18 ms·
China's e-buses dent oil demand more than electric cars do
- m0zg 8y agoWhat's the advantage compared to a tram or trolley bus? I don't get it.
- VladimirGolovin 8y agoNo need to build and maintain the infrastructure (rail and overhead power lines.) The ability to navigate the road freely -- trolley buses often have trouble circumnavigating badly parked cars in their way, sometimes causing the driver to get out to reattach the "prongs" to the wires. Also, trams are somewhat prone to "tram jams" caused by one faulty streetcar blocking the railway. And they simply cannot get around a badly parked car.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoTrolley buses also have to slow down at intersections to avoid coming unhooked.
- smcl 8y agoOther than the need to maintain rail + power lines, I think these issues are overblown. The badly parked car scenario sounds pretty horrendous in theory - one careless actor causes chaos for an entire city center! In my experience it simply doesn't happen - I think people just know how damaging it could be (and possibly how much trouble they would be in) that they pretty much have to be considerate and self-aware. However I have seen trams broken down temporarily (a couple of times in the last 7 years of taking 2 trips daily) but these get resolved surprisingly quickly with minimal fuss. Additionally I've only seen a Trolley lose its connection a couple of times, and the resolution took about 1 minute. This is of course heavily based on personal experience, if you have experience to the contrary I'd be curious where this is. A friend complained a bit about Trolleys in Wellington needing frequently reconnected, but I don't know how common that is or whether they just had some bad luck
- IshKebab 8y agoYou underestimate how much infrastructure costs.
- TheAdamist 8y agoyou way overestimate people - it happens fairly frequently in philadelphia that the trolleys are blocked by illegally parked cars. Cars also try to beat the trolleys at intersections and cause accidents all the time - which when the trolleys are old 50s/60s solid steel beasts - a modern car does not win that fight.
- eMSF 8y ago>In my experience it simply doesn't happen - I think people just know how damaging it could be (and possibly how much trouble they would be in) that they pretty much have to be considerate and self-aware. That's not really the why, at least not here. The shortcomings of trams (including derailing and the inability to maneuver past stuck or badly parked cars) are handled by a 24h emergency crew dedicated for just that. I think they move on average less than one car per day, but those missions are much more frequent during wintertime. Trams are much more prone to failure than buses.
- m0zg 8y agoStill seems like a trolley bus at least could get out of such a bind with a very small battery that lasts like 3-5 minutes. It could then recharge said battery when it reconnects. That way it won't have to haul ten tons of flammable batteries everywhere it goes.
- mcv 8y agoBuses can go where trams and trolleys can't. Buses are everywhere, even in cities that have trams and trolley buses. So it's important that they too go electric.
- Brakenshire 8y agoTrams are horribly, horribly expensive. You can spend hundreds of millions on a line which could be provided at a tenth of the price by a bus lane and some buses. And the bus lane is more flexible because you can use it as a spine for services branching off at either end.
- austincheney 8y agoThen just imagine if shipping tankers became electrified. The world's 6 largest shipping tankers produce more CO2 than all the world's personal vehicles combined.
- burlesona 8y agoThat’s surprising to me. Do you have any references for that? Why are the ships so emissive?
- a-wu 8y agoI think it’s because once they are in international waters, they use extremely dirty burning bunker fuel.
- saagarjha 8y agoI think it's because they use cheap oil that tends to be really, really dirty when burned.
- Simon_says 8y agoI don't think that could be a full explanation. Perfectly clean burning turns all of the carbon atoms in the fuel into carbon dioxide. [hydrocarbons] + O2 -> CO2 + H2O "Dirtier" burning would result in less CO2 emission.
- manicdee 8y agoThe problem is that you are assuming that what these ships are burning is [hydrocarbons] when it’s much more than just that. There are various impurities including sulphur, which lead to extremely dirty emissions such as SO2. The OP is misinformed with regards to the “6 largest ships” claim and the “CO2” claim — as covered elsewhere in comments on this article.
- imtringued 8y agoThere are worse things in cigarettes than nicotine. In a similar way there are worse things in bunker fuel than hydrocarbons.
