27 ms·
Protections Against Fingerprinting and Crypto Mining in Firefox Nightly and Beta
- bluedino 8y agoKind of a shame that I can't browse that site using a VPS on a tier-2 VPS provider (Vultr)
- notyourwork 8y agoCan you elaborate on why you cannot browse that site? From your comment it is not clear to me what the problem is but it reads as if you are trying to blame mozilla.
- bluedino 8y agoMost often I get a 403 forbidden
- LinuxBender 8y agoWorks fine from my VPS. Perhaps set a custom forward/reverse DNS name for your node.
- meruru 8y agoI can access it from Tor.
- mzo123231 8y agoI love all the new features that Firefox has been coming out with. They understand their users perspective.
- syoc 8y agoI really welcome Mozilla's effort in fighting the uphill battle against browser fingerprinting. I am however very interested in the terms of Mozilla's partnership with Disconnect. Are obsoleting their add-on for Firefox out of the good of their hearts?
- groovybits 8y agoIf I'm not mistaken, Firefox's currently built-in Tracking Protection also borrows from the base Disconnect blocking lists. So this would not be the first time they've used them.
- SECProto 8y agoGreat! I look forward to these protections being included by default in the future, as they allude to.
- empath75 8y agoSeems like they're just using a blacklist? Those seem to be able to be gamed pretty trivially.
- rubbingalcohol 8y agoAgreed. Setting up blacklists is just whack-a-mole. I'd be more interested in detection of actual fingerprinting techniques, such as system font enumeration using canvas, or WebGL GPU fingerprinting. It would be technically possible to detect the creation of WebGL or canvas contexts that aren't actually rendered in the layout and prevent data gathered from those contexts from being sent in any XHR payload. I'm sure that's a lot of work. Maybe it would be better to find the worst offending JS APIs and demand a user consent step similar to webcam or notifications in order for the scripts to run at all.
- drewmol 8y agoI couldn't help but read the headline and think to myself: This is great! I should probably jump right in to this .001 % bucket of Firefox nightly users. Combined this with my >1% OS, custom profile of barebones unsupported, blocked, not installed client technologies and then they'll really never get my fingerprints!
- discreditable 8y agoIf you enable resistFingerprinting, Firefox reports a "standard" user agent. Without that, your Nightly user agent probably makes you trivial to track.
- benmmurphy 8y agoSome sites are using these APIs as a way of providing positive data that the users environment is not a bot. I think if you ban this kind of thing you are going to break some important web apps.
- walrus01 8y agoOne would think that the past 25 years of experience with SMTP RBLs would teach people that using predefined DNS based blacklists (or IP space range blacklists) is indeed a game of whack-a-mole.
- gbrindisi 8y agoI do appreciate the feature! But how feasible would be to limit the amount of info retrievable from the JS layer instead than relying on a black list of domains serving fingerprinters?
- eli 8y agoDepends what sites you’re ok with breaking. Users will blame the browser if it works in chrome but not firefox
- gruez 8y agothats what privacy.resistfingerprinting is for
- capnrefsmmat 8y agoMozilla devs seem to take this into account whenever adding new JS features, at least on their mailing lists. For example, this discussion of a new API for gamepads immediately turned to a discussion of its fingerprinting risks and how they can be mitigated: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/mozilla.dev.platform/75GrJSPHAu0/V3DZcKyxBQAJ https://groups.google.com/d/msg/mozilla.dev.platform/75GrJSP...
- andrepd 8y agoThe www has an API for gamepads. I need a moment.
- mywittyname 8y agoIt seems entirely appropriate for browsers to support input from devices other than keyboard, mouse, and touch screen.
- bzbarsky 8y agoBrowsers run on TVs...
- wongarsu 8y agoYou remember how HTML5 was sold as the replacement for Flash; as a platform perfect for browser games? This is the logical extension of that.
- 2_listerine_pls 8y agoI am not trying to diminishing this post, just want to point out that a great way to increase adoption would be to make a better and simpler-looking UI. A great deal of users prefer Chrome for this reason.
- luckylion 8y ago> The average user doesn't even know about fingerprinting Yet. Give it one or two scandals, maybe involving a heavyweight like Reddit, and users will be aware of what fingerprinting is and why it's not in their interest to have their digital fingerprints taken, analyzed and stored every time they enter the internet equivalent of a grocery store. Give them analogies they can understand and they will feel like they're in a dystopian surveillance state movie, because that's what we're in on the internet.
