13 ms·
Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimental Study (2015)
- Epskampie 8y agoI feel like I experience the downside of flat design daily while using the gmail and google calendar interfaces. Finding items and discerning the different areas seems to take longer than it used to. N=1, so your mileage may vary.
- laurentdc 8y agoWhen I use Safari on macOS I find myself misclicking tabs more often than I'd like to admit. It's like I have to stop and actively process what I'm selecting, which has never happened to me before in a browser. The all-gray UI is such a downgrade for me. [0] [0] http://uxcritique.tumblr.com/image/107150709190 http://uxcritique.tumblr.com/image/107150709190
- interlocutor 8y agoHere are some examples of how flat design has made things worse in MacOS and iOS: http://uxcritique.tumblr.com http://uxcritique.tumblr.com
- andyidsinga 8y agoI really like that site and the concise descriptions of the problem. ..it's also a little madding to read for too long as one starts to ask themselves "why did they do that" over and over again.
- phkahler 8y agoWhy? Because design.
- jimktrains2 8y agoI feel like mystery meat navigation is just the new hotness, like it was before as people played with UI paradigms. The issue I see is that , as the examples in that blog point out, there is nothing conaitent to learn and apply later which is why we came back to more traditional UIs for a while.
- wahnfrieden 8y agoInteresting to look over these and see how at least many of the iOS issues have been addressed in later releases.
- discreteevent 8y agoFlat design is form over function and this study appears to prove it. Usually in design there's a reaction against the tyranny of the mainstream. I never liked flat design, even just aesthetically, and I've been waiting for the backlash in this case, but when will it ever arrive!
- PavlovsCat 8y agoI did not spend that much effort on this.. I know the text-shadow on links is kinda bad, and I'm also not happy with the green for visited links. But other than that, this made HN much more readable for me, I figured you might enjoy it as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18752033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18752033
- buboard 8y agoif you ask me, it's form against function
- renox 8y agoNever? 1) Users didn't ask for flat design 2) There's absolutely no evidence that flat design are better and there are evidence that they are worse Yet I don't expect that UI will go back to 'classic UI', many of those who create UI care more about being perceived as modern (or more accurately not being perceived as outdated) than efficiency, so flat design will probably be replaced by another 'fashion driven design'..
- jonhendry18 8y agoJust like the current inexplicable vogue for illustrations of humanoid figures with bizarre body forms. Which designers seem to love and be very proud of using.
- Teckla 8y agoWhen it comes to computer based user interfaces, I think the problem might be that they start to "look dated" after a while, even if they are perfectly good. The flat fad is just a new coat of paint to make things look fresh and new. When the flat fad has run its course, they'll put on another fresh coat of paint. That's my guess, anyway.
- karmakaze 8y agoA related thing is contrast ratio of text on background. I try to test on at least a few computers/displays and when choosing between two almost equally subjectively good pick the one with higher contrast.
- rayiner 8y ago> Our results suggest replacing the flat style user interfaces with interfaces based on the design principles developed over decades of research and practice of HCI and usability engineering. Apple should just revert HEAD to the iOS 6/OS X 10.6 branches and back-port any bug fixes. Almost all of the last near-decade of work in UIs has been a mistake.
- christophilus 8y agoElementary OS has done well in this regard, I think. They’ve avoided most trends, and have focused on refining their UI. I wish they’d get more funding and traction.
- zozbot123 8y agoLinux in general has been doing just fine. The one really notable change I've seen lately is a transition towards a hybrid click/touch interface, with ubiquitous "big" targets for tapping and swiping, as part of the switch to GTK+3. And that seems necessary if we're to work towards having a Linux desktop on smaller, touch-capable devices, so I have no real issue with it. The widget style has changed a bit, but it still looks quite traditional, avoiding the excesses of both "skeuomorphic" and "flat" design.
- turbinerneiter 8y agoAnd big targets are easier to click on with a mouse, too. And the space problem resulting from bigger targets also makes you think harder about what targets to present, and which ones to move to subscreens.
