37 ms·
For First Time in More Than 20 Years, Copyrighted Works Will Enter Public Domain
- NeoBasilisk 8y agoI wonder if we will see another extension since Mickey is getting close to the chopping block again.
- walterbell 8y agoThe entertainment industry has backed down from seeking copyright extensions.
- justtopost 8y agoCitation needed.
- walterbell 8y agoThe political environment and visibility around copyright issues has evolved, and there are other legal avenues that can be pursued by Disney. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16096448 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16096448 > Will Congress do the same thing again this year? To find out, we talked to groups on both sides of the nation's copyright debate—to digital rights advocates at the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Public Knowledge and to industry groups like the Motion Picture Association of America and the Recording Industry Association of America. To our surprise, there seemed to be universal agreement that another copyright extension was unlikely to be on the agenda this year. "We are not aware of any such efforts, and it's not something we are pursuing," an RIAA spokesman told us when we asked about legislation to retroactively extend copyright terms. "While copyright term has been a longstanding topic of conversation in policy circles, we are not aware of any legislative proposals to address the issue," the MPAA told us. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/01/well-probably-never-free-mickey-thats-beside-point https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/01/well-probably-never-fr... > we expect that Disney will try to use another body of law to suppress creativity and commerce involving Mickey Mouse, whether or not "Steamboat Willie" and "Plane Crazy" are in the public domain: trademark law. If you sell something Mickeyish—including its public domain cartoons—Disney might ask a court to stop you because people who buy the cartoons from you may think they're buying from Disney.
- ryacko 8y agoMaybe Mickey is not popular anymore, and Disney is moving on to newer IPs.
- IMTDb 8y ago"walterbell, HackeNews - Dec 2018"
- pwg 8y agoI wonder what effect the huge SOPA/PIPA outcry had on this change in position?
- dannyobrien 8y agoThey recently successfully lobbied for for life + 70 in TPP, and includes a similar provision in the USMCA (the successor to NAFTA) to compel Canada to bring its copyright term up to life + 70 also. The aim is to establish a new global norm of life + 70 / 95 years for corporate works, as opposed the Berne minimum of 50 years. There’s still plenty of room to ratchet. Mexico, the other USMCA signatory, has life + 100 years. (Disclosure: I work on this at EFF)
- leowoo91 8y agoMany are reading, probably: http://copyright.nova.edu/mickey-public-domain/ http://copyright.nova.edu/mickey-public-domain/
- josho 8y agoDisney has prepared for this moment. They have registered trademarks for every aspect of mickey mouse (e.g. the name, his silhouette, etc). So, yes the original B&W steamboat willie video will enter the public domain, but mickey mouse as a brand will continue forever as trademarks do not expire.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI don't understand why this wasn't the original strategy. Surely even in 1998, Steamboat Willie itself wasn't making much money. Trademarking Mickey makes much more sense.
- gwern 8y agoI've wondered myself, and from reading the commentary on Ars (https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/01/hollywood-says-its-not-planning-another-copyright-extension-push/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/01/hollywood-says-i...) and elsewhere, the answer seems to be something like: in 1998 they could do so easily, and why take the risk of letting Steamboat Willie slip? They could, so they did. In ~2015-2018, it wasn't looking nearly so easy (and there was now Big Tech opposition to reckon with), so the calculus changed.
- Aloha 8y agoSteamboat Willie is of virtually no commercial value now - honestly very little that Disney made prior to 1938 has commercial value or had it 1998.
- Asooka 8y agoDisney have Marvel now, which is printing money. I don't think they've done anything Mickey-related in a long while, they might actually let him enter the public domain. There would probably still be many restrictions on his use, his iconic shape is probably some form of trademark as well.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I don't think they've done anything Mickey-related in a long while https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mickey_and_the_Roadster_Racers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mickey_and_the_Roadster_Race...
- jeremymcanally 8y ago> I don't think they've done anything Mickey-related in a long while... They recently produced a number of shorts (like 3 seasons worth) starring Mickey, there are a few shows out starring him on the toddler focused market, they're building a keystone attraction at Disney's Hollywood Studios around Mickey, they use him extensively in the parks still in new ways, etc. He is still in very heavy use throughout the company, but I don't think Steamboat Willie entering the public domain will damage that. :)
- jumelles 8y agoThis year was actually Mickey's "90th birthday" and Disney did a massive amount of promotion and advertising. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/02/business/media/mickey-mouse-anniversary-90th.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/02/business/media/mickey-mou...