- 2_listerine_pls 8y agoI care about security, fingerprinting, etc... but most people don't and they don't want to learn about it. They like pretty looking things, pretty looking apps, pretty looking browsers... Apple designs have proven this, there are cheaper products with the similar features yet people want Apple. You would think everybody knows this but Windows still looks like shit. Google has improved their design system a great deal. Logitech realized this and improved its designs a few years ago, now ask them about their sales. Better usability, simplicity and design will increase adoption. It's not an opinion, it's an overlooked fact.
- luckylion 8y ago> I care about security, fingerprinting, etc... but most people don't and they don't want to learn about it. Imho they would care if they knew. They don't know so they don't even know why & what they should learn about it. That's why it needs scandals and good analogies to tell them about it. They won't read "weird" tech blogs, they need the evening news to tell them about it, and to explain it in simple terms. Kind of what Al Gore did back then with global warming: "the planet has a fever". Everybody can understand that. It's not technically correct, but it gets the point across. People don't know what other products are better than Apple's, so they rely on social proof: everybody is buying Apple, so it must be good, so they buy Apple. People are starting to shift away from Facebook because there's a narrative "Russia stole the election by using Facebook". It's wrong, but it gets the point across that Facebook's algorithms aren't transparent, FB has too much data on the users and whoever controls FB wields a powerful weapon. That got people's attention, that's what you need to for any technical issue that the general public should be informed about.
- GeekyBear 8y agoI appreciate it when my browser takes the position that it acts as the user's agent, and not the advertising network's agent.
- bloopernova 8y agoThis attitude from the Mozilla crew has convinced me to try switching from Chrome for a week. (I understand that these latest features aren't yet available in the normal releases)
- CedarMills 8y agoI switched completely to Firefox on my work computer. Don't miss Chrome at all.
- Daniel_sk 8y agoMe too. I am absolutely happy with Firefox after switching about 6 months ago. I don’t miss anything.
- kevingadd 8y agoI think current Firefox has audio/video autoplay controls, and in my experience they're wonderful compared to Chrome's. A one-time popup that lets you easily control it per-site. Already enough to make me prefer it.
- hanniabu 8y agoThoughts on Brave browser?
- spammersharass 8y agoThe only problem that keeps me from entirely supporting Firefox / Mozilla is that they had to be so vitriolic in opposing someone's right to their own opinions and beliefs. The time they got rid of Brendan Eich still leaves a bad taste in my mouth. The irony of calling yourself "free and open".
- daveFNbuck 8y agoThis is very exciting, but it seems it's just building in partial uMatrix functionality. It's really becoming a pain to have so many overlapping tools doing the same thing.
- staticvoidmaine 8y agoI'd like to challenge your attitude on this. Does it not make sense to have your browser handle this out of the box? Personally I'd rather have overlapping functionality for a bit while we work toward a sane browser by default than the alternative which is maintaining some number of extensions each with their own configs etc...
- daveFNbuck 8y agoI agree with you. I'd be very happy if they announced that all uMatrix functionality was being added to the browser. I'd be happy to have overlapping functionality for now if that's the future. My biggest disappointment is that this doesn't do anything new. My secondary disappointment is that this will make my life a little harder when I can't get a website to work. I hope you're right that this means I eventually won't need to install a plugin for uMatrix functionality.
- jefftk 8y ago> In the coming months, we will start testing these protections with small groups of users and will continue to work with Disconnect to improve and expand the set of domains blocked by Firefox. We plan to enable these protections by default for all Firefox users in a future release. Default settings can move the industry in a way that opt-in things like uMatrix generally don't. (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google)
- daveFNbuck 8y agoThat's why I said this is exciting. For normal users it's a big win, and that has much more potential to move the industry.
- muckrakerz 8y agoDoesn't Brave, Brandon Eich's project, already do this? Its nicer to use to.
- malikNF 8y agoI have had mixed results with brave on my phone. Sometimes it blocks adverts sometimes it doesn't.
- alexkavon 8y agoOh you're right. Silly Mozilla adding protections to their browser for their user-base. That's it everyone. Shut down Mozilla and have all the users switch over to Brave. Brandon Eich's got everything covered.
- muckrakerz 8y agoNo one said you couldn't use Mozilla. But this is being treated as news when it has already been done elsewhere. I strongly support your right to use whatever browser you want.
- jefftk 8y ago> In the coming months, we will start testing these protections with small groups of users and will continue to work with Disconnect to improve and expand the set of domains blocked by Firefox. We plan to enable these protections by default for all Firefox users in a future release. While lots of people here already have uMatrix or other blockers running, blocking fingerprinting and cryptomining domains by default would be a big step! (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google.)