- pcwalton 8y ago> Almost all of the last near-decade of work in UIs has been a mistake. You keep saying this, and it's just not true. The extreme skeuomorphism in the older iOS versions was just as maligned as flat design is today. I wouldn't mind adding some more shading to buttons to make them more easily identifiable, but let's leave the cheesy leather textures in the Calendar app dead and buried, please. I'm not a fan of the Windows 95-era design either. As an example that comes to mind, traditional menus have atrocious usability. Ribbon-like interfaces that feature actual buttons you can click or tap on, with more important buttons larger and/or highlighted, have been a huge improvement over trying to wade through a sea of identical-looking pull-downs full of text. It's important to remember that the move away from pull-down menus was informed by a good deal of end-user research, a lot more than this article. Regarding iOS, I'd like to see this study try modern UI fonts like San Francisco. There's a reason why Apple, Google, and Microsoft invested in new fonts, and that's because faces such as Helvetica (which, by the way, was used in iOS 6) that weren't designed for screens are harder to read.
- emn13 8y agoOne possibly explanation for these results which would be less interesting that their suggested conclusion: bigger items with smaller margins are better than smaller icons with larger margins. The difference on the icon results were particularly large and convincing, and if you look at their example icon stimuli, clearly the flat icons are simpler (as expected) and presented with more margins (perhaps also as expected in flat design), but that also means to get the same number of icons on screen, the icons were smaller. I think it's at least worth considering whether that might explain a large part of the difference. Another limitation is that tiny and non-diverse sample size, and the fact that it's a few years old. They had just 20 students, almost all male, Russian university-student-aged - it's just not a huge or diverse sample; and the experiment was run in 2014; people have a few more years of flat design expectations under their belts now. Looks pretty decent, those results, but I still think it's a little early to draw solid conclusions based on this alone.
- frereubu 8y agoTo back up your more skeptical points, and to hint at the linked study being a symptom of the file drawer problem, here's a study that cites the linked one and which finds no statistically significant difference using a more diverse set of subjects (although still only 21 of them): https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326069864_Affordances_and_Metaphors_Revisited_Testing_Flat_vs_Skeuomorph_Design_with_Digital_Natives_and_Digital_Immigrants https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326069864_Affordanc... It does commit the fingernails-down-blackboard sin of talking about "trends" for non-significant results, but otherwise seems relatively sound. Here's another that effectively finds no significant differences, while subjects perceived flat design as more usable (although full text isn't available so I'm not sure about the methods): https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325563195_A_Comparative_Study_of_Skeuomorphic_and_Flat_Design_from_a_UX_Perspective https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325563195_A_Compara... Caveat - this is just from a quick search through studies that cited the linked article. There may be more robust studies around.
- H1Supreme 8y agoWhen I worked in design, I was always a fan of clean, modern, Swiss inspired design. But, that was mostly print (magazine ads, direct mailers, etc). When I moved into GUI design (early 00's), I went overboard on beveled, 3D, overly ornate designs. As did many people. "Flat" design was a natural response to the endless bevels. Which, was also taken to an extreme. iOS 7 was, imo, the worst representation of this. The icons, the palette, and especially the entirely-too-thin font weights were all awful. I think a flat base design, with dimension added in appropriate areas is a happy medium for GUI's. I'm still on MacOs 10.12.6, which I think represents this pretty well. As does the the Material Design widgets. Even if I think they're a little boring stock.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoI'm a fan of clean design, which is most definitely not flat. The trouble is UI and UX stopped being anything about productivity and became simply empty fashion. iOS 6 was an excess of 3D shine and starburst effects, and skeuomorphism excess like news looking like a set of library or newsagent shelves. Mitigate some of that and the UI would have been lovely. And finished. Since iOS 7 the excess flatness detracts from usability and discoverability. I still feel the camera icon looks annoying wrong and bland, as do settings, photos, calendar, passbook, compass, safari. Games and Passbook are determinedly unrepresentative of anything at all, just random blobs of colour conveying nothing at all. Still, on the plus side MacOS and iOS have not followed through with the excess of bland extreme flatness that is Windows 10. That still seems to want to push the propaganda of a phone GUI on the desktop that started in 8. Several years of regular use and I still hate it at every touch. Even adding every tweak I can find to make it more like 7 and it's still a significant step back from 7, and two headed in typically Windows fashion in that settings are partly in apps partly in old control panel. Usually control panel is required for basics that for some reason aren't felt necessary to allow configuration of any more. Never a complete transition from one to other. After all this progress? I find the app based settings worse in every respect, and perfectly typifies the ethos. Fixing a ton of things that were not, in any respect, broken. I guess they knew that or they'd have continued to permit theming. :)
- atombender 8y ago
- amluto 8y agoAs a personal anecdote, I've spent quite a bit of time watching toddlers interact with the world. In my experience, if it looks like a button, a toddler can tell it's a button and will be interested in pushing it. (And might even say "button"!) If it looks like a switch, a toddler will be interested in switching it. If it looks like a button on a touch screen, a toddler might still think it's a button. If it's a flat blob that looks like every other flat blob designed by that designer (but looks nothing like a flat blob by other designers!), toddlers don't recognize it as a button. Shocker, I know. Obviously, the majority of computer users aren't toddlers, but I think there's a lesson here. I really miss the old Windows 3.1 / 95 / 98 days when controls were more or less standardized and you could reliably tell which were buttons, which were radio buttons, which were okay buttons, etc.
