29 ms·
If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too
- sokoloff 8y agoFTA> Consider an increase in the quality of public services — say, garbage collection, or perhaps in San Francisco the elimination of public urination. ... Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties. Gee, I don't know. Maybe I don't want to live a city that reeks of urine and has garbage all over the place...even if the effect of that is that more people want to come live here as well.
- techterrier 8y agoAh that's fine, all the landowners will be living in NZ compounds with armed guards soon enough.
- jfnixon 8y agoThen don't live in a city that reeks of urine and has garbage all over the place. Cities are ancient relics of a time when human beings had to have their atoms in the presence of each other to communicate rapidly. Don't live in one unless it has the quality of life you can accept. If you keep supporting sub-par cities, they'll never improve.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> Cities are ancient relics of a time when human beings had to have their atoms in the presence of each other to communicate rapidly. You're forgetting the transfer of material possessions and wealth, safety, and employment. It's great that you've found a way to work remote, but that's the not the reality for the majority of people. I also wonder whether 5 million people living in less than a thousand square kilometers is more or less wasteful than 5 million spread out over a billion square kilometers. You'd have to spend a lot more to transfer all the goods everywhere, as well as moving people around.
- jakeinspace 8y agoEarth's surface area is half a billion square kilometers.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoSorry, I was wrong in my orders of magnitude. 100,000 square km then?
- pault 8y agoI believe I once read that at the population density of Tokyo, every human on Earth could fit into the state of Texas. Whether that would be desirable is another question, but I imagine that a lot of our current environmental problems would go away with increased density.
- rootusrootus 8y agoIn the right ballpark but it would be about 4 billion people in Texas, which is roughly half the world's population. On the other hand, at the density of Manila, you could fit the entire population of the planet into Ohio.
- Nasrudith 8y agoYou forget another important factor - infastructure scaling. If communication alone was adequate we would see companies going to disporia models or setting up in unincorporated areas- instead they are paying premiums to concentrate in /expensive/ cities.
- lallysingh 8y agoI think the point is that when some areas push for that, their rents go up, and some people get priced out. Either an equilibrium forms where there's a "pee+garbage rent discount" for an area, or you see migrations across the "smells like pee+garbage" boundary as rents adjust. I suspect it has to do with the sign of the derivative of demand, where the trend is to look for better areas (overall reduction in pee, higher rent) or to look for cheaper rents (more pee).
- BurningFrog 8y agoYeah, but it it's also from a perspective where the only things that matters in the world is housing cost. Sometimes you have to step away from your models and remember they're just models.
- lallysingh 8y agoNo. The models tell us about the real world and behavior. People have a choice: smell pee or have a more distant from stuff/smaller space to live in.
- oflannabhra 8y agoHis point is that any improvement will result in higher rents, as well. The people paying for the "improvements" will be the renters. It's entirely rational that people would put up with public urination if the only other option is "paying" for it to go away (even if they might not be happy with putting up with it).
- ramphastidae 8y agoThe author’s main point seems to be that in a market dominated by landlords in which rents are rising, cities do not have an incentive to improve public services as any improvement in their quality will only benefit landlords through further increases in housing prices. Am I missing something, or wouldn’t higher tax revenues from growing property values easily offset this issue in such a scenario?
- thomasahle 8y agoHigher tax revenues does not offset the problem of increases in housing prices. You may say that housing prices is not a problem, and cities should just lean into it an keep improving public service, but if they are trying to reduce housing prices thst might be counter productive.
- lordalch 8y agoThis is why California's property tax system, in which taxes don't increase until a property is sold, is often cited as a major factor in its housing dilemma.
- timerol 8y agoTo be pedantic, 1978 California Proposition 13 (Prop 13) limits property tax increases to a max of 2% per year. In the decades since, especially in areas with high growth, the overall tax being paid on property has become a tiny percentage of the property value. This tax is reset to a reasonable rate when significant construction or a sale happens.
- georgeecollins 8y agoCan't stress often enough the problem that the unintended consequences of this bill have caused. Most people that voted for it though it would just limit the increase of property taxes on homes. They didn't realize it affected warehouses, factories, etc. It's a mess that has to be changed.
