18 ms·
Why I’m so “against” Ethereum
- frustratedmngr 8y agoI find it extremely disturbing that cryptocurrency discussions sound so much like political debate
- arcticbull 8y agoMore like religious debates honestly: “the cryptocurrency I ‘invest’* in is the one true future and all the others are shitcoin scams” — like calm down, IMO they’re all scams ;) * It's not an investment as it does not convey ownership interest.
- tim333 8y agoThere's a reply to each of the 50 tweets by Vitalik Buterin on Reddit here https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/aac4hr/tuurs_criticism_discussion_thread/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/aac4hr/tuurs_crit... By the way, not much mentioned in the discussion but I'm for Ethereum and kind of anti Bitcoin because of the awful environmental impact of proof or work which the Ethereum folk are at least trying to find a solution to.
- keymone 8y ago> awful environmental impact of proof or work compared to what? you can't have free cheese and environmental (and social) impact of existing fiat systems is far worse. > Ethereum folk are at least trying to find a solution to PoS was known long before PoW. PoS is not and cannot be a solution because it doesn't provide objective measure by which competing chains can be compared. only trust in third parties that can be hacked, coerced, etc. oh and ofc "the rich get richer" - so much for fixing awful impact from fiat systems.
- jspook16 8y agoThere are other projects like Komodoplatform that are make big strides in block chain tech.
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoTL;DR: A long, insightful, and at least partially correct critique of the "state" of Ethereum as of today. My humble 0.02 is that what's current is immature and unstable, but there's a decent chance that Ethereum, or Bitcoin, or both, will at some point in the future provide some interesting technical solutions/services. The fact that Ethereum is not there yet is not a good enough argument for me.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoOther than making some people really rich, what problems would it solve that aren’t better solved by existing solutions which don’t burn energy to create secure entropy?
- gamma-male 8y agoDNS
- coralreef 8y agoYou kind of asked a loaded question, but to answer your question; whatever thing needs decentralization.
- alexkcd 8y agoPoW will centralize towards cheap energy access. PoS will centralize to majority stake holders. I would bet that such energy access or stake follows a power law distribution. So long as that is true, neither system will ever provide decentralization.
- coralreef 8y agoOkay, but what happens to energy prices when enough miners flock to low-cost centers? Prices go up. In a long enough time horizon, opportunity to take advantage of energy prices basically gets competed away. I haven't read much on energy production, but as far as I know there are many places on the planet that cheaply produce renewable energy.
- randomacct3847 8y agoHe’s criticizing Eth for being a “ science experiment”? The entire crypto ecosystem is just an experiment, including bitcoin. It’s all immature and unstable.
- gumby 8y agoYou're agreeing with him. He's responding to people saying "hey, why are you criticising ETH, don't you like this stuff?" And he's saying that even the "blue chip" cryptocurrency projects are still very experimental phases and he takes them seriously enough to criticize them.
- berberous 8y agoExcept he seems to give BTC a pass. I'm not familiar with this guy and just skimmed his tweetstorm, but he seems to be part of a group that thinks BTC >>>> ETH.
- jarfil 8y agoETH is theoretically better than BTC, while BTC is practically better than ETH. Depending on whether you want something cool to experiment with, or something to actually use, one is far better than the other.
- joshschreuder 8y agoFor some definition of "actually use". How would you define that?
- Semaphor 8y agoI got more practical use out of ETH than I did out of BTC. In my case, the use was small-ish donations. ETH was cheaper and way faster.
- h1d 8y agoThose are apple and orange. You don't necessarily say HTTP is better than TCP or JavaScript is better than HTML.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- apo 8y agoBy now the Ethereum bloat is so bad that cheaply running an individual node is practically impossible for a lay person. This is an important yet under-appreciated point. It's now extremely difficult to sync an Ethereum node from scratch. If the processes ever completes on commodity hardware, it takes weeks. And that difficulty will only climb as more and more stuff gets dropped onto the Turing-Complete "world computer." This situation drives users in ever greater numbers to services that tell them which transactions are valid or not. Verification with a full node, the bedrock of censorship resistance, dies a death of 1,000 cuts as a result.
