12 ms·
Avoiding a transit of the United States
- owenmarshall 8y agoIMO, the Wikivoyage link is a better one: https://en.wikivoyage.org/wiki/Avoiding_travel_through_the_United_States https://en.wikivoyage.org/wiki/Avoiding_travel_through_the_U... In general I'd recommend Wikivoyage over Wikitravel - the material seems fresher and it is run by a community rather than a corporation with heavy-handed policies.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- paulgb 8y agoFor anyone new to the distinction, Internet Brands bought Wikitravel and the community didn't like that, so they forked to Wikivoyage. IB tried suing Wikivoyage for this despite it being allowed under the content license -- either IB didn't do their due diligence on the license of the content they bought, or they thought they could bully the community fork through the cost of fighting it alone. It was eventually thrown out of court, as it should have been. Wikivoyage is now hosted by Wikimedia, the same nonprofit that hosts Wikipedia.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThank you for the context.
- cjensen 8y agoJust to really emphasize this... Internet Brands literally sued one of the volunteer admins for this[1]. Please use Wikivoyage instead! [1] Disclosure: As an admin, I may or may not have been one of the "unnamed co-conspirators" in the lawsuit before IB dropped the suit
- cedivad 8y agoThat reads like vBulletin vs XenForo to me. Funny.
- medmunds 8y ago> recommend Wikivoyage over Wikitravel Seconded. Wikivoyage was a fork of Wikitrsvel. The history is... interesting: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Brands#Wikitravel_and_Wikimedia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Brands#Wikitravel_a...
- metalliqaz 8y agoNon-mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Brands#Wikitravel_and_Wikimedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Brands#Wikitravel_and...
- turdnagel 8y agoAre there any community guidelines around linking to sources when making claims about what a party might have said? On that very page is the claim: > US officials have said Canadians may be banned for life from entering the US for legally smoking it, or for working for or investing in the legal companies involved. Which may very well be true, but cannot be verified without a source.
- trynewideas 8y agoJust checked the article Talk page and the editor who added it linked to https://www.thestar.com/amp/news/cannabis/2018/09/13/canadians-who-smoke-marijuana-legally-or-work-or-invest-in-the-industry-will-be-barred-from-the-us-customs-and-border-protection-official.html https://www.thestar.com/amp/news/cannabis/2018/09/13/canadia... from there.
- dmix 8y agoI'm sure the Huawei executive was aware of this and actively avoided transiting through the US. She probably didn't assume Canada would also do the US's bidding. The charges against her work with Iran had made headlines nearly 5+ yrs before she was arrested, so she must have known there was a risk travelling there.
- OldHand2018 8y ago> I'm sure the Huawei executive was aware of this and actively avoided transiting through the US. She probably didn't assume Canada would also do the US's bidding. Because everyone in Canada has already forgotten about the hacking and IP theft from Nortel, right? 17 years ago, Hauwei stole my source code and pushed my employer out of a joint venture in Australia. I know that I'll never forget about it. Do you think Canadians have a short memory or are especially forgiving about tens of thousands of people losing savings and pensions?
- rlglwx 8y agoIf the Canadian government requests the United States government to detain someone, the US would. That's the nature of extradition treaties. Nobody is doing anyone's "bidding".
- dmix 8y agoSure but don't act like it's just some run-of-the-mill legal process without significant political implications for Canada and their citizens, which are most certainly balanced and considered beforehand. I doubt it's an automatic process merely because a treaty exists.
- ben509 8y agoA treaty means it's a matter of law in both countries. It may not be automatic, but if they don't follow the laws they promised to uphold, they risk voiding the treaty.
- Kalium 8y agoYou're right! It's by no means some run-of-the-mill legal process without significant political implications. It's a run-of-the-mill legal process that the Chinese government has decided should have significant political implications for Canada and Canadian citizens. It's important to bear in mind that this was a set of decisions deliberately chosen by the government of China in response to Canada obeying its obligations clearly laid out in a readily available treaty. As you so wisely and correctly note, no legal process is automatic. Yet routine extraditions, even of politically sensitive people, come quite close.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> "The United States does not allow sterile transit, which means that even if you have an immediate connecting flight, you have to pass through Customs and Immigration. This is time-consuming and tedious" The history behind this isn't as simple as politics. Many US airports have evolved without the physical separation between local and international departures areas. So all of the airport is "in" the US. That makes perfect sense given the geography involved. The bulk of US flights are local. Even with Canadian flights it is normal to clear US customs and immigration within Canada prior to boarding the flight to the US. So, rather than politics or protectionism, there simply was no practical need for separate terminals. Starting from that history, it is far easier to screen all passengers as they land rather than retroactively divide an airport into zones. LAX is notable for having separate local and international terminals, but iirc everyone is still screened on landing.
- saryant 8y agoA few more recent airports have been built to make this change possible should policy ever shift. IAH was specifically designed to allow future sterile transits without major construction.