- 8y ago
- jpdus 8y agoThis is a huge problem. Prices and rents are left to "the market", but construction is not at all. Strong rent control should be introduced everywhere and ownership for investment reasons should be massively discouraged (e.g. by strong taxation). On the other hand protection of existing landlords should be reduced to encourage new building. Rent seeking is damaging the economy and the society and only privileged landlords benefit from current conditions. Unfortunately most economists seem to be biased or are probably benefitting themselves, thus there is no concentrated effort to push for better policies.
- hammock 8y agoThis article feels like a strawman to me. Infrastructure improvements are not the cause of SF rents. You just need to walk down any block, or sit on BART (if it's working!) and step in a pile of excrement to prove that. Having lived in a few places I see rent control and legislation like Prop 13 as major contributors. When people cite the average rent in SF, that's based on what's currently on the market. What is not counted is the (much greater) inventory that is currently occupied, with rent-controlled tenants paying far less than market rate. When someone cites "the unaffordability" of rent in order to justify rent control, what you also don't see is the high cost of MOVING that comes with rent control. My SF neighbor had been in her unit since the 90's, paying less than half my rent, and she can't afford to move if she wanted to! If she were to move she'd have to leave the Bay Area. She's trapped. Rent control doesn't improve housing choice in that sense.
- philipov 8y agoDo you think it's more likely that without rent control she would have been forced to move earlier, or that her income would be higher than it is now? Something about this situation seems circular, but your argument doesn't admit to there being a feedback loop involved, which makes me suspicious.
- NotAnEconomist 8y agoI think the implication is that her having been forced to move at the due economic point would have been less coercive than now being trapped into a single location by economic forces -- leaving her freer to seek happiness in other ways, eg, job mobility. Further, that if all the people of a certain class were forced to move, eg baristas could no longer afford to be in the area, it places a strong economic incentive on fixing the actual political problem, which is semi-masked by her current arrangement. I'm not sure I agree, but I think there's an argument to be had that she'd have more freedom to leave a job if she were living somewhere that she were also free to relocate, and that at scale, this economic distortion leads to high friction.
- captainbland 8y agoThis article makes some interesting points, but I do find it strange that they reference George without referencing his famous idea of a land value tax in this context, a proposal which would at the very least put a sizeable dent in the ability of landlords to directly benefit from the increase in value of their land resulting from municipal service improvements while also encouraging better use of property in general. Rent controls could be another alleviating factor. As could indirect competition from subsidised/social housing. I'm not really comfortable with how the article attempts to frame municipal social improvements as something which must implicitly also drive wealth inequality, despite the other potential remedies to this.
- Symmetry 8y agoRent control is good for the people who already have housing who don't see their rents go up, but it's bad for people who might want to move to an area. It's very much a "pull up the ladder behind you" sort of policy and in the case that the article addresses it will tend to weaken coalitions in favor of reducing housing prices for new home buyers/renters and will tend throw currently homeless people under the bus.
- crdoconnor 8y agoIt's bad for people who might want to move to an area of you believe that rent control significantly affects the supply of housing. If you believe that then it might be worth pondering why New York's highest rate of homebuilding occurred when it had its strictest rent controls though. In reality all rent control really does is redistribute some the spoils of rising land values from certain owners to certain renters. This makes some property owners extremely angry but as far as renters and potential renters are concerned it's potentially good or potentially neutral. If you really want to incentivize home building you need to disincentivize land hoarding. That means repealing prop 13 or implementing LVT.
- kortilla 8y agoJust because there was a boom during the time of ham fisted rent control does not mean it was caused by rent control nor does it imply that rent control was even good for it. Have you ever considered how much more housing might have been built if it weren’t for rent control?
- viburnum 8y agoThe author is on the Koch payroll.
- ausbah 8y agoOkay? That doesn't automatically invalid what he is saying.
- aeorgnoieang 8y agoThe Koch's give money to lots of nice people.
