11 ms·
The Sounds That Haunted US Diplomats in Cuba? Lovelorn Crickets, Scientists Say
- ape4 8y agoCanadian diplomats too. And US diplomates in China. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Havana_syndrome https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Havana_syndrome
- jpatokal 8y ago...but only in Guangzhou, which is in subtropical southern China and also has very noisy crickets.
- fit2rule 8y agoWhat's really interesting, is the utter lack of evidence - yet absolute abundance of theories and opinions as to what The Enemies are doing to The Americans. Given the fever pitch that is the current tone of American politics regarding "all the bad things our enemies are doing to us", could this entire case be explained as mass hysteria? Until there is real evidence that The Americans are getting targeted by Their Enemies in this high technology game, I think the only sane thing to do is conclude that there is some collective madness going on here, especially among the "intelligence community", which never seems to pass an opportunity to extend its powers at every incursion, imagined or otherwise - and which also, by the way, seems to be weathering inspection 'by their own people' in ways that would seem more appropriate for kindergarten. America today seems all too willing to find reasons for its aggressive domination, militarily, culturally, and economically, of 'lesser nations' - are these "attacks" just another case of Americans, whining about not being able to play with their toys?
- Jgrubb 8y agoYour ideas are intriguing to me and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.
- mruts 8y agoYou know, capitalizing random words does nothing but undermine your points and makes your post read like the ranting’s of a nutcase. Also, I believe it’s against HN’s rules. In the future, you should probably revise your writing style if you want anyone to take you seriously.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoPlease watch your tone here. The post you're referring to is calm and makes valid points, it is your post that is toxic. Critical thought is not against HN rules.
- prolikewhoa 8y agoCritical thought is not against HN rules. Your post talks about the commenter being a "ranting nutcase", which is a personal attack and actually against the rules.
- Gigablah 8y agoHN's rules include the following: - Don't be snarky. - Assume good faith. - Don't post shallow dismissals. Also, the rule you're referencing pertains to UPPERCASE, not capitalization.
- prolikewhoa 8y agoFor some reason HN loves to downvote people with critical political thought, because history & geopolitics seems to be ignored if it's outside of the NYT/WaPo status quo (the people who push war & conflict for financial & power gains, see Manufacturing Consent). I agree with you. This is the USA actively & agressively trying to find reasons to bomb or persue regime change operations like they have throughout almost all of their history. Anyone who doesn't heavily criticize every big "we're under attack" story about foreign nations needs a reality check, and a history lesson on what caused the Iraq War, as well as the consent manufactured for it by those very newspapers [1]. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/2003/02/06/irrefutable/e598b1be-a78a-4a42-8e1a-c336f7a217f4/?utm_term=.d1738d5b07ce https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/2003/02/06/i...
- adventured 8y ago> This is the USA actively & agressively trying to find reasons to bomb or persue regime change operations like they have throughout almost all of their history. Where almost all of their history mostly equals part of post WW2. The US dates back to the ~1776. Post WW2 was ~170+ years later. Before that, US foreign meddling was no more egregious than any other equivalent nation throughout history. In fact it was probably far less due to the age of the US and lack of the structural development of the political tools required to persistently meddle in foreign affairs. The US military rarely left US shores for the first 140 years, which is the majority of US history.
