15 ms·
Article 13 Is Back On: Worse, Not Better
- Kenji 8y agoOne day nobody will care about this back and forth between EU politicians and they will finally pass a law that will destroy the internet as we know it. It's inevitable because we have to win every single time, they only have to win once. My point being: Harbours for creative and intellectual people will always be under fierce attack by the common fool, and they will always have to occupy a niche, hidden from the intolerant eye.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoexactly. we already did try to push back these and other directives, didn't work, stuff gets added to random articles or just passed verbatim some time later because people cannot rile up activism every single time without generating increasing apathy from the sense of helplessness. lol this is exactly what's happening but no, -1 hive mind tries to disagree facts.
- jplayer01 8y agoYou're entirely right. Defending against the encroaching of our rights and the freedoms afforded by the internet (or freedoms in general) requires constant vigilance. A one-time win doesn't matter - big interest groups continue to exist and continue to pour money intro ensuring their interests are disproportionately represented. This is a losing battle for us. It's a gradual chipping away at our rights that will continue because it simply requires too much effort on the part of citizens.
- Digit-Al 8y ago"Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty; power is ever stealing from the many to the few."
- c3o 8y agoOn the face of it, the fix is rather simple: Vote for politicians who listen at least as much to civil society as they do to corporate lobbyists. Unfortunately, the political system currently structurally incentivizes the opposite, especially at the EU level, about which there is little reporting because that is all organized at the national level. If Julia Reda weren't an MEP and hadn't been sounding the alarm for years now, the first you heard about Article 13 may have been after the final vote in which an even worse version of it was enacted. At this point, the Greens/EFA group in the EP is the only one which has even taken the time to build infrastructure to voluntarily track (necessary to even hope to achieve any kind of balance!) and transparently publish their lobby meetings online. (Here's an ugly backend view, the pretty one is on individual MEPs' websites: https://lobbycal.greens-efa-service.eu/all/ https://lobbycal.greens-efa-service.eu/all/)
- simias 8y agoSurely there's a less inflammatory article out there discussing this?
- mcv 8y agoIs there a less inflammatory way to discuss this?
- Ygg2 8y agoSure. We can pretend it doesn't exist. Or we can shout loudly LALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU...
- sputr 8y agoSometimes truth is inflammatory. Art 13. is a natural disaster in the making. I've publicly debated many proponents, even had the plesure of debating mr. Voss and ... they have no clue what they are doing. Remember the US congress deposition of Google and Faceboko CEOs and how utterly uninformed they were? Well the elected representatives in Europe are no better. Their response to most arguments on how this will hurt creators is "we're just trying to protect creators". No counter arguments, just "our intentions are good". Yeah, I've almost given up at this point. Most legislators just don't understand how modern economy and society works ... and the political groups (like the Pirates) who do, are having a very hard time growing due to overall apathy.
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoYou mean trouble growing like Google? You know Google is a pirate, right? Protected by the dmca.
- raverbashing 8y agoOh poor poor big content, let me shed a tear for them
- 8y ago
- mcv 8y agoYou'd think those law makers would learn. Or maybe we're the ones who should learn. When the original proposal was shot down, we were happy because we thought/hoped it was shot down for our reasons, but even then there were signs that some parties in the EU opposed it because it wasn't quite terrible enough. So now they made it worse. I hope we can keep getting this shot down, but it seems to be important enough for the copyright monopolists to keep pushing this, and public opinion may eventually tire of this. The good thing is that EU elections are coming in May. We need to know which parties support this so we can campaign against them. Let them bleed in the elections if they won't listen.
- cravespotato 8y agoThey only negotiate the bribes. EU is never for the good of the citizens but which corporation pays more to get their way.
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoThey have learned. 2 decades worth of learning from the failed dmca, which basically granted Google immunity from copyright violation. Why should companies like Google be allowed to profit off content creators' work without complying with those content creators' licenses?
- giancarlostoro 8y ago> Why should companies like Google be allowed to profit off content creators' work without complying with those content creators' licenses? If only it were the actual content creators and not corporations that publish the content for the content creators.
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoThis does not in any way diminish my point. If I contract a publisher to print my book or movie is still not right for Google to steal that book or movie and put ads on it. I don't know why society let's them get away with that.
- ddebernardy 8y agoBetter source: https://juliareda.eu/2019/02/article-13-worse/ https://juliareda.eu/2019/02/article-13-worse/
- dang 8y agoOK, we changed to that from https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190204/09090341521/article-13-is-back-germany-caves-to-france-as-eu-pushes-forward-ruining-internet.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190204/09090341521/artic.... Thanks!
