8 ms·
I lived a few doors down to someone who basically ran an ad hoc AirBnB ... before Airbnb. It was pretty terrible. Parties all the time, trash, they parked an
by duxup 8y ago
I lived a few doors down to someone who basically ran an ad hoc AirBnB ... before Airbnb. It was pretty terrible. Parties all the time, trash, they parked anywhere (in other people's driveways...) because there were likely no long term consequences for doing so, the folks staying there didn't care because why should they?
I was on the association board, it's kinda thankless job as we had to deal with this house.
We got the usual riot act / pushback from the folks operating that short term rental about how the association was terrible and oh man the government and how we just were protecting hotels (like man, I don't have any connection to hotels...). They tried to organize the other folks who rented out their places (traditional long term rentals) to push us off the board, they actually got several to go along with it, but they failed (it wasn't even close, we had a limit on how many units could rent out at once anyway so they never were going to have enough numbers).
In the end it was just a horrible situation to open up what was a hotel, right in the middle of our association / neighborhood. Fortunately the law was on our side and they eventually sold the unit and left.
Local governments are run by the locals and they should get to decide where businesses like that operate and zone and so forth. The idea that Airbnb should just get to be the almighty "disruptor" and land on your neighborhood with no recourse is pretty absurd at face value, especially when the argument is usually about how folks should have some freedom, but what they mean is their freedom, not the communities.
- koboll 8y ago>In the end it was just a horrible situation to open up what was a hotel, right in the middle of our association / neighborhood. By joining a HOA, you've delegated away to the collective the right to dictate to your neighbors what they can and can't do with their own property. In your case, the system worked - because you are in a HOA. If people want to exert that kind of collectivist control over their neighbors, that's the kind of organization they should be buying homes in. But outside of that structure, what gives someone the right to dictate to their neighbors what they can and can't do with their own property? All kinds of small businesses are routinely run out of residential zoned properties. "Renting a room" seems like the kind of small business that's ideal for this situation - it takes no more infrastructure to house a vacation rental than it does to house a longer-term resident. "Hotels" require employees and elevators and truckloads of supplies delivered weekly; vacation rentals have none of that, and so the comparison makes little sense beyond "they are noisy". Leaseholders can also throw parties and be disruptive; there is an existing legal process to deal with noise complaints. This category of complaint seems like a thin veneer around the core of truth that people who sink a colossal chunk of their nest egg and future earnings into one asset are knee-jerk averse to anything perceived as a threat to it.
- Juliate 8y ago> But outside of that structure, what gives someone the right to dictate to their neighbors what they can and can't do with their own property? Ha. Don't come in Europe cities. There _are_ regulations in cities about that. And rightly so.
- friedman23 8y ago> And rightly so. Here come the emotionally and ideologically charged appeals to authority.
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> Here come the emotionally and ideologically charged appeals to authority. Property rights are usually a literal appeal to authority (e.g. a community or a government).
- friedman23 8y ago>Property rights are usually a literal appeal to authority (e.g. a community or a government). You are so hopped up on your ideology that you attributed some argument to my post that I wasn't even making. My post was criticizing the person for not even attempting to make an argument and instead devolving into just saying "you are wrong, I'm right". Anyway, I find it interesting how angry people get about people using their homes as an additional source of income. I guess people just need a scapegoat for every little thing wrong in their lives. Look at some of the horrible anecdotes in this thread, there is someone actually blaming an increase in crime in Miami on Airbnb.
- prklmn 8y agoYour mischaracterization of why people are getting angry is quite funny to me.
- 8y ago
- anoncoward111 8y agoWhat you are describing is precisely the same situation I had when I lived in an apartment building next to a long-term tenant. She simply didn't give a shit about the noise and trash she generated and all of us had to deal with it. The landlord didn't care either. The police told me to deal with the landlord, because the noise wasn't at 3AM and wasn't "an event" like a concert. But her music was loud enough to shake my walls such that pictures fell off of them. The town never returned phone calls. I simply vacated the apartment and told the landlord he would be more than welcome to sue me in court for the remainder of the lease. Strangely, he never did, but I have a feeling that I would have had a hard time defending myself in court. Though it is an unpopular opinion, I now feel that single family homes might be peferable to apartment buildings, if the caveat is that "the town and police will not do anything about anti-social behavior" as it is so rightfully called in the UK.
- duxup 8y agoWe actually limited the % of units that could be rented out in our association as well for the same reason (we actually allowed exceptions based on need (have to move fast and can't sell and so forth), and actually approved those 100% of the time, it just rarely came up). Long term rentals can have problem tenants too, but long term rental owners at least had way more leverage over their rentals than short term (who really in our case didn't give a damn).
