27 ms·
Ethereum Plans to Cut Its Energy Consumption by 99 Percent
- chrispeel 8y agoProof-of-Stake is indeed a good thing, and a worthy focus of the article. From the article we read "the long-term hope is that apps built from them will eventually make Ethereum the ultimate cloud-computing platform." Ethereum does not claim to be a computing platform in the same way that AWS is; it's for low-complexity business logic only. I think it's misleading to use "ultimate cloud-computing platform" to describe Ethereum.
- r32a_ 8y agoEthereum claims to be the "World Computer" that lets you build "Unstoppable Applications". If that doesn't sound like an AWS competitor then I don't know.
- plywoodtrees 8y agoSure, it's in some sense "an AWS competitor" but something like a billion times less efficient, measured by throughput, energy efficiency, or cost. So, in practice, no it's not.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoWell put! To put it another way, the problems that Ethereum will solve are not ones that could be solved by AWS.
- anoncoward111 8y agoTotally agree. Despite both being energy/transport companies, Embraer and Tesla are solving two very different consumer problems.
- ENGNR 8y agoAWS actually made an interesting product, a distributed ledger that's 'trustless' as long as you trust Amazon, but with none of the overhead of blockchain so at least it's efficient I think Ethereum is going big places, but the AWS ledger solution is probably also going to be good for smaller industries where competitors don't trust each other, they want a database that's shared, and they all might trust Amazon enough to control it (eg if they're all using AWS anyway) (https://aws.amazon.com/qldb/ https://aws.amazon.com/qldb/)
- runeks 8y ago> […] a distributed ledger that's 'trustless' as long as you trust Amazon […] This has been possible since the 80’s due to public key encryption. It’s not having to trust a central actor that’s the innovation behind e.g. Bitcoin.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- outside1234 8y agoCan we get real for a second? Ethereum has no chance of taking on AWS or Microsoft. Those are multi billion dollar business with billion dollar requirements in infrastructure investment on a yearly basis. Not going to happen.
- r32a_ 8y agoI agree! But that's what Ethereum was pitched as.
- bigiain 8y agoSeems to me you're making invalid assumptions about what "world computer" means. There's not a lot to go in in those two words, but claiming they mean Etherium is out to capture all (or any) of AWS's customers is a _very_ long stretch.
- Zhyl 8y agoI see it less of a computing platform and more like the spinning table from the beginning of Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom. The goal isn't to compute faster or better than others, it's for parties with competing interests to trust the computations that have taken place.
- profalseidol 8y agoIt's a git with stored procedures that can push commits.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoComparing Ethereum to AWS is an apples and oranges comparison at best. One is first order, and the other is second order. You could make an argument it’s a competitor to AWS Lambda, but it would be akin to saying lxc is a serverless competitor.
- r32a_ 8y agoI'm not comparing them, Ethereum marketing team pitched Ethereum as a world computer not me.
- konschubert 8y agoYou are misunderstanding what they mean with “world” computer
- vvillena 8y agoThink of it as one, single "world computer" and it will be much closer to reality. Everyone can access that computer for free, and use it for a price.
- banachtarski 8y ago> ... for free ... for a price
- bigiain 8y ago"access" vs "use". Everybody can see the code/transactions that are run for free. Everybody can have their code run and execute transactions for a price.
- bigiain 8y agoI use quite a lot of AWS - and there's precisely zero chance I'll ever migrate, say, a mobile app backend platform to an Ethereum "unstoppable application"... There are quite probably innovative new things that can be built using Etherium's "world computer", but my guess is that almost _none_ of what's currently running on (and paying for) AWS resources will move to it.
- nivexous 8y agoProof-of-stake will ultimatumly fail. The majority stakeholders can change the protocol at will to their benefit, and there’s no defense (without mob theft). With proof-of-work, at least miners can defend or fork. Best of luck to them though.
- r32a_ 8y agoAlso once a majority of stakeholder hit 51% there is no way to take away the 51% With PoW, an entity could theoretically out mine the 51% attacker by just throwing more hashing power at bitcoin
- solveit 8y agoYou can always buy them out. But honestly, a 51% attack seems like a much less likely way for ethereum to fail compared to it just not living up to the hype.
