9 ms·
Drivers claim Uber won’t pay fees to launch forced arbitration cases
- Someone1234 8y agoForced arbitration being lawful is one thing, but the employer both being able to force arbitration AND pick the arbitrator who is on their payroll should be illegal. In effect you've taken a process out of an independent court and put it with a private business which is being paid by one of the parties. Seems super sketchy even to the point of criminality.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThat's the point of it. It protects the corporation from the rule of law.
- derekp7 8y agoAt the minimum, the arbitrator should be licensed and certified by the court. Further, the plaintiff should be able to sue the arbitrator if they failed to act in good faith (i.e., if the arbitrator was sleeping during the deposition, or clearly rendered a decision not supported by the evidence).
- lalaithion 8y ago>Further, the plaintiff should be able to sue the arbitrator if they failed to act in good faith They can. 9 U.S. Code § 10: (a) In any of the following cases the United States court in and for the district wherein the award was made may make an order vacating the award upon the application of any party to the arbitration— (1) where the award was procured by corruption, fraud, or undue means; (2) where there was evident partiality or corruption in the arbitrators, or either of them; (3) where the arbitrators were guilty of misconduct in refusing to postpone the hearing, upon sufficient cause shown, or in refusing to hear evidence pertinent and material to the controversy; or of any other misbehavior by which the rights of any party have been prejudiced; or (4) where the arbitrators exceeded their powers, or so imperfectly executed them that a mutual, final, and definite award upon the subject matter submitted was not made.
- thebluehawk 8y agoSo they require you to do forced arbitration, then just refuse to act on it (or act very slowly). From a business stand point, of course they would. Most of these cases will at best require time and money to sort out, and at worse cost them even more money (compensating a driver for damages or lost wages). So why wouldn't they let these get tied up in bureaucracy until the drivers decide it's not worth the effort? Force arbitration is bullshit and anti-consumer.
- Someone1234 8y ago> Force arbitration is bullshit and anti-consumer. Definitely. I love this quote further down in the article: > Last June, for instance, I wrote about a Fitbit lawyer’s all-too-candid admission that no rational litigant would pay a $750 filing fee to arbitrate a claim over a product that costs $162 – a concession that plaintiffs' lawyers called the “ugly truth” about mandatory arbitration clauses.
- clubm8 8y ago>Last June, for instance, I wrote about a Fitbit lawyer’s all-too-candid admission that no rational litigant would pay a $750 filing fee to arbitrate a claim over a product that costs $162 Sometimes it's not about the money - sometimes it's about sending a message.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoFor Fitbit, it's about the money. They reduce their costs with this strategy, and they don't care about your message.
- clubm8 8y ago> For Fitbit, it's about the money. They reduce their costs with this strategy, and they don't care about your message. I'm saying this is a dangerous line of thinking. What happens when someone does spend the money? Or finances a large group of people to exercise their rights? (Recall the Gawker case - they threat modeled that Hulk Hogan couldn't afford to seek relief in the courts. But they pissed off someone much richer than Hogan, who was happy to help him access legal relief.)
- dannykwells 8y agoWhat rube at the 9th circuit fell for the 'ol "of course we'll act in good faith" argument?? In the long run I think this kind of practice will only hurt Uber - they have huge issues with driver retention any way, and their dream of self driving cars is laughable. Lyft (who's only a little better, but still better) will continue to gain ground in the US especially and will eventually become the market leader in mobility.
- derekp7 8y agoThey both have to worry about customers though. I'm afraid to take either Uber or Lyft, due to the fact my credit card may be randomly charged a $250 or more "damage fee". It is ridiculous that they just take the driver's word for it without something like dashcam evidence as proof.
- deminature 8y agoIt's extremely uncommon to receive a damage fee, has to be substantiated with a photo and you can dispute it. Avoiding rideshare because of it is like refusing to go outside because you might be struck by lightning.
- parthdesai 8y ago>Lyft (who's only a little better, but still better) The same lyft and not Uber that is suing NYC to not pay minimum wage of $17.22? I'm not saying Uber is an angel, but neither is Lyft and at the end of the day both of them are businesses that'll look after themselves first.
- icebraining 8y agoReading into that lawsuit, this seems like an oversimplification. Lyft is arguing against a particular formula that will be applied by TLC to calculate that wage based on the company's utilization rate, claiming it benefits Uber vs smaller companies. I think it's a fair argument if we don't want Uber to monopolize the whole market.
- 8y ago
- mikeash 8y agoForced arbitration is a violation of human rights. Access to the courts should always be available. These clauses should join “sell yourself into slavery” as examples of obvious things you can’t do in a contract.
