11 ms·
A Behind the Scenes Take on Lithium-Ion Battery Prices
- cft 8y agoI bought lithium stocks in 2017 and it has been an investment disaster.
- derp_dee_derp 8y agoI bought lithium stocks in january 2019 and it has been great.
- Scoundreller 8y agoI ate a small stock of lithium and feel okay.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoWhich stocks and why? Lithium is extremely plentiful, IIRC, and my impression is production could be easily ramped up, unlike Cobalt which is mostly from a handful of mines in the DRC.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoWhich leads to another interesting question, why is cobalt (or anything else) heterogeneously distrubuted in the earth’s crust? The answer is probably too long to explore here, but if anyone has a tldr, I’m listening.
- philipkglass 8y agoLargest factor: the abundance of liquid water and associated chemical effects. Second largest factor: the existence of living organisms that also alter the chemical environment. For example, lead sulfide is nigh-insoluble in water, so where water containing dissolved lead meets water containing dissolved sulfide, a concentrated ore body of lead sulfide (galena) can form. Sulfate anions are more common in Earth's natural waters than sulfide anions, but so-called sulfur reducing bacteria convert sulfate into sulfide as part of their respiratory cycle. That's an example of the biological contribution to ore body formation. As an element in Earth's crust, lead is actually rarer than so-called rare earth elements like neodymium. But neodymium's aqueous chemistry doesn't offer such common opportunities for concentration as lead, so in practice useful ore bodies of lead are much more common than those of neodymium. The lack of liquid water on other celestial bodies is why they don't form ore bodies like on Earth. On the Moon and Mercury, for example, one would expect to find no economically exploitable deposits of either lead or neodymium.
- cft 8y agoBit I still thought that the total volume of sales will be bigger, even if they maintain the price per ton. Apparently the price dropped.
- alphakilo 8y agoAlthough the price may be getting lower, I was lucky enough to hear a presentation from the head of Automotive Engineering at the University of Windsor. The professor conveyed that there are many other issues for power storage such as a limited amounts of cobalt and difficulty in retrieving it. I inquired about what is likely to happen as cobalt is a relatively scarce resource if we are looking to use it for powering our world. He said he is sure that they [researchers] will find some substitute, but right now there is none. As the scarcity of other elements in power storage increase, it may drive up the prices, even if the lithium itself can be sourced.
- grecy 8y agoA tweet from Elon a while back said the next-generation of Tesla batteries will contain no Cobalt.
- jfk13 8y agoAnd as we all know, Elon's tweets are the gold standard of reliable forward-looking information. /s
- newnewpdro 8y agoLow cobalt content in their battery design is one of the Tesla industry advantages currently, and as mentioned in another comment here Elon has already said they'll need no cobalt in the near future.
- benj111 8y agoIs that actually a Tesla advantage? Panasonic manufacture the cells, do they not own the ip etc? I suppose its a current Tesla advantage, Panasonic are signing contracts with other manufacturers though, so it isn't really a defensible moat.
- InTheArena 8y agoThe chemistry is actually specified by Tesla, not by Panasonic. It is specific to them. How much of an advantage is it? That remains to be seen, but given the efficiency wins of Tesla over its competitors this year, it seems defensible.
- saidajigumi 8y agoI really love this quote from the end of the article: There is also a legitimate debate about whether or not experience curves inherently capture technological step-changes. Put simply, something that looks like a future breakthrough today might end up simply being another point on the curve, by the time it is developed and engineered into a viable product and brought to market in a decade’s time. Sometimes this is definitely not the case, e.g. the Moore's-law-like curve of network speed improvements[1] tend to occur in steps, related to the need to upgrade both infrastructure and the endpoints to achieve a new speed tier. [1] pick your domain: LAN, WiFi, cellular
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe wireless techs usually have a lot of refinement over time, so that the real-world speed you get for a price is a lot smoother than a step function on revisions. LAN tech is isolated enough that each link upgrades in a step function, but bigger paths are a function of the price of multiple links and also smooth out.
- nkingsy 8y agoNow I'm annoyed that a high quality beefy 1.6kw ebike battery costs $900 shipped.
- Tade0 8y agoHow much kWh does such a battery store?
- nkingsy 8y agosorry should've put kwh not kw. If you ride conservatively that's 80-100 miles on one charge
- driverdan 8y agoThat must be with a small motor (500W or less). I can't find a decent ebike with a 750W+ motor for under $1200.
- xxpor 8y ago750W is the legal limit in the US, so the market for anything over that will be relatively small.
- driverdan 8y agoThat's only partially true. The 750W limit applies to what you call an ebike as a seller, not your ability to sell it. Many companies ignore that law since it's not strictly enforced.
