11 ms·
A Harvard Astronomer on the Interstellar Object ‘Oumuamua
- ycombonator 8y agoDr Avi Loeb is one of those rare individuals in his field who doesn't believe in "settled science" as opposed to others in his field.
- colordrops 8y ago"settled science". Love that term.
- rando444 8y ago>When you look at all the stars in the vicinity of the sun, they move relative to the sun, the sun moves relative to them, but only one in five hundred stars in that frame is moving as slow as ‘Oumuamua. You would expect that most rocks would move roughly at the speed of the star they came from. If this object came from another star, that star would have to be very special. If we're to assume that this is something that was expelled from a remote solar system, wouldn't you then also assume that there had to be some explosion or collision to get this thing on its current course? And wouldn't that account for a speed that doesn't match nearby objects?
- dbingham 8y agoBut not for the odd shape, or for the apparent change in acceleration with out any off-gassing.
- joe_the_user 8y agoAs your quote indicates, it's not just not going at the speed of any nearby star, it's going at the particular speed of the galaxy (or galaxy's average rotation). If an object were expelled randomly by a nearby star, it's speed would be: star's speed + random extra boost. The chances this would exactly the galactic speed seems small.
- Symmetry 8y agoBut given a long enough time and an object with a low enough ballistic coefficient I'd expect it to come to rest with respect to the interstellar medium, maybe. I don't know if that works out quantitatively in this case.
- jerf 8y agoKinda a weird speed for an alien artifact too, though. One would expect for it to be launched. Humans may in some sense have a small time horizton, but you have to have an absurdly long time horizon to fling probes out into the universe at the local average speed and expect them to encounter anything, since by definition of "local average speed" that's literally the speed least likely to encounter anything. In some sense, that's actually literally the least likely velocity I'd expect to be an alien result. (And it's also conceivable that humans have bizarrely long time horizons, if the future of all intelligence is moving into a machine intelligence on a computational substrate as fast as possible. If intelligences subjectively experience hundreds or thousands or millions of times faster, it's like dropping the speed of light by the same factor, and it still takes all the same amount of energy to launch probes. I'm not saying this is inevitably true, but I do think there's an excessively strong bias to assume that humans are as bad as possible in every possible way.)
- nerfhammer 8y agoIt's exactly what you would want to do if you didn't want someone who found it to be able to tell where it came from
- jerf 8y agoFor that, you just need the velocity vector not to be in the very narrow class of vectors that point back at you. There's no need to put it in "galactic neutral", especially given that, as I said, that's literally the worst possible speed to get anywhere. That's just one possible choice from the almost-every-possible-vector selection set that will work to disguise your origin. Of course, we also have the question of why you would care to disguise your origin for a "space probe" traveling at such a slow speed. (Pretty much every conceivable mechanism that could have something traveling at any appreciable speed and that slowed it down anytime in the recent past would be very easily detectable. Of course you can invoke inconceivable mechanisms, but as I often say, you have to understand you have left rationality and logic behind when you do that; if we're going to say this object has a magic drive that decelerates without any detectable emissions, we might as well ask why it's not just using an FTL drive, or why any alien civilization is bothering to "probe" us when they've long since landed at Area 51 and have long since been running our civilization anyhow as our secret leaders.)
- modzu 8y agothank you Dr. Loeb for giving this the attention it deserves. oumuamua demonstrated that we aren't equipped to respond fast enough to these types of objects. we need plans in place that addresses the latency of fast moving objects so that we can prioritize them for study and not be left wondering...
- emsy 8y agoI'm not exactly sure why you are being downvoted at the time of my reply. Surely being prepared for this situation will give humanity benefits regardless of any actual contact with alien civilizations. Similar to how having environmental friendly tech is a net plus regardless of your stance on global warming.
- gowld 8y agoWhy? We haven't even finished studying all the slow-moving nearby objects.
- peterwwillis 8y agoThis is the guy that believes aliens created a solar sail-powered pancake-shaped spacecraft 600,000 years ago just so it could fly by us and say hi, right?