- pathseeker 8y ago>Forced arbitration is a violation of human rights. What about two parties choosing arbitration as a clause in the contract they enter into together?
- CamTin 8y agoArguably you shouldn't be able to enter into such a contract, similar to how you can't contract yourself into slavery, even if you want to.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- crooked-v 8y agoIt's a failure of society to presume that a huge corporation and a single employee can have a true meeting of the minds for complicated contracts.
- nraynaud 8y agoI think that's how consumer protection should work: company extends shady contract, regulator says nope to the entire industry. For example you should be able to get out of a contract with the same ease as you got in. (also I am still a bit baffled, it took one hour to sign my contract at my gym and 1h30 at the bank to open an account, this symmetry principle might not play in my favor in the US).
- pixl97 8y agoNice word 'choosing' reminds me of this saying... "In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread."
- plink 8y agoUber must hold the world record for the slowest inevitable capsizing of a corporate ship ever.
- rchaud 8y agoGive employees no legal recourse in actual courts, then make sure their sole remaining option doesn't get paid and doesn't start proceedings. Let's say forced arbitration is acceptable (IMO, it's not). Why not make Uber provide a guarantee that arbitration must begin no later than 60 days after the claim is filed? Or would that be another example of the socialist regulations that are ruining free enterprise in America?
- zelon88 8y agoSeems reasonable to me. If you're going to require alternate forms of litigation it's only fair that you put a time limit on it. Otherwise this would certainly become quite a lucrative loophole for corporations to avoid any and all responsibility.
- rchaud 8y agoWe're already headed down that route with the gig economy as a whole. The W2 is the first thing to go.
- viscanti 8y agoI'm conflicted about this. I think forced arbitration is a terrible predatory practice. But I also think there are lots of frivolous class action lawsuits. All the claims cited here were from a single class action lawsuit that was thrown out. I'm all for Uber drivers making more money but they filed a class action lawsuit asking for a different compensation structure than what was offered. They knew the deal when they signed up and it seems like a sketchy attorney took on their case for a big pay day and when that was thrown out they're now taking this next step. If I sign an agreement with an employer about my compensation, I don't have a realistic expectation that I'd be able to sue them when they continue to do what they told me they'd do and I'm no longer happy with it (my recourse is to walk away and work somewhere that better matches what I'm looking for). Frivolous lawsuits drive up the cost for customers almost everywhere. It's a big reason why medical costs are so high. People see a big organization that has some cash and they think they can file a suit as a way to quick riches.
- mikeash 8y agoAccording to this article, malpractice costs (including the cost of defensive medicine done due to the fear of lawsuits) accounts for 2.4% of health care spending: https://www.forbes.com/sites/rickungar/2010/09/07/the-true-cost-of-medical-malpractice-it-may-surprise-you/#78683f6a2ff5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/rickungar/2010/09/07/the-true-c... That’s a decent amount of money but I wouldn’t call it a big reason. One of the problems with bringing health care costs down is that there aren’t any big reasons for it, just lots and lots of little ones.
- Eliezer 8y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3048809/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3048809/ That was a shockingly low figure relative to what I’ve heard from friends in medicine. Looking up the original paper showed that the estimators used for that figure were very sketchy, and the authors of the paper did not claim otherwise. They were simply grasping for any estimator they could.
- 8y ago
- anth_anm 8y agoAllowing people to "sign" away their 7th amendment rights, in some cases in order to simply maintain already paid for services, is ridiculous. Arbitration should be between equal parties (i.e. businesses, you and your neighbor) or you should only agree to it with advice from a lawyer. These clauses are just more corporate abuse.
- iabacu 8y agoForced arbitration is broken, but not entirely useless. The actual problem is vendor lock-in and the conflict of interest in those who choose the vendor. There should be a law that allows you to pick whichever arbitrator you want (within limits, like picking court jurisdiction), rather than being forced into a single vendor.
- techsupporter 8y agoI argue that the actual problem is that mandatory, binding arbitration is viewed as a contractual "choice" when it is not a choice if included in a contract of adhesion (so-called take-it-or-leave-it contracts). If a contract can be negotiated on an individual basis between the contracting parties, fine, permit mandatory arbitration. However, mandatory arbitration should not be permitted otherwise because to do otherwise puts the lesser party at a distinct disadvantage, especially when all market participants include these clauses. For example, is it a "choice" about mandatory arbitration when both of the Internet providers serving my address have contracts of adhesion that include no-opt-out-clause mandatory arbitration? It is not. At the bare minimum, the law should state that contracts of adhesion must include a 60-day opt-out clause for mandatory arbitration, with notice of opting out being provided via some reasonable means (e.g. not via Telex to a disused closet in Boca Raton). If arbitration is so great, let it stand on its own legs without being imposed by one side of the contract.