- piokoch 8y agoEU slowly starts to resemble old monarchies, detached from reality, "solving" problems that does not exists and totally missing important issues like Euro currency zone crisis, immigration crisis, lack of common and cohesive policy towards Russia and US, economic inequalities between old and new EU members, southern and northern EU countries. After Lisbon treaty EU became some kind of mixture of the union of independent countries and a single organism. "The force" that is supposed to bind all countries into a single organism are EU council, EU commission and EU parliament. The real power is in the hands of the first two institutions - that's the EU bureaucracy which became a modern days "monarchy" - people does not have any power to decide who is nominated to those bodies and those bodies can do whatever they want. EU parliament is pretending to be some kind of "democratic" control, but, at the end of the day, everyone votes "properly", if not, voting is repeated again and again, MPs are disciplined, some words are replaced with their smoother version and we get what we were supposed to get.
- ginko 8y agoWhy are these articles always used for anti-EU tirades? Did people also call into question the democratic legitimacy of the United States while SOPA was on the table?
- dingaling 8y agoPerhaps because the European common market seemed to operate successfully for 40 years without such legislation? If the EU was purely about trade, like the EC&SC and EEC were, then we wouldn't be having this conversation or even Brexit. But such opportunities are useful to remind EU citizens that they are part of something much more daunting and profound.
- timrichard 8y agoThe United States is pretty settled as a sovereign nation. The EU is on a roadmap for complete integration along the model of the USA. It's not unreasonable for people to stop and question whether this is what they want when they see that they have no power to oppose disagreeable, draconian laws like this one.
- Shivetya 8y agoto be honest, after reading this post and the julia link I understand why the law is bad but the idea it is worse simply because it applies to more groups is wrong. a bad law is always a bad law. the small business exception merely turns a bad law into a bad law as a money grab because penalties will be assessed on a company with deeper pockets and likely increased just because of that. the whole idea of exceptions to internet related laws recently based on size of the organization or just as worse, its "for profit" or "not for profit" method of business is just politicians moving their weaponization of laws into a new forum
- kmlx 8y agowe're getting the the Great Firewall of Europe in small but important steps. expect to see more "Banned because you're from Europe" messages plastered all over the Internet. except for VPN and moving to another country, is there any other way for a European to avoiding EU regulation?
- mcv 8y agoVote. Write and talk about this. Create awareness. We need to shoot this down again and again until they learn. We need to vote them out of office and fix this corporate corruption in our government. Most importantly, we need to get non-geeks to care about internet freedom, because as long as they believe the talk about how this is necessary, or simply don't care, the copyright monopolists will be able to get away with pressuring governments to undermine our freedom.
- makomk 8y agoI don't think we even can vote them out of office. All proposed EU laws are created by the European Commission, which is made up of unelected political appointees that aren't even meant to represent the views of ordinary citizens. We really have little say. The European Council is a little better in that it represents member governments which could be voted out of power, but unless there's a huge number of single-issue voters in multiple states who care only about this I can't see this having much effect. Democratic accountability in the EU is incredibly weak, and the member governments seem to love it because it's great for creating laws they couldn't get away with at the national level.
- ginko 8y ago> I don't think we even can vote them out of office. Of course you can. The European Parliament has the last say on EU laws. There's an upcoming EP election in only a few months. The head of the largest faction (essentially either EPP or ESP) will become head of the commission. There's few times as good as now to contact your local MEP and voice your concerns about article 13.
- onlydeadheroes 8y agoSadly, it is time we join the pedos and traffickers in Tor sites. Our discussion sites, our culture creation sites, all of those should be divorced from law enforcement's reach and be moved to safety. It might seem ridiculous to move a site like HN to tor, but it is ridiculous right up to the day it isn't, and then it is too late. We would also free ourselves of copyright, which in the current state only restricts creativity (the things you would put effort in, risky) and in practice fully allows duplicating complete works (effortless, no risk). The time of running the web on the simplest paradigms (direct connection) that facilitate meddling has come to an end as any bovine lawmaker can give us impossible instructions that they do not understand themselves. It is time to assert the power of mathematics, let them stew in it a little while, let them realize they can't just shut the whole thing down anymore, and maybe in a couple generations they will have cleaned up their lawmaking act and we can try to join lawful society again. Maybe. But I expect that in time a fully torified core of sites will be considered a foundation of freedom, and not something to give up in any circumstance.