- reustle 8y ago"Forget Tesla" is the wrong attitude. We should applaud every win we can get, big or small.
- omarforgotpwd 8y agoThey just put Tesla in the title to get people to click on it
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- twblalock 8y agoThe framing of the article is that oil companies need to be more concerned about the Chinese buses than about Tesla. It's a simple rhetorical device, not a statement that Tesla does not matter.
- hawkice 8y agoI've sometimes been concerned that headline writing is (metaphorically) subcontracted to buzzfeed everywhere, NYT, The Atlantic, Bloomberg, just about everywhere.
- twblalock 8y agoPeople talk about "clickbait" but it's not really new. On a website, or the pages of a paper newspaper, there is a bunch of stuff vying for readers' attention and the headline has always been a way of making stories seem interesting.
- randomsearch 8y agoRecently (thanks to a post on HN) I’ve discovered the Financial Times to be a mature news source that doesn’t generally go in for clickbait.
- trevyn 8y agoReuters as well.
- siculars 8y agoThis is a very good way to think about the price of goods. When supply and demand are in relative equilibrium price remains stable and reflects the cost of production plus some margin for manufacturers. When you trim demand even slightly by a few percent - which EVs in their various forms will inevitably do - what happens to price? Where is the new demand for oil to compensate? Jet fuel? I believe price per unit oil will decline until supply is withdrawn to stabilize at a lower value, which may or may not happen. The total market value for gasoline will shrink.
- jwr 8y agoThe price of oil is unrealistic, because it does not reflect the terrible damage to our planet. In other words, the current price can be so low because we are "borrowing" the planet from our children and grandchildren. We get cheap oil because they will not have a planet to live on. If the price were to include a carbon tax, it would likely be at least ten times higher and we would very quickly get rid of our beloved gas guzzlers.
- crumpets 8y ago>We get cheap oil because they will not have a planet to live on. Yes they will. Hyperbole is unnecessary and harmful when the real projected outcomes are already bad enough. >If the price were to include a carbon tax, it would likely be at least ten times higher and we would very quickly get rid of our beloved gas guzzlers. 10x is highly unlikely. At 450kg of CO2 per barrel and even $50/ton of CO2 offset costs that’s about $25 additional per barrel, which puts it at a lower cost than the 2007 era peaks.
- gibybo 8y ago>If the price were to include a carbon tax, it would likely be at least ten times higher and we would very quickly get rid of our beloved gas guzzlers. Wouldn't you expect a carbon tax to be similar in price to the cost to get the carbon back out of the air? CO2 released per barrel of oil (when converted to various fuels and burned) appears to be around 300-450 kg [1][2], but we can round up to 500 kg to be conservative and make the math easier. The cost to take it back out of the air appears to run between $30-$200/tonne depending on how you do it [3][4][5]. I think it's worth speculating that this cost is likely to drop precipitously as the demand and scale at which we need to do it increases, but we can very conservatively stick with $200/tonne for now. Crude oil is at about $59/barrel today. $200 * 0.5 tonnes = $100. So with the most conservative estimates, it wouldn't quite triple the cost. [1] https://pyrolysium.org/how-much-co2-produced-by-burning-one-barrel-of-oil/ https://pyrolysium.org/how-much-co2-produced-by-burning-one-... [2] http://numero57.net/2008/03/20/carbon-dioxide-emissions-per-barrel-of-crude/ http://numero57.net/2008/03/20/carbon-dioxide-emissions-per-... [3] https://www.c2es.org/document/the-cost-of-u-s-forest-based-carbon-sequestration/ https://www.c2es.org/document/the-cost-of-u-s-forest-based-c... [4] https://cleantechnica.com/2016/01/19/carbon-capture-expensive-physics/ https://cleantechnica.com/2016/01/19/carbon-capture-expensiv... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sequestration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sequestration
- cinquemb 8y agoI think the bigger concern for China in regards to this is slowing the pull on their fx reserves in light of their overall demand [0]. Indonesia and Malaysia are taking the biodiesel approach with decent amount of success at cutting their fx spend [1]. Why China cant pursue something similar to Indonesia and Malaysia probably has to do with their Ag policies/capabilities/climate. [0] https://ycharts.com/indicators/china_oil_consumption https://ycharts.com/indicators/china_oil_consumption [1] https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Markets/Nikkei-Markets/Malaysia-plans-to-start-using-B-10-biodiesel-from-Dec.-1 https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Markets/Nikkei-Markets/Mala...
