28 ms·
The End of Being a Duke Professor and What It Means for the Future of Higher Ed
- rdlecler1 8y agoWe have a couple of generations that haven’t been exposed to the horrors of a dictatorship. History must repeat itself. In the meantime, Duke and other such institutions will loose their appeal to those with deep and independent curiosity and to the parents who guide their children down that path. History will not favor these institutions.
- bluedevil2k 8y agoYou're claiming schools like Harvard, Princeton and Duke will become less appealing to students? That's pretty crazy and not at all in sync with the where the money is going. Look at the endowments of these schools, do the billions of dollars make it look like they're less appealing.
- edraferi 8y agoIt seems like there’s a gap in the market for a hard-nosed, teaching-first university. A place full of passionate professors with high standards. A place where high school valedictorians work their ass off for a B. A place where you feel your best will never be good enough because the standards are impossible... until, one day, you get an A. And that grade MEANS something. And after four years, the students walk out into the wide world and kick ass up and down the street. Somebody get $100M and start recruiting all these great professors academia can’t handle....
- dboreham 8y agoScotland?
- nugget 8y agoI went to a top school and my observations in hindsight: 1. brilliant professors and peers were inspirational and encouraged ambitious and creative thinking 2. >90% of education is self-education 3. very little of what I learned in class prepared me for the real world and among my classmates there has been relatively little correlation between academic success and real world success
- chongli 8y agoI don't know how to say this without it sounding like a brag, but here goes anyway: this is University of Waterloo in a nutshell. I'm entering third year, studying math, and every single one of my friends has gone from high 90s in high school (multiple valedictorians) to struggling to keep an average in the 70s-80s range. Anecdotally, one of my friends did a work term for the Dean of Science (and pure mathematics professor) at another university (which shall remain nameless) and she said the stuff we've been doing in first year isn't covered until 3rd/4th year at that school. Heck, her old high school AP calculus teacher couldn't do assignment 1 from our first year calc 1 course.
- metaphor 8y agoAdmittedly struggling to find the exception[1] that you speak of. Maybe I'm looking at the wrong course? The experience is effectively the same at any tier 1 university in the US. Some even have special names[2]. [1] https://www.studocu.com/en/course/university-of-waterloo/calculus-1-for-honours-math/297397 https://www.studocu.com/en/course/university-of-waterloo/cal... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditions_of_the_Georgia_Institute_of_Technology#Getting_Out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditions_of_the_Georgia_Inst...
- chongli 8y agoI only looked at a few of the assignments from your first link but they are much easier than the one I wrote [1]. Perhaps my term was an outlier. Have a look for yourself. [1] https://docdro.id/khG8VN7 https://docdro.id/khG8VN7
- mkl 8y agoI'd be interested in seeing that assignment, if you can lay your hands on it. I teach university maths.
- chongli 8y agoI posted a link to it in reply to the other person.
- 8y ago
- pnw_hazor 8y agoUnited States Military Academy
- lquist 8y agoThis might be Minerva (https://www.minerva.kgi.edu/ https://www.minerva.kgi.edu/)
- 2calazm 8y agoThese places already exist outside of the US, and that type of repeated stunts from Duke, Brown, Reeds, etc, is probably a boon to them. I believe the current climate is a deterrent for foreign students, who in the US are caught between anti-immigrant sentiments on the right, and reactionary identity politics on the left (such as African and Indian students being called race traitors at Reeds). International students represent a significant source of income in higher ed and their enrollment has nose-dived in the US in the last few years. If this continues this will benefit non-US international universities who will manage to attract that population, not just in terms of revenue but also in standing. So my guess is the places you describe already exist and they're about to be better known within a few years as trust in US universities erodes.
- snaky 8y agoThere's something like that at K-12 level https://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/2016/03/15/there-fear-math-and-then-there-fear-russian-math/Gn1XU68cOEw5G0UM8gIOhM/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/2016/03/15/there-fear-...
