14 ms·
I read that book too, and agree it's phenomenal. It's not just about capping insurance profits. The countries doing the best also have price controls on the hea
by DennisP 8y ago
I read that book too, and agree it's phenomenal. It's not just about capping insurance profits. The countries doing the best also have price controls on the healthcare providers. Doctors make a lot less money. On the other hand they generally don't have to pay for medical school.
France, Germany, and Japan all have similar systems, according to the book. They have private nonprofit insurance, some kind of mandate to purchase it, a government price list on services, guaranteed coverage of anything on the list, and digital medical records.
A lot of German primary care doctors don't even hire office staff. They prescribe whatever they want, swipe your medical card, and they're guaranteed to be paid in a week, no questions asked.
Japan has a clever way to handle the mandate. If you don't pay your premiums, nothing happens, but if you need healthcare you're not covered until you pay your back premiums.
I wish all the Americans who think the rest of the developed world runs on single payer would read this book. None of the three countries I just mentioned use single payer. The book also covers Canada and the UK, both of which are single payer (and single provider in the UK), and while their results are pretty good, they're not as good as the other three.
- mikeg8 8y agoThanks for your great comment and I agree especially with your last paragraph. While reading the book, I was so frustrated with how poorly my county has handled such an important issue, probably the most important.
- jellicle 8y agoSufficiently advanced regulation is indistinguishable from single-payer - insurance is completely reliable, covers everything, and is completely fungible. Who cares what name is on the card? The easiest way to accomplish that is just to have a single government insurer. But you can finagle your way in the back door by regulating the shit out of insurance companies too. One-third of the US population is on a US single-payer system right now.
- DennisP 8y agoIf you define single payer that broadly, ok. I'll just mention that Japan gives you your choice of about 2,000 insurance providers, which advertise extensively.
- kaibee 8y ago> I'll just mention that Japan gives you your choice of about 2,000 insurance providers, which advertise extensively. How does all of this additional overhead provide more value to the consumer at the end? How are they actually differentiated?
- DennisP 8y agoI'm not sure (possibly because I read the book years ago). The other two countries handle it differently. Japan's healthcare cost is the lowest of the three though, at 5% GDP, despite an aging population of heavy smokers. So there doesn't seem to be that much overhead.
- philwelch 8y agoDespite Japan's aging, heavy-smoking population, Japanese people tend to be very healthy for reasons that aren't necessarily related to their healthcare system.
- kenhwang 8y agoAnd Americans tend to be overweight and unhealthy. Access to healthcare doesn't automatically shift culture to live a healthier lifestyle (and I suspect it might even do the opposite).
- whitepoplar 8y agoIt would be great if gym memberships could be made free for everyone. I bet it would even be cheaper in the long run to buy an Equinox membership for every American than it would be to do nothing.
- ascar 8y agoGermany has a split system between mandatory government healthcare and voluntary private healthcare, once you pass a certain income threshold (about 80% above average income) or are self-employed. There are differences. The voluntary insurance usually pays 2x to 3x of the mandatory one and covers more treatments that are seen as optional by the government insurance. E.g. physiotherapy is covered by government insurance only for clear indications while private insurances might cover it as a precautionary measure in many more cases. Also private patients can usually skip some waiting time (e.g. days instead of a few weeks). But (nearly) everyone is covered, government or private, and can go to the doctor without worrying about money. Even the government insurance isn't a single entity, but you can choose between multiple providers. All charge the same 14.6% of pre-tax income (capped at ~55k income) plus an additional 0.7% to 1.x% depending on the provider. They also compete on additional services. E.g. my provider adds a free professional tooth-cleaning per year and free travel-vaccination among other things.
- null000 8y ago> Also private patients can usually skip some waiting time (e.g. days instead of a few weeks). See, now, that just really doesn't sound like a good idea to my ears. Why should someone be forced to sit through weeks of suffering while a handful of others don't, for the sole reason that they have more money to throw at the problem? I can understand buying better or more thorough treatment, or buying treatment from more expensive providers I guess, but line jumping via money just seems immoral when it comes to health care.
- ascar 8y agoWhy do you think line-jumping is more immoral than getting worse treatment? In one case you just have to wait in non life-threatening and non-urgent cases (you only have to wait if you actually can wait). In the other case you are actually in a worse physical or mental position.