- village-idiot 8y agoBy the by, it’s not clear that proof of stake is good for crypto, although reducing the CO2 budget is unambiguously good for the rest of us. Most PoS systems I’ve seen basically reward the oldest money holders with the right to stamp new transactions. This reduces the cost, but is extremely centralizing, bordering on neo-feudal. The cynic in me also notes that developers of these chains are regularly the oldest money, making their motivations suspect at best.
- dlubarov 8y agoIn most PoS designs, registering a new validator account takes some fixed amount of time, just as a measure to prevent grinding attacks. If registration takes an hour, and I can't predict the random seed an hour in advance, then I can't predict how my account will be scored, so grinding would be futile. Most PoS designs don't otherwise favor old accounts. I know Peercoin does, but that's a very small project, and I'm not aware of any others. Ethereum 2.0 definitely won't have any such mechanism. In the current spec [1], staking is binary; either you have an active validator account or you don't. [1] https://github.com/ethereum/eth2.0-specs/blob/master/specs/core/0_beacon-chain.md https://github.com/ethereum/eth2.0-specs/blob/master/specs/c...
- DennisP 8y agoThat sounds like the "coin age" system of Peercoin. Ethereum's PoS ignores coin age, which probably couldn't be used anyway because Ethereum uses account balances instead of UTXOs.
- Sargos 8y agoPoS is actually more decentralized when PoW. PoW is controlled by a few mining pools but PoS will have tens of thousands or more validators. In PoW only a few people have the resources to build and run mining farms. Certainly not me. In PoS anyone can stake on a desktop or laptop. This greatly increases the amount of people who can participate in the network.
- StreamBright 8y agoWhat is it good for?
- keymone 8y agoPoS was known way before PoW. It simply doesn't solve the problem at hand - decentralized consensus between mutually distrusting parties.
- DJBunnies 8y agoBingo.
- robertAngst 8y agoThis guy knows his byzantine general's problem. If POS worked, great. I wouldnt trust it for a half decade of use.
- Sargos 8y agoIOHK has many conference accepted peer reviewed research papers that show that proof of stake has equivalent security properties as proof of work.
- keymone 8y ago> conference accepted sure. > peer reviewed not so sure.
- runeks 8y agoA peer reviewed paper saying WPA2 is secure also exists. That clearly didn’t make it so. Only if we enumerate all possible attack vectors, and prove resiliency against these, is the proof as general as you claim. The difficult part — as the WPA2 paper shows — is the former. How do you know when you’ve enumerated all possible attack vectors?
- Sargos 8y agoThat's a good question. It's impossible to prove that anything besides math itself is absolutely true but we can say that for all known knowledge what is in this paper is true and secure. Unless some new discovery is made the papers show that proof of stake has similar mathematical security properties as proof of work.
- superkuh 8y agoProof of stake isn't a tested and reliable mechanism to achieve distributed consensus. It'll be interesting to see what happens to a real cryptocurrency that tries switching to an entirely new form of consensus.
- RealityVoid 8y agoIt is, and exactly these kind of experiments are what crypto cryptocurrencies should be about.
- anthonybsd 8y agoThat's not true. Pure, non hybrid PoS has never been deployed on any crypto at scale. The fact that Ethereum is on their 3rd iteration and still can't figure out how to make it work years after promised delivery should be alarming at least.
- TylerE 8y agoThis news is good for Bitcoin.
- cdiddy2 8y agoIs Tezos not pure PoS?
- anthonybsd 8y agoTezos uses delegated PoS, so no, I don't think it qualifies. D-PoS is sort of antithetical to the idea of decentralized blockchain due to a small number of nodes and very questionable process of node (witness) selection.
- wmf 8y agoWon't any pure PoS system naturally evolve stake pooling that looks like DPoS?
- miguelrochefort 8y agoI wonder how it compares to Cardano's Ouroboros proof-of-stake system.
- jacoblambda 8y agoCompared to PoW almost every PoS protocol is only going to marginally differ wrt power usage. As for other metrics my bet's on Cardano but right now it's anyone's game.
- fiatjaf 8y agoIf Ethereum produces no good whatsoever, using less energy is still too expensive.