- karmakaze 8y agoA similar 'experiment' with similar results is landing page optimization. You want to be very clear what you're trying to communicate and what you want the visitor to do with as few distractions as possible. It turns out the same types of optimizations that you make on a landing page are good UI/UX features for past-middle-aged people to use. Computers don't have to be hard, we just put everything on the screen and have the user sort through what each thing does and whether it's in or out of context for the current action.
- iamben 8y ago100% agree with this and the parent. Especially with landing pages I aim for the 'mum' test. She's in her 60s and is petrified of computers. If someone like her understands what has to be done / the messaging is clear / the flow of the page directs her to do what I want, it'll probably be a success. Anecdotally I remember being on a call with my dad (in his 60s) trying to talk him through downloading and installing some antivirus software from download.com (or whatever it was back a few years back). Frustratingly it kept going wrong - "I'm pressing to the download button, but it's just not working!" Except he wasn't. Eventually we figured out he was clicking a banner ad because it "looked like a button," far more so than the flat, actual download button. On a site like that, I often wonder whether it's entirely by design. Happy advertisers get more clicks (albeit probably with shitty conversion), happy site owners get to charge more knowing they provide more clicks. Everyone wins. Except my 65 year old dad.
- wilde 8y agoI expect that they would see even stronger results if their population were in a developing country. Flat design shifts the processing load for the user interface from the designer to the user, and it depends heavily on the user being used to computing interfaces so that they can guess correctly.
- kobrad 8y agoThis is all in all a bad way of talking about things. Flat vs. traditional is in the title. I think this can't be taken seriously, and that you all should know better. No time to read this in full, but they start by comparing windows 8 and windows 7 - so the problem is not the functional redesign, no, the problem is that it's flat? What is this
- revskill 8y agoTypical example is iOS design (Traditional) vs Android (Flat). Android design is a mess. Learn from iOS instead.
- tmcw 8y agoThe results are reported, but the inputs - the websites and screenshots used as test data - are conspicuously absent.
- sologoub 8y agoNice to see this type of research coming out of МГУ (Lomonosov Moscow State University)! Haven’t gone through the study, but seeing the examples wondering if there is also selection bias - many older Russian sites still look fairly dated and users may be more used to that look, finding it more familiar and easier to navigate.
- dehrmann 8y agoWhen Apple did the flat redesign of iOS, it caused a lot of problems for my grandma who could already barely tell something is a button. I know I've struggled with toggles and check boxes that don't make it apparent they're active.
- buboard 8y agoWe shouldn't have to rely on post-hoc science to tell us that. Designers should not be allowed to execute in counterproductive ways in the first place, and there was nothing non-obvious about this. We have rules about how road signs should look. How are we going to get back the time lost now?
- zanny 8y ago> We have rules about how road signs should look. Probably a bad example because its signs on public, state owned roads. Private roads don't have signage requirements, you can even have your kids drive your cars without a license on private roads. However we do have building code and more importantly the ADA which sets standards for businesses (like, ya know, websites) to meet minimum accessibility standards. The problem is I don't see any congress where the average number of mathematicians within their ranks is within a margin of error of 0 or rarely enough scientists to fill counting on one hand being capable of writing actually good regulation in this or any software related regard.
- buboard 8y agoI believe most big companies employ psychologists or at least someone with knowledge of how psychophysics and human perceptual systems work. None of them would have approved "flat" as a sane choice
- bbertucc 8y ago“19 female and 1 male university students” participant is a laughable small sample group. How can any insight be drawn from that?