- anticensor 8y agoDo not say that to MPs. They would make arbitration a precondition of lawsuit as they have done here in Turkey.
- eesmith 8y agoHere's an example of vendor lock-in. Many journal require that authors submit along with an "ORCID" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ORCID https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ORCID . The ORCID terms of use have mandatory arbitration - https://orcid.org/content/orcid-terms-use https://orcid.org/content/orcid-terms-use , and they choose the arbiter. Thus, there's no way to publish in many journals without this agreement. Oh, and the ORCID says registration can be done in "three easy steps" which takes only "30 seconds". Yes, they basically say they don't expect people to read the terms of service as part of the registration!
- mnm1 8y agoSo the law allows the perpetrator of a tort to be judge, jury, and executioner over its victims and then further allows that same perpetrator to lie to a federal court without repercussions and not even carry out the arbitration it promised. Finally, it gives the victims no further recourse against the perpetrator. And this is supposed to be just? The law has a loophole essentially saying that it doesn't need to apply if both parties agree. Absolute insanity really. What's the point of even having a civil court system then? Imagine if they did this with criminal cases. The insanity of the current system does not preclude that. What a failure of government to do one of its basic duties.
- thisisweirdok 8y agoI'm getting really sick of large corporations essentially moulding bureaucracy to benefit themselves and fuck over everyone else. I'm also seeing things like popup more frequently like NET90 payment terms... or accounting departments that won't pay someone unless they fill out a form 100% correctly (oh, and BTW if you fill out the form incorrectly they'll sit on their hands and NOT notify you... so you basically only find out via nagging). If I owed my bank money you think I could sit around twiddling my thumbs waiting for them to guess what the proper request format is? I recently had a company tell me that they only accept invoices ONE DAY A MONTH and there's nothing I can do about it. Uh, excuse me? Forced arbitration is another wonderful example of course. Just sit around basically in a siege knowing that almost no individual person can outlast you (basically Uber's business model anyway, undercut the competition and put them out of business with time).
- riskable 8y agoYou need to CALL OUT these businesses loudly and publicly. This whole, "I'm not paying you for 90-120 days and then I notify you of a typo precisely 91 days later when you ask where the money is" needs to end. So in that vein: Fuck GE Healthcare. They have NET120 and they will do all the things you and I have described and more in order to put off payment to small businesses for as long as possible. I didn't get a check from them until their stuff broke (had nothing to do with my software but they thought it did) and I refused to help them until I got paid. Whaddayaknow, I had a check overnighted to me with early morning delivery!
- tgsovlerkhgsel 8y agoHope you told them (after cashing the check for your past services of course) that you won't help them due to their previous payment behavior, or that you require cleared pre-payment at a significantly higher rate.
- woolvalley 8y agoWhat happens when you offer a contract that says that net90 is %150 of costs, net30 is %120, net14 is %100, etc and any late payment (typo bullshit or not) has a %20 compound APR billed per month, like a credit card? Basically a contract that would be fine if the corp doesn't play shenanigans, and wouldn't if they do.