- mcv 8y agoSometimes I wish we could go back to the early 1990s, when governments didn't care about the internet, and it wasn't controlled by corporations yet. Some way to cut out the corporations and governments and run a network directly between people would be nice. Preferably without pedos and traffickers, of course, but it's probably unavoidable that if we'd be able to do our own thing without corporate/government interference, then so would any other group. That makes this a tough problem.
- konschubert 8y agoGovernments are constructs created by people. You can’t circumvent them.
- sifoobar 8y agoThey're also supposed to serve the people; and when they don't, it's the people's responsibility to remove them from power. Which is just about where we are right now in many countries, at the point where that coin drops collectively.
- wslh 8y agoLiberte fraternite egalite
- emersion 8y ago(It's the other way around -- "liberté égalité fraternité")
- cravespotato 8y agoBeneath the image of socialist do-gooders emerges the true face of the EU project - a fascist super state controlled by unelected maniacs. Soviet Union 2.0. I hope this whole thing collapses when first domino (Brexit) drops. Where is law enforcement in this? Corruption here is bright as the sun.
- titanix2 8y agoBravo la startup nation !
- TomMarius 8y agoThe top-rated comment when they cancelled it last time was "seems like the system is working". So is it?
- ailideex 8y agoDepends on who you are and your perspective - it definitely is working for someone - just that someone is not representative of EU population.
- bsaul 8y agoAs a french i beg other european nations : please, don't let french law makers decide the future of european internet. They don't understand a thing about technology (or science in general) and have a passion for ideology and state regulation. One of the reason we have had riots every single week for the last 3 months is because of their inability to make smart and pragmatic regulations. Don't listen to them.
- entity345 8y agoFrench lawmakers do not decide. EU legislation passes through majority support. This is not a national issue so let's not try to make it one. > One of the reason we have had riots every single week for the last 3 months is because of their inability to make smart and pragmatic regulations Except that many rioters want a rollback on pragmatic measures for purely ideological reasons, of course.
- StavrosK 8y ago> French lawmakers do not decide. No, but they influence enough that they highly correlate with the outcome.
- ailideex 8y ago> This is not a national issue so let's not try to make it one. Why not?
- coldtea 8y ago>EU legislation passes through majority support. Which is hugely influenced by top dog states and their behind the scenes talks.
- Mirioron 8y ago>EU legislation passes through majority support. Due to the way the EU is set up and the "EU parties" are set up, this basically means that France and Germany have a ridiculous amount of sway on the issue.
- 8y ago
- Aeolun 8y agoI find it hard to understand how anyone can think this law is a good idea. Who exactly are they claiming to protect?
- marcus_holmes 8y agoBecause of the structure of the EU, the process of creating new laws is extremely vulnerable to lobbying. Parliament can only vote down laws, which can only be proposed by unelected officials. So the leverage that the average EU voter has is only applicable at one very narrow point in the process (the vote to approve), while lobbyists can always buy influence with the lawmakers all they way through the process. And this is the result. Though it does have to be said that the same process came up with the GDPR and that was a decent (and necessary) piece of legislation. I do wonder why FAANG aren't more active lobbying the EU, though
- detaro 8y ago> I do wonder why FAANG aren't more active lobbying the EU, though They are quite active. I.e. Google is said to have spent 30+ millions on lobbying about the copyright reform. Facebook is lobbying too: https://www.politico.eu/article/inside-story-facebook-fight-against-european-regulation/ https://www.politico.eu/article/inside-story-facebook-fight-... (although not necessarily as one would think from their public statements, it seems like they're quite happy to tout how effective upload filters are when it seems like they can use that as an argument to avoid other rules)
- c3o 8y agoThe 30 million figure was a downright lie by UK music publishers – it includes the entire lobbying budget (for the year 2016, bizarrely) of any industry association Google is listed as being a member of, which for some reason even includes the political think tank of the German CDU party, whose politicians are actually BEHIND the law, not opposed to it. Here's an in-depth factual analysis of copyright lobbying: > The limited information which is available about lobby meetings shows the intense level of lobbying taking place on the Copyright Directive, but it also interestingly exposes that the biggest lobbies were not in fact big tech companies and their associates, as many headlines claimed, but the publishers, creative industries and collecting societies. https://corporateeurope.org/power-lobbies/2018/12/copyright-directive-how-competing-big-business-lobbies-drowned-out-critical https://corporateeurope.org/power-lobbies/2018/12/copyright-...
- dsabanin 8y agoArticle 13 looks like a really nice foundation for censorship. It’s interesting for me to see how EU socialistic tendencies correlate with things like “right to be forgotten”, “article 13” and other initiatives. It’s as if party nomenclature is worried about their self preservation already. It’s also telling to see how little effect citizens of EU have over these decisions.