- maxsilver 8y ago> I don't think they've done anything Mickey-related in a long while Check out Disney Junior. There's like 3 or 4 different unique TV shows on-air daily that all feature Mickey Mouse in one form or another. (Mickey Mouse Clubhouse, Micky and the Roadster Racers, Minnie's Bow-Toons, Tsum Tsum, Mouskersize, probably a few more.). And that's just the shows -- there's brand new Mickey merch in toy stores all across America today. (There's even a Steamboat Willie plush toy in Target stores nationwide right now, if it hasn't already sold out - https://www.target.com/p/disney-mickey-mouse-90th-special-edition-steamboat-willie/-/A-53328454 https://www.target.com/p/disney-mickey-mouse-90th-special-ed... ) We aren't in the target demographic for this stuff, so it's easy to forget about it. But Disney heavily promotes Mickey to the very young kids.
- hinkley 8y agoThe surprise for me was learning that Disney is almost as worried about Winnie the Pooh as they are about Mickey. He’s nearly the same age and they sell a ton of merch.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI would expect them to be more worried about Winnie the Pooh given the impact of China and Xi's sheer irrational hatred and sweeping bans over the one image comparing the two.
- smelendez 8y agoThe Pooh character from Milne's first book is arguably more marketable than Steamboat Willie. Another studio could easily do a Pooh reboot with a new animation style and compete with Disney. I'd argue Mickey is more valuable as an icon than a character. And he's so associated with Walt Disney I'm not sure another company would ever be taken seriously making new Mickey material. People know Pooh,Piglet,Eeyore, etc. as personality types. Not sure that's true for Mickey, Minney and friends.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYup. Mickey == Disney, it's pretty much a brand symbol. Nobody is going to touch that. Winnie the Pooh... I didn't know until now that it's even associated with Disney in any way. I grew up reading & watching it as a kid, and even this year I saw Christopher Robin in the cinema (I must have mentally tuned out Disney logo at the beginning). Point being, it's a franchise now, and it still sells like hot cakes, to adults. All the adult friends I know have a sentiment to Winnie the Pooh, and are - or are going to - show it to their kids. Not surprised Disney would want to protect that.
- Mindwipe 8y agoIt's also complicated by the fact that Pooh is unambiguously in copyright in Europe until 2027.
- RickSanchez2600 8y agoSuperman and Batman too are old enough to enter the PD, or at least the old comic books are.
- walterbell 8y agoFrom Creative Commons and Internet Archive, https://creativecommons.org/2018/12/05/join-us-for-a-grand-re-opening-of-the-public-domain/ https://creativecommons.org/2018/12/05/join-us-for-a-grand-r... > Join creative, legal, library, advocacy communities to celebrate the public domain growing again for the first time in decades, and come network with an amazing lineup of people and organizations who will help us welcome this new class of public domain works. Presenters include Larry Lessig, academic, political activist, and founder of Creative Commons, Corynne McSherry, legal director of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Cory Doctorow, science fiction author and co-editor of Boing Boing, Pam Samuelson, copyright scholar, Ryan Merkley, CEO of Creative Commons, Jamie Boyle, the man who literally wrote the book on the public domain, and many others.
- cocacola1 8y agoI'm going to that event. Looking forward to it.
- linkmotif 8y agoWhy doesn’t this happen every year?
- dlbucci 8y agoCopyright length has been increased several times over the past century, so before any copyrights can expire, they get extended. "Oddly enough", each time, the extensions "coincidentally" tend to happen right before the Mickey Mouse copyright expires.
- tzs 8y agoThe only copyright extensions that affected Micky Mouse were the 1998 Act mentioned in the article, and the 1976 Act.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoSonny Bono happened.
- eldridgea 8y agoAFAIK, there have been several legislation changes (often at the behest of Disney) to extend copyright protection length. It was often done retroactively through several years of content. So many years of material were extended through this specific year instead of works expiring for a particular limit for work (e.g. 75 years).
- aidenn0 8y agoIt will from now on going forward, unless congress extends the copyright length again. 20 years ago congress retroactively extended copyright for 20 years.
- jeremyjh 8y agoThis is explained in the SP.