- wurst_case 8y agoSince you work on ads, may I ask why you support this? Won't this make most of your features ineffective?
- asdff 8y agoGoogle ads has the engineering to work around this, competitors might not and would therefore loose market share to Google ads. Of course he is supportive, his stock options just improved.
- tialaramex 8y agoIn principle advertising is fine. Telling people that a product exists is useful. "Do you need a hat shaped exactly like a golf ball? At Dave's Golf Ball Hats we sell six sizes!". Targeting this advert to most likely be seen by people who actually had been thinking of buying a hat shaped like sporting equipment is still a good idea too. But an advert that steals from you, or harms you is neither of those things. Google Ads doesn't need those to be profitable. It would suit them if those went away.
- JohnFen 8y ago> Targeting this advert to most likely be seen by people who actually had been thinking of buying a hat shaped like sporting equipment is still a good idea too. Not if that targeting is done using data gathered about me without my consent -- as it almost universally is. Targeting based on context (what sort of website the ad is on, for instance), is fine.
- founderling 8y agoIn collaboration with Disconnect, we have compiled lists of domains that serve fingerprinting and cryptomining scripts. Now in the latest Firefox Nightly and Beta versions, we give users the option to block both kinds of scripts Isn't this something that content blockers like umatrix already excel at? Why put it into the core of Firefox? I would prefer to see Firefox giving more power to extensions. For example, it is still impossible to make an extension that makes a typed in url use https per default. Because it is not possible for an extension to know if a network request stems from the user typing it, using a bookmark or one of the other many ways a browser can be triggered to do a network request. So typing urls in Firefox keeps being dangerous because it will load the url per http by default.
- meruru 8y agoI prefer to have features like this in core so I don't have to give a ton of permissions to a third party. I hope it becomes powerful enough to replace uMatrix.
- founderling 8y agoExtensions are analyzed by the Firefox team: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/AMO/Policy/Reviews#Submission_Guidelines https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/AMO... If the review process is still insecure (That is how I understand you reply) I would prefer them to put their energy into this. Analyzing popular extensions in depth (and giving them some 'in depth analyzed' badge) so you do not have to trust a third party.
- meruru 8y agoI don't know how much I can trust the review process. I believe they have relaxed it a bit recently: https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2017/09/21/review-wait-times-get-shorter/ https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2017/09/21/review-wait-times... >Add-ons built on the WebExtensions API will now be automatically reviewed. This means we will publish add-ons shortly after uploading. Human reviewers will look at these pre-approved add-ons, prioritized on various risk factors that are calculated from the add-on’s codebase and other metadata.
- huhtenberg 8y agoDo I read it correctly that fingerprinting is blocked purely with a script/domain blacklist?
- VWWHFSfQ 8y agohow else would they block it
- IshKebab 8y agoPresent a uniform environment to scripts. For example fingerprinting doesn't work very well on iPhones because they are all so similar. Firefox could pretend to be some sort of "standard" machine. That's definitely not easy but it beats blacklists which are trivial to work around.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoThey already do this in some areas, like returning a fixed list of installed fonts, but fixing every possibility of fingerprinting is extraordinary hard since there are so many ways to pull in some data. At some point it light actually hurt the user experience.
- mikro2nd 8y agoI don't much like the notion of farming out my "cryptomining blocker" to some unknown-to-me third party. There are a (small) number of sites that do cryptomining after asking for an opt-in permission (e.g. bit.tube). It seems to me that this is an interesting exploration of new, alternate funding models than serving ads, and I, for one, like to (sometimes) support these. I'd hate to see them land up in a blocklist I don't have some degree of control over.
- mcsmash 8y agoThis. The internet desperately needs to progress beyond an advertisement driven business model. Disallowing these scripts seems a little heavy handed. Perhaps the addition of a "requestComputeResources" method to the browser's api would give a way to throttle them instead of outright banning them.
- VWWHFSfQ 8y agoNobody would use that API if they can just do it anyway without the users consent
- endorphone 8y agoThey make it optional. To be real, though, somewhere close to 0% (rounded to the third decimal place) of users would agree to grossly inefficient cryptomining in the browser. As a web funding model it is terrible and is almost always akin to malware. It certainly costs the user much more in electricity costs than it will ever benefit web publishers.
- bodyloss 8y agoAnd as a global ecological cost, it's pretty huge.
- SilasX 8y ago>They make it optional. Mozilla? Optional protection? Don't trigger my memories. They also made it optional to block unsigned extensions, which you could turn off if you wanted to tweak one to fix a bug because it wasn't being maintained fast enough. Like, if you believed in the whole Open Source/tinkering philosophy, or something, which Mozilla may or may not care about. Then, they started disallowing it in 2016. And they turned off key remapping too.
