listen from time to time to stations that play the kind of music I like. Sometimes I check out various places that have top 100 charts. If I find something I like, I go get it and add it to my collection. Rerun the script and resync my devices.
- guest123467321 8y agoIf you have a phone nearby you will never be sure who else is hearing to your CD.
- b15h0p 8y agoOn a tangent: Does anyone here have a good solution for self-operated music playback for kids? Suitable for age 2+? Moving away from physical media has made selecting their own music much more abstract and difficult to manage for kids. I am aware of the Toniebox (in germany) which operates with NFC-figurines (i guess) which are pretty expensive.
- reaperducer 8y agoGet an old iPod Shuffle from a thrift store. Cheap, durable, tactile.
- m-i-l 8y agoI got a Taf Toys "My First MP3 Player" a few years back. Parents could load a USB stick with MP3s on any PC (including Linux), then plug the stick into a secure compartment on the device (requiring a screwdriver for access, like the battery compartment). Children then had buttons for play, stop, next, previous, volume up, volume down. Only minor issues/features were that the maximum volume was pretty low (presumably to make it safe for babies), and it would switch itself off if no buttons were pressed for a short while (again presumably so it would be safe to leave unattended). Was going to post a link, but it seems it is no longer available.
- fdsa_fdsa_99808 8y agoThe #1 reason to use CDs / LPs: Music "devices" have insanely bad UX. Like absolutely fucking awful. I've got a 10 kilobuck set of speakers that take (in the highest SQ config) a digital input. The "best" solution I've come up with is to use a portable player that has a coax digital out. This is a well reviewed portable player and one that supposedly is happy driving a home stereo. It's fucking awful. Keeping the thing charged, free of ground loops and finding albums on it is so painful I listen to my stereo way less than I should. Oh, and the update loop for getting new music on it? Fuck. Of course, I sold my CD player years ago and got rid of most of my CDs. Every time I struggle to turn on my stereo I consider buying a CD player, burner and a few spindles of blank CDs. Yes, I could drive the setup with a computer and a USB / SPDIF adapter. WHAT THE FUCK HAS GONE WRONG THAT THE BEST SOLUTION IS TO BUY A SEPARATE COMPUTER TO FUCKING PLAY THE CONTENT OF CDS?
- nixpulvis 8y agoThe biggest problem I have with the way I listen to music these days is that I'm basing tricked into thinking my "library" is a collection of my music. I get that a $10/m subscription isn't selling me each song I listen to, but it is letting me collect them, and that collection is a lie. At any moment it may change, songs can be deleted at will by Apple, or Spotify. This service is great in that it exposes a much wider quantity of artists to me, but it's a price for a radio service, not a music collection.
- johnklos 8y agoThis is why I rip Blu-Ray and DVD discs, then play from the file. I don't keep the files. I just can't stand the forced advertisements.
- izzydata 8y agoI've reverted back to using a standalone mp3 player. I got one of the newest Sony Walkmans and threw a large SD card in there. Something about it just feels right.
- criddell 8y agoMy daughter got a record player for Christmas last year and it caused me to think about my relationship to music. After she got the record player, I've taken her to the record store a few times and it was like stepping out of a time machine. I loved everything about it (Waterloo Records in Austin is pretty fantastic). I ended up buying a CD player and pulling my collection out of the attic. I had forgotten how good music from a CD sounds on a big stereo. These days, I'm mostly listening to entire albums (even when I use a streaming service). I've also started buying CDs again. When I stopped buying CDs, they were usually between $15 and $25. In the past four months I've bought a bunch and haven't paid more than $8. I know CDs are dying and now that I'm back into it, it kind of makes me sad. It's shocking to me to think the format was defined 40 years ago. The Philips and Sony engineers did a fantastic job.
- mirrorlake 8y agoI had a similar experience last winter when I popped a CD into my desktop. Probably the first time I had heard music with a bitrate higher than Spotify’s 320kbps in a few years. Within a day I was off buying my favorite albums on FLAC and making a CD wishlist. Made me remember why I bought nice speakers in the first place. And I’ve thought this for a while: With gigabit internet connections spreading, video streaming services that soak up bandwidth (10-20+ Mbps all day), WHY are companies stingy about audio bitrate? My connection can stream multiple 4K videos, yet audio is the same (or worse) bitrate than what I burned on CDs in 2003.