- asdff 8y agoThis is like if the whole town is on fire, but you have enough money to pay the fireman to save your house first. Priority access to universal needs shouldn't be given based on personal wealth. I wonder if the people who wrote this line jumping into law qualified for the public or private insurance.
- tdhoot 8y ago>> Japan has a clever way to handle the mandate. If you don't pay your premiums, nothing happens, but if you need healthcare you're not covered until you pay your back premiums. Wouldn't it always be a good idea to not pay premiums until you have a major expense then?
- DennisP 8y agoYou could, but you'd have to keep the money in savings anyway, and there'd be some hassle at a time when you might not want to deal with hassle. In practice, it turns out most people just pay their premiums, at least in Japan. But if it turns out to be a problem, you could always charge interest.
- tdhoot 8y agoI wonder what they do if someone can't pay. The system doesn't seem too different from the US to be honest, in that people with poor financial planning skills may decide to skip on insurance premiums and end up not having enough money saved to pay for medical expenses/back premiums when they occur.
- ethbro 8y agoBe that as it may, it sounds like the Japanese system is much more effective at keeping prices low.
- null000 8y agoI think a baseline requirement for these types of systems is that people don't go out of their way to be assholes for negligable gains. My understanding of Japanese culture is that, by and large, people don't do that. Americans, meanwhile, have a pretty heaping helping of petty asshats. For exhibit A, go look up some of the asinine BS tax protesters try to get out of pretty basic civil responsibilities.
- joshcain 8y agoI'd guess there's some kind of interest/penalty you have to pay along with the back premiums.
- euske 8y agoOne of the main reasons why I gave up career in the States and came back to my home country (Japan) was healthcare. I had a day surgery in the US and the whole experience (i.e. bills) just scared heck out of me. I am very happy with the system here. Everything is extremely efficient compared to the US. A little while ago, I had this mysterious headache and went to an orthopedist, dentist, psychiatrist, neurosurgeon then took an MRI. All within one week. My Canadian friend told me that it would be a half-year ordeal in Canada. By the way, I'm not rich.
- DennisP 8y agoThat fits with what the book described. The author had a bum shoulder and saw a doctor for it, in each of the countries he covered. In Japan he got an appointment immediately and the doctor offered surgery the next day. Financially they're the most efficient of all the countries in the book.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stuxnet79 8y agoIn Canada, if it was serious, half a year is actually even quicker than I'd expect. I'd really love to try out the Japanese healthcare system. As it stands, I'm convinced that healthcare is an impossible problem to solve.
- david927 8y agoI'm convinced that healthcare is an impossible problem to solve. You need to travel more. The German system, for example, is very old, very simple and works very well.
- egeozcan 8y agoI like the healthcare situation in Germany but normally you would have to wait months for a surgery, if it's not very critical. An appointment with a specialist can also mean waiting weeks or months.
- philwelch 8y ago> Japan has a clever way to handle the mandate. If you don't pay your premiums, nothing happens, but if you need healthcare you're not covered until you pay your back premiums. So what happens when you go to the ER? Obviously if it's a true emergency they'll save your life and try to bill you later, but then what? Would it ever make sense to deliberately stop paying your premiums? If you can pay "out-of-pocket" for medical expenses, you might be better off saving your premium money until you need medical care that's actually more expensive than the back premiums. That creates an adverse selection problem (assuming that enough of your prospective customers are devious enough to try this). Even if you can't pay out-of-pocket, you could just stop going to the doctor until something serious happened.
- DennisP 8y agoMaybe there's a little interest on back premiums. Whatever the details, it's working out very well for Japan. They get great results at very low cost.
- luckydata 8y agoSeems completely unnecessary though, just wrap that in the taxes and be done with it.
- adventured 8y agoIt's about to stop working out very well for Japan. The costs in their system are exploding higher rapidly and putting everything at risk. Their system won't remain intact for much longer at the rate healthcare costs are outpacing economic growth. Here's the relevant chart: https://i.imgur.com/s97bp9R.jpg https://i.imgur.com/s97bp9R.jpg "Health-Care Paradox Threatens to Add to Japan’s Debt Problems" "Japanese seniors, who enjoy the world’s longest life expectancy, pay as little as 110 yen ($1) out of pocket for specialist appointments. While these visits may help prevent expensive-to-treat diseases, they’re becoming unaffordable in a country where almost 1 in 7 people is 75 years or older, and annual health-care expenditure grew at a pace 40 times faster than the economy from 2000 to 2016." https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-13/health-care-paradox-threatens-to-add-to-japan-s-debt-problems https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-13/health-ca...