- FollowSteph3 8y agoWe’re cobstantly dealing with environmental issues and global warming yet burn incredible amounts of energy and carbon compared to the value this gives us. It would probably be more environmentally friendly to not use crypto currencies then to stop using all the electricity you do each day...
- lykr0n 8y agoJust goes to show how short sighted some people can be. Make money now, or give up that chance so future me or my possible future kids might have a slightly better world to live in. Now multiply that by a lot and- it's hard.
- emasirik 8y agoTo many people, the world in which they have more money is probably the "better" world to live in, even if that world as a whole is less healthy.
- bordercases 8y agoYou assume that the people that use cryptocurrencies also tend to be the people that want kids.
- lykr0n 8y agoI mined NiceHash for a bit. Made a couple of grand doing it (I also pay for 100% wind power), but I didn't really consider the impact it would have. I saw the $10 to $15 a day for little to no work and took it.
- agumonkey 8y agoI feel as if the digital world is half drug and that cutting off will lead to a weird period of time until we can enjoy non electronics based good times. Still it may feel weird that such modern and sophisticated tech led to more problems than bonuses.
- dnautics 8y ago
- zorpner 8y agoWhy was the title changed from the accurate actual title of the article? It is neither misleading nor linkbait.
- floatingatoll 8y agoNote that only the word “absurd” was removed.
- amasad 8y agoSome good criticism of PoS in @TuurDemeester's thread from last week: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1078682801954799617.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1078682801954799617.html And HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18780489 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18780489
- wslh 8y agoNothing in Tuur Demeester resume [1] makes me think he is able to discuss PoS which is being developed by top scientists (including one Turing Prize) in projects like Cardano, DFINITY, Algorand, and Ethereum. [1] https://www.linkedin.com/in/tuurdemeester/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/tuurdemeester/
- josu 8y agoPoS is not only a computing and cryptography problem, it's also a social science and game theory problem. There are not that many "scientists" that are knowledgeable on those areas. Nick Szabo (the authority figure you may be looking for) doesn't seem to like PoS: >Conjectured governance under proof-of-stake seems to involve programmers & other amateurs making legal & accounting decisions. Bitcoin governance does not. Even when lawyers & accountants properly take over PoS governance, PoW governance will likely be far more socially scalable. https://twitter.com/nickszabo4/status/956461360161935361 https://twitter.com/nickszabo4/status/956461360161935361 Tuur is a pretty insightful guy, and even if he doesn't have the credentials, the critique stands on its own.
- wslh 8y agoNot saying that Tuur doesn't have the right to criticize. Saying that at the end this discussion has a strong academic side where you can formalize the problems involved, the adversarial attacks, and balance the solutions. Non academic fights on strongly academic topics, in general, cannot distill the signal from the noise.
- mabbo 8y agoI want to write a snarky or skeptical comment about how it's probably going to fail, but honestly I kind of love the way Proof of Stake works. Instead of mining, those who want in put down a stake of ether that they can mine it and get a better chance of winning based on the size of the stake. If they get caught cheating, they lose their stake. There probably going to be some fun when the first serious exploits happen (oh shoot, what happens if someone does [whatever]?) but I think the premise is solid enough that it's worth trying. I do still have serious concerns over things like the DAO hard fork and the expectation that non-expert developers can or should be writing smart contracts, etc. Ethereum isn't perfect. But if they can provide the same service without the need for mining, all the power to them.
- Ericson2314 8y agoAll the power not to them, you mean ;)
- xorcist 8y ago> If they get caught cheating, they lose their stake in that chain. In any distributed blockchain there's going to be several chain(tips) at any given time.
- RexetBlell 8y agoYou are talking about the nothing at stake problem. It's address here: https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-FAQs#what-is-the-nothing-at-stake-problem-and-how-can-it-be-fixed https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-FAQs#wh...
- DennisP 8y agoIssuing staking transactions on more than one chain is one of the defined slashing conditions. All the transactions are public so any other staker can see that you've done it, submit the evidence in a transaction of their own, and earn a reward while causing some or all of your stake to be destroyed. ("Some or all" because the devs recognize that you might get hacked, so the penalty depends on how much of the total stake misbehaves at once. If it's only a small portion, it's not damaging and presumed to be accidental.)