- ninguem2 8y agoWilliams, Harvey-Mudd, Reed...These places exist. But more people would like to go to Duke, Harvard, Berkeley,... Why is that, I am not sure but the market values the latter better.
- ausbah 8y agoWow, sounds like any top 30 university in the US...
- akhilcacharya 8y agoSounds like my low ranked public school... https://www.ncsu.edu/ https://www.ncsu.edu/ I’d recommend if only for the convenience and price! Again I feel like a lot of people on HN are privileged by a childhood of high achievement..I didn’t have that and could never get into a Duke-like institution (or Duke either for that matter).
- tzs 8y ago...and after four years, the students walk out into the wide world and find that employers often think someone with A's from some random easy state college is better than someone with B's from the hard high standards school.
- jrochkind1 8y agoDoes there exist a "teaching-first university" at all? If so, not many.
- pjc50 8y agoThe "polytechnic" class of higher education institution? The problem is that people seem to believe that research is osmotic: that students in the same institution as some research is happening will learn more. Hence the most prestigious universities are those with high-status research programmes.
- qntty 8y agoThis is what a liberal arts college is.
- RugnirViking 8y agoWhat do you think students do all day? I went from working as a programmer to going to university because I wanted to. I've found the world of university far more taxing and difficult than I ever found working. Many, many people on my course dropped out in the first year. Over half! I really do feel like it's 'hard-nosed', as you say. Not only that, but I feel like it's not even uncommon. Some people have suggested, and it might be true, that this is related to studying STEM subjects at uni, with a much easier sense of right or wrong. However, anecdotally, I know many people who are spending many many late nights and long weeks working on art or writing reports in other subjects as well. In universities, you are encouraged to take work home, to practically be working all the time. Leisure time of course exists, but fully expect to feel or be made to feel guilty for taking that friday evening off to enjoy yourself, even far from any important deadline. This isn't to say that you're wrong, but "one day, you get an A. And that grade MEANS something. And after four years, the students walk out into the wide world and kick ass up and down the street." seems like a pretty apt description of the way higher education works. I haven't seen anybody just cruising through life getting good grades in university in the way one might at high school, because unlike high school you literally don't get handed the majority of the learning required. You actually have to put in the hours for success, right now.
- wpasc 8y agoI believe HN has both right and left leaning individuals, but I wonder if most people would condemn the practice of professors being ousted from schools for daring to challenge their students' "safe space" notions and microagressing them? This is not an isolated event and universities skew heavily in one direction politically. Is it universally agreeable that the end of healthy debate in college is a really, really bad thing?
- SantalBlush 8y agoIt's been my belief that many people get offended by opposing viewpoints because their beliefs--while perhaps correct--weren't firmly grounded in much evidence. A well formulated counterpoint forces us to refine our argument (or abandon it), and most people just don't seem very interested in doing that.
- mpweiher 8y ago“He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that. His reasons may be good, and no one may have been able to refute them. But if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side, if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no ground for preferring either opinion... Nor is it enough that he should hear the opinions of adversaries from his own teachers, presented as they state them, and accompanied by what they offer as refutations. He must be able to hear them from persons who actually believe them...he must know them in their most plausible and persuasive form.” -- John Stuart Mill
- wtallis 8y agoConfronting controversial topics in the classroom is important, especially for a school of public policy. But I don't think it's good to assume that any debate being suppressed would have been healthy debate. in this particular case, the professor and the university are both being deliberately vague about what debate subjects were deemed to have been handled badly, and what kind of positions the professor advocated or endorsed, if any. With so little information, there's not enough evidence to rule out the possibility that the professor was bringing up important subjects but then fumbling the discussions in a way that gave some students a negative and unhelpful experience.
- TheOperator 8y agoI think there is something to the notion that there should be schools which are inclusive to students who would struggle under teachers like this. I just don't see why that school should be Duke University. I don't understand why the most elite schools seem to be among the most likely to decide that their students need protection from harm. Polarizing teachers seem like they should be right in an elite universities wheelhouse.
- Erik816 8y agoIf you struggle with a teacher who respectfully challenges your views, you don't belong at any college.
