8 ms·
China's GDP Growth Pace Was Inflated for Nine Years, Study Finds
- wnevets 8y agono not china, no way! It has been no secret that any numbers from china needs to taken with a grain salt.
- rohan1024 8y agoIndian. I am not sure if our GDP numbers are correct either.
- cscurmudgeon 8y agoIf anything, for India it is the other way around due to the massive informal economy and tax avoidance.
- dimmuborgir 8y agoApart from the opposition parties, I could not find a single reputed source that says India's GDP numbers are fudged.
- NTDF9 8y agoIndian numbers could be fudged, but is out in the bare for financial firms, banks and bond holders to examine. And yes, India's GDP is probably higher because of the gigantic informal economy. People are richer than their tax documents make them seem.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoNot surprising at all, the government is uncannily accurate in their prediction (growth will be 6.9% this year, at the end of the year: hey look, we did it!). Kind of like how almost every province usually has a 4.0% unemployment rate. That isn't to say China's GDP hasn't been growing, just that the numbers are always being fudged one way or the other. They used to even fudge the numbers down (growth higher than reported) to prevent the appearance of overheating. It is ironic that Li Keqiang is premiere (#2) but Xi Jinping has decided not to use his index (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Keqiang_index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Keqiang_index) that gets around fudging with more accurate statistics.
- dis-sys 8y ago> It is ironic that Li Keqiang is premiere (#2) but Xi Jinping has decided not to use his index (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Keqiang_index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Keqiang_index) that gets around fudging with more accurate statistics. Li Keqiang Index has three components, electricity consumption, railway cargo volume and bank loans. They all had pretty good growth, e.g. https://www.caixinglobal.com/2018-12-06/china-railway-corp-signals-sustained-growth-ahead-101356386.html https://www.caixinglobal.com/2018-12-06/china-railway-corp-s... https://www.caixinglobal.com/2019-01-30/chart-of-the-day-chinese-electricity-consumption-growth-hits-6-year-high-101376236.html https://www.caixinglobal.com/2019-01-30/chart-of-the-day-chi... People need to be realistic, China's current GDP per capita is lower than world's average, it is an extremely poor country totally under developed. With the largest domestic market and hard working population, how hard will it be to grow at 6-7% to catch up with some in the middle of nowhere countries with $20k USD GDP per capita?
- ksec 8y agoI am not sure why you are downvoted, agree with much of it, sort of disagree with > how hard will it be to grow at 6-7% to catch up with some in the middle of nowhere countries with $20k USD GDP per capita? It seems people are now downvoting comments they don't like. You may not like the above comment, but it is hard to argue against it as they are facts. This to me, is a much bigger problem on HN right now. The quality of discussion ( especially anything to do with China ) is dropping.
- learc83 8y ago>It seems people are now downvoting comments they don't like. This isn't new. It's been part of HN since the beginning. pg said this a decade ago. >I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness. Maybe he or the current mods have changed their minds since then or maybe they haven't, but it's been part of the culture here from the start. >You may not like the above comment, but it is hard to argue against it as they are facts. I didn't personally downvote it, but I don't think people who did are necessarily arguing with facts. Parts of the comment were facts, and parts were conjecture. Downvoting the comment because you disagree with the conjecture seems reasonable to me.
- nodesocket 8y agoChina "inflating" AKA lying about economic numbers is widely known and accepted by US stock market folks and analysts.
- LapaluxToday 8y agoHonestly, is this news? I have always been advised (and believed) that Chinese GDP growth figures were unreliable, consistently matching the desired government goal for growth.
- ddebernardy 8y agoEconomists (e.g. Michael Pettis) were already calling China out for its long history inflated numbers when the 2007-2009 crisis erupted. Perhaps this view might go mainstream with the looming recession?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Perhaps this view might go mainstream with the looming recession? Nobody, including Beijing, took China’s official statistics at face value. What’s novel in this work is the larger-than-expected magnitude of the error.
- ddebernardy 8y agoThe article mentions China overstated its growth by an average of 1.7 percentage points per year since 2008. Best I recollect from back when I was reading Pettis' blog on a regular basis, that figure is actually lower than what he was been suggesting China had been overstating its growth by in the decade prior to 2008. Pettis is about as specialized in China financial markets as you can get, having basically studied and blogging about the stuff exclusively insofar as I'm aware while living and teaching finance there. He has many criticisms of how China is reporting numbers. One in particular is that local officials are expected to meet certain GDP targets. When the numbers don't look like they'll be in, they'll take on debt and build a bridge to nowhere to make their numbers. The point being, from where I'm standing from there doesn't seem to be anything new in the magnitude of the error. (It's great if the article made you privy about how overstated the economy was.)
- vkou 8y agoEconomists have also predicted 5 Chinese recessions, and 4 American ones in the past decade. That the bubble will pop isn't very interesting. When, is.
- cscurmudgeon 8y agoUnfortunately, this is a cultural issue with China. Anyone who has had any involvement with academia or research, where cheating is easily detectable, has known this.
- dang 8y agoPlease keep nationalistic flamebait away from HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix&page=0&query=by:dang%20nationalist https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
- mempko 8y agoI'm sure all countries have been cooking the books.