- h1d 8y agoI wonder but what had Ethereum achieved exactly to this day? Are they starting to optimize before reaching to some practical state? If the power consumption is out of hand when its usefulness is not, then investors are putting too much money in it.
- marcosdumay 8y agoThey are pivoting into something that may be more useful. Mining is the bottleneck on bitcoin usefulness. ETH will have both different usage scenarios an one less bottleneck. (No idea if this is enough.)
- wmf 8y agoMining is the bottleneck on bitcoin usefulness. Can you elaborate? If you want to use Bitcoin, just buy it. Mining seems more complex to me (and more expensive since I don't have a hydro dam in my backyard).
- iSnow 8y agoEvery transaction in BTC is secured by miners - that's the whole reason mining exists in the first place. If you buy it and transfer it to your wallet, some miner mines that transaction into a block (and gets rewarded for that).
- marcosdumay 8y agoThe needs if miners set the maximum bitcoin transaction rate. The more miners that come, the less transactions it can sustain, and that algorithm can not change without the coin losing much of its value.
- sgarman 8y agoMy guess is these investors were investing in what it will become not what it is now. Isn't that the whole point in investing?
- lrvick 8y agoCould also be 100% if their Proof-Of-Stake game theory does not work as well with real funds worth stealing as it does on testnet. Full disclosure I hold some ETH but I would not dare put all my eggs in that brazenly "do it live" basket. One party can hold >50% of all funds and we would have no way of knowing. I wish people would look at less energy consuming proofs of work that still allow us real world evidence of decentralization. We need more experiments like Chia with proof of wasted disk space instead of proof of wasted electricity.
- mulmen 8y agoI'm confused as to the purpose of ETH. On one hand it sounds like an investment that you can "hold" as you say. On the other it is a computing platform. So what is it you "hold"? Compute resources? Why is it valuable to allow speculation on compute resources? Can a person ever really reason about the cost of a system running on ETH? How do you plan for those costs? Is is a compute platform? A cryptocurrency? Something else? Both?
- rhlsthrm 8y agoETH is what you use to pay fees to the network to transact on it. i.e. if I want to transfer you some "tokens" on the Ethereum platform, I would have to pay a fee in ETH. This makes it a speculative investment, since if more people want to use the network, there is more demand for ETH as a currency. Since there is not an unlimited supply of it, there is a supply-demand dynamic on ETH as a currency.
- randaouser 8y agoIt is a computation platform first and foremost. You can pay gas in ETH. Every opcode has a set gas price, so executing a compiled contract on the network costs you some ETH. Why would you want to run code on ETH? Most notably, it requires no 3rd party trust to execute the code whereas traditional cloud architectures require you to trust that the execution environment is kosher e.g. amazon vm is not compromised, amazon hardware does not have side channel attack. It is ideal to write a token or currency on ETH platform as state changes like balances are better left completed on trustless architectures
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoSerious question: why was the reward for mining ever so high? Wouldn't most of the energy consumption problems not be a thing if the reward for mining was drastically lower?
- ac29 8y agoBecause block rewards are in a fixed amount of cryptocurrency, not a fixed amount of USD or similar. As prices increased on cryptocurrencies, block rewards became more valuable - but not because the miner was issued more crypto. These energy consumptions concerns wouldn't be as relevant if ETH was worth 0.01 USD, for example.
- gweinberg 8y agoMining is where the new coins come from, so the rewards for mining are proportional to the value of the coins.
- WatchDog 8y agoLower relative to what? If a mining reward was 1 eth instead of say 10 eth, then 1 eth would likely just be worth 10 times more.
- AgentME 8y agoIf mining had always been 1/10 of what it is now, then that would probably be true since everyone would have 1/10 of what they would have had otherwise, but if the mining reward was suddenly axed now, then there's no reason for that to be true.
- chrispeel 8y agoFor Proof-of-work, one wants to incentivize many miners to join the network and mine blocks and thereby increase the security of the network. Others agree the reward is too high at present; the upcoming Constantinople hard fork will reduce the block reward from 3 to 2. I think the developers didn't anticipate that it would take so long to get to proof-of-stake, and also did not anticipate that the price of Ether would go so high and thereby bring so much mining power on board.