- munk-a 8y ago> At midnight on New Year's Eve Don't count your mouse ears before they hatch, there's still time for Disney to step in and demand we support the poor artists by extending copyright terms.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoThey've got until 2024 before Steamboat Willie enters the public domain. Until then we're just going to be getting the years from 1922 to 1928. I wish that Congress would just say "Everything before Steamboat Willie is public domain, everything else has copyright in perpetuity". Just give us everything they can afford to lose while still getting paid.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoHow about instead we say "everything is death of the artist + 20 years, except for Disney, who will pay the government $50mm a year to keep that deal in place" and then if people want to fight a Disney battle, no one else has to care.
- zanny 8y agoWhy exactly do artists need copyright for 20 years after they are dead, again? ... why exactly do they need copyright, again?
- hackcasual 8y agoTo promote the progress of science and useful arts. Estates are things. I'm sure a fair number of artists have been encouraged to publish towards the end of their life to support their children or causes they believe in.
- Beldin 8y agoActually, since copyright is life + x years, an artist that wishes to leave his descendants with a source of income off of his works is better off creating a work and leaving it to them to slightly tweak and then publish as "by FAMOUS_ARTIST and his second cousin's daughter". That way, copyright will last for the life of the involved descendant as well. So I'm doubtful if anyone would publish anything just for the same of supplying for their children. It's just not the best way to achieve the goal.
- kccqzy 8y agoThis definitely will have a great impact. In high school, there was a school directive that basically adds extra hoops to jump through if a literature teacher wants to assign as a reading some work published in or after 1923. The motivation was that the school was worried that poorer students might not be able to afford those works since they have to buy them. In the end almost everything I was told to read in the high school literature class was published before 1923.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- grawprog 8y agoReally?? So there were no libraries either at your school or in town? I dunno when I was in highschool we read things from lots of different time periods, including things after 1923, and there was no mention of copyright worries in the slightest.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoWhat library has 25+ copies of any book lying around, for an entire class to check out, for at least a month?
- grawprog 8y agoWell every book I did a report on in highschool was either provided by the school or taken out from the library. If it was a book the entire class was expected to do, we would be provided copies. If we got to choose it was up to us to get them. I was poor and couldn't buy books for school. The library always worked for me. I did alright.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CJKerr 8y agoSchool libraries working to support an established curriculum? This was totally normal in my high school - the texts that would be studied by a particular grade were stable for several years at a time, so they would acquire enough copies for 2 classes (60 students).
- jacques_chester 8y agoI feel it should be permissible to extend copyright indefinitely, so long as there is an extension fee, increased for each year of registration, without upper limit. Maybe first 35 years (~1 generation) free. At year 36 you pay $100 to extend. By year 70 you're paying several million to extend. By year 90 you better hope that The Mouse is worth the twenty two billion dollars you owe.
- toyg 8y agoNot a terrible idea, although it obviously penalises individual authors vs big business. I would argue that it should only apply to businesses and inheritors, so that an author could still behest his IP as a worthy inheritance. However, I fear it would result, in practice, in another immediate bonus extension for existing IP (i.e. the Mouse would continue to be owned by Disney for free until 2060). After all, it wouldn't be fair to tell a company they have to find an extra $22b per year from next January.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoYeah, the only way it remotely works in theory is if the fee is some percentage of the revenue you earned off the IP in the last year. Practically it's an unenforceable nightmare that is so prone to "Hollywood accounting" type gimmicks that doesn't work at all.
- earenndil 8y agoI don't think making it a % works. If that % is less than 100, then you never have any incentive not to pay it.
- Bonooru 8y agoRevenue != Profit. There are costs associated with making money off of the IP. You'd stop when those costs and the cost of renewing are greater than the revenue taken in.
- 8y ago
- giancarlostoro 8y agoHow long for awesome video games to enter public domain? If only companies would open source games more often after about a decade when the game will likely sell in insane bundles on Steam.
- toyg 8y agoPong was released at the end of 1972, so let's say 1973 minimum. That's 50 years from now. In practice, the "awesomeness" we remember wasn't really there before the '80s, so it's more like 60 years.