- jdhn 8y ago>If you don't pay your premiums, nothing happens, but if you need healthcare you're not covered until you pay your back premiums. So what happens if you don’t pay your premium but then have to use the ER? Do they refuse to take you, or are you stuck with a bill? Does that bill go away if you pay your back premiums or not!
- mrep 8y agoDon't quote me, but I've read many places in the US that ER's are required to take you if you are in a life threatening situation and if you cannot pay, the hospital just ends up owning the costs and then passes those costs to everyone else through insurance fees.
- tathougies 8y agoIs that in Japan (where the question was asked) or the United states?
- mrep 8y agoSorry, US. I updated my comment and I'm from the US but I have yet to use my personal medical care outside of my parents when I was a kid
- adventured 8y agoLegally the ER can't turn you away if you can't pay, in the US. What they can do - specifically relevant if you're a US citizen - is send you a bill and then after you don't pay it send it off to collection agencies, which then harms your credit rating for the next five or seven years (I believe various states have different laws on when these have to drop off your credit rating, it's usually either seven years or slightly less). This has improved a bit lately, with new credit scoring updates that considerably reduce the hit from medical bill collections on your credit. However it's obviously still a ridiculous situation. Most non-private hospitals in the US have low income programs you can sign up for (eg if you go into the ER due to an emergency and run up a big bill), that eliminate most or all of your bills if you fall under a certain income level. That's subsidized by government funding programs. Typically though if you're at that low of an income level, you should just sign up for Medicaid anyway. Those programs are usually most valuable when someone in the eg 22-50% income bracket (the most vulnerable in the US insurance system, where you're above Medicaid and below typical good paying career or job status) is caught inbetween insurance / jobs for a number of months and gets hammered by an ER visit.
- SilasX 8y agoThere’s nothing innovative about cutting off someone’s health care until they can pay, and it probably wouldn’t last long as a policy here.
- luckydata 8y agoOk but why focusing on the insurance systems that are still sub-par compared to Italy, UK and Spain where the single payer system yields even better results for less money?
- DennisP 8y agoThe book did cover the UK and Canada, and found they did not get better results for less money. The author didn't visit Italy or Spain. For quality results, the book used rankings by international organizations, based on statistics like "cure rate after diagnosis of major disease." For cost, it used percentage of GDP and cost per capita. Germany, France, and Japan were tops in quality, and Japan was also the cheapest at 5% GDP. Germany spent 13% GDP but with expansive coverage. Incidentally, the UK is not single payer like we're talking about in the U.S. It's also single provider. All doctors in the system are employees of the NHS, much like the VA in the U.S.
- DanBC 8y ago> It's also single provider. For England that's completely incorrect. Services are commissioned mostly by local clinical commissioning groups (There are about 195 of these across England), but sometimes centrally by NHS England, but they are provided by a range of different organisations. Some of these are NHS organisations, but they don't have to be. It's possible that NHSEngland and CCGS commission NHS services from non-NHS providers. Doctors (and all other healthcare staff, and all manager, and all admin staff) are employed by NHS Trusts, or by other provider organisations. Some examples of non-NHS providers who are commissioned to provide NHS services might be- Livewell South West, a large community interest company that provides a range of in-patient and outpatient treatment. https://www.livewellsouthwest.co.uk/ https://www.livewellsouthwest.co.uk/ Priory Group, a large private provider that also provides some in-patient NHS treatment, especially around in-patient eating disorder treatment or inpatient learning disability "care". https://www.priorygroup.com/ https://www.priorygroup.com/ (Note that LiveWellSW are pretty good, and Priory Group are piss-poor and often abusive.) Even NHS Trusts aren't single provider. They are their own organisation, with their own executive boards and accounts, working independantly from other NHS Trusts. If they're a foundation trust they have a bit more freedom with their budgets and staffing. Here's a nice description of what the NHS is and how it works: https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/how-does-nhs-in-england-work https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/how-does-nhs-in-eng...