- corv 8y agoProof of Stake is unable to deal with network partitions, the likes of which every so often happen to cut entire countries off the Internet PoS is a disaster waiting to happen for Ethereum.
- jron 8y agoDon't worry. They'll just roll the chain back.
- dahdum 8y agoThe stakers will lose their stake, and those shards affected will go offline, but the rest of the network will continue on until the interruption is over. Ethereum is designing the system specifically to accommodate that sort of problem, last I remember you needed 95%+ uptime to generate return, so if your internet goes out 5% of the time you should not stake.
- wmf 8y agoWhy would the minority side of the partition go offline? How would it even know that it's on the minority side of a partition?
- stale2002 8y ago> How would it even know that it's on the minority side of a partition? Because it would be obvious? The world does not exist in a state where a "true" network partition can ever happen. A "true" network partition I would define as preventing all information, of any type, from going into and out of a country. This is a ridiculous scenario that isn't even worth considering.
- jzwinck 8y agoI imagine that means it's OK if my network connection goes offline 4% of every hour. But what if I'm offline for 4% of 90 days, all at once?
- dlubarov 8y ago
- amasad 8y ago> To make their intentions clear, Ethereum’s core developers reprogrammed their PoW code to create an exponential rise in mining difficulty. Known as the “Difficulty Bomb,” it began slowing the creation of new transaction blocks in late 2016 and was expected to bring ether mining to a grinding halt a few years thereafter. > This time bomb has, however, functioned more like an alarm clock with a snooze button. In October 2017, when mining time had already nearly doubled to 30 seconds, the Ethereum team reset the clock, delaying PoW’s doomsday by about 12 months. And they will likely hit snooze again shortly. How can Ethereum be decentralized if they can so easily keep changing it? > In June, they decided to make a clean break and to build an entirely new blockchain—one that operates solely via PoS. How can Ethereum be decentralized if they can so easily keep changing it? I'm a total dilettante in crypto but if something is decentralized you can't make large-scale changes to it at the drop of a hat. Imagine how much coordination effort it takes to change TCP/IP or HTTP.
- hanniabu 8y agoThe miners can choose to fork fork away from those changes. The core team is merely starting the change and the miners are supporting and carrying out those changes by continuing to mine the chain with those updates.
- amasad 8y agoWhy would the miners agree to adding the "difficulty bomb" which is against their incentives? It's more likely they didn't have a say in it.
- nostrademons 8y agoBecause otherwise they end up mining the chain that nobody's using. You can own a lot of ETC and it doesn't do you much good if you can't sell them because nobody's interested in using or trading them.
- amasad 8y ago
- Ihfhcub 8y agoWhy only cut ethereums power by 99%? I've a perpetual motion machine that'll cut the WORLDS power but 99%. Buy my perpetual motion token now! Sale starts tomorrow *Disclaimer. Ethereum PoS and perpetual motion machines are both fraudulent technologies
- DonHopkins 8y agoAnd make Mexico pay for it!
- chris123 8y agoThis will be interesting, especially when they start nuking miners they don't like.
- NoblePublius 8y agoI’m skeptical of any reporting that refers to a crypto asset’s “market cap,” as if there was enough liquidiy somewhere in the system for all HODLrs to exit at anywhere near that price.
- samatman 8y agoThis is special pleading; there is no stock, no matter how blue chip, for which the market cap reflects the price at which all 'hodlers' could simultaneously sell their position. That's just... not how markets work, at all.
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe idea of everyone with a stock exiting simultaneously is way too suspicious and hard to mentally model, so let's say a supermajority instead, because some event makes a big holder and some followers want to move out. Perhaps the stock was replaced in an index fund. And you made up "simultaneously", so I'm going to ignore that and say "a week or two" instead. There are thousands of major stocks that could support this with a small price movement. If any big crypto coin had supermajority (or even 10%) of the owners try to cash out, the money would dry up right away.