- major505 8y agoDon`t know about London or Ny, but I see people complain of high rents in SF area, but they don`t want to fight stupid zoning laws that don`t allow the construction of tall buildings, because it would "disfigure" the city. I say, take the politics out, and let market decide what to do.
- 52-6F-62 8y ago(edit: I don't think it's so simple as that) I think we already know what the market would decide to do. Joni Mitchell sang about it some time ago...
- allengeorge 8y agoPeople do complain about high rents in NY and Toronto, but - and this is a big one - homeowners vote consistently and so politicians listen to them. I would _speculate_ that: 1. renters are more transient, so are less invested in the community 2. most people don’t make the connection between restrictive zoning policies and rent prices 3. It’s politically unpalatable to be shown as “against homeowners”, especially given how much ownership is prized
- mcguire 8y ago"renters are more transient, so are less invested in the community" This is the theory behind the US support for home ownership.
- cletus 8y ago> Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties. Good example of this: residents in the Tenderloin (successfully) fought planting of trees because of gentrification. I can't find the original source but this [1] mentions the opposition. Overall I found this article pretty shallow. For one it ignored recent history where American cities were in decay up until the 1990s. A core problem here is that homeowners gnerally consider rising prices to be good. Thing is, it's only good if you cash out. Take Vancouver where a rundown Victorian might cost you $4m+. You might have bought that for $175,000 in the 90s but that $4m won't help you move to another part of Vancouver (unless you move much further out or move to something much smaller) because everything else is just as expensive. You definitely can't trade up to a nicer area or a bigger house either. Where that gap might've been $50,000, it's now more likely $500k+. Another problem not mentioned is Dutch Disease [2]. I'm firmly of the belief that Australia is pretty much at this point. What people don't realize is that when property prices go up so much this also affects commercial prices and those higher prices are inputs into everything you buy. You still need workers. They need more money. Again, that makes everything you buy more expensive. It seems to converge on a point where there's very little economic activity. One reason I like NYC is that even though prices are generally high there are options for lower-income people. Sure they might not be Manhattan below 96th street (well, probably 125th at this point) but you can still leave much cheaper in the outer boroughs. You'll note that the article said "Manhattan" not "New York". That's not an accident. Compare this to the Bay Area where all the nurses, firefighters, teachers, all the tech company ancillary workers (bus drivers, cafeteria staff, security and so on) are living 2+ hours away because that's all they can afford. Honestly, the Bay Area is just one giant middle finger to the poor. As for solutions, it's not rent control. It's not outlawing investment properties either. People seem to forget that to rent a place to live someone else needs to own it. I actually think the Swiss have done the best of developed countries here. The Swiss tax property speculation punitively (it may have changed but at one point it was 100% capital gains tax if you owned for less than 2 years) and made it somewhat more difficult to simply park money there in property. That's a big problem in NYC, SF, LA, London, Sydney and the other major developed cities: capital is now global so it goes and parks in the form of real estate in major cities. That does absolutely nothing for the city. Things I would be in favour of: - Higher property taxes for nonresidents - Higher property taxes for owners of unoccupied properties - Restrictions on foreign ownership of property - Owning property in NYC makes you a resident of NYC so all your income is taxable by NYS and NYC - Higher capital gains on non-principal residences with a teiered structure like the Swiss where the rate goes down the longer you hold it. - Withholding state and federal taxes on all rent earned that you can only claim back against other US expenses. [1] https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/residents-seek-greener-tenderloin-despite-obstacles/ https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/residents-seek-greener-tende... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease
- golemotron 8y ago> To see why, step back and consider two 19th-century “classical economists” who focused on high rents: David Ricardo and Henry George. Both built models where land is so scarce that the cost of renting land absorbs most of the social surplus. We are not (yet?) at that point, but these models give insight into where today’s most expensive cities are headed. The thing is, land is not scarce. There is an incredible amount of land in the US. When rent is high in a city that is the market telling you that you need to develop new cities. There's no reason why people have to be piled on each other like rats in San Francisco and NYC.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> There's no reason why people have to be piled on each other like rats in San Francisco and NYC. Yes there is. It's where all the economic and social momentum is, not to mention the infrastructure - what steps does someone take to encourage people to flock to a new city that has no infrastructure, no businesses, and no population? What branch of government or enterprising individual builds out the infrastructure for such a project?