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoOne of the problems with the Canadian system is frankly its proximity to the U.S. A large portion of our homegrown medical talent goes immediately south of the border for higher salaries (see your point about price controls on healthcare providers above).
- vasili111 8y agoIf you need talents to stay in your country then you need to pay them more.
- JauntyHatAngle 8y agoThe argument being made is that USA is allowing companies and medical practitioners to price gouge, therefore allowing for wages for medical practitioners higher than can be offered locally. I don't think inflating your own wages to match a system that appears systemically ineffective is the right response, especially when your own system is more effective overall than the one you are losing talent to. In the USA, medical practioners get paid more and the country might gain talent as a result, but the people pay more for it and it results in it being less accessible and less effective overall.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- samatman 8y agoI think that misses the point. Germany pays doctors less, and can, because the switching cost is far higher. Canadians get to keep their first language (most of them do at least), stay on the same continent, which reduces travel to see old friends and extended family, and otherwise have fewer culture shocks to adjust to.
- djrobstep 8y agoNo, the US needs to stop over-paying their doctors. And doctors need to stop being corrupt by reducing supply of doctors through restrictive medical school entry.
- icelancer 8y ago> A lot of German primary care doctors don't even hire office staff. They prescribe whatever they want, swipe your medical card, and they're guaranteed to be paid in a week, no questions asked. Any sort of change towards this in the United States (and I agree, it's a good one) will be spun as losing jobs and crushing the economy, which is a very hard argument to defeat.
- ThePhysicist 8y agoI haven’t come across a single doctor in Germany who didn’t have at least one office assistant to handle incoming patients, schedule appointments and do the bookkeeping. Most doctors seem to have more though these days as the administrative burden has increased. There’s also a trend for doctors to share office space and have a joint office and reception (also to reduce cost).
- DennisP 8y agoThat makes sense. But many U.S. medical offices have people devoted entirely to billing insurance companies and fighting with them over what will be covered.
- snarf21 8y agoExactly, plus all the people at the insurance company that are paid to try to find ways to NOT cover it or to pay at a lower billing code.
- laurencerowe 8y agoGermany and the UK have very similar health outcomes [1] but the UK spends significantly less - 9.7% vs 11% GDP [2]. The UK probably should spend some more on healthcare but it's an open question whether that would be more effective at improving health outcomes vs spending the money on reducing poverty. [1] https://www.commonwealthfund.org/chart/2017/mortality-amenable-health-care-2004-and-2014 https://www.commonwealthfund.org/chart/2017/mortality-amenab... (2014 figures) [2] https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm (2014 figures)
- growlist 8y ago> The UK probably should spend some more on healthcare but it's an open question whether that would be more effective at improving health outcomes vs spending the money on reducing poverty. There are other policy interventions that could also make a big difference to health e.g. making our urban environment friendlier for exercise by reducing traffic, reducing emissions, introducing dedicated separate cycle lanes, stricter punishment for speeding, and making our mental environment less hostile by e.g. stricter controls on advertising, control of body fetishism e.g. Love Island etc. in the media, limiting development/improving access to nature, etc.
- simonh 8y ago>A lot of German primary care doctors don't even hire office staff. They prescribe whatever they want, swipe your medical card, and they're guaranteed to be paid in a week, no questions asked. It seems to work that way in France too, my mother lives over there half the time. She gets medical appointments and treatment almost immediately for almost anything where in the UK she'd be in multi-month long queues. I'd take the NHS over the US system any day, but there definitely seem to be useful lessons to learn from Europe as well. I'ma huge Maggie fan, she was our best post-war PM by far, and a good candidate for best PM ever, but her market based reforms of the NHS were utter failures.