- huehehue 8y agoI'd like to agree, but then we'd have an even larger uneducated and willfully ignorant mass. Perhaps we could be more tactful, or find some way of easing people into sensitive discussions. Quarantining those people, enticing as it may seem, will just make things worse.
- tomp 8y agoIs it still "education" if you're just confirming a person's preexisting beliefs? Remember, the guiding principle of science (and pursuit of knowledge in general) is skepticism.
- huehehue 8y agoThat's not what I'm suggesting at all, we shouldn't coddle anyone. I'm advocating for a system that can effectively handle pigheaded people so we don't end up with more anti-vaxxers.
- jfoutz 8y agoI'm sort of up in the air about it. Although you're more likely to change the mind of someone at university than anywhere else in the world, you're never going to change the mind of your professor. They've invested years if not decades in their opinions. I think pulling out the dirtiest, most underhanded rhetorical tricks is fair game in college. It's up to me to pick apart the nonsense. (Thanks philosophy!) I also think it's completely reasonable to say up front, these topics are off limits - for no reason whatsoever. It's hard to get a 17 year old to say, no discussion of X. Another aspect is, the classic victorian phrase, "you have the advantage of me". Some key word or phrase to indicate, i'm not prepared to deal with this, and you can't hold it against me. Not just can't, but will be held in contempt by every person participating in the conversation if you press the issue. It requires subtlety, taste and discretion. I don't think an arbitrary set of rules can actually capture the subtlety required. Can tact be a standard?
- elamje 8y agoThis commentary is a subset of what is happening in the world. Free speech is not under attack as an alarmist might conclude, but is rather under review. Unfortunately , the review is being held and judged by mainstream media which tends to go the way that the author describes Sanford. At the end of the day, our social norms will be pulled towards the most sensitive people rather than the intellectually challenging ones.
- neilv 8y agoI haven't figured out a good opinion on the controversies of trigger warnings and safe spaces. It might be a brief pendulum swing. I think that we all could stand to show more sensitivity to everyone else, and I don't know whether that would be enough. But I've never met any 12th-grader who is so knowledgeable and wise that frosh year at a proper college shouldn't shake up their developing mind, and challenge much of what they thought they knew -- about the world, themselves, and even thinking itself. (College is not a place to party and practice your whiteboarding theatre until you can get a FAANG job, knowing not much more than you did in high school.) Whether it's in the humanities, social sciences, quantum physics, or even functional programming: if students are not surprised and uncomfortable at times, I'd think they're not learning enough.
- labster 8y agoPart of the thing about the safe space movement at universities is that it's happening at just about the same time that universities have just about completed their transition from educational institutions into corporations. If you think about them as any other corporation, they are just doing their best to keep the customers coming. Would you want to pay money to faculty who challenges the consumer's assumptions, or do you want to build a strong lifestyle brand, which in turn drives future "donations", sports income. Every other corporation is giving us information tailored to our desires, so why would a university want to risk the corporate enterprise on antagonistic professors with differing opinions? That just devalues the brand. Note that the OP has been a "professor" at Duke for 20 years, but has essentially no job security. He's basically an independent contractor in the gig economy. That's kinda common in the community college level, but it looks like it's finally made its way to the elite schools too. We used to have secretaries for professors, but now the colleges have secretaries for the deputy assistant administrators. So to me the trigger warning, safe space culture wars are only a symptom of the problem that our universities have become mirrors of the large corporations.
- neilv 8y agoI don't know about the particular case in the article, but I thought the tradition of tenure was partly to permit professors to pursue currently-unpopular ideas, like perhaps this person was doing at Duke. I didn't know a prominent university would have a non-tenure-track professor teaching for 20 years. What is that hefty tuition paying for? I've talked with some tenured professors who hire adjuncts, and they feel bad about the situation, but those individual professors had no say over it. Perhaps if entire faculties came together and petitioned, at least at the wealthier places, universities might spring for all instructors being tenure-track professors (assisted by grad students).