- Rexxar 8y agoAll depends on the effect you are measuring. 20 can be enough if the effect measured is big (if you test an ebola cure on 10 contaminated persons and 10 of them survived, you have with a very high probability found something great). The real question is "Is the effect measured big enough to be signifiant with a sample size of 20" ?
- TagAsDelusion 8y agothe problem is that this must be told
- z3t4 8y agoI think the extra brightness and contrast of modern screens has something to do with the UI design "fashion". It's now possible to use contrasts instead of 3d/depth, and it's even more effective then print as the contrast on (new) screens are much higher.
- c3534l 8y agoMinimalism is one of those things where simplicity is the goal, but not the measure of success. It seems many people (I'm looking at you Windows 10) forget the design part of flat design. Making all the icons indistinguishable general forms is simpler, sure. This study makes the same mistake: it finds removing indictors of function make things harder to read. But they forgot to indicate function in other ways to compensate. It's as if you intended to prove goto isn't bad by removing it from a language without break, return, continue, or loops.
- jonhendry18 8y agoI often have a hard time finding an app I want to use on my iPhone. And I don't even have that many apps. Either I'm finding it hard to distinguish the icons from each other, or the icons aren't distinct enough for my brain to firmly associate an icon with its app.
- bsenftner 8y agoI was one of the original beta Mac developers, back in '83. Before the Mac was released. The idea then was to visually duplicate real world interfaces, and I gotta say they are easier for everyone, across the board, to grasp. Still, to this day, there are many people who do not use computers on an hourly basis, and they certainly do not get familiar with flat interfaces. However, the much maligned over-done interfaces are grasped immediately. Imagine that. It is because the software operates to mimic a real world item that person of many is familiar using already, without software. It is as if the entire reason for the UI is being missed by modern UI "experts" because duplicating real world objects and their innate feedback is too boring, or something. Imagine it as a stepping stone to n augmented reality where you are mimicking real world items, if you must. Real world mimicry is intuitive, and that is hands down easier. I don't need a study.
- aasasd 8y agoNielsen Norman Group have also ran a study, with results similarly unfavorable for flat design: https://www.nngroup.com/articles/flat-ui-less-attention-cause-uncertainty/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/flat-ui-less-attention-caus... (Possibly it's not the only study of theirs on the topic.) Notably, NNG uses a more 'real world' methodology, testing realistic user tasks in browsing websites. For the unfamiliar, 'Nielsen' is Jakob Nielsen, an authority on usability, working and writing on it for two decades now, and he's a big advocate of usability testing in design process. (BTW, “Designing Web Usability: The Practice of Simplicity” of his is an excellent writeup on how websites should function—I'd bet it's as valuable today as it was in mid-2000s for me, because the functioning of humans doesn't change.) They also noted that flat design has made some steps back to the immediate recognition of the olde pseudo-3d interfaces, notably with 'Material design': https://www.nngroup.com/articles/flat-design/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/flat-design/ But not many steps.
- DenisM 8y agoIt's remarkable how UI design followed architecture (as in: buildings) down the dark alley - both went on a crusade to expose inner substance of things by cleansing it from "redundant ornamentation", both ended up steamrolling over the ergonomics, the human comfort, in the fight for the inhuman ideal. This is what I see when I look at the web (+Electron) today: https://www.google.com/search?q=modern+architecture&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=modern+architecture&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=brutalist+architecture&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=brutalist+architecture&tbm=i... This is what I would prefer to see: https://www.google.com/search?q=victorian+architecture&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=victorian+architecture&tbm=i...
- kevinlou 8y agoThere has to be a better approach than to just settle on one of the two extremes: what architecture styles have a mix of moderate ornamentation, but with straightforward and utility-driven design?
- jonhendry18 8y agoOld brick industrial buildings, the sort that get turned into exposed-beam loft style workplaces or condos. The front exteriors often have a bit of ornamental stonework. Nothing baroque, but just enough to make the exterior interesting and attractive. When designed the architects probably weren't paid to mess about putting in useless impractical things, because these were workplaces. For example, the buildings on Chicago's Printers Row (From 525 S. Dearborn south)
- barbecue_sauce 8y agoMcMansions.
- kevinlou 8y agoOh my.
- aasasd 8y ago
- sheeshkebab 8y agoI tried to read this, but the ads and spam for random crap is all over the site... how did this even make it to HN top page?