- charlesdaniels 8y agoI agree with the general sentiment in the comments that this is good -- fingerprinting in particular is something browser vendors should be trying to combat. I am concerned about the approach however; a simple blacklist of fingerprinting scripts may be insufficient, in that non-blocked scripts can still access the data that is used to accomplish fingerprinting. Personally, I would like to see more security around the data that is used for fingerprinting, such as user agent, screen size, window size, loaded plugins, and so on. If this type of information was either protected with permissions, or if bogus values were provided to non-user-whitelisted sites, then it would be far harder to fingerprint users, as there would be less identifiable information to go off of. A less aggressive approach might be to have some kind of notification to the user if a website is accessing many API calls that are commonly associated with fingerprinting. Maybe a site that just wants to know window size is fine, since it might want to render something or select a certain layout, but if a site wants to know a wide variety of different information all at once, that would be a red flag that could be signaled to the user in some way.
- jacekm 8y ago> like to see more security around the data that is used for fingerprinting, such as user agent I think this is already available, just not enabled by default. In about:config one need to set privacy.resistFingerprinting to true. (be aware however that this setting causes problems with google captcha - the number of challenges that you will need to solve will drastically increase)
- proxygeek 8y ago> this setting causes problems with google captcha - the number of challenges that you will need to solve will drastically increase No kidding. I'm talking about ~30-40 clicks (1 click per task in the captcha grid)
- pinko 8y agoWhy can't they just allow the user to whitelist recaptcha?
- Eli_P 8y agoRight decision to make a step towards a user and protect their market. Preventing fingerprinting is interesting and non-trivial by itself. It's impossible to implement with just a plugin. One day I found that navigator.getGamepads() did rat out my gamepad in Chrome while using private mode, I twitted Google, they didn't answer. Who knows what else is exposed. I didn't know Firefox had privacy.resistFingerprinting.reduceTimerPrecision.jitter option, that's cool, but what about requestAnimationFrame()? Games wouldn't work without it. Not to mention spawning workers and passing values between them; delays while using things like shaders and gpu.js; decoding various formats like audio and measuring time, etc. Anyone tried to block videos on news sites? They are unstoppable, I can watch vids like with everything red in uBlock Origin. I think Mozilla could make a contest for breaking their fingerprint resistance, before they are ready to merge their privacy features from Nightly to master branch.
- jlrubin 8y agoFeels anti-competitive to have defaults to block mining while not having default enabled advert blocking. I'm much happier for a site to mine on their tab while I'm watching a video than to show me 2 minutes of advertisements every 10 minutes. On mobile in particular, where video ads end up eating a large chunk of my data costs.
- jakubp 8y agoYou are happier to have your resources stolen and not be aware of it (it's invisible, you can't see what's happening and react - right?) than to be shown an annoying thing which is very much in your awareness? I don't know, I'd rather know someone is harming me silently and have the means to stop it by default. The things that are shown in front of me, I can handle them...
- jlrubin 8y agoFirefox already has tools to throttle tabs which are abusive CPU-load wise, which seems sufficient in this case. And it's unclear such resources are being 'stolen' if it's stated in the site ToS. Cryptocurrency mining is a lot less deleterious than ads. Mining doesn't need to track your behavior, it doesn't generate misleading native content, and it doesn't distract you from what you're trying to do. Sign me up! disclaimer: I was one of the founders of Tidbit, https://www.eff.org/cases/rubin-v-new-jersey-tidbit https://www.eff.org/cases/rubin-v-new-jersey-tidbit, the first(?) crypto mining ad replacer.
- thekyle 8y ago> “we do not believe Tidbit was created for the purpose of invading privacy.” I don't see how a cryptocurrency miner was ever going to invade anyones privacy so this seems like a weird choice of words.
- kevingrahl 8y ago> And it’s unclear such resources are being ‘stolen’ if it’s stated in the sites ToS. Unless I, as a user, explicitly consented to crypto mining, no such thing should be allowed to take place. Same thing goes for auto playing videos.
- anthony_doan 8y agoNice. I've been using add-ons that protect from canvas finger printing but those are super laggy and slow firefox down.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 8y agoThis endless war could be solved with a single meeting with the 3 major adtech companies. All browsers have to do is share a single advertiser ID and have it reset by the user whenever they want. No more cookies, pixel syncs, or fingerprinting and all the related countermeasures. This is the exact mechanism used by mobile apps right now so it's already well-tested and proven to work.