- est 8y ago> Why China cant pursue something similar China plans to push 100% ethanol fuel at the end of 2020.
- cinquemb 8y agoSource? I see that they had a goal of 10% by volume[0], I'd really like to see the numbers behind how they'll get that, compared to where there are at now on that. I have my doubts on that number or on any serious execution, sounds dead on arrival: "By 2020 China wants all gasoline sold in the country to contain 10% ethanol by volume, which is what the United States currently mandates with its Renewable Fuel Standard. Building an ethanol industry is a necessary first step to building the Chinese bioeconomy, but there's a long way to go. China currently produces about 800 million gallons per year (mgpy) of ethanol, with about 500 mgpy derived from corn. Based on expected gasoline demand of 45 billion to 50 billion gallons, to meet the 10% ethanol blending rules in 2020, the country would need between 4 billion and 5 billion gallons of ethanol per year. It will be nearly impossible to site, build, and ramp up enough new production capacity to supply demand from domestic production alone by 2020. That's why many industry experts expect the Chinese government to turn to ethanol imports to fill the gap -- and only the American market has enough spare capacity to cash in on the opportunity."[1] [0] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/12/china-plans-nationwide-use-of-ethanol-gasoline-by-2020-state-media-says.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/12/china-plans-nationwide-use-o... [1] https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/05/07/china-is-unlikely-to-meet-its-2020-renewable-fuels.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/05/07/china-is-unlikely-...
- natch 8y agoNow they need to get off coal as the source of much of that electricity. I’m not saying they won’t though... I’m pretty sure they are onboard with both cleaning up their environment, and limiting their CO2 emissions.
- shard972 8y agoWhat makes you confident they are onboard with limiting CO2 emissions when they are currently looking the other way at rising CFC emissions which are far more harmful.
- xiphias2 8y agoIt looks like it's just 18 companies, and the profit is not big enough for China to protect them instead of playing by the rules. CO2 is a much harder case because of the pervasive oil lobby.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI'll keep pointing out that everyone everywhere hates the strings that come attached to oil dependence. That is except for the US neocon establishment and the countries economically dependent on oil cartels. AKA Gulf States, Saudi Arabia and Russia. In ten years the world is going to look a lot different geopolitcially.
- osdiab 8y agoThey’ve done a ton of stuff to limit emissions, from flat out banning coal furnaces in some regions (somewhat prematurely) and halting all construction for future coal plants, investing in mass transit much more than any country on the planet, prioritizing nuclear energy, leading the world on solar, mandating all electric scooter car and bus fleets across the entire society. Chinese (yes, people are very outspoken and critical about environment even in censored media) and foreign press coverage on the sheer scope of environmental reform happening in China right now is well documented and prolific. But it’s a big country, so change like this takes time to see the macro effects. You can see it all playing out on the ground if you go in person, but the air won’t totally clean up until power generation fully transitions - I’d give it a decade to be safe (but ask locals now and they’ll tell you it’s at least gotten better). Meanwhile our president here in the USA is unraveling the EPA and defunding Dept of Energy, even as we’re #1 polluters of the world. I think we are in no position to talk on this one. All it takes to find this is a little time and an open mind.
- Razengan 8y agoExcuse me for this tangent, but when it comes to environmental concerns, why do we still skirt around the largest elephant in the room? Curbing population growth. We have laws against almost every "natural human instinct/desire": X Murder X Rape X Theft, even if you're stealing food when you're starving X Taking shelter in property that you don't own, even if you were freezing to death X In some countries: Being with whom you love So why are we resisting laws against "Making babies whenever you want" and not even discussing them without annoyed dismissals and instant shutdowns? Is it because the people who shape the zeitgeist — First world countries — have yet to experience the horrors of rampant overpopulation? People who vehemently argue against population control, ought to own up to the fact that we should then guarantee access to food, shelter and healthcare for every new human. You shouldn't expound one human right only to continue to prevent everyone from many other rights.