- radicaldreamer 8y agoThat's not what he said at all?
- peterwwillis 8y agoNo, it is what he said. In this article, he mentions a dead alien civilization sending it. He also mentions the pancake shape. In this other article[1] he mentions it taking 600,000 years to reach us from Vega. In this article[2] he mentions the solar sail. You can find it all on the Wikipedia page[3]. But thanks for the downvotes, guys. [1] https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-news/astronomers-spot-first-known-interstellar-comet/ https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-news/astronomers-s... [2] https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-if-true-this-could-be-one-of-the-greatest-discoveries-in-human-history-1.6828318 https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-if-true... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ʻOumuamua https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ʻOumuamua
- mfoy_ 8y agoDown-votes are not for factually correct or incorrect comments. They are for comments that either do or do not contribute to the discussion. Saying that he believes that "aliens created a solar sail-powered pancake-shaped spacecraft 600,000 years ago just so it could fly by us and say hi" is incredibly dismissive, and also a misrepresentation of his views, and his point.
- peterwwillis 8y agoThose are his views. I didn't misrepresent them, I stated them plainly. As a result, it sounds like a stupid idea. That is my contribution to the discussion. Not liking this contribution, or not agreeing with it, doesn't mean it's not a contribution. The downvotes are because people don't like it.
- joe_the_user 8y agoThere's definitely not enough evidence to say Oumuamua is an artifact of an alien civilization. But there isn't enough evidence to say it isn't either. Moreover, as far as I know, there is enough evidence to be pretty sure every other significant celestial body is not an alien artifact. So it's higher on the scale than anything else. The argument I've heard is that it is a disabled alien probe. This makes sense given that any device sent into space will probably last much longer as space junk than as a working device. So, the density of alien space junk would be higher than the density working artifact. Thus, if this thing were to turn out to be disabled alien probe, it would be more or less what you'd expect to see occasionally if alien civilizations of our level existed in some moderate density (note, most of "Fermi Hypothesis" possibility arguments involves hypothetical higher levels of civilization, which seems to me a rather thin argument).
- cptaj 8y agoThere is definitely not enough evidence to be pretty sure every other celestial body is not an alien artifact. Just a few weeks ago New Horizons was doing a flyby of kuiper belt object Ultima Thule. Before the flyby, this object was merely a couple of pixels in any of our instruments. In fact, it exhibited odd light curves that seemed very unlikely for a regular asteroid. This also prompted comparisons to Rama, just like Oumuamua did. Its straight out of the book. So up until the first pictures were downloaded, we definitely did not have enough data to disprove an alien artifact hypothesis. Turned out to be just another asteroid (a pretty interesting one, but no green men) Ultima Thule was a studied object, targeted by an serious AF NASA interplanetary mission, and we knew jack shit about it. There are millions of other kuiper belt objects out there and we know absolutely nothing about them. So yeah, Oumuamua is pretty much part for the course in that regard.
- porphyrogene 8y agoNo one has claimed that Oumuamua is likely an alien device. It has been cited as a possibility and that possibility is being touted as justification for doing more to study such objects. Most of these comments are arguing against a claim that has not been made.
- nabla9 8y agoThe whole case sounds just crazy publicity stunt. After reading more, I think Avi Loeb had a valid reason to speculate and put it out there even the numbers have large uncertainties and put the article out because the argument is good enough even with the large uncertainties. It's the fault of the general public if they get carried away. (If I would bet, I would say the probability is less than 0.00001 that the hypothesis is correct.)
- aschampion 8y agoPBS SpaceTime's excellent coverage of Loeb's paper: 'Oumuamua Is Not Aliens https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wICOlaQOpM0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wICOlaQOpM0
- porphyrogene 8y agoI am making a note to read the paper because this interview was a disaster. The interviewer asked a personal question about religious beliefs and denies that the question was inappropriate after putting him on the defensive by questioning his reasoning from a decidedly uninformed perspective. Why not survey others in the field and voice their objections instead of condescending to the interviewee? This reads like some weird gotcha journalism... in The New Yorker of all places.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tokai 8y agoIf you as an interviewer ever say "Hold on. Let me finish", you have failed and should rethink your methodology. It was embarrassing to read.