- zanny 8y agoPoor, starving Nintendo and their substantial revenue stream from Super Mario Brothers 1 might be three generations from now Disney when it comes to copyright extension.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cogman10 8y agoHere is what I see happening. Companies stop worrying about the copyright law. Why should they? With youtube they have effectively proved that they can shut down any video they like without any negative repercussions. And now that piracy is way down due to streaming services, what do they gain by maintaining their copyright? We've extended copyright so long that there isn't even a reason to extend it further. And now, the mechanisms to enforce copyright are so biased towards large corporations that, even without infringing, they can make your life a living hell if you cross them. Don't believe me? Look at just about any youtube content producer. Basically all of them have stories about their content being pulled because some mega corp hears them mention something that might be theirs.
- epmaybe 8y agoAre you saying that you believe corporations will continue to submit DMCA takedown notices on content that is newly found in the public domain, with no liability? It seems as if you are trying to look at the move of some copyrighted works into the public domain through the lens of the DMCA, without considering that a content creator who receives a DMCA takedown of works that are in the public domain has hard evidence to counter said notice, which isn't necessarily the case in the setting of "fair use".
- cogman10 8y agoNo, I'm saying that, today, copyright holders are submitting DMCA take down notices on content that does not contain copyrighted material at all. Not even under the fair use clause. There is hard evidence to counter those notices, but ultimately nobody ends up taking it to court because it is too expensive. See: https://www.dailydot.com/upstream/youtube-copyright-claims-thefatrat/ https://www.dailydot.com/upstream/youtube-copyright-claims-t...
- derefr 8y agoYou don’t need to “take it to court”; if the recipient of the DMCA complaint says to the host that they disagree with the DMCA takedown notice, the host is required by the DMCA to put the content back up (or, at least, return it to whatever state it would be in if the DMCA takedown notice didn’t happen), and it is then the responsibility of the complainant to take the other party to court. Which the complainant will never do, in these cases where it’s obvious that it was just an overzealous algorithm flagging things it shouldn’t have—because actually pursuing damages for those situations are exactly the type of thing that make a judge issue contempt-of-court charges.
- shmerl 8y agoSo, Mickey Mouse curve is finally starting to crumble? Current copyright term is insane, it should be significantly rolled back.
- mymythisisthis 8y agoWhat math and electronics textbooks where published in 1923?
- cocacola1 8y agoFinally. This is probably one of the more significant events of the decade. The culture that's locked up behind copyright could have a major societal impact down the line.
- philwelch 8y ago> The culture that's locked up behind copyright could have a major societal impact down the line. This stuff is almost 100 years old. It was written for a society very different from our own.
- cocacola1 8y agoThe beauty of the public domain is that it enables people to update that stuff for the modern era. That it can now be widely disseminated is the first step. Look at King Arthur. A thousand year old legend that’s getting another variant next month - The Kid Who Would Be King.
- ryl00 8y ago> This stuff is almost 100 years old. It was written for a society very different from our own. Different, yet still the same in many important ways. If this means great things like Harold Lloyd's seminal comedy Safety Last! will now be freely available, we've all won something...
- ionised 8y agoI don't see how that's relevant.
- stormbrew 8y agoMeanwhile in Canada, a bunch of stuff will be leaving the public domain thanks to the renegotiation of NAFTA synchronizing Canadian copyright to American. Yay?
- marvindanig 8y agoThis is seriously the worst part of this whole bad news cycle we're on. We need to elect people with strong moral fiber and then hold those elected accountable. There are good people in politics!
- Vinnl 8y agoIt's not just needing to have strong moral fiber, but also be willing to sacrifice whatever other parties in a negotiation offered for you lengthen the copyright period.
- comex 8y agoHuh! I hadn’t heard about this. In theory, there’s still time to stop it from happening. Although USMCA was signed, it hasn’t been ratified by the US and, due to objections from newly elected Democratic House majority, probably won’t be ratified in its current form. Unfortunately, I don’t think those objections include anything about copyright, so in lieu of some massive public lobbying campaign, any revised version they agree to probably won’t change that part. On the other hand, there’s a substantial chance that Democrats and Republicans fail to reach a deal on revisions, nothing gets signed, and Trump’s threat to unilaterally terminate NAFTA gets put to the test (both politically and, potentially, in court). I guess we’ll see.