- Theodores 8y agoThe comment about use of capital letters is a fair one, pointing it out is also fair comment. This is a good thing to learn in the mini-echo-chamber of HN, other forums don't bother to nit-pick enough yet writing style is extremely important. Regarding your main point, it is not about not being allowed to play with the toys. The whole post 9/11 doctrine of militarism that has ended up as 'America First' has gone awry. A play was made to secure the world's energy supplies by military means and it has not worked out as planned. Iran is still a sovereign nation, Russia is back then there is China, the world's new big consumer of oil using the tactic of being nice to people. War is inevitable with many, many provocations made by the US and the junior UK partner. Neo-liberal capitalism just demands war. The thing is that 'where there is smoke there must be fire' and a lot of people slowly get convinced that some of the nonsense is true. There is no appreciation that some of the supposed adversaries are smarter than us with cultural heritages that are different. in the West anything less than neo-liberal economics with 'democracy' is considered wrong, meanwhile, on the other side of the world, this way of running the show is seen for its shortcomings. The memes in our media are many, but regardless of the facts, people end up believing them. There is no evidence that the Russians meddled in the election, that the Russians poisoned some spy in Britain, that Huawei kit is used to spy on people in the West, that President Xi brutally murders thousands of people in China or that these Cuban folk are doing nasty things to U.S. diplomats. However, I know that I will never be able to convince people in my own family that this much is true, I also know that getting downmodded is a result of writing such things. Or, on other forums, getting accused of being a 'Russian troll'. Therefore, given that you take the stance that you do, please do take on board the comments about use of capitals. Don't give people any spurious reasons to dismiss your writing for style points instead of content. This I have learned from HN. Evidence - citations of facts - is also important and another lesson to be learned from HN. For instance, in the Huawei case your opinion might be that Huawei would be mad to sell kit with backdoors in it because if they were caught then they would have a disaster on their hands that would destroy their business, as per the Sony BMG copy protection rootkit scandal of a few years back. Now if you found something you could quote from an important Huawei person explaining this then you can argue your point from evidence. Also with the Huawei kit there is the problem that the Five Eyes can't backdoor it because they don't have the deals they have with Huawei that they do have with the Cisco's of this world. This cannot be backed up with facts. Again, fair down-modding to be expected. You might believe this to be true and you might even have gossip to back up your hunches. But it is not enough. You lose. Therefore, what else could be going on? When you look at Huawei products the facts are that they are really good. Unless you are deeply invested in Apple products (or Cisco) then the Huawei products are what you want - they aren't just really good, they are vastly better on almost every metric if you can prove it with something on the end of a link. If you have another link that proves China are planning to dominate the market by 2025 (or whatever) then that point has been made without having to mention 'Five Eyes'. There is also the matter of lobbying, Huawei haven't spent what their rivals have. Of course no facts will work when trying to discuss the matter with people that just believe the news and what they are told, guided by xenophobia instead of respect for hard working bright people in China. They will just mumble the lies parrot fashion and shout loudly if challenged. You can expect 'what about Tibet?' next. Again, for the made up mind that can't be won. The Dalai Lama being CIA funded matters not. Another bete noir is how the Chinese steal 'our' IP. Now I don't have any patents however I wasn't a big fan of stealing software or music in my earlier years. Yes I was that idiot who paid for products from Silicon Valley and bought vinyl records en-masse. Silly me, I should have just used hacked versions. Invariably those that claim the Chinese 'just steal our IP' are people that have never bought any legitimate software in their life, unless it is for a Playstation. Same with music and DVDs, always ripped off with a few exceptions. If not that then there can be that silk shirt, IP ripped off from China, albeit a long time ago. This can be dismissed as 'whataboutism' by those who insist China steal IP from the West but can't cite a single patent violation. 'Whataboutism' can be exhausting. Russia can be moved on to, not to mention Iran and Cuba. How can anyone defend such dastardly regimes? They don't have 'fair democracy', they don't respect 'human rights' and so on. Every day the papers are filled with more and more reasons to hate these and other countries. Syria is obviously utterly beyond the pale. North Korea too. After so many years I nowadays think it is best to go 'Rosa Parks' on people when it comes to these important matters of hate. Rosa Parks was kind of an accidental revolutionary hero in not wanting to give up her seat on the bus for a white person. She was just too tired that day to give a damn. It was too much effort. She wasn't wanting to start a revolution, she was just tired. So there is a disarming tactic of just going AWOL when it comes to who we are supposed to hate. Cuba? Haven't they got the best doctors in the world and aren't they the only country that is environmentally sustainable? Love to go there!!! Let's try Iran. Did you know they have built a wall the envy of the Trump that keeps a flood wave of heroin out of Europe from coming that way from NATO's Afghanistan? In Europe we should be eternally grateful to them for that, even if they don't let women go to football matches? Aren't their religious temple things more splendid than anything found in the West with civilised culture that pre-dates the West by millennia? There is no answer if you go full-on 'Rosa Parks' with people on these things, you might not win over the dedicated haters but you just might win over their friends by having genuinely nice things to say about our brothers and sisters in far off parts of the world. It is in this way that I think the war of ideas has to be won. Over the last few years we have seen protest movements that have not achieved anything, right now in Paris there is an example of this, years ago there was Occupy Wall Street. They failed. Even worse is the meme that Jewish people secretly control everything with dog-whistle words like 'globalists' being used. Being too tired to hate is better, the traps are avoided.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoIts not very American to do soul searching and introspection. It would be nice if the US produced more Twain's and Chomsky's but such intellectuals are outliers and certainly don't run for office.