- xur17 8y ago> This is an important yet under-appreciated point. It's now extremely difficult to sync an Ethereum node from scratch. If the processes ever completes on commodity hardware, it takes weeks. And that difficulty will only climb as more and more stuff gets dropped onto the Turing-Complete "world computer." This is simply untrue. I recently synced an Ethereum node on a 2 year old desktop computer. Took ~1 day.
- xiphias2 8y agoYou did a fast sync, not a real full sync (which verifies the transactions since the genesys block).
- erulabs 8y agoRight, but re-verifying every txn (a "full sync") isn't exactly the topic. You do not need to re-verify every txn to run an Ethereum node, which is what the article suggests is extremely difficult. And that's not a "light" node, it's a full node, you're just trusting the network initially (additional "trust" is "built" as transactions are processed by the node, which is the beauty of the merkle tree structure). It certainly makes plenty of sense that single handedly reverifying the entire chain will become increasingly difficult with respect time and energy. It becomes a very complex argument about network trust at that point, but the point still stands that "It's now extremely difficult to sync an Ethereum node from scratch" is a very dubious statement (for admittedly varying definitions of 'extremely difficult')
- DennisP 8y ago> state channels (ETH’s version of Lightning), but it is unclear whether main-chain issued ERC20 type tokens will be portable to this environment. The Raiden project is the closest thing to Lightning, was recently deployed to the main chain, and explicitly supports any ERC20 token. The article says Plasma is dead because...Peter Todd, a Bitcoin dev, claims they had a similar idea and rejected it? Meanwhile, on Ethereum a bunch of teams are actively working on it and the Loom project has a version up and running. The article asks why if proof of stake is so great, didn't Ethereum just start with that? Because proof of stake had widely-recognized security flaws (like "nothing-at-stake"), and it took years of research to fix them all. The entire article is of similar quality.
- pouta 8y agoCan you share those fixes?
- phlip9 8y agoFirst, some Proof-of-Stake setup: 1. Assume we have some set of "validators" who control the global consensus process. They come to consensus on the current global state of the system. These validators are vaguely analogous to miners in Proof-of-Work consensus. 2. These validators have coins bonded as collateral in exchange for more voting power in the consensus process. One key idea necessary for Proof-of-Stake is to punish Byzantine validators, i.e., those who deviate from the consensus protocol, by destroying their bonded stake. If you misbehave, then you lose some proportion of your collateral. Thus, validators have incentive for participation (from rewards and fees) and a _disincentive_ for malicious behavior. This is in contrast to Proof-of-Work consensus, where there is no way to punish a specific miner that misbehaves--we cannot programmatically take away physical mining ASICs. Changing the Proof-of-Work function is only an absolute last resort as it unfairly punishes the other honest miners. So what constitutes misbehavior? When can we confidently punish another validator? An example is when a validator publishes signed attestations for conflicting forks--an example of equivocation. When presented with signed evidence of equivocation, the honest majority of validators can agree to punish the equivocator. This punishment system solves the original "nothing-at-stake" problem where a validator has no disincentive not to contribute to both sides of a fork. On another note, the OP seems to misunderstand the fundamental consistency vs availability (in the event of a partition) trade-off that consensus algorithms must to make. Bitcoin's Proof-of-Work is more AP with probabilistic eventual consistency. In the event of a partition, the side with less mining power will make transactions unaware of the partition. When the partition heals, all transactions on the weaker side will revert, effectively double spending all transaction recipients on that side. In contrast, many Proof-of-Stake protocols use a more traditional PBFT-style consensus process which favors consistency over availability. In the case of a partition, the weaker side will simply become unavailable (if it contains less than 1/3 of the voting power). In the event that no partition has >2/3+ of the voting power, the entire system will become unavailable. Also in contrast to PoW's eventual consistency, PBFT-style Proof-of-Stake allows for finality as soon as the validators come to consensus on the next block.