- pmoriarty 8y agoThere's a much better interview here: https://boingboing.net/2018/12/06/interview-with-the-astronomer.html https://boingboing.net/2018/12/06/interview-with-the-astrono...
- tokai 8y agoThank you. I'll read it. I have heard multiple interviews of Loeb on youtube.[0] I like that he doesn't hide away the potential for wonder in astrology/cosmology. In that way he reminds me of Sagan a great deal. Sagan faced some ridicule as well in his time, so go figure. [0] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCz3qvETKooktNgCvvheuQDw/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCz3qvETKooktNgCvvheuQDw/vid...
- TomMckenny 8y agoFor some reason, it seems a widespread habit to drift from astronomical or quantum discussions into religion. So widespread that we see Apollo astronauts reading Genesis and Youtube search results on those topics return a jumble real science with mysticism. Yet this seems to happen much less for, say, chemistry, geology, materials science etc. (nor software questions mercifully) It's not quite clear why (western?) minds are wired this way. Particularly since chemistry was tied up with mysticism for centuries yet subatomic science is brand new. But it would be nice if at least professional interviewers would avoid straying into non-sequiturs.
- api 8y agoMy favorite speculation is that Oumuamua is a spent deceleration stage for a larger inbound multi-stage interstellar rocket. It would probably be a nuclear fusion rocket or similar. Previous stages flew past us and we didn't notice. The next stages(s) and/or the payload should arrive shortly. Since it's decelerating the next stage will be traveling slower.
- mfoy_ 8y agoThat's actually a fun thought... once you've got your probe up to a third of the speed of light or whatever... how are you going to slow down again in order to actually do anything useful? Or maybe this is a solar sail that was part of an ACCELERATION stage for a probe that already passed through our solar system millions of years ago.
- api 8y agoI'm not a rocket scientist (heh) but I'm imagining a many-stage nuclear rocket. You'd have a whole bunch of acceleration stages followed by a much smaller number of deceleration stages followed by the payload. You wouldn't need as many deceleration stages since you've already spent all the mass in your acceleration stages. Building such a thing in space would involve sending up the stages themselves with some kind of heavy lift vehicle, assembling them in orbit, and firing it. The number of stages you could assemble would be quite large since there's no air resistance or (relative) gravitational stress in space. You'd just have to not exceed the tensile strength of the material during acceleration. You could put together 100 stages or more I'm sure. It's one rather brute force but workable way of reaching some nontrivial fraction of the speed of light. Someone should do the math on this for fission (NERVA-like), thermonuclear pulse (Orion), and pure fusion.
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoIf we were to do an interstellar ship with current physics it would probably rely on: - Preacceleration strategies that speed up the craft without using its onboard/deceleration reaction mass/fuel (gravity whips, launching lasers for a solar sail, cannon-fired fuel pods) - Pulse nuclear acceleration using "preseeded" fuel pods launched ahead of the craft and captured as the craft caught the pod - ion drive once the preseeded fuel pods weren't practical anymore - ion drive, solar sail, and pulse nuclear and more gravity whips to slow down Pulse nuclear/orion ships are the only thing that gets close to specific impulse and performance to get to Alpha Centauri in anything reasonable. It becomes a LOT more feasible if fuel pods are prelaunched, or seeded by a leading disposable fuel seeding ship (it doesn't have to slow down, it can just, uh ... .... fly through the target system once it's done. Uhoh.
- rotexo 8y ago“...at least a quarter of the stars in the Milky Way galaxy have a planet like Earth, with surface conditions that are very similar to Earth, and the chemistry of life as we know it could develop.” I was rather surprised by this claim. Isn’t it currently beyond our ability to detect earth-sized planets around other stars? Isn’t it also beyond our capability to directly detect surface conditions on planets around other stars?
- nateberkopec 8y agoIt is not beyond our ability, as "detecting earth-sized planets" was the explicit mission of the Kepler spacecraft.