- tribby 8y agodesign is about solving problems given constraints. flat design is oftentimes (more-so in the past than right now) a reasonable solution for the web, due to constraints related to latency (sending graphics over the wire) and the computational cost of rendering complex graphics/interfaces. from that perspective, flat design makes total sense to me, even if I don't always care for it personally. browsers can't even agree on how to render vector graphics or what falls on CPU vs GPU. projects like pathfinder[1] are sorting some of that out, but we've got a long way to go. flat design is only a very small percentage about aesthetics. IMO, flat design takes the "best for the most for the least" approach of charles and ray eames (and so many others who followed the same ethos but maybe stated it less eloquently), and perverts "the least" to mean least amount of effort/money for the computer (or, cynically, the designer as well), rather than for the user. it either skews the idea of a design constraint, or highlights problems with the web as a platform. whatever flat design accomplishes, it isn't perfect for all cases, but it isn't necessarily bad, either. we just have to remember that as technologies mature, it's always possible we're designing for constraints that no longer exist. I say this a lot, but when talking about web design, in retrospect, flash was like future alien technology that got taken away from us. although I understand the attack surface that came with it and why it had to go. 1. https://github.com/pcwalton/pathfinder https://github.com/pcwalton/pathfinder
- karmakaze 8y agoIt seems like you've made an reasonable explanation but it doesn't follow the timeline of how things happened. Flat design has been coming about recently after significant increases in hardware and network capabilities. Current web apps that use flat designs are just as heavy as any other.
- tribby 8y ago> Flat design has been coming about recently after significant increases in hardware and network capabilities sorry, I should have emphasized the web/browser part of my explanation more. the chip in an iphone could support these things, but could safari? we didn't even have a <video> tag back then. 3D transforms in CSS were brand new (i.e. unusable if you wanted to support legacy browsers), same for WOFF files, requestanimationframe, drop shadows, and so many other modern conveniences. 4G was also brand new -- and uncommon. the web was going through some serious growing pains, and that's just in the highly developed world -- this doesn't really touch on the global availability/use/implementation of the tech we're talking about. it's possible my timeline is off, but designers were still constrained by those doing the engineering during this time. maintaining web apps with hacks to support as many browsers as possible was a nightmare. and so compromises were made -- clearly. and I think flat design came out of that, for better and for worse. > Current web apps that use flat designs are just as heavy as any other. that's what I was getting at toward the end of my comment with regard to observing constraints that may no longer actually exist.
- linuxblender 8y agoFlat Design seems to take its cue from advertising (instead of editorial). Ads (especially in magazines) often look great - clean, elegant - and editorial designers can be envious. But some hoariness is not only functional, but helps offset substance from marketing.
- stevebmark 8y agoFlat design was a mistake. I correctly called this out years ago. It's a horrible choice Johny Ive was only able to poison the world with once Steve Jobs wasn't there to force good design guidance on him. Everyone followed suit and the pendulum has swung _hard_ towards the objective failure of flat design. It's slowly swinging back. Look now at how you reacted to it and analyze your choices. This is a good exercise in realizing an industry trend was a terrible idea and making sure you learn from it if you ever thought flat design was a positive move.
- zapzupnz 8y agoI thought the world had gotten beyond "Steve would be rolling in his grave". Apart from anything, Windows Phone and its flat design came out in 2010, three years prior to iOS 7. Windows 8 came out in 2012, one year before. Please don't pin an entire phenomenon on one man, especially the wrong one.
- jonhendry18 8y agoThat's the saddest thing. Apple copying flat UI from Windows Phone, which is dead now.
- zapzupnz 8y agoI don't think Apple copied the flat UI from Windows Phone. It had already become a trend by that point, and OS X had started to move to lighter gradients and flatter buttons in 10.7, released in 2011. I'm sure the web had already started getting flat by then, too.
- zoom6628 8y agoIf I wasn't a grumpy old product manager, I would be tempted to get cynical and say that flat imposed higher cognitive load which keeps you on the page/UI longer which gives more time for other things to get your attention and create the mental lock in thru mix of attraction and sunk (time) cost...i.e.ive spent so long to figure this out I may as well stay and look around. Another Responder pointed out that material design is better. Maybe I'm ignorant but I don't see how. Perhaps icon quality/diversity is better these days but the basic premise of 2D facsimile for real world 3D objects is still there. Personally I prefer that UI things can be easily and uniquely related to action. This can be achieved by education I. E. sliders now look like nice rounded corner progress bars of yesteryear but we have gotten used to them thru their imposition on us by G and A. That said I have used a few very old GUI programs and their look now is jarringly uncomfortable even though the tools are great and the UI is clear. Progress?