- guan 8y agoThe US used to have a program called “ITI” which was suspended in 2003. I don’t know exactly how it worked logistically. Travelers were supposed to stay in a certain area of the airport. I believe Miami had a separate secure transit area—was the area you are referring to at IAH in use until 2003? Other airports may have relied on other measures to make sure transit passengers didn’t proceed into the US. (There was also a related transit without visa program that allowed visa-free transit within the US, using multiple airports.)
- TremendousJudge 8y agoI traveled through the US on a connecting flight in 1999 without a visa and it was possible. "Transit without visa" was a thing.
- dooglius 8y agoI was under the impression that international flights connecting through the US put travellers in what is technically international territory, and doesn't involve any of the difficulty associated with entering the country. Is this no longer the case?
- kenneth 8y agoThat's never been the case. US airports do not have sterile international zones.
- ipsi 8y agoMaybe? All I can say is that last couple of times I transited through LAX, I had to go all the way out through security and passport control - I could have walked out the front doors of the airport - and then all the way back through. It was the same flight number, and the same physical plane that I was getting back on! I then decided that was too much of a pain, and flew through Dubai instead, which has a vastly superior transit experience!
- delecti 8y ago> I then decided that was too much of a pain, and flew through Dubai instead, which has a vastly superior transit experience! At least assuming you're not a member of a demographic for whom that's a potentially dangerous location.
- gambiting 8y agoSo I always wondered - what happens if your flight has to make an emergency landing on US territory and you don't have a visa? Are the passengers held separately until they can board another flight, so they don't have to go through customs in that case?
- jeff_vader 8y agoThis reminds me a recent story when Norvegian Airlines plane was forced to land in Iran due to [engine problem][1]. As a result: The passengers have now officially entered Iran, and no longer are allowed to enter the US under the visa waiver program. This means if any of them are flying onwards from Oslo to New York (which many are) they have to go to a US embassy and ask for permission. They might have to do it for the rest of their lives. [1]: https://www.airlive.net/boeing-737-max-8-stuck-in-iran-since-december-14-a-real-headache-for-norwegian/ https://www.airlive.net/boeing-737-max-8-stuck-in-iran-since...
- komali2 8y agoI can't see a single sane thing about this situation, and none of my senators seem to give a shit. When I call my comments are "noted." It's a bad idea. It shouldn't be that way.
- vanekjar 8y agoI would extend it to - avoid transfers anywhere in North America (including Canada). US and Canadian airports are pain in the ass regarding customs and immigration. Better to transfer in Europe or Asia and fly directly from there.
- travelbuffoon 8y agoCanada is massively better - many routings don't require going through security, leaving only a cursory immigration check (at special transit desks).
- khuey 8y agoEr, really? Usually it's the other way around. i.e. when flying from country A to country C via country B, in country B's airport you just go through a cursory security check but no immigration or customs formalities.
- travelbuffoon 8y agoYes, indeed. US/Europe to -> rest of world (except US) involves no security when transiting Canada. Domestic connections do require security, connections to US generally require preclearance security. Connections from most other countries also go through security. The odd thing is that they don't separate arrivals: so you'll mingle with worldwide arrivals, go through transfer immigration with everyone else, and finally you show your boarding pass and get routed either to the departure gates, or to security, based on your boarding pass.
- travelbuffoon 8y agoDisclaimer: this might not be the case at all airports, but certainly YVR and YYZ have implemented this.
- jordigh 8y agoMexico too?
- lvs 8y agoWhat a deeply saddening state of affairs.
- skh 8y agoI think the only way for the U.S. to go back to a sane system for international travelers is for people to stop visiting the U.S. for vacations. We won't change until large businesses like Disney take an economic hit.
- nradov 8y agoThe Disney theme parks just raised prices again. They aren't lacking visitors.
- skh 8y agoHence the call for people to stop coming to the U.S. for tourism. I'm not claiming Disney is hurting now. I'm suggesting that the best way to change the U.S. government's treatment of visitors is for companies like Disney to hurt.
- coldcode 8y agoOnce air travel in the US ceases to function, at least 30% of the guests will be unable to come to Disneyworld. That's a big hit. For example visiting Disneyworld is the biggest tourist attraction in Brazil and it's in Florida.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoIt's going to take a lot to accomplish that. Disneyland is super crowded on a huge fraction of the days of the year. There's just not a shortage of domestic customers. In the 1950's when Disneyland opened, California's entire population was (very roughly) 11 million people. Today, there are (again, very roughly) 11 million people in Los Angeles County alone. Since opening, Disneyland has expanded its ability to take in customers by cannibalizing its old parking lot, but there's not much additional, affordable room for expansion today. And there are precious few fair-weather locations that are also economically and politically suitable for "another Disneyland campus." It's also worth noting that the Disney Corporation, though large, has about 1/5 the stock market capitalization of Google.
- 8y ago
- treve 8y agoIt's always worth at least $100 - 200 dollars to avoid a US transfer. The machine guns, and tv's with propaganda of 'how great the US is' are all creepy as hell. Not to mention being yelled at by border security. Seems to be pretty common (in newark at least)
- mtrpcic 8y agoI have travelled in and through the U.S. dozens of times (including through Newark) and have never once seen a "machine gun".