- munk-a 8y agoI think one of the differences is that long term rentals can establish a pattern of bad behavior by the tenant, a short term rental may constantly be in a terrible state but no one renter has committed enough repeated offenses to warrant a citation. The correct answer here (and with a lot of modern society) is that sub-contracting is not an out, the owner of the property has ultimate control over who rents from them and can put in the time and effort to vet people even if they're just staying for the weekend, it's just viewed as an unreasonable cost so people ignore it.
- vladgur 8y agoIn most cases, thats not true. Its very straight forward and quick to evict a short term renter for violating terms of the lease(noise violation etc). Whereas its a lengthy and pricey process to evict a long term tenant in many jurisdictions
- freshm087 8y agoThe article is essentially about tax authorities trying to offload their work on AirBnB. Irresponsible owners will not disappear if it happened.
- koboll 8y agoIt's worded very poorly, too, such as "The onus is on hosts, Airbnb argues", as if there's some debate over whether 1099 contractors are responsible for their own taxes. I'm sure local governments would love to collect a big check from Airbnb instead of hunting down thousands of tax-dodgers; but doing local tax collection authorities' work for them isn't exactly Airbnb's responsibility.
- perpetualpatzer 8y ago>doing local tax collection authorities' work for them isn't exactly Airbnb's responsibility. Not by default, sure, but nothing prevents a local government from creating a law that says, "where an organization takes commissions in connection with its marketing and/or or the facilitation of payment for short-term rentals of property within our jurisdiction, the organization is responsible for collecting any occupancy taxes associated with the transaction."[0] [0]https://www.arnoldporter.com/en/perspectives/publications/2018/07/in-wayfair-supreme-court-overturns-quill https://www.arnoldporter.com/en/perspectives/publications/20...
- freshm087 8y agoWell, nothing except other laws prevent law-making institutions from creating any law. But, I think, it's not an argument in itself :-)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Tsubasachan 8y agoAirBNB ain't disrupting shit. Flop houses and illegal hotels have existed before. Silicon Valley doesn't do history ofcourse so they think that it is all new. As you say the laws to destroy them already exist, all it takes is the effort to use it.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't think AirBnB remotely fits the notion of a 'flophouse.' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flophouse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flophouse
- uwuhn 8y agohttps://www.airbnb.com/rooms/23131937 https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/23131937 10 people per room.
- seattle_spring 8y agoAnd listings like that are... what percentage of the total listings? 0.00001%? I bet there are more shared rooms on Craigslist than there are on Airbnb.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt appears to be aimed at students, not homeless people who want to get off the street for one night. As the Wikipedia article I linked states, flophouses were typically rented by transients -- what we generally call "the homeless" these days. The term "flophouse" originated with hobos and propagated out to the larger culture. I was homeless for several years. The prices listed in the thing you linked are comparable to what I sometimes paid for one night for a hotel in Fresno. There are people these days who are without permanent residence who live in hotels. Some definitions of homelessness count them as homeless. What you linked really doesn't fit what I am talking about. I have seen articles about illegal rentals stuffing multiple people into one room in big cities. They usually found them via Craigslits, iirc. Most AirBnB listings are along the lines of the cost of a hotel or more. From what I gather, they wind up being a hotel alternative in most cases, not something dirt cheap with no amenities that a homeless person might rent for a night or two. I blog about homelessness. I still talk to homeless people at times. I've had a college class on homelessness. I'm not uninformed on the topic of homelessness and what homeless people today are doing to get by. AirBnB rentals are not some bog standard coping mechanism for today's homeless, from what I gather.
- praneshp 8y ago> , we had a limit on how many units could rent out at once anyway so they never were going to have enough numbers What does this mean? If I owned a house in your neighborhood and had to move away for work, my options are to sell the house, or get on a waitlist till the number of houses rented out reduces? As someone that's never owned a house, that sounds like a shitty rule that should be disrupted. I'm assuming there is a positive side to that only homeowners can see.
- eropple 8y agoIt certainly sounds like he's talking about a condo association ("unit"), not an HOA, which tend to care about different concerns. Rules like this make it hard for an owner to not be aware of negative impacts that their property is inflicting on their co-owners. You know--the other people involved in the con-dominium. Words are fun and educational, aren't they? So, yes, there is a positive side. Most people have lived in places with absentee landlords. Many people don't want a preponderance of absentee landlord properties in a place where there is such direct impact from doing so; the thinking goes that if you rent out a house across the street from me, they might be annoying, but if you rent out a condo unit above mine, your tenants might flood my apartment because they didn't tell you the toilet had problems. Important difference. If you don't like that, don't buy into a condo association that does it. It is extremely rare for a rental-limit rule to be put in place these days, so in practice you should know going in whether those rules are in place. If by some chance you live in the one in a thousand that does try to put those rules in place today, sell and move on.