- rotexo 8y agoI guess I should ask a different question then. Have we detected any earth-sized planets? I can only remember hearing about super-earths and gas giants, and I generally read the exoplanet discovery announcements when I see them.
- skykooler 8y agoWe have indeed. This page has some that are also in the habitable zone: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_potentially_habitable_exoplanets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_potentially_habitable_... Note that, while some are super-earths, others like Kepler-438b or the planets in the TRAPPIST-1 system are Earth-sized or smaller.
- anoncoward111 8y agoThis is actually a really weird claim. We know now thanks to Kepler that many stars have planets just like our Sun does, but so far we've only been able to see large gaseous planets and a few rocky ones that can be as large as 1.5x Earth. 25% sounds way too high. We have not even found many stars like our own with rocky Earths like our own yet. I am certain we will eventually find them, but I think the number of rocky planets with oxygen atmosphere and liquid water is going to be under 1%. Life is most likely rare but abundant- 1% of 100 billion is a butt-ton of Earths
- gloriousduke 8y agoOumuamua probably isn't artificial, but observations of objects like it and Tabby's star, fast radio bursts and contact binary systems* will likely increase as our instruments and data parsing improve. So, if aliens are the cause of any these or some repeated, anomalous future observations, it's only a matter of time before we all but confirm we are not alone. *https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/vvbx4x/starivores-intelligent-life-that-could-eat-the-sun https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/vvbx4x/starivores...
- nateberkopec 8y agoWhat's the future for the study of Oumuamua? Apparently, it should be beyond the orbit of Saturn by the end of this month. Will we _ever_ know what it is definitively, or is it too late?
- anoncoward111 8y agoUnlikely that we will ever know for this specific object, but hopefully we will be more poised for future study ;) Oumuamua is moving way too fast for anything to catch up to it anytime soon. If I remember correctly it's moving about as fast as New Horizons in the 23km/s speed range. You would need lots of years to catch up to it!
- aspectmin 8y agoI would like to understand this better myself. If we dedicated some resources and say... a year until launch, could humanity (current state of tech) build something that could catch up to this thing in a reasonable (2, 3-5 year?) timeframe?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nkurz 8y agoThe following October, Avi Loeb, the chair of Harvard’s astronomy department, co-wrote a paper (with a Harvard postdoctoral fellow, Shmuel Bialy) that examined ‘Oumuamua’s “peculiar acceleration” and suggested that the object “may be a fully operational probe sent intentionally to Earth’s vicinity by an alien civilization.” The referenced paper is here: Could Solar Radiation Pressure Explain 'Oumuamua's Peculiar Acceleration? https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.11490 https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.11490
- pewdiepotpie 8y agowe [as a species] already have probes landing on interplanetary bodies; and have made considerations to manipulate trajectories of such. I would entertain the possibility the object in question could be just such a hacksteroid of mostly cosmic origin with some tech pushing it around.
- airstrike 8y agoBeing a Harvard astronomer in and of itself doesn't make one's arguments any stronger. What a silly headline.
- mfoy_ 8y agoI down-voted you, and here's why: 1. An appeal to authority is a logical fallacy. However, authority does serve a purpose. People will take Harvard astronomers more seriously than backyard astronomy enthusiasts. Therefore his credentials are relevant. 2. No one, at any point, makes an argument that you should believe anything he claims on his credentials alone. 3. In this world of click-bait headlines and ad-revenue-driven content, this doesn't even qualify as close to click-bait. It doesn't even say UFO, or alien, or artifact, or anything controversial. The title of the article is literally what it is. It is a Harvard astronomers thoughts on an object in space.
- airstrike 8y ago> 1. An appeal to authority is a logical fallacy. However, authority does serve a purpose. People will take Harvard astronomers more seriously than backyard astronomy enthusiasts. Therefore his credentials are relevant. You're basically saying "appeal to authority is a logical fallacy but it's an OK fallacy" We should judge his opinion on the validity of his claims, not on the credentials he carries. If the backyard astronomer makes a more cogent argument, we should prefer that over the Harvard astronomers. Ideas have merits, credentials don't. Carl Sagan famously said One of the great commandments of science is, "Mistrust arguments from authority." ... Too many such arguments have proved too painfully wrong. Authorities must prove their contentions like everybody else.