- criddell 8y agoI think the bitrate stingyness comes from the fact that people tend to watch Netflix at home over wired internet and they listen to streaming music over a more expensive wireless connection, often on crappy headphones. There are higher bitrate services out there. Deezer will stream FLAC and there are probably others. Where are you buying FLAC files from? For now I'm still happy with physical CDs although I have ripped them to ALAC. I'm not sure what the difference is, but when I scroll through my library on iTunes there's never anything I want to listen to, but if I look through my physical discs I always find something I want to put on.
- beat 8y agoYou know what else doesn't have ads, privacy terrors, and algorithms? Vinyl. But really, I think the pleasure of vinyl is the pleasure of being fully engaged in the act of listening. The privacy is the privacy of your own experience.
- ubermonkey 8y agoThere's definitely something intentional about picking a record and dropping the needle. We enjoy that. You can get lots of the same experience with CD, too, though.
- pier25 8y agoYeah but knowing that every time you listen to a record the needle removes a bit of its lifespan is not a great feeling.
- beat 8y agoEh. With proper care and a well-configured turntable, records can last a long time. And you can always buy a new one.
- ubermonkey 8y agoI used to be a serious CD holdout, but then a few things happened that changed things for me. Storage Look, I'm in my late 40s. I've been buying music on CD since I was about 17. I have LOTS. It's not really sustainable, so when iTunes went DRM-free, I started buying the odd thing there. I live in a place with a proper record store, so I still buy things there, too, but mostly stuff I know I really want the best experience out of. Random music that I kinda know I'll tire of and probably never revisit, though? Definitely iTunes. Fucking Sync. I'm in the Apple ecosystem, because this works best for me and my family, but one thing they never really sorted before Apple Music was whole-family-uses-same-library. It was awkward and vexing, especially to the non-technical members of the household, and so (e.g.) my wife ended up just not really having music with her on her phone. That's annoying. Plus, even for someone like me, it was annoying that if I bought a CD (or a vinyl record with a download code), getting that music on my phone was a hassle. So when Apple Music happened, I eventually signed up, and holy cow I haven't really looked back. What's great about it for my wife is that she never has to bother plugging her phone into a computer to get music at all. She can just add stuff on the fly, from Apple Music. Maybe it's stuff we own already, but that wasn't on the phone yet. Maybe it's new stuff she wants. Doesn't matter; still easy. We still buy records and CDs from our local shop, too -- mostly the same algorithm, between "I want this forever" and "this is probably transient" -- but overall we're both listening to MORE music than we did before. I mean, think about it: I'm paying Apple basically the cost of a CD per month for our family account, but the world is literally our oyster. MANY times since I signed up I've found myself reading a review of some album somewhere, and wanted to hear it. Before, I'd have to make a note to go find it online somewhere, or find a Youtube clip, or whatever. Now I can just have it, almost immediately, on my preferred device and through good headphones. It's pretty great. Now, I'm really only willing to do this because the vendor is Apple, and I trust them with my listening habit data. I wouldn't trust an ad-driven provider AT ALL, which is why I never signed up for Pandora or Spotify or whatever. But with Apple, all this is easy, and I'm not concerned about the privacy implications. I still have a shitload of CDs and vinyl, though. It used to be that "hey, pick a record" was a fun party game, because so few folks have big record collections. Now CD has picked up some of that novelty, too, and people enjoy browsing through the CD stacks when we entertain. But that's all a special corner case. ;)
- rchaud 8y agoI'm definitely on board with physical media. Almost all the vinyl I've bought comes with a download code anyway, and album artwork shines on a 12" x 12" canvas much more than it ever could on the tiny thumbnail you get on a music player app. That being said, indie music stores like Bandcamp are digital only, but offer one-click DRM-free MP3 downloads for purchased songs/albums. The UX is focused on buying music first and supporting individual artists, rather than commoditizing their sound into an algorithmic playlist where they're lumped in with everybody else. I honestly find Spotify and Apple Music bad for music discovery if your tastes aren't really adjacent to Top 40 (is that even a thing today?) style pop music. Back in the day, Last.fm used your iTunes/Foobar play history to show you bands you'd like. The algorithm was based on user-submitted tags, and the recommendations weren't limited to bands that had deals with the platform. I discovered a ton of new music across very different genres there. Unfortunately it doesn't look like the site is very active these days.