- myrandomcomment 8y agoIs anyone surprised? The government in China has to manage for image internally to their population. I am not saying this is bad, it is just the trap the current government is in. They have of move to a non export driven economy. The cost of building in kit in China has just climbed. Low end manufacturing has been moving out for years. China still has a wealth gap issue they are trying to manage. This means they have to move to a domestic spending driven economy as fast as they can.
- diminish 8y ago1-2% overstatement of GDP, if that's big news, that will depreciate the Chinese currency and boost the exports more.
- ggm 8y agoThe article states that the provinces have a material reason to inflate. The provincial governments are far stronger than people routinely seem to understand, we're obsessed by the strong statist arguments of 'scary China' and don't think about their internal structure and where strength and weakness lies. I believe Chinese central planners don't like misleading numbers, it makes the five year plan much harder to design. The Chinese technocrats wouldn't like this situation any more than western investment does.
- mc32 8y agoI would decouple the economic and political realities of “the mountains are tall and the emperor far away” from national military might. Vietnam, Russia, Tibet and other neighbors can attest that that one is not like the other.
- ggm 8y agoPossibly, yes. The article I responded to focused on the economy. Do you see signs of Chinese territorial ambition, spratleys aside?
- barry-cotter 8y agoChina’s territorial claims in the South China Sea are ridiculously broad. The nine dash line in particular is insane, extending into the EEZ of six other countries. China claims that entire area, not as its EEZ but as territorial waters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_disputes_in_the_South_China_Sea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_disputes_in_the_So... > The disputes involve both maritime boundaries and islands.[8] There are several disputes, each of which involves a different collection of countries: > The nine-dash line area claimed by the Republic of China, later the People's Republic of China (PRC), which covers most of the South China Sea and overlaps the exclusive economic zone claims of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Vietnam. Maritime boundary along the Vietnamese coast between the PRC, Taiwan, and Vietnam. Maritime boundary north of Borneo between the PRC, Malaysia, Brunei, Philippines, and Taiwan. Islands, reefs, banks and shoals in the South China Sea, including the Paracel Islands, the Pratas Islands, Macclesfield Bank, Scarborough Shoal and the Spratly Islands between the PRC, Taiwan, and Vietnam, and parts of the area also contested by Malaysia and the Philippines. Maritime boundary in the waters north of the Natuna Islands between the PRC, Indonesia and Taiwan[9] Maritime boundary off the coast of Palawan and Luzon between the PRC, the Philippines, and Taiwan. Maritime boundary, land territory, and the islands of Sabah, including Ambalat, between Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines. Maritime boundary and islands in the Luzon Strait between the PRC, the Philippines, and Taiwan.
- longcheng 8y agoGDP is a number. I have relatives in China, and I visit China every year. I would say the average people in China live a better life than average Americans do here, and it's still constantly improving. Then, why don't I go back to China? My kids are getting education here, and they can not catch up back in China.
- resters 8y agoConsider that Fannie and Freddie were allowed not to provide detailed financials to congress for several years in a row preceding the 2008 housing collapse. It's not a matter of "oh wow, a major government fudges numbers", it's "how many major ways in which my government fudges numbers might I not be aware of?"
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Fannie and Freddie were allowed not to submit financials to markets for several years in a row preceding the 2008 housing collapse Source? I’m searching and can’t find one. I also remember reading Fannie & Freddie prospectuses from that time. Each contained extensive financial disclosures.
- resters 8y agoInformation was omitted: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/03/business/dealbook/why-no-punishment-for-financial-executives-fannie-mae-is-case-study.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/03/business/dealbook/why-no-...
- digitaltrees 8y agoThis article doesn’t support your original claim at all.
- cryptonector 8y ago> This article doesn’t support your original claim at all. Could Fannie’s officers really have been accurately disclosing the risks the firm was taking shortly before its sudden collapse? It is here where the case got complicated. While he was chief executive, Mr. Mudd said that subprime mortgages accounted for about 2 percent or less of the mortgages Fannie Mae was insuring. The commission’s case largely rested on the fact that this percentage did not include the insurer’s longstanding programs for low-credit score borrowers, Expanded Approval and MyCommunityMortgage. The theory about the Alt-A loan disclosures was also not that Fannie had not disclosed that it was in the business. It classified a number of its loans as Alt-A, and told investors as much. But it did not disclose that it had instructed lenders not to classify certain other loans as Alt-A, even though they were also supported by low documentation. ... The 2008 crisis definitely involved some sort of fudging or failure to disclose. But it also involved failure to see systemic risks building.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoThe winds of exaggeration blow still. [1] [1] https://foreignpolicy.com/2009/03/10/beijings-gdp-numerology/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2009/03/10/beijings-gdp-numerology...
- crb002 8y agoOne easy way to measure GDP is count their new large truck sales. That number is hard to game.
- coliveira 8y agoAll countries inflate GDP, because there is always a gap of uncertainty about existing economic activity and governments like larger numbers. And since Chinese growth is higher than in other parts of the world, it is normal that the gap be larger, in the range of 1%.