- golemotron 8y agoAren't we problem solvers?
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoNo, we evolve society based upon cost / benefit - my argument above is that there is far to great a cost for any benefit. Someone needs to come up with billions in seed money for a high risk potential payoff in centuries?
- golemotron 8y agoCheck out Austin, TX. The trick is finding something happening organically like that and then growing with it.
- robbyt 8y agoCan anybody explain to me why NIMBY is the common explanation for high rent in SF, but in other cities with high rent have tons of development? There's tons of development in NYC, London, but prices are higher than ever. To me, NIMBY-hating seems to benefit the land developer far more than the renter.
- xxpor 8y agoNYC does not have a ton of construction going on, on a rate basis. They permitted fewer units per existing unit than SF and LA did last year.
- astazangasta 8y agoCalifornians like to pretend Prop 13 never happened, because homeowners don't want to pay property taxes. The alternative is to blame a lack of housing stock.
- et2o 8y agoThere is development in NYC but there could be exponentially more except for the very strong NIMBY movement here. Most of the new development is occuring in Long Island City and Downtown Brooklyn, where there isn't as much organized resistance from old rich people. Chicago built multiples of NYC in terms of buildings over 40 stories in the past decade. NYC has at least equal demand (probably far greater) for tall buildings, yet much of the most expensive neighborhoods in Manhattan are filled with four story buildings.
- 0xB31B1B 8y agoYou need to re evaluate your priors WRT “london, nyc are building a lot of housing”. The rate of housing supply growth in both of those cities is near historic lows and below the rate needed to support natural population growth (residents having kids, kids moving to their own place), and your reference frame for judgement is likely comparing to 2008-2013 where there was little construction anywhere due to the financial crises. At a broad level, housing prices rise because the rate of office space growth/job growth exceeds the rate of housing supply growth. All of the cities you have listed have created far more jobs than housing units in the past 25 years, and office supply growth is probably most of the construction you perceive. Tokyo is the best example of a city that has balanced job growth with residential supply, and it is one of the most affordable mega cities.
- nautilus12 8y agoFirst things first. There are entire buildings in NY and SF just sitting empty because foreign investors use it for money laundering and long term investment. This HAS to be made illegal, people need these homes. I am even a staunch libertarian and I think it should be regulated to buy homes and just let them sit empty. Does anyone know of any movements in goverment or elsewhere to combat this?
- harryh 8y agoThis point of view only makes sense if there is a strong limit on the number of homes that can be built. This is not the case. Both SF & NY can easily build many many more homes simply by building up. The fact that they, for the most part, aren't doing so is a much much much bigger problem than a few empty homes here and there (as a % it's still a very very small number).
- nautilus12 8y agoI think that if houses could be built more quickly to satisfy both the investment crowd as well as consumers then this would happen because those who benefiet from selling houses would make more money...
- chairmanwow 8y agoThis generates pressure, driving up prices by constricting housing supply sure, but what is preventing SF from constructing lots and lots of new buildings? If there is pressure to increase the amount of available housing, then the government of SF has a Civic responsibility to create an environment where the housing supply can increase. Full stop. Property speculation will always take place.
- nautilus12 8y agoBecause...there is a housing shortage. The definition of a housing shortage is that houses cannot be produced fast enough for people to consume them. Assuming that the supply is what it is, if a large percentage of that supply is being used for investment, then people can't live in them. You have to assume that the economic machine is doing everything it can to increase the supply because then those who benefiet from selling expensive house can _make more money_....
- Causality1 8y agoHuman beings did not evolve to live in a population density of sixty thousand people per square mile. The fact urbanization is increasing even while larger and larger chunks of the economy become location-agnostic as they move online is insane.
- lazyasciiart 8y agoHuman beings didn't evolve to be online either.
