10 ms·
Cancer death rates are falling, five-year survival rates rising
- admiralspoo 8y agoSad caners of the pancreas, lung, liver, esophasgus, stomach and brain are still pretty deadly.
- fizixer 8y agoGreat. But we need to tackle it at multiple levels, specifically prevention and not just treatment. Furthermore, we need to develop a way of sustainable organ and blood availability. The only way I can see this happening is through synthetic/artificial means. What Organovo is doing is a good start, but they still need the matrix from an existing organ. Here is what I see as ideal: - Around the time a baby is born (before or after, or both), some stem cells, DNA samples etc are collected. - We need a tech for storing those samples for decades, not years. Including a tech for "feeding" and growing them in a sustainable manner. - Then we need to have a way to differentiate organs out of them. - And be able to store working organs for decades, not years. - And a tech to artificially grow, maintain, and store blood. - And inject that person's immune system culture into those stored samples and organs on recurring basis. So that they are up-to-date with that person's immune system. That means, if and when a person has organ failure, or is in need of blood, (s)he has the stuff ready from his/her own stash. No dependence on one another. It's crazy and super-moonshot? yes. But it's a very realistic way forward. And it's a holy grail worth working towards.
- koolba 8y agoThis country (USA) can’t even agree to provide free universal vaccinations for children, how would they ever cover something like that for the masses? What you describe sounds like it would cost millions per person.
- b_tterc_p 8y agoThat sounded preposterous to me so I looked it up. I think it leans towards being false. Obamacare seems to require plans to cover them without copay, and if you don’t have health insurance, the CDC provides a free program to get vaccinations for kids. https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/programs/vfc/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/programs/vfc/index.html Bring 18 or under and uninsured is enough to qualify. To your credit, public awareness of this may not be everywhere.
- koolba 8y agoRequiring people to buy something (insurance) and covering the cost only if their income is below a given level is not the same as providing it directly to everyone.
- b_tterc_p 8y agoThat’s not what this says? Either you have insurance and it must be covered or you don’t have insurance and it’s available for free through this program. Income is not a variable here.
- istjohn 8y agoIn my hometown Columbus, Ohio, the county health department will provide free vaccinations if the parent states they are unable to pay anything. I don't know how common that is, but I don't generally consider our county or city governments to be particularly generous.
- credit_guy 8y agoFor your first 2 bullet points, the technology and providers exist already, and it's somewhat of a big business. For my kids, we used ViaCord. The collection of the Umbilical cord blood cost us about $4k per child, and the storage is supposed to work for at least 20 years (most likely they don't claim more because they don't have the history to prove it, not because the cells will somehow denaturate at the 20y point). [1] https://www.viacord.com/why-bank/benefits-of-cord-blood/?gclid=CjwKCAiAkrTjBRAoEiwAXpf9CWZOr5RROnIIvmvChr3xNJ0AlZamaosuDbrGX44CAZS9xqSiYJaMEBoCJu0QAvD_BwE https://www.viacord.com/why-bank/benefits-of-cord-blood/?gcl...
- forgotmypw3 8y ago>prevention and not just treatment. Unfortunately, this conflicts with "the economy". Many of us are getting paid to produce cancer-causing products, such as: * processed foods (most of the things you buy in a supermarket) * most shampoos, cosmetics, soaps, detergents, cleaning products, etc. * paraffin candles * cigarettes and alcohol * components of all these products and the byproducts of their production * not to mention shit done on industrial scale * the air, if you live in a populated area * and so on. If you really want to reduce your and your family's chances of getting cancer, you're doing your research and doing a lot of work to move away from the mainstream (which is still stuck in 1950's level of knowledge) on these habits, but most people are not, and just blindly trust the government and oversight bodies to protect them because it's "easier" and "cheaper" and "they wouldn't allow it to be sold if it was harmful". Years later: Surprise!
- agumonkey 8y agoI'm thinking of ways to start groups of aquaponics to grow local and toxin free. Spending more time in the green is good, eating simple and fresh too. The ~power of mainstream is high, it's not super easy to swim across the flow
- forgotmypw3 8y agoNo, it is not easy at all. And even in educated circles, your opinions will be in the minority, and cognitive dissonance will work against you too. People hate finding out that they're wrong, and nobody wants to admit that they've been poisoning themselves and their family for decades. It's either that or cancer, though...
- agumonkey 8y agoI think it's more fear of doubt than being wrong. I'm sure if you come with a ready made solution they won't resist nearly as much.