- rndgermandude 8y ago>A lot of German primary care doctors don't even hire office staff. I have never been to a German doctor who didn't have some staff. It's true however that they usually do not have admin-only staff. They have, depending on the size (and specialty) of their operation, 1-3 "Medizinischer Fachangestellte" (MFA, qualified medial employees) per doctor and maybe 1-2 "Auszubildende" (people still in training). This a qualified job which requires formal training and a diploma. Usually it's one person in charge of the appointment book and reception/waiting room and additional people helping the physicians. They are helping during examinations, calling up people from the waiting rooms, keeping appointment books, keeping the patient files and printing out the prescriptions etc (to be signed by the doctor), and to some degree interact with the health insurers. But they also do some hands-on jobs, like they are usually allowed to apply some medications, and operate medical equipment on their own (e.g. last time I visited my dentist, the x-ray machine was operated by an MFA; she had to have a special qualification for that). They are also in charge of writing the invoices for procedures not covered by health insurance providers (e.g. additional checkups). My GP is a single lady shop, and she hired 3 MFAs. My dentist shop has 3 dentists working there and one "technician" and has an MFA support staff of maybe 15. So there is still a lot of admin work, after all. >They prescribe whatever they want Not exactly. German doctors prescribe an "active agent" (even tho a lot of times they will put a brand name). German public insurers will only pay for a max price for a given agent. So if "generics" are available, the pharmacies will likely fill prescriptions with those. >swipe your medical card Eh, you give your card to the doctor's MFAs and they will put it in their card reader, etc. It's not like there is a checkout line where you swipe stuff yourself. >they're guaranteed to be paid in a week Usually one month to four months. It goes like this: Every physician has to be a member in the "Kassenärtzliche Vereinigung" (KV, physicians association, and KZV for dentists) of their federal state. Otherwise, you cannot be reimbursed by the public insurers. There is about 160k physicians and 60k dentists organized in the KVs and KZVs. The physicians then report all the items (procedures, prescriptions, consolations, etc) they want to charge to the KV, which collects the information, tallies up everything and calculates the earnings based on a complicated "points" system, charges the insurers and distributes the money back to their members. The physicians are paid once a month (usually the 15th of each month for most KVs) a progress payment, based on the estimated earnings for a quarter, estimated based on previous quarters in particular. The actual final tally is done only once a quarter where any money not yet paid through the progress payments is paid out. In the worst case, this could be a negative number, meaning a physician has to pay back some of their previously collected progress payments. That's why (AFAIK) KVs will usually underestimate the progress payments to avoid exactly this later. >no questions asked. The KVs will totally ask questions if your doctor starts billing a lot "funny" items (e.g. if a single doctor would charge a lot of flu vaccinations during the summer months, the KV will ask about it). And last I heard, there are spot checks/(not-so) random audits too. The KVs by law are required to make sure everything is OK, so they also dabble in fraud detection and quality control.
- rscho 8y agoAbsolutely true. As a doc, the US problem boils down to a cultural issue that can be summarized as: "there is no reason my money should pay for the care of others, but if I personally need care, then it should be of the absolute best quality and should be provided until my last breath no matter what" The people maintain the system themselves by insisting on that, and that is the root of every other problem. Before alleviating restrictions for med school, US people should think about pulling the plug on the legions of evidently terminal patients receiving maximal care that just prolongs their intense suffering every day around the country. Why do you think your doc does every exam under the sun as soon as you step foot in the office? 1 - if solo, more money; if networked, makes you look better for the "employer" (insurance company/hospital/HMO, etc.) 2 - if you have too many exams, you will complain on the internet. If you have too few exams and something goes wrong, you will drag the doc into court. Weigh the incentives and I think even the most conservative person should see a problem.
- arethuza 8y ago"there is no reason my money should pay for the care of others" Isn't the cultural issue largely a idealogical issue - things like the UK NHS are avowedly socialist? In the words of Aneurin Bevan, founder of the NHS: " A free health service is pure Socialism and as such it is opposed to the hedonism of capitalist society." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan Personally, at least when it comes to healthcare, I'm a socialist: "The collective principle asserts that ... no society can legitimately call itself civilised if a sick person is denied medical aid because of lack of means."
- rscho 8y agoIndeed, I think so too. Ironically, people essentially tend to ask for freedom of choice above all in the US healthcare system (I want complete price info, yada yada...) when the US system is evidently already the one offering the highest level of patient autonomy, probably worldwide (regarding the ethics principles of beneficence, nonmaleficience, Justice and autonomy). But guess what? That has a price, who would have thought?! Another point is that IMO, you can't go extreme on one principle without impacting the others. Nonmaleficience is clearly a problem in the US.