- harryh 8y agoHumans didn't wear manufactured clothing or have access to antibiotics for the vast majority if our existence either. Things change.
- anonuser123456 8y agoHumans evolved to be highly adaptable.
- Symmetry 8y agoHumans evolved to live in hunter-gatherer bands that were functionally anarchies, guided by a consensus established under the influence of respected leaders. If a consensus couldn't be reached the band split. Given all the changes we've made to our living situation going from 6,000/mile^2 to 60,000/mile^2 isn't really a big issue. If you want to live in the countryside nobody is stopping you but many of us actually enjoy living in cities.
- legitster 8y agoSo much time oxygen is burned trying to get San Franciscans to change their ways. Why don't businesses shop around for cities more? Make it in the city's incentive to solve these problems? Why does San Francisco deserve a monopoly on high paying tech jobs? It is pretty clear that nothing is getting done because no one is worried about the big businesses moving away?
- kortilla 8y agoTech jobs have little to do with SFs housing problem, tech is just a convenient scapegoat. In the 80s the blame was finance.
- umeshunni 8y agoMeanwhile, every time there's a proposal to increase density and build more housing, the local NIMBYs show up and protest. My neighborhood association just sent us this today: https://m.imgur.com/gallery/TvX3679 https://m.imgur.com/gallery/TvX3679
- rayiner 8y agoSan Francisco sounds like such a hellscape. Apparently, most of the city is zoned with a 40-foot height limit: https://qpho.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5843aebefa7517e39d3b4bd6fc1f6a99.webp https://qpho.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5843aebefa7517e39d3b4.... That's about the same as the height limit in our neighborhood in exurban Maryland.
- kradroy 8y agoThe buildings might get 2 stories taller! At least they chose a reasonable time for the meeting. I don't know what to do in SF other than trying another round of electing supervisors at large. The way the "supervisorial courtesy" works in the city turns neighborhoods into inviolable fiefdoms. I can influence my supervisor, but my district isn't going to be able to solve the various urban decay problems on its own.
- bduerst 8y ago
- Necromant2005 8y agoRent control as any other control tend to more control. I may say unpopular opinion, but if you can't afford to life in SF - fk SF and the valley and move to the place witch fits you more. Look at amount of angel investors in the valley, their amount is decreasing year to year. People are leaving SF/valley for a better places for better costs/proposition value. It's a general economical factor. All those will eventually, led to describing popularity/population of the area and decreasing rent as result. When a tech giant will leave sunny California, all those NotInMyBackyard will be happy to get a new block next to their place in order to get a job.
- UncleMeat 8y agoIf everybody who can't afford to live in the area moves then we won't have people staffing grocery stores or cooking in restaurants or teaching kindergarten.
- egypturnash 8y agoWelcome to Galt's Gulch, where everyone is just too important to do any of the real work!
- imgabe 8y agoWell golly, I guess billionaires will just have to bag their own damn groceries or maybe work on building more housing so the help can have a place to live too
- bthrn 8y agoThat would in turn make the area less attractive to live in, and some of the wealthy people who want to have groceries would consider living elsewhere. It's not black and white like that but in general this is how markets are supposed to work (in theory).
- redisman 8y agoWhat really happens is they get a really expensive organic grocery store that can afford to pay the employees because of the margins.
- linuxftw 8y ago> By the same token, the incentives are skewed when it comes to the cost of problems. Say air pollution or homelessness gets worse. You might think that would degrade the quality of life in a city. But don’t leap to that conclusion too quickly: To the extent land is truly scarce, the main effect would be a decline in rents and real estate prices. Landowners would be worse off, but the typical city resident might find that the cheaper cost of living offsets the deterioration in conditions. There's a seemingly endless legion of morons moving to these mega-cities that can't afford to live there. I don't know what their ambitions are, but it's obviously unsustainable. Fortunately, I think CA and NY are going to tax themselves out of existence in the next generation or so. Everything is cyclical, and I believe these cities are anomalies reaching end of life.