- Animats 8y agoRefusal to proceed with arbitration has been a problem.[1] Surprisingly, there's still litigation over whether this voids the arbitration clause. At the appellate level, several courts have ruled that it does.[2] The 9th Circuit dealt with this in another case.[3] "On the assumption that Brown's narrative is true, this case displays a dark side of our nation's policy in favor of arbitration. When a defendant in a judicial forum refuses to respond to a complaint that is properly filed and served, the court has the power to enter and enforce a default judgment. Arbitration works differently. The American Arbitration Association could not compel Dillard's to pay its share of the filing fee, and in the absence of the fee it could not proceed. Brown had no choice but to come to court. Many people in Brown's position would simply have given up. Because she did not, we have the occasion to make clear that when an employer enters into an agreement requiring its employees to arbitrate, it must participate in the process or lose its right to arbitrate." [1] https://www.bdlfirm.com/arbitration-the-consequences-of-a-partys-refusal-to-cooperate/ https://www.bdlfirm.com/arbitration-the-consequences-of-a-pa... [2] https://www.arbitrationnation.com/tag/roach-v-bm-motoring/ https://www.arbitrationnation.com/tag/roach-v-bm-motoring/ [3] https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-9th-circuit/1105777.html https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-9th-circuit/1105777.html
- grellas 8y agoWhen a lot of money is at stake, it is no surprise that litigants abuse the legal system. Uber is contractually required to pay the up-front arbitration fees so that the JAMS arbitrations can move forward. I super-slow-walks the process. What is the remedy? Well, JAMS itself does not really have a remedy. It is a private organization that moves forward with the arbitration process as its rules are complied with and as it gets paid. Nor is there an obvious remedy in the courts for individual failings in this or that arbitration procedure. Courts normally are not even involved in such processes. Only when a clear pattern emerges (as it now has) can a court intervene to remedy a problem such as this. In the meantime, what has happened? A lot of time has passed. A lot of the claimants (I am sure) have become discouraged and have possibly lost their motivation to move forward with their claims. And Uber has moved well along the path toward ultimate success in winning it all in its market, currently resting on a valuation of $120B. Is any of this defensible? No. Will Uber try to defend it? Yes, through double-talk and prevarication. Will it be doing so in good faith? Not at all. Will the aggrieved drivers be able to overcome it? Perhaps, but they will likely get too little, too late. And, for Uber, it will be a historic liability that vanishes into the ether as it looks backwards on eventually settling the claims while basking in its massive success. In a just world, things like this should not happen and perhaps Uber will be upended by something or other along the way anyway. But this sort of cynical abuse of legal processes in neither rare nor the exception in cases where modern litigants have the means and opportunity to gain massively from the abuses. It is not the exception but the rule. And this in turn illustrates the obvious limits of using law as a solution for society's problems. The law can and does help solve problems to a point. But it is always subject to abuse and, in the end, money, power, and corrupt motives often work to undercut its effectiveness. This sort of case is Exhibit A to prove the point.
- crooked-v 8y ago> And this in turn illustrates the obvious limits of using law as a solution for society's problems. This problem is a result of people being prevented from using the normal legal process to handle their disputes. "The limits of the law" only applies here so far the Supreme Court has ever-expansively applied the Federal Arbitration Act to override the laws of the states.
- 8y ago
- projektfu 8y agoThe author followed up with another post, "Uber Tells its Side of the Story in Mass Arbitration Fight with 12,500 drivers": https://www.reuters.com/article/legal-us-otc-uber/uber-tells-its-side-of-the-story-in-mass-arbitration-fight-with-12500-drivers-idUSKCN1PA2PD https://www.reuters.com/article/legal-us-otc-uber/uber-tells...
- joshuaheard 8y agoThis is true with any arbitration. If you sue someone it costs about $500 to get the case started in a government subsidized court. In private arbitration, it costs about $1,500. The person initiating the case has to pay, not the defendant. In this case, the drivers are initiating the cases so must pay the initial filing fee.
- jeffdavis 8y agoDoesn't it depend on the terms of the arbitration clause inthe contract?
- briffle 8y agothat is not how the current contract is written, and if the drivers did have to pay, then it would be assumed that they would get to pick the aribters to be used.
- joshuaheard 8y agoI haven't read the contract. Typically, an arbitration service can be named, in this case JAMS, but who pays the filing fee is not in the contract, since it's usually the one initiating the arbitration.
- MilnerRoute 8y agoThis story is from December.
- crb002 8y agoMeh. If they want to not perform on the arbitration clause, they get stuck with going to court. Seems like a win for employees?
- pseingatl 8y agoHow can anyone think that the court system is a panacea for dispute resolution? Or even that it is a better alternative? The courts are the emergency rooms of dispute resolution: on the civil side clogged with foreclosure cases, personal injury slip and falls, divorce protection orders and absent judges who are sitting on the criminal side because the criminal courts are drug courts. Federal courts have limited jurisdiction and criminal cases get priority. Except for bankruptcy, there is no civil side. Would you rather sit in an emergency room or see your own doctor? That is how arbitration is supposed to work. The friction point is the payment of fees. And there is no reason why the disputes of a class of people could not be submitted to arbitration. A lawyerless individual is much better off navigating an arbitration by himself than trying to navigate an American courtroom. Of course, if you don't want concierge justice, you are free to stand in line with everyone else. Understand though, that concierge justice comes at a price. The idiots at Uber simply don't want to pay the price.
- pseingatl 8y agoHere's an interesting scenario which obtained in one of the courts that the arbitration refugees are dying to get into: https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/houston/article/Houston-federal-judge-bars-female-prosecutor-from-13610959.php#photo-16110453 https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/houston/...