- AgentME 8y ago"Solving" fingerprinting by fingerprinting ourselves seems like it might miss the point for a lot of people.
- manigandham 8y agoMissing the point is the cause of all this mess.
- AgentME 8y agoIf you care about fingerprinting because you care about privacy and limiting companies' ability to profile you, then adopting an advertiser id is giving up completely.
- fwip 8y agoWhy would advertisers stop using the existing, better methods?
- manigandham 8y agoAn Advertiser ID is the best method, especially because it can be looked up by multiple companies and is user controlled. Unlike what people seem to think, adtech has been designed from the start for anonymity. The persistent ID is needed primarily for ad frequency and conversion tracking. Eventually identity is revealed when someone fills out a form or buys something but that's not necessary at the top of the funnel.
- muxator 8y agoI recently enabled privacy.resistFingerprinting in about:config (which basically is the configuration switch toggled by the UI described in this blog post). Everything went fine, until I noticed WhatsApp web becomes unusable, because it does not generate the initial QR code for establishing the session (to be fair, it flickers, which seems worse, as it smells of an active countermeasure on WhatsApp/Facebook part). While I did I not have yet the time do dig deep into the specific technical reason WhatsApp may have to expose such a maddening behavior, I am inclined to think that this is more a policy choice. If so, it's troublesome. We collectively as users arrived to the point of willingly give up the keys of our online communication to a few megacompanies. It's their infrastructure and their product, so they are in power of steering it in whatever direction it wants. I see this as something that will increasingly become a political problem. As tech versed person, I see the responsibility for not doing enough about it.
- bl4ckneon 8y agoAny way to get the list of these domains to put into something network wide like pihole?
- gradstudent 8y agoI've never understood why the user-agent string gives out so much system-specific information. Why not return less information, such as only the browser make and version?
- feedbeef 8y agoI agree that User-Agent is suspiciously leaky, but it's microscopic compared to JavaScript. [1] It's unfortunate that browsers are privacy-insane by default. Luckily, with a bit of effort, most browsers [2] allow you to mitigate this with plugins (e.g. User-Agent switcher, Cookie/Referrer controller, and JS/Adblocker). Pi-Hole [3] can help too. Mozilla should be commended for trying to improve the situation. 1. https://panopticlick.eff.org/ https://panopticlick.eff.org/ 2. Chrome's days are numbered: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18973477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18973477 3. https://pi-hole.net/ https://pi-hole.net/
- Smithalicious 8y agoI don't like this reaction to crypto mining scripts. I won't argue that a lot of crypto mining scripts out there are blatantly abusive but I think that as a concept it's a great business model. I wouldn't have a problem using sites that eschewed ads and used crypto mining scripts instead and I would have no reason at all to block them (unlike ads) as long as they're well behaved. I think blocking mining scripts is a step backwards, hindering the adoption of something that could finally be an unobtrusive and ethical replacement for the failing advertisement model.
- Rychard 8y ago> I think blocking mining scripts is a step backwards, hindering the adoption of something that could finally be an unobtrusive and ethical replacement for the failing advertisement model. If the content on a website is just a vehicle for delivering advertisements, I would consider such a business model to be fundamentally flawed. Swapping "delivering advertisements" with "hijacking my processor cycles to mine cryptocurrencies" doesn't exactly offer anything that would convince me to change my mind. I'm more than happy to pay for quality content, but I'd prefer companies to be forthcoming about the cost involved in providing it, rather than turning me or my data into a product that can be sold to the highest bidder.
- Smithalicious 8y agoThat's a fair position to hold but it doesn't scale. It's extremely hard to actually convince people to buy something regardless of how much they like it, doubly so if it's something nonphysical like online content. I would also love to live in a world where I could just deposit some reasonable amount of money every month and have it fairly distributed to pay for all the things I love, but I can see that that's not viable in the real world. Having websites silently use my unused computer resources is a perfectly viable alternative to me in a way that forcing me to stare at things I don't care about is not.
- Rychard 8y agoSure, but tapping the unused power of my high-end desktop PC seems to be far more valuable than doing the same thing to a mobile device with a constrained power profile. How can I be sure I'm not being taken advantage of?
- arisAlexis 8y agoI very much prefer to mine a bit with my browser than watch ads
- sologoub 8y agoThe fingerprinting list includes Stripe, why? https://github.com/mozilla-services/shavar-prod-lists/blob/7eaadac98bc9dcc95ce917eff7bbb21cb71484ec/disconnect-blacklist.json#L9516 https://github.com/mozilla-services/shavar-prod-lists/blob/7...