- dang 8y agoWe ban accounts that do nationalistic flamewar on HN, regardless of which one they have a problem with. It leads to lame, rude, and dumb discussion. Please do not foment it on this site again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: you've done this before and we've warned you before (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18578205 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18578205). If you continue to do this we will ban you.
- hnmonkey 8y agoAmerica is constantly targeted by their enemies, much like every country on earth. They don't kick back and take breaks when it comes to state-sponsored intelligence work. There has been real evidence of that going back forever. Are you working under the assumption that America has no enemies and no one is continually attacking it in different ways? Your sane conclusion is that there's collective madness happening? Seems like a pretty large stretch of the imagination for that to be the sane conclusion, especially after doctors have studied it and said otherwise. Your comments are extremely anti-American with just about 0 evidence to back any of it up. It comes off as a pretty out-there anti-American rant to be honest.
- aaron695 8y agoCubans told us (who were to stupid to know after hearing it ourselves) a year ago https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.4375193 https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.4375193 Lol, fake news going strong. It's mass hysteria as we're knew straight away but still we continue rehashing and rehashing the fairy tales. Not sure what the USA wants here... Boring incompentance I suspect.
- dieAlready 8y agoWhy am I reading this shit? Why do I pay attention to anything from The New York Times. I seriously wish they’d just implode, go bankrupt and disappear.
- petecox 8y agoOur local species of cicada has been measured at 150 decibels - bloody loud. So I imagine if the bedroom walls were bugged next to one's pillow, hearing damage is plausible. It's consistent with a "blaring, grinding" noise and the cricket's internal proximity sensor that caused the sound to disappear when the occupant moved away from the vicinity of the wall. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-09-15/us-investigates-mystery-acoustic-attacks-on-diplomats-in-cuba/8950568 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-09-15/us-investigates-myste...
- bjourne 8y agoHere is the mysterious recording https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANykud9iE1A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANykud9iE1A and here is the perfectly matching cricket sound https://entnemdept.ifas.ufl.edu/walker/buzz/492a.htm https://entnemdept.ifas.ufl.edu/walker/buzz/492a.htm This whole story is reminiscent of the n-ray debacle 100 years ago https://www.wired.com/2014/09/fantastically-wrong-n-rays/ https://www.wired.com/2014/09/fantastically-wrong-n-rays/ Lots of scientists and officials are so sure that "it was something" that they now can't admit that it was "absolutely nothing".
- scoot 8y agoWow, that second recording (which continued to play in the background after I left the page in the HN reader I’m using) brought on a bout of tinnitus. I only played it on an iPhone at a modest volume (below half), with the phone a comfortable reading distance away.
- graeme 8y agoJust tried. Could be power of suggestion but I think it temporarily increased my tinnitus.