- samatman 8y agoI suppose this could be settle empirically, though I don't know how to get the data. Can you point to examples of large stocks having a supermajority (let's call it 66%) of all stocks move in one business week, without a corresponding crash in price? Call it dropping by half. If, as I suspect, this sort of movement is both extremely uncommon and unfailingly accompanied by a deep discounting, then perhaps this balance of supply (people willing to sell) and demand (people wanting to buy) is part and parcel of what makes a commodity valuable, and valuable at a certain price? Because GP was saying that market cap should be based on a counterfactual; s/he wants it to mean something it doesn't.
- jki275 8y agoCan you cite any stock that could actually support a super majority of owners dumping their stock on the market? I don't have any data on this, but it doesn't seem logical that could happen. Generally large amounts of stock hitting the market at once results in price depression.
- rhlala 8y agoMake pos the validator of the pow. I find it really well designed in Decred crypto currencie. The hard thing is setting the rules to make everyone (users, miners and developers) have power, can change things. That governance.
- Temasik 8y agoTezos baking already live
- anticensor 8y agoAs long as Ethereum sync bandwith problem is not solved, it will not become commonplace.
- safgasCVS 8y agoThis was going to happen anyways as crypto is dead
- rocqua 8y agoHow does time work in a POS system? In POW, the block time is a result of the difficulty, which relies on very low accuracy time-stamps for blocks. Yet, with POS it seems to me I can 'mine' a block at any given moment. Thus, what determines the 'block time' in POS? If the 'block time' gets to be too fast, then the size of the blockchain is going to be quite large.
- _robbywashere 8y agoThe origin of money itself is deeply rooted in proof-of-work.
- koliber 8y agoCoin miners use lots of electricity and release a lot of heat. Electrical heaters use lots of electricity and release a lot of heat. Would it be viable to start a company that sends attractive-looking coin miners to people who heat with electricity? Have the coin miner subsidize 25% of the electricity consumption as the icing on the cake. Would the numbers work on that? Heating is mostly used in the winter. However, some people also heat water year-round with electric heaters. Miners get significantly cheaper energy and free co-location, at the expense of lower amount of total mining per year (as the miner would not be mining when no heating is needed) and increased logistic costs. An added bonus is that it completely nullifies the "wasted energy" argument.
- einr 8y agoWould it be possible to efficiently transfer the heat into the air without using fans? Because having a bunch of GPU fans on full blast in your living room is not an option. Electrical heaters are silent and need to be.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoYou can heat up water in a boiler in a basement in a traditional heating system.
- mikkelam 8y agoI believe this has already been done in Siberia
- keymone 8y agoflipping a bit takes energy. if you flip a bit and also release heat - your bit-flipping hardware is inefficient.
- Tor3 8y agoThe only way to make it more efficient is to use less energy to flip that bit. Energy use always end up as heat.
- zby 8y agoI don't care much if the waste is in energy or hardware or in any other resource. And the level of waste depends only on the block reward and the price of ETH, not the algorithm used, because as long as it is profitable people will burn resources to get the rewards. In free competition people will do that until it gets unprofitable and it gets unprofitable when they burn as much value as they get from the reward. This is MC=MR argument - first presented in: http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/ http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/ . I believe it is possible that PoS is still more efficient than PoW - by being more secure with the same block reward: https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-stake-can-be-cheaper-than-proof-of-work-da14223a965 https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-stake-can-be-cheaper-than-p... , but still the main point holds: the waste depends on the reward not the algo.
- DennisP 8y agoYes but the waste in PoS is just the opportunity cost of locking up capital, not anything physical. Your first link argues that the cost is still physical because of stake grinding, but there are solutions to stake grinding.
- keymone 8y ago> opportunity cost of locking up capital that's one part and it is also paid by PoW miners by buying the hardware. then there is another part - block rewards. where's MC=MR int hat for PoS? > solutions to stake grinding only ones that involve trusted third parties.
- DennisP 8y agoSo the basic idea of stake grinding is that by trying lots of different things, the staker can increase his odds of being the one to create a new block. This can be prevented without trusted third parties if you have a collaborative way to generate random numbers, which cannot be manipulated by the stakers. For example, in Dfinity they use threshold signatures. If any m of n stakers submit their part of the signature, a random number is created; no smaller subset of stakers can predict what that number will be, and the number is the same regardless of which stakers submit. (The number is used to choose the staker who produces the block.) A similar attack is to sign multiple histories, so regardless of which is accepted, you get some reward. In Ethereum, if you do this then you're penalized, losing some or all of your stake (depending on size of the attack). Any staker can see the evidence that you signed conflicting histories, and submit the evidence to the winning chain, receiving a small reward for doing so and destroying your stake.