- devb 8y ago> indie music stores like Bandcamp are digital only Many bands on Bandcamp offer bundles of vinyl, CDs, t-shirts, etc. with the digital download. One example off the top of my head: https://filthyfriends.bandcamp.com/album/emerald-valley https://filthyfriends.bandcamp.com/album/emerald-valley
- poelzi 8y agoBadcamp has physical media as well. It's up to the artist to produce and deliver them. Since I find mp3 unacceptable audio quality, especially on PA sound systems, I collect flac only. Many shops have a shitty policy on lossless, thanks bandcamp for being proper.
- orblivion 8y agoBandcamp really is fantastic and will always have a special place for me. Just let me buy the stuff, choose my format, (even ogg!). Even let me sample it a good amount of times, and no obnoxious nonsense on their website. I hope they're doing really well. That said, for a larger number of really major artists, I heard about something called HDTracks. I haven't tried them yet, but it seems that they sell FLAC in 24 bit audio.
- x3haloed 8y agoThis headline smacks of fear mongering. Privacy TERRORS. ALGORITHMS! Walking, talking murder bots! Seriously? Please. If you pay for your streaming service, you don't have ads. Privacy concerns are an abstract existential concern that don't have practical effects at least in the context of music streaming. And algorithms? I don't understand what the fear is here. Just a general anti-technology sentiment? Why not make a playlist of your own or simply listen to and album from beginning to end? Maybe we've lost a little something moving into the realm of the purely digital, but that is the essence of change. It involves tradeoffs. And change is inevitable. Face change with courage - not by dearly holding onto everything that was.
- mrfredward 8y agoI agree with everything you just said, but I want to add a counterpoint. About a year ago, YouTube Music started playing ads for depression medication for me constantly. My music choice is...err...not particularly happy most of the time. I actually first noticed the ad after listening to a song called "Happy Pills." I have no evidence that I was profiled based on my music choice aside from this one coincidence, but it was enough to make me question if I want Google to know everything I listen to. Music gives insight into the emotional state of a person, so it could become a very real privacy concern, if it isn't being exploited already.
- andai 8y agoMy phone has this feature where it periodically checks if I'm still looking at it, to turn off the screen if I'm not. It doesn't take the opportunity to spy on my facial expression, but I reckon it won't be long.
- godshatter 8y agoSome of us care about privacy. "Privacy terrors" is granted a bit extreme. I differ from the author in that I prefer to listen to random songs from my collection of curated favorites that I have built up over the years rather than listen to individual cds. I've tried streaming services and that whole paradigm is just not what I want. I prefer to know that the next song is one I want to listen to, and I'm OK with not randomly finding that the next song is a new favorite. I have other ways I discover music. I prefer to control the music files I listen to and don't trust the cloud to keep them safe. When I was younger I listened to cassette tapes and cds more than I listened to radio. Am I afraid of this new technological world? Well, no, probably not, since I've spent most of my spare time (and later, my work life as well) programming or otherwise interacting with computers since at least 1978 or so. People are different. It's a good thing.
- wafflesraccoon 8y agoNot to go against the grain but I love Spotify, the Discover Weekly is killer for finding new music. I also have a large collection of vinyl at home for when I really want to enjoy an album. Also because Tool won't release their albums online =(
- wprapido 8y agoI also use Spotify as a great music discovery tool. That's where it stops at though.
- berry_sortoro 8y agoWhy I play mp3/4 with cementine and various other open source players directly from my harddisk? Because no ads, no spying, no algorythms. I use to use last.fm but I turn it off now and just use it to find new music based on searches if I feel like it.
- astraltheman 8y agoRemember when Sony BGM put the rootkit on their CDs? I guess as long as you're not putting it in a computer, you're good.
- admax88q 8y agoTime for the weekly NYT article lamenting the progress of technology I see.