- scoot 8y agoCould be, but for me at least, I don't get tinnitus too often (that I'm consciously aware of†), and I didn't know that this was one of the supposed symptoms of the alleged "attack" until after I'd played the sound, noticed tinnitus, and written that comment. I genuinely went from no tinnitus to conscious tinnitus after playing the recording. † I get the sense that the brain masks it to an extent, like other background noises, but it comes to the fore when conscious of it, like now as I write this comment. However in this case, it came to the fore, or was brought on, depending how you think of it, as a result of playing the annoying noise. The tinnitus came before the thought of tinnitus, if that makes sense.
- spydum 8y ago
- arkitaip 8y agoCrickets still sound more plausible than the status quo explanation that intelligence agencies in multiple countries would attack US (and Canadian!) diplomats with no apparent motivation, especially after being "caught" committing the supposed attacks. Most likely, though, the diplomats are experiencing a mass psychogenic illness.
- marcoperaza 8y agoThe US has reduced staffing at affected embassies and has probably taken other precautions. Don’t you think that hostile governments have good reason to hinder US operations on their territory? A lot of intelligence gathering happens through embassies. It’s not as far fetched as you make it sound.
- empath75 8y agoCuba was working really hard to get relations normalized. It makes no sense for them to attack Americans.
- marcoperaza 8y agoAs was the Obama administration, which made these allegations in the first place.
- adventured 8y agoEspecially when you consider that China is aggressively moving to buld up its relationship with Cuba right now.[1][2] Russia is attempting to station nuclear bombers in Latin America right now, with Cuba's #1 ally.[3][4][5] All of which is conveniently being ignored by both the article and the skeptics in this thread. Those competitors (and potential enemies) aren't non-existent, they're publicly going to work right now in the backyard of the US. Why the hell else would Russia be attempting to station its bombers so close to the US? It's a response to NATO and the tensions with the US on arms treaties, or just another case of Putin pursuing a copy of the USSR strategy of poking their US enemy in one of the few ways they can. [1] https://www.newsweek.com/cold-war-2018-north-korea-china-build-relations-cuba-bringing-old-us-foes-1096716 https://www.newsweek.com/cold-war-2018-north-korea-china-bui... [2] https://www.khmertimeskh.com/50557332/china-cuba-sign-agreements-to-promote-economic-cooperation/ https://www.khmertimeskh.com/50557332/china-cuba-sign-agreem... [3] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-46522358 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-46522358 [4] https://www.smh.com.au/world/south-america/russia-sends-2-nuclear-capable-bombers-to-venezuela-20181211-p50lea.html https://www.smh.com.au/world/south-america/russia-sends-2-nu... [5] http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/25570/venezuela-agreed-to-let-russia-set-up-a-bomber-outpost-on-this-carribean-island-reports http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/25570/venezuela-agreed-...
- empath75 8y agoI’ve been convinced all along that this is just mass hysteria. Anxiety and stress can cause almost all the symptoms they’ve talked about.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoIt is. It's nothing but anti-Cuba propaganda. Business as usual for US & Cuba relations.
- empath75 8y agoI don’t think it’s anti-Cuba propaganda. I think these people genuinely think they’ve been attacked.
- owenmarshall 8y agoIIRC the first reporters were CIA agents stationed at the embassy. Mass hysteria seems an even more plausible possibility if you assume that some of the reporters aren’t genuinely reporting their experiences.
- marcoperaza 8y agoThe medical team at the University of Pennsylvania, who actually examined the victims and published their findings in the peer reviewed Journal of the American Medical Association, found that the victims suffered real injuries and psychosomatic illness was ruled out. Meanwhile, all these people who have never examined the patients keep speculating the opposite. Color me skeptical.