- RexetBlell 8y agoCheck out the Proof of Stake FAQ by the Ethereum team that addresses many of the concerns in this thread: https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-FAQs https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-FAQs
- jillesvangurp 8y agoI'm glad we switched away from Ethereum in favor of Stellar; it will take most of this year and probably next for the dust to settle on this. Until then, Ethereum continues to be unusable for serious dapps (which are rare to begin with) that have expectations that exceed having reasonable transaction throughput (<4/s, globally, for everyone) and latencies (minutes to hours). Until then, this is a toy platform for wannabe ICOs, misc gambling applications, and not much else that I would qualify as substantial in transaction volume or user base. I f your use case is "nobody does anything that requires a transaction to happen more often than maybe once a day and you can justify the high tranaction cost", ethereum is for you. Otherwise if say, you expect to have users that do stuff in your platform, use something else that works right now instead of waiting for the next two years for Vitalik et. al to actually deliver on their promises with something that is usable, scalable, stable, secure, and available. We switched to Stellar, which also implements proof of stake and provides a reasonable compromise between security and availability. It has its own challenges but transactions clear in <4s and there are dozens to hundreds of them per minute globablly. It also skips the convoluted smart contracts (which IMHO are severely expensive, hard to fix, exploitable bugs waiting to happen) in favor of simple but adequate financial constructs builtin to stellar for custom assets, transactions with multiple signees, transactions with limited time validity and many other features that you can combine to emulate many of the more things people attempt to do on top of solidity. E.g. you can do escrow transactions, payment channels, and many other things. It also scales down reasonably well for micro transactions with values measured in a percentage of a cent (though payment channels are probably the way to go for that).
- wslh 8y agoThe Stellar protocol has not been yet peer reviewed. Not saying that is wrong but I would say that when you start relaxing consensus assumptions you can come up with even simpler protocols. For example, using trusted third parties to timestamp your transactions. In this way you solve the ordering issue in consensus (assuming no timestamp can give the same time). For example, imagine if Google, Amazon, Microsoft, and companies from other countries provides this (Microsoft has a timestamp server for creating code certificates).
- ramoz 8y agoIs there a public blockchain that can be used solely as a ledger, vs having to integrate with the currency model?
- jzymbaluk 8y agoHyperledger is a series of projects sponsored by the Linux foundation, Hyperledger Fabric [1] is an example of a blockchain project that is solely a ledger and smart contract platform, that isn't focused on the currency use case. AFAIK there isn't a canonical public Fabric blockchain, it's mostly focused on companies that want to roll their own private/permissioned blockchain, but I'm sure there are projects that are what you're looking for. [1]https://www.hyperledger.org/projects/fabric https://www.hyperledger.org/projects/fabric
- ramoz 8y agoThanks, yea we've considered implementing our blockchain requirements in Fabric and making it readable through a public api. But this is really then a "centralized" implementation. The currency models of public blockchains are a distractor from the products (would-be DAPPs) that we want to deliver, where an immutable ledger is still a selling point. Is it even worth it to do blockchain at this point? Maybe if we make the nodes completely public? idk.
- gcmartinelli 8y agoCriticizing cryptocurrency for it's energy consumption is absolutely ridiculous. Every step in technology requires ever increasing energy consumption... hell... the universe expects us to keep increasing complexity and energy consumption! Increasing entropy is basically our purpose... And trying to decide what is - or isn't - a valid use of energy is pure arrogance. If anything, we should be arguing about energy sources...
- jpadkins 8y agoHow different is PoS and PoW in practice (for ASIC eligible blockchains)? I need to devote X units of currency to get Y hashrate to gain 51%. This is a stake, needed to achieve a certain level of PoW. One difference is PoS requires stake only from internal currency (you must buy/mine a stake in that currency), vs ASIC PoW you can use a foreign currency to buy your 'stake'. This might mean PoS is less volatile, or resistant to external attacks.
- tdmat 8y agoi can run POS node on a medium instance from AWS.