- reidjs 8y agoThose “morons” are moving there because there are more opportunities to earn money than in their hometown.
- linuxftw 8y agoAnd then complain about how they don't make enough money (aka, the rent is too high) and the place is nasty? A simple cost/benefit analysis shows that living in SF or NYC is a losing proposition for most.
- goobynight 8y agoIt's only a losing proposition for those that are borderline retarded and think that driving Lyft or bartending is worth it in the city. Who cares though? They opted to grind it out and provide services to rich people and middle class engineers while making some landlord rich. More power to them if they enjoy that. Once you're clearing SF costs by $50k+ per year, it could start to make sense, right? I would only move to the bay for $150k+ and that's the desperate low end. Probably more like $170k is the minimum to have it make sense vs the alternatives available in 2019.
- throwawaysea 8y ago
- johnrob 8y agoI’m still waiting to hear a good explanation for why expensive housing is desirable but expensive food/water is not.
- lmm 8y agoIt's good to have an economy in which really good meals that cost 100x or 1000x as much as a normal, good-enough meal are available to those who want them. Likewise it's good to have an economy in which really good houses (which in practice means houses in particular locations) are available to those who want them.
- Atheros 8y agoOP said "expensive" but you switched to "good location".
- dredmorbius 8y agoHousing (or rather, real estate) is an asset, a durable store of wealth. Food and water are consumables. Not durable, not wealth stores. There's a great deal that hinges off real estate, especially in finance. https://web.archive.org/web/20190115035057/https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/eDscpi6Kg7L https://web.archive.org/web/20190115035057/https://plus.goog... (And no, I'm not saying that high housing prices are good, but explaining the dynamic which drives them.)
- johnrob 8y agoBut there are certainly ways a subset of the population could profit from increasing food prices too. The question is a moral one.
- dredmorbius 8y agoThe ultimate question to me is how the common weal benefits. A question for which in part the problem is in not having a good measure. Certainly not GDP or mean income, though measures of net happiness or well-being exist. But individual advantage is a false measure.
- crazygringo 8y agoThis article contains an central economic fallacy. > Take the example of San Francisco; with nicer streets, even more people might want to move there. That would push up rents by an amount roughly equal to the value created — putting the gains from the higher quality of life into the pockets of landowners. ... The political economy problem now should be obvious: Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties. This is equivalent to saying, why would anyone want a Starbucks to open in their neighborhood when the value of the Starbucks is captured mainly by Starbucks shareholders? (Assume, for the sake of example, you like Starbucks, otherwise replace with whatever you like.) The answer, obviously, is that enough people find it to be a beneficial trade for both parties: people want to spend more money for better coffee. That's the invisible hand of the market that improves the sum of things. Similarly, gentrification is about people wanting to pay higher rent to live in a nicer neighborhood. Yes the landlords get more money... but the tenant gets the nicer neighborhood! (Or closer access to more jobs, or whatever.) That's the whole point. That's free trade. The author tries to claim that "residents just won’t care enough about the quality of life in their city." That couldn't be more wrong. On top of it, the author literally contradicts themself with the earlier line "with nicer streets, even more people might want to move there". You can't have it both ways, sheesh...
- cf141q5325 8y ago>Similarly, gentrification is about people wanting to pay higher rent to live in a nicer neighborhood. Not the same people though. The quote from the article holds true for tenants who cant afford higher rents. Gentrification is generally a processes of displacement. There the old saying, that graffiti tags keep the rent low holds true.
- crazygringo 8y agoWell of course. But that's just how the economy works. Workers whose skills are no longer needed get let go and have to retrain to more productive skills. People who live in a neighborhood that gets too nice for them to afford wind up moving to a neighborhood they can afford. If you argue that neighborhoods shouldn't improve because rents will go up, you're basically arguing against economic progress in general. It's the same as saying a longer-lasting higher-quality product shouldn't be released because it will cost more than the lower-quality one.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoIt may be a dream but I hope that a tech like Hyperloop could expand the range of a reasonable commute much loke the introduction of the automobile did in decades past. Being able to live in Utah but work in California would do wonders.