- forgotmypw3 8y ago
- ed312 8y agoThat may help in some cases, but cancer specifically represents a broad class of diseases and treatment isn't always that simple. Blood-based cancers and later stages (having spread to multiple parts of the body) become more challenging to treat. Additionally, the disease can mutate even with a patient so you might need different treatments depending on how your disease has changed.
- supermw 8y agoHaving cloned organs ready for transplant won't extend life as much as you think. A lot of this doesn't mean much if you can't replace a faulty circulatory system, which will inevitably cause organs to fail even if they are brand new. Unfortunately, a circulatory system is practically impossible to replace. It would cost tens of millions of dollars and you'd have to already be in great shape to survive the very long recovery time. And then you do all this, only to die eventually, all the same.
- fizixer 8y agoI'm going by the assumption that, aside from genetic reasons, a circulatory system can in principle be kept in good shape through diet and exercise. I think the first step is to focus on things that we don't have a solution for. Having good diet and exercise is a fairly comprehensive solution, no matter how hard it might be to maintain a lifelong strict regimen (as long as you're able to have such a regimen, your chances of the circulatory system going bad are slim to none). In the case of organ failure, we don't even have anything other than reliance on organ availability from others.
- jzl 8y agoThe article goes into this, but reminder that cancer survival rates must be carefully considered as a part of a bigger picture. In short, if cancer patients are surviving on average 5 more years than, say, X years ago, but cancer is at the same time being detected 5 years earlier, then the expected length of life for a cancer patient remains the same. This is well-understood phenomenon in cancer statistics but often glossed over in press pieces and not particularly well understood by the general public.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoDoesn't early detection lead to better odds of beating it? Something has to give...maybe you're out of luck either way?
- astura 8y agoIn some cases, the only thing that detection of non-symptomatic cancer does is turn someone into a cancer patient who's tumor would otherwise never threaten their health or effect mortality. The more cancer you look for the more cancer you find. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-case-against-early-cancer-detection/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-case-against-early-... >What’s clear is that cancers fall into a few general behavior patterns, which Welch and others have compared to animals that must be kept in the barnyard to prevent a deadly rampage. Papillary tumors are like turtles — they move very slowly and never pose an escape risk. They don’t need screening, because they will never cause trouble. Then there are rabbits, which are eager to hop away to other parts of the body, but can be confined if they’re found and fenced. These are the cancers that can be helped by early detection and treatment. Birds, on the other hand, are so flighty and quick that they can’t be confined. Screening makes no difference for bird cancers, because they’re so aggressive that they can’t be detected before they’ve begun their deadly course. >No cancer screening has ever eliminated the majority of cancer deaths. Instead, the best screening can do is reign in the rabbits. Birds remain unstoppable, and they’re the ones responsible for most cancer deaths. This is why, Welch says, three decades of mammography have failed to put a dent in the rate of women presenting with metastatic breast cancer upon their initial diagnosis. Women with breast cancers that behave like birds will almost never be helped by a mammogram, nor will men with the most aggressive prostate cancers be saved by PSA tests.
- darawk 8y agoObligatory reading before reading cancer statistics: https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/08/01/cancer-progress-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/08/01/cancer-progress-much-m...
- glalonde 8y agoThe article links to that very post.
- ed312 8y agoCancer represents a broad class of diseases (like "viral infection" is everything from common cold to HIV). If you or someone you know is diagnosed with cancer, and especially if it is later stage, please seriously consider comprehensive genomic profiling (CGP). CGP can help identify targeted therapies (and often clinical trials) which treat the specific genetic alterations or other factors in your disease. I'd like to shamelessly plug the company I work for, Foundation Medicine (https://www.foundationmedicine.com/ https://www.foundationmedicine.com/) who is a leader in this area. Regardless of who you go with, please do CGP to learn more about your disease and the options you have.
- throwawaymath 8y agoIs there any reason not to do CGP preemptively?
- aaavl2821 8y agoI believe they are sequencing tumor tissue
- yread 8y agoMutations can be divided to germline (~what you inherited, it's part of your normal dna, but it increases likelihood of getting cancer, for example by making dna self repair less effective, think Angelina Jolie) and somatic (random (?) mutations that enable unlimited growth, switch off cell death and so on and are only present in the tumor). There can be multiple mutation groups within a single tumor. Preemptive testing is useful and done for people with history of early cancers in family but obviously can detect only germline mutations. Most of the targeted therapies target somatic mutations. Some hospitals doing genomic testing share their data through AACR GENIE project https://www.aacr.org/Research/Research/Pages/aacr-project-genie.aspx https://www.aacr.org/Research/Research/Pages/aacr-project-ge...