- rdtsc 8y agoHow was it ruled out. Did they find physical damage in the brain or other organs? In a lot of cases it was self reported or stuff people could fake if they wanted "oh look, I am losing my balance and falling". Another point to consider is that a lot of the staff were CIA emoyees working in an embassy that was probably going to be closed or have staff reduced because of the current administration's stance regarding Cuba. And one thing CIA employees do professionally is make up cover stories. If they could make up a cover story to retire early with extra pension for injuries in a high profile case, I can see some taking that route. For instance last time we discussed a story in the New Yorker about someone who went through this and surely at the end they said they might retire early because of the injuries received. That for some reason made me skeptical too...
- jackweirdy 8y ago> Imaging > MRI neuroimaging was obtained in all 21 patients. Most patients had conventional imaging findings, which were within normal limits, at most showing a few small nonspecific T2-bright foci in the white matter (n =9, 43%). There were 3 patients with multiple T2-bright white matter foci, which were more than expected for age, 2 mild in degree, and 1 with moderate changes. The pattern of conventional imaging findings in these cases was nonspecific with regard to the exposure/insult experienced, and the findings could perhaps be attributed to other preexisting disease processes or risk factors. Advanced structural and functional neuroimaging studies are ongoing. The study concludes that "These individuals appeared to have sustained injury to widespread brain networks without an associated history of head trauma." but its not clear to me whether that is to say the study identified specific signs of injury (the imaging section certainly doesn't indicate that) or whether it is saying the symptoms would usually be explained by injury that is as-yet unidentified https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2673168 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2673168
- __m 8y agoHow do you explain the heating rays coming from the sky though? They are clearly under attack
- anoncoward111 8y agoAt the risk of being downvoted, I must ask: Do we assume "incompetence", or "deliberate action", in misidentifying the source of this sound? I always assume good faith and that honest mistakes happen, but in the realm of politics, "mistakes", whether rightly or wrongly, lead to hundreds of deaths [1] [1] Korea Air shootdown, USS Vincennes shootdown, US bombing of Chinese embassy Belgrade [2] [2] "Sorry, intern put in the wrong bombing coordinates"
- will_brown 8y agoI think it’s a very fair question. Just look at the Bay of Pigs intelligence operation. You have US intelligence agencies organizing/training a bunch of Cuban dissidents/exiles in Miami, to launch a paramilitary operation to over throw Castro with the backing of the US military/intelligence agencies and then allowed this group to get slaughtered (with no heads up they were withdrawing support). Is that just incompetence or deliberate action. To this day it’s a fair question, I personally conclude it’s both and I call the mixture of incompetence/deliberate action...politics.
- stevenwoo 8y agoCouldn't this be explained by the US intelligence agencies just being bad at reading the general public in Cuba, the invasion could not have succeeded with such a small force without a general uprising and IIRC the invasion was supported by both Eisenhower and Kennedy so to claim it was some deliberate failure on the part of the USA needs extraordinary proof of conspiracy including both presidents - the US government has supported many other coups around the world. It seems more like the intelligence agency trusted their Cuban allies enthusiasm and reading of the situation too much.
- aylmao 8y agoOr the Iraq intelligence operation, which led to the Iraq war and a lot of the present-day instability in the region. There was wrong intelligence that was believed-in, and right intelligence (claiming there were no massive stockpiles of WMDs) that was dismissed [1][2]. [1]: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/iraq/9937516/Iraq-war-the-greatest-intelligence-failure-in-living-memory.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/iraq/9... [2]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/12/13/the-pre-war-intelligence-on-iraq-wrong-or-hyped-by-the-bush-white-house/?utm_term=.579c68912125 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/12/...
- zenexer 8y agoFifty years from now there's going to be a PBS documentary with the true story. Until then, we have no way of discerning fact from fiction, and any real intel is going to remain highly classified.