- zerogvt 8y agoEverywhere I look I see the same story unfolding and hurting the productive parts of the economy (productive as opposed to rentier ones). Jobs move in a place. Cost of living (largely dominated by rent) is reasonable. Workers move in. Cost of living starts to rise and rises till the point where a lot of the workers actually pay most of their income just to get by. Pockets of them (e.g. married high earning couples and singles that are lucky to have a place) still save a lot but the proportion of people that actually makes no sense to live and work there any more is getting too high. In my eyes this is a highjacking of the productive capitalism by the rentier parts of it and it is demoralizing, unproductive (by definition) and destructive. An apartment does not produce value. It is a mere necessity. The people living there may produce value if they are allowed to. But sinking all their energy and finance in just securing a roof over their head leaves less and less for any productive risk taking. Disclaimer: Living the renting/housing drama in Ireland.
- leetcrew 8y agoI don't know exactly where people get this idea that landlords just sit on their hands and collect money for doing nothing. maybe it's a result of the "divergence of incentives" other posters have mentioned in highly regulated markets. where I live, mortgage payments are significantly less than typical rent for comparable structures, but I am quite happy to pay my landlord the difference for taking the cognitive load of caring for a house of my shoulders. anything goes wrong with the house and I just shoot him an email and his guy fixes it by the end of the week. when we came to see the house for the first time, he was there with his guy scrubbing the floors on his hands and knees. what I'm saying is, maybe an apartment doesn't produce value, but it doesn't maintain itself either.
- apexalpha 8y agoA few days back there was an article here on HN on Amsterdam's plan to block people from renting out homes that where previously occupied by the owners of the building. I commented [0]: "Good [...] A city of renters is a soulless city; less people are long-term invested and no one really buys into the community they live in. ¨ And this article seems to agree with me on this point. One sentence in particular captures my thought: "The political economy problem now should be obvious: Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties." This article has given me more and better arguments to formulate my stance on this topic. Good post! [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19451013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19451013
- abecedarius 8y agoYou're leaving out a central part of the argument: where housing supply is restricted, a rational renter knows that any improvement in quality of life just raises their rent in balance -- making it no actual improvement. This doesn't hold where housing responds to demand.
- darksaints 8y agoThe thesis behind this editorial is in direct contradiction to your idea. The reason that people become apathetic is only tangentially related to ownership...it is actually about incidence: who benefits from improvements in public services? In a world where landowners successfully push for land scarcity, all benefits of public services go to landowners, regardless of whether or not they are residents, pushing non-landowner residents to apathy towards public service improvement. If you don't restrict land uses, allowing everybody to live in the city without being sucked dry by landowners' economic rents, then both renters and resident-owners will be pushing for public service improvements, while the institutional or non-resident owners will be the ones apathetic towards improvements. Renters don't make the city worse, concentrated economic benefits going solely to landowners does that.
- usaar333 8y ago> "The political economy problem now should be obvious: Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties." Because even renters want to live in a nice place?
- yonran 8y agoThis matches some of Greg Clark’s descriptions of a preindustrial Malthusian economy in A Farewell to Alms (https://www.amazon.com/Farewell-Arms-Ernest-Hemingway/dp/0684801469 https://www.amazon.com/Farewell-Arms-Ernest-Hemingway/dp/068... or see his lecture https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uYJJlnyDpps https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uYJJlnyDpps). When the population is limited by scarce natural resources and the technology to alleviate the scarcity does not exist (or is forbidden in the case of San Francisco), then virtue is vice and vice is virtue. For example, disease increases mortality, leading to increased average incomes, so he argues that the dirty Europeans had higher average incomes than clean Japanese.
- yonran 8y agoOops. I linked to some other book with a similar name. This is the correct book: https://www.amazon.com/Farewell-Alms-Economic-History-Princeton/dp/0691141282 https://www.amazon.com/Farewell-Alms-Economic-History-Prince...