- bendoernberg 8y agoAmong many other points, more than half the laws you mention are terrible. We shouldn't be banning people in need from taking food or shelter when there's an extreme excess of both, or loving who they want.
- twblalock 8y agoBecause population growth is expected to decline over the next century already, and because population is not really the problem anyway. We have the ability to improve the carrying capacity of the earth and we have done so repeatedly over time. Dire predictions of the negative consequences of overpopulation, ever since Malthus, have turned out wrong. The population doomsayers didn't even anticipate the real problem we face today: climate change. Climate change is not caused by overpopulation, but rather by the industrial output of developed countries. These countries, except for China, are not densely populated and have lower rates of population growth than the rest of the world because obtaining contraception is legal and convenient. On top of that, regulating reproduction is a violation of the most basic human freedoms.
- Razengan 8y ago> population is not really the problem anyway. > Dire predictions Those are not only predictions, but existing examples. I invite you to visit the slums of developing/"third-world" countries, or even just see images/videos of them. > regulating reproduction is a violating of the most basic human freedoms. We regulate MANY things that are also basic human freedoms.
- evolve2k 8y agoThis points out a new opportunity. Why stop at China for electric busses (yes they are probably manufacturing them locally)? Cities are seeming increasingly more able to be proactive than countries. Encourage local cities to one by one electrify the bus network and this effect goes global. It’s obvious tangible action that citizens can demand and mayors can visibly deliver. Game for those playing at home, do a search on what make of buses are used in your home city. Search for if that manufacturer is trialing electric buses. Interested to see what you find.
- jonwachob91 8y agoThe City of Orlando has had electric buses since 2017[0] https://www.orlandoweekly.com/Blogs/archives/2017/08/17/orlandos-first-all-electric-lymmo-buses-launch-this-friday https://www.orlandoweekly.com/Blogs/archives/2017/08/17/orla...
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThe opposite is occurring in places like Seattle. The overhead electric trolley lines are coming down as batteries become good enough to support electric buses without the PITA of going off line (electric was already needed for many routes in Seattle because of hills). Electric also makes more sense in Seattle because 70% of its electrify comes from hydro.
- StudentStuff 8y agoWhat route has been de-eletrified? IIRC Seattle made a big push to invest in the overhead catenary system just a few years ago, as the neighborhoods that have overhead catenary wires were in a frenzy over the mere suggestion that they'd be retired. The overhead lines do force King County Metro to avoid changing routes (a boon for local riders), and are 50% faster at getting the bus up to speed after a stop. Short of something wrecking the overhead lines on most of a route, I doubt they'll be retired soon.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYa, I thought they were moving away from it, but it turns out they are improving overhead lines by combining it with battery tech to allow for better performance (less chance of unhooking at greater speeds using batteries to fill in gaps at intersections). See the new first hill street car: https://sdotblog.seattle.gov/2015/05/04/first-hill-street-car-testing-moving-along/ https://sdotblog.seattle.gov/2015/05/04/first-hill-street-ca...
- thewhitetulip 8y agoBy this logic, we should "forget" all the go green initiatives because China (and Africa) are building a "Green Wall" to stop their respective deserts from widening. https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/04/china-great-green-wall-gobi-tengger-desertification/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/04/china-great-gree... I say this is mainly about China because Africa has modified their green wall project and instead of planting billion trees from East coast to West coast, they are helping communities to thrive by planting trees and reviving land. China is crazy in this sense, there is a thick patch of shrubs that now border the Gobi desert and mainland China. By 2030 it'll be the largest manmade plantation on Earth. edit: 66 billion trees planted so far!
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThe trees planted in the Gobi in 2008 are already mostly dead because they couldn’t commit enough water resources to maintain the ones they carelessly selected. As a result, the Beijing dust storms that were gone since 2009 started coming back in 2015. Whenever the Chinese government does something, don’t assume it will be sustainable by default.
- tomnm 8y agoSource?