- rland 8y agoI have read probably 4 or 5 of these articles, written by professors/teachers, claiming to have been punished for their speech. 2 common threads about them. The first is that they rarely discuss specifics about what positions or what opinions got them censured. The second is that the comments section is typically full of drive by commenters who aren't responding to the content of the post in particular but to the idea that a professor might be censured for [their view]. I think its fair to say that everyone believes that universities ought to be places where it's possible to explore radical ideas. But sometimes, things are just wrong. If a professor teaches a load of students that the Sun orbits the earth, they're going to be censured, and nobody would be surprised. I can't say anything to respond to this particular post, because I have no idea what this guy in particular is even being censured for -- whether the idea itself has value enough to discuss. The fact that some students believe so is certainly not a high enough standard.
- garmaine 8y agoWhy should specifics of what is said matter if the point is free speech?
- rland 8y agoFree speech is necessary, but not sufficient. It isn't simply that the speech has to be free; it also must be worth exploring. To use my analogy, the Earth-centered model is free speech, but it isn't worth much, because it is wrong.
- Ntrails 8y ago> Earth-centered model is free speech, but it isn't worth much, because it is wrong. And yet in schools around the world people are taught that electricity flows from positive to negative, and everyone is happy. xD (slightly disingenuous, but I'd say wrong and not useful are merely correlated rather than 1-1 linked)
- gumby 8y ago
- Aloha 8y ago"As to academic freedom, Professor Charney’s complaint argues that the criticisms of his classroom performance, and thus the decision not to renew his appointment, really had to do with his “radical free speech” approach, in which he forced his students to discuss controversial viewpoints on hotly contested issues of politics and public policy. The panel finds no evidence, however, that anyone at Sanford objected to Professor Charney’s raising of any particular issue, or expression of any particular viewpoint, in his classroom. Indeed, Professor Charney stressed that he intentionally introduces provocative views on all sides of issues and that students would have difficulty determining his personal views. The issue was not what Professor Charney discussed but how he handled discussion of difficult and emotional issues with and among students. Professor Charney perhaps could have made more effort to learn to manage classroom discussion of difficult topics in a manner that would have left all students feeling fully heard and respected."[1] In short, not everyone felt warm and fuzzy when discussing difficult issues - something which I believe to be a near impossibility - not when we live in a world where even presenting a dissenting opinion can be considered offensive -- indeed letting the discussion go where it may, would probably make many people feel uncomfortable. [1] https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qrGaqKye_5hJxEAFYmTrzNYLJeXVlnF7/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qrGaqKye_5hJxEAFYmTrzNYLJeX...
- logjammin 8y agoIt's hard to say for sure on this quote alone. On one hand, I could read it the way you did -- I have my own qualms about what often feels like an arms race about getting offended. On the other hand, though, if I'm trying to be calm about this, I could also read it as pretty mundane bureaucrat-ese for "look, this guy was just being an asshole and we don't want him back". Being the free speech guy / gal in charge of a classroom is a risky endeavor and requires the same amount of talent, calm, tact, neutrality, and wit that, say, a standup comic needs when trying to get people to laugh at a tough subject, and I can easily imagine an earnest but less than talented (in this specific way) educator losing their cool in a room full of jacked up and emotional undergrads debating Trump, abortion, I/P, pick your hot button issue. "Could've made students feel more fully heard" could indeed be "sensitive undergrads whining", but it could also be "guy proclaims himself mischievous contrarian view-challenger but reveals himself to be pedantic narcissist / unhinged / aggressive / insert pretty unattractive trait or behavior here". I see that emphasis on how he handled it and I wonder if if isn't the latter. Commanding a room is a difficult thing with way more art and god-given ability involved than people think, especially when the emotion in said room is running high. There's a reason diplomacy, marriage counseling, and the like aren't easy. Like I said, who knows from the quote, but I've been in both kinds of room as a student. Neither would surprise me and I think we'd all do well to consider both possibilities.