- mixmastamyk 8y agoAm familiar with George, but hadn't put this together before: > Why exactly would non-landowners press for improvements in their cities? The value of those improvements will be captured mainly by other parties. Always wondered why some folks want the city to be as shitty as possible. First compelling reason I've read.
- rootusrootus 8y agoBut does it really work that way? I.e. the effect may be real enough, but among the non-landowners, who actually considers that the net effect of improving the city would result in them personally paying more to live there?
- mixmastamyk 8y agoSee my cousin comment. Many vocal folks online in the neighborhood, though don't know their numbers are significant or not. (Measure S in Los Angeles was soundly defeated.) In another neighborhood (East LA) new businesses were vandalized allegedly by anti-gentrification groups.
- gowld 8y agoThey don't want the city to be as shitty as possible. They want to be able to get what they can afford. Here's an analogy: Imagine if Apple drove all PC competitors out of the market, fair and square, by making a lovely product that is expensive, to the point and PC makers couldn't sustainably sell low-cost lower-quality PCs. Imagine you can't afford an Apple Mac, but you cold have afford a low-cost lower-quality PC. You'd suffer becuase the world is passing you by and leaving you out. Would you be wrong for opposing Apple's business in any way you can? If you are exlucded from the social contract, you have no obligation to uphold it.
- mixmastamyk 8y ago> They don't want... You haven't read the facebook comments in our neighborhood group, where even the upgrade of a crumbling parking lot or flop house covered in graffiti to a modest apartment building meets howls of protest and "disgust."
- peterwwillis 8y agoThe problem isn't the rent, it's that we're renting. Even if your economy is strong, if the citizens don't have equity, market volatility puts them at significant risk, which then puts your economy at risk. As more and more labor is shifted to cities, more people have to move to cities, which puts more of the economy in a dangerous position when the market can no longer support those people. I think we need to increase people's economic security by increasing home equity, and stabilize the labor market to make it easier to get and keep a job regardless of where they live. This will require other changes, such as methods to encourage businesses to spread to neighboring cities, improvements in transportation, and probably legislative reforms to de-incentivize landowners' ability to destabilize markets.
- abalone 8y ago> But San Francisco is a “not in my backyard” locale where the amount of new construction just isn’t that high, for legal and regulatory reasons. I’m so tired of hearing this. It’s not accurate. It’s a simplistic political slogan that the YIMBY crowd keeps repeating and it’s time to correct it. The SF Chronicle just ran a story on how multiple approved residential construction projects have stalled along the Van Ness corridor, right next to a new hospital. The key reason? Multiple interviews with developers paint a clear picture: Skyrocketing construction costs.[1] [1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Turns-out-SF-s-big-new-hospital-on-Van-Ness-13698405.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Turns-out-SF-s-b...
- jplayer01 8y agoHmmm, the article doesn't go into where the rising construction costs are coming from and it seems incredibly dishonest not to address it. It could just as well be that NIMBYism is leading to legal/regulatory issues which are driving up construction costs. It could be something else entirely, but we can't tell from the article and without that information, there's no way to draw your conclusion that NIMBY isn't the problem.
- abalone 8y agoOr it could be, you know, all the construction happening in the city. But who knows! It’s probably NIMBYs somehow! Definitely not a massive influx of techies in a boom economy, nope, definitely not anything to do with tech.
- jplayer01 8y agoWell, that isn't constructive at all. I don't know why the construction costs are suddenly so high. Do you? Or do you just think you know? Do you actually care or do you just want to further your own views, despite any obvious bias?
- smallgovt 8y agoWhy does the author look at each city as a closed system? If we improve one city's community and rents go up due to increased demand, that necessarily means rents went down somewhere else in the US. So, net-net, landowners didn't necessarily get richer. Furthermore, when the non-upgraded city eventually decides to invest in improving their neighborhood, people will move back, and the system as a whole will equilibrate.
- ilaksh 8y agoI work for a bootstrap startup and my solution for not being able to afford the rent in California has been to just move to Mexico. So far it's been working out great since I have actually been able to save a little bit of money. Only problem is occasionally it smells bad and once every few months the water doesn't work. Which is the problem I am dealing with today.