- darkpuma 8y agoMy thoughts exactly, this whole story is textbook spook shit. Any of the involved parties may have any number of hidden motivations for lying to everybody. Normal analysis of news stories assumes that at least some of the involved parties are relatively neutral and at least aren't intentionally lying, and that conspiracies rarely happen. That all goes out the window when you're dealing with intelligence agencies. Take Roswell for instance. The government said it was a weather balloon. Conspiracy theorists said it was aliens. "Rational skeptics" said it was an experimental aircraft that the government covered up with the weather balloon story. Paranoid "rational skeptics" said it was an experimental aircraft and that the government had seeded the aliens conspiracy theory to distract anybody skeptical of the official weather balloon story. The reality? It seems clear now that it was a balloon, but not a weather balloon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Mogul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Mogul Everybody got misdirected.
- lisper 8y agoThe crickets could just be a red herring. Just because the sound recorded turned out to be crickets doesn't mean that there wasn't something else going in in addition. And I have to say, listening to the recordings, that sound would drive me absolutely nuts.
- DoctorOetker 8y agoAdd a few degrees of global warming, and those crickets will be all over the US :-s The bay of crickets invasion
- lisper 8y agoThere would be a certain poetic justice in that.
- njharman 8y agoPerhaps it was aliens or magic? Its never the probably, most mundane, natural, with conclusive evidence answer. Is it?
- lisper 8y agoIt's usually the most mundane answer. But the answer also has to be consistent with the data. I am given to understand that the victims suffered actual brain damage. It's unclear whether or not this is true, but if it is true, then that probably rules out crickets as the cause.
- pdimitar 8y agoYeah, because listening to crickets or cicadas in the wild definitely leads to hearing loss and brain damage. Nobody is screaming "CONSPIRACY!" here. But you can't claim with a straight face that such a natural sound would have such consequences either.
- clubm8 8y agoObviously the sound was not crickets, but two weather balloons vigorously rubbing themselves. Obviously this is a sensitive subject[1], so the USG had to invent a cover story. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Mogul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Mogul
- scarejunba 8y agoThe whole thing and its explanations has conspiracy theory overtones. Honestly, I’m going to null hypothesis this whole event because none of the stories are convincing.
- oldgradstudent 8y agoThe reason for the conspiracy theory overtones is that a lot of information is not being reported. > The first four Americans to report being struck by the phenomenon — including the fit-looking man in his 30s — were all CIA officers working under diplomatic cover, as were two others affected later on. Even this report effectively leaks the identifies of the intelligence officers involved. [1] https://www.propublica.org/article/diplomats-in-cuba https://www.propublica.org/article/diplomats-in-cuba
- olivermarks 8y agoReminds me of the mysterious and highly disruptive drone activities at UK Gatwick airport just before Christmas. Mass confusion about what actually happened if anything
- bvinc 8y agoThere was an article a year ago or so that I thought was pretty convincing. It talked about how multiple high frequency spying devices could be interfering with each other and creating the effect. What happened to that theory? No one seemed to think it was solved after that article came out.
- newnewpdro 8y agoSo the recorded sound appears to be a red herring, and we're no closer to understanding the nature of the attack.
- raptordamus 8y agoThis is easily debunked by the fact that similar attacks happened to US personelle in China. Having read about the history of the CIA, planted stories like this are not actually conspiracy theories. This has the feel of a very real coverup. It seems so obvious. Here is the story about China personelle suffering the same attacks: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jun/07/sonic-attack-fears-as-more-us-diplomats-fall-ill-in-china https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jun/07/sonic-attack-f.... Are you telling me attack crickets are invading multiple countries now? Quite the BS story. Super suspicious.
- jnaina 8y agoI grew up in a tropical country and went to a Primary school which had massive number of Angsana tress directly outside the open windows. Everyday we would be bombarded by the sounds of multiple Cicadas chirping away. They were very loud and it would go on for pretty much the whole day. And sound itself would be very distracting. The whole school was affected by these sounds, but I don’t recall any of my class/school mates getting impacted by the sounds (except for perhaps a constant bloody distraction that got me disciplined for not paying attention in class)