- ed312 8y agoThere is no harm that I am aware of - but it may not be considered necessary depending on the source. For example, some insurance providers will only reimburse after you're at a certain stage. I can tell you that if I or someone I love was diagnosed, I would get CGP immediately. Potentially avoiding a round of chemo that probably wouldn't even work... that's worth it to me.
- Bucephalus355 8y agoMedical statistics is an entire field of study that has multiple disciplines. There are many controversies in this field. Regarding how death rates are calculated, there are controversies in the field regarding how to best calculate from both a math and even a philosophical standpoint. This article, which talks about the famous paper from 2015 that first noted the dramatic rise in suicide, covers the controversy well. Some of the best statisticians and researchers in med stats, who all are competent and mean well, simply cannot agree if the death rate has gone up or down [1]. [1] https://www.thecut.com/2015/11/gender-controversy-over-white-mortality.html https://www.thecut.com/2015/11/gender-controversy-over-white...
- jzl 8y agoAs the old saying goes, "smoking is the leading cause of statistics."
- ph0rque 8y agoWhy have uterine cancer survival rates fallen, anybody know?
- yread 8y agoCould it be because of the HPV vaccinations? That there are fewer more severe cases?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- salex89 8y agoCan someone explain what does the 0.67 prevalence number mean? That can't be 67%?
- kgwgk 8y agoWhat 0.67 number? Are you refering to "The share of people with cancer (even when corrected for ageing) has been slowly increasing in recent decades. Global cancer prevalence has risen from 0.54 percent to 0.64 percent since 1990"? Prevalence is the the share of people who are currently diagnosed with cancer. The link in the first sencence quoted (https://ourworldindata.org/cancer#global-perspective-on-cancer-prevalence https://ourworldindata.org/cancer#global-perspective-on-canc...) gives more info.
- salex89 8y agoYes, sorry. That's what I meant, thanks.
- appleflaxen 8y agoIf you mean the sentence which says: Global cancer prevalence has risen from 0.54 percent to 0.64 percent since 1990 then it 0.64% (or "64 times in ten thousand"); not 64% (or "64 times in one hundred") this is kind of similar to the famous problem of 0.02 cents (which is not 2 cents, but two hundredths of a cent) which gives verizon such difficulties in explaining correctly [1]. 1. http://verizonmath.blogspot.com/2006/12/verizon-doesnt-know-dollars-from-cents.html http://verizonmath.blogspot.com/2006/12/verizon-doesnt-know-...
- martin_a 8y agoCancer really gives me shivers. I can be hit by a car this evening and get killed. I can get a stroke in sleep and not wake up tomorrow morning. I could even be electrocuted by some stupid accident I make while tinkering with electronic components. Somehow all those "types of death" are fine for me. They are accidents, bad luck, whatever. But they all come sudden. Knowing that you are ill and will not get well again and can just "sit around" and wait till you die. That really hits me whenver I think about it. Nevertheless I don't see a doctor regularly to do a checkup. I'm in my 30s, maybe I should start doing that.
- gus_massa 8y agoI don't want to make you more nervous, but there are some car accidents that are not fatal but breaks so many things that you have a loooooong time to recovery with many operations and medical problems (perhaps you loose most of your liver?). I'm not sure if they are predictible fatal after a long time. Some with heart or brain stroke. There are some variants between no stroke and fatal stroke.
- martin_a 8y agoOh, I know, I know. I crashed with my motorcycle and had a concussion on my milt. Didn't think about it first but realized how bad it was, after doctors wouldn't let me go after four days in hospital. There is lots of scary stuff out there, I'm aware of that. Maybe it's also about the "actio = reactio" thing in my head. Crash = you may die or be severly injured. Overweight might lead to strokes, ok. I can grasp all of those concepts and understand them. But cancer can just come out of nowhere and it could kill you, although you did nothing wrong.
- skohan 8y agoYeah it was like that with my dad. He was super fit, didn’t drink, probably worked too much but that was about it as far as vices. But all the same the cancer came and just swallowed him up. We tried everything but it was just the disease was totally indifferent to our efforts. Before that experience I never really got what the big deal with cancer was. But when it clicked that it’s basically your own cells evolving to destroy you: well it’s pretty dark if you think about it.
- leptoniscool 8y ago5 year survival rate is just a single data point. It would be better to also look at 7 year and 10 year survival data. Is this available?