- mmmBacon 8y agoThis is the world we live in now. Doesn’t matter if you actually harmed someone. What matters now is whether someone feels you as doing harm. The word of the person who perceives harm is taken as fact and the accused has little to no recourse or defense.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lowdose 8y agoIs this is a symptom of a very developed society in which abundance of wealth creates the possibility where certain individuals will always find a way to feel victimized?
- krageon 8y ago> Doesn’t matter if you actually harmed someone. > What matters now is whether someone feels you as doing harm Can you briefly explain what you believe the differences between those statements are, as I can very easily imagine a position where I would say that those are arguably the same.
- apta 8y agoI'm not OP, but an example is people feeling "triggered" because they don't like what they're hearing, even if it is the truth and backed up by evidence, and they in return cannot back up their view.
- rdtsc 8y ago> Unfortunately, a growing number of university students equate being made uncomfortable in the classroom with being “harmed.” University is a place of learning as they say. An important thing to learn is how to exert power over those around you. One way of doing that is to leverage the irrationality of large institutions in your favor. Large institutions, including whole countries, buy into different ideologies at different times. And so, to exert power over someone you just have to denounce them as not falling in line with the current ideology. You can then bet on the system "crushing" them so to speak without you lifting a finger. In a communist totalitarian country, if you didn't like your neighbor's haircut, just tell the police they engaged in propaganda against the workers' party, and there is a good change their livelihood could get considerably worse. It just takes one phone call. Want ruin someone's life in US today? Call child protective services and tell them you saw their kids playing unsupervised outside and you're "very worried" and hang up. Then watch them get house and work visits for quite a while. Going back to the article at hand, I suspect there is a similar process happening in some of these cases. For every student actually feeling harmed by a professor like this, there is a student who realizes they can claim they are harmed, and then they can both eliminate the professor, and gain social standing points for "standing up" and "fighting against the system". Two birds with one stone so to speak. That is indeed a very important and valuable lesson to learn. > Last April, I was informed that my contract would expire in one year—and was then assigned to teach two classes of the very same required Sanford course, one in the fall and one this spring, in which I supposedly had a tendency to harm students. If Sanford actually believed their own rhetoric, they would be guilty of knowingly endangering their students. This is beautiful. Pure ideology at work. You can tell because of the ridiculous contradiction at play. Everyone in the game knows that the professor didn't harm anyone, otherwise why the heck would they ask him to teach another class. But they also know that they will suffer a similar fate if they don't fall in line.
- charliebrownau 8y agoOne of the issues with the GLOBAL SOCIALIST MARKIST LEFT is now they no longer have anything in common with the RIGHT WING They no longer support:- Treat people as inviduals Everyone has free speech Everyone has free expression Everyone can critise all regions and belifs Vocal critisms isnt "harm" Heck these are the same group of people claim its a females RIGHT to kill an unborn baby and its the right of every western country to allow global immigration from every fucking nation Yet its the same group that false claims and push's the equality hoax . while being the companies and people that fund fake news
- yarg 8y agoMore and more this safe space bullshit is infiltrating the former bastions of free-thought. It is a disturbing trend where it no longer matters if someone can convey a counter argument to any given point of view, the mere presence of a point of view contrary to the modern anti-liberal left world view - even if purely rhetorical - breaches the safe space contract and justifies censuring or even punishment. It will only lead to a greater chilling effect as time goes on, and whereas great universities once taught the ability to critically consider the available information, they are rapidly reaching the point where they only serve to push people towards grossly limited and increasingly dogmatic world views. In an increasingly polarised society it terrifies me that both of the the left and the right seem to consider liberty an enemy.
- esyir 8y agoOn the free speech front, I'll note that at the moment, the right seems to care more about it than the left, or at least it pays more respect to its dressings. Whether this changes once the power balance tips is a whole different story.
- pjc50 8y agoFrom where I see it the right has leapt to the defence of certain kinds of speech, but absolutely not all speech, and certainly not all kinds of employer-speech interaction. I don't think the right is really going to stand up for "you can't fire your employees for their public statements", is it? In fact, the right is more likely to be in favour of "employers should be able to fire their employees at any time for any reason", so why is the highly specific case of university professors (and no other educators) different? The right is also more likely to conflate free speech with some kind of "unchallenge privilege" - the idea that people using their speech to complain about your speech is somehow bad. The giveaway for this is people going on television and writing in the national newspapers to complain about how they are "silenced". If they were really silenced I wouldn't be hearing about it through those channels but through some kind of samizdat.