- mfoy_ 8y agoYour entire comment is off-topic. You ignored points #2 and #3 and misrepresented #1. That's a classic straw-man fallacy. I did not say "it's an OK fallacy", so do not put those words into my mouth. I said authority serves a purpose. It can serve as a signal, used to filter out noise. His arguments must, of course, stand on their own. If you actually read the article, you'll find he makes some good arguments. In fact, neither this headline nor this article even make the "appeal to authority" fallacy in the first place. So why harp on it?
- olefoo 8y agoIf this unusual object were an artifact and our solar system wasn't it's destination the most positive evidence for it's artificial nature would be it's onward destination. As yet I haven't seen any extrapolations of its post-encounter track.
- fxj 8y agoIt is all speculation and no proof, but a good advertisement for the cited scientist.
- arisAlexis 8y agosome good news. if it's a solar sail it means that their technology doesn't include em drive warp speeds and all that fancy stuff so it will take them a long time to come and kill us all
- apo 8y agoThe title's use of "Harvard" is interesting in that it hints at appeal to authority. Imagine that the astronomer were based at Lackawanna College. Would that information be worth conveying through the title? "Lackawanna College Astronomer on the Interstellar Object ‘Oumuamua" I doubt it. The problem with appeal to authority is that there's no place in science for it. Not only that, appeal to authority undermines science itself. As Carl Sagan put it in The Demon-Haunted World: Arguments from authority carry little weight – authorities have made mistakes in the past. They will do so again in the future. Perhaps a better way to say it is that in science there are no authorities; at most, there are experts. https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/535475-arguments-from-authority-carry-little-weight-authorities-have-made https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/535475-arguments-from-autho...
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIn a way, quoting Carl Sagan is an appeal to authority in itself. If the same words were said by /u/RandomRedditUser, the quotation would carry less weight. You could also see the "Harvard Astronomer" and "Carl Sagan" here as appeal to expertise, for which university association is an imperfect proxy.
- apo 8y agoI see how it could be interpreted that way. But my purpose was to credit the author and his book. Had I left the quote without attribution and claimed it as my own, I'm sure someone would have suggested I should take a refresher on plagiarism. Ditto had I paraphrased Sagan without attribution. If I had merely given the quote without a link or context, I'd run the risk of perpetuating false quotes. Had /u/RandomRedditUser written the text instead of Sagan, I would have cited it in the same way.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI'm not criticizing the way you quoted Sagan; what I'm trying to say is that there's no escape from any kind of "appeal to authority". There's too many people saying too many things that are too expensive to evaluate on their own merits; we all use heuristics to filter and rank stuff. Appeal to authority/expertise is one of those (and, as all heuristics, imperfect).
- LyalinDotCom 8y agoIs the object too small and/or traveling too fast that we can never get better photos of it? I am assuming we can still predict where it should be even after it left our system?
- drdrey 8y agoIt was detected too late (already 0.22 AU from Earth and moving away) and it is tiny, only about 100m. We will never get any photos from it.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Loeb has long been interested in the search for extraterrestrial life, and he recently made further headlines by suggesting that we might communicate with the civilization that sent the probe. “If these beings are peaceful, we could learn a lot from them,” he told Der Spiegel. Such as why it's a bad idea to communicate with alien civilisations, particularly ones that appear to be more technologically advanced than ours.
- newnewpdro 8y agoHaving already read multiple articles about Oumuamua, the only thing this particular article added to my knowledge is that Isaac Chotiner is not a particularly good interviewer.
- ncmncm 8y agoThis guy will need to have a chat with a plasma physicist, one of these days, if he wants to get to the bottom of this. When he does, he will then need to keep it to himself, because there's no quicker route to ostracism, in astronomy, than to start talking about electromagnetics.