- dcosson 8y agoThe "positive side" for the homeowners is pretty obvious - it lets them keep anyone that's not one of them out of the neighborhood. I don't know the specifics of this particular neighborhood, but if it's anything like the vast majority of America, it likely is a very shitty rule that should be disrupted.
- nradov 8y agoHOAs don't block purchases by particular people. There's no need for disruption here.
- dcosson 8y agoI mean, this just sounds to me like a pitch for AirBnB. They managed to solve this exact problem you're complaining about via the rating system and guests being attached to their real identity. The vast majority of AirBnB guests are very respectful and reasonable. As for your tight local control, fuck that. No, you shouldn't get to decide exactly what happens in your neighborhood just because you got there first. You don't own the neighborhood, you own single plot of land, and people who want to buy other plots of land and collectively evolve the neighborhood in new directions should have just as much of a right as you do.
- eropple 8y agoI understand that there is this odd notion that every man is sui generis and all, but you live in a society. You can change the property under the purview of the association. It would be stupid to assert that you cannot. But you must win a vote to do so--and you agree to adhere to the results of association votes by buying into the property and into the association. Such positive tyranny one must endure. Makes my heart break. But you have a way out! You can always choose...to not buy a place with a condo association or HOA. (I didn't. Single-family home. Would recommend!)
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I understand that there is this odd notion that every man is sui generis and all, but you live in a society. I think you mean sui iuris (legally autonomous) not sui generis (a unique case).
- eropple 8y agoYeah, you get me. It's been a while since I had to Latin in anger.
- joe_the_user 8y agoSomeone can change the rules of local associations or someone can just defy the rules along with enough other people that the association becomes powerless. That's the mode of operation of AirBnb, for good and ill.
- rayiner 8y ago> Local governments are run by the locals and they should get to decide where businesses like that operate and zone and so forth. Local governments are the wrong level for those sorts of decisions to be made. You don't have any right to tell your neighbors what to do with their property. Now, it's legitimate for the government to make rules of general application for everyone, but local governments have too much conflict of interest to make these decisions in a globally optimal way. Japan, which has a national zoning law, is the right model. In our system, we'd apply it at the state level.
- duxup 8y agoI like to imagine there is this magic wall between properties where nothing ever crosses over and in that situation we could somehow allow an absolute property rights sort of thing. The catch is that it just doesn't work that way.
- pcwalton 8y agoI mostly agree, but I do think there is a role for local government to play, as local governments tend to have more access to local information. But local government should not have the ability to be exclusionary. In other words, the state should decide how much housing, office, etc. cities must allow to be built, and cities can choose where to put it, as well as establishing reasonable height limits and so forth as long as they actually zone for the amount of building the state has mandated. In theory, this is how the system is supposed to work here in California. We have the statewide Regional Housing Needs Allocation, which is a kind of statewide zoning that sets targets for cities, which can then zone as they want to meet those targets. Unfortunately RHNA is not enforced, and there are too many loopholes that let cities circumvent their legal obligations. The Housing Accountability Act closes some of those loopholes, but not enough. :(
- mullen 8y ago> Japan, which has a national zoning law, is the right model. In our system, we'd apply it at the state level. I agree with you on this, however, Japan regulated AirBNB because renting a room for a short period of time is a pure commercial activity and not allowed in Residential areas.
- Giorgi 8y agoYeah! how dare for normal people to make money! Local governments should rule over them!
- seattle_spring 8y ago> I lived a few doors down to someone who basically ran an ad hoc AirBnB ... before Airbnb. It was pretty terrible. Parties all the time, trash, they parked anywhere (in other people's driveways...) I lived, several times, a few doors down to someone who did all this and didn't run an Airbnb. They're just shitty people, and they're going to be shitty neighbors regardless of Airbnb.
- tschellenbach 8y agoAirBNB can fix that by not allowing people to use AirBNB that are too abusive.
- rfrey 8y agoYour anecdote created a very strange comment string with a lot of comments from people who seem to be strongly defending libertarianism, except for the part about honoring contracts.
- duxup 8y agoSadly a lot of libertarianism seems very ... not pragmatic / thought through. I personally like the idea of a world as simple as many imagine it, but sadly I don't think it is that simple. A great man once said: “People don’t think it be like it is, but it do."