- marcoperaza 8y ago
- ggm 8y agoThis "trigger warning" and "harm" thing.. I've been out of tertiary education too long to understand it. I'm sure it's not only American but it feels like an American crafted problem taken worldwide. Future leaders in minority communities need to be able to defend themselves but learning to do it by firing academics on negative feedback feels like the wrong lesson. I'd rather they did it in a real ballot box, not in academia. The guy may be a complete dick, but I don't get the feeling he's David Duke or John Birch society stooge.
- ptah 8y agominorities should not have to waste energy defending themselves, when others use that energy to further themselves instead
- SolaceQuantum 8y ago"I'd rather they did it in a real ballot box, not in academia" You mentioned you're not american so please allow me as an american to educate you on how minorities and voting work. Minorities are systematically targeted in america to prevent voting. America, in fact, has a long and fairly recent history of attempting to prevent minories from voting or to make their votes literally worth less than others. The electoral college, for example, is a system that allows rural white communities to by and large have votes that are worth more than the votes of urbanites, which are often more diverse and have more people of color. Areas with significant people of color voting populations have historically had laws in place or new policies being pushed to make it more difficult to vote (see: voting is on a weekday, voting booths are hard to get to and lines are long due to lack of voting booth number, the disallowance of mail in voting or the outright throwing away of mail in votes.) That is to say, this sentiment is all well and nice, and I agree with this sentiment. But in America it is unrealistic to say minorities should stop using what benefits they can and should continue operating under systems that devalue them.
- stonogo 8y agoThis whining conveniently omits his demotion ten years ago, as well as the fact that a faculty vote was held on the matter. Exercising free speech is one thing. Challenging student views is fine. Using a required course as a trolling arena and being a pain in the ass to work with is, huge surprise, a great way not to get your contract renewed.
- richardhod 8y agoDo you have a source? This sounds useful
- cf141q5325 8y ago>Using a required course as a trolling arena This is actually the most important point of this case in my opinion. Dont screw over students by going off topic in mandatory courses. Stick to the course material, your ego is not more important then putting an entire course of students at a disadvantage. Mandatory courses are mandatory for a reason, its so the students learn the basic foundation of their field of study. You dont get academic freedom on your mandatory lectures, as your day doesnt consist of only mandatory lectures. Create an elective course on the topic if its interessting to you. Profs who do this are the perfect example for why tenure is a problematic idea. Getting rid of a Professor who is sabotaging required courses is a monstrous task and generations of students have to suffer under the ego of one person.
- ausbah 8y agoI feel like I'm always a bit disappointed whenever I see discussion around topics like this. Whenever cases like this are brought up, I think they're usually presented in a very one sided manner that is intent or pushing a single perspective or agenda of sorts. So the subsequent discussion around the topic becomes equally distorted. I am not saying the professor in this article wasnt wrongly fired, but I wish there was a bit more discretion in the comments because this article was a.) a multi party account written by one person and b.) written to push a perspective that puts him in a positive light. I think there may be more to the story here.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 8y agoWelcome to the Heckler's Veto becoming the norm of higher education if not corporate life. This is the method of choice in almost all instances of issues surrounding race, religion, and orientation, now. Look at Intersectionality[1] for clues to why the situation has gotten out of hand. In essence there are so many levels of grievance. In effect, unless you are part of the class of people your right to discuss or raise an issue is called into question and by default denied. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality
- ordinaryperson 8y agoWhile I agree and sympathize with Professor Charney's on one level, on another the real problem (IMHO) is the lack of legit opportunities in Higher Ed. In the corporate world people are fired or let go for silly reasons or non-reasons all the time: that's at-will employment. But for people in most fields they just find another job and move on; the problem here is there aren't many opportunities to teach at a prestigious university, at least not at anything resembling a living wage. Years ago I was working for this one tech company who terminated a guy in his late 50s who'd been there over 30 years. I ran into him crying in the bathroom -- he asked me at his age, what was he going to do? Two wrongs don't make a right -- but making people unfireable (tenure) doesn't seem fair either. Hope Professor Charney finds another gig but I don't know if it's the outrage he presents it as here.