- ehmish 8y agoIt's mentioned here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-North_Shelter_Forest_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-North_Shelter_Forest_Pro..., but the cited reference to it is in "The Epoch Times", which from what I've seen has quite an ideological bent against china, so I'd take it with a grain of salt
- Flollop 8y agohttps://e360.yale.edu/features/chinas_reforestation_programs_big_success_or_just_an_illusion https://e360.yale.edu/features/chinas_reforestation_programs... Not only that, there are concerns around lack of biodiversity in the trees being planted: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/09/160907125303.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/09/160907125303.h...
- charliebrownau 8y agoMost people don't want an electric supercar We NEED NOW an affordable 2 door electric car that can go 105KM/per hour, for a distance of 80KM on single charge. With the ability to recharge it off solar panels or mains
- milkmiruku 8y agoAs seen on some YouTube channels, the 'SPIM08HP' cell - https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/42-SPIM08HP-3-7V-8AH-LITHIUM-POLYMER-BATTERIES-25C-200A-SUPER-CELLS-24V-36V-48V-/202508210597 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/42-SPIM08HP-3-7V-8AH-LITHIUM-POLY...
- clomond 8y agoNot all that surprising when you consider the utilization % of any typical bus versus car. Given a bus may be driving on at least 1 maybe two shifts, means it is driving around 12-16 hours typically per day. (50-75% utilization). Most cars as personal vehicles(unless they are in a ride hailing service or taxis) will have a typical utilization closer to 2-8% of the time as they drive for maybe 1 or 2 hours a day. I have similarly found many oil "demand models" not using "electric miles traveled" as a key metric and rather using something more simple like "# of vehicles replaced". Utilization is important, but often ignored or not thought about.
- teknologist 8y agoI see a lot of news of these "green" vehicles being used in China but few seem to be questioning where that electricity comes from. Coal power is still a massive thing in China.
- epanchin 8y agoPollution in cities causes huge health issues. Displacing that pollution is a big priority. Centralising electricity generation makes it easier to switch to renewables later on. Also, higher grid usage means more investment. (China is already 24% renewable, about twice the USA.) No-one living in a city is going to question why they’re switching diesel buses to remotely coal generated electricity.
- spongeb00b 8y agoElectric buses seem to be fairly common in UK city centres. I first saw one in London about 4 years ago - it was surreal when walking past a typical red double decker at a bus stop and it just glided away with the faintest whirr. I’m all for buses and taxis turning electric to reduce the diesel fumes in cities.
- tialaramex 8y agoGliding away silently is often a hybrid. London does own electric buses, but mostly it has hybrids (and lots of conventional diesel buses). If you were on the bus its engine probably started a minute later, it's still an improvement, and I assume that environmentally not spewing fumes at bus stops helps a little with local air quality, but it's not usually an electric bus.
- Blackbeard_ 8y agoYeah, right on. To put some numbers behind that it seems only ~1% of London's buses are electric whereas about a third are hybrid. http://content.tfl.gov.uk/bus-fleet-audit-31-march-2018.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/bus-fleet-audit-31-march-2018.pdf
- magduf 8y agoConsidering that most of a city bus's use is at low speed, constantly braking and accelerating from stops, the hybrid should be a huge improvement environmentally; it's the perfect use-case for a hybrid powertrain (where the ICE just runs at constant speed and charges the batteries, known as a serial hybrid vehicle).
- mcv 8y agoAmsterdam also has a number of electric buses, though I'm not sure how many. I'm also glad to see lots of Teslas and Priuses as taxis. Clearly this is the low-hanging fruit for cutting back on fossil fuels: short range city traffic that's in constant use. It also improves the air quality in city centers.
- 8y ago
- known 8y agoDaily emissions of cruise ships same as one million cars https://www.euractiv.com/section/air-pollution/news/daily-emissions-of-cruise-ships-same-as-one-million-cars/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/air-pollution/news/daily-em...
- greatpatton 8y agoNot in term of CO2, but in term of ultra-fine particles, and sulfur emission. Not exactly the same.
- captainredbeard 8y agoIt's worth noting that not all cruise ships use bunker fuel. Disney's cruise lines use diesel.