- adventured 8y ago> On the other hand, there’s a substantial chance that Democrats and Republicans fail to reach a deal on revisions There's zero chance the Democrats and Republicans fail to ratify the new USMCA. Neither party particularly wanted to dump NAFTA in the first place, it was almost entirely a Trump push to renegotiate it. USMCA is very slightly better for the US and North America, so it's better than the deal they all supported before that. It's a small group of Democrats posturing with their new control of the house. They understand the cost of letting the trade pact drop and they have no interest in owning that mistake.
- ksec 8y agoOff Topic Question. So can Public Domain be consider an open source license now? Previously I read there were lots of argument about it being now applicable to software.
- mikekchar 8y agoIn the US, if you put your software in the public domain it is in the public domain. It is not a license. With a license, you are retaining your copyright. You're just allowing someone to use it in ways not ordinarily allowed by copyright. If something is in the public domain, you do not have a copyright. You can't even issue a license because you have no legal claim over the work. In many other countries, it is not possible to voluntarily put works in the public domain. In those countries, you need to have a license. This is where something like CC0 is useful. CC0 has not been approved by the OSI as an open source license, but that's not really an issue. However, CC0 does not contain a patent grant and so it's probably not the best choice for software if you are looking for an open source license.
- beefhash 8y ago> However, CC0 does not contain a patent grant and so it's probably not the best choice for software if you are looking for an open source license. Patent license scares are greatly overblown and really only a realistic danger in case of corporate code. People tend to have the decency to point out that the algorithms contained in the code are patented. A license containing a patent grant might actually be dangerous because it creates a false sense of security for the receipient, thinking they have a valid title, only to find out later that corporation X actually had a patent on this algorithm. Additionally, if you're sitting in a European jurisdiction, a patent license is completely pointless. Because software patents don't exist there. There's literally nothing that could possibly be licensed.
- mikekchar 8y agoThat's great if all the people who might use your code are in Europe, but for those in places like Canada, Japan, etc, they can't use your code without exposing themselves to risk. It's great if you say, "I won't sue you", but best to put it in the license ;-)
- balibebas 8y agoThe concept of ‘Public Domain’ is an admission IP even exists, which it doesn't and why some jurisdictions do not even recognize the concept.
- _ph_ 8y agoIn my eyes, copyright should be limited to 50 years after the first publication or the death of the author. This would still allow for proper commercial use of the works by the author, yet put realistic limits on how long a copyright holder can block access to copyrighted work. Because beyond direct usage of the copyrighted work, it always creates a risk for genuine new creators that their creations are percieved as infringing on some random copyrighted piece. For figures like Mickey, which are actively used, rather trademark law applies. While the early cartoons might expire in copyright, that only gives the public the right to use those cartoons, not to create random "Mickey Mouse" products. That is a reasonable differentiation in my eyes.
- Noos 8y agoThat's a pretty fair compromise.
- benj111 8y agoWhy 50? To my way of thinking, copyright should be set to the minimum required to induce/allow creators to create. I can't think of any creative medium/industry that would look more than 10 years out (except maybe Disney with their Marvel and Star wars factories, but I think that supports my point). Copyright is a government granted monopoly. We have pretty beefy laws regarding virtually every other kind of monopoly because its generally against the public interest. The only reason to offer the monopoly in this case is to encourage content creation. So the period of monopoly should be no longer than necessary.
- _ph_ 8y agoAs a resonable compromise. Between 0 and the current 95 years, it is at a good middle. Also resonates well with the natural life spans. If your are creating works between 20 and 40, you have them under copyright for most of your life. The protection span should be long enough, that individual creators are not disincentivized to not publish creations early.
- benj111 8y ago
- zelphirkalt 8y agoFunny, a website with a "hall of shame", but it tries to use Google Analytics and Twitter, two things known for tracking their users everywhere at every step. Is it itself on its "hall of shame"? The "hall of shame" does not even load properly, when you block Google Analytics and Twitter, as I usually do. So you are forced to be tracked, if you want to see the content. That is another bad pattern, I would say.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fiala__ 8y agoI suspect you wanted to comment on this? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18722952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18722952
- test1235 8y agoI think you meant to comment on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18722952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18722952
- Jenz 8y agoHaha, wrong item, one off ATM
- sbhn 8y agoWho cares about copyright, i consume all my content from archive.org
- solarkraft 8y agoarchive.org kind of has to care.