- saurik 8y ago> Another Responder pointed out that material design is better. ...I don't see how. ...the basic premise of 2D facsimile for real world 3D objects is still there. Material design uses shadows to add a third dimension. The shadows cause boundaries and can help indicate parts of the interface that can move independently. I would definitely not claim this is much better, but it is at least a little bit better.
- anilgulecha 8y agoA question to any design enthusiasts and experts here: What currently maintained web/CSS framework has not gone the flat-design way, is inline with HCL guidelines, and has a reasonably complete widget set.
- news_hacker 8y agoI enjoy Palantir's Blueprint. https://blueprintjs.com/docs/ https://blueprintjs.com/docs/
- buboard 8y agoI know it is not what you ask for, but i have deliberately been using bootstrap 2.3 for that reason. It still works with minor fixes.
- alkonaut 8y ago> Our results suggest replacing the flat style user interfaces with interfaces based on the design principles developed over decades of research and practice of HCI and usability engineering. This feels like a straw man argument. Of course nicer looking design is usually worse for function. If nothing else, just sticking to ONE type of consistent design lets all users rely more on memory. They seem to assume that user interfaces are designed with the sole goal of being usable. Have they seen any modern furniture? When they say "our results suggest that" they don't mean that the product (e.g. a web site) would be better in some sense such as making more money long term. They say it would be easier to interact with. I completely buy that. But that's the easy part of the equation to prove! The hard part is: does a site that's nicer looking according to a majority of users but 5% harder to interact with get enough extra business to offset the more difficult UX? Does the company valuation or other metrics such as ease of attracting talent improve? This is the similar to the question "would a furniture maker sell more of this chair if it was 10% more comfortable but a bit uglier?".
- neuronic 8y agoSince when is relying on memory exclusively a good thing? It has downsides as well, particularly blind flight when using software. Sometimes a user should be required to think at least once before clicking, for example when sending money. In this case, UX should cause him to do exactly that. Pavlovian responses to interface design play into malicious actors hands after all.
- vbuwivbiu 8y agothe paper is unconvincing and doesn't control for bad design vs good design The argument that interactive elements must be skeuomorphic doesn't work today since _every_ element is interactive
- sgt101 8y agoGood to read this work, more work like this is needed and the design community needs to pay attention to it. Watch a six year old try to use google for the first time; results are swamped by a blizzard of ads and maps and diversions. This is design driven by greed and a/b testing at it's worst - our tools are only just fit for purpose and the costs that that imposes on us are hidden and absorbed personally.
- progfix 8y agoRant: Everyone who has put at least a little bit of thought into UI design knew from the beginning that flat design is bad. But no, it is 2019 and we still have scrollbars and buttons that are barely visible. Just because Google and Microsoft unreasonably decided to do it that way and every other one blindely copies that (because how can a those big, big companies be possibly wrong?). Fuck accessibility, even though we serve billions of customers on a daily basis.
- solarkraft 8y agoSimplification. I know what my scroll bar looks like and prefer it not to have multiple borders and shadows. It's easier on my eyes and mind. (I don't love everything about "flat design", but not everything needs to be super skeumorphic)
- stinos 8y agoMakes sense: a scrollbar is super common and isn't something you interact with directly that often because there are alternatives (swiping, or on a pc the scroll wheel, up/down, pg up/down). But most other controls don't have that many alternatives and/or don't nearly always appear in the same position so then some actual visual recognition is needed. Of which the results are described in this and other papers.
- solarkraft 8y agoAgreed. There is some value in slight hints through gradients or borders. Ideally we could all choose our preferred themes like we can with GTK.
- progfix 8y agoI have a rather cheap monitor (as many other people probably have) and I can barely make out the grip of the scrollbars when I don't sit straight in front of the display. What about people with bad eye sight or colour-blindness? I am sure they have even more trouble than I have. Windows 10 does BTW not allow to change the scrollbar colours even though it was possible in most older Windows versions. They simply don't care about accessability and userability these days.
- Wildgoose 8y agoI remember trying out an Android sleep app that had a "flat" design. It never worked. On the last day of the trial I realised why - part of the flat "design" was actually a button that I also needed to press. I was so annoyed I deleted the app.