- steve19 8y agoI don't think this is true. Certainly in many countries GDP calculations are transparent. The economists calculating them are bureaucrats who serve the government, not whichever party is currently in power.
- coliveira 8y agoOh, right, the same kind of people who gave AAA status to mortgage based derivatives. You must live in a different world, then.
- Leary 8y agoHow does the study capture the growth in the services sector?
- learc83 8y agoCan we do something about every article remotely ctitical of China being flagged. I'm assuming that's what happened since this article very quickly moved from 1st place to below other articles that are older and have far fewer comments and upvotes. Edit: currently #21 despite more upvotes and comments and being newer than the top 3 articles.
- headsupftw 8y agoIt's actually the opposite. Every comment not critical of China gets downvoted quickly. Proof: comments on this article and other articles critical of China, remotely or overtly.
- learc83 8y agoDownvoting is different from flagging. Articles can't be downvoted only flagged. If you look at the comments in the thread that have been flag killed, they are mostly low quality comments on both sides of the issue. And looking at downvoted comments, there doesn't seem to be much correlation at all between upvotes and whether the comment is critical of China.
- dis-sys 8y ago> they are mostly low quality comments on both sides of the issue. Please have a look at the other reply I made in this thread, when someone mentioned that Li Keqiang Index and argued that it is a better indicator of China's real GDP growth, I listed recent figures to show that if Li Keqiang Index is actually more reliable, there would be higher real GDP growth. My cited numbers are from Caixin, which is considered as a pretty reliable private source. What happened to my reply? My "low quality" comment is downvoted within seconds. I don't think China bashing comments are being treated the same way. Rather than just blindly marking other people's replies as of "low quality", maybe you can share some more details on why my downvoted reply above is of low quality and how can I improve from that. Oh, btw, with high confidence that this reply is going to be downvoted fast.
- 8y ago
- powerapple 8y agoAnd everything is fine.... maybe GDP is not important anyway.
- jerkstate 8y agoIt's especially notable that China has been caught inflating their GDP numbers because their Paris Agreement carbon output was tied directly to carbon per unit GDP, see https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/paris-climate-conference-China-IB.pdf https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/paris-climate-confe...
- known 8y agoI think every country does that
- m0zg 8y agoReminds me very much of the Soviet Union. CPSU could also produce whatever paper numbers they wanted. Whether any of them matched reality was another story entirely. Everyone knows how that ended. That said, I no longer trust the mass media to report something like this accurately either. For all we know someone might be throwing in a narrative to help (or hurt) the ongoing trade negotiations.
- wholien 8y agoEh, it's really actually pretty hard to calculate GDPs. Many countries can't get within 1% due to reasons, so 1.6% per year isn't that big of a difference. China also has interesting accounting systems that actually might under-count the GDP, for example the GDP calculations mostly ignore the GDP of small firms. > Companies with annual revenue below 360k RMB (roughly 53k USD) are exempt from VAT tax and all subsequent taxes. China has more than 65 million (2017 estimate) such micro companies, often single person, or single family (two people). If you multiply the two numbers together, it is up to 3.4 trillion USD per year. Just assuming only 1/4 to 1/2 is achieved, that is a 0.85 to 1.70 trillion USD economy, roughly 7% to 14% of overall Chinese GDP will have to be estimated, and can be potentially massively under reporting. source: https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/aycs6x/chinas_2016_gdp_might_be_overstated_by_16/ei2g6bf/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/aycs6x/chinas_20... - I will probably look this up in the future but can't verify this comment right now. Here's a paper from the National Bureau of Economics Research that suggests that Chinese GDP might be understated: https://www.nber.org/papers/w23323 https://www.nber.org/papers/w23323 - this paper analyzes Chinese GDP by looking at its nighttime light usage. In this vein, I've heard that government actually tries to be conservative with the numbers so as to avoid the overstatement claims, but I have 0 sources on this. For the Brookings paper linked in the post, one big issue with it is that it didn't account for a tax-related change that happened in 2008-09. See this reddit comment for details: https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/aycs6x/chinas_2016_gdp_might_be_overstated_by_16/ehzu2ww/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/aycs6x/chinas_20... - this means that the overstatement is still there, but probably smaller. The author of that reddit comment emailed the authors but hasn't heard back. It does seem like everyone will take the "OMG CHINA FAKES EVERYTHING" at face value as it confirms their biases. I don't want to speak on either side of it, growing up in China we/my parents/friends all make fun of the GDP numbers and call them chicken butt (鸡的屁 sounds like GDP). Maybe the core of the issue is that no one really has transparency so it's really hard to tell for sure, so no one, domestic or foreign, trusts the numbers given by the government. If so, maybe the objective ways of doing analysis, like satellite footage on night time lights, is the way to go (not to say the article I linked is thus 100% the truth). Anyone have other ideas on what indicators, like nighttime lights, can be used here?
- XuMiao 8y ago
- cyphunk 8y agoCould someone explain why this is on HN? I ask because this comes up often on other non-tech topics. Personally I'm happy these topics can be discussed here.
- taobility 8y agoWestern economists have desperate view with China's economy for two decades, and their faces have been slapped for two decades.