- pier25 8y agoOff topic but... I buy a couple of 4K Bluray movies every month. I want to get the best possible quality and also support film makers, but damn, other than the image quality getting movies from torrents is still the best user experience. It's not even a money problem for me. Not only pirated movies are available weeks before you can buy them in Amazon, but you don't get any anti piracy ads, or trailers that you can't skip. The available catalog in torrents is immense too. I waited like 6 months before I could buy the Dark Knight trilogy in 4K because it wasn't available anywhere. The Nolan 4K collection is also very difficult to get without spending an arm and a leg in my country. You also don't get all the regional BS. I can't even get the digital online versions of the Bluray discs I buy because I don't live in the US. I've considered buying digital (iTunes, Prime, etc) but the regional catalog we get is poor. Google Play Movies for example doesn't even have 4K and, hear this, not only most movies are dubbed, if you want the original audio and the dubbed audio for the kids you have to buy 2 movies. Yeah. And then, since you don't really own the digital movie you bought, it can disappear from your library or you can lose the 4K version like what recently happened with iTunes. I love movies, I want to spend money on movies, but damn the studios and distributors need to find a better way of selling their content.
- jslabovitz 8y agoI've been collecting CDs for a few years now. I rip them for archiving and for easy playing (iPhone, etc.), but also enjoy handling the real object. I like the experience of simply listening to album the way it was originally intended by the artist, in the original order, with the production values intended at the time, not mixed up with other songs. Streaming, or even shuffling, often makes me tense and anxious (radio did too). Because it's a bit of a pain to get music to the iPhone (with ALAC conversion, etc.), I recently experimented with matching albums with Apple Music and just using that version. However, I've been disappointed that many of those albums aren't actually the same ones as my CDs! (Again, this is Apple Music: other streaming services might be different.) For example, tracks might be remastered (sometimes for good, sometimes not), and often the album is a 'deluxe' version with extra tracks. If there was a way to 'hide' those extra tracks, I'd be okay with it, but sadly it feels like the original intent of the artist has been corrupted by the record label to sell more content. So I'm slowly returning to my first method, and only listening to ripped music, an album at a time, in its original order.
- dev_dull 8y ago> in the original order I agree with most of what you said, but so many albums include awful filler music between hit songs. This was one of the reason mp3 downloads became so popular. Everybody knew record companies were just adding filling to get to a certain album lengths.
- max76 8y ago> Everybody knew record companies were just adding filling to get to a certain album lengths. Sometimes. Maybe even often. Never always. To me the highest achievement a recording artist can make is an entire album that is a good coherent work of art best enjoyed as a whole. Some artist actually deliver this.
- Finnucane 8y agoMusic producers have been doing that since the invention of the LP. Along this line: reissues of LPs that include every alternate take.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoI still only buy CD's when buying music, then rip to FLAC for other uses. My Pioneer receiver can play them both, streaming services, and the horrible local radio, so all bases are covered.
- musicale 8y agoIt also sounds pretty good. But I wish iTunes/Apple Music would switch to Apple Lossless - then I wouldn't bother buying CDs, ripping them, and shelving them.
- abhiminator 8y agoReading headlines like these kind of makes me wonder -- is going back to analog/old school devices the new micro-counterculture?
- shmerl 8y agoWhy not play a DRM-free audio file (Opus, while having lossless FLAC backed up) instead of an obsolete CD? I don't use renting services for music, but I don't buy CDs either (unless it's the only way to buy it). I buy audio files. The benefit of CDs though is also getting the lossless version, when digital one sold is lossy only. Other than that - I don't see the point.
- JohnFen 8y agoI'm not married to CDs, specifically. I buy them, but them rip them into digital files and save the CDs as backups. However, I don't use music streaming services either -- they are unacceptable to me for the reasons the article states, and more. Instead, I keep a library of digitized music, and either stream it from my own streaming server or put a subset of them onto an SD card and play them from there. That satisfies my need for quality control, to be free of tracking and ads, and to have confidence that the music will never just disappear on me. Not to mention avoiding an unnecessary ongoing expense.
- porjo 8y agoNot to mention superior sound quality! I've been listening to classical music on Spotify and it sounds awful to my ears using headphones, even with so called HD audio enabled.