- Beldin 8y agoThe article is not about his contract not being renewed, but about the reason for that lack of renewal. Saying someone who consistently rates amongst your top performers as having unsatisfactory performance is clearly false. Which means that not only did Duke cave in to an amount of complaints far outshone by praise, it also tried to hide this fact (circumventing its own bylaws).
- ordinaryperson 8y agoYep. I'm not disputing the injustice (at least, as his essay lays it out -- some comments on the article tell a different story of him being difficult to work with). But contracts not being renewed -- happens all the time in the "real" world. My point is just: good people don't get their contracts renewed all the time, often for silly or dumb reasons, and it's not some cosmic injustice because most people find another job. The fact that finding one of these jobs is so difficult should not change the basic risk/reward stature of at-will employment.
- imgabe 8y agoWho is raising these kids to believe that hearing something they disagree is equivalent to "harm"? It must be my filter bubble, but I only ever hear about people decrying this practice and never anyone supporting it. Where is it coming from?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoDid you read the article? From what I understand there’s not enough evidence to make this conclusion.
- imgabe 8y agoTo make what conclusion? That some students believe that they are being harmed? That language exactly is what is used in the article. Why do you think it's not supported?
- Ragnarork 8y agoBecause you're stating that the "harm" that was reported is just "hearing something they disagree with" when there's no evidence hinting at what the "harm" actually was.
- imgabe 8y agoWhat do we suppose it was? That he physically assaulted the students? That he was verbally abusive and screamed at and belittled them? Neither of those are consistent with him being a highly regarded professor for 20 years with overwhelmingly positive student reviews. Neither of those would make any sense in the context of one of the reviews from a student in the same class quoted in the article: > As a woman of color, I write to bring attention to an aspect of Charney’s teaching that will be as missed as much as it is needed in today’s political climate…The climate at Duke reflects the polarization of the country at large. Conversations are halted before they can even begin. Instead of listening, instead of understanding or trying to understand, people on both sides are combative and dismissive…Charney taught us how to have those conversations, how to navigate race relations, how to empathize. So, there is ample evidence suggesting that the students who complained merely heard something they found disagreeable and construed that as harm. Other definitions of harm are not consistent with the evidence available.
- Causality1 8y agoAcademia is full of cowards. It has been for decades, probably since private companies overtook them as the center of the research world back in the 70s.
- bsder 8y agoThis is what happens when you don't have tenure. At this point, the only solution is to start demanding that all teachers at universities either have tenure or don't teach.
- GrryDucape 8y agoI wonder if Mike Nifong's prodigy was one of the complaining students. Keep your head up Professor, there are plenty of us in your corner! Let's petition Coach K to speak up on your behalf and see if the school has the balls to fire him too...
- charliebrownau 8y agoCan Western Tax funded Schools and Univierites last past 2025-2030 when they have been turn into LEFT WING MARXIST brainwashing camps and most of these "woke" and "progressive" campus's don't respect state and federal laws Instead run their own illegal "courts" and "investigations" that treat men guity before innocent and ALL women to be belived and when its found out they DID LIE , often the only proof that can prove they lied is video evidence , females face zero accountability for lying about a male student or male teacher Considering the amount of "vegans" and "feminists" that refuse to admit that gender is based off your birth , science, biology and DNA How can we get any scientific breakthrough done in reality, when unis are pushing out Marxist brainwashed entitled wankers in droves
- WesternStar 8y agoI think the way to read the response of the Faculty Comittee is this. He was an adjunct he hasn't earned the protection of academic freedom. He gets to keep his job if he fulfills what we feel like is necessary to be a member of our community. We feel like he's a negative experience for students and we don't think his addition is worthwhile. I'm all for not indulging the carebears but the message "You were allowed to stick around after you failed because we thought we could use you and felt sorry for you. But we don't like you and some of our students don't like you. Go find another job." That is not a carebear handling of things if he wanted to have academic freedom he had a right to get tenure. He's an adjunct he needs to act like it. This is very much like Augusta where the don't have formal rules some things are simply frowned upon and its your responsibility to understand the culture of the club. It was his responsibility to understand the culture of the faculty in his tenuous position. That is a very important lesson for him and for students by his example.