- bubblethink 8y agoWhat constitutes a European website ? As long as you are not accepting local currency and don't have a registered company in Europe, are you still affected by this ?
- volkl48 8y agoWell, from a practical perspective, if you have no operations in or other ties to a country, you are not subject to their laws. US-centric sites ignoring GDPR compliance would be one such example.
- sametmax 8y agoBy operation, do you mean a legal one, a financial one or a technical one ?
- Nasrudith 8y agoProbably the first two only. Financial and legal are within reach while technical requires a draconian solutions if you aren't paying anyone to carry your content or doing something home country illegal like hacking EU servers. You can say, insult the king of Thailand all day every day on the internet and if you have no legal or financial ties you are safe.
- sametmax 8y agoGood question. I host http://0bin.net/ http://0bin.net/. I comply to the regular take down notices, but by its very nature, I cannot filter the service since I cannot see what's been pasted. Would it mean I'll have to move the server outside europe ? Would it mean I'll have to block european IP ?
- bubblethink 8y ago>Would it mean I'll have to move the server outside europe ? Perhaps ? >Would it mean I'll have to block european IP ? Not really ? They can block you if they want (similar to how DMCA works). That gets into general censorship territory though, for which people are looking into other solutions for far more oppressive regimes than the EU. See signal in Iran, domain fronting etc. As for currency exchange, this may be the killer app for cryptos ?
- jswizzy 8y agoTheses are the same law makers who passed Net Neutrality too and laughed at Brexit.
- crb002 8y agoAnd they wonder why the Brits want out of this.
- lbj 8y agoThis has happened countless times: A very ill received proposal meets sufficient public resistance to be publicly labeled as "defeated", only to resurface in an almost identical version months/years later. It seems obvious that strong powers playing the long game are lobbying to see this passed.
- afpx 8y agoThis seems to have become standard operating procedure in the US, and it really kills peoples' trust of our legislative system. It's saddening to hear that the EU is not immune to it either.
- lbj 8y agoI would say it's standard in most western countries.
- jandrese 8y agoEastern countries too, unless they're too totalitarian to hold votes.
- Mirioron 8y agoThe EU has been pulling this stuff for a while. Back when Ireland had a referendum whether they should ratify the Lisbon treaty the Irish voted against it. A year later they were asked to have another referendum with some concessions given by the EU. Referendums don't really work if one side can just ask to have another one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThis will kill any form of free expression on the Internet in Europe. Join me in considering France, and soon the EU, as an enemy of human rights. The European Convention on Human Rights, Article 10, is dead.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Mirioron 8y agoI used to be in favor of the EU, but over the last decade the more I learned about how it operated and what kind of regulations they passed, the more opposed I became to it. Just the fact that they're bringing this proposal back again means that the "lawmakers" have zero respect for the general public.
- ajmurmann 8y agoSounds like the reason it went away in the first place wasn't because of concerns of the public, but because Germany and France couldn't agree on the details about who is affected. Given the new proposal, it seems like booth parties might have thought the other's proposal wasn't wide enough.
- zaarn 8y agoNo, the OP details that the German proposal was to exclude small businesses (<X million per year and <50 employees) but the french wanted the article 13 to hit everyone equally.
- jplayer01 8y agoI agree to an extent. If France decided to implement these laws in their own country, 30 something other countries could shrug and do their own thing, while the French could attempt to fight it on a local or regional level. While the EU has enabled plenty of good, it's also the perfect platform to implement less good policies such as this in the interest of corporations or rightsholders on an intranational level in a way that wasn't possible before. It's also much harder to be heard as a citizen on the EU-level. I'm not sure what the solution should be, since overall I support the EU.
- jelly 8y agoIt's almost unbelievable that they want to remove the single piece of protection that makes Article 13 remotely acceptable to me: exemption for SMEs. If many small European internet platforms were allowed to grow in place of the existing American megaplatforms we could have a more competitive ecosystem (i.e. platforms couldn't suddenly change their policies or UIs without risk of significant user losses) and upload filters wouldn't be a legal requirement.
- azinman2 8y agoBut that’s been the case as we haven’t had article 13 yet, meanwhile where are all these competitive ecosystems?
- jelly 8y agoFailing to overcome the network effect unfortunately. My (perhaps naive) hope for this copyright directive was that it would add a cost or limiting factor to the network effect, i.e. after your platform grows past a certain size you are accountable for every user and have to filter uploads at great cost.