- sandwall 8y agoStage Migration, otherwise known as, "The Will Roger's Phenomenon," is an important consideration. Derived from a joke, "When the Okies left Oklahoma and moved to California, they raised the average intelligence level in both states." When we move members of one set (undiagnosed) into another (diagnosed) it changes the values of both. In other words, if we diagnose people earlier, the entire diagnosed set appears to be living longer. See this classic for more information: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM198506203122504 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM198506203122504
- nabla9 8y agoHow does 5 years survival rate relate to cancer deaths? Do people survive longer with cancer before eventually dying, or are more people cured?
- Tepix 8y agoIf you diagnose the cancer earlier... it will appear as if they live longer.
- sandwall 8y ago100% There's also some debate on what should be considered "cancer." DCIS, is stage 0 breast, but any diagnosis is a very emotional event. https://blogs.plos.org/dnascience/2018/04/12/dont-tell-me-my-dcis-isnt-cancer/ https://blogs.plos.org/dnascience/2018/04/12/dont-tell-me-my...
- skohan 8y agoThere’s no such thing as “cured” with cancer, only remission. In general the goal with Oncology is to help people live longer, and improve quality of life for people with cancer. 5 year survival rates are one broad metric which probably broadly indicates they’re getting better at fighting the disease on those fronts.
- sandwall 8y agoWe're not sure. One interesting study on breast cancer patients receiving radiotherapy, found that local control was obtained but more women were eventually dying from heart failure from being in the radiation field. This essentially offset the gain. This couldn't be seen with 5 year survival rates. Now physicians are focused on protecting the heart and hopefully, eliminating cardiac toxicities. That vignette just shows that 5y survival is a difficult metric and only shows a small piece of the picture. Others have rightly pointed out, stratification of data based on stage would be helpful. Improvement in 5 year survival of stage 4 patients, could be very meaningful. Unfortunately, new treatments are adding months (on average) not years. The best thing we (as a country) did, was wake up to the dangers of smoking. When per capita cancer diagnoses decline and survival rates remain steady (or improve), then we know more people are living longer.
- bigmit37 8y agoI’m more interested in incidents of cancer among younger people. Is it rising or falling?
- agent008t 8y agoSo what should one do today to minimize their early death from cancer risks? Do some kind of a genetic screening? Have periodic (annual?) checks for specific cancers?
- greedo 8y agoAvoid getting too much sun (melanoma); reduce your read meat consumption (colon cancer); don't smoke, or quit if you currently do. Some studies have indicated that grilled meats can also increase the chance of risk. Other than that, pay attention to your body. My colon cancer indicated by bleeding that was not regarded by my GP as more than just a potential hemorrhoid. A year later a thoracic surgeon discovered a 5cm mass. I got lucky...
- thewhitetulip 8y agoI recently researched about cancer and realised that anti oxidants are said to prevent cancer. There was a study done in US, the Boston study or something like that, it said that excess dairy consumption is directly linked to cancer. Green tea, green vegetables and any anti oxidant source prevents cancer.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> Green tea, green vegetables and any anti oxidant source prevents cancer. That doesn't seem to be the case. They seem to have no effect: https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/diet/antioxidants-fact-sheet https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/d... Or can possibly make it worse: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antioxidants-may-make-cancer-worse/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antioxidants-may-... When Dr. Oz is turning on Antioxidants you know there's something there: https://www.doctoroz.com/article/can-antioxidants-cause-cancer https://www.doctoroz.com/article/can-antioxidants-cause-canc...
- Balgair 8y agoThough it may seem cliche' and overused, speaking as someone with a close relative that is affected: FUCK CANCER There is vigorous debate in these comments on the exact stats and what they really mean. All the same, this is fantastic news. Slowly, we are beating back this evil.
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoA more comprehensive immunotherapy approach to cancer (which in my unqualified opinion is the real path to "cure") will probably require custom treatments specific to the patient's genome and cancer biochemistry/gene expression. This does not match any sort of modern drug/device delivery method, which is all the corporate types want. It probably takes lots of labor and tests, not necessarily expensive, just not extremely profitable. Which doesn't make me optimistic for its near term implementation. Anyway, I've had a mother and three friends die of cancer. Basically, if the drugs and radiation failed, it was game over.
- sjg007 8y agoAt some point we will be able to program the immune system to function like a smart bomb and kill most cancers. Some cancers may not be immunological targetable but might be druggable. Or druggable and later targetable.