- nkingsy 8y agothat's the price for the battery
- tonyedgecombe 8y ago>$62/kWh by 2030 I seem to remember reading that $100/kWh is the point where electric cars are cheaper to manufacture than traditional ICE cars.
- benj111 8y agoIf that's the case, what manufacturers are actually going to be in a position to take advantage in < 5 years?
- mdorazio 8y agoMost of them. Pretty much all the major OEMs have announced plans for fully electric lines within the next 5 years and have already started developing test vehicles and tooling for EVs. Outside of Tesla, the frontrunners currently are probably Audi (they have an entire e-Tron line that just isn't pushed much in the US), BMW (same with the i line), Nissan, and Chevy. Keep in mind, too, that cheaper batteries doesn't just mean cheaper Teslas, it also means cheaper hybrids which are likely to remain popular for quite some time.
- Scoundreller 8y agoI just want a plug-in plug-in hybrid kit for regular ICE cars. Plug it into a port in your trunk and it takes over all electrical loads (roughly 10-15% of engine load, more when driving slowly), until empty. Maybe it can also pre-A/C the car (are AC compressors electric yet? Other pumps are (coolant, power steering, brake assist and obviously fuel).
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThat's an interesting idea, you could take the load off the alternator to squeeze out a bit more fuel economy.
- benj111 8y agoIts unclear how many of those are anything more than dipping their toes in the water. Theres a lack of product range, and don't forget the scale, these manufacturers are currently producing 1000s of evs, they need to scale to millions. VW seem to sound most serious, aiming for 50 models by 2025, but what do they have now? And don't forget lead times. They will be starting to design those 2025 cars right about now. Are they ready for that?
- 11thEarlOfMar 8y ago"Based on this observation, and our battery demand forecast, we expect the price of an average battery pack to be around $94/kWh by 2024 and $62/kWh by 2030." Would very much like to know the assumptions and factors for the demand forecast. Will manufacturers keep up, or will there be under-supply, either of the batteries or any of the key components? Will the pricing of different battery technologies transpire at markedly different rates?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nightfly 8y agoI really hope hydrogen fuel cells take over at some point.
- sasoon 8y agoThey will not, whole process from water to hydrogen to fuel cell to electricity is very inefficient. You only get 1/3 of input energy back (if you use 100kWh to make hydrogen, you get back from the fuel cell 35kWh)
- DuskStar 8y agoNot to mention hydrogen is a massive pain to store, to transport, and to convert to electricity. Hydrogen fuel cells aren't ever going to happen. [0] Power to weight sucks, energy to weight sucks, and safety sucks among other things. The supposed advantages over electric cars (infrastructure, range, refueling, longevity) don't exist, and at current rates of tech development won't ever exist. But the disadvantages (complexity, hydrogen storage, inefficiency) still do. 0: https://ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-cars-dont-work-part-1 https://ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-ca...
- pmuk 8y agoIt'll be great when these battery cost reductions filter through to home batteries. At the moment a Tesla Powerwall 2.0 costs $6,700 for 13.5 kWh, so $496/kWh, which is doesn't work as a financial investment. We've got a solar installation and so I have been considering getting a battery for either off peak to peak cost arbitration, or capturing excess solar energy for use at night. In the UK a Powerwall costs around £9,000 to £11,000 including additional hardware, taxes and installation. Based on some estimates (see below), at current prices I think you would be lucky to get a third of that back through energy bill savings. If the Powerwall sold at closer to its battery pack cost, it might be worth considering. Off peak to peak arbitration Peak cost of energy (£ per KWh) - £0.1573 Off peak cost of energy (£ per KWh) - £0.0815 Saving per KWh - £0.0758 Powerall 2 - maximum lifetime throughput - non solar uses (KWh) - 37800 [1] Lifetime power bill saving £2,865.62 Solar PV energy capture PV System Size (KWp) - 5.76 Solar irradiation - 986 Annual yield (KWh) - 5679 Annual energy exported to grid - assume 70% - 3976 Annual proportion that could be captured - estimate 50% - 1988 [2] Peak cost of energy (£ per KWh) - £0.1573 Annual saving - £312.66 [3] Warrant Period (years) - 10 Total saving over warranty period - £3,126.57 [1] https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/powerwall/powerwall_2_ac_warranty_europe_1-5_english.pdf https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/pdfs/powerwall/pow... [2] In winter months, all solar energy could be captured, but in summer the panels will produce more than the Powerwall is able to store. [3] Doesn't factory in degradation over the period, which Tesla quotes at 80% capacity after 10 years
- WhitneyLand 8y agoWhat prevents cheap home lithium power? It seems easier for powerwall derivitives to become cheaper than solar because the % total cost of ownership not attributable to batteries is less. For example, it may not require a bunch of people on your roof, maybe less permit or zoning related costs, maybe less electrician labor, etc. Why couldn't a startup with a couple of EE's design something comparable or maybe even something with ease of installation innovations using commodity battery cells? Couldn't they buy cells in small batches online at first, paying notch or two higher than wholesale until they ramp up sales? Not sure how it couldn't start as a garage business for a clever engineer undergraduate and a clever sales/marketing/distribution person. I mean, people are already rolling their own as side projects right (without going into the practicality or safety of that, just in reference to the barriers to entry)?