- ngcc_hk 8y agoEu as a socialist and self centred platform is only by a matter of degree different from China.
- amyjess 8y agoStuff like this is why I've gone from being horrified by Brexit to hoping for a hard Brexit. The UK can do better than being stuck with Article 13.
- pygy_ 8y agoThe same lobbies exist in the UK, I'd expect a copycat law to land as well.
- iosjailbreak 8y agoDownload Electra Jailbreak iOS 12.2 To iOS 12.2.3 Utility, https://ios-jailbreak.com/electra-2019-celebrate-ios-12-2-jailbreak-releace https://ios-jailbreak.com/electra-2019-celebrate-ios-12-2-ja... The Electra Jailbreak for iOS 12.2.1 and iOS 12.2.2 is finally available for download! This is an always up-to-date article that contains download links for everything required to jailbreak iOS 12.2 on your iPhone, iPad or iPod touch: the Electra app, Cydia Impactor, and iTunes. The two paragraphs above are merely to say that we’ll need an Apple ID to sign the jailbreak iOS 12.2 Electra app, that you’ll be required to re-run the app every time you reboot (if you want to use anything jailbreak-related post reboot), and that said app will need to be resigned using your Apple ID every week.
- thecleaner 8y agoI think that all data scientists can pick up the baton here. Maybe we could have a nice analysis about the evolution of Article 13 and who supported what clause. Given that elections are in May this would be valuable information. For the DS people it could be a great example of how to communicate complex ideas in a simple manner. Just a project suggestion for ones portfolio.
- moby_click 8y agoAt least they added an explanation with regard to "best efforts": > When assessing whether an online content sharing service provider has made its best efforts according to high industry standards of professional diligence, account shall be taken of whether the service provider has taken all the steps that would be taken by a diligent operator [...] taking into account best industry practices [...] Further, they added "future developments" to the state of the art of existing means. Page 7, https://www.politico.eu/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Mandate-Romania-February-8.pdf https://www.politico.eu/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Mandate-R...
- crsmithdev 8y agoI wonder if at some point it will just make good business sense not to offer your service / product in the EU? I imagine the cost of developing and running software to comply (plus the fines for anything but perfect compliance) would exceed potential revenue from EU customers in many cases.
- Cynddl 8y agoDo you mean as someone not living in the EU? More than 500M people live there and their primary market, when offering a service or a product, is indeed the European market.
- crsmithdev 8y agoYes. Of course, if you are living in the EU, you are stuck with that market :)
- walterstucco 8y agoThen don't do it. There aren't many products EU is gonna miss anyway.
- jandrese 8y agoDepends on your service. Something like Wechat could pretty easily decide to just not service the EU. It would be a much tougher choice for someone like Google or Amazon.
- ohthehugemanate 8y agoPersonally I'm rooting for the worst possible version of Article 13. Feed the lawyers, starve the businesses. Make the starkest possible contrast between countries where the lobbyists win, and everyone else. Sometimes you need to get bitten to learn to avoid the snake. The EU can be to copyright law what Brexit is to internationalism and free trade. A brutal, public, and visible example that completely fucks a major economic player, to the obvious benefit of its neighbors. The Internet is global. It is much easier to move a digital company than a bricks-and-mortar one, and this would give ample incentive. We will continue connecting the world, continue progressing, and continue making great money doing it. And all the EU citizens will be shut out of that for as long as our government can keep its eyes shut. Their eyes will open a lot faster under visible economic pain and international embarrassment than they would on the present course.
- koonsolo 8y agoYeah, in a way, I hope after this Article 13, we (Europe) get blocked from all major "user generated content" sites such as Facebook, YouTube, Reddit, etc. Try to explain it then to the general public.
- DigitalWheelie 8y agoThis is a depressing thread. :(
- kragen 8y agoThe admin of my Mastodon instance tells me he'll have to shut it down if this passes: https://nerdculture.de/@ij/101541005474837977 https://nerdculture.de/@ij/101541005474837977
- rmbeard 8y agoPerhaps the internet is only temporary and will soon be gone, at least in some parts of the world. Perhaps it will be confined to only a few countries. Perhaps something will be developed to replace it.
- anticensor 8y agoHackerNews with Turnitin/Copyscape would be far worse than what it is now like. Really, there are just a few companies which can implement a "copyright" filter. For text: *Copyscape *Turnitin For the rest: *Google+Amazon+Apple (ContentID) *Microsoft+Facebook+Netflix ("Microsoft Rights", anyone?)