- hangonhn 8y agoDid you fly in the years shortly after 9/11? There were soldiers armed with rifles, which may have automatic firing capabilities, back then. They aren't present now but I wonder if the GP's post is an impression from that period.
- Kephael 8y agoI've only seen police openly carrying modern sporting rifles at LaGuardia. There are police and military openly carrying long guns in public in many European countries these days so I'm not sure why anyone would be surprised to see them at an airport.
- treve 8y agoNot sure what they're called then! Semi-automatics?
- jakebasile 8y agoA "machine gun" in the legal sense, in the US, is any weapon or device capable of firing multiple rounds per pull of the trigger. They have been illegal to manufacture for civilian use since 1986, although devices made before that time are legal for civilian ownership at the Federal level. It requires payment of a tax to the ATF and a background check (these are called NFA items, and the Gun Owner's of America is currently petitioning the Supreme Court to challenge it). A semi-automatic weapon can only fire once per trigger pull and then uses the force of the exploding round to load the next round from a magazine. These are extremely common in the US, but you probably did not see them since many are conceal carried or used only at home or at the range. What you saw at airports were probably "machine guns" used by police and military to guard the airport. A civilian legal "machine gun" can run upwards of $10000 and is likely not something people would carry in public, even if it is likely legal to do so depending on open carry of long guns laws in that locality.
- m0skit0 8y agoAs a citizen of a Muslim country this is very useful information, thanks a lot!
- jordigh 8y agoThis is a sore point for me because I live in Canada but I'm from Mexico. The US happens to be between the two countries I care about the most. In my head, I've fantasised responding to border agents' questions of "why do you want to come into the US?" with "I don't. You're just in the way."
- madcaptenor 8y agoI assume you'd be in favor of the Mexi-Canadian Overpass, then? https://politics.theonion.com/u-s-protests-mexi-canadian-overpass-1819566460 https://politics.theonion.com/u-s-protests-mexi-canadian-ove...
- jraph 8y agoYou got me with your link.
- curun1r 8y agoEww, no. That would still leave transiting travelers to see views of the US countryside and breathe in polluted US air. Instead, Canada/Mexico should contract with Musk’s boring company to create a tunnel where trains, automobiles and Canadian oil can travel between the two countries while staying blissfully unaware of the dystopian nightmare going on above them.
- bparsons 8y agoThe moment I could afford to, I started avoiding connecting flights in the United States wherever possible. The user experience is appalling, from parking lot to gate. I have visited places that take security very, very seriously (Israel, Russia, China etc.) and all manage to make the entire process more bearable than the United States. I don't really understand why they can't make their airports function.
- gonzus 8y agoSame here. In fact, I have actively avoided travelling to the US for the past four years, which means I have mostly missed conferences. I would really like to travel there again, I have friends and favourite places, but the hassle is just too much, even with a passport that makes things easier than average. Sad! :-)
- idontpost 8y agoBecause foreigners are not welcome. Seriously, this isn't hard to understand. The US is an unfriendly, hostile nation. While most Americans, individually, are not unfriendly or hostile to foreigners, the government is decidedly so and has been for decades.
- _red 8y agoNot true. The southern border is wide open. However you need to be the right socio-economic stratum to be accepted. We are mainly interested in importing slave chattel, who can be used to pick avocados, clean the rich houses, and vote democrat. Its the modern plantation 2.0 system.
- nraynaud 8y agoI live in Arizona and my experience is not that of an open border. There are packs are rich republicans with guns scouring the border to play tough, defoliation by helicopter, occupied-France style CBP checkpoints, random Chinese citizens being killed in the streets, and a town of laws against foreigners.
- vertline3 8y agoI can see the US perspective with concerns after 2001. It is hard to have to be scritinized, but it is a new reality. Nothing wrong if you are a foreigner avoiding it. I don't think the anti US crowd is productive here, because they still will have to keep the measures in place.
- djsumdog 8y agoI had no idea you had to go through customs in the US simply to transfer international flights. That's INSANE! I've had connecting flights though Moscow and Doha and didn't need to "enter" those countries or have a visa just to switch planes. Sometimes you go though another security checkpoint, but I've never had to present my passport until I reached the destination country.
- sethhochberg 8y agoTransit visas aren't just an American thing, nor is some kind of customs check - I transited via Moscow to Georgia (from the US) recently and had to pass through some limited form of passport control and a security re-check. No transit visa was required in that case, though.
- BeetleB 8y agoNot sure where you're from, but for many countries in the EU, you do have to show your passport, and have a transit visa, if you are from a set of unwelcome countries. Many people I know avoid transits in the EU because they don't want to pay the fees for a transit visa (and because people from other countries don't need to).
- FireBeyond 8y agoThat's what is called 'sterile transit', and in many countries is still the case (and was broadly the case before 9/11).