- yason 8y agoThe sheer length of timespans involved in copyright make it very detached from the actual reality a lot of people grew up with. A copyright of a few years would better reflect what has been going on in the daily life since 70's-80's. If you grew up then you would see films of only few years back on TV at which point you could tape them for yourself and your friends. Anything that was broadcast immediately became effectively free: there was always someone who had a copy you could borrow or copy yourself. This gave the industry a lot of time to milk revenues from the cinema and then home video until everyone had it from broadcasts. With a few notable exceptions, I don't see content from five years back making a huge cashflow, not to mention ten years. Thus copyright could be a paid privilege. You would get the copyright for the first year for free. Then it would cost more each year to maintain the copyright for one more year. Let's take a small percentage of the first year's total sales for a given piece, make it the cost of copyright for the next year and for the following year, add the same percentage to the previous cost of copyright. We would therefore effectively be taxing the practise of hoarding content under copyright. At the same time income from the content would fall so the markets would reach a point where it would cost too much to keep the copyright in effect. The content business could make their own decisions per each piece of content. They would extend copyright on the most popular films and music while let go of the ones that don't sell too well. All this would benefit everyone and make the copyright monopoly vs people's rights closer to a balance.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Nursie 8y agoThe only counterpoint I can think of is that it seems unfair for copyright to lapse after a couple of years on a song and then have a movie studio pick it up and use it as a movie theme a few years later. They could end up making a ton of money with it and not benefitting the artist at all.
- teddyh 8y agoIf the hypothetical movie studio from your example could not have used the song because of copyright, they would not have used the song, leaving the artist just as bereft of benefits as before – there is no change for the artist either way. If the movie studio can pick the best song from all available non-copyrighted songs since there are a large number of them, the artist will still not benefit but the movie studio might make a better movie, benefiting them and thereby the economy and society as a whole, even if nothing changes for the artist.
- netcan 8y agoThere are different reasons that get out forward for copyrights, but the main one is generally money, incentivizing and compensating creative works. That reason can't credibly (imo) support these long timespans. Few works produce revenue 50 or 100 years after publication. But even assuming a work dies, once you discount for time, revenue in 100 years is basically worth nothing now. Reducing or increasing copyright length by a decade would have almost no effect on working authors and can't financially incentivize their work.
- bediger4000 8y agoAgreed: the ridiculously long copyright we've got now can't financially incentivize authors' work. Therefore, something else is motivating arbitrarily long copyrights. What is that motivation? I would suggest just plain control freakery. Even in USA, control over employees and resources, even to the detriment of the corporation, seems to be prized.
- nybble41 8y agoI would guess that the main financial motive for ever-increasing copyright terms is strictly anti-competitive, in the sense that the studios are attempting to avoid competing with their own back-catalogs. There is more decent entertainment out there already than any one person could properly appreciate in their lifetime; the only way the studios can ensure a market for their more recent works is by banning all the older ones.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deytempo 8y agoWe’re coming for you Mickey Mouse
- andrewla 8y agoIt might be that in order to have a coherent discussion about this we need to separate the concept of copyright into two areas. One is the right to exclusive distribution of the original work. The other is the right to make derivative works from that work. In both cases the commercial/non-commercial distinction may also make sense, but I think these are the gross categories. Let's call these two new rights "cloneright" and "adaptright" Since we lump them together, these two things get mixed up. Cloneright addresses concerns about the ongoing availability of a work (or translating the work to a different format) causing problems -- old video games, old films, old music, out-of-print books, things like that being lost or hard to obtain because making electronic versions of them is not possible without the approval of the copyright holder. It seems reasonable that this should lapse on a relatively short time horizon. Adaptright is a different matter, and is harder to quantify. I don't think it would be acceptable for other authors to write sequels to an author's books, or studios to adapt them without the original author's permission, for a longer timeframe than cloneright makes sense for. Saying that the lifetime of the adaptright is tied to the author's lifetime makes sense here. It can take a long time for a book to be adapted into a movie, and it makes sense to have the original author to have some say in that (unless they choose to forfeit that right). It might make sense to break this further down by commercial/non-commercial usage, or even by type of copyrighted work (relatively few songs, for example, are successfully adapted to movies or books, so adaptright might have to mean something else there) but I think this is a better framing of the copyright discussion than lumping the two gross categories together.
- soperj 8y ago*First time in more than 20 years in the US.