- fizixer 8y agoYou can buy Samsung INR18650-30Q (top of the line) off aliexpress in bulk for about $3 a piece. It's about 11 Wh. You'd need 90 of these batteries to make a 1kWh pack, costing $270. Obviously this does not include casing, assembly, and BMS (battery management system), but that's an inexpensive (probably 10%) overhead. Buying in "super bulk" and "from alibaba" would probably be even cheaper, and would probably approach $176/kWh. edit: Check out Jehu Garcia on youtube if interested (no affiliation).
- Vintila 8y agoIs there anyway to confirm they are legit Samsung cells? Batteries seem too ripe for counterfeits.
- fizixer 8y agoTwo options: - Sort by orders. If seller has sold the most, probably a reliable seller. - Buy a handful (or samples) first (you can ask seller that you need samples first), and test their capacity (using e.g., a good charger, I have Zanflare C4). The model I mentioned should have 3Ah (or 3000Ah). If confirmed, those are legit cells.
- Scoundreller 8y agoPlus the first order is the least likely to contain bad cells because you’re doing QA.
- fizixer 8y agoCorrection: 3Ah or 3000mAh.
- aidenn0 8y agoInteresting that we are already well below the predicted cost per kWh of one report[1] from 2012 that projected a price of EUR250 in 2020; according to the bnef article that price was crossed between 2016 and 2017. The 2012 article used a 14% rather than 18% reduction per doubling of capacity that the BNEF article is using. 1: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/225025651_Competitive_Cost_Analysis_of_Alternative_Powertrain_Technologies https://www.researchgate.net/publication/225025651_Competiti...
- WhitneyLand 8y agotldr anyone? are there game changing inflection points likely within 5 years or is the key take away prices continue to fall fast?
- AdrianB1 8y agoMy own personal conclusion is that electric car batteries are already at the price of an engine and auxiliary equipment (alternator, turbo, injection pump, gearbox) of an ICE, so the price of small electric cars should be ~ $10,000. We have SUV's that cost $10,000 built by Renault in Europe and $7,500 sedans, so a $10,000 electric city car is possible.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoIt's a fairly short and information-dense article. Just go read it. Solid-state would be a game-changer, but mid- to late-2020s is about when that would come about.
- WhitneyLand 8y ago>>just go read it. Uh...no? - There's nothing wrong with suggesting a tldr/summary post. You hear some here say they'd prefer every article had one. - It's doesn't leach or degrade site comment quality. At least not if common sense is used to ask sparsely, and keep one's contribution to request ratio > 1. - It can provide real benefit to the community. When was the last year one person could absorb the sum of all human knowledge, 17th century, or earlier? I along with plenty of others most often do "just go read" the article here if it seems interesting. Plus a metric crap ton more from other sources. There's just not enough hours in the day. It's humanly impossible to fully read merely the subset of content that seems interesting. None of that withstanding, thank you for adding the one liner sentence about the article in question. No sarcasm. I consider that beneficial in the same spirit, and it was appreciated. The main point is concepts analogous to RTFM may have validity in certain contexts, but I don't believe HN is the best possible fit you could find for them.
- pier25 8y agoSo will lithium batteries be able to scale to over 1 billion cars today in the world and other vehicles (trucks, buses, etc)? What about the homes of almost 8 billion humans? Will we go from peak oil to peak lithium?
- sxates 8y agoWill steel production be able to scale to 1 billion cars? Or Rubber? Leather? Maybe today's production levels don't support the wholesale replacement of every vehicle on the road over night, but there's no shortage of lithium in the world. It's just a matter of the market encouraging greater production, which will ramp up as demand for batteries increases.
- behringer 8y agoWith driverless cars coming our need for everyone to have at least one car will completely go away. I'm guessing we'd be looking at one car per family living in the same town!
- AdrianB1 8y agoIn time, probably yes. But the life span of cars need to increase a lot because the advances in electric engines are minimal (efficiency is already very high), batteries are replaceable and there is no reason to design and build cars for an average lifespan of less than 25 years instead of the current ~ 15. That is a saving not just in money, but also in pollution caused by steel processing, transportation, etc.
- atomical 8y agoAre the batteries being charged in the graphic at the top of the page? Where is it from?