- Temasik 8y agoWhat about tezos?
- Proven 8y ago> The elephant in the room is the transition to proof-of-stake, an “environmentally friendly” way to secure the chain. (If this was the plan all along, why create a proof-of-work chain first?) Well, how would they do an ICO and get the money if they first developed it (and did it like Bitcoiners did - "for free")? Sell that ICO, pump dat bxxx, exit in a low tax jurisdiction.
- menzoic 8y agoLots of misinformation in this article. My favorite one is "Plasma is dead". Meanwhile Plasma MVP was just demoed at Devcon last month...
- cdiddy2 8y agoPlasma was also developed by the same guy who created the lightning network
- kev009 8y agoWhen reading this I think of my deep knowledge of TCP (especially the pain points) and yet it is "The Internet" for the past while. Compared to simpler protocols like Delta-T and later/better protocols like XTP, TCP still "won" for a variety of reasons (adoption, good enough, numbers of implementation, hardware implementation, etc) There are a couple reasons I think Ethereum might prevail over bitcoin: * Vitalik is young and "all in", god willing he will have many decades to refine and improve Ethereum. Think Linus and Linux versus the cabal of Bitcoin and BSD core leadership. * Most of the criticism in this article are things that have slipped committed or expected dates. The community is aware of the problems and is looking forward to fixing them despite it taking longer than expected. It's ok to be wrong and off on dates if you get it right "just in time" which is only obvious after the fact. All in all, Bitcoin might be BSD and Ethereum might be Linux. BSD was technically better for a decade, but Linux had the central leadership of a young Linus and scaled better in adding new developers and corporate users into the mix at the right time. That seemed to matter more than quality, stability, and longevity of governance at least up until now. It's perfectly valid to point out the technical flaws and remind people they missed their commitments. But I'd caution against making financial decisions with too much weight on that alone, which would be about as effective as making them on the expected good will of the community of a cryptocoin :)
- kortilla 8y agoInteresting that you picked TCP given the fact that the TCP everyone runs today isn’t the original one.
- dhh2106 8y ago>TCP still "won" for a variety of reasons (adoption, good enough, numbers of implementation, hardware implementation, etc) Agreed Ethereum is way ahead in the ecosystem race. There are lots more developers using eth and tooling available compared to other chains, and 2019 is poised to accelerate the ecosystem. The technology still needs work in certain areas (by the way, so does btc). Talented and experienced people are working on it, despite what this tweetstorm says
- h1d 8y agoI guess BSD and Linux were aiming to take the same position as OS where Bitcoin and Ethereum are not. No one sane would get Bitcoin staffed with complicated features beyond its simple purpose of keeping a decentralized ledger. Nothing else would go forward if it isn't for Bitcoin running in a stable way. Bitcoin would be positioned as TCP whereas Ethereum would be regarded as HTTP protocol ready to run apps on top. BSD's position is more like Bitcoin Cash (or SV). Similar purpose, different philosophy.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y ago>Ethereum is becoming increasingly centralized. How do people see the forks, the ‘closed’ meetings, the pivots, the obvious influence that a couple devs have over the entire system - and still walk away with any notion there is decentralization?
- bhaak 8y agoThe usual reply is "Ethereum Classic". If Ethereum were as centralized as claimed ("cult of Vitalik", etc.), the survival of ETC wouldn't have been possible.
- Kiro 8y agoNone of the things you mention have anything to do with the decentralization problem he's talking about. See the attached tweet. It's about not being able to run a full node yourself, which consequently means everyone is using third-party services such as Infura.
- imtringued 8y agoIf everyone being able to run a full node is necessary for bitcoin then it's simply going to fade away into irrelevance.