- etrevino 8y agoHe wasn't an adjunct. Some universities (or schools within universities) do five year contracts now as an alternative approach to tenure.
- richardhod 8y agoPrecisely this. I find it appalling that an associate professor was not given tenure, because that is normally a tenured position, particularly since he'd been there 20 years
- krull10 8y agoI think he was an Associate Professor of the Practice -- it's not a tenured position, but more a longer-term teaching-type appointment. It generally offers more job security and benefits than an adjunct might receive, but at many universities such a position is not (and was never) on a tenure-track line.
- WesternStar 8y agoI think this is a difference of degree but not kind. Duke still has tenured faculty. He is clearly not afforded the rights of tenured faculty. For this matter functionally he's an adjunct because that's how they ruled on him.
- vincent-toups 8y ago"I got fired therefor the sky is falling."
- rnernento 8y agoThere seems to be a tremendous opportunity in higher education right now. Costs are out of control, administrative positions like this will eventually result in lower quality education and likely less successful graduates. An institute that truly values and teaches critical thinking while minimizing costs could change the world.
- puranjay 8y agoA friend was let go from a teaching job at a prestigious college in my city because she was - in the words of the administration - harsh and hostile to students who had blatantly plagiarised their papers. I guess when education becomes a business, you have to place the customers - the students - satisfaction over, you know, the education
- matthewmcg 8y agoTo me, a much more disturbing trend in higher education is allowing wealthy donors to set the ideological agendas of universities. The James G. Martin Center, despite its “.Center “domain name is a far-right think tank funded by the ultra conservative Pope family of North Carolina. You may know them from their bankrolling of the disenfranchisement and gerrymandering efforts in that state. You always hear from these folks how their ideas are being suppressed etc. But they have a very powerful platform.
- dank79430 8y agoNot sure if ratemyprofessor is used as heavily nowadays but this seems relevant: http://www.ratemyprofessors.com/ShowRatings.jsp?tid=605892&showMyProfs=true http://www.ratemyprofessors.com/ShowRatings.jsp?tid=605892&s...
- audace 8y agoMy sister was one of the many students who signed multiple letters of defense. She leans very much to the left end of the ideological spectrum but still had nothing but amazing things to say. What a shame.
- mooreds 8y agoThe issue with treating college like a normal good is that there are positive externalities. So the customer (the student who is paying) doesn't capture all the good that is provided. There's value in having an educated populace and in inculcating common values. That value accrues to society as well as the student. That means that we can't compare paying for college to paying for a normal good, say a car. If there was a way for drivers to give a car poor ratings and that affected the car company negatively, that's great! The market works. But college is about more than just skills transfer, and that's why having student feedback is important but can't trump other considerations. That's also why most universities have some state aid (either direct in terms of cash from the treasury, or indirect in terms of being a non profit). I don't know how to solve this, though.
- SkyBelow 8y ago>say a car. The issue with treating a car like a normal good is that there are positive externalities. Sot he customer (the one buying the car) doesn't capture all the good that is provided. There's value in having electric cars, cars which have better MPG that pollute less, cars with safety features that prevent crashes (even a single vehicle crash in a populated area massively slows down traffic), cars with safety features that protect passengers who weren't the customer, cars that are less likely to injure people who will have to depend on government provided healthcare if injured. I could apply this to a book, a video game, a tv, a computer, a smart phone, an internet connection, a bicycle, clothing, food, and even housing.