- lawn 8y agoBecause there are several different kinds of decentralization and it's not black and white. Miner decentralization is important is the whole security model relies on nobody controlling >50% of hashrate. Developer centralization is another important point. BTC arguably fails at this when a small group, combined with extensive propaganda campaigns, artificially constrains Bitcoin's throughput. There are no valid arguments against raising the blocksize to 2MB for example. Then there's node centralization, wealth distribution and maybe other types I'm missing.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y ago>Developer centralization is another important point. BTC arguably fails at this when a small group, combined with extensive propaganda campaigns, artificially constrains Bitcoin's throughput. There are no valid arguments against raising the blocksize to 2MB for example. If a handful of people could effectively destroy a “currency” at any point... it’s not decentralized in any sense of the word that is important for trustworthyness or longevity. A government could crash its own money, but there is a strong incentive to not do that. Bitcoin or Eth has nothing tied to it, it’s entitely at the whim of some programmers who as I understand it, aren’t economics experts. That’s the point I made above. You want to say the blockchain and hashing is decentralized, great. But when people use that word, they’re talking about (imo) how it’s “safe” to put money into because “no one owns the crypto coin” and if anyone still believes that latter part, well, they probably aren’t paying attention.
- dlubarov 8y ago> 7/ Recently, a team of reputable developers decided to peer review a widely anticipated Casper / sharding white paper, concluding that it does not live up to its own claims. That's rather misleading. The critique was about Casper CBC, which is very different from Casper FFG. Casper FFG is the basis of the Ethereum 2.0 design, and it's not very controversial. Casper CBC may be more controversial, but nobody is suggesting that it be deployed any time soon. It's Vlad's ongoing research project.
- xmly 8y agoAs a developer, I checked Ethereum's code base. To be honest, it is not that complex in the tech itself. I know it is not fair to just count code lines to compare the complexity. But the Ethereum python code base has only 30K-40K lines code including test while Linux kernel has 15M lines.
- mothsonasloth 8y agoEthereum is predominantly written in C++. The python codebase you are talking about is the Ethereum client / virtual machine of which there are several implementations written in Java, Go etc.
- gamma-male 8y agoNon of you are right. Go ethereum (geth), the official client is written in Golang
- xmly 8y agoI know GETH is the official one now. But that does not matter at all. So a software written in Python is only 30K line with tests, it could become 15M lines once it is rewritten in Go? Of course, it is IMPOSSIBLE! Btw, there is also a RUST implementation from Gavin Wood, which is much faster than Geth.
- gamma-male 8y agoI have no idea what python implementation you're talking about. Concepts behind cryptocurrencies are most often not hard, but there are a million implementation details to consider if you want to write a production ready client
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoThis is bitcoin maximalist dreck, I’m surprised to even see this nonsense upvoted on HN.
- russdpale 8y agoPerhaps, but its nice to see some discussion in these comments that isn't just taking a dump on all crypto currency like I have seen many times before.
- nebali 8y ago>>12/ However, upon closer examination [Plasma] was the recycling of some stale ideas, and the project went nowhere Past tense? this guy isn't very thorough.
- arisAlexis 8y agoThis is a very good read from what I call the thought leaders of HN and Silicon Valley. https://a16zcrypto.com/ https://a16zcrypto.com/
- juliebooth 8y agoI live in USA Florida and i am a happy woman today? I told my self that any Loan lender that could change my Life and that of my family, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to Them. If you are in need of loan and you are 100% sure to pay back the loan please contact them and please tell them that Mrs Sharon Coolidge referred you to them. barrymoreloans12@gmail.com
- mimixco 8y agoVitalik & Co have enough money to hire an army of top developers if they want to try and fix ETH. The fact that they don't is proof that it's unfixable and that they don't care.
- cdiddy2 8y agoThere aren't enough devs who know how to write/research decentralized apps for them to hire. If you know of them, they will hire those people gladly
- xmly 8y agoFB and Aws both have a branch of devs who know P2P and blockchain. P2P is not that complex, just it is not worth time to work on it at this moment because it goes nowhere. Actually, P2P research was only hot around 2000-2005.